More Than You Wanted to Know About Opening Day, 2021 Edition

Hope springs eternal on Opening Day, it is often said, and that may never be more true than in 2021. The COVID-19 pandemic that stopped the world in its tracks and has thus far killed more than half a million people in the U.S. alone (and nearly three million worldwide) has not yet ended, but vaccinations are becoming more widely available, and the promise of some semblance of normalcy is on the horizon. In marked contrast to last season, major league baseball is starting on schedule, and with a limited number of actual paying customers in ballparks — too many in Texas, and none for at least the first two months in Toronto, but with most teams and their respective municipalities taking a fairly conservative approach. All told, the situation is definitely better than when the 2020 season belatedly kicked off just over eight months ago.

Beyond that, MLB planned to offer MAXIMUM BASEBALL on Opening Day, with all 30 teams set to play their first games of the season on the same day, with no night-before staggered starts and no holding some teams back for the next day. Alas, this potentially historic occasion was pre-empted first by the weather in Boston, as the Red Sox announced on Thursday morning that they’ve postponed their contest until Friday at 2:10 pm ET, and, after the initial publication of this article, by a COVID-related postponement of the evening’s Mets-Nationals contest (and Friday’s as well), yet another reminder of the difficulty of carrying out the season in the middle of a pandemic.

While it was not uncommon for teams to launch their seasons in unison during the pre-expansion era, when there were just 16 teams — it happened 18 times from 1910-56, according to the good folks at Baseball-Reference — it has happened only once since the first wave of expansion in 1961-62. More recently, it almost happened in 2018; while a full slate of 15 games was scheduled for Opening Day, two of those contests were postponed due to rain.

The only time it actually happened during the expansion era was in 1968, and under less-than-ideal circumstances. In the wake of the April 4 assassination of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., all of American sports observed a three-day moratorium, though baseball, led by ineffectual commissioner Spike Eckert, left the decision of whether to go ahead with the Opening Day games scheduled on April 8 and 9 up to individual teams. Protests and unrest, and then an uprising by players, led by the Pirates’ Roberto Clemente (one of an major league-high 11 Black players on the team) and the Cardinals’ Bob Gibson, keyed the postponement of those games. Finally, on April 10, all 20 teams got underway.

With Opening Day comes the individual teams’ choices of starting pitchers, which generally carry a certain symbolic significance. Teams with championship hopes or at least postseason aspirations put forth bona fide aces while teams with lower ceilings offer up the best they’ve got. Injuries, expedience, and other considerations sometimes take precedence, thereby turning the slate of Opening Day starters into a snapshot in time that may not be entirely representative. In that light, Opening Day start totals themselves aren’t exactly a marker of greatness or worthiness for the Hall of Fame, but rather a byproduct of stature and longevity, with some dumb luck thrown in. Proponents of Jack Morris often cited his total of 14 Opening Day starts and his relative ranking as key points in his favor when talking up his case for Cooperstown. Morris is in a four-way tie for second in the modern era (1901 onward) alongside Steve Carlton, Randy Johnson, and Walter Johnson, and two starts behind leader Tom Seaver; he’s also the owner of the longest streak of consecutive Opening Day starts with 14 (1980-93). However, it should be obvious that his total doesn’t make him a better pitcher than, say, Sandy Koufax, who made only one Opening Day start.

If you’re wondering how that particular quirk happened, teammate and fellow Hall of Famer Don Drysdale, who developed into a frontline pitcher earlier than Koufax, made seven such starts, though just two during the 1962-66 window when his left-handed counterpart was the most dominant pitcher on the planet. Johnny Podres, the 1955 World Series hero, got the call in ’62 off an All-Star caliber season, breaking Drysdale’s four-year streak, and then Big D sandwiched the aforementioned two starts around Koufax’s lone Opening Day turn in ’64. Claude Osteen took the ball in 1966 because Koufax and Drysdale jointly held out for 32 days, until March 30, and didn’t make their respective first appearances of the year until April 13 and 15, the Dodgers’ second and fourth games of the season.

On the subject of Dodgers’ Opening Day starters, three-time Cy Young winner and freshly crowned World Series winner Clayton Kershaw is set to take the ball on Thursday for the first time since 2018, having missed the last two such assignments due to injuries. A mid-spring bout of shoulder soreness led to his being behind schedule as the big day arrived in 2019, and so Hyun Jin Ryu took the ball while Kershaw’s season debut was delayed until the Dodgers’ 18th game of that year. Last year, Kershaw was scratched on game day due to lower back stiffness, so rookie Dustin May was called up from the alternate training site. This time (knock on wood), the 33-year-old southpaw is ready to go.

This will be Kershaw’s ninth Opening Day start, which will move him into third place among active pitchers:

Active Leaders in Opening Day Starts
SOURCE: Baseball-Reference
Yellow = scheduled Opening Day starter for 2021

As for the active leader, Verlander, he’s actually inactive at this writing. His 12th Opening Day start, which took place last July 24, moved him into a three-way tie for eighth place in the modern era, but it proved to be his only start of the season, as he suffered a forearm strain and ultimately wound up needing Tommy John surgery, which will sideline him for all of this season. The number two pitcher on the list, Hernandez, recently opted out of his minor league deal with the Orioles amid a bout of right elbow soreness and a sadly unsurprising lack of giddyup on his fastball.

Here’s the full slate of starters:

2021 Opening Day Starting Pitchers
Visitor Starter OD GS Home Starter OD GS Time (ET)
Thursday
Blue Jays Hyun Jin Ryu 2 Yankees Gerrit Cole 2 1:05 PM
Cleveland Shane Bieber 1 Tigers Matthew Boyd 1 1:10 PM
Twins Kenta Maeda 0 Brewers Brandon Woodruff 1 2:10 PM
Pirates Chad Kuhl 0 Cubs Kyle Hendricks 1 2:20 PM
Braves Max Fried 0 Phillies Aaron Nola 3 3:05 PM
Diamondbacks Madison Bumgarner 6 Padres Yu Darvish 1 4:10 PM
Dodgers Clayton Kershaw 8 Rockies Germán Márquez 1 4:10 PM
Cardinals Jack Flaherty 1 Reds Luis Castillo 1 4:10 PM
Rays Tyler Glasnow 0 Marlins Sandy Alcantara 1 4:10 PM
Rangers Kyle Gibson 0 Royals Brad Keller 1 4:10 PM
Mets Jacob deGrom 2 Nationals Max Scherzer 5 7:09 PM
White Sox Lucas Giolito 1 Angels Dylan Bundy 1 10:05 PM
Astros Zack Greinke 4 Athletics Chris Bassitt 0 10:07 PM
Giants Kevin Gausman 1 Mariners Marco Gonzales 2 10:10 PM
Friday
Orioles John Means 0 Red Sox Nathan Eovaldi 1 2:10 PM

Kershaw doesn’t lack for former teammates getting Opening Day assignments; no fewer than five ex-Dodgers will take the ball on Thursday, namely Darvish, Eovaldi, Greinke, Maeda, and Ryu. Darvish is the only pitcher in the entire group who’s making his debut with a new team, one expected to be the third-best in baseball according to our Playoff Odds. No pressure, dude.

Seven of the above hurlers will be making their first Opening Day starts, which pales in comparison to last year’s total of 18, a swell that owed something to spring or summer injuries and opt outs. In addition to May starting for Kershaw, Tommy Milone filled in for Means, who was scratched three days before last year’s assignment due to arm fatigue, and Eovaldi was given the honor in the absences of Chris Sale (Tommy John surgery) and Eduardo Rodriguez (post-COVID myocarditis). Eovaldi’s -0.3 WAR in 2019 brought up the rear among the 2020 starters, while this year’s low man is Bumgarner, who was torched for a 6.48 ERA and 7.18 FIP en route to -0.5 WAR in his first season in Arizona but who still has a long enough track record (and a high enough salary) to get another shot.

The top matchup in terms of the overall quality of the two teams, at least according to our Playoff Odds, belongs to the Blue Jays versus Yankees. The pair are forecast for 87.0 and 95.4 wins, respectively, and this is the only pairing where both teams have odds above 50% (91.3% for the Yankees, 50.7% for the Blue Jays). While Ryu and Cole are both Cy Young contenders, the top matchup in terms of the overall quality of the two starters — and the one scheduled for prime time on the East Coast via ESPN — was the Mets-Nationals one, where deGrom, a two-time Cy Young winner, was set to square off against Scherzer, a three-timer. Unfortunately, Wednesday’s report of an as-yet-unidentified Nationals player testing positive for COVID-19 and forcing four other players and one staff member into quarantine already threatened to overshadow that game, and on Thursday morning the game was officially postponed while the Nationals continue to conduct contact tracing. Assuming the Nationals do get to play soon, and that Scherzer isn’t among the ailing or quarantined players, he and Nola will take over the active lead in consecutive Opening Day starts with four, as Verlander’s string of five straight comes to an end.

Two other Cy Young winners besides Kershaw will be in action on Thursday, namely Bieber, the reigning AL winner, and Greinke. As for the reigning NL winner, Trevor Bauer, he’ll have to wait to make his Dodgers debut on Friday. Oh, and if you’re wondering about Cy Young himself in light of those all-time totals, he made 14 Opening Day starts, only six of which are captured by Baseball-Reference’s Stathead (f/k/a the Play Index); the other eight occurred in the 1891-1900 span. In my spot perusal of the 19th century’s workhorses, the highest total of Opening Day starts by a starter besides Young is Bobby Mathews with eight.

Back to the present day, the elephant in the room in this pandemic-adjacent season opener is ballpark capacity. The Athletic’s Evan Drellich gathered data on all 30 parks for a tracker published last week. According to that data, 26 of the 30 ballparks will open the season at 33% capacity or lower, with 16 of those at either 20% or 25%. The Red Sox and Nationals have the two lowest in terms of percentages, at 12% for the former (about 4,500 fans) and 12.1% for the latter (5,000 fans). In terms of head counts, the Blue Jays, who will spend at least the first two months of their season at TD Ballpark, their spring home in Dunedin, Florida, will have roughly 1,275 fans, which is 15% of capacity.

At the other end of the spectrum, the four teams exceeding 33% capacity are the Rays (36%, and in an indoor stadium to boot), Rockies (42.6%), Astros (50%, with the roof open or closed based on the weather) and Rangers. The last of those will open the season at a cringe-inducing 100% capacity, which they’ve rationalized by promising to offer “socially distanced” sections for subsequent games, when safety concerns will somehow come back into vogue. Yeesh.

That potentially hazardous situation, the ongoing plight of the Blue Jays (who of course spent last season in Buffalo, New York), and the Nationals-Mets postponement are just a few reminders that as the season begins, we’re still far from business as usual in baseball. Still, with fans and even players lining up to get shots — hat-tip to the Cardinals, who apparently will become the first team to reach 85% vaccination compliance, which will allow them to ease some restrictions — we’re in a much better place than a year or eight months ago. Play ball!





Brooklyn-based Jay Jaffe is a senior writer for FanGraphs, the author of The Cooperstown Casebook (Thomas Dunne Books, 2017) and the creator of the JAWS (Jaffe WAR Score) metric for Hall of Fame analysis. He founded the Futility Infielder website (2001), was a columnist for Baseball Prospectus (2005-2012) and a contributing writer for Sports Illustrated (2012-2018). He has been a recurring guest on MLB Network and a member of the BBWAA since 2011, and a Hall of Fame voter since 2021. Follow him on BlueSky @jayjaffe.bsky.social.

27 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
yabu00
5 years ago

Shouldn’t you use a t distribution for this? Excellent article though.

bluerum29
5 years ago

What is highly unfortunate is that even when they get vaccinated the players/staff are still required to get tested twice a week….

Left of Centerfield
5 years ago
Reply to  bluerum29

None of the vaccines are 100% effective and they are likely less effective against some of the newer strains. So I really don’t see the problem with testing vaccinated players.

bluerum29
5 years ago

How long you want to keep testing people? How long you want to continue protocols that prevent us from getting back to normal? Last summer the goal was to get a vaccine so we could get things back to normal. We have multiple vaccines.

Brian ReinhartMember since 2016
5 years ago
Reply to  bluerum29

Safety protocols make the return to normal happen faster, not slower.

I actually almost agree with you – the evidence is growing more and more positive that vaccinations almost totally prevent infection, period, not just serious illness. Last I saw it was like 0.4 people per 1,000 vaccinated who are infected in studies.

But where we disagree is: what’s wrong with the occasional test of players? It’s not like a test takes hours or causes side effects or cancels games. It’s a literally risk-free way of making sure that the tiny possibility of infection doesn’t happen.

bluerum29
5 years ago
Reply to  Brian Reinhart

It is just another inconvenience. If you are vaccinated, no reason not to just go on with your everyday regular life routines.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  bluerum29

Imagine that you had a bulletproof vest that worked 93% of the time, and you lived in a neighborhood where someone shot a gun outside at you every day. If you are careful about when you go out, he will only hit you occasionally, and when he does hit you the bulletproof vest will usually stop it. But what you are proposing is to ignore him entirely.

I realize this isn’t a perfect analogy since if your neighbor had the bulletproof vest they wouldn’t be firing the gun, and in real life that doesn’t make any sense. Also, in this analogy, it penetrating your bulletproof vest will also make you fire guns at your neighbors as well (who hopefully are smart enough to own their own bulletproof vests), which also doesn’t make sense. Also, it’s probably more likely that your bulletproof vest has a 7% chance of not working at all (so it’s a binary 0-1 outcome). But this should give you a sense of why precautions are a good thing even if you are mostly protected.

bluerum29
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

That analogy doesn’t work at all because even those who are exposed to the virus don’t always get sick and of those that do, a very tiny percentage actually die from it. Add to the fact that one gets a vaccine it would reduce your chances that much more. The risk of death for healthy people is beyond miniscule. With the vaccine, good to go, no reason to worry at all. There will always be some risk to our lives out there in the real world, but can’t go about worried about them everyday. you take precautions yes, but many people take those to the extreme even when not talking about the virus.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  bluerum29

Okay, fine. Change it to a “less-lethal” bullet. Are you really excited to go outside knowing someone is shooting most-likely-not-lethal bullets at you?

I suppose you might get used to it after a while, but what I don’t understand here is that you’re extrapolating from your own personal tolerance of risk to entire policies, which change the actual level of individual risk. If people get tested and they have the vaccine then yes, you can more or less go about your everyday life. Otherwise the level of risk is quite a bit higher.

bluerum29
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I haven’t been tested once, don’t have the vaccine yet (probably will this summer when I have more time to do it). Everyday life has been basically normal. If I were in a more health at risk group I would be more concerned, but I’m not, so I’m not.

Smiling PolitelyMember since 2018
5 years ago
Reply to  bluerum29

Maybe there’s something worth caring about more than yourself, your own health, and your own convenience: People who can’t get vaccinated due to autoimmune disorders, People who haven’t been able to get a vaccine, and People who get the vaccine but for whom protection doesn’t work against various strains for whatever reason. People who look forward to stadiums without masked people. What if you tried caring about more than your own inconvenience?

You don’t follow safety protocols for yourself–you do it for your community so that you can all be healthy. As America stands upon the precipice of a potential 3rd wave or upper hand, it’ll be up to each of us to value something beyond annoyance to succeed. Maybe just sublimate your ego for a few minutes, put on a mask, get tested (even once! over the course of a year!), and care about someone or something else more than yourself. Might change your world for the better.

bluerum29
5 years ago

For those at higher risk, them and their family should take extra precautions, just like with anything else they do. Wearing a mask and getting tested are not needed for me as well. I work in a school that has only had a mask requirement for 6 weeks out of this school year. There are only a couple places that I have been to in the past 3 months that require a mask, other than that, I don’t even carry one with me at this point. Health matters, but so does living a happy and fulfilling life.

Lanidrac
5 years ago
Reply to  bluerum29

The issue isn’t just about you. It’s about passing the virus to others. Even if you personally are asymptomatic, a positive test means you can then be quarantined to help prevent the spread to other more high risk individuals. While most people don’t need to be tested that much, continuing to wear a mask in public is very important in this regard. For people being paid to perform in public, preventing the spread is especially important and as such need to be regularly tested.

bluerum29
5 years ago
Reply to  Lanidrac

We don’t quarantine for other sicknesses we get. If I were sick I would stay home until I was better then go back to work. Wouldn’t need the test to tell me I’m sick. As for the masks, wore it for a while when numbers were much higher, but not because I was concerned with getting sick. At this point, only if a business insists and I really need to go in there. I’m just glad they were never required to be worn while working out at our local rec. center.

Lanidrac
5 years ago
Reply to  bluerum29

That’s because the only other active sicknesses in the U.S. that are anywhere near as deadly all have vaccines of their own or otherwise don’t cause widespread outbreaks. Even if someone doesn’t get vaccinated as a child and does catch something like the measles or worse, they’re highly unlikely to pass it on to someone else. Back before the vaccines, anyone who did catch those diseases was indeed quarantined, and even then they didn’t spread as easily as COVID does save for other epidemics that definitely used quarantines like the one with influenza a century ago,.

As for telling when you’re sick, you’re a fool to solely rely on that. Many people with COVID never show any symptoms but can still easily pass it on, and even those who do get sick go through an incubation period as carriers before the symptoms appear.

bluerum29
5 years ago
Reply to  Lanidrac

People live and people die, it is a reality of this world. Some die when they are not expected to and it sucks, it is not fair. But the truth is that life is not fair. We just have to go on living and making the best of it, those who are still here need to live the best they can for those who didn’t get to keep doing so.

sbf21
5 years ago
Reply to  bluerum29

This self-obsessed and selfish attitude is why we have 550,000 dead and going much higher. Its disgusting.

sbf21
5 years ago
Reply to  bluerum29

Probably nothing has pissed me off more during this pandemic than idiots who talk about being infected with the Coronavirus as a binary outcome – either you die or you’re fine. That’s far from reality.

It ignores the survivors who experience symptoms every day that diminish their capacity to live normal lives – the long-haulers who have neurological impairments and unending physical ailments that cause pain and disability. Then there are the huge number of people who were either barely ill or non-symptomatic who, nonetheless, have damage to their hearts, lungs or other organs that is likely to cause long-term and possibly chronic health problems as they age.

Left of Centerfield
5 years ago
Reply to  Brian Reinhart

CDC recently said 90% effectiveness in the real worlds for the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines. Of course, that’s against the original virus, not the new strains. There’s also the possibility that vaccinated people can still spread the virus. That issue hasn’t been fully studied yet. And we also have no idea how long protection lasts for.

DeadheadbrewerMember since 2016
5 years ago

Happy Opening Day, everyone! Play ball!

Anon21Member since 2018
5 years ago

I’m inclined to be suspicious of the Rangers’ 100% capacity plan too, but…how dangerous is it, really? Outdoor transmission is much, much rarer than indoor transmission. I think there’s a single documented case of the “two people passing outdoors” in the entire world, despite the fact that that scenario takes up a lot of real estate in people’s brains. Outdoor transmission from prolonged, maskeless, face-to-face contact is better attested (although again, it’s clear that simply being outdoors is a strongly protective factor for even a high risk activity like face-to-face conversation), but spectating at a baseball game seems to be somewhere in between–you’re sitting near the same people for hours on end, but presumably lots of people will wear masks, and unlike a face-to-face conversation, air and spit probably aren’t being directed at your face from a distance of a foot or less.

Remember in this regard that people feared a surge in cases from the outdoor, masked protests last summer, but it never materialized, in spite of all the chanting and talking.

Brian ReinhartMember since 2016
5 years ago
Reply to  Anon21

I think the concern here is that people are sitting in the same seats next to strangers for 3+ hours. Personally, as a person in Dallas who could attend, my beef with the Rangers’ rules is that filling every seat means masks are a necessity, and a baseball game is a long time to wear one. If there are 5-6 empty seats between me and the nearest stranger at an outdoor park, I can take it off some. Not if we have our elbows on the same armrest.

bluerum29
5 years ago
Reply to  Brian Reinhart

I’ll go to a game when it can feel like it did in 2019. I want to enjoy it with my only 2 concerns being how much money I spend and does the team I’m rooting for win.

free-range turducken
5 years ago
Reply to  Brian Reinhart

And if people are allowed to take their masks off to eat and drink, they might take their sweet time doing so because wearing masks for a long time can get very annoying. Plus, I don’t know how spring allergies are in Texas, but nothing like a good strong sneeze to spread stuff around to your next-seat neighbor.

bluerum29
5 years ago

If they are allowed to take them off to eat and drink? Where do you go that you keep a mask on to eat and drink. We don’t even wear them into the restaurant any more let alone wear them while eating.

Brian ReinhartMember since 2016
5 years ago

To answer your spring allergy question, Dallas is to allergies what Vegas is to bad decisions. I’ve been punched in the face by it every day since literally New Year’s. Especially this year staying isolated and never getting any real diseases or colds, it’s been eye opening to realize that probably 3 of every 4 days I’m sick from allergies.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Anon21

If everyone is masked, it might actually work. The protests really gave us a sense that outdoor activities while everyone is masked is really quite safe. Even with people yelling.

But if we start taking away masks (and it will be hard to enforce), I’m not sure the premise holds. 100% capacity for unmasked people yelling, even outdoors, might be fine but it’s probably not a good idea! Especially since the new strains are more contagious. Like, it might be okay, and you probably wouldn’t have one person infecting a hundred people like if it was indoors.

Just to add insult to injury, it’s not even a good natural experiment since everything else in Texas is open now too. You kind of hope that if policy makers do something risky at least you’ll learn something from this but this is not one of those cases.