Jeff Sullivan FanGraphs Chat – 8/20/12





Jeff made Lookout Landing a thing, but he does not still write there about the Mariners. He does write here, sometimes about the Mariners, but usually not.

30 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Well-Beered Englishman
14 years ago

My suggested Worst Possible Defensive Infield:
C Jesus Montero
1B Carlos Lee
2B Dan Uggla
SS Yuniesky Betancourt
3B Miguel Cabrera

although that’s using actual position players at their actual positions. Here is my real Worst Possible Defensive Infield:
C Jon Rauch
1B kinda doesn’t matter, but let’s say Edwin Encarnacion
2B Billy Butler
SS David Ortiz
3B Adam Dunn

This guy
14 years ago

I vote for Brett Wallace over Miggy, and Jim Thome over Edwin.

Nate
14 years ago

Nonsense. If you’re gonna go “out of position” players you need stuff like:

SS Bartolo Colon

etc.

This guy
14 years ago
Reply to  Nate

If you’re going to get creative, why stick with active players? I tend to think Jim Abbot would make a pretty terrible shortstop, and would probably run into trouble with the running game at catcher.

James Gentile
14 years ago
Reply to  Nate

hooo party foul!

Scott
14 years ago
Reply to  Nate

That reply from “This Guy” is vicious(ly hilarious!!!!)

TomG
14 years ago

Replace Montero with Miguel Olivo and I’d agree. Montero is bad but Olivo is special bad.

MangoLiger
14 years ago
Reply to  TomG

I cite Rob Johnson.

RA Rowe
14 years ago

You need more left handed throwers in the batshit crazy one.

PShwa
14 years ago

For some reason the thought of Jose Altuve playing 1B is hilarious in my head. Let’s go with that.

Well-Beered Englishman
14 years ago
Reply to  PShwa

I initially put Jose Altuve cuz he’s so bleeding short, but I thought some commenter would come along and point out that Jose Altuve is athletic.

This guy
14 years ago

The big difference between Carson’s initial Fangraphs articles and Jeff’s is that Jeff comes with hundreds of loyal, snarky, and bitter M’s-fan followers that will throw down if anybody starts to get too bitchy.

TKDC
14 years ago

Great, another blogger with a huge West Coast bias.

James
14 years ago
Reply to  Jeff Sullivan

If you know the most about the Ms then don’t be afraid to talk about the Ms. Nobody comes here for chatters who give boring answers to the popular questions. I’d rather see a well thought out Ms answer than you take a stab at something outside your wheelhouse. Of course over time you should gravitate away from single teams, but for now have at it.

Gary York
14 years ago

Someday the tidal waves of East Coast bias and West Coast bias are going to crash together in the middle of the country and destroy Nebraska.

PiratesHurdles
14 years ago
Reply to  Gary York

If Nebraska is destroyed and no one is around, does it make a sound?

TomG
14 years ago
Reply to  Gary York

Thankfully, due to the mass consumption of deep-fried mayonnaise balls, most Nebraskans will just float safely atop the crests of the crashing waves.

Grant Brisbee
14 years ago

I don’t think enough time was spent on the part about Grant Brisbee being great. Work that in more next time, but like you said, it’s all a learning lesson.

mlathrop3
14 years ago

You may like sea otters, but the regular otters of Eastern Washington are big and mean. What if an animal was only as tasty as it was cute?

AustinRHL
14 years ago

This was a fantastic chat, Jeff. I was honestly a little skeptical of the idea because your long-form writing is so good and I didn’t know how your unique skills would translate to this form. It looks like I had no reason to worry!

john
14 years ago

wow mariners and random stupid shit. worst chat of all time

Person
14 years ago
Reply to  john

wow random stupid shit. didn’t even include the mariners. worst comment of all time.

john
14 years ago
Reply to  Person

fuck u get off his dick

Person
14 years ago

By the way, looking at chatter names is not necessary. I was just curious. And you’re bound to eventually get questions like “Why is so & so getting his questions answered and NOT ME?” *POUT*

In which case it’s good to know. I think.

Aussie MarinerMember since 2016
14 years ago

I am sad that these are on at 2am my time.