Jay Jaffe FanGraphs Chat – 10/6/26

Good afternoon! Welcome to my first chat of October, and my first chat on our new platform — this should look pretty much the same for you on the other end of this but it's my first time in a new interface, so bear with me.

Yesterday I wrote about the Padres' Ty France, who almost played the hero in the Padres' first two games against the Brewers. https://blogs.fangraphs.com/ty-frances-near-heroics-havent-b…

Last night I watched the atrocity that was the Yankees' infield defense against the Rays. Shades of Game 5 of the 2024 World Series. yikes.

Was Schlittler's subpar performance partly due to his 117 pitch outing against Boston?

I think the big thing is that the Rays kept Schlittler in fastball counts, so he didn't utilize the secondary pitches that were so successful for him (esp. the curve) against Boston. DIdn't miss as many bats, and when the Rays put it in play, the Yankees failed to convert those into outs, which led to pitching with men on base, more fastballs… etc.

Who knows how that game might have gone if he'd gotten a couple strikeouts when he was in james?

In their last job posting, is "The Pirates Why" a typo, or an essay question to be answered as part of the application process?

I checked with David Appelman, that's actually not a typo, it's verbatim from their post. https://pirates.rec.pro.ukg.net/PIT1500PITA/JobBoard/1571bce…

it's "why do you want to work for the Pirates?" I guess

Yamamoto-Sale tonight feels like the first true playoff ace matchup since…Luzardo-Sale in the Wild Card Round. What are your feelings on the use of pitching so far in these playoffs, where most every game feels like a bullpen/high-leverage game?

We've seen a lot of short outings from frontline pitchers. I wasn't so surprised to see Blake Snell struggle given his recent groin issue and general penchant for being excruciating to watch, but Payton Tolle, Sonny Gray, Jacob Misiorowski, and Parker Messick all went less than 5 in their first starts. All of those guys are gonna receive Cy Young votes

I think a lot of it has to do with overloaded bullpens and off days and maybe some overfamiliarity with the pitchers, but having studied postseason usage patterns, starters tend to go a bit deeper as the rounds progress. A team in a best-of-three can't afford to let a guy work through too much but a team in a best-of-seven has competing priorities when it comes to starter/bullpen usage

How indicative of problems are the Sox's two blow out losses? I imagine there was at least one point during the season where they lost 2 with a similar margin, so maybe they are just two bad days?

It's just two bad days, honestly — and the emotions are heightened because it was the Yankees and because the two games followed the same pattern. You put Schllittler on that mound in Yankee Stadium with a permanent red-ass against the Red Sox and good luck to you. The Red Sox lineup was as healthy as it's been all year for a few minutes, but then Anthony got hurt, Chad Tracy got itchy with pulling his starters and pulled the wrong levers, and Aaron Boone was able to run circles around him.

Now, do the Red Sox need to beef up their offense? Absolutely, and the early exits are a pattern (the Sox haven't won a series in 5 years). Pete Abraham, who covers the team for the Boston Globe, called them a second-tier team in yesterday's column, and he makes some valid points about where they stand https://www.bostonglobe.com/2026/10/05/sports/red-sox-news-c…

Also, how unwatchable was Blake Snell for the Dodgers the other night? Good lord.

Old friend Jon Tayler nailed it in a Bluesky post:

Jon Tayler (Jon Tayler’s Version)
@jontayler.bsky.social
– Loaded the bases but only gave up one run? Check
– Equal parts unhittable and unwatchable? Check
– Fans of both teams came out of it upset? Check
– Inning felt like it took 45 minutes? Brother, you better believe that’s a check
2/3

I went into this postseason thinking that the Brewers and Rays, in that order, were the best teams, and the models were overrating LA and NY. Haven't really changed my mind. Your thoughts?

That's who i picked, and it was by far the most common pick in our staff poll at the outset of the postseason, with 9 out of 26 staffers picking that exact matchup, with no other one getting more than 3. So far, I don't see any reason to regret that choice. https://blogs.fangraphs.com/heres-whos-maybe-going-to-win-th…

Christian Yelich. Did this season effectively quash his HOF hopes, or did his string of mostly meh campaigns following his monster seasons in 2018 and 2019 already take care of that?

The latter. Through 2019 (his age-27 season), Yelich racked up 32 bWAR and looked like a guy who had a real shot at the Hall, but in 7 seasons since, he's added just 13.1 bWAR, with a high of 3.5 in 2023. Outside of those two big years, he has just one other season above 4.0 WAR (2016, 4.9). That's not gonna get it done, alas.

Which team that's down 2-0 would you most want to be right now?

Probably the Guardians, just because the White Sox, given their youth and shaky starting pitching, seem more surmountable than the Rays or Brewers — though jeez, the Padres came so close to winning both of their games.

If the Brewers and White Sox make the World Series, will anybody outside of the Midwest (and Florida) watch it?

The ratings won't be as good as Dodgers-Yankees or Dodgers-Blue Jays, but it's not like the White Sox are a small-market team, and I do think that the more people see of these Brewers, the more they'll catch onto them.

Not that I am complaining, but what is wrong with the Dodger's bats? They have felt average this year

I don't know that you were paying enough attention. Their 111 wRC+ was second in the majors behind the Cubs, and that's despite the injuries to Ohtani, Smith, Freeman (power outage), Pages, etc. They even hit for a 121 wRC+ in September while Ohtani was mostly down

They looked fine against the Braves in Game 1 but utterly helpless in Game 2, and have their work cut out against Chris Sale, but they remain a dangerous team.

Hmmmm. is something amiss in readerland? I haven't had a question submitted in 22 minutes… could one of you following this submit a q?

what's for lunch

Ha, that's a good question. Was going to order chicken banh mi but was also thinking I'd wait til after the chat and take a walk since it's so nice now.

Does Bo Bichette opt in?

I think so. He didn't have a very good season , (.260/.312/.390, 96 wRC+), with just two months of above-average productionn. I'm sure he could get a greater guarantee than $84 million but not at that AAV, not anywhere close.

please don't banh mi from the chat!

Well played!

if we get a brewers/dodgers nlcs rematch does it go differently or do the dodgers dominate again

If that happens — and I'm not gonna guarantee it, because by losing Game 2 the Dodgers have complicated things for themslves — I think it will go differently

Are chats now only open to subscribers?

No but IIRC you now have to be logged in (as in, have a user account even if it's free) to submit a question.

Is Mason Miller really tipping his pitches? Seems like it’s too obvious for the Padres to not notice.

yeah, I don't know. if somebody shows me a video breakdown I'd buy it (is there one? I missed it) but until then I think it's speculation.

Jay! Piggybacking on the Yelich question: why do you suppose Murphy waited until Yelich was probably on the bubble for being DFA’d to give him the “captain” honorific? Think it has anything to do with the fact that an org like the Brewers would at least consider DFAing him and he was trying to fend that off? I know, real conspiracy BS, but just curious what your thoughts are.

DFA'd? that seems a stretch given that he's owed another $58 million or so over the next two seasons and is just one year removed from a 29-homer, 3-win season. It would be unlike them to punt like that.

Do you think shohei pitches again

Absolutely, but not this season.

Chisholm's first inning woes were unimaginably bad but his defense has been sub-par, to be polite, all year. Do you see him being in demand this off-season or seeing a very weak market at what I expect to be his asking price?

Even with his bat taking a dip to ~average, he was a 3.5-WAR player this year, though his defensive metrics varied widely (6 FRV, -8 DRS) and he didn't exactly make a good case for himself last night. It's a lean market, he's youngish (heading into age-29) and he'll have suitors.

now, could the lockout and/or a qualifying offer significnatly impact his market? Absolutely.

also about the cba expiring in december are people overreacting about the lockout or could the season lose games or not happen, what is most likely?

I can't get onboard with the doom and gloom scenario of a full season lost. Evan Drelich reported that losing 60 games to a stoppage may be the real deadline due to the impact on TV rights deals. Hopes for expansion and Manfred's pressure to bolster his legacy are also factors, but with franchises selling for ridiculous values I think it's tougher for the owners to make the case to the public that baseball is a bad invetment for owners. I think we wind up somehwere around where we were last time, maybe losing a bit more in terms of games.
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7627090/2026/09/25/mlb-lock…

(sorry, that was a wordy answer to compose)

When do you think the time comes that the Yankees explore moving on from Boone? Do you think it's already here? Or is he once again prey to NY fans who just want to blame somebody?

IMO it feels like the Yankees have to miss the playoffs or Aaron Judge has to turn against Boone for that to happen. Ownership is quite complacent these days and sees Boone as a stable presence who gets the Yankees to the playoffs, but for Yankees fans, that's obviously not enough.

Assuming the Dodgers don’t win the World Series, do you think that will kill MLB’s “the fans want parity” BS or will they still try to power through with that narrative?

Oh MLB is absolutely going to bullshit its way through whatever actually happens.

Who get more MoY votes, Roberts or Weiss?

Weiss. Voters have stopped paying attention to Roberts, he's old news. He was 7th in 2024 and didn't receive votes last year. This is Weiss's first successful team in any real sense, and in his first year in a new job for a team that finished 76-86 last year.

Pitching almost always dominates in the post-season but this year is even more one-sided than usual. The overall batting average is well below .200 and not a single team has gotten 10 hits in a game in any Division series game yet. As more and more 6'6" Misiorowski, Tolle and Skenes types continue to enter the game do you fear that the balance between pitching and hitting will continue skew in the pitcher's favor to a point in which it is a detriment to baseball.

I think the observed trend will even out as the postseason continues, and I think that while the current velocity trends tend to tilt the balance towards pitching, the churn from injuries is such that it tends to temper things. I know not everybody loves the current version of baseball but I don't see a way things change immediately — efforts like the ones to ban the shift and to encourage stolen bases have had small effects but leveled off.

Read any good baseball books this season?
Or really any good books, period.

Two: Michael Clair's We Sacrifice Everything to Baseball, about the Czech World Baseball Classic teams, and Thomas Gilbert's Death in the Strike zone, about 19th century pioneer Jim Creighton.

Current reading: Moses and the Doctor, by Luke Epplin. About ABA stars Moses Malone and Julius Erving joining forces to break up the Celtics-Lakers dominance in the 1980s. Epplin's previous book about the 1948 Indians, Our Team, was great.

If you had to pick a remaining player in these playoffs who has the most to gain for his hall of fame case, who would it be?

Giancarlo Stanton, whose case is going to depend upon things beyond WAR — his postseason resume is strong, and if he has an impact given the current situation of his having taken 1 AB since April, that's going to add to the legend.

If we get a Brewers-White Sox or Brewers-Guardians WS, or alternatively a Dodgers threepeat, does that meaningfully impact CBA negotiations about a salary cap?

No, not really.

Hey Jay! Think the dodgers will/should start enrique over Tucker and Rojas over Muncy to maximize RHH looks against Sale?

Tucker was actually stronger against lefties this year and has basically level platoon splits over the past four (136 LHP, 133 RHP in terms of wRC+). Muncy was level this year too and has 2 HR in the post so far.

If Carlos Delgado was able to hang around a bit longer to get 27 more HR and hit the vaunted 500 mark does he suddenly go from one and done on the ballot to HoF worthy?

Probably, given his PED-free reputation.

Do the Mets’ youth brigade and cromulent finish bode well for 27 (assuming there is a 27) or is it a mirage Mets fans know too well?

I think there's definitely some reasons for optimisim given the young talent, but there's not a lot of dead money coming off the books so you may not get a lot of instant gratification.

What is first move you'd make to make Phillies more competitive?

Eat as much of Trea Turner's contract as humanly possible and get a good-fielding shortstop (probably via trade).

There are lefties and then there is Sale, who is an entirely different entity altogether,

Indeed, but it's the upper-end LHBs who generally are the ones who get thorugh against the aces.

Am I crazy or are the Yankees not dead yet? Rays have not hit lefties nor played well away from home this year.

The series will change in tone with the move to the Bronx. The Rays use the turf well, the Yankees looked like dogs who discovered snow for the first time and had meltdowns. But the Yankees have zero margin for error so I'm not high on their chances to win the series

I think Kiké Hernandez will play but over Edman, not Tucker

More plausible, yes.

If you're going to type Kiké please use the accent (i added it this time because I am all-powerful, apparently).

While on the question of managers, is Venable a lock in the AL or does Cash, who is making a case as one of the best of all-time, get another one.

IMO it's gonna be Venable, though Cash will certainly have his support.

If you’re Jed Hoyer what do you do for 2027? You have a core on the infield that’s older but still near their peak, and you need to either take advantage of that in 2027 or disband it and rebuild. You have one OF still under contract, and basically zero pitchers. Sure seems like whatever window they had open the last couple years is already closing.

Man, I don' t know. They absolutely need pitching more than anything else and well, the top guy on the market is Skubal. I suspect they make efforts to retain Suzuki and/or Happ.

do you think the yankees inability to perform in the postseason is any type of sustained trend, specifically related to Boone and the hitting coaches? 9 eliminations in a row (in 10 years) has to be some sort of record. Judge and Stanton (neither of whom are even on the roster) are the only leftovers from Boone's first team and yet the team looks lifeless and completely overmatched year after year in their eventual series of elimination. every single year from 2018-2026 their pre-series odds of the eventual round of elimination either had them as favorites or a virtual 50-50 yet they look completely uninspired and uncompetitive and overmatched literally every year. with the exception of the super tight 5 game set against tampa in 2020. i don't like scapegoating managers but it's literally the same thing every year. it feels like more than statistical noise at this point

the eliminations are a function of making the playoffs, which has gotten easier as the field has expanded. IMO the big issue is the organizational complacency with qualifying versus winning the division. They've won 3 division titles under Boone but mayde the playoffs 5 times as Wild Cards, and as was pointed out last night, Boone's teams haven't won a series when they didn't have home-field advantage. They've gone big for pitching, and have a tremendous rotation as well as the ability to produce pitching from within, but settling for the 3B platoon, and having a lower hit rate on position player prospects is an issue. They have needed to go the extra mile for an infield free agent for awhile, damn the cost.

Who do you have in the NL ROY race?

I think I'd go with Chase Burns. Very good seasons from Benge, Wetherholt, good from McLean, but Burns was a nose ahead of them — a star-level season.

[note: i goofed, see below]

As the resident historian, between PCA and Alonso/Mets drama, is 2026 The Season of Pete?

Sure, let's go with that, even with a 6.31 ERA from Pete Fairbanks

Assuming the Rays save Rasmussen for Game 5, the Yankees should independently be favored in Games 3 and 4, correct? What then are the odds this series goes 5? I feel like it's not as bad as everyone seems to think

Hey Nick! Fortunately we've got a guy who can answer that better than I can in Dan Szymborski. https://www.fangraphs.com/standings/playoff-odds/postseason-…

Though wait, this has Rodon for 3 and Fried for 4 and I think that's no longer the case. But basically the Yankees have about a 52% chance in both of those games. The problem is that when you win 52% of the time, you lose 48% of the time, and you can't lose again; right now the Yankees have a 14.8% chance of winning down 2-0.

Do the Phillies remove Mattingly's interim tag on the grounds that the players like him, and that that they're likely to fire him in a year (two at most) anyway once it's clear the current core's window has closed and it needs to be blown up. Like, if you think your window of contention is about to close, maybe just make Mattingly the caretaker until it officially closes, then go find a promising young guy who can manage a rebuild.

No, you go out and get a better manager than Don Freakin' Mattingly because you don't have a year or two to play with given this core. I think Dombrowski brings in Alex Cora

With regards to the Mariners, do you think this season was an outlier, or do you think the team has really regressed this badly?

I think there need to be major changes, and I'm not sure I keep Dipoto.

I think Burns may have exceeded his eligibility last year.

Gah, this is a case where we have him in our leadeboards as qualified based on innings (using the check box) but B-Ref has the days count and he's over. So… gah.

In that case, it's much more of a toss-up between the other guys I named. I might go with Benge just because there was a big divergence in Wetherholt's defensive numbers driving his placement (23 FRV, 13 DRS — still excellent but a 1-win difference).

Ok folks, that's it from me for today. Thanks so much for stopping by, and for filling the queue with good questions!





Brooklyn-based Jay Jaffe is a senior writer for FanGraphs, the author of The Cooperstown Casebook (Thomas Dunne Books, 2017) and the creator of the JAWS (Jaffe WAR Score) metric for Hall of Fame analysis. He founded the Futility Infielder website (2001), was a columnist for Baseball Prospectus (2005-2012) and a contributing writer for Sports Illustrated (2012-2018). He has been a recurring guest on MLB Network and a member of the BBWAA since 2011, and a Hall of Fame voter since 2021. Follow him on BlueSky @jayjaffe.bsky.social.

3 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Joe SavareseMember since 2024
1 month ago

ROY–NO STEWART?

JameyMember since 2020
1 month ago

Can we return the chats to being full page instead of in the little scrollable window?

I’m finding this new layout pretty annoying on my iPad.