Reports: Tigers Close to Signing Justin Upton
All winter, it’s been pretty clear that the Tigers needed another outfielder, and with an apparently soft market for Yoenis Cespedes and Justin Upton, it seemed perfectly logical for the Tigers to jump in and make a play for one of the better remaining players on the market. After all, this is a win-now team that threw $110 million at a good-not-great starter at the start of the off-season, and has a core of quality players who aren’t getting any younger; leaving a gaping hole in the outfield for the sake of cost effectiveness, at this point, was a strange proposition.
Apparently the Tigers now agree, and look like they’re going to be the landing spot for Justin Upton.
Sources: Upton six-year deal with #Tigers expected to be in $125M range. Agreed upon in principal, per @BNightengale.
— Ken Rosenthal (@Ken_Rosenthal) January 19, 2016
The crowd projected Upton for 6/$120M before the off-season, while I came in at 7/$140M, so the price seems right in line with what was presumed to be reasonable before the market looked to have softened. Given that Chris Davis and Ian Kennedy — also presumed to be dealing with little leverage — also landed larger than expected contracts in recent days, it may be time to stop assuming that the remaining free agents are going to have to take big discounts to get a long-term deal at this point. There’s clearly still plenty of money hanging around.
For the Tigers, Upton is a significant upgrade, even though he’s also more of a good player than a great one. If he can retain some of his non-offensive value as he ages, this contract should turn out okay for Detroit. It’s not any kind of steal, but it’s a good player at a reasonable price for a team that needed win-now production and probably shouldn’t be too concerned with their long-term future. The inevitable crash is coming to Detroit in a few years, and at this point, the only question is if they can get a title out of this roster before it happens. Adding Justin Upton to the 2016 roster makes that more likely.
Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.


Mike Ilitch JDGAF
The opt out clause is a huge win for the Tigers. The value of an opt out seems to be a benefit to the team as well as the player in most cases in my opinion.
Nah. Not at all. Dave has covered that pretty thoroughly, actually.
http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/on-opt-outs-and-risk-mitigation/
http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/on-opt-outs-and-the-value-to-a-team-again/
Players opt out if they can get a new contract that is better than their existing one. Without that opt out, the Tigers could have traded Justin Upton for other players and not paid him another dime.
If Justin Upton is worth less than what his contract is paying him then he doesn’t opt out.
I guess I didn’t really think about it that way, but that’s a good point. I figured it acts as an incentive, but I’m not sure how much that would actually boost his performance, if at all.
After the Tigers signed Jordan Zimmerman, I wrote in a comment that Mike Illitch deserves so much respect for the cash he lays out – he really goes for it.
The next person responded to me, and wrote a comment dismissive of Illitch.
Again, I’ll say that I think Illitch deserves some major props – I can only dream that the Mets had an owner like this.
It’s not THAT admirable, he’s 86. If these contracts flop and cost his company money in 2020, as morbid as it is, he probably won’t be around to see it.
The success of the players’ performances are irrelevant; these contracts will or will not cost his company money either way. I highly doubt that the salaries are that high, though. The revenues from the baseball team are more than likely higher than its salaries.