FanGraphs Baseball

A Quick Defense of Matt Williams

On Saturday night, Matt Williams removed Jordan Zimmermann with one out to go, trying to preserve a 1-0 lead. Drew Storen entered immediately gave up a single to Buster Posey and a double Pablo Sandoval, tying the game at 1-1; the Giants would go on and win in 18. Williams was heavily criticized in the aftermath of the game for taking a pitcher out who was, at that, throwing a shutout, especially given that he had only thrown 100 pitches on the night.

But let’s just look at the numbers here for a second. We’ll look at career and 2014 batting against both pitchers.

Career BA OBP SLG
Zimmermann 0.249 0.292 0.383
Storen 0.224 0.289 0.330
2014 BA OBP SLG
Zimmermann 0.244 0.277 0.354
Storen 0.210 0.262 0.278

On a per-batter faced, Drew Storen has been a more effective pitcher than Jordan Zimmermann. This shouldn’t be a big surprise, since good relievers are almost always the hardest guys in all of baseball to hit, and Storen is a very good reliever.

And as you’re probably sick of reading about by now, pitchers get worse the more often they face the same hitter within the same game. Here are Zimmermann’s career splits by times through the order:

Split PA BA OBP SLG
1st PA 1,304 0.226 0.273 0.355
2nd PA 1,291 0.256 0.293 0.389
3rd PA 982 0.262 0.313 0.407
4th PA 81 0.338 0.363 0.468

The first time Zimmermann faces a hitter in a game, he’s lights out. Second time, still pretty good. Third time, he’s roughly league average. The fourth match-up has been a disaster for him.

And yes, Zimmermann was throwing the ball well on Saturday night, but you only get to face a guy a fourth time through the order if you’re pitching well, so that entire data pool is essentially comprised of performances against Zimmermann late in games in which he had already performed at a high level. 81 plate appearances is of course a small sample, but both the league-wide and Zimmermann-specific trends are clear; his performance declines the longer he stays in, and by the time a hitter has already faced him three times, they hit him pretty well.

Even if we cherry pick the numbers, we can’t come up with a scenario where the expected line against Storen would be worse than against Zimmermann. Storen’s career .273 wOBA allowed is better than Zimmermann’s career-best .280 wOBA allowed this year, so even if we give Zimmermann credit for his 2014 performance and still hold Storen’s entire career line against him, Zimmermann still loses out. Add in any kind of times-through-the-order penalty and it ceases to even be remotely close.

Storen was the right call. It didn’t work, but that doesn’t make the move a mistake.


FG on FOX: The Benefits of Situational Pitching

Statistical analysts have long been fascinated with the idea of clutch hitting. Often times, those who who have provided memorable hits have been assigned an ineffable quality, with the idea that they can raise their game when runners are in scoring position, with two outs, or late in games. The reality is most great clutch hitters are simply good hitters, and over time hitters put up roughly the same numbers regardless of the situation.

For pitchers, the situation is slightly more complicated. Hitting is reactive – one can only take what they are given. Pitchers have more control in big spots, and often their pitch usage with runners on base or in high leverage situations varies from their normal pitch sequencing.

It’s a matter of bearing down. We hear often that a pitcher “needs” a strikeout in a given situation, and often pitchers attack batters with that very outcome in mind.

For some hitters, this is the most important part of an opposing pitcher’s scouting report. Miguel Cabrera is a born hitter, the kind of guy who can rope doubles and hit opposite field home runs while falling out of bed. His unique skills and seemingly innate ability to put the bat on the ball allow him to spend less time in the video room than most players. In fact, he barely studies opposing pitchers much at all.

In a profile of Cabrera’s approach I wrote in 2013, he explained that most of his video work comes from just watching pitchers with runners on base or looking at what they throw from the stretch. It’s the only information he wants because he feels it gives him an edge when his team needs him most.

Some players don’t want that kind of information, but a hitter like Cabrera — the rare talent that can sit on one pitch and still react to others — it can make all the difference during the game’s most dramatic moments as many pitchers make specific and deliberate adjustments when confronted with runners in scoring position.

Read the rest on FoxSports.com.


The Postseason Strike Zone, Thus Far, Vizualized

According to Google.com, this how much an umpire makes yearly:

A Major League umpire’s starting salary is around $120,000, with the senior umps earning up to $350,000. That may sound like a lot for what seems to be six months’ work, but the umpire’s season is considerably longer than that with Spring Training, All-Star Games and postseason play added into the mix.

OK. Call me naive, but $120,000 seems like a lot for 12 months work. I know many people who would take that salary for 24 months of work, in fact. The point is, umpires do OK for themselves. And I’m fine with that, for the most part. Yes, it’s a handsome sum, but umpires have a pretty tough job, all things considered.

In our Game 1 chat, Dave Cameron and I touched briefly on the announcers for the Postseason games. I won’t paste it verbatim, but the gist was that though the announcers perhaps weren’t the greatest choices, it’s very hard to announce baseball. A character trait/flaw of mine is to always be sympathetic toward people who have jobs that I would find difficult, and therefore I tend to cut them some slack. I do the same for umpires. They have to have laser-like focus all the time, people boo them incessantly, and every decision they make is now available for people to see on the Internet. We should absolutely hold them to a high standard, don’t get me wrong, I just think it’s a super-weird and unforgiving job. Now that my conscious is somewhat clear, here is every ball and strike call of the Postseason thus far (all data via baseballsavant.com):

You can filter by umpire and pitch result using the buttons on the right. The strike zone used for the Gameday streams is included for reference. Hovering over a pitch will give you all the deets. I won’t comment too much on the overall performance — you can click around to get a general idea of what’s going on. But I will comment on that one random ball in the middle of the zone. It was thrown by Phil Coke during the eighth inning of the blowout Game 1 of the Orioles/Tigers series.

cokecall

That’s pretty bad. But it wasn’t 100% the umpire’s fault.

cokebadball

PitchF/X and TBS’s system disagree on the actual location, but that’s the pitch. It’s a fastball, and Alex Avila totally whiffs on it. When a catcher has to dive to one knee to catch a pitch, it’s gonna be hard for an umpire to call a strike. It’s reverse framing, so to speak. It looks like their signs got crossed, but we can’t know for sure.

I plan on updating this data as the Playoffs progress, so stay tuned for that. In the meantime, go forth and spout your many concerns in the comments. Or privately among friends. Or not at all. It doesn’t really matter to me.


Dan Szymborski FanGraphs Chat – 10/6/14

11:58
Dan Szymborski: Boom.

11:58
Dan Szymborski: Will keep this fairly strictly to an hour. Dan got his yearly flu early this year and wants to sleep so that he doesn’t sleep during games.

11:58
Dan Szymborski: And yes, I realize I should probably get the damn flu shot.

11:58
Comment From Los
The orioles and royals are playing way over their heads. I guarantee they regress and neither reaches the world series.

11:58
Dan Szymborski: heh

11:58
Comment From Del Martin
Where does Detroit throw all that Little Cesar’s money after this embarrassing exit?

Read the rest of this entry »


Buck Showalter and Managing the Postseason

The Orioles finished off the Detroit Tigers yesterday, winning their division series three games to none, though the primary story of the series still seems to resolve around the Tigers and their disastrous bullpen performance. Despite throwing $10 million per year at Joe Nathan over the winter, and then trading for Joakim Soria at the deadline, the Tigers bullpen combined for 19.29 ERA in this series, and that includes two shutout innings from regular season starter Anibal Sanchez. If you look at just the Tigers postseason pitchers who were relievers in the regular season, they combined to allow 11 runs in just three innings against the Orioles, good for an ERA of 33.00.

The Orioles likely would be up 2-1 in this series even if the Tigers relievers had pitched well — Detroit’s starter left with the team down 4-3 in Game 1 and down 2-0 in Game 3, and the Tigers never managed to make up those deficits in either game — so it’s not accurate to say that the Tigers bullpen cost them the division series. However, on the other end of things, we could put together an argument that the Orioles bullpen, and more specifically Buck Showalter’s management of his relievers, won this series for the Orioles.

Read the rest of this entry »


What Went Wrong For The Tigers

It’s not a stretch to say that heading into the ALDS, the biggest concern in Detroit was about the bullpen — specifically how first-year manager Brad Ausmus had chosen to deploy it late in the season. Baltimore ended up sweeping the Tigers in three games, and the bullpen was directly involved in two of Detroit’s losses. At least one Ausmus decision — lifting Anibal Sanchez for Joba Chamberlain in Game 2 — was enough to get the manager torched by analysts and fans. There were some unhappy, as well, about Ausmus’ decision to bring in Chamberlain in Game 1 and with his choice to pinch-hit Hernan Perez for Andrew Romine in the ninth inning in Game 3 (as though that were really a thing that mattered at all).

Ausmus’ inexperience was perceived as a weakness. He made unpopular decisions that went poorly, and now his team is headed home. Guess we know where to place the blame, right? This is some quality #narrative, of course. It’s not necessarily wrong, entirely, because Ausmus certainly made some choices that didn’t require second-guessing, since they’d been first-guessed in the moment. It’s just a little too simplistic, a little too convenient.

Read the rest of this entry »


The Washington Nationals vs. Vic Carapazza

This is a story all about how an umpire flipped-turned a playoff game upside down.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m not blaming the outcome of Saturday night’s marathon game between Washington and San Francisco entirely on fourth-year umpire Vic Carapazza, working in his first MLB postseason. I would never do that. Despite what disgruntled fans might lead you to believe, the blame for a team’s loss can never be placed on the shoulders of one individual. Especially not in a game that lasted 18 innings.

There are countless factors that played into Washington’s loss, and that’s been reflected in the media’s coverage of this game. The offense went scoreless for 15 innings after taking a 1-0 lead in the third. Many have focused on manager Matt Williams‘ decision to remove starting pitcher Jordan Zimmermann after a walk in the ninth. Some have focused on… the male genitalia? But a lot of attention has turned to Carapazza, who had a shaky strike zone and ejected Williams and shortstop Asdrubal Cabrera in the bottom of the 10th for arguing balls and strikes.

Cabrera and Williams need to keep their cool in that situation, but, boy, did Vic Carapazza have himself a rough night.
Read the rest of this entry »


Effectively Wild Episode 549: ALDS Postmortems and the Rest of Baseball’s Big Weekend

Ben and Sam marvel at a wild baseball weekend and dissect the ALDS sweeps.


ALDS Open Thread: Sunday, October 5th

There’s no official chat today, so feel free to chat in the comments section for today’s ALDS games.


Sunday Notes: Adam Jones, Kinsler’s Glove, Price’s Cutter, Britton’s Sinker, more

What is the best way to attack Adam Jones? The answer would seemingly be to avoid the strike zone. The Orioles outfielder walked just 19 times in 682 plate appearances – that’s a 2.8 walk-rate, folks – and his 56.5 Swing% was the highest in the American League. His 42.1 O-Swing% was topped only by Salvador Perez.

Unfortunately for the opposition, while Jones chases pitchers’ pitches, he also chases pitchers by getting hits on some of those pitches. His 63.0 O-Contact% isn’t particularly high, but that says more about his proclivity to sometimes chase pitches in a different area code. If it’s close enough to the zone, he has a knack for getting knocks.

In the words of David Price, “I don’t think there’s a pitch Adam Jones doesn’t think he can hit, and he might be right.” An American League pitching coach offered a similar perspective, saying “Adam Jones will swing at a ball that bounces in the dirt and he’ll also swing at a ball that’s neck high. The difference between him and other guys who do that is he’s like Vladimir Guerrero – he can hit those pitches. One time this year he lined a ball back through the middle on a pitch that was six feet high. It was ridiculous.” Read the rest of this entry »