As the reader will already know, my colleagues here at FanGraphs have gone to great lengths to provide learned previews for each of the postseason games thus far. Certainly, the writing and the analysis, it’s quite good — nor would I dare change it.
Having said that, though, I will level criticism on one ground — namely, for their (i.e. my colleagues’) inability to predict the future, or even to offer a prediction of same.
For example, consider Dave Cameron’s preview of tonight’s Cincinnati-Philadelphia game. Looking at the contest from the Reds’ point of view, Cameron offers some notes on Roy Oswalt‘s excellence, Bronson Arroyo’s relative inferiority, and how Dusty Baker might be best suited to leverage his bullpen against the Phillies.
That’s fine — all of it — but one thing is conspicuous by its absence from Cameron’s preview: the exact score of the game and the specific events leading to said score.
With all due respect to Cameron, I’m forced to ask: Is this still 2009, or something? If FanGraphs is going to lead the way in baseballing analysis, Dave, we’re gonna have to go the extra mile.
It’s with those shortcomings in mind that I offer to the reader this “Preemptive Review” of Game Two of the Cincy-Philly Divisional Series — in which the author (I, Carson One-Million-Dollars Cistulli) provide a review of a game that has as yet to occur.
You can find an image of the game’s exact box score below and a can see both the box score and play-by-play by clicking here. In the meantime, however, here are some things that will definitely, no-questions-asked occur tonight:
1. Roy Oswalt will strike out 15 batters, en route to a 5-2 victory.
It’s a true fact!
2. Chase Utley will hit two homers, one of the inside-the-park variety.
It’s been pre-ordained!
3. Aaron Harang will pitch 0.1 IP in relief.
Doubt it at your own risk!
4. Laynce Nix will twice be “frozen” on a strike three.
It’s getting cold in here!
Note: The box score and play-by-by play are definitely NOT courtesy of What If Sports. How you even got that idea is super preposterous.
Carson Cistulli has published a book of aphorisms called Spirited Ejaculations of a New Enthusiast.