Matt Williams on a Dreadful Defensive Day
Matt Williams wasn’t a happy camper after yesterday’s loss at Fenway Park. It wasn’t so much the final score – Boston won 9-4 – it was the manner in which it transpired. The Nationals played defense like they were allergic to horsehide. A pair of sky-high fly balls were allowed to fall untouched. Ground balls resembled hot potatoes. Bag coverage was shoddy. Only one error was charged, but the ineptitude was undeniable.
The prohibitive favorites in the National League East have lost five of seven games, and while it’s way too early to panic, it’s never too soon for pointed questions. The Washington skipper received several of them after the defensive debacle. Here are a handful of his responses, which were delivered with exasperation and a hint of snippiness:
* “Balls that are up there for four, five seconds need to be caught. Ground balls (that) are hit need to be caught and thrown across the diamond. It’s got to get better.”
* “These are big league baseball players. They’re here because they can catch a baseball. Any time you go out there against a club like this and you don’t catch fly balls, and you don’t catch ground balls, they’re going to kick your fanny.”
* “A wake up call? We’re fully awake, man. Believe me. With all that’s been said about our club, we’re fully aware of it. We’re fully awake.”
* “Last year’s over, man. Last year’s way over. We have to catch the ball tomorrow.”
* “Nobody is playing tight. It’s a function of catching it, making pitches, and getting base hits. Nobody’s tight. Those expectations were there long before today.”
Chances are, this game, and the 2-5 start, will become forgotten footnotes in a pennant-winning season. But for now, Matt Williams’ team is playing poorly, and defense is one of the culprits.
David Laurila grew up in Michigan's Upper Peninsula and now writes about baseball from his home in Cambridge, Mass. He authored the Prospectus Q&A series at Baseball Prospectus from December 2006-May 2011 before being claimed off waivers by FanGraphs. He can be followed on Twitter @DavidLaurilaQA.
Needs moar GIFs.
Ian Desmond looked especially putrid yesterday, even for a SS as terrible as he’s always been. Also that game would have been way different if not for Mookie’s crazy day. Robbed Harper of a 2 run HR in the first, stole 2nd and 3rd on the same pitch then scored the first run, then hit a 3 run HR. Unbelievable day for him.
I won’t defend Desmond’s terrible play this season, but he’s been an excellent defensive SS for many years now.
Since 2012, he’s been the 7th best defensive SS, better than defensive whizzes such as Andrus, Rollins and Alcides Escobar.
You should really qualify that statement with “According to UZR”. If you look at DRS, he’s 14th (out of 19 qualifiers) with -9 DRS. Either way, he’s ahead of Rollins though.
I’ll leave this here:
http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/on-ian-desmonds-defense-walk-year/
The only thing that’s made Desmond look like an average SS is his decent range. But range is only good for so much if you’re below average with everything you do after getting to the ball.
And the Nats’ defense strikes again, with Desmond’s mediocrity leading the way!
What bothers me more than the defensive sloppiness (which can largely be explained away by the windy conditions in Boston) is really bad bullpen management. I wish Williams was as outspoken about that topic as he is about the testy weather conditions on Monday.
It was slightly windy, but being at the game it didn’t really make a difference and didn’t get gusty until the late innings. Harper had what felt like days to figure out that fly ball and the extra stolen base can’t be attributed to wind at all. If anything I’d say sunlight.
I don’t think the extra stolen base can be blamed entirely on the players — that’s a consequence of shifting, and it’s probably the coaches’ responsibility to prepare the players for that situation. If the pitcher sprints for third, they maaaaaybe can get him out, but if I’m Matt Williams, I’m much more mad about the booted grounders/dropped flies.
It is the pitcher’s responsibly to cover third in that situation, which Williams acknowledged in the post-game presser. Zimmerman said he feels he made the tag in time — replay doesn’t agree — but either way, he was late getting over.
But Williams is responsible for the really bad bullpen management. We saw it last year when he ended the team’s playoff run, and we’re seeing now that he did not learn any lessons.
The Nats had a former player that also has a degree in Mathematics as their manager. I haven’t seen much of Davey’s managerial style, but that seems like a good way to connect a team to the front office.
IMHO Davey Johnson had lost his fastball by the time he was managing the Nats. 2012 was good. 2013 looked like the entire team didn’t have focus, including Johnson.
Can we get rid of Matt Williams yet?
-a Nats fan