Eno Sarris Baseball Chat — 3/6/14
11:46 |
: I’ll be here at the top of the hour!
|
11:47 |
:
|
11:47 |
: Enjoy, in the mean time.
|
12:00 |
: hey you guys
|
12:00 |
3 favorite War on Drugs tunes |
12:01 |
: That one, that one and that one. I just heard them for the first time this morning. In related news, I’m an old man with a toddler son. What’s funny about this is that it sounds like some sort of Fleetwood Mac plus Bruce Springsteen, and despite the fact that I don’t like either of those bands, I like this one!
|
12:01 |
Just saying heya Eno! Still waiting on when that official NYC meetup will be. |
12:01 |
: Gotta get out there! Or make Petriello run it.
|
12:01 |
14-team mixed, 1 catcher auction. Best strategy to just spend $1 on whomever is left at the end? |
12:02 |
: Yes. I had a 14-teamer last night and waited forever and just took Miguel Montero third to last. I didn’t want AJ, and someone took Yan Gomes as a utility guy. So I guess I like about 12 catchers without reservation.
|
12:02 |
What would surprise you more from 2014 Billy Butler? 60/15/80/.280 or 70/25/100/.300 |
12:02 |
: the one with the 25 homers. He hits so many ground balls!
|
12:03 |
Hey Eno! What do you think about Matt Kemp this year? I heard about his BP session where McGwire stated it was the best he’d ever seen and he did sprints yesterday. Waited on him all season last year before dealing him in the last month. Is he just mess in with us? |
12:03 |
: I thought he wasn’t going to be ready for the season, so yeah he’s a mess to project. Also, he K’ed too much when he was healthy, so I doubt he’s a .300 hitter ever again. And with the injuries, maybe the speed is going to go too.
|
12:03 |
Great job, Eno. Wondering if viewership at Beergraphs and Fangraphs took a noticeable uptick after that segment. |
12:04 |
: No way FanGraphs would feel it, but BeerGraphs might have, We’re growing fast but still small.
|
12:04 |
Whats Yordano Ventura’s 2014 upside if Hochevar is done? |
12:06 |
: You mean done starting, right? Ventura, Duffy, Davis look like they’ll make up one starting spot as of now. They have to give up on Davis, and Ventura is better than Duffy, probably. On the other hand, Ventura’s secondary stuff leaves me cold, none of them have good whiff rates and he doesn’t throw them much. Duffy could sneak in.
|
12:06 |
Have you seen Bryce Harper? Please explain to me how a naturally gifted profession athlete with access to the worlds finest training facilities can put on so much muscle in only 7 months? Seems suspicious to me |
12:06 |
: Thin mints!
|
12:06 |
Which multi-elib players do you like more? Prado or Zobrist? |
12:06 |
: Prado actually, but maybe they close. .290/15/5 vs .250/12/10?
|
12:07 |
Hi Eno…I’m in a 12 team, 5×5 roto and I have the 11th pick. I’m debating offering my 1st and 2nd (pick 11 and 14) for the first pick and their 4th round pick (pick #48) Just off the top of your head, would you do it? |
12:08 |
: That’s trading Edwin Encarnacion and Troy Tulowitzki or Adrian Beltre for Mike Trout and Jean Segura, maybe? You know… I would. Trout is that good.
|
12:08 |
Which former Diamondback do you prefer this year: Eaton or Davidson? |
12:08 |
: Eaton. Davidson has too many holes in his swing and questions about his defense.
|
12:09 |
Who is on the “injured, but should be back by May and contribute” list this year? |
12:10 |
: Cole Hamels, it looks like. Maybe Billingsley, maybe Jaime Garcia. Machado? Parnell?
|
12:10 |
What’s the ideal number of pitchers and hitters in a league where we keep seven? |
12:10 |
: Two pitchers.
|
12:11 |
marketing strategy: E Knows |
12:11 |
I totally pre-ordered the [expletive] out of Lost in the Dream. Added on Wagonwheel Blues too. Will be a happy day when that shows up in the mailbox. |
12:11 |
My own personal projection for Ryan Goins: |
12:11 |
: Well done, excellent interlude right out of the gate.
|
12:11 |
You think Billy Hamilton will stay in the majors all season? Similarly, what do you think about Dee Gordon’s prospects of starting or even platooning 2B? |
12:14 |
: You know, the Reds don’t really have another great option in center. I kinda think he might stick even with a .290 OBP. Gordon might actually factor in. With Sellers and Hairston and all their utility guys dried up finally, he could step in and be a bad backup defensive SS that can switch hit and play all around the infield. If Guerrero is bad against righties, then maybe there’s an actual role for Dee, as impossible as that has seemed at times in the past.
|
12:14 |
How soon, if at all, do we see Addison Russell this year? The A’s don’t really have much at 2nd and Lowrie is certainly not a safe bet to stay healthy. |
12:14 |
: He’s closer than it might seem, too, since he did well in the AFL. I think they’ll want to give him at least 300 PA in Double-A though, so unless there’s a long-term injury to Lowrie, doubt we see Russell until the second half.
|
12:14 |
I’ve done a bunch of drafts, and always seem to end up with the same staff. Is Salazar, Sonny, Cobb, Samardzija and Cole good enough to keep repeating? |
12:15 |
: I love it, but you may want to sprinkle in some lower-variance lower-upside veterans in the middle of the staff.
|
12:15 |
Any chance Pujols returns to form? |
12:15 |
: Of course. Health would go a long way.
|
12:15 |
I traded Yu Darvish as a third round keeper for Freddie Freeman as a 10th round keeper in a points league. Good move? |
12:15 |
: Probably one round of surplus for five or more, so yeah.
|
12:16 |
Hey Eno! A follow-up to what I asked in your AL-LABR article. You would choose Paxton over Keuchel if it was just a straight draft pick right? |
12:16 |
: Yeah, even with the crazy velocity numbers. I figured Paxton would go for more.
|
12:16 |
Stanton, Pedroia or someone else around Pick #22? |
12:16 |
: I like Pedroia there, sure. Stanton is okay, but he’s a one-category guy.
|
12:17 |
What do you think about Oswaldo Arcia? I drafted him in the last round of a 25-man draft, 12-team mixed. Mistake? |
12:17 |
: Nah, that’s a perfect place to take a shot. Problem with Arcia is that he’s a bit one-noted (power) and he plays in a park that suppresses power.
|
12:17 |
Mark Trumbo hits 40 bombs this year. True or false? |
12:18 |
: I love Trumbo, pushed his projections, have him rated higher than my co-rankers on this site, and only got him to .260/36. But that’s within range of 40.
|
12:18 |
how surprising would the Astros have to be and how well would Correa have to hit in order to see him in september 2014? |
12:19 |
: Anywhere close to pace for .500 might be enough, there’s a bit of a backlash to some of their tanking, and you can see that this year they paid some money for actual players.
|
12:19 |
Eno, you are truly the man of the people. Anyone ever tell you to run for political office? And, any shot of Gausman making starting rotation out of camp? Thanks. |
12:20 |
: That’s pretty hilarious. I’m not a citizen and there are way too many things that would get me in trouble lol. I do love people though, which can be rare in the blogosphere. As for Gausman, I think he’s super sexy and the only guy with ace upside on that roster. Why would they have Boring Bud Norris in the rotation over that? (They might.)
|
12:20 |
Buster Olney tweeted this morning that Andrew Cashner could have a breakout season. His ADP is sure to rise. What’s the earliest you’d feel comfortable drafting him? |
12:22 |
: Checking my rankings because I love him too. Cashner moved from the bad slow slider to his hard knuckle slider in the second half last year and his strikeout rate took a lurch forward. Plus park and league and all that. I had him 35 among pitchers, between Cueto and Samardzija and Wacha and Shields.
|
12:22 |
: There’s still some injury risk.
|
12:23 |
Carter Capps? I have him in the 27th round of a 15 team league? Throw back and redraft in rounds 30-34? Same question for Storen who I have in the 21st? |
12:23 |
: Yeah there’s some value there but no need to keep a reliever. You might get Vick Black in the 30th instead.
|
12:23 |
Eno, I have questionnnssssss |
12:23 |
Have you seen this? Between this and AB blocking their trademark for “The St. Louis Brewery”, Schlafly has some issues. http://www.stltoday.com/business/local/who-owns-the-right-to-the-schlafly-name/article_7d33e934-03e3-530a-86e7-f4c7a3bcffd8.html |
12:23 |
Thursday is the best… thank you for making it so. |
12:23 |
Experience Bij! |
12:23 |
How do you decide on names for your dozens of teams? Same ones year to year? |
12:24 |
: I just realized that like seven or eight of my 12 teams are now dynasty or keeper, so they don’t even need names. And in my LABR/TOUT leagues, I have to use my real name. So I only get to name like three teams a year, and I usually just do some stupid baseball pun.
|
12:24 |
Are you sticking with your young-SP-centric approach this year? If so, who are this year’s names to be targeting? |
12:26 |
: It really worked well last year, and I guess in LABR I got Alex Cobb and Sonny Gray. But if you’re talking lower picks, it’s not as obvious this year. I like Alex Wood, Dan Straily, Drew Smyly, Kevin Gausman, and then a tier lower I like Jenrry Mejia, Tyler Skaggs (just because park and IP and chance of regaining velo) and James Paxton.
|
12:27 |
Would you rather draft Justin Upton this year or wait a round and draft Heyward? Because of keepers, Heyward will definitely be drafted the round after Upton. |
12:27 |
: I have them separated by two bucks, which is just about a round lol.
|
12:27 |
How do you feel about Tommy Hunter, closer, this year? |
12:28 |
: Really really intensely meh. I mean, he could do it, but his splits aren’t great and the curve isn’t your power curve strikeout pitch, it’s the big yakker. I’d rather move Norris in there.
|
12:28 |
Eno! Can you give me 4-5 awesome Holds RP for a Ottoneu FG points auction league??? |
12:29 |
: Cody Allen, Danny Farquhar, Joaquin Benoit, Shawn Kelley, Mark Melancon, Sergio Santos, Jake McGee, Kelvin Herrera.
|
12:29 |
Will Kelly Johnson get enough playing time in NY to be a reliable util guy for fantasy? great position flexibility. |
12:30 |
: I’d take him for my bench in H2H, but I wouldn’t put him in a starting role. Not with the state of that infield seeming so.. in flux. It’s good in that he could get time at second and third, it’s bad in that the team might be looking for a more long-term solution out of their younger guys.
|
12:30 |
NL only while Zimmermann is the better pitcher, who would you rather target as a cheaper alternative in a trade Lance Lynn or Patrick Corbin? |
12:30 |
: Corbin. For sure. Corbin’s change is better than Lynn’s.
|
12:30 |
I’m looking at relievers to target who won’t start the year in the closer’s role, but should contribute 5×5 regardless, guys like Melancon, Brothers, Crain, Benoit, Clippard, Allen, Farquhar, Santos, Black, Soria, Scheppers… who stands out? |
12:31 |
: Santos, Crain, Allen, Farq, Melancon. But Brothers is the clear number one.
|
12:31 |
why dont catchers ever have to make 40-60% or 60-90% plays?? the # is very low in their category on IE |
12:31 |
: Maybe it’s just hard to judge those. Like, a can of corn pop foul is easy. and the ones they really have to lunge for, easy. But something they kind of have to go get but not really?
|
12:32 |
In a pts based dynasty league who would you prefer: Sal Perez, Brandon Belt, Brad Miller, Headley, Prado, Rasmus or Taijuan Walker? I am leaning Walker due to his prospecty-ness… None would really be a starter for me this year, if it matters. |
12:32 |
: Brad Miller plays shortstop and has power and speed.
|
12:32 |
I come for the baseball chat, stay for the ludes. |
12:32 |
Isn’t the 59th minute also top of the hour, or am I not getting it? |
12:32 |
i imagine you saying “hey you guys” like sloth from the goonies |
12:33 |
: Exactly.
|
12:33 |
Most likely player to end up with -1 WAR or worse and still qualify for the batting title? |
12:33 |
: Emilio Bonifacio? Maybe not on that team. Rafael Furcal? Casey McGehee?
|
12:33 |
are you taking the 2013 infield shift data into account with valuing players for 2014? (moves to more shift happy divisions….players that are more prone to the shift not being as readily regressed in babip etc.?) |
12:34 |
: We’re doing some work on xBABIP with an infield pull% factor to try and factor this in. Matt Adams, for example, got shifted late in the season and his BABIP dropped precipitously.
|
12:34 |
With Stetson Allie starting the year in AA, do you think that he can ever become a solid Major Leaguer with the bat? And because he hasn’t been a hitter since high school, how much leeway can we give him regarding his age? |
12:34 |
: Age is also important from an athletic standpoint: reaction time, bat speed, that sort of thing. I am very skeptical that he can do anything more than Rick Ankiel it, and he’s playing first base so not even that really.
|
12:35 |
Who will be more valuable this year as a 3rd OF in a 5 CAT league, Khris Davis or Avisail Garcia? |
12:35 |
: I’d rather have Khrush, by a fair amount.
|
12:35 |
If you like Bruce Springsteen more, check out Wagonwheel Blues. If you like Fleetwood Mac more, check out Slave Ambient. |
12:35 |
Cole Hamels 🙁 |
12:35 |
every time my boss gets sick, he goes on and on about how he “never gets sick”. this has happened three times in the last three months, yet he continues to be convinced that he is immune to everything and these are all just anomalies |
12:36 |
: you’re on fire
|
12:36 |
A strategy–since pitching is so unpredictable and variable, wouldn’t it make sense to spend even more on hitting and a top closer or two and just take cheapish options on pitchers? just wondering if there are successful examples of that |
12:36 |
: That describes the general strategy right now. Some are trying to say that elite pitching is more projectable, and therefore elite pitching is worth it, but I dunno. I shop in the middle and avoid having to go for longshots.
|
12:37 |
I’m losing in my Iditarod Fantasy contest! I can’t find any advanced metrics. |
12:37 |
Please Eno. Terry Collins now says he might bat the pitcher 8th? Please tell me he is slowly going senile and will be replaced before he actually does anything stupid in the regular season |
12:37 |
: Oh good god that plus Eric Young maybe leading off is enough to make me want to eat a hat.
|
12:37 |
Thanks for the chat! It’s my first year in a Ottoneu Fangraphs points league. Any advice for roster composition in terms of relief pitching? We just completed the first half of our auction draft, and so far I have Street ($6), Clippard, and Gregerson. |
12:38 |
: yeah, spend 3-6 bucks per, generally target holds guys, but iffy closers are a value since saves are worth a point more than holds. Get six probably.
|
12:38 |
Hey Eno, Thanks for Chatting. In my 3rd round 5×5 league (C. Davis/Gomez are keepers), I have choice of Reyes,Bruce, Choo, Rios. Who would you take?? |
12:39 |
: I have Reyes, Choo and Bruce all separated by a dollar or two. It does seem like your team could use an MI though.
|
12:39 |
Is sano worth holding in a keeper fantasy league? Or keep sonny gray or brad miller? |
12:39 |
: Miller or Gray and that’s tough, like both, but probably the hitter since he plays SS.
|
12:39 |
will Jesse Crain get the closing gig in Houston? |
12:40 |
: Maybe, but if he starts season on DL, Qualls gets first shot and the incumbent has to screw up to lose his job, generally.
|
12:40 |
How much will Choo’s production change going from the Reds lineup/Great American to the Rangers lineup/The Globe |
12:40 |
: More runs, don’t see a big power boost.
|
12:40 |
which is more common- a ground ball that produces a hit or a fly ball that produces a hit? Are line drives a different category altogether? |
12:40 |
: the batting average on GBs is like .230, FBs is like .200, and LDs is like .700.
|
12:40 |
So in the podcast you said you don’t love Eric Hosmer. Why lie? We know that you have been making googly eyes at him for years. |
12:41 |
: I bought him in AL-LABR! I like him at a price. I think he can .280+/20/10-. But I don’t think a big power spike is coming, not with all those ground balls. Also, watch THT in the coming week for more on this name.
|
12:41 |
Best hangover cure? |
12:42 |
: Gatorade first. Then salty food and water.
|
12:42 |
if we say that fangraphs is a star destroyer, what star wars vessel would be the appropriate comparison for beergraphs |
12:42 |
: x-wing
|
12:42 |
#sadterlude: I was really excited to grab Hochevar for $2 in my uber-deep 20-teamer for that sweet swingman SP/RP eligibility and potential to start (league where anyone throwing innings is useful). 🙁 |
12:42 |
Hochevar partial UCL tear, right? |
12:42 |
which happens 1st Franklin traded or a FA signs? |
12:43 |
: Interesting question because teams looking for help at SS are both looking at Drew and Franklin. But with the Ervin Santana wrinkle, I say FA.
|
12:43 |
If you had to pick 1 of these guys to breakout, which would it be? Gyorko, M. Adams or K. Seager |
12:44 |
: I think Seager is pretty much sussed. I think Adams might be a tad over-rated, but would .265/26 be a breakout? It would, and it might be less than some expect. So I’ll go Gyorko, based on some more walks and perhaps a bit more power.
|
12:44 |
Can Matt Holliday keep this production up? |
12:44 |
: He’s going to start hitting the DL some day.
|
12:44 |
Can I draft/buy Yordano Ventura and expect him to be my #4 starting pitcher? Or just a bench/flier guy in a 12-team mixed league? |
12:44 |
: I’d prefer very much if he was on my bench.
|
12:44 |
Josh Hamilton 30 HR .260 with and .800 OPS? |
12:44 |
: under on power
|
12:45 |
I heard that the instant replay rule involves the managers throwing a red baseball at the umpires to initiate the challenge. Is this true? |
12:45 |
Are bitcoins dead now? |
12:45 |
Enows What You Did Last Summer |
12:45 |
Matt Adams or J Abreu? |
12:45 |
: Abreu!
|
12:45 |
How much should I downgrade Hamels with the recent news? |
12:45 |
: 1/6th at least!
|
12:45 |
Cole Hamels showing brokenness signs. Chance Phillies fall back to 5th beyond the Marlins? |
12:46 |
: The pitchers that might come in for him are CRAPTACULAR
|
12:46 |
are we in for a repeat of Bronson Arroyo’s 2011 if his back woes don’t clear up? (his GB% dove 5% that season and his HR/FB skyrocketed perhaps due to a lack of ability to get downhill plane on his pitches?) |
12:46 |
: I want NO shares of him this year. Not one.
|
12:46 |
I’m frantically trying to trade a cheap Beachy after watching yesterday’s outing. Is it too early to be getting nervous? He looked like a mess regardless of the decent line. |
12:47 |
: He needs command to be successful. I might have to watch that start now.
|
12:47 |
which highly rated prospects will be called up earliest? |
12:48 |
: Andrew Heaney. Gregory Polanco. Noah Syndergaard. George Springer. Mark Appel. Marcus Stroman. Roughly in order.
|
12:49 |
Is Tommy Medica a flash in the pan or is he legitimately good? |
12:49 |
: He was old for his levels and the upper minors parks for the Padres are hitters parks. There’s no pedigree, and the deck is stacked against him. I prefer Alonso by a long shot.
|
12:49 |
Why is everyone so down on Todd Frazier? Sure the BA could be better, but decent numbers at a shallow position this year. |
12:50 |
: Not much more projection I don’t think, but useful.
|
12:50 |
I’m sure you’ve posted this before, but if you could again: Xander B.s’ projections for this year? I have agonized over him vs. Mauer for a month now for final keeper in a Keep 5/Keep Forever. Probably zero% chance I get Mauer back if I throw him back in the draft, maybe 75% chance I get XB, but not sure I want to take the 25% chance. |
12:50 |
: Something like .264/16/8 with a great OBP.
|
12:50 |
Will there be a master list of the Fangraphs Roto Rankings or just the existing one by position? |
12:51 |
: I doubt we can get to this tonight but there does seem like some love for this, so expect it soon.
|
12:51 |
Would you trade a $9 Uehara for a $13 Sonny Gray? |
12:51 |
: yes.
|
12:51 |
What percentage of hitting is bat speed and what percentage is pitch recognition? Baez looks like he could be a hall of famer based solely on bat speed while being below average at pitch recognition. |
12:51 |
: No idea how to answer this, or even to test it!
|
12:51 |
Am I climbing the ADP lists yet? Top 6 Player? |
12:52 |
: Yes he does seem to be climbing, up from around 10 to middle of the first round.
|
12:52 |
Would Prince a steal at $23 for 4×4 otto? |
12:52 |
: yes.
|
12:52 |
How much would you pay for Feliz in an AL only auction right now? |
12:52 |
: 4-5 at most, something like that. No velocity is bad news, has tons of competition.
|
12:53 |
I’m doing my first ever 5×5 draft next weekend. I’ve always done points leagues, and I’m afraid I’ll value players incorrectly. What are some basic things I need to keep in mind to avoid such pitfalls? |
12:53 |
: Sort baseball for batting average and stolen bases because you’re not used to thinking about them. Read the list.
|
12:53 |
Carlos Gomez….270 AVG, 25 hrs, 40 steals good possibility? |
12:53 |
: Under on average and homers, but not by a ton.
|
12:53 |
Is almonte worth a flier for cheap? |
12:54 |
: In deeper leagues, yes. With news that Ackley is in LF and Saunders in CF, there’s already 1/3 playing time open for Almonte.
|
12:54 |
No citizenship? Can you and Cistulli trade? |
12:54 |
: I’m an EU citizen with a greencard, and that absolutely would have helped Carson this year.
|
12:55 |
Were Greg Maddux (in his prime) to pitch to Pablo Sandoval (in his prime) 1000 times in a row, how many BB would Pablo get? How many HR? |
12:55 |
: 30 walks? 20 homers?
|
12:55 |
Thoughts on Julio Teheran? Looking at pitch values and whiffs, he seeming has a great fastball and slider. His curve and changeup get above average whiffs too. |
12:55 |
: Yeah it’s all there. What’s missing is a willingness to throw the change more. That’s the only strange thing.
|
12:56 |
Thoughts on Garza? Better pitch framer, decent D behind him…he’s being drafted around AJ Burnett / Corbin / Bucholz. How would you order them? I think I go Corbin / Garza / Bucholz / AJ |
12:56 |
: Agree, though I might have AJ ahead of CB based on IP. DECIPHER THAT MUMBO JUMBO
|
12:56 |
The New York Mets with a 90 million dollar payroll. What a joke. 90 million= 90 wins. |
12:56 |
: Eh Braves been doing it for about the same.
|
12:57 |
You could still run for something, plenty of political positions don’t require citizenship and just ask yourself this: are any of the things that might get me into trouble politically worse than, or even on par with, what current politicians have already done? |
12:57 |
: This is true. But then I have to ask: Do I have the cash to fund a campaign. No, so very no.
|
12:57 |
Seems like Jose Abreu is going to get so much helium that he loses his value. |
12:58 |
: Totally possible. I have him below Pujols for example. And Ortiz. And Butler.
|
12:59 |
Rank these closers in the order that you’d take them… Jones, Axford, Hunter, Brothers, Veras. |
12:59 |
: Veras, Axford, Brothers, Jones …… Hunter
|
12:59 |
So, I know spring training and junk pitches and guys wearing numbers that start with 8 and 9. But, would looking at Everth Cabrera’s contact rate be a good idea before my draft? |
1:00 |
: At the very least, it’s a per-pitch metric, and it’s very key to his upcoming year.
|
1:00 |
Got laughed at at the draft table for not taking a single SP till round 12 (12-team mixed). My SPs: Salazar, Ryu, Corbin, Kluber, Ross, Griffin, Straily, A. Wood, and J. Johnson. Who gets the last laugh? |
1:00 |
: Yeah looks pretty good to me.
|
1:00 |
Jose Fernandez or Chris Sale?? |
1:00 |
: Sale
|
1:01 |
You can’t beat names of defunct franchises for fantasy team names. The Cleveland Spiders or Worcester Ruby Legs is pure class |
1:01 |
: Cleveland Spiders from Mars
|
1:01 |
How do you feel about your Labr squad? |
1:01 |
: Really good actually. I know they’re young, but that means they’re pre-peak, and most of them have job security.
|
1:01 |
Man….target the young guys Eno ISN’T touting….if you play in a good league most of your leaguemates knwo Eno’s guys too….. |
1:01 |
: Plus, Lucas Duda.
|
1:02 |
At what point in the season does Dean Anna get a starting role. Follow up: how many days after that will he be 100% owned in ESPN and Yahoo? |
1:03 |
: No idea. I bought him in LABR mostly because he’s a lefty on the infield with great contact rates, and some power and speed. And that infield sucks. But it’s a shot in the dark.
|
1:03 |
Tried the Indira Stout from Ballast Point? Not sure if I hate it or love it |
1:03 |
: Is that the one that tastes like Indian food?
|
1:03 |
How would you utilize Brandon Moss in weekly leagues? I was attracted by the position eligibility and the power, but now I’m having buyers remorse. |
1:04 |
: Yeah he’s still going to platoon and 520 PA or so has to be his ceiling. But he has power, so it’s all good.
|
1:04 |
how often do you question/think twice re: zips results? or do you? (im terrible at coming up with questions) |
1:04 |
: I don’t question them, I just use ZiPs, Steamer and the Fans to create a range of projections. Then I pick my projection somewhere in the middle of that range, sometimes closer to the Fans if I’m feeling frisky.
|
1:05 |
what!! you don’t have Wacha above 35?!! what am I missing here????? |
1:06 |
: None of us did. He does need to work on a third pitch to get same-handed batters out. Boston jumped on his fastball and put a book out on him.
|
1:06 |
I’ve keeping an eye on Billy Burns out of Oakland. Speed + a potential .400 OBP. Do you see any chance that he makes an impact this year? |
1:06 |
: Gentry and Crisp probably have it figured out. I think Burns is a little bit more of a longer-term asset. But fun to watch.
|
1:06 |
Are you worried about pitchers who are having injury issues currently? (Latos, Hamels, Greinke, Verlander, Iwakuma, etc.) |
1:06 |
: Past injury concerns beget future ones.
|
1:07 |
More upside, Tyson Ross or Jose Quintana? |
1:07 |
: Ross, I guess, but he has a lower floor and they both don’t have super high ceilings. Q has a good curve and some deception, okay command. Ross has a great great slider, velocity, terrible mechanics, and no change.
|
1:08 |
shot in the dark eno, first closer to lose their gig via injury/ineffectiveness? |
1:08 |
: Latroy Hawkins. Oh, he might have already done it. hmmm. Rafael Soriano elbow tenderness?
|
1:08 |
Personally, I welcome seeing Bartolo Colon getting more at bats in the 8 spot, but that’s just me. |
1:09 |
BEst hangover cure is Pho |
1:09 |
The only real downside of Opening Day drawing nearer is the increasing coherence of these chats. |
1:10 |
A beer and a baseball question. Beer first! We are escaping the Swedish state-run alochol system for a month this summer. Any favourite breweries to visit between Portland and San Fran? |
1:11 |
http://beergraphs.com/leaderboards/breweries/?q=®ion=us_pac&min_solid_s=0&max_solid_s=100.0&min_solid_pct=0&max_solid_pct=100.0&min_bar25=-9&max_bar25=270.0&min_bar=-102&max_bar=543.0 but Russian River is a must, Cascade is probably too. Elysian, Lagunitas. Drake’s.
: This can help |
1:11 |
as for baseball, due to draft-pick trading I have Trout, Miggy and Kershaw as my 3 keepers in a 12 team Roto League. But no draft picks until round 9. What would be the optimal strategy here? |
1:12 |
: Guess you have to hit hitting hard while others are going pitching. I usually am looking for pitching in those rounds. Keep your eyes open, but think about SPs and MIs.
|
1:12 |
Where are you drafting Javier Baez? |
1:12 |
: In re-drafts? Bench or not at all.
|
1:12 |
Is there a good enough chance Mailel Franco gets significant 2014 AB’s that I can live with David Freese at 3B in the interim? |
1:12 |
: Yes. Apparently Asche has looked atrocious at third.
|
1:12 |
A good DC brewery (Atlas) is coming out with an IPL. What to expect from an IPL? |
1:13 |
: Sorta like a session pale ale. Weak by ABV, some good hopping.
|
1:13 |
Revisiting a comment from a month ago, when you told me to withihold judgement, I’ll ask again: how bad is Archer now?!?! |
1:13 |
: I’ll agree it’s not as good as before, though I can’t quite put my finger on why. It’s not like the change was really a change, after all.
|
1:13 |
I live in Wilmington, NC. This Spring, we are getting 4 new breweries in the general area. Which is great, bc the one brewery we already have does not make good beer. |
1:14 |
On a more serious note, there was a study done by some grad students to find the best hangover cure. Conclusion: bacon sandwich. The fat and salts help you rebound quickly and the bread provides carbs for energy. |
1:14 |
is there a spreadsheet somewhere that already averages out ZiPS and Steamer or am I going to have to do that myself? |
1:14 |
: I have that. Maybe I can fill the rankings spreadsheet with that. So many things to do!
|
1:15 |
Am I as dangerous as my name sounds? |
1:15 |
: so so so good
|
1:15 |
with s much volatility at the cloer spot, can I justify spending some solid picks on Kimbrel AND Chapman/Holland? |
1:15 |
: They can still get injured.
|
1:15 |
In a keeper league with openings at all these positions would you take Brad Miller, Travis D’arnaud, or Profar? |
1:15 |
: miller
|
1:15 |
Eno, how much bump does Rajai Davis get with the Dirks surgery? |
1:15 |
: A sizeable one!
|
1:16 |
Eno! Help me out… this may be out of your range of expertise, but maybe the chatters can help. I am rolling through Nashville and Memphis and am looking for good brewery recommendations. |
1:16 | : |
1:16 |
You buying the Trevor Bauer post hype sleeper re-hype? |
1:17 |
: Love to have him for a buck in an AL-only.
|
1:17 |
Are you on board with the massive hype for Javier Baez?How much concern is the plate discipline? |
1:17 |
: Bust rates on prospects with those kinds of walk and strikeout rates are fairly high, actually. I might shop him if I owned him. (I don’t.)
|
1:17 |
After what appeared to be a breakout, is Domonic Brown now getting close to the underrated tag? No one seems to believe. |
1:17 |
: Yeah with more PA this year, I think he can do pretty much the same thing.
|
1:17 |
And now for something completely differnt, Carlos Gomez. |
1:18 |
Two of three here: Mejia, Paxton, and Duffy. |
1:18 |
: Mejia and Paxton, as much as I still have a bit of hope for Duffy. Only problem with Mejia is injury — his career high is like 110 IP. Love the new slider.
|
1:18 |
BYO Indian restaurant tonight. Should I bring Hop Suplex (2xIPA), Saison de Lente, Stochasticity, or Old Guardian? LH Nitro Milk Stout an option too but I haven’t found that to be a great option with food |
1:19 |
: I think you’ll want the DIPA because Indian food brings BIG BOLD flavors and your saison will just be water.
|
1:19 |
Article Idea: You guys talk about plate discipline and how it translates at the big league level. Would love to see an article quantifying the average. Example: On average a player with a 20% K-rate and 10% walk rate in AA/AAA typically sees X% increase in K-rate/decline in walk rate. |
1:20 |
: That’s a problem because the correlation is low. K and BB rates can tell you about the likelihood of a prospect succeeding in bigs, but they tell you less about their actual MLB K and BB rates, if that makes sense.
|
1:20 |
Do you take any of this Miller battling Franklin stuff for the ss job seriously? |
1:20 |
: Nobody I’ve talked to that watches the Mariners thinks Franklin is a shortstop.
|
1:20 |
Hey Enosaurus. Im probably just really dumb, but I can’t figure out the “auction values” link on rotographs “draft tools” sidebar. Every time i click on it it just seems to take me to the projections page. I know I must be missing something obvious. |
1:20 |
: You are not. I should break the link, but we’re working on something nice.
|
1:20 |
CRAPTACULAR is being kind to Miguel Alfredo Gonzalez, David Buchanan, Jeff Manship and Sean O’Sullivan |
1:21 |
Dude, I am just POUNDING bubblegum flavored Trident right now. |
1:21 |
CarGo or Braun? |
1:21 |
: My values say Cargo but my projection says .285/27/13 for Braun.
|
1:21 |
Grady Sizemore have anything left? |
1:22 |
: They say they not sure he can play every day and I say uh-oh.
|
1:22 |
If bat speed was everything, Rickie Weeks would be sitting on 250 million Mariners doubloons. |
1:22 |
Pay $45 for Darvish or $30 for Shields in an AL-only auction? |
1:22 |
: neither.
|
1:22 |
Is there any hope for Chris Carter’s BA? |
1:22 |
: No. It could actually get worse.
|
1:22 |
any way you can run zips on the team from “major league”. i’d love to know what dorn was capable of |
1:22 |
wait. EU citizen is a thing? Not a German citizen? |
1:23 |
: Well, yeah I’m German, but I’ve held on to it a bit more because EU than any thought I’d go back to Germany to live. Wish they’d let me double up.
|
1:23 |
the Maddux/Panda thing but with Vlad because duh. |
1:23 |
: I think I’d give him 20 walks but up the homers to 40 or so.
|
1:23 |
my theory is that the Phillies shifting is really just a sly way of Asche auditioning for 2B |
1:24 |
: Throwing is part of the problem, and Utley’s knees are degenerative. So, yeah.
|
1:24 |
I am way high on Gerrit Cole–higher than Shelby Miller, Michael Wacha, and Kevin Gausman. Does that sound right? |
1:24 |
: Yes.
|
1:24 |
: I made a gentleman’s bet with Lawr Michaels, I took Cole, he took Gray.
|
1:25 |
NL Only league, $10 Ike Davis, $1 Mike Olt or a $2 Oscar Tavares? |
1:25 |
: Oscar actually! And I’m not sure about his PT this year.
|
1:25 |
Few seasons ago I played against the 1864 Wabash Mashers. Best. Name. Ever. |
1:25 |
Did you see Brian Wilson’s knuckleball? http://wapc.mlb.com/cutfour/2014/03/04/68690860/brian-wilsons-first-pitch-of-the-year-was-a-knuckleball |
1:25 |
Baseball is like church, many attend few understand. |
1:25 |
if you look at actual baseballmonster values from last season, miggy was twice as valuable (or more) as every hitter after McCutchen (who ranked 6th overall hitter). What’s your opinion on this? If that’s the case, doesn’t wouldn’t it make sense to spend basically whatever Mig costs in an auction rather than buy a later first rounder for considerably more than half of what mig costs? |
1:25 |
Miggy or a later first and second rounder? |
1:26 |
: Miggy, see? yeah the only thing that I wondered about my AL-Labr draft is if I should have gone to 43 on Miggie. Might not have mattered, I wouldn’t have gone to 45.
|
1:26 |
I tend to wait til the fourth round to select my “ace”, and I suspect the two top guys available will be Bumgarner and Sale. What’s the cae for one vs the other? |
1:26 |
: NL and mechanics to Bumgarner.
|
1:27 |
Speaking of Duda. Any chance he ends up with the Mets 1b job? |
1:27 |
: Yes but not sure when. Might be after mid-season trade.
|
1:27 |
every time i read dean anna’s name out loud, it makes me think that De-Nana would be a great name for a service that comes to your house and removes your bananas. (or a hospital that offers euthanization, but…maybe not that so much) |
1:27 |
A few months back, frequent commenter HSCHER mentioned that he was training his eventual work replacement. I have shown up at these chats every week since wondering if this was the week he won’t be around. Nothing from him yet this week. I’m worried. |
1:27 |
: oh noes!
|
1:27 |
I liked the Boston Beaneaters for a defunct franchise name. |
1:28 |
What position do you find yourself waiting on longest (besides P and C)? Seems like third-tier 2b has the best bargains relative to the prices of the top-tier. |
1:28 |
: Outfielders. There are so many!
|
1:28 |
If you had to go 5/4/3 on zips, steamer, fans, how would you go? |
1:28 |
: Love Zips and Steamer, and Steamer just updated their pitching so… hard to choose there. Fans three for sure.
|
1:29 |
You seem to be higher on Rendon than most, does .270/13/60/65 sound about right? |
1:29 |
: Yeah and my projections have (slight) overs on BA and HR.
|
1:29 |
Why does Delino Deshields have a zips projection? |
1:29 |
: JR?
|
1:29 |
Your enoites will fund your campaign |
1:29 |
Coherence is overrated |
1:29 |
What’s wrong with punny fantasy baseball team names? |
1:29 |
Would you rather have Chris Davis power or Billy Hamilton speed? not for fantasy or real life baseball, but you, eno, you. |
1:30 |
: I play a little more basketball than softball and plenty people have great power in softball. Hamilton speed.
|
1:30 |
Tell me something nice about Didi! As in, he is starting SS opening day |
1:30 |
: I think if he’s not starting in Arizona, he could be starting in New York, so the floor is decent.
|
1:30 |
I’m actually going to bat the pitcher lead off this year. You know, get him out of the way. |
1:30 |
Archer is still the best- the House Call episode (2 weeks ago) was top 5 all time |
1:30 |
Archer is still Archer. Shows are good, bar too high. |
1:30 |
Fun Fact: Kimbrel’s Curveball allowed 0 Fly Balls in play last year. 0. |
1:31 |
Magic Hat #9 was one of the first “great” craft beers. What happened to the brewery? they’re a dog now? |
1:31 |
: I think they got bought, haven’t done anything new in a while.
|
1:31 |
Earliest you take a top flight closer in a 12 team league? In other words, keeping Holland in the 13th is ok, right? |
1:31 |
: Yes, that’s fine. I start looking a them in the 8th/9th.
|
1:31 |
Going to be in Florida this weekend for baseball! Besides Cigar City, any brews I should be looking for? |
1:31 |
: Terrapin is down there too.
|
1:32 |
Im in scottsdake now. Why is it such a beer wasteland here. No good bottleshops even |
1:32 |
: Papago!
|
1:32 |
Archer isn’t as good because it has become Archer,Cheryl and Pam. |
1:32 |
btw, where did you rank Harvey this time last year? |
1:32 |
: checking
|
1:33 |
: I was the most aggressive and had him 39.
|
1:33 |
Can Derrick Norris break out a little bit? He has some good minors seasons under his belt |
1:34 |
: He mashes lefties but 29% Ks and .097 ISO against righties has been his problem so far.
|
1:34 |
Is Mike Trout Hopslam? Is Jeff Franceour Coors Light? |
1:34 |
: Mike Trout should be Pliny the Younger because he’s worth a pilgrimage.
|
1:34 |
Im going to the new cubs park tomorrow. any idea of the beer selection? |
1:34 |
: Actually I think the old Cubs park had Dale’s.
|
1:34 |
Hole Camels |
1:34 |
The phrase MoneyBall should be banned from everything. |
1:34 |
Duuuuuuuuuude |
1:35 |
Eno, you gotta get to AZ Wildeness brewing in Gilbert (Phoenix) next week. Its far and away the best option out here |
1:35 |
: They showed up in my fantasy beer post today on BG, so yeah.
|
1:35 |
I just cut into my avocado. It’s brown inside and looks like death. DAY RUINED. |
1:35 |
Morneau or Howard? |
1:35 |
: Morneau.
|
1:35 |
Who has the best outfield arm in baseball? |
1:35 |
: Puig? Martin?
|
1:36 |
Germany: biggest post-hype sleeper. |
1:36 |
: Were they ever hyped?
|
1:36 |
Eno! I have been doing some research on phenoms that pitch lights out their first year, and realize in year 2 (first full year) their performance is no where near as good as expected. You see any truth to that as applied to Cole, Wacha, Cingrani, Miller, Gray, etc. |
1:36 |
: Oh I regressed all those guys and still liked what I saw. I mean, yeah Jose Fernandez won’t be as good as he was last year. He’ll still be good.
|
1:37 |
Regarding the Beachy start mentioned earlier, the change up looked like a true out pitch and the command wasn’t that bad. |
1:37 |
In my experience, the name Joe is not quite as common as one might think, but it shows up in chats a lot |
1:37 |
I went to see the Angels play yesterday and the OF was Boesch, Cowgill and Someone named Matt Long. |
1:37 |
: Spring training!
|
1:37 |
Will I be ok if Jon Jaso or Derek Norris is my starting catcher in a 12-team, 23 starter Ottoneu Fangraphs points league? |
1:38 |
: Problem is that it’s still a 12-teamer. Norris v LHP is fine, but not sure if Jaso v RHP is going to be enough, even with the walks.
|
1:38 |
How about the Brooklyn Cake-Eaters? |
1:38 |
Wily Mo Pena Mo Problems |
1:38 |
Which of these would you prefer to stash in a dynasty? Correa, Lindor, Russell. |
1:38 |
: Russell for me.
|
1:38 |
What is the baseball equivalent of a missed open dunk/layup? Dropped pop up? |
1:38 |
: yup
|
1:38 |
Are IPL’s the new thing in 14 Fathom was tasty |
1:39 |
I just bought a sixer of a raspberry wheat ale from {name redacted}, but it has the single worst after taste I’ve ever encountered in a beer (something like burnt soap and Oprah’s feet). What do you do with the rest of the other case? |
1:39 |
: You put it in the back of your fridge at your next (x) parties and hope someone picks it up.
|
1:39 |
No, not Delino Deshilds Jr, Delino Deshields. http://www.fangraphs.com/statss.aspx?playerid=275&position=2B |
1:39 |
: Strange, that.
|
1:39 |
What’s your take on my rotation in a 12-team Ottoneu Fangraphs league? Gio, Cole, Latos, Bailey, Iwakuma |
1:39 |
: thumbs up
|
1:40 |
How much would you value Trout in a first time OttoNeu draft? |
1:40 |
: Keepable under 50, draftable under 60
|
1:40 |
Rh-ENO-cerous!!! your pitching calls are eggcellent |
1:40 |
Is goldy the lock for my 3rd overall pick ??? |
1:40 |
: I can’t push anyone else that high.
|
1:40 |
WHy doesn’t Cingrani ever get any love? He dominated the minor a great krates his first year… |
1:41 |
: I like him, but it’s just one pitch. Want to see more.
|
1:41 |
None of breweries in Maine get any love on Beergraphs. Lack of exposure, or is the beer seriously that much better everywhere else? |
1:41 |
: the new brewery metrics LOVE Maine Beer Company. Top five in three metrics.
|
1:41 |
Hameltoe |
1:41 |
Dylan Bundy- any value this year? thoughts in general? |
1:41 |
: If you have like three DL slots, he’s a good pickup late in a draft.
|
1:42 |
WHAT IF THEY GET BETTER ENO. WHAT IF THEY GET BETTER |
1:42 |
: The pitchers? Well if Wacha’s cutter, Gray’s change get better, sure, they can get better. G Cole under-rated by the fact that he didn’t use his offspeed much in first half, his K rate went up when he started to.
|
1:43 |
Salazar in the 10th?..segura in the 9th?..castro in the 8th?..or cobb in the 14th?..pick 2 points league |
1:43 |
: I like Segura in 9th best. I have him second at SS.
|
1:43 |
Wait, hold on, just got here. How can you not like Fleetwood Mac? I’m not taking your fantasy advice anymore. |
1:43 |
This is the year for CARLOS QUENTIN! |
1:43 |
: For some reason I love those two together.
|
1:43 |
Im in my first points league this year with one catcher. 14 team where would you look to pick up a catcher |
1:43 |
: Very very late.
|
1:43 |
At your AL-LABR auction, Darvish goes for $28 and a host of decent-to-good arms go for around $18. Doesn’t that make Darvish a great value in comparison? |
1:44 |
: With injuries, I’d prefer to spread my pitching risk around.
|
1:44 |
Did you even consider that Domonic brown might be the greatest player of all time? |
1:44 |
: No, I did not!
|
1:44 |
Regarding Wacha: Not disputing your ranking but do you seriously ding him that much for one bad game? The fact that it was the last game of the World Series doesn’t change the fact that it was the absolute smallest of sample sizes… and he held the same team to 3 hits a week prior. |
1:44 |
: No, those were possible reasons for regression. My projection has regression baked in, doesn’t need a reason: 183 13 0 164 3.54 1.2
|
1:45 |
all of the 2b and 3b options – besides the few at the top, make me sick. what shall I do?! Could you bring yourself to starting Brad Miller and Chase Headley to start the year? OBP league, so Headley does get a bump |
1:45 |
: Yeah I’d be fine with that, but I’d like to supplement with some upside at third somehow. Arenado, Asche, Franco, something.
|
1:45 |
how long is a ottoneu draft? Also, I think saves should be the same as hlds because closer get more saves and are still more valuable |
1:46 |
: The first draft is really long, you have to draft 40 players x 12 teams. After that they settle in around 3 hours.
|
1:46 |
Is taking Hanley over goldy at 3 a dumb move? Or could it pay off |
1:46 |
: Given his injury history, I don’t like it.
|
1:46 |
strange that u can’t push Chris Davis past Goldy. |
1:47 |
: Not with this projection 621 557 85 98 38 4 0.276
|
1:47 |
jeff Francoer defense highlights are my favorite kind of highlights. One more year. |
1:47 |
What % of budget do you ration for hitters/pitchers in a standard auction? |
1:48 |
: 68/32. If you go by positions, should be 60/40 in most leagues, but I move it because pitchers are about 25% less projectable than hitters, and they get injured more, stay injured longer.
|
1:48 |
How about a Rotographs article on ESPN RP with SP eligibility? |
1:49 | : Check this list first |
1:49 |
Do you get depressed when commenters bash your team in the comments section after a column? |
1:49 |
: I actually loved that team so much that a little dash of realism only brought me back to I feel great about this team.
|
1:49 |
First time in an Ottoneu league. Best place for advice? |
1:50 |
: Chad Young, the ‘ottoneu’ tag on RotoGraphs, and FG+ for the auction values.
|
1:50 |
HAMELTOE and OLD DIRTY BASTARDO are gold, Jerry! GOLD! |
1:50 |
I don’t care if he doesn’t like Fleetwood Mac. BUT THE DOOBIE BROTHERS SHALL NOT BE DENIED. What a fool believes he sees! |
1:50 |
When you talk about ratios there- arent the values for pitchers already lower than hitters based on the projectability/injuries? |
1:50 |
: injuries perhaps yes, but not projectability, that’s not baked into values unless you move the P/H mix.
|
1:51 |
are you all going to make ’10 bold predictions’ again? |
1:51 |
: yes very soon
|
1:51 |
Are you a Giants A’s fan or both? |
1:51 |
: Family members are Giants fans. I root for great moments.
|
1:51 |
Do you bring a glove to games? |
1:51 |
: Nah, I usually bring my computer to work.
|
1:52 |
: I gotta podcast!
|
1:52 |
: Thanks for hanging out!
|
1:52 |
May the beer be with you. |
With a phone full of pictures of pitchers' fingers, strange beers, and his two toddler sons, Eno Sarris can be found at the ballpark or a brewery most days. Read him here, writing about the A's or Giants at The Athletic, or about beer at October. Follow him on Twitter @enosarris if you can handle the sandwiches and inanity.
ENO: I purchased Fangraphs+ on Feb 14 and I still can’t access it. And my copy of the Hardball Times hasn’t come yet. I have an Ottoneu auction tonight and am not happy. I noticed on the comments to your Fangraphs 2014+ column that my problem isn’t unique. Any suggestions?
We fixed those problems, and they mostly came from form of payment. If this is your log-in name, I’ll get it fixed asap.
For what it’s worth, there was someone with an aol address that looks a lot like your name that was signed up and all good for FG+, so maybe you have two log-ins? I’ll look into the annual.
I got my Hardball times within a week. I was surprised!