Mike Newman Prospects Chat – 1/4/13





Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.

7 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Elijah
13 years ago

Who is the SP that has the best chance to be successful at the Major League level of the Mariners four prospects (not who is the highest rated):

Taijuan Walker
Danny Hultzen
James Paxton
Brandon Maurer

Pat G
13 years ago
Reply to  Elijah

Generally lists take into account both ceiling and floor, certainly someone may be more likely to be successful sooner than others, but the ranking will usually reflect the person most likely to be successful as well

melotticus
13 years ago
Reply to  Elijah

First to Seattle – Hultzen
Longest career – Walker
Most likely to be confused for Joe Mauer’s cousin – Maurer.

Bery
13 years ago
Reply to  Elijah

Hultzen has the highest floor out of any of the Mariners’ main pitching prospect, so I’d have to say he has the best probability of having success. Walker definitely has the best chance of being an ace-caliber pitcher.

Klements Sausage
13 years ago

Always enjoy reading your stuff, Mike, but you keep repeating the same mistake.
Oscar Taveras is an elite prospect in the Cardinals’ system. Tavares sang ‘Heaven Must Be Missing An Angel,’ circa 1976.

Tim
13 years ago

Thank you! I’ve noticed it for months but never commented on it.

Ethan
13 years ago

Why not just put JJ Hardy at 3rd? No change in batting value and your young ss gets where he needs to be.