The Cubs Need and Also Now Have Yu Darvish

(Photo: Mike LaChance)
At the beginning of the offseason, Travis Sawchik suggested in these pages that, at a moment in the game defined by the presence of Haves and Have Nots, that the Cubs would need to sign right-hander Yu Darvish in order to retain their standing among the former group. Much later in the offseason — just a couple weeks ago, in fact — Craig Edwards asserted that the Cubs still needed to sign him.
As of this afternoon, however, the Cubs no longer need Yu Darvish. Because they already have him, is why. Please allow Ken Rosenthal to explain.
BREAKING: Yu Darvish to #Cubs, six year-deal in $150M range, sources tell The Athletic. Pending physical.
— Ken Rosenthal (@Ken_Rosenthal) February 10, 2018
Clarification: Darvish six-year guarantee with #Cubs is $126M with ability to get to $150M, according to sources.
— Ken Rosenthal (@Ken_Rosenthal) February 10, 2018
Given the strength of their offense, the Cubs were never in danger of failing to compete at some level this season. Chicago’s field players recorded the fifth-best WAR collectively among the league’s 30 clubs last season. They’re currently forecast to improve upon that finish, situated second at the moment in FanGraphs’ depth-chart projections for 2018.
But the pitching staff has been a different story. Despite having assembled a strong homegrown core of hitters, the organization has failed to develop pitching of any real merit. The pillars of their world-championship rotation were all mercenaries of a sort. Jason Hammel, John Lackey, Jon Lester all arrived as veterans. And while Jake Arrieta and Kyle Hendricks both flourished only after arriving in Chicago, they still don’t really count as organizational successes — at least not the sort that are easily repeated.
Cubs pitchers finished just 12th by WAR last year — and that is a club that received roughly 340 innings combined from Arrieta and Lackey, both of whom left via free agency this winter. The midseason addition of Jose Quintana has compensated for those losses, of course. Nevertheless, depth has remained a pressing issue for the current iteration of the team. After all, the five-man rotation is a bit of a misnomer: clubs generally require some kind of contribution from eight starters over the course of a full season. The signing of Darvish allows them to substitute Darvish’s three wins for whatever replacement-level option (Eddie Butler? Luke Farrell?) was currently occupying that eighth-stater spot. It allows the Cubs to deploy Mike Montgomery in a swing role, for which he’s probably better suited.
Of course, in what has developed into the objectively slowest offseason ever, the terms of Darvish’s deal are also of some considerable interest. Back in November, erstwhile managing editor Dave Cameron designated Darvish as the top free agent of the winter, projecting him for a six-year, $168.0-million deal. The crowd was more reserved.
| Type | Years | AAV | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dave Cameron | 6 | $28.0 M | $168.0 M |
| Median Crowdsource | 5 | $25.0 M | $125.0 M |
| Avg Crowdsource | 5.4 | $24.0 M | $130.7 M |
On the one hand, one might observe the crowd’s projection and suppose that Darvish has just received a market-value deal in what appeared to be a hostile environment for free agents. On the other, it’s worth noting that the crowd has exhibited a tendency to misunderestimate deals received by top players. So, in reality, a correct prediction by the crowd for a pitcher of Darvish’s ability is actually historically incorrect. Maybe not $40 million incorrect, but Darvish has likely just signed for less than precedent would dictate.
Carson Cistulli has published a book of aphorisms called Spirited Ejaculations of a New Enthusiast.


Maybe I misinterpreted the reports, but I think I read somewhere that the Twins and/or the Brewers made an offer of about that total amount over 5 years. If so, then Darvish took a “discount” by spreading it over 6 to make a team a real title contender.
5/110. 16 million and a year short
Apparently he can earn up to $150M and also has an opt-out clause. These make the contract worth more than a “vanilla” $126M for 6 years. Still, it is quite likely other teams outbid the Cubs in some sense but he preferred to go there – (pure speculation warning) maybe for the best chance to erase any questions about his playoff pitching so he can use that opt-out to cash in when all the big spenders are open for business.
I didn’t know that, and yes, I agree that makes it a big difference.
After googling around, the opt-out sounds like it is after 2 years (but I haven’t seen any firm number on it). That would be another one of those “genius if it works” moves by the Cubs, because they would almost certainly prefer to pay Darvish through his age 31-32 seasons while avoiding 33-35/36.
I bet the Nats are glad Scherzer didn’t have an opt-out even though they will be paying him through age 36.
I bet Max Scherzer is enough of an outlier that we’re both right.
Scherzer will make 3/107+ his last 3 years $35.95m for years ’19-21
It’s $30M AAV before the gimics. If you count it that way the Nats got a 6.4 WAR pitcher for $15M in the first year.
The main feature for the Cubs is even if he opts out, he will not end up in Milwaukee this year or anywhere else in the NL Central ever if the Yankees, Dodgers, Rangers et al are bidding on him.
How does this myth still get perpetuated? The opt-out will not favor the Cubs. It just won’t. So, let’s say his opt-out has arrived:
-If the Cubs prefer Darvish to opt out, it’s because they don’t think he’s worth the remaining contract, in which case he won’t opt out.
-If the Cubs prefer Darvish not to opt out, it’s because they think he projects to do better than the remaining contract, in which case he will opt out.
Neither situation is preferable to the team. It’s a player option. Player options favor the players.
We don’t know what no-trade and opt out provisions may have been offered by those clubs, though. It sounds like yu got some valuable benefits on those items in this deal.
“So, in reality, a correct prediction by the crowd for a pitcher of Darvish’s ability is actually historically incorrect.”
Uh, what?
I’ll take a stab at this:
Given that the crowd is consistently very lowball when predicting contracts, the fact that they are correct in this case makes them wrong.
Or something.
“even a blind squirrel finds a nut”
What’s weird about that is I’ve seen multiple Fangraphs articles this winter mention how surprisingly accurate the crowd estimates for FA contracts have gotten over the years as evidence that analytics are making teams’ evaluations of players grow more similar than they ever have been before. Also what’s weird about that would be that insulting your readership is usually not a good business move for fledgling online publications.
“Insulting” – wrong
“Fledgling” – laughably wrong
The crowd is historically low. This time we were pretty accurate. Choices are either (a) the crowd is getting better at reading the market or (b) Darvish signed for less than a FA of his caliber probably should have expected to get.
I suppose there is a (c) which is that the additional incentives aren’t hard to earn, or that the reported opt-out has a monetary value to Darvish that we can only poorly estimate.
Is he working on a knuckleball in that picture?
And to think, Mike Leake got a 5 year, $16 million a year contract. Darvish is a big upgrade over that (at least a win a year, potentially more) and only makes a bit more? What a steal.
5/80 verus 6/126 plus incentives, an opt out, and a no trade clause strikes me as more than just “a bit more.” Will be interesting to see the final details of Darvish’ deal, though I agree it may very well be a bargain for the Cubs.
Leake’s deal also included a no-trade, but I agree that the other points are clearly meaningful differences in value that require looking at more than just headline numbers in comparing Darvish’s contract with Leake’s.
While Darvish is no doubt a better pitcher than Leake, it’s also worth noting that Leake got that contract when he was three years younger than Darvish is now.
25 percent more is significant IMO
The Leake deal was widely seen as an overpay at the time.
Not to sound snarky, but no one has taken a scalpel to Leake’s elbow. That does make a difference.
So where does a rotation of Yu, Hendriks, Quintana and Lester rank for a playoff rotation?
Around 5th? Guess it depends on whether Lester bounces back.
Curious what us fans think.
Ditka 150 – Astros 0
I think it’s one of the best in baseball. Don’t sleep on Chatwood, he’s a BABIP suppresser with a great defense behind him.
No definitive ace but 4 guys that I would call 1b or 2a talents plus Chatwood as a #5. I think it is great regular season rotation but lack of a shut down ace might hold it back in playoffs.
Gonna attempt to answer this–who would I want to face the least in a 5 or 7 game series? Thinking of each team’s top 3-4 starters and ignoring teams’ 6th or 7th starters or depth:
1 – Indians
2 – Nats
3 – Astros
4 – Cubs
5 – Dodgers
I’d agree with this, but Indians/Nats are equally terrifying for me, while the Astros/Cubs/Dodgers are equally (slightly less) terrifying.
I’d also give some consideration to the Red Sox (Sale/Price/Porcello), Yankees (Severino/Tanaka/Gray) and the Mets (Syndergaard/deGrom, but only in a 5 game series)
Just adding up Top 3 starters WAR gets us something like:
Cleveland (Kluber 5.2, Carrasco 4.2, Salazar 2.1)=11.5 over 466 innings
Nationals (Scherzer 5.1, Strasburg 4.5, Gonzalez 2.5)=12.1 over 591 innings
Dodgers (Kershaw 5.8, Hill 2.6, Wood 2.5)=10.9 over 457 innings
Astros (Verlander 3.9, Keuchel 3.9, Cole 2.8)=10.6 over 585 innings
Cubs (Darvish 3.6, Quintana 4.3, Lester 3.5)=10.4 over 576 innings
Red Sox (Sale 5.4, Price 3.4, Porcello 2.4)=11.2 over 554 innings
Mets (Syndergaard 5.5, deGrom 4.9, Lugo 1.7)=12.1 over 525 innnings
Yankees (Severino 4.3, Tanaka 3.2, Gray 2.9)=10.4 over 550 innings.
Stras has seems to get better as the season ages and has been amazing in the post season. He appears to “settle in” in the second half, career long he has dropped 0.5 BB/9, decreasing FIP and xFIP by 0.30.
Put another way, I’d rather face post-season Kershaw than post-season Strasburg by a long shot. I realize Dave doesn’t agree with this, but post-season Kershaw has a real long ball problem.
“Misunderestimate”? Is this actually an accepted word now?
Perhaps an attempt at humor?
never misoverestimate the quality of the attempt at humour
https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=misunderestimate
… many of our readers probably weren’t grown to an age to hear at the birth of the word. Get off my lawn.
Lol Theo has fooled himself once again. Has given out monster contracts to Heyward, Lester and now Darvish. Enjoy not signing Harper now, or being able to sign Bryant & Rizzo when they hit FA.
Yeah that Lester deal really stunk. Only got the Cubs 1 WS.
Pretty sure the Cubs have “Fuck you.” money. Guessing they’ll be just fine.
MLB teams have now spent $926m in guaranteed pay to FAs this offseason. Martinez, Hosmer & Arrieta are reportedly sitting on offers totaling ~$375m. If those three signed their best offer today, offseason spending would be up to $1.3b- with 86 FAs still unsigned.
Over the past 5 off-seasons, free agent total spend have averaged slightly under $1.8b, with the $2.4b spent in 2016 being the large outlier.
2013: $1.5b
2014: $1.8b
2015: $1.7b
2016: $2.4b
2017: $1.4b
Assuming Martinez, Hosmer & Arrieta accept offers similar to the highest ones they have now, 2018 total free agent spend will lag the recent average by about $500m.
About 75 FAs have signed so far this season, with average AAV a bit above $5m, average years a bit above 2, and consequently average ‘total spend’ around $12m.
So if 50 of the remaining 86 FAs sign in the next 6 weeks, and their average AAV is around $5m, average years are around 2, and average ‘total spend’ is around $10m, then the $500m gap will be closed as 2018 will have seen a typical recent FA spend- in the mix for the 2nd largest FA spend of all time, though not touching the 2016 peak.
What realistic signings might make up that $500m gap in total free agent spend? Moustakas, Cobb, Walker, Lynn, Holland, Dyson, Nunez, Lucroy, and Morrison are all ranked top 25 on Fangraphs 2018 FA rankings. Dave & the crowd projected these 9 FAs to earn $350m in total spend. Let’s say this group secures only 65% ($230m) that amount by opening day- averaging $10m AAV, 2.6 years, therefore 26m in total spend.
That would mean the rest of the 75 available FAs would need to earn ~$270 to close the gap, so the gap would close if 45 of those 75 sign for an average of $4 AAV, 1.5 years, $6m total spend.
With ~6 weeks left, that would work out to a bit under 10 signings per week, for a around $100m in total commitment each week. While this offseason has been historically slow/late, it will not prove to be historically cheap by any means, but will likely see the 2nd highest ever financial commitment to FAs.
‘After all, the five-man rotation is a bit of a misnomer: clubs generally require some kind of contribution from eight starters over the course of a full season.’
In 2016 the Cubs got the grand total of 46 innings out starters other than their top 5:
https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos=all&stats=sta&lg=all&qual=0&type=8&season=2016&month=0&season1=2016&ind=0&team=17&rost=0&age=0
And they represented the beginning of a dynasty.
Much was made about how historically lucky with injuries the 2016 Cubs rotation was. That Cubs rotation is an extreme outlier. The quotation you singled out is the rule that has been proven time and again.
I was being sarcastic. During the 2016 season I was one of the few people here who would point out that the Cubs were getting historically lucky with their starting rotation’s lack of injuries, going against the prevalent narrative here that on the contrary, they were simply one of the greatest teams in baseball history and luck had nothing to do with it, and I was roundly booed for it (the historical luck of the 2016 Cubs didn’t became the dominant discourse here until a few months into 2017, when the Dodgers became the latest great team in baseball history).
You’re also just a troll.
Or I notice things a long time before most other people here do and people like you don’t like it.
Is Darvish throwing a knuckleball in that picture
Man, 6 years for $126M with the ability to get up to $150 million.
Just imagine what he might have been offered if he had more than 10 wins in any of the last 4 years? Real crazy money might have been earned had he achieved more than 3.5 fWAR or 1.5 WPA since 2014.
I really am having a hard time understanding the hype about Darvish. Since 2015 he’s #53 among starting pitchers in WAR, behind people like Mike Leake, Kevin Gausman, and Michael Wacha. He’s barely ahead of Jason Hammel.
#analysis
Well he missed all of 2015 and part of 2016 because of Tommy John, so #53 is pretty impressive.
But that cherry picking happens to include 1 and a half years where he was out with injury. Yes, that happened, but why not use his whole career? Or just use last year.
Over his career, he’s averaged 3.8 WAR per season that he has pitched, even including the half year in 2016. Even if you include the 2015 where he didn’t pitch at all (which is fair), he’s averaging 3.2 WAR per season. And last year was 3.5, so it’s not like he has declined a ton.