Arrieta-Cole, Objectively One of Best Playoff Matchups Ever
Individual performances tend to be magnified in the postseason, and that is especially true of pitchers. While 16-18 other players appear in the lineups and many others will have profound impacts on the outcomes of games over the next month, the starting pitcher will likely have more influence over the outcome of a single game than any other player. Everything is magnified in the playoffs from managerial decisions to clutch hits, errors, and great plays in the field, but starting pitching is perhaps most deserving of the increased scrutiny. By the end of the second inning, perhaps sometime into the third, the starting pitcher will have taken part in more plays than any position player during the entire game.
In a winner-take-all game like the Wild Card, deserving players might be pushed to the background ahead of the game in favor of the pitching, but the matchup between pitchers will likely be the difference between the team that keeps playing and the team whose season is over. For those watching the Cubs take on the Pirates, they will witness one of the very best pitching matchups the playoffs have ever seen.
In Jake Arrieta and Gerrit Cole, both teams will feature bona fide aces. Arrieta might have just had the best half-season of all time. Overall, he’s pitched 229 innings with an ERA of 1.77 and a FIP of 2.35, giving Arrieta a 45 ERA- and a 60 FIP- over the full season after league and park are taken into account. He’s in pretty rare company. Consider: since the end of World War II, these are the qualified pitchers with an ERA- below 50 and a FIP- below 65 over a full season.
| Name | Season | Team | IP | ERA | FIP | WAR | ERA- | FIP- |
| Pedro Martinez | 1999 | Red Sox | 213.1 | 2.07 | 1.39 | 11.6 | 42 | 31 |
| Roger Clemens | 1997 | Blue Jays | 264 | 2.05 | 2.25 | 10.7 | 45 | 50 |
| Pedro Martinez | 2000 | Red Sox | 217 | 1.74 | 2.17 | 9.4 | 35 | 48 |
| Ron Guidry | 1978 | Yankees | 273.2 | 1.74 | 2.19 | 9.1 | 47 | 58 |
| Dwight Gooden | 1985 | Mets | 276.2 | 1.53 | 2.13 | 8.9 | 44 | 58 |
| Bob Gibson | 1968 | Cardinals | 304.2 | 1.12 | 1.75 | 8.6 | 38 | 64 |
| Zack Greinke | 2009 | Royals | 229.1 | 2.16 | 2.33 | 8.6 | 48 | 54 |
| Pedro Martinez | 1997 | Expos | 241.1 | 1.9 | 2.39 | 8.5 | 45 | 57 |
| Roger Clemens | 1990 | Red Sox | 228.1 | 1.93 | 2.18 | 8.2 | 47 | 55 |
| Greg Maddux | 1995 | Braves | 209.2 | 1.63 | 2.26 | 7.9 | 39 | 52 |
| Greg Maddux | 1994 | Braves | 202 | 1.56 | 2.39 | 7.4 | 37 | 54 |
| Pedro Martinez | 2003 | Red Sox | 186.2 | 2.22 | 2.21 | 7.4 | 48 | 51 |
| Jake Arrieta | 2015 | Cubs | 229 | 1.77 | 2.35 | 7.3 | 45 | 60 |
| Pedro Martinez | 2002 | Red Sox | 199.1 | 2.26 | 2.24 | 7.3 | 50 | 54 |
| Randy Johnson | 1997 | Mariners | 213 | 2.28 | 2.82 | 7 | 50 | 62 |
The only pitcher with better context neutral numbers in both ERA and FIP and more innings was Dwight Gooden in his amazing 1985 season. It is easy to see why so much attention has been given to Jake Arrieta this season and in this matchup, but the Pittsburgh Pirates’s Gerrit Cole has had an excellent season of his own. Cole’s 5.4 WAR is fifth in the National and ninth in Major League Baseball. Pitchers don’t choose their opposition, leaving great matchups more to a question of chance than a complete reflection of their own skill, but the high level of both players heading into this game is something rarely seen in a game of this magnitude.
A one-game playoff has been an incredibly rare event in MLB history. The advent of the Wild Card has created generally more playoff teams and more possibilities for ties at the end of the regular season, and the introduction of the Wild Card Playoff Game in 2012 has guaranteed a one-game playoff in each league every year. The games this season will be the 18th and 19th winner-take-all one-game playoffs in baseball history, the first having taken place in 1948 and the second not occurring until the New York Yankees played the Boston Red Sox after the 1978 season. Many remember the 1951 game between the Dodgers and Giants and Bobby Thomson’s home run, but that game was actually the final game of a three-game series, which the National League used for the last time in 1962, again while featuring the Dodgers and Giants.
While quantifying which pitching matchup among these games is a very difficult task, the simplest solution is perhaps to look at single-season WAR as a measure of how well the two pitchers were doing during the year. Very good pitchers who were injured for much of the year, like Johnny Cueto in 2013, will not fare well this way, but overall this seems to be a reasonable method. If we take only the average of the two pitchers, we come up with the following the chart.
| Year | Event | Matchup | Player | WAR | Player | WAR | Winner | AVG WAR |
| 1995 | Tie-breaker | Angels v Mariners | Mark Langston | 4.1 | Randy Johnson | 9.5 | Mariners | 6.8 |
| 2015 | NLWC | Cubs v Pirates | Jake Arrieta | 7.3 | Gerrit Cole | 5.4 | 6.4 | |
| 1978 | Tie-breaker | Yankees v Red Sox | Ron Guidry | 9.1 | Mike Torrez | 3.3 | Yankees | 6.2 |
| 2014 | ALWC | A’s v Royals | Jon Lester | 5.5 | James Shields | 3.3 | Royals | 4.4 |
| 2015 | ALWC | Astros v Yankees | Dallas Keuchel | 6.1 | Masahiro Tanaka | 2.2 | 4.2 |
While taking the average seems like a good idea, we have several games with great disparities between the two starters. Randy Johnson and Mark Langston carry the top spot due principally to Johnson’s 9.5 WAR in 1995. As a result, like Dan Szymborski did in his piece on the greatest one-two rotation punch in history, I took the geometric mean ((WAR1*WAR2)^.5) to lessen the influence of one truly great pitcher. Switching to the geometric mean pushes Arrieta/Cole over the top. Below is a complete graph of the top one-game playoff matchups.
While the Arrieta/Cole matchup is clearly impressive and historic, teams playing in a one-game playoff generally had to fight just to get to the playoff. Otherwise, they would not have ended in a tie to begin with, and this ends up with teams unable to set their best starters in these games. Expanding the field a bit can provide this duo more competition.
Adding all winner-take-all games — Game 7s in the World Series, Game 5s in the Division Series, etc. — we can compare this matchup to every game in which both teams were confined to a win-or-go-home scenario. Including the two games about to be played, there are 108 pitching matchups to examine. Using the geometric mean once again, we come up with the following table featuring the top-10 such games.
| Year | Event | Matchup | Player | WAR | Player | WAR | Winner | AVG | GEOMEAN |
| 2001 | NLDS | Cardinals v Dbacks | Matt Morris | 6.1 | Curt Schilling | 7.2 | Dbacks | 6.7 | 6.6 |
| 1965 | World Series | Dodgers v Twins | Sandy Koufax | 10 | Jim Kaat | 4.3 | Dodgers | 7.2 | 6.6 |
| 2001 | World Series | Yankees v Dbacks | Roger Clemens | 5.6 | Curt Schilling | 7.2 | Dbacks | 6.4 | 6.3 |
| 2011 | NLDS | Cardinals v Phillies | Chris Carpenter | 4.8 | Roy Halladay | 8.3 | Cardinals | 6.6 | 6.3 |
| 1985 | World Series | Cardinals v Royals | John Tudor | 6.4 | Bret Saberhagen | 6.2 | Royals | 6.3 | 6.3 |
| 2015 | NLWC | Cubs v Pirates | Jake Arrieta | 7.3 | Gerrit Cole | 5.4 | 6.4 | 6.3 | |
| 1995 | Tie-breaker | Angels v Mariners | Mark Langston | 4.1 | Randy Johnson | 9.5 | Mariners | 6.8 | 6.2 |
| 2003 | ALCS | Red Sox v Yankees | Pedro Martinez | 7.4 | Roger Clemens | 4.5 | Yankees | 6.0 | 5.8 |
| 2003 | ALDS | Red Sox v A’s | Pedro Martinez | 7.4 | Barry Zito | 4.4 | Red Sox | 5.9 | 5.7 |
| 2001 | ALDS | A’s v Yankees | Mark Mulder | 5.7 | Roger Clemens | 5.6 | Yankees | 5.7 | 5.6 |
And that same thing, in graphic form:
Matt Morris facing off against Curt Schilling is a surprising result mainly due to Morris’ presence, but Morris was once one of the better pitchers in the game. After a nearly five-win rookie season in 1997, Morris suffered shoulder and elbow injuries, missing 1999 and much of 2000 due to recovery from Tommy John surgery. Morris came back strong in 2000 and 2001 before diminished velocity turned him into an innings-eater for the remainder of his career. In the Diamondbacks-Cardinals series in 2001, Morris went toe-to-toe with Schilling in Game 1 of the series, losing 1-0. The Cardinals almost ended the Diamondbacks’ dream playoff run before it could get started as Morris and Schilling again dueled, this time in Game 5 for the series win. Morris and Schilling each gave up one run on solo home runs, but the Diamondbacks scored in the bottom of the ninth off the Cardinals bullpen for the walkoff win.
The Arrieta-Cole matchup still sits comfortably in the top ten of dueling aces in winner-take-all games. Arrieta does have the edge in the matchup between the two pitchers, but the team with the better pitcher does not always win. In the 75 games in which one pitcher had at least a one-win WAR advantage, the better pitcher’s team posted a 44-31 record. It is probably a little unfair that a 97-win team and a 98-win team have to face off in a one-game playoff just to make the Division Series, but it has produced one of the greatest pitching matchups of all time.
Craig Edwards can be found on twitter @craigjedwards.




The difference is that Geritt Cole has playoff experience. Jake Arietta may very well pull a Johnny Cueto on Wednesday night. Great season and dreadful wildcard performance. Remember Clayton Kershaw didn’t look so hot in the playoffs after a great season and people were shocked when that happened. Don’t count the Pirates out. Pittsburgh is counting on World Series baby! And there’s no logic to this post. It’s one game. Statistics & logic are out the window. It’s mostly about who keeps a cooler head. Ask Terry Bradshaw, an average quarterback who kept his cool during the playoffs and has 4 Super Bowl rings to show for it!
or maybe Arrieta is about to be discovered as the greatest postseason player ever. What’s even the point of having this debate
The “point” is some people need to make themselves feel better, when they KNOW they don’t even DESERVE to be playing this game at home.
How do the Pirates not deserve to be playing it at home? They have the second best record in all of baseball. What are you talking about?
I get being irrational as a fan while watching the games but it’s pretty easy to be objective now. The Cubs are a really good team, the Pirates are a really good team. Arrieta and Cole are incredible pitchers and if one pitches poorly it won’t be because they “choked” or aren’t “clutch” it will be because of baseball.
http://www.fangraphs.com/depthcharts.aspx?position=BaseRuns
This is a site for statistics. Do some research next time.
Yes this is a site for statistics, not insane rambling filled with bias. By Baseruns the Cubs are the 4th best team in baseball and the Pirates are 5th. By record 3rd and 2nd, in what way are these teams not pretty damn close to evenly matched?
You really are a dolt. Even if you use baseruns THE PIRATES WOULD STILL BE HOSTING THE WILD CARD GAME
Umm, why would the Pirates not deserve to have the home game?
There is no possible way that RynoDawson is anything other than a parody account, right? I mean that honestly. No one is that dumb. In fact I feel dumb for thinking for a moment he was real.
Jason:
My original point was that the statistics are regular season statistics. The playoffs are fundamentally different than the regular season. If you ever played the game you would know that. It’s like comparing apples and oranges to use regular season stats in the postseason. I realize that the teams do because they don’t have a large enough sample size of postseason stats for most players. But I was making the point that you can’t draw some conclusions using regular season stats when predicting postseason games. There is the playoff fever factor. Some players traditionally do very well in the playoffs like Reggie Jackson and others don’t like Dave Winfield. No explanation for it. It’s a very real thing. Barry Bonds was great in the regular season, but predictably poor performance in the playoffs. AJ Burnett for the Pirates / Marlin / Yankees… Great in the regular season… Wouldn’t trust him in the playoffs again. Ever. I’m sure others see what I’m saying. Certain players for lack of a better word choke. Other seem to take advantage of others under performance due to pressure.
Strictly speaking, I’m not discussing statistics, but the fact that the regular season statistics are not valid in the postseason due to the additional stress on the players affecting their ability to perform at their normal statistical level.
If you don’t understand what I’m saying, I can rephrase that. But please don’t say that I’m ignorant or trolling because you don’t have the capacity to fathom it.
Willy,
When you state the following:
_____
“… I was making the point that you can’t draw some conclusions using regular season stats when predicting postseason games….
_____
you are fundamentally incorrect. First, conclusions can always be drawn. They may or may not be logical. They may or may not accurate and/ or precise. They, however, can always be drawn. Further, regular season stats do have some predictive power over postseason outcomes. Heck, there is a prime example mentioned in Craig’s article alone —
_____
In the 75 games in which one pitcher had at least a one-win WAR advantage, the better pitcher’s team posted a 44-31 record.
_____
There’s a pretty easy conclusion to draw from that — the team with a clearly better pitcher will have a clearly higher chance of winning. Are there other, numerous factors at play? Of course there are. Is it a guarantee that the team with the better pitcher will win? Of course not. It didn’t stop me from drawing a very rational, very logical conclusion, however.
Now, if you really, really wish to push and assert that there must be some extra Playoff-Clutch skill, find a way to legitimately examine it or find someone else who has. The anecdotal examples you bring up of Reggie Jackson vs. Dave Winfield aren’t comparable because Jackson was a clearly superior player to Winfield during the regular season. You’re talking about a prime 5-7 Win player vs. a prime 3-5 Win player. Even isolating out their respective Yankee-only careers, Jackson was clearly superior (he was 3.5-5 W player vs. Winfield’s 2.5-4 W player). My conclusion, therefore, would be to expect Reggie Jackson to be superior to Winfield. And none of this is even into the fact that two OF of overlapping eras don’t compare to SP matchups in the slightest.
If, however, you still wish to choose to believe in those anecdotal examples and want to assert that they mean something, support it. Case studies (à la Jackson vs. Winfield and Kershaw’s 2014) can be interesting, but in the scientific community, they are not even hypothetical. In the statistical world, they have to be done with extreme care and, even then, are likely to be without significant sample size to be considered useful.
Obviously I’m a Pittsburgh Pirates fan because I did sports medicine in Pittsburgh, and currently live in Charleston WV home of the West Virginia Power – PIRATES single A full season team. I know a few of their players and they have a lot of talent here. But that doesn’t mean that I’m not right in my arguments that they have a strong team, and statistically playing at home is a big advantage for them. Read all of my posts and you will see what I mean.
Obviously I stayed at a Holiday Inn last night. And my mom knows someone who met the ruler of Jordan in 1988. And I have many leatherbound books. I’m SMRT, bruh…
And I work for the team. Doing mostly biomechanical analysis. Similar to what Jim Benedict does for the pitching staff I do for milb infielders. So yeah, I’m pretty smart. And cole Tucker’s injury was not my fault
Do you also drive a Dodge Stratus?
The difference between Cueto and Arrieta is that Cueto was pitching with an injury in the 2013 WC game.
An injury that caused him to drop the baseball? And gave up a home run on the very next pitch? Quite a coincidence there!
No but the injury likely played a large part in him pitching poorly. He’s pretty much completely dominated Pittsburgh in every other start of his career.
Is there some kind of running contest for who can make the least appropriate comment on this website, or is all sports discussion everywhere just that deeply and ineradicably contaminated by irrationalism?
The very nature of sports fandom is irrational, is it not? I wouldn’t expect too much.
On this American Life some years ago, they were featuring this 24 hour coffee shop in Chicago. One of the more violent incidents in the recent past of that coffee shop was when a Cubs fan smashed a mug on the face of a White Sox fan.
http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/172/24-Hours-at-the-Golden-Apple
All this comment from Willy suggests is that Pirates fans are very very scared. Pirate fans are just trying to look for a little glimmer of hope.
The Bucs aren’t the only team with WS aspirations, considering the Cubs have been pretty great the last 3 months I would assume they also have a WS or bust mentality. Your post is illogical. By this logic, you should also not disregard the Cubs using this to “will themselves to a win”.
As you can see from recent history, the team with the significantly better pitcher usually wins this “winner take all” matchup. The Cubs have the better pitcher in this matchup. If I was a bucs fan, I would be very worried as well.
The Cubs also have the significant edge in the managerial department, while Clint Hurdle is not a bad manager is not in the same department as Maddon. Maddon will have this team loose and ready to play, if you learned anything from this year you would notice experience hasnt meant a thing. The Cubs were not suppose to have 97 wins because they were starting nothing but rookies with zero experience. The Cubs rookies have played well beyond their years this whole year.
It seems like Buc fans are doing nothing more than poking the bear and giving more for Arrieta to feed off of. I suggest sitting tight as Cubs fans will do, and cross your fingers you are even allowed a hit off Arrieta.
No all Willy’s comment suggests is that Willy is crazy.
“As you can see from recent history, the team with the significantly better pitcher usually wins this “winner take all” matchup”
Good thing neither team has a significantly better pitcher.
But one does right now, Arrieta is head of heels better than Cole at this point in time. All numbers will point to that, considering he put up historic numbers this second half…
No he isn’t. He had a significantly better second half than Cole, but that is neither predictive of his next start nor does it mean he is a significantly better pitcher than Cole. Remember Kris Medlen in 2012? How’d the Wild Card Game go for him?
Arrieta is pitching great right now, and I concur that he gives the Cubs the edge. But is he “significantly” better than Cole?
Let’s do some extremely dirty back-of-the-envelope calculations. If Cole pitches to his season averages (again, I know this leaves a ton out, but we’re just trying to get a rough sketch here), he’ll pitch 6.5 innings and give up 2.2 runs. Arrieta will pitch 6.9 innings and give up 1.6 runs. i.e., Arrieta will give up about 0.4 fewer runs and get one or two extra outs. Over the course of one game that’s not even close to significant. (It’s like being in the 7th or 8th inning of a game that’s 2-1 or 3-2 Cubs.)
Of course, this thought experiment points up just how silly it is to lean on their average numbers. Over the course of 9 innings, variance swamps every meaningful distinction between these two guys. Again, I would bet on Arrieta – he gives them better odds going on for sure. But played out in actual time time no one can be so sure.
To add some color to your post, Brian: being up 2-1 in the 7th as an away team puts you somewhere near 70% game odds, 3-2 in the 8th 75%. That’s pretty good!
Another way of looking at it: the difference between Arrieta and Cole by fWAR is the same as the difference between Cole and Kyle Hendricks by fWAR. Arrieta’s got one more GS, so some other numbers: difference between Arrieta and Cole by RA9-WAR is same as between Cole and John Danks; FIP as between Cole and Tyson Ross; xFIP as between Cole and J.A. Happ; SIERA as between Cole and Rick Porcello. If it were Cole opposing nearly any of those pitchers, I’d think we’d say that’s “significantly” better, even if variance could well swamp a Porcello v. Cole matchup.
Kris Brown struck out with men on base multiple times on Saturday. In a game they needed to win. That was a pressure situation. Against Milwaukee. They scored 1 run against Milwaukee on Sat. and had trouble on Sunday also. Doesn’t sound so loose to me.
Of course the PIRATES are respectful of the Cubs. They lost the season series to them. They’ve had trouble hitting this SP all year. But if Cole has a good game or if the Cubs rookies show their youthful inexperience, the previous statistics don’t mean anything.
I have an MD from one of the best medical schools in the country and an mph in conjunction with public health residency. I also did sports medicine at the University of Pittsburgh. So don’t talk about me like I’m some idiot for not spouting stat after stat when talking about this game. Stats over a large sample (season) mean nothing when looking at a single game. A person that has .320 BA can go 0 for 5. And a SP can hit 2 home runs.
What is Joe Madden’s track record in the playoffs with the Cubs? Unknown. Hurdle. Beat Cincinnati in wild card game. Lost to Bumgardner. Came close to beating Cardinals in divisional series. WON THE WORLD SERIES with Rockies. People forget about that one. So to say the Joe Maddon is a better playoff coach than Clint Hurdle seems somewhat strange to me.
What I do know is the Pirates team is pretty much designed for PNC Park. Extremely fast outfielders for the large dimensions of the outfield. Ground ball pitchers to take advantage of their extensive shifting of infielders. Fast outfielders to allow for outfield shifting also, more than any other MLB team. And the large dimensions of the field work against the Cubs home run hitting position players. A cold night, results in heavy air, keeping more balls in the park.
Best bullpen in baseball. Rested starting pitchers. Cole was skipped a start. Was Arrieta? No. Score one for Hurdle over Madden in my book.
Now the kid in me wants to say that Andrew McCutchen will become the next Steve Garvey in Chicago Cubs fans memory… but the adult in me says don’t do it. Well I guess it’s too late. Actually it’s much more likely to be our catcher. Why do I say that? He’s a likeable guy. Umpires like him. He’s a great “pitch framer” . He walks a lot so Arrieta will have to bring the ball into the strike zone for once.
The Pirates don’t do it often, but they’re capable of working the pitch count against great pictures. Look at Jose Tabata against Max Scherzer at the end of his NEAR perfect game. 10 or 12 pitches before mad max screwed up and hit Jose with a pitch. Ouch. (Nuff said! 🙂
I didn’t mean working the pitch count. I meant making the pitcher throw a lot of pictures. Trying to get Ariana out of the game by the 5th inning by getting him over 100 pitches. I believe that will be their strategy. Just foul off a ton of pitches. They are capable of doing that. They like to walk, but can’t do that against Arietta because he gets calls on the edges. He’s too dang accurate. So they need to basically swing at everything… treating it like batting practice, hoping to get a piece of it. Without swinging at stuff three feet in front of the plate. I really believe that will be PIRATES strategy Wednesday night.
We are allowed to talk strategy without numbers, right? Or do I have to say that SP on average don’t throw more than 100 pitches on average anymore. End of the Pirates leave the majors in runs scored after the 7th inning and have the best seven eight and nine relievers in baseball. FanGraphs put up a chart yesterday showing that mark melancon, Tony Watson, and Joaquin Soria had the most successful appearances with the least meltdowns in baseball. 75 saves among them, including Soria’s from the Al prior to his trade.
So yeah, the Pirates have a chance in this game. A very good chance. A very good coach. A decent RESTED EXPERIENCED starting pitcher. A great 7th 8th and 9th BP. And a manager with a World Series title. That’s all I’m going to say.
So continue to make fun of me.
You have to be a troll right? Maybe I’ll look the fool for even bothering to respond to your post that is just littered with inaccuracies but I’m bored at work so why not
First off, who is Kris Brown?
Cubs have won 8 in a row, I think that makes up for only winning one game 1-0.
Cole being skipped a start is an advantage? I don’t see how taking a player out of their regular schedule is smarter. Arrieta has pitched every 5 days like always but they’ve run back his pitch count to keep him fresh. I’d consider that smart managing.
Also, Hurdle gets credit for his managing in Colorado and Maddon doesn’t get any for his time in Tampa? Not really fair to judge Maddon’s playoff success in Chicago when this is his first season and really management will probably have very little to do with the outcome of the game.
Arrieta has a very low walk rate so I think he throws in the zone fairly often.
The Cubs work the count just about better than every team in baseball.
Having a medical degree (if you in fact have one) doesn’t mean you have any logic or objectivity when it comes to baseball, quite obviously.
Not trying to disagree with you like you’re an idiot, but Clint Hurdle’s Rockies didn’t win a World Series. They got swept by the Red Sox in 2007.
I am currently disabled from my service in the US Army Medical Corps so I rely upon voice recognition, Google, to type. Occasionally it auto corrects things like Kris Bryant to Chris Brown. I apologize for that. Apparently Chris Brown is more popular than Kris Bryant. Even when I correct it, it corrects it back.
I have read just about everything I can on baseball statistics over the past couple years, and have been involved in baseball for the past 25 years. Extensive sports medicine training. If you want to know why there are so many elbow ulnar collateral ligament reconstructions, aka Tommy John surgeries… I can tell you.
But I do know PIRATES baseball. I do understand much of why they do what they do. And their reasoning makes sense. They have had success with it for 5 years now. And they haven’t gotten lucky in the draft like Chicago. Or hired extremely talented scouts. However you want to say it. The talent they have, they can’t afford to keep. Cole will be gone in a few years
“Having a medical degree (if you in fact have one) doesn’t mean you have any logic or objectivity when it comes to baseball, quite obviously.”
I beg to differ.
Thanks rich. I didn’t watch the World Series in 2008. Had surgery in the fall of that year. And with rehab, I had a lot on my mind.
But even getting to the WS says something. Sometimes you learn more from losing than winning…(did that sound convincing?)
@Willy… tl:dr
You are welcome to disagree Ben but I think there are plenty of very smart people who are irrational about many things, particularly when they have a rooting interest.
I would agree to disagree.
What has Joe Maddon ever done to be considered a great manager?
I am dying to know…
He had the best team in baseball two years in a row when he was with the Rays; surely, the best manager in the game, with a significant edge over Hurdle must have at least one ring… right?
“It seems like Buc fans are doing nothing more than poking the bear and giving more for Arrieta to feed off of. I suggest sitting tight as Cubs fans will do, and cross your fingers you are even allowed a hit off Arrieta.”
I’m sure Jake is reading fangraphs at this moment with his coach standing behind him yelling “use it Jake, use it!”
“Statistics don’t apply to individual events, just to individual events in groups.”
If you want to, check out the following article. It’s pretty cool and the author has some of the same thoughts that I have. And remember this guy gets paid to express his opinions and has the time to cite his sources.
http://grantland.com/the-triangle/mlb-playoff-myths-to-ignore/
I completely forgot that Matt Morris was once a very good pitcher. The only thing I remember about him is that Dave Littlefield traded for him.
HAHAHAHA Thanks again Orioles
Jake “Cy Young” Arrieta is the MAN. Sorry Cole.
The Pirates are like the Lucknals but without all the bs playoff stuff. There lucky to finish ahead of the Cubs in the “standings”, but guess what. 98 wins means you lose to the base runs champ on your home field! LOL
Bring on the Lucknals
I’m a Cubs fan but Lucknals might be the least creative thing I’ve ever heard.
Seriously, shouldn’t you go with “Luckinals” anyway?
I’m a Cardinals fan who has watched the horrible music videos and Lucknals IS the least creative thing I’ve heard
Not a single good point made in this garbage, well done. What a zero point zero you are.
How we long to be 0.0 (WAR) this year… =/
By the tone of that you would have thought that the Cubs had made at least one playoff appearance in the last 6 years.
Or won a world series in the last 106 years.
I think you meant to post on ESPN rather than here. I’m sure you’re just lost. It’s okay. It happens.
2015 BASE RUNS CHAMPS! WOOOOOOOOO!!!!
You mean the dodgers right? Because that is who led the National League. Or perhaps you mean the blue Jays. Placing 2nd in baseruns doesn’t make you the champions of anything lol. Look I think somebody has to re-read the significance of baseruns even Fangraphs doesn’t think the winners should be based solely on baseruns. Its the events with the sequencing stripped which still matters its just not predictive year to year. Get your facts straight please. Thus why guys like Tango are arguing for inserting context and sequence in awards and such. The Wins are what count. Cards will have to do some retooling next year because all of these teams are strong. Base Runs is a good estimate for how they would perform context removed but as has been written before this year has been very wonky. Plus it fluctuates just a few days ago the Pirates and the Cards were behind them by 2 wins by baseruns.
As a Cardinals fan, I would like to point out that I recently went to the Cards-Cubs game at Wrigley (a joke wedding present from my Cub fan uncle).
I was expecting cub fans just to be off the wall annoying and obnoxious about this year and their impending world domination for the next decade.
What I got was the complete opposite. Of course fans were teasing me when Soler and Bryant went back-to-back, but by and large very respectful of what the Cardinals have accomplished over the last 16 years (or 80 years), while enjoying their own good season and they were excited about a once in a lifetime playoff series Cards vs. Cubs.
————————————-
On the way out I overheard a cub dad teaching his son to give a cardinals fan (me) the “stink eye”. So, I stared down that little punk for a bit. He sarcastically apologized for the Cubs ruining my day and I sarcastically congratulated him on 3rd place … and we shook hands are parted enemies for life with mutual disdain. 😉
————————————-
Anyway, my point is … the real jag bag cub fans seem to just be on the internet … which either means its a safe place to get stupid or they’re just trolls. Who has that kind of time?
Thank you for that comment! As a Cards fan I get embarrassed when other Cards fans gloat about “11 rings” or taunt Cubs fans with 1908 and all that crap. I mean, yeah, it’s kinda cool for me that the Cards have won a lot of championships, but I was only around for 3 of them, and I had a bearing on the outcome of exactly zero of them. So gloating of any kind just strikes me as nonsense. But good-natured ribbing – like the stink eye you exchanged with that kid – that I can get behind.
I agree completely concerning all fanbases. I am a Cubs fan that went to a Cards-Padres game a couple of years ago at Busch. My son and his friend wore their Cubs jerseys to the game. Everything was great until the end of the game, when an obviously drunk Cardinal fan yelled at my son “F… Soriano and F… the Cubs”. Immediately, there were numerous Cardinal fans that stepped in and apologized for him. Just goes to show that all fan bases are 95% cool … it is the 5% that really give them a bad name. Good luck to all the other NL Central teams.
Not to go even FURTHER off topic but as a Bosox fan with my Troy O’Leary and Valentin jerseys to prove I rooted before they stopped choking, I dont gloat a single bit we’ve won 3 in 9 years now. Despite all the trash I took from Yankee fans…..On the topic though, This reminds me a tiny bit of Lester going into the wildcard game hot (obv not nearly as hot as Arrieta)
Point is Cole is no kid anymore and Arrieta is just this year experiencing his first full year of dominance and it’s like we’ve anointed him Clayton/Pedro and their sustained excellence over 7,8 years. I have an inkling The Pirates will get to Jake and the Cubbies will get to Gerritt. I don’t think this game will come down to Arrieta throwing a one hit shutout with 17 k’s..
Thank you goOppo. You understand what I’m saying. And I do respect the Cardinals and Cubs. They have a very good team. And the Cubs will no doubt win a World Series or two if they can keep their team together. That is a lot of talent. Cardinals are incredible. Pittsburgh has 3 starting pitchers coming up from Triple A that will be extremely good. The next few years will be very fun. And the Brewers look talented. And the Reds did not just give away their players… they appear to have gotten value for them. This division is going to be a nightmare for a few years to come. In a good way. It’s going to take 95 games to win
Well, I’ll agree with you that the Pirates have more coming but you and I both know they won’t be able to keep the talent like the Cubs will. I think If the bucs have some extended success this year people like polanco, cole, marte, maybe that shutdown relief core will stick around with some short term deals. The Royals did get some people to make commitments to the team. With the talent the Cubs and Pirates have coming up, and their coaching staffs and fanbases…I am actually rooting for one of the two
Of course somehow the Cardinals will be good it’s like taxes. But it’s great to see the real deal come out of those two cities. The Cubs are set, with epstein at the helm. Hopefully the bucs can keep a couple of those core players esp Marte and Polanco. Bc the pirates and Cubs IMO deserve to have a series after their respective years. Too much talent saturation
And I work for the team. Doing mostly biomechanical analysis. Similar to what Jim Benedict does for the pitching staff I do for milb infielders. So yeah, I’m pretty smart. And cole Tucker’s injury was not my fault.
Stick around Chicago buddy – the jag off Cub fans are everywhere. Most arrogant and unbearable fanbase in the city, and there isn’t a close second.
The Cubs already have 8 HOF’ers on the field, the best pitcher the world has ever seen, the greatest manager in the history of baseball and the BEST FANS IN THE WORLD!!!!!!! Because after all you must be a great fan to deal with 100 years of losing without giving up…. right? Or you’re just an idiot who demands no accountability from your team and enjoy rooting for failures.
HAHAHA Thanks again or
Jake Arrieta “Jersey” me. Sorry, Aug.
Pirates as Lucknals, but without all the BS playoffs. He was happy to win Panda “in”, but you know. 98 wins to meet the basic operations you Champ Tribunal. laughter
set Lucknals
Ryno,
I’m a Cubs fan, and reading your comments on this page is borderline nauseating.
The only thing this comments section has proved is that RynoDawson is a dolt.
WTF is going on here??? I honestly can’t tell if all these comments are sarcastic, or if the “new readers” have all congregated here. The collective IQ of commenters has really fallen since the mouthbreathers have started showing up here.
All I want for Christmas 2015 is a moderated-for-sanity FanGraphs discussion community.
(me too…spoofing these trolls is like shooting dead fish in a barrel)
If you knew how many dead fish in a barrel I’d shot in my career, you wouldn’t have the audacity to speak to me like that!
What exactly would be the intelligent conversation to have regarding this article. It talks about one very controversial statistic, Wins Above Replacement, about two players, who are pitching in one game AND very likely will not be the only pitchers in that game.
Should we talk about how controversial the WAR statistic is and how most intelligent baseball people disregard it entirely? Especially with regards to starting pitching. I mean in the real world, not in online hobby chat rooms. Or should we talk about how comparing only two players who won’t even play the entire game is not a good way to predict the outcome of the game? But everyone should agree on that so there’s no real controversy there. So this article doesn’t lend itself to any type of intelligent discussion. So why don’t you start an intelligent discussion based upon this article. This so called troll can’t think of one.
Craig, I did not need any extra reason to be hyped for this game. I’m so genuinely excited for what’s bound to be a phenomenal game; I can’t wait!
Once again, in unison:
Jesus Christ, Pedro Martinez.
And not necessarily in that order.
Pedro Martinez!! I never get tired of seeing his name at the top of all of these lists. We got to see him play. That will be special forever.
Well, unless you were an Expos fan. Then it is decidedly less special and more just painfull.
*single tear*
It’s like a pitcher going 27 and 2 with a .5 whip and 1.00 era. These are just random numbers I’m throwing out. Just that he was that dominant in the AL ,in that division, in that Era. I will never forget the 97 with sizzle on the end, the parachute changeup, or the uncle Charlie that seemed like a cruel joke. What Pedro did IMO from 96 through 2003 trumps Kershaw or Clemens Cy Youngs.
In fact if Kershaw wins the nl mvp last year, like Verlander did, How did Pedro lose out to Pudge with a 10.6 WAR being the singular most dominant pitcher by leaps and bounds.
I think you meant to put an = in place of the , after the word “Christ.”
<*
TIL Matt Morris had a 6.1 WAR in 2001.
On Fangraphs, greater hype may be correlated with dumber comments.
Please read my second post and we will see I am neither crazy or dumb. I’m a highly educated professional and understand statistics probably as well as anyone working in a baseball sabermetrics position. Not to say I understand sabermetrics, I understand Public Health Statistics. But I do understand stats not too say I understand Sabra metrics, I understand public Health statistics. But I do understand stats professionally
Oh bless you. You’re trying so hard.
If you had any idea what I had accomplished in my career, you would not have the audacity to speak to me like that.
I performed surgery with Hank Baunson and Thomas Starzal. I did research with David Gellar. My career was sidetracked when I was injured protecting your condescending blank serving in the US Army Medical Corps. So for anyone to question my intelligence because I have difficulty now secondary to a traumatic brain injury makes me want to explode. Think before you talk in such a condescending manner. People have feelings.
Seriously.
I’m getting really into advanced Sabra metrics, like Chickpea Density Above Replacement Hummus
If you “understand statistics probably as well as anyone working in a baseball sabermetrics position” wouldn’t that include using caution about reading too much into small sample sizes?
Not when it HELPS my argument. I guess I’m being more of a fan today because of the 35 year World Series drought. I obviously know that. MD University of Pittsburgh mph WVU
He’s using a talk text app….His grammar mistakes that are being pointed out are just making the rest of you look like the people that laugh at kids with a stutter
It’s not the speaking/typing/software translation mistakes that people are annoyed with. It is the fact that:
1. He is likely trolling.
2. He thinks intelligence is proven by having a medical degree.
3. He is ignoring the research that has been done on “Clutch”.
4. He keeps repeating what he did in the past, over and over.
By the way, it is rude to have an at length discussion without correcting your app’s typing mistakes. IPhones should be used for glancing at things quickly, not holding at length online discussions. Turn off the spell check, and use your degree.
Objectively, the Cubs are the best team in the NL playoffs. That’s what we know for sure when we strip out luck. Now, Arrieta is he best pitcher on the best team. Can the Pirates compete? I don’t think so, but I will give them that they earned more of their wins than the Cardinals, who got mostly by luck. Now, anything can happen in one game and the playoffs are a crapshoot, so the Cubs need to be proud regardless of playoff outcomes that they are the best and proved that during the regular season via BaseRuns, wins, etc. Now the only team that can compare is the Blue Jays. Those teams SHOULD play in the World Series. Any other outcome is a result of luck.
PREACH
Cubs win the NL, any other outcome is a fluke
WOOOOO 2015 BASE RUNS CHAMPS! THERE ARE NO COMPONENTS TO LUCK OTHER THAN SEQUENCING; A RASH OF INJURIES IS NOT BAD LUCK SO SHUT UP LUCKNALS!
BASE RUUUUNS!
If only champs were identified by their base run totals. But they are not. Another metric has the honors: Win totals.
I don’t expect baserun totals used to determine game winners, division winners and WS winners any time soon.
“Another metric has the honors: Win totals.”
Well…kinda. Specifically, world series win totals. We have many historical examples of season wins leaders not hoisting the trophy.
They keep bringing up baseruns saying it proves they’re the NL champs…if they can’t beat the “luckinals” or bucs doesn’t thag at least make them at best the 3rd best? bc ya know the whole winning the nlcs usually determines who moves on
And they don’t even have the best BaseRuns record in the NL. It’s weird.
Dude?
Okay, so at this point you (the reader) have read some comments. Enough comments to make some conclusions. Yes, there are indeed some very dumb Cubs fans. They exist, with more and more of them by the hour. But keep in mind -remember- there are also those fans of the organization who have been beaten humble by years and years of relentless losing. We know we’re not special when it comes to this years playoffs, so we pray to the baseball gods. Let me feel what it’s like to feel.
Pray for us.
Jason:
Pittsburgh won 8 in a row in late Sept also,off quality team including Kershaw, Greinke LA & two from Chicago Cubs.
CHI beat up who? Milwaukee? CIN?
My comment about the 8 game winning streak was just in counter to you saying that they didn’t seem very loose because they were in a couple close games. I’ve maintained that both teams are very good and anyone who says one team is clearly better or definitely going to win just sounds foolish. I will be cheering and swearing irrationally at my TV tomorrow while rooting for the Cubs but I can still be objective in talking about them now
Touche
The “dumb” Cubs’ fans would be the ones who acquiesce to the Cardinals and their history of luck. I would consider “smart” Cubs fans to be the ones who are focused on how good the team has been (and how much BETTER than Pirates and Cardinals) based on BaseRuns. Cameron and Sullivan rely on BaseRuns to analyze how good teams are. No one calls them dumb.
I don’t care about any of their histories at all right now. By almost any measure the Cubs, Pirates and Cardinals are very good teams. With the Cardinals injuries they might be in worse shape at this exact moment but they are still good. BUT if you think in a one game playoff that one of these teams has a drastically better chance at winning than the other does, then you are biased. And if you want to argue why one team is a 55% favorite over the other then go nuts but it’s basically a coin flip and should be one hell of a game. Enjoy it! There is literally no benefit to being able to say, I told you so.
I think you may actually be one of the goonimals.
That’s my point. I think it’s basically a coin flip. But the Arietta side is a little bit more likely to come up… About 55% more likely. And I’m not happy about it.
TBH, I am not buying Arrieta postseason hype until I see it. Also, any baseball fan worth their salt knows Cole can go 8 and give up zlich. Or, with the middle of the order both teams have, Jake and Cole could be out by the 6th…and the Cubbies bullpen isn’t exactly garbage compared to Pitt. (you’re welcome Pittsburgh fans for taking Hanrahan, and giVing you melancon
It plays well evenly to display all the happy we get in this column. All force let under our ringling spellboundly funtimes get plenty of rest and don’t let the crackling of trolls beleaguer you gentle reader.
don’t let the crackling of trolls beleaguer you gentle reader.
That is one of the greatest English sentences of all time.
Looking at the comments, I thought this was in response to another Craig Edwards Cardinals puff piece lol.
WillyG gets my vote as best troll ever on Fangraphs.
I have never seen the Medical Doctor, Military Hero, Brain Injury and almost tangentially related professional expertise cards played by one character.
Actually this also gets my vote as funniest trolled comments section on Fangraphs. What with BigDaddyCool and RynoDawson and WillyG all contributing? Incredible.
The only chest I crack open is the one with my ice cold brewskis for the big game.
“I performed surgery with Hank Baunson and Thomas Starzal. I did research with David Gellar. My career was sidetracked when I was injured protecting your condescending blank serving in the US Army Medical Corps. So for anyone to question my intelligence because I have difficulty now secondary to a traumatic brain injury makes me want to explode. Think before you talk in such a condescending manner. People have feelings.”
These trolls are ridiculous.
That such posters are called trolls is another data point proving the pro-Cardinals, pro-Pirates, anti-Cubs bias at Fangraphs.
The fact is that Ryno, BDC, WillyG, Ruben, and I are all totally normal Cubs fans merely conversing here exactly as we all do among ourselves at home, bars, ballparks, everywhere, all the time. Just today, for instance, I screamed GoCubsGo awesomeness in the face of some old lady on the train who had the audacity to bully me by wearing black and gold in public. Look at every other sabermetric site that allows comments – every Cubs fan there will express themselves pretty much like we do. Stop pretending we are any different! By calling us trolls you’re denying us our right to claim our identity and experience as Cubs fans; you’re basically committing a hate crime.
Now I’m a Cubs fan??
Google and Search: STEVE BARTMAN FELONY FRAUD
This comment section is nearly ruining this play-off game for me.
This is honestly one of the worst comment sections I’ve seen on any FanGraphs article in a while. Like, a few jokes here and there is fine and all, but there’s no room for any discussion or discourse regarding the actual article at all. It’s a shame, too; this is a well-written, well-researched piece. Craig deserves better than this.
“If you had any idea what I had accomplished in my career, you would not have the audacity to speak to me like that.”
Biggest game of the year, and a great column gets bombearded by all sorts of stupid comments.
“http://www.fangraphs.com/depthcharts.aspx?position=BaseRuns
This is a site for statistics. Do some research next time.”
They’re not any more fun the second time, mate.
“I obviously know that. MD University of Pittsburgh mph WVU”
I’m sure Craig is laughing and not nearly as gloom and doom as you seem to be about the previous and following comments. Besides, what do you expect, it’s the Cubs with an ace in a one game playoff. It’s the pirates with an Ace in a one game playoff.
Although the way ppl talk you’d think Arrieta has sherzered since the allstar break
Great stories, bro’s. Cute premise for an article, too. But Arrieta/Cole as “greatest matchup ever” is just the tiniest bit of hyperbole. HOF Bob Gibson against MVP Mickey Lolich in ’68 WS game 7 or Gibson/ MVP Jim Lonborg in the year before’s WS Game 7 are just two examples of timeless matchups that would’ve been the internet’s “greatest matchup ever” back then had Al Gore invented it when he was 19 years old.
Using the above methodology,
Gibson WAR (1968) 8.6
Lolich WAR (1968) 3.2
Geometric Mean: ((WAR1*WAR2)^0.5)
(8.6*3.2)^0.5
(27.52)^0.5
5.3
So, it’s a good score, undoubtedly, but it’s much lower than the other games Craig listed above.
And for good measure,
1967 Gibson WAR 4.3
1967 Lonborg WAR 5.7
Geometric Mean: 5.0
To be fair to Mr. Gibson he broke his leg in 1967 and that 4.3 WAR was accrued in only 175 IP, and was sandwiched in-between 6 and 8.6 WAR seasons (which he followed up with 8.8 and 9.8 WAR seasons). I don’t know what his year would have looked like had he not had his leg fractured by a comebacker, but he was certainly better than a 4.3 WAR pitcher that year, and every other year between 1962 and 1972.
Al Gore never said he invented the internet.
Yes, there is more detail on Snopes.
http://www.snopes.com/quotes/internet.asp
Halladay/Carpenter was my favourite in recent memory. Doc allowed 1 run and was so good, but the Phillies lost cause Carp threw a shutout.
Cubs are America’s team Pittsburgh is a joke now and will always be war cubbies to win world series in 6 games and all you pirates fans are welcome to celebrate with us in chi town
I am a Pirates fan. I am scared of Arrieta. I don’t really think the crowd will cause him to lose it. (I think the Cueto game was hilarious.) I think I’d be pretty dumb not to be scared of Arrieta.
I also think Cubs fans would be pretty dumb not to be scared of Cole. Or maybe they’d just be pretty dumb if they were really overconfident in winning a single game against a playoff team.
Or maybe we’re all just fans who want our team to win.
Marc Bolan sins up for arbitration. 10 million next year. Gone. Neil Walker 10 million next year. Gone. Fortunately from what I’ve seen, our first round pick looks really good. Kevin Newman out of Arizona shortstop. He’s a great infielder. Better shortstop than Jordy Mercer defensively. He will learn to hit eventually. For now, Harrison & Kang. Alvarez will be due around eight million in arbitra
Huge T. Rex fan here, Marc Bolan robbed by Bowie and Reed imo — should be the face of rock’s greatest era, instead a footnote in pop culture history. Alas.
He uses a speech to text editor!
He meant Mack Bolan.
Melancon-10,000,000.
Tony Watson MAY become a starter next year. Ray Searage talked about it in spring-training of 2015. Keep Caminero, Soria, Bastardo. Hughes too. Maybe Charlie Morton moves to BP.
MLB Rumors ran the arbitration article. Estimate Arrieta due over ten million. I think he will win.
Pedro Alvarez due eight million. Might win. Really. Offense balances defense.
I think the one thing we can ALL agree on is that RynoDawson is an asshat
1908. Curse of the Billy Goat. Steve Bartman. Maybe next year, Cubbies.
And the final results are in. Jake Arrieta is the real deal, even in the post season, and the Pirates were correct to be scared. Cubs 4-0