This year’s AL Wild Card Game will be a battle of competing philosophies, at least when it comes to the choice of starting pitchers. On Tuesday at Yankee Stadium, the opposing managers announced their picks for Wednesday night’s game. The Yankees have decided to remain old-school, with manager Aaron Boone tabbing 24-year-old righty Luis Severino, an All-Star who despite second-half struggles finished fourth in the league in WAR (5.7) and in a virtual tie for fifth in FIP (2.95) — and one whose early exit in last year’s Wild Card Game pushed the Yankees into a bullpen-oriented approach anyway. As for the A’s, a club whose rotation has has lost staff ace Sean Manaea and five other starters to season-ending surgeries, manager Bob Melvin is going the new-school route, with 29-year-old righty Liam Hendriks as his opener — a first of sorts. In eight September starts, Hendriks threw a combined 8.2 innings.
Together, the choices offer something of a callback to a year ago. Heading into the AL Wild Card game, then-manager Joe Girardi was ambivalent about the possibility of saving Severino for a potential Division Series Game One and relying upon his wealth of dominant relievers to face the Twins. “You could do that but that’s not something you’ve done during the course of the season,” Girardi told reporters. “And we have some starters who are pretty qualified to make that start… If you start doing crazy things, things guys aren’t used to, then I’m just not comfortable doing it. You want to keep it as normal as possible.”
Despite Girardi’s reservations, it was clear that the Yankees were built for such a scenario thanks to general manager Brian Cashman’s July 19 (re)acquisition of David Robertson and Tommy Kahnle to add to a bullpen that already included Aroldis Chapman and Dellin Betances. “A veritable clown car of effective righties who can miss bats and take over before Twins batters get too familiar with Severino,” is how one wag put it.
Despite Girardi’s best-laid plans, “normal” went out the window in the first inning, when Severino retired just one of the six batters he faced, served up two homers, and dug the Yankees a 3-0 hole. With Chad Green, Robertson, Kahnle, and Chapman combining to get 26 outs (13 by strikeout) while allowing just one additional run, the Yankees’ bullpen kept the Twins at bay long enough for their formidable offense to go to town on Minnesota starter Ervin Santana and lesser relievers.
Though he managed the Yankees to within one win of their first World Series berth since 2009, Girardi was replaced by Boone this past winter. The Yankees increased their win total from 91 to 100 but still wound up seeded as Wild Card hosts. In the days leading up to the game, Boone didn’t completely dismiss the possibility of a bullpen-oriented approach, though not an “opener”-type start. “Absolutely, it’s a consideration,” he said on “The Michael Kay Show” last Wednesday, explaining that he could use one of his top options for a shorter stint before opening the bullpen door. “I could see Happ, Masa, or Sevy [J.A. Happ, Masahiro Tanaka, or Severino] — even if they are pitching well — not going deep. We’ll be rested and lined up, so I can see getting two, three, four, or five innings from (the starter) and then roll it out.”
The Yankees even went through something of a dry run with an opener on Monday, September 24 against — who else? — the Rays. With Jonathan Holder making his first start since 2015 in High-A, Boone used eight pitchers, with exiled starter Sonny Gray representing the only one to throw more than one inning. The results were compelling: two hits and one run allowed, with 13 strikeouts to offset six walks in a 4-1 win that, coincidentally enough, eliminated Tampa Bay from postseason contention while clinching a berth for Oakland.
“I don’t think it’s fair for them to say a ‘bullpen day,’” Rays Manager Kevin Cash said afterwards. “More like a ‘closer day.’ They all just kind of come in there and have wipeout stuff from the second that Green steps on the mound.” Indeed, between Betances, Chapman, Robertson, and Zach Britton, who together accounted for four innings that night, the Yankees have no shortage of experienced ninth-inning types at their disposal. That’s part of what gave the idea of a bullpen game its appeal, particularly with relatively little clarity regarding the team’s options to start.
Severino had emerged as a Cy Young candidate in the first half, posting a 2.31 ERA and a 2.75 FIP en route to a spot on the AL All-Star team, but he was pummeled for a 5.57 ERA in the second half. His FIP was just 3.37 in that latter span, but his BABIP shot from .278 to .379, his homer rate from 0.7 per nine to 1.3, and his slugging percentage allowed from .316 to .490. From July 7 to September 5 — the last outing a six-run, 2.2-inning grind against this same A’s club — he made just two quality starts out of 11, with a 6.83 ERA and a 4.66 FIP. Only over his final three starts, during which he allowed four runs in 17.2 innings against the Twins, Red Sox, and Rays, did he right the ship.
“I feel like after some bumps in the road certainly the second half of the season, he’s turned a corner and really started to throw the ball better,” Boone said of Severino on Tuesday, adding that “performance, experience, stuff, opponent” and input from his coaching staff and Cashman went into the decision.
Tanaka was almost a mirror image of Severino this season, pitching to a 4.54 ERA and a 4.91 FIP before the All-Star break — during which he missed a month due to bilateral hamstring strains suffered while running the bases in an interleague game at Citi Field — and a 2.85 ERA and a 2.98 FIP after. However, he was pummeled for nine runs in eight innings in his final two starts against the Red Sox and Rays. Happ, the sole lefty under consideration, gave the Yankees a 2.69 ERA and a 4.21 FIP in 11 starts after being acquired from the Blue Jays on July 26.
For what it’s worth, the A’s have generally fielded a righty-heavy lineup, with Matt Olson the only lefty-swinging regular, though Nick Martini has lately platooned in left field with righty-swinging Mark Canha. Jed Lowrie is the team’s only switch-hitter. Even with that tilt, the A’s had the league’s second-highest wRC+ (112) against righties, and they were tied for third (105 wRC+) against lefties. Of the 43 qualified AL starters, Severino’s .280 wOBA allowed to righties ranks 10th, with Happ’s .313 at 24th and Tanaka’s .324 placing 29th. By comparison, Chapman (.238), Betances (.250), Robertson (.254), Holder (.261), and Green (.273) were all better at handling righties than any of the three starters.
As for the A’s, starting Hendriks is a gambit to which Melvin turned shortly after losing Manaea for the season in late August — this, after Jharel Cotton, A.J. Puk, Kendall Graveman, and Daniel Gossett all underwent Tommy John surgery, and Andrew Triggs went down with a nerve problem that culminated in surgery to alleviate thoracic outlet syndrome. At the time Manaea went down, the San Francisco Chronicle’s John Shea wrote of a potential matchup with the Yankees, “Don’t be surprised if management decides to go bullpen happy in a wild-card game, especially because it likely would follow two off days.”
Hendriks is the leader of that conga line. Roughed up for a 7.36 ERA and a 6.44 FIP in 11 first-half innings, he was designated for assignment on June 25 and outrighted to Triple-A Nashville, where he spent July and August. A long-toss program helped him boost his velocity: according to the Pitch Info daya, his average four-seam fastball velo jumped from 93.8 mph before the assignment to 96.7 mph after being restored to the 40-man roster in September. The 29-year-old righty allowed just two runs in his eight “starts”; only in the first of those turns did he go longer than an inning or throw more than 28 pitches. His second start came against the Yankees on September 4; he struck out Brett Gardner, then retired Giancarlo Stanton and Andrew McCutchen, as well.
The A’s went 4-4 in those games, with Daniel Mengden or Chris Bassitt — a pair that combined for 24 starts earlier in the season — usually following and throwing three to five innings as the “bulk guy.” From there, Melvin would piece it together with a bullpen bolstered by the in-season acquisitions of Jeurys Familia, Fernando Rodney, and Shawn Kelley to augment the work of ace closer Blake Treinen and setup men Lou Trivino and Yusmeiro Petit.
Said Melvin of the A’s adoption of the opener strategy:
“[W]ith as many injuries as we have had to our starters, we are trying to find a way to get a little bit better. Part of this was starting Liam, bringing a starter in after that, had mixed results as far as it went. Some games were good, some not. Sometimes we tried to extend Liam and tried to get him through a second inning; that didn’t work. So there’s been some trial and error with this. But I think the reason that we started looking at this is because we’ve had so many injuries in our rotation, and we’re just trying to do the best possible thing that we think for a particular day.”
Said Hendriks of the assignment:
“Same as any other game. I’m taking it the same way, warming up the same as I do, trying to keep it as much as a relief appearance as I can. All it means is I’m relieving in the first inning.
“There’s no difference in the game. Obviously it’s a do or die, but to everybody out there, it’s the same strike zone, same guys in the box, just going to go out there and do it and see how it goes.”
By the admittedly noisy measure Jeff Sullivan used last month in his effort to document the spread of the opener — starts of 40 pitches or fewer, which could also capture hooks of traditional starters due to injury or ineffectiveness — Oakland’s total of 11 such outings ranked second in the majors, well behind the Rays (58) and just ahead of the Angels and Twins:
Looking over Oakland’s log of such starts, only Trivino’s one-inning appearance on September 28 represents a true use of the “opener” role with a pitcher besides Hendriks. Triggs and Brett Anderson departed the other two early due to injuries. Still, given the rough performance of their ramshackle rotation in September — a combined 4.66 ERA and 5.08 FIP from Edwin Jackson (five starts), Mike Fiers (four), Anderson (four), Trevor Cahill (three), and Mengden (one), it’s understandable why they’d search for alternative approaches and lean heavily on their successful bullpen.
The A’s bullpen was not quite as dominant as the Yankees’, but Treinen (0.78 ERA, 1.82 FIP, 31.8 K%, 3.6 WAR) had a season for the ages. The unit as a whole was more clutch than the Yankees, performing better than expected in high-leverage situations:
|Yankees||3.38 (3)||78 (2)||3.33 (2)||76 (2)||30.2% (1)||9.7 (1)||8.6 (2)||2.16 (4)|
|Athletics||3.37 (2)||81 (3)||3.91 (5)||95 (6)||23.6% (7)||5.7 (3)||12.5 (1)||4.78 (2)|
As Sullivan pointed out on September 10, the A’s bullpen was on pace for a record WPA, but regression over the final few weeks dropped them merely to fifth in our calculations, which go back to 1974; the 2012 Orioles bullpen holds the record with 13.5 WPA.
The numbers above, of course, include the contributions of players currently absent from each club’s respective roster — and omit the starters who will be available out of the two bullpens on Wednesday night. According to Boone, the Yankees will carry 10 pitchers including Tanaka, Happ, and Lance Lynn to provide length and perhaps some tactical advantages as well as accounting for contingencies. The A’s will carry 11 pitchers, including Fiers as a potential bulk guy if not necessarily the first pitcher to follow Hendriks. (Mengden has been sent to Arizona to prepare for a possible Division Series start.) Unless Melvin chooses to include Anderson, Ryan Buchter will be the only lefty to counter lefties Didi Gregorius and Brett Gardner.
One game certainly won’t settle this philosophical clash, but it will be fascinating to see how the choices of Severino and Hendriks play out in the crucible of October baseball. The Rays’ innovation earlier this year led the A’s to go this route, and who knows where this could lead if Oakland has success on the game’s biggest stage.
Brooklyn-based Jay Jaffe is a senior writer for FanGraphs, the author of The Cooperstown Casebook (Thomas Dunne Books, 2017) and the creator of the JAWS (Jaffe WAR Score) metric for Hall of Fame analysis. He founded the Futility Infielder website (2001), was a columnist for Baseball Prospectus (2005-2012) and a contributing writer for Sports Illustrated (2012-2018). He has been a recurring guest on MLB Network and a member of the BBWAA since 2011. Follow him on Twitter @jay_jaffe.