Lance Lynn Is Now a Cy Young Contender
Last night, Lance Lynn got the second half of the season off to a very good start for the Texas Rangers by striking out 11 while issuing just two walks in seven shutout innings. Even with that great start, Lynn is still second to Max Scherzer, who leads all pitchers with 5.5 WAR, but he’s now accumulated 4.4 WAR and is a full win clear of Charlie Morton and Gerrit Cole, who are tied behind him. When Lynn shut down the Astros, he wasn’t just dominating an average team. Houston has the best hitting offense in all of baseball, with a 118 wRC+ and an 18% strikeout rate that ranks second in the majors. Three weeks ago, I noted Lynn’s perch atop the AL WAR Leaderboard as an interesting peculiarity, an unexpected development. His performance since then has thrust him to the forefront of the American League Cy Young race.
On June 20, I wrote about how Lynn’s ERA was misleading, how he lessened his sinker usage in favor of the cutter, and how he used a different approach with runners on base to minimize damage. One thing I missed when writing that piece was Lynn’s slightly different arm slot, which Michael Ajeto wrote about at Pitcher List and which likely helped make his cutter better. In what ended up being less than fortuitous timing for my article, Lynn immediately went out and gave up four runs in the first inning of his June 22 tilt against the White Sox. Since that inning, Lynn has pitched 28 more frames, struck out 31 batters, walked just three, and allowed only three runs. His ERA at the time of the article was around four; it has since dropped to 3.69. That might not seem too low, but consider that Baseball-Reference’s version of WAR, which is primarily run-based as opposed to the FIP-based version here at FanGraphs, also thinks Lynn is excellent. His 4.5 WAR there is second in the AL to Mike Minor and third in baseball with Scherzer also ahead of him. Over at Baseball Prospectus, Lynn leads the AL with 4.2 WARP.
Here’s where Lynn ranks in a bunch of stats, both traditional and modern:
| Lynn | AL Rank | |
|---|---|---|
| WAR | 4.4 | 1 |
| FIP | 2.86 | 2 |
| FIP- | 60 | 1 |
| IP | 122 | 3 |
| SO% | 25.8% | 9 |
| HR/9 | 0.74 | 4 |
| BB% | 5.5% | 7 |
| bWAR | 4.5 | 2 |
| WARP | 4.2 | 1 |
His relatively low poor ERA showing (13th) is mitigated by having no unearned runs, which is unusual, and pitching in a hitter-friendly park. Lynn’s case as AL’s best pitcher this season stands on its own, but he’s actually been even better since a so-so start to the season:
| Lynn | AL Rank | |
|---|---|---|
| WAR | 3.9 | 1 |
| FIP | 2.53 | 1 |
| FIP- | 53 | 1 |
| IP | 94.1 | 1 |
| SO | 110 | 3 |
| ERA | 2.86 | 8 |
| ERA- | 58 | 5 |
| HR/9 | 0.67 | 2 |
| BB% | 5.3 | 9 |
Consider this your Lance Lynn Cy Young update.
Craig Edwards can be found on twitter @craigjedwards.
Generally speaking, if you’re leading in all 2 major WAR calculations and #2 in a third–which all take very different routes toward estimating value–that’s pretty strong evidence.
Still, this is a little different than in the NL, where Max Scherzer is on pace to have his best season ever for the second consecutive year. He’s been unbelievable lately.
What surprised me last night was watching him up to 98 mph. Somehow, in his age 32 season, he’s become a big velo guy….
I get that you are trying to imply something, but he hit 98 years ago as well. Is it unreasonable that he did some velocity training?
*cough*CharlieMorton*cough*
I find the years that Minor and Lynn to be fascinating.
The have relatively pitched the same amount and have the same bad defence behind them (which is 25th in MLB in DRS).
Neither has given up an UER, but yet Minor has given up 17 less ERs than Lynn thus far.
Neither of them give up many homers and in the Top 20 of HR/9.
Minor has a Hard Hit rate of 37.7% while Lynn is 34.7%, and yet Lynn’s BABIP is .331 and Minor’s is just .264.
The only thing I can think is perhaps Lynns BIP hit the left side of the field more than Minor where there is a distinct difference in DRS (Adrus and Cabrera having bad years, Guzman and Odor having better defensive years).
so looking, Lynn has a pretty favorable remaining schedule- 8 on the road- with only game at Yankees being a tough matchup.
I think Morton right now has to be the favorite, if he can keep it up he’s got a FIP better than Lynn, and an ERA 1.5 runs better than Lynn. That’s a pretty tough combo to overcome. Especially with for the older voters, the wins being nearly equal….
Yeah, I think that 3.69 ERA is going to be a tough pill to swallow. It would edge out LaMarr Hoyt’s 1983 season (3.66 ERA) for the worst ever by a Cy Young winner. He and Hoyt would also be the only two winners to finish outside of the top-10 in league ERA.
We are barely past midseason, what if his era overcorrects and ends up in the low 3s? It is very plausible imo
Oh sure, that would obviously help him. But there’s also the “Mike Minor contrast effect” that will hurt him. Right now, he has a teammate who has an ERA a full run lower than him. Voters are likely to look askance at that. I would guess he needs to cut that to at least half a run to have any chance of winning.
the problem is realistically right now he’s so far back. If any of Morton, Verlander, Minor, Cole have good 2nd halves, they will beat Lynn pretty close no matter what.
Most voters also aren’t going to care about Verlander’s WAR total. Among qualifiers, he is currently 2nd in the AL in IP, 3rd in ERA, 2nd in K’s, 10th fewest BB’s, has the lowest average and WHIP by far, and is tied for 3rd in wins.
I don’t think most voters are going to look askance at the BABIP and the home run totals and hold it against him. If Morton continues what he’s doing, he’s the favorite, but I would put my money on Verlander winning (even though he wouldn’t be the best pitcher in the AL).
Yeah WAR to most voters is completely irrelevant.
so looking at the Tango Cy Young tracker, which has been extremely accurate recently….
Lynn is only #8 in the AL right now. behind in order Morton, Verlander, Minor, Cole, Giolito, Barrios, and Montas. By the time he starts next, he could easily get passed by Bauer and Bieber.
He’s going to have to have a really great 2nd half to have any chance.
Kindly, it’s Ajeto, not Atejo!
Oops. Fixed. Thanks.
I think Doug Brocali should win coach of the year. What he has done with those castoffs is amazing.
If addition by subtraction counts, he should be have a plaque in Cooperstown
Which castoffs are you referring to?
Pence, Santana, Forsythe, Minor, Lynn, Chavez.
he’s the orioles pitching coach but go off
Julio Rangel is the Rangers new pitching coach