Byron Buxton Brought His Leg Kick Back to Minnesota
Byron Buxton played a major league game for the Minnesota Twins last night, the first since his most recent demotion to Triple-A Rochester last month. Also, in that game, Byron Buxton hit a big dinger:
It’d be great to see Buxton succeed. You hate to see any individual fail, let alone one with the type of promise which Buxton possesses. He’s still just 22 — this thing’s far from over — but thus far, Buxton’s done little to deliver on that promise. So we look for developments.
Upon his demotion in early August, I detailed, with the help of hitting instructor Ryan Parker, the numerous changes we’ve already seen in Buxton’s swing. So of course, I was interesting in seeing what that swing looked like this go-around. Particularly so when that swing led to a dinger in Buxton’s first game back.
Buxton had a leg kick in high school, which the Twins muted upon their drafting of him in favor of the organization’s go-to “front foot down early” hitting approach. That’s what we saw in 2015. That’s what we saw in the beginning of 2016, too, though after his first demotion to Triple-A in April, he returned a month later with a leg kick. Given the lack of success Buxton experienced in that stint, it was worth wondering whether Buxton and the Twins would stick with the leg kick, or revert to the original plan.
The leg kick’s still there, and maybe the most important note to be gleaned from this at-bat is that Buxton stuck with the leg kick throughout the count, even after it got to two strikes, something he wasn’t always doing his last time in the bigs. Where Buxton used to shorten up by going back to the toe-tap with two strikes, we’re now seeing Buxton commit to the leg kick more than ever, though it comes with the same caveat Parker provided in my analysis of Buxton last month: the foot’s still coming down before the upper-half of the swing begins, negating much the timing and power the leg kick is intended to provide.
As a counter, watch the .gif above again and pay close attention to where in the swing Buxton’s front foot plants on the ground, and then do the same for this Josh Donaldson swing:
Of course, comparing any hitter to Donaldson is unfair, but if you want to see what an effective leg kick looks like, look no further than Donaldson.
It’s just another something to monitor with Buxton. They could’ve abandoned the leg kick altogether, and they didn’t. To me, that’s a positive sign. The kick itself could still probably use some ironing out, but the committal with two strikes seems to indicate that the plan is to stick with this approach for the time being. The strikeouts never went away, but Buxton homered in four consecutive Triple-A games last week, and he’s already got the first of this go-around in the bigs under his belt. Byron Buxton isn’t going away any time soon, and neither is his intrigue.
August used to cover the Indians for MLB and ohio.com, but now he's here and thinks writing these in the third person is weird. So you can reach me on Twitter @AugustFG_ or e-mail at august.fagerstrom@fangraphs.com.
The one thing I will say in response to your two gifs you used is that Buxton is being thrown a curveball, and Donaldson a fastball. Buxton’s leg might have landed earlier than Donaldson because he was gearing up for a fastball, and had to adjust mid swing to the breaking ball. Whereas Donaldson was able to let it rip from the get go.
Yeah, I considered addressing this. Suppose I should have. You’ll have to take my word that the front foot landed like that for every pitch in the at-bat (and was also that way throughout his previous stint in the majors).
I really don’t understand why teams insist on changing things that have clearly worked in the past for guys, I understand changing something if it’s not working but why change it just for the sake of saying “this is how our organization does this”. It’s not as bad for hitters, but it seems much worse for pitchers, just makes zero sense to me.
Yes, and I also don’t understand why you would draft a player in the first place if the first thing you were going to do is throw out all his mechanics and teach him a set of new ones…seems like you’re just adding points of failure there. It’s one thing to tweak a swing or a delivery, it’s another to say “Well, we think he’s a great athlete and we just hope he adapts”.
At that point, why not just get a guy who already has something close to the approach your organization wants?
I think the idea is that despite the fact that balky swing mechanics might work at amateur levels, those flaws will be exposed by professional pitchers and good off speed stuff.
I agree that I wouldn’t change something until it doesn’t work in the low minors but I think orgs don’t want talented young players to experience failure right out of the gate.
BFD
I think it is good that Buxton uses his athleticism and does not try to slap and run. hitting it in the air is more productive and he does have some pop.
slapping it on the ground can work for speedy types but not if you strike out 20+ percent. Buxton likely never will be a great contact hitter but if he can become a 270 hitter with 20-25 home runs and some walks he would be a very valuable asset.
eno said in a podcast with Chris Mitchell that he likely always will have some contact struggles but can be a productive player.
However eno said his likely ceiling is more Cameron maybin or Carlos gomez and not Mike trout like prosepect analysts thought 2 years ago.
Love the leg kick analysis. I’ve been implementing one this season with mixed success. The difference between Donaldson and Buxton’s timing is something I’m still wrestling with. I’ve found Buxton’s timing is more natural for me since I’ve always been an early step guy. It works well against anybody humming 85+ (about 1/3 of my mens league).
However, it’s hard to get separation between the stride and the swing. If the foot’s down too early, the hip loses the tension added by the kick – defeating the point. Donaldson’s approach is MUCH more effective versus very slow pitches.
That’s a lot of power to generate from (pretty much) only the top half of the body, even more surprising for a skinny guy.