There’s Already a Book on Shohei Ohtani
I imagine we’ll be accused of writing clickbait. I imagine many websites will face the same accusation. And, sure, there’s probably plenty of bad Shohei Ohtani coverage out there. But, already, this is something special. Readers have possessed a voracious enthusiasm for consuming Ohtani articles. Writers have possessed a voracious enthusiasm for composing Ohtani articles. This is something that none of us have ever seen, and, if anything, Shohei Ohtani has exceeded the hype. Of course it’s still embarrassingly early. But, this is the best thing going. There is so much for us to see, and so much for us to learn.
There’s an argument that early analysis misses the point. That Ohtani is easy to appreciate, and perhaps best appreciated, with the eyes. He hits harder than almost anyone. He pitches harder than almost anyone. He’s playing his first-ever meaningful MLB games, and he’s arguably the greatest baseball talent Japan has ever had to offer. To this point, he’s been absolutely dominant on both sides, which is something long considered impossible. Ohtani shouldn’t be able to be this good. Players aren’t supposed to actually meet the runaway hype. Was Ohtani hyped…too…little? If you want to just let his beginning wash over you, I completely understand. In many ways this is bigger than regular baseball.
But I have a job to do. My job is to generate written baseball content, which can hopefully teach you something. If you’re interested, let me teach you something about Shohei Ohtani, the hitter. Everyone in baseball ends up with a scouting report. Ohtani, I guess, will have two of them. But, hitter Ohtani? Pitchers have already tipped their plan.
Of Ohtani’s three home runs, I’m guessing the consensus favorite is the one he hit against Corey Kluber. Less because of the pitch and swing, and more just because of the opponent. Kluber is great! Ohtani got him. Here is the home run, again. I’m sure you’ve seen it a million times.
1-and-1 pitch, up and over the plate. Clearly, a pitch Ohtani found drivable. Here’s the pitch right before.
And here’s the target for where the first pitch was supposed to be, before Kluber missed his spot.
Ohtani faced Kluber the first time in the third inning. Here’s the target for the first pitch.
Here’s a pitch from a little later.
Like many good pitchers, Kluber was trying to work Ohtani side to side. But there was a special emphasis on going in, and that’s something other pitchers have done, as well. Even though Shohei Ohtani has hardly played, and even though Ohtani will develop over time, he’s been attacked extremely inside. More, I can say, than any other hitter. Have you ever wondered how many games it might take in the regular season before a hitter has a scouting report slapped on him? In Ohtani’s case, the answer is apparently zero.
From Baseball Savant, here is Ohtani’s very early pitch-location heat map.
For the sake of comparison, here’s the heat map for lefty Eddie Rosario, who has been approached in a more or less average way in the early going.
Ohtani has seen a lot of hard pitches, and he’s seen a lot of inside pitches. The very highest rate of inside pitches, at that. Here are the hitters with the highest early inside-pitch rate, defined as the rate of pitches over or beyond the inner half.
| Player | Inside Half% |
|---|---|
| Shohei Ohtani | 72% |
| Yasiel Puig | 63% |
| Marwin Gonzalez | 59% |
| Lonnie Chisenhall | 57% |
| Austin Barnes | 56% |
| Victor Caratini | 56% |
| Juan Lagares | 56% |
| Eric Hosmer | 56% |
| Yoan Moncada | 56% |
| Lorenzo Cain | 54% |
Ohtani’s at No. 1, and he’s there easily. This is nothing new for, say, Yasiel Puig. For him, this has already basically stabilized. For a different way to measure the same thing, I looked at average horizontal pitch location, flipped to put lefties and righties on the same side. The units here are feet, away from the center of the strike zone. The higher and more positive the number, the more inside the average pitch.
| Player | Horizontal Location |
|---|---|
| Shohei Ohtani | 0.45 |
| Yasiel Puig | 0.26 |
| Marwin Gonzalez | 0.18 |
| Eric Hosmer | 0.15 |
| Colby Rasmus | 0.11 |
| Miguel Cabrera | 0.10 |
| Lonnie Chisenhall | 0.09 |
| Austin Barnes | 0.08 |
| Michael Conforto | 0.07 |
| Lorenzo Cain | 0.06 |
The average pitch to Ohtani so far has been inside by 5.4 inches. Puig is in second, with an average location inside by 3.1 inches. As you can tell from how quickly the numbers begin to approach 0, most batters are pitched away, on average. For the league, the average location is outside by roughly 2 inches. That means, compared to the average, Ohtani has been worked more inside by nearly two-thirds of a foot. Obviously, we’re barely talking about any real amount of playing time, here, but from the beginning, Ohtani has been pitched as if he can’t do much with pitches on his hands.
This is not necessarily surprising. And to Ohtani’s credit, this, for example, was good contact, even if it just led to an out.
But the home run against Kluber was on a pitch well over the plate. So was another of the home runs. Ohtani did take Josh Tomlin deep on an inside pitch, but that was a slow, looping curveball, which isn’t exactly the same thing. The idea would appear to be that Ohtani is vulnerable to inside heat. And if you get him thinking about being jammed, that could open up something away.
Again, this isn’t a shock. For an Effectively Wild podcast some time ago, Ben Lindbergh and I spoke with Dennis Sarfate, who went to Japan and blossomed into one of the best relievers in the world. Sarfate was high on Ohtani’s bat, but did say he felt like he should be pitched inside. He highlighted that as the one weakness. And furthermore, it’s worth remembering that Ohtani isn’t just another talented rookie. Some teams invested years in scouting him, and that scouting knowledge wasn’t deleted or thrown away when Ohtani signed with the Angels. Teams have had reports on Ohtani for a while. And on Ohtani’s side, he asked teams about those reports during the posting process. He wanted to know what they thought about him. I don’t know why teams wouldn’t have been sincere. Teams would’ve said he can be pitched in, and Ohtani would’ve taken that to heart. Or something like that.
One thing that’s clear is that, reports be damned, Ohtani has been amazing. It’s not like he’s been pitched inside and as a consequence he’s batting .050. He’s homered in three straight games. Ohtani’s results don’t look like those of a guy who’s been figured out. I should also say that Ohtani would be far from the only hitter to be vulnerable to inside heat. Plenty of guys don’t like inside heat. It’s precisely how Tyler Chatwood overwhelmed Joey Votto the other week. That all being said, this is something to watch. As the hitting sample grows in size, we’ll get a fuller understanding of Ohtani’s various strengths and weaknesses. He’s already been pitched in a very particular way, and in the long run, it might even work. Just as it used to be too early to say Ohtani was a disappointment, it’s still too early to say he’s a total success. There is an unbelievable amount of baseball still on the schedule.
I can’t close without saying one more thing. Shohei Ohtani has already made his first adjustment. It took zero regular-season games for a scouting report to get around. It also took zero regular-season games for Ohtani to change his hitting style. A screenshot from early spring training:
And, from later spring training:
Ohtani already got rid of his leg kick, replacing it with more of a toe-tap. His swing is still the same swing, and he might still be long to get the barrel through the zone, but this might make Ohtani a split-second quicker to respond and get around to something inside. Ohtani might’ve already responded to the scouting report. Even in spring training, lessons were being learned, and strategies were being responded to.
Every step of the way, Shohei Ohtani is certain to fascinate. We already see him near the top of some hitting leaderboards. We already see him near the top of some pitching leaderboards. And we already see him being pitched to in a specific, extreme kind of way. Just another leaderboard for him to sit atop. I am just so happy we’re here. I am just so happy we all get to see this.
Jeff made Lookout Landing a thing, but he does not still write there about the Mariners. He does write here, sometimes about the Mariners, but usually not.








This is great Jeff, not clickbait at all
I enjoyed ThamesGraphs to begin last year. I am excited for OhtaniGraphs!
And like ThamesGraphs, they’ll go away if we stop having reason to see them. Only to be replaced by the return of TroutGraphs as he does Miketrout things.
I mean, I DID click on it instantly, but
Fantastic piece.
I noticed that his BB rate was around 5%, so either pitchers are too much in the zone or he’s not missing any of the best pitches to hit.
Was he a big OBP guy in JPN? His swing is so reminiscent of Ichiro and Matsui that it’s hard for me to envision him not always being quick to the ball.
Over his career in the NPB, he walked 119 times in 1170 PAs, so around 10%.
Thank you!
I’ll bet many of those were intentional
Three career intentional walks in NPB.
“I’m not so happy.”
~ Jerry Dipoto
I still see more disparity of ceiling and floor than probably any other big leaguer, but it’s gonna be fun no matter what. I’m on the hype train!
I wonder if he has a teammate with experience in adjusting to being pitched in certain ways…
Albert Pujols is on his team.
i don’t know if you can call it ‘a book on ohtani’ when it’s not been effective. more like a generally floating consensus or even prejudice.
fact of the matter is most batters simply suck at hitting low and away pitches more than they do against inside fastballs. it’s probably the case that this ‘book’ is aiding ohtani right now.
When I read the headline I thought, damn, publishing a book is now faster than ever.
Actually, yes.
As long as it’s an ebook, all it takes is one click.
Now, writing the book… There, your “mileage” will vary.
“I am just so happy we’re here. I am just so happy we all get to see this.”
Same dude … same.
Interesting observation on pitch location that I hadn’t heard yet, and love the tie-in to past commentary on EW. The toe tap has been mentioned elsewhere. So overall I wouldn’t call it clickbait, even though in my case it was since I specifically clicked on it because of my thirst for Ohtani-related content. But for the love of all that is succinct, could you cut the verbose, self-aggrandizing metacommentary that serves in place of a traditional introduction for each of your articles?
Yeah, I hate it when writers have personalities and senses of humor. Where’s the bullet-pointed executive summary of this article about my entertainment!!!
I would prefer a combination of zero’s and one’s
I think I saw a 2!
82 words, the first 62 of which could be considered verbose self-aggrandizing metacommentary, to ask for more succinctness. A+
If you truly believe that, pretty much any comment that doesn’t introduce new information could be considered verbose self-aggrandizing metacommentary. No one is above critique, and we can each do better.
Great read. Going to have a blast following Ohtani this season. 2018 already turning out to be a barn burner.
It seems like only a matter of time before Ohtani takes a pitch off his right hand considering how much and how far pitchers work inside on him, and his right hand being his bottom hand on the bat. I really hope it doesn’t happen, but it almost seems inevitable.
Seems like one would start off pitching him inside, even knowing nothing about his hitting, just on the theory that he has to be anxious about that.
I mean, I watched one clip of his long HR swing and said “everyone should be busting this guy with fastballs inside” in the last thread, and I think we can all agree that means it’s not exactly a deep insight that this is the easiest way to attack him. We’ll see how he adjusts when pitchers stop missing out over the plate but it doesn’t look like anyone’s executed this plan consistently against him yet. It does seem like an injury risk.
For his sake I hope he starts wearing some Bonds-like protective armor soon.
From what I’ve seen, it does look like he’s wearing a fairly protective elbow guard which also covers most of his forearm. And I may be mistaken, but it certainly looks to me like he’s been wearing a hard-shell guard over the top of his right hand batting glove (similar to what Tyler Flowers wears), to protect against a potential break of his pitching hand. So, to my eyes it looks like he’s wearing about as much as he can to protect himself, but for sure, it’ll always be tense when he gets pitched inside.
I was always under the impression that the hole in his swing would lead to him striking out way, way too much to be valuable. That he could adjust if he was given enough reps, but that he wouldn’t be given enough reps.
What I learned from this article is this:
1) Shohei Ohtani is good enough that even with the contact question, he is still is a very good hitter. He’s just oozing with talent, and he destroys mistake pitches.
2) He is adaptable enough that he is already making some fairly large adjustments. He may not need as many reps to adjust as I thought.\
Before the season started, someone (I think NEIFI Analytics) ran some comps for him in Japan and one of them came back as Joey Gallo. I thought that was probably a best case scenario for year one, but that comp looks really good right now.
And that’s just his hitting! The book of Ohtani looks like it is going to be an instant classic, a NYTimes bestseller, a Pulitzer Prize winner. Maybe there is even a movie adaptation in the works. Color me impressed.
It also doesn’t seem like they are just throwing heat. I also think they are trying to cut the fastball in on him so he gets contact for popping up.
His bat angle seems very destructive, even for a heater inside. He turns on it very quickly. What they are trying to do is get movement on the fastball so that contact is just off the barrel.
He’s going to have some great April stats. But when pitchers start to get their sliders and cut more controlled , he’s gonna have to quicken his reaction a bit. Same situation happened with Harper, who once started getting ahead of the jams, pitchers employed getting him with that above-waist fastball right off the outside corner.
And Harper has a much more compacted swing; Maybe unlike Bryce all these tactics come out in this one year, and he adjusts to all of them and really becomes dangerous. But I do foresee he’s gonna have a lot of work ahead of him based on how other hitters like him were treated.
He is exciting and this is an awesome baseball year already!!!
75% HR/FB!
GOAT!
hey everyone found this amazing video that helped my son make varsity team for pitching. Thought I would share it. https://tinyurl.com/ydc8d5xg
Although you have published a lot of evidence that appears to indicate that there’s a consensus to attack Ohtani inside, I was wondering that, due to the small sample size of different pitchers Ohtani has faced so far, is it possible that these particular collection of pitchers are more likely to work the inside corner against MOST batters, not just Ohtani? That could skew the heat map a bit if you think of it that way.
I just want Ohtani to steal 20 bases.
Couple points, he is not going to continue hitting in the 8 hole. Second, plenty of pitchers throw right and bat left. Now, they don’t all have the value of Ohtani and they certainly won’t be batting as much as him, but honestly I think it is a lot less of a concern than people are acting like it is.
His combined WAR seems to be 1, but the combined WAR page is currently missing his pitching number.