Contract Crowdsourcing Results: Bryce Harper and Manny Machado

In October, we asked you what contracts you expected Bryce Harper and Manny Machado to sign. Months later, Harper and Machado are still looking for an employer, and so on Wednesday, we asked you about the contracts again. The idea was to see whether the community has lost a little faith in the agents or the market. Do you still see the same big contracts, or do you expect smaller terms? What have you made of all the recent reports?

As you all know, you are (probably) not Bryce Harper, Manny Machado, Scott Boras, or Dan Lozano. This is just a fun exercise that means literally nothing in the end. But, it might not surprise you to learn that FanGraphs readers don’t see quite the same dollars anymore. After running the project again yesterday, we’ve received thousands of entries, so everything ought to be stabilized. The results are posted in the table below.

Contract Crowdsourcing Comparison
Player Month Avg Years Avg AAV Avg Total Median Years Median AAV Median Total
Bryce Harper October 9.1 $33.0 $300.1 10 $33 $330
Bryce Harper January 8.5 $31.3 $265.8 9 $31 $279
CHANGE — -7% -5% -11% -10% -6% -15%
Manny Machado October 8.6 $31.7 $273.0 8 $32 $256
Manny Machado January 7.9 $29.7 $233.0 8 $30 $240
CHANGE — -9% -6% -15% 0% -6% -6%

In words: The first time around, you all expected Harper to get an average of $300 million, with a $330-million median. Now those numbers have dropped to $266 million and $279 million, respectively. And the first time around, you all expected Machado to get an average of $273 million, with a $256-million median. Now those numbers have dropped to $233 million and $240 million, respectively. By and large, you still collectively think these two players are going to sign two of the biggest contracts in baseball history, but time has lowered the bar. You no longer think that Boras and Harper will be able to exceed Giancarlo Stanton’s $325-million guarantee.

Again, because we’re all on the outside looking in, we’re able to know only so much. We’re able to know only what different sources with different agendas want us to know. Yesterday, someone wanted us to know that the White Sox had an offer of $175 million out to Machado. Then Machado’s agent wanted us to know that, no, that’s absurd, that number is way off. Of course the White Sox are more interested than that. It should be obvious why Lozano felt compelled to issue the kind of statement he did, and we can never really tell when we’re being told the truth. Teams clam up now more than they ever have, so it only makes sense that most of what we ever see is coming from the player side. I don’t know why someone would’ve floated that $175-million rumor, but I’m sure there was some kind of motivation.

The hardest thing right now is probably figuring out who is even making up the market. The bigger the market, the bigger the contracts are likely to be in the end. We have a good sense that the Phillies want to sign one of these guys. On Machado, we are to understand the White Sox are involved. On Harper, we are to understand the Nationals at least *have* been involved. There was an offer of $300 million at the end of the season, but the Nationals have done a lot since then, most notably signing Patrick Corbin for $140 million. I can’t tell if the Nationals are out, or if it’s inevitable they ultimately present the high bid, not wanting to say goodbye to a franchise icon. Complicating matters is that Anthony Rendon is a year from free agency, and he’s expressed interest in remaining. I don’t know where the Nationals are today, and, beyond that, I don’t know if there’s anyone else involved for either player. It’s hard to believe there wouldn’t be, but no one’s been leaking.

Everyone wants a resolution. I can’t give you one. I don’t think you know much more now than you did before you clicked on this post. But a few minutes, at least, have elapsed. That matters, to some small extent, because Bryce Harper and Manny Machado are going to sign major-league contracts. They’ll sign those contracts somewhere within the next month and a half, I presume. Might happen today. Might happen in five weeks. It’s not just that we’re all waiting for more information. I think we’re also all just waiting to learn some actual truth. Everything out there now is strategic.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed. We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member. 1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other. 2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off. 3. Dark mode and Classic mode! 4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them. 5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects. 6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.) 7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only. 8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO. 9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members. 10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features! We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it. In case you didn't read all that, here's the short version. Membership includes:
✓Ad-free browsing
✓Unlimited FanGraphs & RotoGraphs articles
✓Historical & platoon projections
✓Leaderboard & player-page stat heatmaps
✓One-click data exports
✓Customizable player-page dashboards
✓Dark & Classic site modes
✓Weekly Members-only mailbag
✓FanGraphs Walk-Off, your year in review
✓Optional homepage photo removal
✓Gift articles to non-Members
✓Full postseason coverage




Jeff made Lookout Landing a thing, but he does not still write there about the Mariners. He does write here, sometimes about the Mariners, but usually not.

73 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
BacterunMember since 2016
7 years ago

John Jaso on this contract situation “It’s bizarre. Such is this game, and such is life” .

WARrior
7 years ago

Harper’s average length and amount was, and still is, below his median, indicating some people have been very pessimistic about what he would get. Machado in October was just the opposite, indicating there were some unusually high estimates. But the averages for both have now moved closer to the median, suggesting a more normal distribution.

BipMember since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  WARrior

I wonder if there are many outlier projections that, if removed, would materially change the numbers.

Max Power
7 years ago
Reply to  WARrior

On Harper it’s not necessarily pessimism. It could be that if Boras can’t break Stanton’s record of total value, he’ll try to break the record for AAV with a shorter contract length.

DBRunsMember since 2023
7 years ago

I think these numbers still look way too high. I can’t imagine there are enough teams in play at even $200 million to push valuations this high. I wouldn’t be surprised if both contracts mirror the Jason Heyward deal.

EasyenoughMember since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  DBRuns

For Harper, who had a bad first half and a pretty great second half, it seems conceivable he does a short (3 year), high dollar contract with a second year player option. Machado, with his very good year, seems like he needs to get a good, conventional contract.

bjsguess
7 years ago
Reply to  DBRuns

At $200M virtually every team would have room for Harper or Machado (or at least they could make room). If the Pads were willing to drop $140M on a first baseman who only plays well every other year, there will be a line out of the door of teams who would spend $200M on these two. The field only really starts to winnow when you get in the $250M+ range. Even then, I bet at least 8 teams will be in the running at $250M.

dodgerbleu
7 years ago
Reply to  bjsguess

IMO, the Hosmer signing is worse than that as it’s front-loaded. It’s really a 5-year 100M deal, with a player option for 3-years 39M extension after his age 32 season. Seeing as how he’ll be going into his age 33-season, I imagine he opts out for one more contract thinking he can beat 3 years at 13M each at that point (though the market may say otherwise and I doubt Padre fans will mind by then).

BipMember since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  DBRuns

These are two potential hof hitters hitting the market at age 26. we’re not far removed from two *over-30 pitchers* getting 200M each. if both these guys fail to break 200, then the MLBPA should strike immediately.

DBRunsMember since 2023
7 years ago
Reply to  Bip

These arguments are ludicrous. The value of any asset is how much someone is willing to pay for it. If you list your home for $X and receive no offers, your home probably isn’t worth $X. Sure there is history of players receiving $200 million contracts in free agency, but how many of those contracts panned out? We’re seeing a market correction here, and the only think that needs to change are expectations.

BipMember since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  DBRuns

The value of any asset is how much someone is willing to pay for it.

Ok, what is the value of these assets then: Jose Ramirez, Aaron Judge, Vlad Jr? How much are people willing to pay for them, and how much are they being paid? Teams may be right to pay less for the older free agents, but if the result of that is players get less of the profit pool despite doing the same work they’ve always done, they should still strike. And they have a point, by your reasoning above: there are some extremely valuable players out there who are getting paid a tiny fraction of what they are worth.

Brian McMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  Bip

Well, yes there are players getting paid much less than what they’re worth. From a salary standpoint, you really can’t compare arbitration players and free agent players. I think it’s perfectly reasonable for teams to be hesitant to give a player 300 million for 10 years. After all, the only player to ever sign for that much played for a team that was immediately sold (and that player was quickly traded). Teams realize that so many of these contracts don’t look so great in the 2nd half. Plus, both Manny and Harper haven’t signed yet, and its only mid-January. Let it play out before you light the pitchforks.

nathanjMember since 2024
7 years ago

I wonder if the Mariners should sign either guy knowing that the Mets will flip them a few prospects in 2024 for the last few years of the contract……

Spitball McPhee
7 years ago

New Poll w/option years and type as a variable.

No mention of swellopts though

tuna411
7 years ago

swellopts…opt outs <<< just stupid for the team, fantastic for the player

Ryne DurenMember since 2016
7 years ago

Clearly some teams (even most teams) are impacted by the mostly bad experiences of some long term and big money contracts as much as by their own roster or budget. If teams could get an “opt-out,” there’d probably be more interest in taking the risk. Of course, it doesn’t work that way. The free agent market was very strong for the players for years and maybe some regression should be expected, rather than assuming that the market will always embrace longer contracts and more $.

SenorGato
7 years ago
Reply to  Ryne Duren

What? Are you just going to completely ignore this sport’s rising revenues and the players’ shrinking share?

Are the majority of people on this site hoping teams will hire them based on owner friendly takes or something?

Johnston
7 years ago
Reply to  SenorGato

A lot of that rise in income wasn’t player-related (MLBAM, for example). Demanding on threat of strike that players get a share of income that was not related to them is essentially extortion.

The elephant in the room is sabermetrics. Most teams have a far better understanding today of the actual marginal values of players than they did a few years ago and that’s keeping salaries and free agent signings down. Then there’s the Pujol/Heyward/Kemp effect on big contracts: teams are more aware of the risk of big contracts these days and far fewer of them want to be the next team with a crippled payroll and egg all over its face.

The average salary for an MLB player is still over $4 million a year. That’s a ridiculous salary when you think about it – almost obscene. The players are anything but underpaid, and we are living through a period of market adjustment. Relax.

Famous Mortimer
7 years ago
Reply to  Johnston

MLBAM was only a success because of the sport it showed, though. Are you being this naive on purpose?

DBRunsMember since 2023
7 years ago
Reply to  Johnston

@Johnston: I agree. I think that’s spot on. We’re in a period of market adjustment. Organizations are becoming more averse to long-term commitments. My guess is these 2-3 year deals we’re seeing this offseason become more common. I anticipate this leads us to a CBA with a higher luxury tax threshold and thus contracts with higher AAVs. Player salaries increase, owners worry less about dead money commitments.

timprov
7 years ago
Reply to  SenorGato

It’s very much the union’s fault that they chose to concentrate their CBA gains on precisely the players who are least productive per $, and throw the younger players to the wolves. Is it supposed to be a surprise that the owners are declining to spend those absurd numbers on big-name free agents when they’ve been given almost a free ride on players’ first few years, because those particular players weren’t part of the union yet when the negotiations happened?

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago

I used to think that if I was the Nationals, I lock up Rendon and forget about Harper. But that was back when I thought that Harper’s contract would be $300M+. Maybe I’m alone on this, but I think they’re pretty equivalent in terms of value (Rendon’s actually projected for more via Steamer) and I wouldn’t want to spend much more on Harper than Rendon.

I don’t see how Machado or Harper possibly signs for less than $200M, unless they decide they’re going to take a pillow deal or some other contract situation that lets them test the market very soon. And I think there’s still a very real chance that Machado beats Harper here (which the contract crowdsourcing repeatedly disagrees with me about), but I don’t see how either one tops $300M unless an owner just decides they want the guy, no matter what. It doesn’t sound like that’s the case right now, but maybe it will change.

Brewtown_Kev
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I agree—there’s no $300 million deal in either player’s immediate future unless a team bids against itself. I wonder if the $300 million reported to be offered by Washington at the close of the season was ever really anything more than smoke.

martyvan90Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

“And I think there’s still a very real chance that Machado beats Harper here (which the contract crowdsourcing repeatedly disagrees with me about)” probably more about the crowd respect, fear and or loathing of Scott Boras. I happen to agree with your point from a value perspective and Scott Boras may work against Harper’s best interest in this case especially if he took the Nationals out of play. A legend in his time but even the great ones age.

Spa City
7 years ago

You Maximize your value by getting more bidders in the mix. The best way to get all 30 teams bidding is to take a 1 Year Contract…

If Harper made it clear he would go year to year, each time signing for 1 year to the highest bidder, he could earn a fortune.

The nightmare for every team is paying for the final 3 to 4 years of a player’s career. That brings down the AAV, and precludes teams like Pittsburgh, Milwaukee, Tampa from even considering making an offer.

Long term deals afford security for the player, but if Harper gambles on staying healthy and playing well, he could get $50 a year the next several years by taking 1 year contracts.

Even small market teams can afford $50M on a 1 year deal, and if they are on the verge of making a serious run, any team could afford Harper’s services.

johansantana17Member since 2026
7 years ago
Reply to  Spa City

Minnesota’s payroll is down $30 million from last year. I think they would be a great fit win curve-wise too. You could squint and see them beating stingy Cleveland, for which Harper would be a better positional fit than in Minnesota, for the division if Harper has a 6+ WAR season.

It’s also been previously reported that the Dodgers are interested in Harper on a short term, high AAV deal. I suspect teams like the Cubs and Yankees would heavily reconsider if Harper was available on a 1-4 year deal, and that teams like the Braves, Astros, and Giants might get involved on those terms.

synco
7 years ago
Reply to  Spa City

I don’t think anyone’s getting 1/$50 – something like 1/$35 is probably a lot more likely. The problem is the first guy who gets that and then puts up a down year (Harper’s a perfect example with the up and down nature of his career) is going to ruin the model for everyone else.

SenorGato
7 years ago

FanGraphs, I really truly appreciate at least some of what is on site. THAT said, you guys should change the site name to WeAlwaysSidewithManagementGraphs or something similarly owner friendly. Boooooooooo the enabling

Jason BMember since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  SenorGato

This….this may be the single worst hot take I’ve ever seen on this site. Having lived through the “felony fraud” years, that’s saying something.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  SenorGato

This is a hilariously, completely, and tragically factually incorrect assessment.

SenorGato
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Oh, do I wish to be wrong but it’s really not

Just off the top of my head close to midnight on a Thursday….$/WAR, Machado being comped to Heyward, this discussion…

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  SenorGato

I suppose everything is relative, so there are viewpoints where an article like this would be pro-owner, but…generally speaking, the writers on this site have been pretty consistently pro-players-should-be-paid-more. Last offseason was largely a parade of articles insisting that players should be getting paid more, wondering why they weren’t getting paid more, worrying about player pay declining, etc.

BipMember since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I agree with you as far as where the writers’ feelings lie, but on the other hand, the baseball thinking on this site would very very much support teams collectively backing off the free agent market. I mean look at any ZiPS projection where these players get ~0 WAR projections into their late-30’s.

The missing piece is that baseball-reasoning tells us the young players are the ones producing all the value now, but arguing that young players should be paid more then goes outside the scope of baseball analytics, and so you don’t see as much attention paid to that.

Johnston
7 years ago
Reply to  SenorGato

Señor Gato, as a capitalist who has been here for years I have found the commentariat on this site to be consistently Left-leaning and – with the exception of me – utterly pro-union. Your silliness made me laugh out loud.

The GuruMember since 2026
7 years ago
Reply to  Johnston

this site will go to great lengths justifying the ownership side. the facts are, mlb revenue is going up and the players salaries are going down back to back yrs. Thats just a fact. Last year the excuse was everyone was saving money for this FA cycle to get harper etc. Will be interesting to see this yrs reason. You wouldnt think anything is wrong though reading this site though. ha

Johnston
7 years ago
Reply to  The Guru

MLB revenue is going up but some of that increase, like the MLBAM money, has nothing at all to do with players. For anyone to deserve a share of a revenue increase they either need to be an owner or team stockholder or have contributed to that revenue. Otherwise, this is the equivalent of a Rite-Aid employee demanding a raise because Rite-Aid‘s revenues increased when Rite-Aid sold off some stores: it had nothing at all to do with the employee, their contribution, or their performance, and they accordingly don’t deserve it.

Question: When MLB revenues fall, for whatever reason, will you support immediate player salary reductions? With your weak logic you’re implying that you either have to support such salary reductions or be a complete hypocrite.

The GuruMember since 2026
7 years ago
Reply to  Johnston

Yes i would if revenues fall. Yes salaries should fall concertly with falling revenues. Most fans cant differentiate normal buisness from unions. This is a union, with agreements in place.

These guys have .000001% of population elite skills. God forbid someone with those skills in any industry get paid their worth.

This is unionized…meaning the whole principle is a 50/50 relationship. Its like that in NBA, NFL, NHL etc. 50% of revenue should go to players.

Famous Mortimer
7 years ago
Reply to  Johnston

lol @ MLBAM’s success having nothing to do with the players that were broadcast on the damn service. Nice work, stooge.

The GuruMember since 2026
7 years ago

ha exactly. I’ve always thought the players should start their own network. Every interview etc will be broadcast to the MLB Players Union channel. No player would give the MLB network time of day. All that money goes to MLB and none goes to the players.
All that outside income and advertisement money would start to flow to the union.

BipMember since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  The Guru

That makes no sense. MLB works as-is because people do what they’re best at. Players focus on playing and the media types that MLB hires does the media. If players had to split their time on running a media enterprise too, then they would be worse players, and be outcompeted by players willing to accept the system as it is.

The problem here is that all of MLB’s enterprises need the players in order to succeed, but the players don’t create that revenue themselves, MLB has to deliver the product the players make. The reasoning that players have no involvement in MLB media and therefore shouldn’t get the profit is like arguing that the players have no involvement in ticket sales unless they personally man the ticket booths.

BipMember since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  Johnston

Otherwise, this is the equivalent of a Rite-Aid employee demanding a raise because Rite-Aid‘s revenues increased when Rite-Aid sold off some stores: it had nothing at all to do with the employee, their contribution, or their performance, and they accordingly don’t deserve it.

Of course it has something to do with the employee’s contribution. Rite-Aid would not function as a business without employees. If its employees do their jobs well, the company makes more money, and as such the employees deserve some of the value they create. Of course, it’s complex to put this into practice, but I fundamentally disagree with that characterization.

London Yank
7 years ago
Reply to  Johnston

The Rite-Aid analogy does not work because in MLB (and unlike Rite-Aid) the players are also the product. The players always have something to do with MLB’s success because without the players there is nothing to sell.

BipMember since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  Johnston

Can you explain to me why capitalists are anti-union? Unions IMO are the proof that capitalism is the best economic system (or, maybe the least bad one.) Because in a free society, people are free to associate as they please. If workers choose not to work, and give up their pay as a result, shouldn’t they be free to do that? After all, the worker-company relationship is a mutual one; they both need each other. Each has the right to assert their value. If a company sets pay too low, workers won’t work for it, and if workers request pay too high, no one will hire them for it. Seem to work out for the most part.

Famous Mortimer
7 years ago
Reply to  SenorGato

I don’t think you deserved this much voting down. There’s been a lot of “brain drain” from here to teams’ FOs in recent years, so it’s not outside the realms of possibility that people would view team-friendly takes as a way out of this site and into a well-paying job.

TKDCMember since 2016🏆 MVP
7 years ago

Who reported that $175 million number and is there any accountability that this could have been completely made up bullshit?

Johnston
7 years ago
Reply to  TKDC

Buster Olney did on Twitter.

The GuruMember since 2026
7 years ago
Reply to  Johnston

gee i wonder who told him and why. clear message to other teams theyve set the market. this being leaked is collusion cba violation.

Johnston
7 years ago
Reply to  The Guru

Buster Olney doing his job and reporting baseball news is now somehow MLB collusion? Good grief. Shades of “felony fraud.”

The GuruMember since 2026
7 years ago
Reply to  Johnston

yes it is. Olney is fine, hes a reporter. But its not fine where his info comes from. Clear violation of the CBA for teams to leak contract salary negotioations publicly. This is written in black and white in the CBA.

fjtorres
7 years ago
Reply to  TKDC

One theory would be that somebody on the player side did it to get more teams into the bidding.
When the narrative was $300M-plus, most of the middle market teams that might’ve bid $210M over seven shrugged and moved on.
With a lowball bid floating around, a few teams might pick up the phone to say “Really?”
The answer would be “No way. But we’re listening… You interested?”
Suddenly, it’s not just the Phillies, ChiSox and a made-up “mystery team”.
He still ends up in Philly but with stupid money in the pocket.
It used to be easier to get teams bidding against themselves with “mystery team” rumors but that trick has gotten old.

CL1NTMember since 2025
7 years ago

If I’m Harper or Machado, and the bidding really is as quiet as we think it is, I don’t see why both wouldn’t be open to go three or four year deals.

This will enable several more teams to get in the mix, which in turn will drive the price up. They’re 26. They’re not going anywhere anytime soon. They should advertise wanting a three or four year deal, than go back on the market at age-30 season. Both of them could possibly make $40MM per season for the next four years, then very possibly sign another four-year deal at 30-years-old for around $25-$30MM per year, if they are still playing at a high level.

I think the “10 years” is really pushing everyone away, and I think it’s kind of unnecessary for them since they could easily recieve another big contract in their career, since they are so young.

It’s like they are trying too hard to gain infinite security, when they don’t have to. If they were both average or slightly above-average players, than yah, get that longterm financial security. But if you are already known to be a possible future hall of Famer, than security really shouldn’t be an issue. The production they’ve produced already can give them record-breaking annual salaries.

I fear that the stubbornness of wanting a 10-contract is going to end up losing them money in the end. And when they are 36-years-old and still playing at a high-level, it will have been a pointless situation anyways because obviously if their still good in their mid-thirties than they could have easily had two major contracts in their careers.

FrodoBeck
7 years ago
Reply to  CL1NT

It doesn’t make sense for them for a number of reasons. First is the obvious, security in the off chance they get seriously injured.

But second, you say they’ll easily receive another big contract after a shorter one ends, but here’s the problem with that: this same thing will happen when they hit FA again, except they’ll be 3 or 4 years older, with that much more risk. Their AAV will be pushed even lower, and they’ll have missed out on tons of potential guarantees.

SteveSherman161Member since 2018
7 years ago
Reply to  FrodoBeck

Exactly. How many 30-year-olds are breaking the bank in free agency this year?

johansantana17Member since 2026
7 years ago

Patrick Corbin is 30 this July.

tuna411
7 years ago
Reply to  FrodoBeck

‘security’? what does everyone mean when talking about security? are you guys saying a one year, $20 million dollar contract isn’t enough to set someone up for life, let alone 5 years at $30 million per?

or security of having a team to play for? but they are ‘soooo good’, they’ll have a team for the next 10 years, right?

Listen, I am all for earning top dollars but historical statistics say players are ALWAYS overpaid when signed to a long term contract (last several years VERY seldom are worth the dollars). I have no empathy for mm or bh or kimbrel, or whom ever is shooting for the moon and doesn’t come close to what they publicly want. at these numbers, just sign in a city you like, who cares if it is $3 million less a year (no difference between $190 mil vs $175 mil except to your ego), it is STILL astronomical numbers, numbers each player should never spend (unless you are completely careless with your money).

FrodoBeck
7 years ago
Reply to  tuna411

I think it’s safe to say unless you are a multi, multi-millionaire (hundreds of millions) you probably don’t understand why a guy would want 30 million a year for 10 years instead of 27 million for 10 years. It’s not really a problem insignificant people run into very often. You might think there’s a negligible difference because the dollar amounts are so high, but I guarantee you if you go into an interview where you expect to be paid $12 an hour and the companies you interview with never offer more than $9, even though you’re obviously worth $12, you’d also be trying to squeeze out whatever you can get.

CL1NTMember since 2025
7 years ago
Reply to  FrodoBeck

Shorter deal makes sense because they could most likely make more money in the long-run by recieving TWO contracts (if the bidding is indeed as slow as we think it is right now).

So say Harper does a 4-year, $160MM deal this year. That’s AAV of $40MM for his next four seasons. Record stuff.

Then when he’s 30, he goes for another. 30-years-old isn’t bad, and if he was still a top-5 player through his first contract then he should be able to still get a big contract. I mean Donaldson signed a one-year gig with ATL for like $23MM and he’s 33 (yes he’s under way different circumstances, but he’s making big money based on his past value).

So say Harper (in his second contract at 30-years-old) signs another 4 or 5 year deal that pays around $25MMish.. lets just say 5-year, $125MM. He could that, maybe more, if he’s still a top player in the majors.

So that’s two contracts worth an overall value of $285MM. That’s more than I think he’ll get this year if he signs long-term deal. He’s not getting 10-years. And he’s not getting $300MM (as we’ve seen from the crowdsourcing, which I know means nothing, but is still the popular opinion).

And whose to say he couldn’t get a third contract or an extension on his first or second deal.

TLDR: lower term deal enables more teams entering the auction, which in turn raises price. Plus, given how much we initially thought Harper would get, if he advertised that he wants a 4-year deal than he and Boras could push a narrative that they are “giving in” and would be willing to do a shorter length deal for more money per year. $40MM per year is some damn good money to make for the next four years. And if he’s really this good than he should be fine when he’s 30.

Injuries happen anytime. If he gets seriously hurt he’s not playing either way. And don’t teams have some sort of insurance in the event a high-paid player gets hurt seriously.. like bad enough for the player to be out for multiple years or so?? So they obviously aren’t paying a guy $30MM/year to no longer play for them because they can’t play anymore..

hebrewMember since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  CL1NT

That’s not how insurance works. The contract the.player gets is fully guaranteed – they will get their amount no matter what.

Insurance will pay part (or all) of that money in the event a player suffers a career ending injury, in return for receiving regular monthly payments from the team.

NATS FanMember since 2018
7 years ago

The Nats can still afford the $300 million and should go for Harper at that price. Above that is just damn crazy.

emh1969
7 years ago

Seems to me like the team that should take advantage of this situation is Cleveland. They’ve already saved significant $$$ this off season. They can now trade Kluber for the best package available to generate additional savings. Then, use all that money to sign either Harper or Machado to a contract that includes an opt-out after 3-4 years. Yeah, there’s some risk that Harper or Machado won’t opt-out and they’ll get stuck with an 8+ year contract that they don’t want. But they’re treading water right now and they’re not going to get anywhere without taking some risks. Unfortunately, management is still haunted by the ghosts of Bourn, Swisher, and Hafner…

fjtorres
7 years ago
Reply to  emh1969

If Cleveland were to play that game (offseason PR fan service) the guy to get the big money would be Lindor. He’s younger, homegrown, more consistent than Harper, and actually hustles, unlike Machado.
And he’ll be gone soon enough.

Kluber might actually outlast Lindor on the team.
(Kluber has three years left and Lindor will most likely be traded before hitting free agency.)
Not a good thing but that’s their reality.

emh1969
7 years ago
Reply to  fjtorres

The problem is that extending Lindor doesn’t make the team better right now when they have an opportunity to win. Instead it makes the team better 4 years from now, when we have no idea how competitive they’ll be.

Free Clay Zavada
7 years ago
Reply to  emh1969

But how does swapping out Kluber for one of those two guys help the team in 2019? WAR projections roughly equal. Yes, Indians need position players more, but not enough to commit 8+ years when instead you can be locked in short term with Kluber for cheap.

emh1969
7 years ago

But how does swapping out Kluber for one of those two guys help the team in 2019?

Ummm….cause you’d obviously be trading Kluber for one or more players that can help you immediately.

fjtorres
7 years ago
Reply to  emh1969

No, it doesn’t.
But it gives them the same PR at the same price. “We’re spending!”
And it’s equally unsustainable.
By all appearances they made their flurry of trades to cover Lindor and Bauer’s arbitration and are waiting on trading a starter to see if Bauer’s award breaks their budget. That’s why the OF is a bunch of maybes and prayers.
They most likely won’t sign anybody until they see what arbitration brings.
Hardly a team that’s going to take on a $20M salary, much less what Harper will get.

Dustin
7 years ago

There’s also the secondary story to this, beyond the Machado/White Sox drama, which is this: What happened with Buster Olney to break this story? Olney, by all counts is a legitimate journalist, but this seemed off immediately. This story felt weird when it came out, but then Lozano comes out and says the whole report is hogwash, which justified the weirdness of the report. So, someone out there is lying. Presumably it’s Olney’s source(s), but you have to assume that he got corroborating reports from within the organization, right?

Olney comes off looking like an amateur blogger in this, and that sets off my own personal alarm; Maybe there’s more going on in this than even we know, and I’d be interested to find out what it was/is. Whatever you think of Olney at this point in his career, something that he’s never been has been un-trustable as a news-breaking source on the national level, not as far as I can remember.

Johnston
7 years ago

If I were Harper or Machado I’d be looking for a $30M plus three or four year deal with a consistently winning team that I could help to win a World Series – the Yankees and Dodgers come to mind immediately for Harper.

The GuruMember since 2026
7 years ago
Reply to  Johnston

ha, if you were harper you wouldn’t do that. No way in hell would you agree to a 3 and 4 year deal….you would be 30 years old trying to get your next deal? how many 30 year olds are breaking the bank these days.

Johnston
7 years ago
Reply to  The Guru

“ha, if you were harper you wouldn’t do that. No way in hell would you agree to a 3 and 4 year deal….you would be 30 years old trying to get your next deal? how many 30 year olds are breaking the bank these days.”

That’s exactly what I would do. You are clearly far too young and far too poor to understand this, but the effective difference in your life between having $100 million and having $300 million is really pretty trivial.

Fredchuckdave
7 years ago
Reply to  Johnston

You somehow out stupefied one of the dumbest posts in Fangraphs’ history with this comment; bravo imbecile.

Spitball McPhee
7 years ago

The problem with this lame market is that these players are of near equal value to Win-now teams and Win-soon teams; which should (italics) encompass 15 teams. A team like the Pads, Twins, Jays, Braves, someone else who are 1-2-3 years away have near equal need on the win-curve. This is a once a decade chance to gain a player who will provide ~5 WAR for the next 5-6 years and potential top 5 MVP player in Harper. Man the fuck up.

Schide
7 years ago

Pirates

bookbookMember since 2019
7 years ago

At 8 years, $200 million either player is a steal. If the Mariners signed one, it makes their quickie rebuild an odds on favorite to work, whereas right now it’s a long shot.