Members-Only Game Thread: ALCS – Oct 19, 2026
Welcome to our Open Game Thread for the ALCS game today. Only Members can participate, and unlike our usual staff Q&A chats, your messages will be posted immediately.
Our Member community is made up of thousands of incredibly knowledgable baseball fans, and we think this is a great way to follow a game with like-minded baseball enthusiasts. We might even have some FanGraphs Staff drop in and join the fun. Please be courteous to your fellow Members, or you may find your chat privileges revoked.
Jefferson Leach edited
Over/under for how many innings from bibee? He hasn't pitched in a week, vogt must be mad
Sean Dolinar
I’m hearing under 1 and 2 from my FanGraphs coworkers.
lzfreak
I'm pulling for Cleveland tonight only because I love game 7s and them winning gives us a better chance at that
Nick Smith
Games 7 *are* fun!
Sean Dolinar
Good evening everyone!
Davy Andrews
Hello everyone. Steven Kwan is letting the beard grow and I am proud of him.
NicklePickers
Armstong pitching. Is Nominative Determinism the new Moneyball?
BryanB
Kwan. On. Fire.
Davy Andrews
So somebody on this broadcast seems to have read my article.
lzfreak
That article was excellent
Davy Andrews
Thank you!
Davy Andrews
If I'd had a little more time, I was going to do some fun graphics. You'd see a picture of José Ramírez or whoever with a big thumbs up, and then in huge letters at the bottom of the picture, it'd say "87.2 mph."
Asa
They really ought to give credit
Nick Smith
I think the mindset is that if it's on the internet, it's there to use.
BryanB
Is it just me or are there a lot of Guard fans there?
Nick Smith
👍⚾️👍
Matt Martell
Noted FanGraphs reader Ron Darling
Jon Becker
Hello from Raleigh, everyone!
Jon Becker
North Carolina, not Cal
BryanB
I like how the motion sickness medicine ad makes me slightly sick
Davy Andrews
Hey guys! What's in Raleigh, Jon?
Sean Dolinar
Open source coding conference
Brian547
Greetings everyone… lets give this maybe one last go… I promise to be nice to Vogt for at least… awe who am I kidding. Glad to be here, GO GUARDS!
lzfreak
At this rate Armstrong going 9
Nick Smith
At this rate, he'll have a Maddux.
Brian547
It is very Maddux that he caught that himself!
Nick Smith
The universe is telling us something.
BryanB
New Balance nerfing Ohtani
BryanB
Who makes those pitch coms? Yugo?
Brian547
Old joke… You go…because it doesn't.
asf123
“Huh??” said everyone under 40 😆.
Alan Sherman
coding chat returns!
asf123
Can Joey tillo, or can he not illo…or maybe both??
Ben
Hey I hope everyone is having a great night :) excited to watch some ALCS baseball
bosoxforlife
Can anybody help me? I am trying to come up with anyone who went from the outhouse to the penthouse as dramatically as Fastball Freddie did after his trade from the Mets.
Brian547
I can do the opposite with Casey Blake in CLE… (Bauer both ways?)
Asa
Who at MLB thought "Baseball is Something Else" would be a compelling slogan?
BryanB
Well the other option was “Baseball: we like strikes”
Davy Andrews
Alright everybody, best joke of the night has been achieved before we're out of the second inning.
Asa
Seriously, baseball is kinda cool would have been better
Asa
Baseball is baseball would have been better
BryanB
Maybe they had “Just…baseball” and then Sydney ruined it?
dalewilson13 edited
I would like Szym to calculate how much money Kyle Snyder has increased the estimate for Freddy’s next contract.
moomin
Bailey having a rough series with challenges
Brian547
After Hedgie was the single best in the preseason… the entire CLE team has been awful at it.
Asa
He's had trouble with ABS all season, which is a little surprising considering his framing skills
BryanB
I would like to institute a three challenge rule with my wife.
lzfreak
I wonder if Simpson practices making the ball bounce up high like that
Ben
Most players train to lift the ball… what if he intentionally tries to top it as much as possible
lzfreak
Post-ground launch angle
Ben
lol he's going for yards after contact
Nick Smith
I would love a player who made his living off the Baltimore chop.
BryanB
Let the Simpson worship begin!
Nick Smith
Could he BE any more safe?!?
Brian547
Check that glove for pine tar… I legit dont know if this is legal…
Jack Dorfman
Glad I logged on in time for the Friends reference
BryanB
Thank you Mesa.
Brian547
Words never spoken in CLE after 97…
Dan Szymborski
I wish there was a food called a Baltimore chip
BryanB
Now there is!
Dan Szymborski
chop
Jon Becker
Not sure I agree with Matt Festa as potentially the third reliever used in an elimination game
Asa
Yes it is very odd considering his reluctance to use him in close games in July
dloveteach
… and then the walk. Yi
asf123
Not fit to protect a six-run lead for an inning, but here…sure, why not?
Dan Szymborski
A Festavus for the rest of us
lzfreak
Does the Trop have the most foul territory now that the Coliseum isn't a thing?
Jon Becker
Also by “not sure” I mean “I do not agree.” Your report card will suffer, Vogt
Brian547
I'm doing my best here!
Asa
I like the pronounced turf splash when the ball plunks down in the outfield
BryanB
Yes bartender, I’ll have a Turf Splash with my Baltimore Chips
Hazmat Corntail
It the combo is called The Something Else
Asa
Well done, Sir
moomin
This may not be ideal for Cleveland
Asa
I think we're gonna need a bigger boat
lzfreak
Does this count as small ball? Multiple steals
Nick Smith
Or a bigger bullpen.
Brian547
I know Bibee was not great down the stretch but it is honestly hard to understand why he didnt start this game.
Asa
As a long (lifelong) suffering Cleveland fan, I'm ok with either of the other remaining teams winning this WS this year. The affinity I feel for lower budget teams is sorta like Larry David shouting "Prius!" at the other priuses on the road
Dan Szymborski
I need the Rays to win this game before Cascade Platinum Plus infests my brain permanently in another game
Davy Andrews
That commercial drives me crazy.
Davy Andrews
Imagine being a dishwasher repair guy and just going from house to house saying, "Yeah, nothing for me to repair. You owe me $300 for the visit, though."
Dan Szymborski
I keep hearing "double dong power" and giggle because I"m a child
BryanB
Channel your disappointment at Vogt, Herrin. Yes, yes, let the evil flow through you.
Davy Andrews
Also, we tried those pods. The plastic didn't dissolve all the way and they made my dishwasher leak all over the floor.
BryanB
That’s a feature. It’s called Expanded Water Radius.
Sean Dolinar
They work great in mine.
Asa
So yesterday Vogt empties the tank completely when losing 3-0 but today he goes to Festa.
Davy Andrews
I am so perplexed.
moomin
I am both bemused *AND* amused
BryanB
lol check the ball it him in the arm
Davy Andrews
BryanB, you're on fire tonight. Can you help me punch up articles?
BryanB
Happy to. I have advanced dad joke skills.
Asa
After Pat Murphy facial expression analysis and the thumbs up and down article I have no notes
Asa
I'm vexed. I'm terribly vexed. Nothing against Festa. Seems like a cool guy and all. Something about espresso during the wbc?
Dan Szymborski
YOu can always come back and win three straight in this best-of-9 series
Nick Smith
Found Dusty Baker's burner account.
dloveteach
Strategy: HBP takes fewer pitches than BB.
Brian547
Boy I sure am GLAD the CLE season comes down to a guy not good enough to protect a 6 RUN LEAD!!
Asa
He wouldn't even use Festa to protect a 6 run lead against the Reds in the dog days of summer.
pmaguran
Man, the sooner this bullpen game crap goes away the better. I don’t know what possesses a manager to think nine innings of tired pitchers who the other team is seen three or four times apiece makes any sense. Use your starters. If they don’t have it, pivot to a bullpen game,
BryanB
Can we add that to the negotiations? Verlanders rules.
Brian547
Just fire Vogt!
Hazmat Corntail
Has anyone done an article about bullpen games in the playoffs and if it ever works?
lzfreak
It definitely can work but it depends on your personnel. You eventually need pitchers you can trust in innings that matter so you need to consider that if you're managing
Hazmat Corntail
…especially in higher leverage games?
Brian547
The individual games where teams bullpen have been split 14-14… the team that bullpens more has won 12-11 in series.
Brian547
Since 2024 it is 10-4 for the most bullpeny team
Brian547
or so my very quick AI search tells me
Sean Dolinar
You probably need to look at counter factual pitchers instead of just looking at outcomes. Though, that doesn’t seem to be bad for the bullpen team. If I understand it right.
Asa edited
Is a counter factual pitcher… Fallacious?
Asa
That one skipped 3x off the lake
Asa
Sometimes it sounds like Franceour is talking to himself
BryanB
Wow huge
bosoxforlife
Finally a good challenge at the right time.
pmaguran
What a great challenge
jdbolick
Hicks has been pretty good with challenges in the playoffs.
Matt Martell
This is remarkable considering he was quite bad during the regular season, successful on just 49 of 87 challenges initiated as a catcher
drplantwrench
guardians ran out of steam and now are getting BABIP'd, its really over
Asa edited
There were some babip goings-on yesterday too.
drplantwrench
i missed yesterday (daughters birthday)
Brian547
My intuition is that the luck cannot be as bad as it seems when watching. But then something like that keeps happening and it really may be.
cowdisciple
Hoist'd on their own petard.
Asa
Excused absences are permitted
pmaguran edited
Guess what, Steven…Cantillo could have just started this game and giving you multiple innings. And then you wouldn’t have had a bunch of other pitchers pitching in unusual spots.
Brian547
Magic 8 ball said NO.
drplantwrench
chandler simpson might be my favorite non star in the playoffs
BryanB
Oh WOW
Nick Smith
Nice!
Dan Szymborski
CHANDLER
SadaharuWhoa
The essential Chandler move
Dan Szymborski
He was 3 the first season of ZiPS :-(
Nick Smith
Time is a predator.
lzfreak
What were his projections that year?
BryanB
Ground ball, CMON
Brian547
Ya I think we can just flat say that CLE got out coached in this entire series.
Asa
I generally like Vogt but I think he gets too cute at times. On the other hand I give him credit for getting this far with so little
Brian547
I think its a despite him thing.
bosoxforlife
Vogt is a very good manager. 25 teams would hire him in a New York minute if he became available.
Brian547
Good they can have him
Asa
I tend to agree with you. I just think there is only so much blood you can squeeze from a stone
Brian547
FESTA as the BULLPEN ACE!!!!
Asa
Ha — it's so weird that he wouldn't have trusted Festa in a meaningless game in midsummer but here he was today.
Dan Szymborski
potty training?
asf123
Already maxed on power.
Asa
I like Cantillo but Bibee would have been my choice to start today. Has decent history in playoffs if memory serves — at least before his relief appearance this year
bosoxforlife
The return of the bunt as an offensive weapon has added so much to the game this season
Nick Smith
I'm as much an analytics guy as anyone, but bunt hits are so much fun!
Asa
That inning could have had a very crooked number.
rustydude
Lineup churn he's though. #9 and then top of the order up next inning
bosoxforlife
If a manager can get a team this far with Jo Adell as your cleanup hitter you have to be good.
Brian547 edited
HE IS THE ONE HITTING ADELL CLEANUP!!!!!!!!!!!
Asa
I mean it speaks volumes that the lineup improved so much when the likes of Adell and Lowe joined.
Asa
Adell is all he has! Who's better? Manzardo?
Brian547
almost literally yes
lzfreak
I hope they don't go with "small market disrupters" as the narrative if it's Rays Brewers. These teams had the best record in their leagues this year! They're just good teams!
Asa
"Baseball is something else"
bosoxforlife
No one else to use!
lzfreak
Oh man I wanted to see them challenge Mesa again
Brian547
More horribly coached actions… DONT RUN INTO THE OUT!!!
Nick Smith
Slick as hell double play!
Brian547
Its not a double play if the runner stops
lzfreak
It might still be. Go to first for the force then get Lowe into a rundown. Lowe isn't fast enough to start, stop, start again and be obviously safe at second
Brian547
So what… make them work for the out instead of gifting it
bosoxforlife
I am afraid that wasting that 1st & 2nd with no outs was the Guardians last chance.
rustydude
If this score holds, every playoff series will have been won by the team with the better record.
rustydude
Which might be a good omen for the Brewers
lzfreak
They gotta stop walking Walls
jacob2
Tired: walking Walls
Wired: walling Walks
Davy Andrews
Man, walking Taylor Walls twice is really inexcusable.
Davy Andrews
What he said.
moomin
Taylor Walls legacy game at this rate
lzfreak
Some are calling him "The Petey Halpin of Game 6"
Asa
This is the problem with Cantillo
Brian547
WHY IN THE WORLD IS CANTILLO PITCHING TO DIAZ HERE!!!
Brian547 edited
oh good get Espino up now…why be prepared or anything?
Dan Szymborski
You want to keep your best relievers saved just in case you need to hold a deficit at six!
Dan Szymborski
I wish the lady in that commercial just did better brushing her teeth so that she didn't have to be ambushed
Dan Szymborski
The correct pitcher IS in there now at least
Brian547
The magic 8 ball is right once out of 10 times
Asa
I have a bad feeling about this
lzfreak
Caminero sure does hit it to the deepest part of the park a lot
lzfreak
I think he heard me
Dan Szymborski
I could take the Cascade commercial if after the guy says "Well now we know" if the dishwasher guy said "Knowing is half the battle!"
Phil
I have switched to Rays radio–was listening to Cleveland so far (my TV seems to have died). I love Tom Hamilton and his vowel(s), but it was getting depressing.
Brian547
Hot take… Hamilton is mostly just an old curmudgeon anymore… He was legit great once… that time ended about 5 years ago.
Brian547
same applies to Wilbon on PTI
Asa
I love Hamilton but he can get a little bit get off my lawn at times
Asa
Summer would not be summer without Ron Darling and Keith Hernandez opining on subjects like the true purpose of Area 51
Dan Szymborski
Honestly, I'd be very wary of a product that shows teeth whiteness change in one day
Dan Szymborski
Ron Darling's always fun because I imagine it's James Woods
Asa
Ooh good one
Phil
I appreciate someone who can be invested in his team without being a jerk about it. As a Sox fan, I am very done with Will Flemming, who is invested but struggles with the not being a jerk part.
bosoxforlife
I used to work in the garden and listen to Joe Castiglione. I just can't get into Will Flemming and seldom listen on the radio any more.
Phil
I had only Castiglione for 7 years–couldn't afford cable in grad school. His is the voice of baseball in my head.
Brian547
Its weird like that, I only had a few years of Herb Score… Im not THAT old… and he is the voice in my head.
Brian547
Given how this is going its time for Vogt to pull Espino for Bibee
Dan Szymborski
I used to get really mad about broadcasters when I was younger, but I kinda got over it. Because like Nickleback, they're not really FOR me.
David
Also like Nickelback, we're not sure who they are for
jacob2
I was raised on Hawk Harrelson so all the other broadcasters just seem weird to me
Dan Szymborski
And if you're hanging out here, and paying to read our site, you're not really the target audience for them either
Dan Szymborski
Broadcasters are there for some dude who watches 8 games a year and flips on it becuase it's the ALCS and he needs someone to explain why theres' a guy named Petey
lzfreak
I admittedly was also confused about Petey into this series
David
As I've aged, I've realized I'm not the target audience for much of anything besides Fangraphs
jacob2
I was the target audience for the skateboarding Ray
jacob2
Well, I’d like to see ol Freddy Peralta wriggle his way out of THIS jam!
*Peralta wriggles his way out of the jam easily *
Ah! Well. Nevertheless,
jordanm1031
Is BA saying DeLauter's name correct? I was under the assumption that it was De-La-uter
moomin
in the end, are we not all of the uter
Brian547
Chicago accent … DA law tr… is how I say it.
Davy Andrews
Dan, I cut a joke about those Knowing is half the battle PSAs from my article today.
Matt Martell
I'm both proud and ashamed to admit my first concert was Nickelback when I was in 7th grade. I don't really listen to Nickelback anymore, but I had fun and perhaps against my better judgment, l like that one album, "All The Right Reasons."
Matt Martell
But also if I never heard a Nickelback song again, I would be content
Davy Andrews
edited
Matt, buddy, they publish these transcripts.
Dan Szymborski
Davey, the Fensler Films GI Joe videos was the hit of 2004 nerdy online people
Davy Andrews
Oh my God, I'd completely forgotten about those.
Dan Szymborski
were
asf123
Peralta departs, having pitched more innings than any Cleveland pitcher has gotten outs.
Asa
Should you find yourself rowing home from Troy, take Nereus
Nick Smith
So, Nereus is apparently for counteracting the wrath of Posidon. Who knew?
Dan Szymborski
I feel like Tanner Bibee is on the roster as some sort of punishment, like he has there and sit watching and SEE how little they trust him to pitch
Asa
I had exactly the same thought
Sonny L
He knows what he did
Brian547
Just have to wait for the robot clone to be done like Festa…
Brian547
Why not pinch hit Genoa here?
Dan Szymborski
"SEE TANNER, LOOK WE'RE EVEN LETTING J-RAM PITCH BEFORE YOU"
lzfreak
Have we addressed that Tampa Bay has played multiple ALCS games wearing "Devil Rays" uniforms? What happened to dropping devil from the name? It's one thing for throwback jerseys but this seems like a concerted effort to reestablish devil in the name.
David
It's a luck thing – apparently liked their record in them
Asa
It's in the fine print of their Fasutian bargain
Dan Szymborski
They're pulling out all the theological stops for the ALCS
asf123
They went down to the crossroads, and he said “You can have viable starting pitchers…but I’m taking the naming rights back.”
jacob2
Society realized that gradients are cool
Davy Andrews
I wrote a song in 2020 about how you can't just sell your soul to the devil and then get it back by buying new uniforms. Looks like I was right.
Nick Smith
I started some weird pandemic hobbies too. I get it.
David
White Sox had the Pope, the Rays? Well…
Asa
Beat me to this. Quick on the draw
Sonny L
They saw how far the White Sox got and decided they wanted more
lzfreak
I like that they're just the Rays because I can imagine it's just a bunch of guys named Ray
jacob2
Like the Cleveland Naps
Asa
The original Ray is in New York
jacob2
or the Charlotte Bobcats
lzfreak
The Jays?
Brian547
RAY… when someone asks you if you are a DEVIL, you say YES!
Sonny L
🎶These are the Rays I know I know 🎶
Dan Szymborski
If the Rays get the WS and get Brewers to an elimination game, they should choose then to whip out the never-before-seen red-and-black Tampa Bay Devils unis full of death imagery
Dan Szymborski
"Nate Lowe, standing and smiling"
jabrwcky
Not watching TV all year and then watching commercials during the playoffs is an Interdimensional Cable fever dream and also makes me feel bad about humanity
Nick Smith
Ads represent us at our worst
lzfreak
The founding fathers really screwed up putting election season during the mlb postseason. I hate that I watch way more network tv when political ads are most frequent.
Brian547
Believe me its worse in Ohio
lzfreak
I live in Utah and I even get the Ohio and Texas ads! Like why guys
Dan Szymborski
but you'll have clean dishes and teeth
Dan Szymborski
and you'll know just what to ask your doctor about if you have motion sickness and want to go on a boat chase
David
I'm watching via HBO because I don't really have TV, and there are no ads! It's been lovely, and made me glad the Brewers swept because Fox definitely does have ads.
Brian547
This should be HBO's entire pitch to get more subs
Nick Smith edited
Forgot about HBO! I've been watching via Sling like a chump!
Asa
What is a self driving network
Brian547
I dont know but can it bring me my bag of Chipotle that is twice my volume?
Dan Szymborski
The graphic in the Crest commercials suggests that sparkly toothpaste goes right into your bloodstream
Davy Andrews
Is that not how it works? I might be doing it wrong.
jacob2
Only if you have gingivitis
Brian547
Good use of the RH PH there Vogt… you genius!
Davy Andrews
There's a buffet right behind the Rays bullpen. Do you think the relievers ever ask for a snack?
Jon Becker
They're not saying boo, they're saying BOOOOOOOOOOOS
jacob2
Cam Booser, reliever who throws it exactly where he wants it. What universe is this?
Jon Becker
(I think they're just cheering)
Phil
Booser has been so impressive. The Rays' Ashby.
Brian547 edited
New plan guys… lets get Baker's fingers greasy on fried food. We are going to need about 8 walks to win this as one will surely get caught stealing.
jtrichey
Who are the red-bearded Rays pitchers. They all look the same. Rasmussen, Baker, Booser, and I think at least one more. ?Kelly? It's kind of crazy
lzfreak
It's the new moneyball
asf123
Buck Showalter does *not* approve.
lzfreak
Cade Smith has spent a lot of time pitching from behind lately
Jon Becker
Extremely nitpicking complaint: Darling has been saying "bulks pitcher" instead of "bulk pitcher" all postseason and it's driving me up a wall
asf123
Yale does *not* approve.
moomin
they're the ones who give up RsBI
Jon Becker
That looked like a screwball
jacob2
bang!
rustydude
Wow, what a way to cap this series
Asa
Is exhausted Cade Smith > Tanner Bibee?
Brian547
Nope
jtrichey
Hmmm, has Cade Smith pitched enough now?
Benny The Jet
That feels like the one that does it
jacob2
Junior has just been camping on the high inside stuff all series
cashgod27
HE POINTED AT RANDY AND DID THE RANDY POSE!!!
Davy Andrews
I love that he pointed to Randy and hit the Randy pose. What a move.
moomin
loved that sound off the foul pole
Asa
I feel bad for Cade. He did every they asked this year and he just ran outta gas
jacob2
Junior with a little LiDom flavor on his way to 1B lol
Sonny L
Big Papi meandered so Caminero could amble
Sonny L
Pallacio with the thermawrap on in the dugout. Stars, they’re just like us
Dan Szymborski
Looking like the Guardians might need to Chase DeLaudanum
Phil
Could they bring Randy back? Would he come back for the $2.25 an hour plus tips that they'll offer him?
Brian547
Look I am happy for Jr. but I just wish he still played for CLE… im not sure about this Myers guy
rustydude
No income tax on the tips
Sonny L
330’ off the label is big time bat speed
Brian547
The robot version of Megan Fox is not an improvement.
Asa
Like tears in rain
rustydude
There's a non robot version of Megan Fox?
Dan Szymborski
I like how Scotch-Brite makes sure you know that they're America's number one scour pad since that's really important to viewers
Dan Szymborski
I DUNNO IF I CAN TRUST THE NUMBER TWO SCOURING PAD
Asa
You and I are not seeing the same ads
Dan Szymborski
Are the tru tv/tbs stream commercials very different than broadcast?
Brian547
apparently as we are both in Ohio? and I also did not get the scotchbrite add
Asa
Has the tree fallen in the forest?
Asa
I'm in California watching on tbs streaming
Brian547
thought Dan was
Dan Szymborski
Am I referencing things nobody knows WTF I'm talking about?
Dan Szymborski
I'm on the stream
David edited
The internet has ruined a shared culture! /s
Dan Szymborski
how long have been referencing commercials that only I am seeing?
Sonny L
Guardsball!
asf123 edited
If it’s any consolation, I share your skepticism of second-place scouring pads as a principle, even absent any context.
Dan Szymborski
October 19, 2026: Dan discovers that people are just listening to him and politely smiling and moving on
David
I mean, I genuinely have enjoyed it, and I'm not seeing ANY ads!
Davy Andrews
I haven't seen the scouring pad ads.
Asa
Neither have I. But I HAVE seen the bizarre Jay Leno car contest ads with the cello player. I doubt that plays outside of California but it is WEIRD
John Church
Listening to the game on MLB AtBat app, and what I’m getting is that the ads that no one likes are more entertaining than the game.
Asa
You getting the Byrna ads?
Brian547
Like it probably just feels this way but it really really feels like every margin play has gone for the rays
Phil
I'm not convinced of the necessity of scouring pads. I just buy sponges with the coarse part on the back, and I have survived so far.
Asa
My wife bought the non stick pots. I was skeptical but I will never go back
Phil
I got a big set of Le Creuset as a graduation present 22 years ago. Enamel still intact.
Brian547
Fielder positioning just slightly wrong, HR hits foul poll, Popup just stays in
jacob2
I'm getting ads for America's vices and AT&T
David
HBO Max coverage is presented without ads by PayDay, the candy bar, so I'm going with that was a reasonably cheap ad buy…
David
Peanuts, one might say
Davy Andrews
My goodness.
jtrichey
What about the lying Sherrod Brown ads?
lzfreak
I've been getting those all month
Sonny L
The Pepsi ad with the 90s song about a crys*l bender gets me every time.
Brian547
My current ad is telling me that my financial planner will definitely cheat at basketball
jacob2
Thrivent reminds me of Vivint, who bamboozled me into an expensive home security system that I had to promptly remove and refund once I came to my senses
jacob2
is walking the bases loaded bad
David
I did it lots in high school, and I'm still alive
Brian547
7 more to go
jacob2
my specialty was HBPing them loaded. More efficient
Sonny L
Patrick Bailey. Do it
Benny The Jet
Patrick Bailey could become the Aaron Boone of Marco Scutaros right here
cowdisciple
Homer Bailey, World Series Hero?!
Brian547
Do it for Buster!!
Sonny L
Ohhhh goodness Patty that’s two of em
Sonny L
Bailey will replay that 3-1 cookie in his mind for a long time
lzfreak
This could be the beginning of an epic collapse
moomin
suddenly looking great for my offhand prediction yesterday of 6-5
Brian547
6
jacob2
Ian Seymour… please
Asa
Very interesting
David
This is what happens when you don't look where you're throwing
Phil
This is the scenario I was dreading when they put in the 3-batter rule.
Nick Smith
They need to stop doing that.
Brian547
5
lzfreak
Should've seen less, not Seymour
cowdisciple
Nothing to see here. It's just the northern lights.
Matt Martell
That's textbook intentionally getting hit by Martínez. He turned away from the pitch while leaning into it. Well done
David
A Sam Antonacci special
bosoxforlife
Indeed, a beautiful example of taking one for the team.
Brian547
you guys bought fries for Kelly too, Right?
Phil
Who is this pinch runner? I swear I've never heard his name before.
Dan Szymborski
One offseason, I'd for MLB to tell umpires "Hey, you know that HBP rule that you've been ignoring 100% of the time about making an effort to avoid getting hit? Can we try enforcing that?"
Phil
Back in the day I feel like there were a couple of umpires who had the guts to call it. I haven't seen it in a long time.
jacob2
Rocchio one of the preeminent wielders of dark magic in my experience
David
Spoken like a true White Sox fan
Eddy
Dark as in he swings as if he’s in the dark? Crazy strike three swing
moomin
welp
MyBloodyBallantine
Counterpoint: why should a batter have to make an effort to avoid getting hit?
jtrichey
They should not have to avoid getting hit, just avoid intentionally sticking something in the way to get hit, IMO.
David
Just 5 walks short
bosoxforlife
Rocchio didn't have his magic wand with him this time.
asf123
Jeez. Maybe shorten up the swing just a *smidge* there, Rocchio?
Dan Szymborski
That was really damn scary for the Rays
Asa
That was probably the final scare
David
They will get top of the lineup leading off the 9th, too
Asa
Against Baker though. And he hasn't been Cade Smith'd (ie hasn't pitched in 9 consecutive games)
Dan Szymborski
Kelly could have thrown a beach ball and Rocchio would miss it there
Brian547
almost like you should save the PH for when it matters
Asa
He was swinging for the Keys
asf123
In fairness, it’s his job to do big damage as the no. 9 hitter.
jacob2
I think the turn away from the pitcher but not actually get further from the ball move is a-okay (morally and aesthetically, not with respect to the rules that I won't claim expertise on). Actually leaning into it is a no-no in my book
Davy Andrews
I was taught that move too, and I appreciate it. But if I were king, I'd still say it should count as leaning into it. Because it is.
cowdisciple
Rocchio has looked, uh, not great at the plate.
jacob2
I have been wondering, if a batter is HBP by a ball in the zone but the ump allows the HBP, if the pitching team can ABS challenge
Davy Andrews
That's a great question!
Dan Szymborski
A dog vet named Dr. Lobos? That sound suspicious
Asa
Tell me this was an ad
Dan Szymborski
They should be able to challenge anything. Ask ABS if ketchup should ever be on a hot dog
Brian547
Call confirmed. Yes
Dan Szymborski
I'm against ABS now
jacob2
was JRam subtly grooving to that music or was it just camera shake
asf123
Was just typing, “do you stick with Kelly to start the ninth given Baker’s velo loss?” Apparently the answer is no.
lzfreak
Oh they walked Walls again
jacob2 edited
clearly afraid of the mighty bat of Walls in this series
jacob2
Yandy!
Phil
Welp.
bosoxforlife
The final nail!!
Davy Andrews
That was mostly Walls.
cowdisciple edited
To be fair, if you walk Walls three times you deserve that.
Nick Smith
Gotta get to Diaz, right?
lzfreak
That one feels like the dagger
Dan Szymborski
Well, that's a quick way to get the runs back
Benny The Jet
TOD 10:55 PM
jacob2
if you talk big stuff you better do big stuff!
Dan Szymborski
OK, NOW bring out the chase de laudanum
jacob2
"he's not only a good hitter, he's also comically muscular"
lzfreak
I like to imagine that Yandy is pronounced "y and y"
asf123
Or “Why, Andy?”
comradeyurika
Depeche Mode misheard lyrics
jacob2
I say it exactly how John Travolta says "Sandy?!" in Grease the first time he sees Olivia Newton-John after their time apart
Brian547
Guys im not the oldest one in the chat anymore!!
Brian547
I need more walks :(
Dan Szymborski
Yandy! sounds like a birth control that has obnoxious commercials
Phil
Which only you can see.
MyBloodyBallantine
Too bad for CLE there wasn’t a 5 batter rule
Dan Szymborski
I love when they find a different camera angle that provides no useful information or visual
Sonny L
I’ll watch any angle of 112 to the back of the bleachers
Brian547 edited
Also… Im happy for Yandy I just wish he still played for CLE.. I am not sure about this BAUERS! guy…seriously this is a postseason of ex CLE players making CLE feel bad.
lzfreak
Lotta layers to this one
Antonio Bananas
How do they get topical bumper music ready so quickly?
jacob2
the AL Central sends its failed 1B to Milwaukee and weird things happen
asf123
Not at all sure Yandy should be jumping on guys for bear hugs. Seems like a great way to lose Martinez (?) for the WS with ruptured discs or something.
drplantwrench
*stares in kendrys morales*
Phil
In 2013 David Ortiz had this thing where he would pick up Koji Uehara and carry him around after every playoff save. I was terrified one or both of them was going to get hurt.
bosoxforlife
I loved that team!
BryanB
Man what a game
bosoxforlife
Since I'm 84, I doubt if you ever were.
Dan Szymborski
whew I'm a mere 48
lzfreak
The AL central has once again been mercifully dispatched
comradeyurika
We're getting a new champion
Benny The Jet
Now what do I do for the next 3 days?
BryanB
Right?
moomin
OOTP?
Dan Szymborski
Did he just make a Hurricane Milton joke?
Dan Szymborski
I get some extra time to write my NLCS Dave Roberts report card
Phil
That's the one I've been looking forward to.
Phil
Glad you're the one writing it!
Brian547
I expect carnage in the Vogt one!
war2d2
Welp. The one WS matchup possible where I dislike both teams. Baseball ends a little early for me this year.
Sonny L edited
Will the FG team flet us know if there’s a Jeff Sullivan sighting in the celebration?
Dan Szymborski
how can one dislike the brewers AND rays. That's pop on toast!
war2d2
I mean, look at my flair. It’s more about loyalties (though I have always unreasonably hated TB’s uniform situation).
BryanB
We’re in for quite a World Series I think
bosoxforlife
Looking forward to more exhilarating chat on Saturday night but lasting through this upcoming 4 day fast will be tough.
BryanB edited
I think we should spend the next four days inventing a new stat that perfectly predicts the score in each game. Aaaaand go!
Sonny L
World Series is chalk. Payroll be damned both #1 seeds won the pennant
Asa
Enjoy the rest of the postseason folks. It's been fun.
Phil edited
Amazing that the rays have won two pennants this decade while spending no money at all.
Dan Szymborski
I like the Rays green jerseys
BryanB
How does the Rays farm compare to the Brews?
Brian547
Beer>Skate
bosoxforlife
I think the Rays have oranges and the Brewers have barley and hops.
Phil
FG has the Rays #1 overall.
Nick Smith
WS should be fun. See you folks there!
Phil
Good night all!
I build things here.