JABO: The Transformation of Matt Carpenter
Over the last few years, Matt Carpenter developed into one of the game’s most underrated stars by exceeding at the skill set embodied by the likes of Mark Grace and Joe Mauer over the last few decades; be extremely selective at the plate, rarely strike out, hit a ton of line drives, and create value through elite levels of walks and doubles.
From his rookie season of 2012 through the end of last season, no one in baseball took a higher percentage of pitches than Carpenter, and he ranked 14th overall in contact rate when he did offer at a pitch in the strike zone. Carpenter’s unwillingness to chase pitches out of the zone, and his ability to rarely whiff on swings in the zone, allowed him to post nearly even walk and strikeout rates in an era when pitcher dominance has become the norm. While he wasn’t a big power guy — he hit just 25 home runs during those three seasons — he made up for it by posting one of the highest line drive rates in the game, which allowed him to rank in the top 10 in doubles, so he wasn’t just a slap-hitting singles machine like some other elite contact batters.
This year, though, Matt Carpenter is different.
Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.


Nice one. I am less a fan of the new Matt Carpenter than the old one. But it is likely an aesthetic judgment as you discuss at the end. The wRC+ is the same… It just feels/seems like he helped the team more by starting rallies with doubles and walks than by hitting homers. But man oh man if he found some sweet spot between the two approaches next season! Wow!
Oh yeah, the 2015 swing % image shows why he has been getting rung up on the down and away called strikes at such a crazy rate: he just refuses to swing at those pitches. He has swung at a much lower rate in that area than previously. Last I checked I think it was he and Goldy who were called out on those strikes most often…
Really nice article.
can’t wait to see multiple commentators tear down the narrative in approximately 37 minutes
48 minutes 9.10 seconds. Within one standard deviation of your estimate.
Anyone who is familiar enough with The Wire to understand your reference is probably the type of person to be unimpressed with your appropriation of his name for snarky comments on fangraphs.
Another mysterious 2nd half power surge. Wow, it’s almost like these guys are using the all-star break to refuel! If only it weren’t the worst kept secret inside the game.
You realize his initial power surge began in April and May. He mainly got out of sync due to adjustments babip luck and an irregular heart beat from working too hard. He had to hospitalized just for that. He’s kind of had to fight a slump and a loss of rhythm.
I think he’s also been hurt by the umpires. As you may know, Carpenter has been the victim of poor strike calls (and/or good catcher framing) than any player in baseball this year (and I believe for the past two years combined). He averages more than one ball-turned-into-strike-by-the-umpires per game, which must translate into… what?… 15 points of OBP?
Carpenter himself has said that his struggles this summer were primarily due to him having no sense of what the strike zone would be day to day. For supremely selective hitters like Carpenter (see also Votto’s blow-up the other night) you’d think this would wreak havoc on their approach.
“inside pitches are hit on the ground less frequently than middle and middle-away pitches as well”
This just isn’t true. For both lefties and righties the inside pitches are hit on the ground more frequently. The problem was that you were looking at an ambidextrous heat map instead of either of the handedness heat maps.
Oh CAMERON