State of the Org: American League
At the beginning of June, I wrote about how reach-out call season had begun. As the calendar flips this week, those reach-out calls quickly turn into conversations concerning serious injuries and the initialization of actual trade talks. A lot can change in a month, and has, so let’s check in with each org and try to project the month ahead, beginning with the American League.
AL East
Boston Red Sox
June Effect: Up significantly. The Red Sox entered the month with roughly a 25% chance of reaching the postseason, but are now the overwhelming favorite to win the division (53.5%) with an 83.5% chance to make the playoffs, per our Playoff Odds.
Current Tenor: Buying mode.
What They Are After: Starters who can pitch in playoffs games and a more dependable bat at first base. Hunter Renfroe’s step forward creates less stress about the outfield situation.
Behavior: It’s hard to measure other than by using Chaim Bloom’s history in Tampa. He’ll likely aim high in terms of asks/offers, but a heavy lean on analytics can create evaluation mis-matches that allow a deal to get done.
Tampa Bay Rays
June Effect: Down. The Rays began June as a two-thirds favorite to win the division, but are now at just 19.2%, with a 56.5% chance of reaching the postseason.
Current Tenor: Opportunistic buying.
What They Are After: Offensive upgrades in the outfield, and perhaps a righty power bat for DH/1B duty against lefties.
Behavior: The Rays are always budget constrained, so they tend to play in the margins as they can’t afford to add much in the way of payroll. Their asks/offers tend to start off exceptionally high/low, at times to the point of not being constructive in terms of generating traction on a potential deal.
Toronto Blue Jays
June Effect: Steady. The chances of the Blue Jays getting to the postseason have continued to linger in the 40% range and their odds of winning the division have held steady over the last month.
Current Tenor: Early buying, especially in terms of bullpen help. They should continue to see George Springer as their biggest second-half addition.
What They Are After: More bullpen help, even after acquiring Adam Cimber on Tuesday. One could easily argue that even an average relief corp would have the Blue Jays as a strong favorite to reach the postseason.
Behavior: Aggressive. The Jays know how to get deals done. They identify players as acquisition targets, then go after them while remaining responsive and rational.
New York Yankees
June Effect: Down. The Yankees have gone from a two-thirds shot at reaching the postseason to less than a 50/50 shot after their recent slide.
Current Tenor: Holding. The Yankees have some owner-defined payroll restrictions and also some roster locks. The offense might be struggling, but at this point, they are kind of stuck riding out the season with the lineup that brought them here, for better or for worse. It’s hard to see them getting aggressive in the market unless they get hot between now and the break.
What They Are After: Starting pitching. Gerrit Cole is an obvious Game One starter, but where it goes from there is anybody’s guess. It’s either buy or stand pat, as the Yankees don’t sell unless it’s absolutely necessary, which will not be the case this season.
Behavior: The Yankees tend to work slowly and deliberately in terms of deal making. They are never rushed, and tend to line up and assess multiple potential trades as opposed to zeroing in on individual players.
Baltimore Orioles
June Effect: Steady. The only October baseball Baltimore will see is their final three games of the regular season at Toronto.
Current Tenor: Selling. Freddy Galvis’ injury probably costs the Orioles a decent prospect as he was looking like a strong middle infield target for several potential playoff clubs. Trey Mancini remains of the the best potential bats available, and the extra year of control should lead to a return the Orioles really like. They’re not going to just give him away.
What They Are After: Prospects, prospects and more prospects. Don’t be surprised to see the club look to sweeten a deal by acquiring more international money. This is still a rebuild, but they have to start showing some progress, and will likely target some young players closer to the big leagues.
Behavior: Coming from the Houston school, Elias and company will listen on anyone, and be willing to talk about any player who doesn’t have a chance to be in Baltimore if and when the team becomes more of a contender.
AL Central
Chicago White Sox
June Effect: Down slightly. The White Sox have scuffled a bit in June, but nobody in the division has really been a position to take advantage of it, and they remain the overwhelming favorites to win the Central.
Current Tenor: Buying. The White Sox might like their chances to win the division, but they need to focus on building a roster that will be more dangerous in the playoffs.
What They Are After: The much rumored acquisition of Eduardo Escobar is a perfect fit, but they are frequently rolling out a Triple-A worthy outfield and that should be their focus. Like most clubs in buying mode, the club will also look to address their bullpen depth.
Behavior: The White Sox are good to deal with. They are honest, direct and, while not to such an extent as to get in the way of completing a deal, tough negotiators.
Cleveland
June Effect: Up slightly. Cleveland continues to lurk in second place, seeing their chances of a playoff berth going from roughly 1-in-8 to 1-in-4.
Current Tenor: Light Buying. Cleveland is in a constant state of budget constraint, so don’t expect anything flashy on the shores of Lake Erie.
What They Are After: The team is hoping that a return to health for their rotation pieces will keep them in the race. It shouldn’t be hard to find smaller upgrades to the offensive black holes that are their outfield and right side of the infield.
Behavior: Cleveland can be a tough trade partner. They start high in terms of asks and tend to stand their ground and stay there. They have no qualms with walking away from a potential deal if it isn’t perfect for them.
Minnesota Twins
June Effect: Down slightly. The Twins have played better in recent weeks, but their biggest enemy are all the losses they racked up in the first two months of the season. It’s a case of too little too late, and they remain an extreme long shot to reach the playoffs.
Current Tenor: Starting a selling process, but only on players with expiring contracts.
What They Are After: The Twins likely see this as just a year gone bad as opposed to the start of any kind of a tear down, and rightly so. There is no need to listen on players under club control after 2021 unless somebody wants to get crazy. For now, just build some prospect depth and re-tool to take another shot at it in 2022.
Behavior: Unknown, as this is the first sell-off for Minnesota under Derek Falvey. As buyers, they have been disciplined but easy to deal with.
Detroit Tigers
June Effect: Steady. Steady from zero is still zero, but at least the team is fun to watch and showing some reasons for future optimism.
Current Tenor: Selling. They don’t have any big prizes on the shelf, but a hot Jonathan Schoop should generate significant interest.
What They Are After: Prospect depth, but an imbalanced system could creates a focus on young bats. With a plethora of pitching prospects having arrived or set to do so quickly, more advanced prospects will be preferred.
Behavior: The Tigers tend to focus on specific talents in their sells, finding a headliner that both parties can agree upon and then figuring out the rest of the deal.
Kansas City Royals
June Effect: Down slightly. The Royals were a fun team to watch early on, but clearly over their skis, and their chances of reaching the playoffs have gone from tiny to nil.
Current Tenor: Minor sellers. Dayton Moore doesn’t like tear downs, so the club is more likely to focus on expiring contracts.
What They Are After: Young bats. They surely entered the year hoping that Jorge Soler would be one of the better offensive targets come summer, but his collapse has greatly hindered their ability to provide a big boost to their already strong system.
Behavior: The Royals tend to be aggressive, and also tend to focus on athleticism, tools and upside when it comes to position player prospects, which can produce some good matchups with more data-oriented clubs.
AL West
Houston Astros
June Effect: Up. Houston’s offense is bordering on historic, and their playoff shot has gone from very likely to the most favored team in the league to reach the postseason, with playoff odds of 91.8%.
Current Tenor: Buying, but they are up against the soft cap.
What They Are After: The bullpen is the only issue but it’s a real one, and will certainly be their focus, as it has already cost them several games in the standings.
Behavior: Unpredictable. The Astros stood surprisingly pat last summer, and the industry is still waiting to see exactly how James Click will behave as part of an organization that actually spends money.
Oakland Athletics
June Effect: Down slightly. Oakland is down more because of the Astros than anything they’ve done wrong. Their chances of winning the division has slipped significantly, and while it’s still far from Wild-Card-or-bust, it’s trending that way.
Current Tenor: Buying.
What They Are After: Middle infielders and maybe a bopper in an outfield corner. While their pitching has been good overall, the ‘pen is a bit on the shallow side.
Behavior: The A’s are seen as cheap, but have been known to add bigger names at the deadline on expiring deals. If there is a team that could make a surprise trade over the next month, it’s Oakland.
Seattle Mariners
June Effect: Steady. The Mariners sat at nearly 100-to-1 entering the month, and are still there. So you’re saying there’s a chance…
Current Tenor: Light selling. That said, the Mariners don’t have a whole lot of interest to offer teams. Mitch Haniger is available, but the extra year of control complicates matters a bit. Every team looking for ‘pen help has likely already been in touch concerning Kendall Graveman.
What They Are After: Prospects they like, with a lean towards bats. The Mariners aren’t far from being an interesting team, so players closer to the big leagues, or even 0-3 types will be preferred.
Behavior: The Mariners love making trades, that’s no secret. They are one of the busiest clubs in terms of keeping talks moving and will quickly pull the trigger once they find a deal they like.
Los Angeles Angels
June Effect: Steady. The Angels have played well without Mike Trout to maintain their puncher’s chance of reaching the playoffs at around 10%.
Current Tenor: Standing pat. The odds say they should be moving expiring contracts, and there would be a considerable market for starters Alex Cobb and Andrew Heaney, but historically, owner Arte Moreno has been very hesitant in approving a sell off.
What They Are After: The Angels are trying to build a quick contender, so the focus will be on young players in the big leagues or close to it should they move into selling mode.
Behavior: Unknown, as there’s a new administration in place headed by a first-time GM.
Texas Rangers
June Effect: Steady. The Rangers were all but out of the playoffs on Opening Day.
Current Tenor: Selling. The big question is how seriously they are willing to discuss Joey Gallo and/or Kyle Gibson, who are both signed through 2022 at very reasonable rates. They’ll certainly listen on both, but can afford to be patient if nothing blows their doors off.
What They Are After: The Rangers are still in rebuilding mode and have an excellent farm system they will try to continue to improve.
Behavior: The Rangers are easy to deal with. Very direct and very reasonable. First asks and offers frequently provide a good starting point to getting something done.
Kevin Goldstein is a National Writer at FanGraphs.


Love these inside looks at front office thinking and policies.
Worth it for the “behavior” line alone. I love finding out little details like that. Thanks for this, Kevin.
I appreciate Kevin’s pieces, but I do sometimes find them a little… thin? The behavior sections, for instance, are all great. We love that inside stuff. A lot of this, though, is just looking at the playoff odds or pointing out fairly obvious positional holes. Anyhow, still worth the read. Looking forward to grumbling about the NL article.
These pieces are the logical counterweight to all the ridiculous trade “rumors” and “ideas” that sites just start spreading in July in order to lure clicks. Thank you Kevin!
The concept of Mitch Haniger’s extra year of control as a “complication” is kind of absurd, even if it’s true.
It’s a complication for a team like that only needs an outfielder for this year because of injuries, like the White Sox (although Eaton’s a FA at the end of the year, so that might not even be true).
It shouldn’t be a complication for a team like Cleveland, who really could use a year and a half of an outfielder, but because they’re a team who gets really precious with their prospects they see it as a complication because it is “too good” for them.
There’s a decent chance Haniger’s going to hang on another year in Seattle before he gets traded for international bonus space. Same is likely true for Adam Frazier. Same is likely true with Gallo, although Gallo will probably get a JD Martinez-level return (whoever next year’s Dawel Lugo will be).
Haniger’s complication is that SEA could potentially be competitive next year, and so it may be worth holding onto him unless blown away
You and I both know that glass that half full and half empty are the same thing but the way you’re looking at it is super duper half full. They’ve got a -49 run differential and are projected to drop another -39 over the rest of the season. Lots of things have to break right for them to be competitive in 2022.
Lots of things do need to break right, but I think many organizations fail when they try to thread the needle too much. In other words, they hope that the prospects all arrive and contribute on too narrow a timeline. It also ignores what you have on hand that is legit like Haniger. Also, they can actually go and sign FA’s for next season as well.
Also complicates it from a cost angle. The M’s will want to extract a top 100 prospect in order to feel comfortable dealing him but may not find a team willing to meet that price.
Actually Cleveland will be facing a major rule 5 crunch in the offseason so they need to trade away a few prospects.
The corner OFers are set at this point with Harold Ramirez (115 wRC+) and Eddie Rosario (.315/.346/.444 over the past 33 games). What they really need is a CFer who can hit better than Bradley Zimmer while providing a similar level of defense since neither Ramirez nor Rosario are going to win a Gold Glove or anything resembling one. I like Haniger but I don’t think he fits that description.
To be fair, what you’re describing only applies to 5-7 players in the major leagues and Cleveland is not paying the price for Buxton, Luis Robert, Trent Grisham, Starling Marte, Lorenzo Cain, or Odubel Herrera either. I think you’re right that Cleveland will use its 40-man leftovers to pick up whoever they can, but this team is not going to trade for controllable and/or elite players because they’re not going to want to pay the price.
Someone doesn’t like this, but I challenge you to find players that Cleveland would be willing to move that would provide major upgrades for the team in return. If Starling Marte is available they are not outbidding every other team with a massive center field hole for him, and they’re certainly not going to trade away enough to get hold of someone like Bryan Reynolds. Maybe they’d be willing to trade Nolan Jones and/or Gabriel Arias, and perhaps the teams they would want to trade with believe in them still. Daniel Johnson and Andres Gimenez and Josh Naylor (who is hurt, anyway) are not moving the needle.
Cleveland is actually a really good example of a circular problem going on here that explains why the current trade market is so freaking inefficient right now. Teams who actually are willing to trade prospects to win now empty out their farm systems to win now (hello, AJ Preller), so we’re stuck in a market where the teams that have these big roster crunches (like Cleveland) are also the teams that are most stingy about trading away prospects. I think there’s a world where Cleveland actually is willing to trade away Nolan Jones, but probably not in a world where his stock is high enough that it would get Starling Marte. Because Cleveland’s preferences are relatively rigid, as Kevin alludes to above, the only way a deal happens for a major difference maker is if there is a major asymmetry in evaluation.
I didn’t vote you down above nor on this one. But I’m not clear on why you think Cleveland is stingy when it comes to trading away prospects. They’ve certainly done it in the recent past, trading away guys like Clint Frazier, Justus Sheffield, and Francisco Mejia. We also know that they tried to trade for Marte last year though they obviously weren’t successful.
Also, don’t understand the negative sentiment re: Arias and Gimenez. Arias is hitting .256/.354/.397 as a 21-year-old SS in AAA. He also has a much-improved walk rate compared to last year. What’s wrong with that? And while Gimenez struggled in the majors this year, we know he was rushed. He’s still young (22), has shown some success in the majors, and is thriving at AAA (.281/.327/.532).
The White Sox still need corner outfielders in the future.
They look like they might get back both Robert and Jimenez – both have been cleared to “resume baseball activities” and could be back by September. That still leaves them a little short in the outfield. They regularly field an outfield full of infielders – Vaughn, Lamb, Mendick, and now Sheets are all career infielders pressed into service by injury. Guys like Hamilton and Goodwin were insurance policies that have been forced into full time roles. Garcia is more of a super-utility guy these days, but he shouldn’t be playing 150 games a year and he started his career as an infielder too.
Even when Jimenez comes back, I’d be fine if he never wore a glove that wasn’t a batting glove ever again. Unless they think Vaughn is a left fielder long term (he has looked less bad than Jimenez out there) AND that a prospect will develop into a real RF, they still need another corner OF in 2022. There’s no reason they can’t address that in FA or even via trade if they want, but going into 2022 with Robert, Jimenez, Engel, and the collection of rejects form the island of Misfit Toys that they are using now would be less than ideal.
Gallo would be perfect for them for a number of reasons. I think the real question is that since the White Sox have only one prospect that will get other teams’ attention (Jared Kelley), the question is exactly who they want to trade him for. I’m pretty sure they’d be happy to trade away Micker Adolfo or Blake Rutherford or Jake Burger I’m not sure any set of those guys are going to get someone like Gallo with a year and a half remaining.
As a White Sox fan, I kinda like Adolfo, Rutherford, and Burger as lottery tickets (in that order) and I would not hesitate one millisecond to trade all three for Gallo based on where they are right now.
I don’t think offering all three of those gets you to even sniff Gallo.
I really enjoyed the Draft coverage here that Eric and Kiley did on this site. Maybe they just set a standard that can never be matched again?
I did enjoy the Twitch chat on the Draft that is archived there. I would surely watch a two hour version of a mock draft but I see in Eric’s chat that you guys don’t want to do that unless you get bonus money for it.
Kevin, how do you source the culture of each front office in their trade tactics? I found those snippets to be fascinating. An annual article about different front office characteristics sounds like a natural article series. Add in historical analysis of past dealings and it would be my favorite read right behind the annual prospect list articles.
I imagine it’s from working with the Astros and a mixture of his personal dealings with those clubs and what’s he’s been told through, now, former coworkers.
Need to remember that there’s an inherent bias there. The way he describes the Blue Jays fits with what I know of the team but there were two trades (Hernandez and Thornton) he was involved with. That will obviously shape his view of the team. A different person in another front office may have a different view from their experiences.
Craig, I disagree that this is the first sell for Derek Falvey and Thad Levine, as they traded away Brian Dozier, Lance Lynn, Eduardo Escobar, Fernando Rodney, and Ryan Pressly in 2018, during a season where the Twins finished 78-84.
From the outside, it certainly seems like the strategy for that some of the more prospect-hoarding teams, like the Rays, Cleveland, Yankees, Dodgers, and maybe even the Astros and Red Sox (having ex-Rays in charge and all) are busy figuring out which players they are planning to not protect in the Rule 5 and seeing who they can get for them. Almost like “team needs” are secondary to 40-man roster management.
I remain convinced that 40-man timelines are the big thing that is missing from THE BOARD for this reason. I understand that it’s at Roster Resource if you want to click back and forth a lot but there are some prospects who are definitely going to be way more available than others within the same FV tier.
I’ve upvoted sadtrombone comments about THE BOARD and 40 man timelines before, but I’m stepping out of the shadows to give a more full throated endorsement. I hope others will join me. It’s clear that this has become a big part of how decisions are made in FOs and if there’s a way to make it more visible and available on THE BOARD I’d be delighted to see it.
Eric has responded to this once and his response was “but it’s already at Roster Resource.” I don’t think that’s much of a reason because that means you should be able to pipe it into the board that much easier. As it stands it’s almost easier to go to Roster Resource rather than use the board because the org rank is at Roster Resource but the 40-man timeline isn’t on the board.
What I’d really like is to move the four columns from from the signing year to the bonus into its own tab, and then add 40-man roster timeline in there. I don’t know that you would need to move all of them but it is much more relevant than all of those columns put together.
This whole site is amazing so I don’t want to make it sound like I’m ungrateful, it’s all awesome. But this change would be so, so easy and would be incredibly useful.
Don”t see the White Sox trying to upgrade their OF at all with both Eloy and Robert already doing baseball activities/ahead of schedule. Could be August or even sooner for either or.
They still have a hole in RF in the short and longer term since Eaton’s also on the IL for however long and he wasn’t very effective before that— albeit that he was playing hurt and obviously not healing. There’s no prospect in their system likely to lock down RF; Sheets, who debuted yesterday, is a big guy who’s a career 1B (read: bad defensively in RF) who has a long track record of hitting merely good not great, never really getting to his significant raw pop. The rest of their outfield prospects are either physical but much too raw and in the low minors (Bailey, Cespedes, Beard), or tweeners highly unlikely to be more than 4th/5th OFs (Gonzalez, Rutherford). They could use a longer-term answer in RF, if they want to pursue that in the trade market.
Don’t disagree on that, but offense hasn’t really been a negative, and most teams have holes. But sure, I could see it. I’d imagine they would need a good glove guy, as you cannot really have two negative D’s in both corners.
Agree with all of that, but I want to pile on with my usual “Eloy shouldn’t play the outfield” rant. That means they need 2 corner OF, long term, unless both Vaughn and Sheets (or someone else) is going to hit well enough to cover up the fact that they are first basemen playing the outfield.
Quick edit: this says that the Red Sox entered the month with a 25% chance of making the postseason, but the Fangraphs playoffs odds for them on June 1 were 56.7%. Still up, but not as dramatically as it reads.
Rays numbers are off too. They were 32.4% to win the division, not 2/3. Unless I’ve done something wrong here:
https://www.fangraphs.com/standings/playoff-odds?date=2021-06-01&dateDelta=
This is the funniest line in the article (about the Rays):
“Their asks/offers tend to start off exceptionally high/low, at times to the point of not being constructive in terms of generating traction on a potential deal.”
Reminds me of some fantasy baseball owners I have dealt with over the years…but written in a much more respectful tone. I will have to use the phrase that “your offer is not constructive in terms of generating traction on a potential deal”.
Lol, my first thoughts exactly. Owners like that are the 2nd biggest reason (behind time) why I stopped playing fantasy sports.
It seems pretty clear which team in the AL Kevin disliked dealing with the most.
And it’s not even close.
Has to be that gump Jeff Sullivan’s fault
Was the Zobrist trade before your tenure? I have to wonder if that trade made the Rays smell blood when dealing with Houston.
Yes, it was before Kevin’s time.
It obviously worked on Neal Huntington, so it’s no wonder they keep using that tactic.
The A’s #1 Priority is bullpen help
There seems to be a gigantic difference in value between a player whose contract expires in 3 months vs 15 months. Why wouldn’t the Mariners trade Haniger for example? If Kelenic and Rodriguez do well in 2022 they might be contenders and if not they won’t. Haniger isn’t much of a difference maker. The only complication should be the fairly modest price of the extra year, not the willingness to trade him.
JD Davis for Haniger… ?
M’s add 2 addl control years…..
That would be an excellent deal for the Mariners. For the Mets? I don’t know, if they get an outfielder he better be able to play center field. Also, based on what is going on tonight against the Braves they probably need another starter. Hoo boy.
Point is that Haniger is a legit OFer. He doesn’t need to be a CFer. While JD has no position. And the Mets need a RFer and preferably RHed bat with Conforto likely walking to free agency after this season.
I’d have to think Haniger yields more than JD Davis tho.
I’m a Mets fan and I would be pretty OK with that deal. Davis is a massive liability anywhere in the field, and if the DH comes to the NL next year (which it probably will) then Haniger can slide to left, Dom Smith can move back to first and Alonso can DH. The Mets have a pretty strong glut of 3B prospects anyway.
Why would he slide to LF? Haniger is the RFer assuming Scooter walks. McNeil and Nimmo probably get LF and CF.
Dom Smith (and McNeil for that matter) has been a tremendous disappointment and so I don’t see him being handed any regular role. And he’s by no means a good glove at 1B either. There’s no evidence to support that. Pete has to be the 1Bman. They’ll need to add real bats at 3B and DH. But Haniger is a nice RHed OF bat to plug in to this lineup.
Yea Smith is -12 OAA at 1B for his career. I don’t know why Met fans think he’s a good defensive 1B when all the evidence points to the contrary
Tell the Twins to send the Cubs both Berrios and Buxton
Sure. Something like Davis, Marquez, and Preciado seems fair, right?
I vote Christian Hernandez, want to see Cubs twitter flip out over trading a teenager who would have been part of The Future for an ace
Other players too, sure, but probably not those guys you mentioned. Ian Happ’s under sweet, powerful control until 2024
Hernandez as the headliner for those two probably won’t give you a sniff. They’d definitely need to add one of the three guys I mentioned.
I’m sure this is a dumb question but what are “0-3 types?”
Don’t think it’s a dumb question. Not sure, but I think it’s players in their pre-arb years (they have 0 – 3 years of service time).
Correct
I agree that 1B may be a concern for Boston, but they really need a LH bat there, and there don’t seem to be clean fits. Perhaps Carlos Santana as a SH. Younger Mitch Moreland would be a perfect platoon with Dalbec.
When I go through the LH 1B options, they are on playoff contenders or don’t move the needle. Danny Santana clearly doesn’t solve the issue. They now have Franchy taking grounders at 1B in AAA.
I don’t think this team *needs* to do anything, though. Sale/Eovaldi/ERod/Pivetta is fine for the rotation. The club scores a lot of runs and seems to have a deep bullpen. I’d rather make the bullpen even deeper than pay starting pitcher prices.
Take Dom Smith, please…