Fractured Kneecap Ends Yelich’s Season and Dents Brewers’ Postseason Hopes

Christian Yelich won NL MVP honors while leading the Brewers to a division title and within one win of a trip to the World Series last year, but hopes for repeating that magic took a severe blow on Tuesday night. In the first inning of the Brewers’ game against the Marlins in Miami, the 27-year-old right fielder fouled a pitch off his right kneecap and was forced from the game. In the aftermath of the team’s 4-3 victory, general manager David Stearns told reporters that Yelich had fractured the kneecap and will be out for the remainder of the season, a crushing blow to a team that has overcome a slew of injuries to win five straight games and climb to within one game of the second NL Wild Card spot.

Ouch. Ugh. F***. A player with a reasonable claim as the NL’s best is down for the count as far as 2019 goes, and while thankfully it’s not an injury with career-altering ramifications, right now there’s no joy in Mudville or Milwaukee. This completely sucks.

Facing righty Elieser Hernandez, Yelich fouled a 1-1 slider squarely off his right knee, crumpled to the ground, and remained there for several minutes while being tended to by Brewers athletic trainer Rafael Freitas. He could not complete the plate appearance (pinch-hitter Trent Grisham completed the strikeout, which was charged to Yelich) and limped off the field under his own power (you can see the video here).

Stearns said that Yelich would be flown back to Milwaukee to meet with team doctors and determine whether surgery would be necessary and what the prognosis would be going forward. He praised his star slugger, saying, “Look, I think first and foremost, we feel awful for Christian. This is a guy who has carried us in a number of ways over the last two years. He could have been two and a half weeks away from a repeat Most Valuable Player Award. That’s where our thoughts go first.”

Indeed, with a hot start to September (.345/.513/.724 in 39 PA), Yelich had put a bit of daylight between himself and the Dodgers’ Cody Bellinger (.250/.400/.464 in 35 PA) atop the NL leaderboards and, in theory, in the MVP race:

Christian Yelich vs. Cody Bellinger
Player PA HR SB AVG OBP SLG wRC+ WAR
Christian Yelich 580 44 (2T) 30 (3) .329 (3) .429 (1) .671 (1) 173 (1) 7.7 (1)
Cody Bellinger 600 44 (2T) 11 (15T) .306 (9) .410 (3) .639 (2) 164 (2) 7.2 (2)
Statistics through September 10. Numbers in parentheses are league ranks among qualifiers.

That’s not to say that the likes of the the Diamondbacks’ Ketel Marte or Nationals’ Anthony Rendon aren’t relevant to the race; they finished Tuesday with 6.9 and 6.8 WAR, respectively, for teams who are also in the playoff hunt. It’s fair to say that the battle for the award, which has been cast as one between the Milwaukee and Los Angeles sluggers for most of the season, is now wide open.

As for the Brewers, Yelich’s injury comes at a time when infielders Keston Hiura and Mike Moustakas have both been sidelined by injuries, while center fielder Lorenzo Cain has played through recurring knee soreness, and left fielder Ryan Braun has battled back tightness.

Hiura, a 23-year-old rookie who has been the team’s second-best hitter since arriving (.301/.369/.571 for a 138 wRC+ in 295 PA), has been sidelined by a Grade 2 left hamstring strain since August 31. He took batting practice on Monday, and is now eligible to come off the injured list, but beyond that, his current timeline is unclear. Moustakas, who has hit .260/.332/.522 with 31 homers (second on the team to Yelich), has taken just seven plate appearance since August 26, when he took a groundball off of his left wrist. He drew a walk as a pinch-hitter on Tuesday night, his first plate appearance since September 2, and while he is hopeful of returning to the lineup as early as Wednesday, he’s been dealing with “significant pain” and is clearly not yet 100%. Cain has hit a thin .253/.321/.353 for a 77 wRC+ this year, though his defensive numbers are still well above average. Braun (.282/.338/.484) has started just eight of the Brewers’ last 13 games, though he’s pinch-hit on three other occasions. Additionally, backup catcher Manny Pina (.230/.305/.419) was diagnosed with a concussion after the team’s September 5 game and is expected to be sidelined until at least Friday.

And then there’s the pitching staff. Adrian Houser is the only member of the current starting five (which also includes Zach Davies, Chase Anderson, Gio Gonzalez, and Jordan Lyles) who hasn’t spent time on an injured list this year, and Davies, Anderson and Brandon Woodruff are the only Brewers to make at least 20 starts. Woodruff has been out since late July with an oblique strain; he tossed two innings in a simulated game on Sunday and should return in the second half of September, though his pitch count may be limited. Jhoulys Chacín, the team’s Opening Day starter, missed time due to back and lat strains and pitched poorly enough that he was released last month. Freddy Peralta, another key contributor last year, has been exiled to the bullpen after struggling in the wake of inflammation in his sternoclavicular joint, and Corbin Burnes hasn’t pitched for the big club since mid-July due to shoulder irritation, though he rejoined the team on Tuesday.

Jimmy Nelson finally returned from his late-2017 torn labrum and rotator cuff strain but has been limited to 16.1 innings due to elbow inflammation. The bullpen, such a vital part of last year’s run, lost Corey Knebel to Tommy John surgery in the spring and then Jeremy Jeffress to a hip strain in late August; the latter, who had also battled shoulder trouble in the spring, was recently released. And so on. A staff that finished last season fourth in the NL in ERA (3.73) and eighth in FIP (4.01) has slipped to 11th in the former (4.59) and 10th in the latter (4.57).

Last year’s Brewers were particularly deep in the outfield, but trades of Domingo Santana and Jesús Aguilar, the latter of whom cleared Eric Thames‘ path for regular duty at first base, have thinned the ranks. Grisham, a 22-year-old rookie who was the team’s first-round pick in 2015, has hit .263/.324/.455 (98 wRC+) in 111 PA thus far, figures to see the bulk of the remaining time in right field, though Ben Gamel (.255/.338/.387) is also an option. Both are lefty swingers; righty first baseman Tyler Austin, who has 307 games of minor league experience in right field but just 43 innings at the major league level, could provide platoon help given his career numbers against lefties (.256/.347/.545, 134 wRC+ in 248 PA). Righty Tyrone Taylor, who hit .269/.334/.461 for Triple-A San Antonio, joined the team earlier this week, though he has just two plate appearances so far.

For all of the injuries and two straight months of sub-.500 play (24-27 in July and August, after just a 13-13 June), the Brewers are very much alive in the Wild Card race, with 21.5% odds, not to mention a 3.5% chance of overcoming their five-game deficit in the NL Central race. The loss of Yelich doesn’t help their chances, obviously, but among Wild Card contenders, they have the easiest schedule remaining (.474), with all of their remaining games save for this coming weekend’s three-game series in St. Louis against teams below .500. By comparison, the Diamondbacks (.486), Mets (.488), Nationals (.497), Cubs (.501), and Phillies (.528) have it harder. The Cubs themselves just lost Javier Báez for the remainder of the regular season, and they have other issues as well. It won’t be easy, but despite losing Yelich, it’s not at all out of the question that the Brewers pull this off.





Brooklyn-based Jay Jaffe is a senior writer for FanGraphs, the author of The Cooperstown Casebook (Thomas Dunne Books, 2017) and the creator of the JAWS (Jaffe WAR Score) metric for Hall of Fame analysis. He founded the Futility Infielder website (2001), was a columnist for Baseball Prospectus (2005-2012) and a contributing writer for Sports Illustrated (2012-2018). He has been a recurring guest on MLB Network and a member of the BBWAA since 2011, and a Hall of Fame voter since 2021. Follow him on BlueSky @jayjaffe.bsky.social.

47 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Cave Dameron
7 years ago

I guess it’s Acuna for MVP now.

Sleepy
7 years ago
Reply to  Cave Dameron

MVP of the Braves? Works for me.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  Cave Dameron

You must really like 30-30 seasons, huh? That’s the only logic I can find here.

dl80Member since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Then wouldn’t you pick Yelich and his 40-30 season?

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  dl80

Yeah, what made me say this is that it’s the only performance-related commonality between Yelich and Acuna that isn’t shared by Bellinger, Marte, and Rendon. Maybe CaveDameron thinks Acuna is going to bop 5-10 homers in the last few games here? I’m looking for logic here, I’m doing my best.

Sn0wman
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

But Acuna has 38, so he only needs 2 to also be 40-30? (not that he’d be my choice, either, but let’s get it right).

Cave Dameron
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

No, Yelich already has that too. Acuna will be 40-40 though and his team is in 1st.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  Cave Dameron

Is this what you think the MVP should be for, or is this your reading of the voters?

Jon
7 years ago
Reply to  Cave Dameron

Then why not Bellinger who has had the better season and whose team is also in 1st?

Cave Dameron
7 years ago
Reply to  Jon

Bellinger is only part of the 40-10 club right now.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  Cave Dameron

I see Cave Dameron is getting into character.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  Cave Dameron

Acuna might not even be the best 2nd year player in the NL. Soto making a pretty darn good case for that quite frankly.

WARrior
7 years ago

What makes it worse is that prior to this injury, Yelich had already missed almost as many games (15) as he now will for the rest of the season (18). If he hadn’t missed those 15 games, his MVP chances, as well as prospects for hitting 50 HR (and having the first 50-30 season in history) would be quite a bit better.

BaseballBreaksYourHeart
7 years ago

I think you are misreading the ROS W% from the standings page. That column is the teams projected winning percentage for the rest of the season. So, the Brewers are projected to win 51.1% of their games from here on out (at least based on fangraphs projections, you can toggle to season to date stats or coin flips). So, it is essentially the opposite of what you are saying and having a higher ROS W% is better for your playoff chances. You want to use the strength of schedule column, which tells an even better story for the Brewers: The Brewers have the easiest schedule left out of any NL team.

Mahoney
7 years ago

Over his last 162 games, Yelich has hit .340 with an 1.142 OPS and a 188 wRC+., with 57 HR, and also had 38 SB in 41 attempts. That’s flat out Troutian.

This injury truly sucks.

FrancoLuvHateMets
7 years ago
Reply to  Mahoney

Is it weird that i’m most impressed by the SB ratio?

wOBHey!
7 years ago

Yes

FrancoeursteinMember since 2020
7 years ago

Not at all, fellow Franco.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago

I don’t know that I’d say that Yelich had put space between him and Bellinger…… For one, there are a decent number of voters who look where teams are. Dodgers clinched the division, while Yelich’s Brewers out of playoffs right now. Right now it would have been razor thin. Now, if Yelich had stayed healthy and gotten the Brewers into the playoff- he’d have had a lot better shot with a lot of the voters.

TKDCMember since 2016🏆 MVP
7 years ago
Reply to  stever20

Yeah, Bellinger would be favored today if Yelich had not been injured. The race is not “wide open.” It would take something extraordinary for Bellinger to not win. He leads MLB in brWAR, he is near the top in all the big traditional stats, he has THE NARRATIVE, and he is going to win. He will likely get 85+ percent of first place votes.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  TKDC

yep. If the award voting were today, it’d be Bellinger and it wouldn’t be close.

NOW, if Bellinger were to struggle, and Brewers were to go into the tank the last 2.5 weeks of the season, maybe that would change. But realsitically nope.

grandbranyanMember since 2017
7 years ago

This team hanging around the race (& very likely coming up short), given all the things that have gone wrong this year, is almost more impressive to me than last year’s team coming up 1 game short of the WS with just about everything breaking in their favor.

MoateMember since 2022
7 years ago
Reply to  grandbranyan

I mean they were different teams playing in very different environments, so…sure? I guess that’s a take you could have.

fordfestival
7 years ago

Take a look at all the Brewers’ underperformers and non-entities that you listed. It’s seems miraculous that they’re within a game of first, with a -27 run differential to boot. I’d say this last injury is a death blow for them.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  fordfestival

well, one thing to kind of look at. Brewers record with Yelich in the lineup is only 67-63. They’ve been 9-5 w/o him in the lineup. The schedule is very managable- Marlins(2), Cards(3), Padres(4), Pirates(3),Reds(3),Rockies(3).

tdouglas
7 years ago
Reply to  stever20

Those stats don’t mean anything going forward, though. It’s not like a team can lose their best player and expect to continue to perform at a .643 clip. It’s certainly possible, but it’s more likely that the Brewers just took a knockout blow.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  tdouglas

But given what their schedule is, with 15 of the remaining 18 games with the worst 5 teams in the NL, it very possibly might not be. If they continue pitching to a 3.18 ERA(like they have in September), that’s going to keep them in every game.

Also looking, in the 14 games that he missed, the Brewers scored 4.71 runs per game. In the 130 games that he played in, the Brewers scored 4.72 runs per game. So literally no difference.

Where I think it’ll hurt them will be come playoff time, where they aren’t seeing bad pitching staffs.

Lanidrac
7 years ago
Reply to  stever20

You might want to look up the term “small sample size.” They’re not likely to continue pitching at a 3.18 clip or score as often without Yelich, even with the weak schedule.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  Lanidrac

7 of their remaining 17 games now are against the worst pitching staffs in the NL(including 3 in Coors). And 3 of the other games are at Cincy in that bandbox.

And that can overcome the Yelich injury. He’s been out the last 2 games(got hurt 1st inning of 1st game) and they’ve scored 5.5 runs per game vs the poor Marlins pitching staff.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  stever20

and saw from ESPN this interesting nugget- the Brewers final 13 games of the season(so last 2 weeks) are in 3 of the 5 best homer hitting parks in the majors. For a team that already has hit 227 homers.

kylesch87
7 years ago
Reply to  fordfestival

It is obviously going to be tougher without Yelich, but even an awesome player doesn’t move the needle that much over 18 games. ZiPS still has his projection in and that’s 0.7 WAR. If the Brewers end up either one game out or losing a tiebreaker game then it would be fair to say losing Yelich was the difference, but if they end up three back of so there wouldn’t be much you could say he could have done to make up that differential.

Lanidrac
7 years ago
Reply to  kylesch87

As tight as the race is, though, that one game could very well be the difference. Plus, if they do make the playoffs, not having Yelich is a significant blow to their chances to win it all.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago

So 1 question not related to Yelich.

How do the Phillies have a .447 winning percentage left for SOS?

lets look at schedule-
Braves 2
Red Sox 2
@ Braves 3
@ Indians 3
@ Nationals 5
Marlins 3

On what logical planet is that an easy schedule, let alone one of the easiest possible? Give me the Brewers “hard” schedule compared to that any day of the week and twice on Sunday.

emh1969
7 years ago
Reply to  stever20

I think you may be looking at their projected winning percentage for the rest of the season.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  emh1969

must have been what Jay was looking at- because I got that the Phillies have a .447 SOS remaining from the article….. .447 remaining record would make a whole lot more sense given that rather brutal schedule.

emh1969
7 years ago
Reply to  stever20

Gotcha! Didn’t realize that was in the article. 🙂

But yeah, the Playoff Odds page shows the Phillies with a .449 ROS W% vs. a .528 Strength of Schedule.

https://www.fangraphs.com/standings/playoff-odds

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  emh1969

looking at that- the Brewers have the easiest SOS remaining in the NL(and the Phillies have the toughest SOS remainining in the NL). Would say both of those make a lot of sense given their remaining schedules.

Jon
7 years ago

“pinch-hitter Trent Grisham struck out”

Actually Yelich stuck out.

(ducks)

JoserMember since 2021
7 years ago

I was immediately reminded of Jermaine Dye. That must hurt so much.
Years ago I knew a guy who broke his kneecap playing rugby and had to have it surgically removed. To my surprise that didn’t end his playing career (after rehab) or even affect him much in daily life.

lwendtMember since 2016
7 years ago

Reading those two paragraphs about the pitching staff is just miserable. Even for someone who’s been following closely all year, seeing everything condensed like that makes it feel worse somehow.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  lwendt

Only thing is in this recent hot streak(12-6 now last 18 games), they have had a 3.26 ERA.

Hader 0.00 ERA/0.32 FIP in 9.1 innings is back.
Pomeranz 1.93 ERA/2.14 FIP in 9.1 innings
Black 0.00 ERA/2.78 FIP in 7 Innings
Suter 1.42 ERA/3.69 FIP in 6.1 innings
Jackson 4.00 ERA/3.32 FIP in 9 innings

So the pen has been really good- 3.09 ERA/3.69 FIP in this streak.

baltic wolfMember since 2016
7 years ago

Perhaps this opens the door for Rendon to capture the NL MVP. In a season of home run records being broken with each passing day, his wRC+ of 161 is far above Acuna’s 125.

Very unfortunate injury. It would’ve made for an interesting three way race for the award.

btw Showing my age here, but his injury hurts but doesn’t kill the Brewers rest of the season. In 1972, the Oakland A’s lost Reggie Jackson when he tried to steal home in what was then the only series before the World Series. Of course, that team had some pretty good starters (and the Brewers obviously don’t), but the game has changed immensely since then. Middle inning relievers were only used for blowouts back then and most of them didn’t have the talent of the young hurlers today.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  baltic wolf

Big Nats fan, but Rendon wasn’t close to being in the race, no matter what the advanced numbers say. It was a 2 horse race, and 1 just pulled up.

selling jeans
7 years ago

Given the schedule, status of Cubs bullpen, and return to form of Hader, I think Brewers gonna get that second spot anyway. Cubs have been overrated by FG and everyone else all year. They look like a mess of a team, and Maddon knows he’s gone after season ends anyway

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago

Just a crazy thought that haven’t seen anyone mention. They said a normal timetable for a return would be 6-8 weeks. Well, the World Series starts 6 weeks from this past Tuesday….. You wonder, if the Brewers made the World Series, could he return, a la Schwarber from a few years ago? Even if he couldn’t play the field, he could be DH in games 1,2,6,7 and PH in games 3-5.