Archive for Daily Graphings

Attempting to Peg Fausto Carmona’s Trade Value

Part two of the Twitter giveback. This time Fausto Carmona’s trade value, as requested by Joseph Regan.

The Indians are cozy with trade deadline deals involving top of the rotation starters. In 2008 they traded CC Sabathia to the Milwaukee Brewers for a package that included Matt LaPorta and Michael Brantley. Last year they traded Cliff Lee for Jason Donald, Carlos Carrasco, Jason Knapp, and Lou Marson. This year, Jake Westbrook seems like the odds-on favorite to find a new home, but Carmona could be on the move as well.

Carmona is 26 years old and won’t turn 27 until early December. In 2007 he entered his first full season in the major leagues and performed exceptionally; completing 215 innings with a 3.88 xFIP and a groundball rate over 64%. He was worth approximately four wins that season and Indians’ general manager Mark Shapiro quickly jumped on an extension the following April. The deal Carmona inked guaranteed four years and $15 million, but held three additional club options worth $28 million.

In the two subsequent seasons Carmona tallied 246 innings while walking more batters (140) than he struck out (137). He missed more than 50 games between late May and July in 2008 with a hip injury. In 2009 he was optioned to the minors for seven starts. In his return he struck out 43 and walked 29 as opposed to the 36 strikeouts and 41 walks he granted prior to the demotion.

That improved control has rolled over into this season. To date he’s posting his best strikeout-to-walk ratio since that faithful 2007 season and it’s not particularly close. His FIP is an impressive 4.08 and he’s projected to finish in the 4.40-4.45 range. Given his youth, potential upside, and a contract that calls for relative underpayment, it’s easy to see why teams would be interested in adding Carmona.

Getting an exact feel for Carmona’s trade value is hard because his contract is something unlike we’ve seen traded in recent memory. When the Diamondbacks acquired Dan Haren in December 2007 he had three years and roughly $17 million left on his deal. Arizona tore that up eight months later, replacing it with a four year deal worth nearly $45 million and a club option. It’s not a great comparison, because Haren had three consecutive 200+ inning seasons with at least 4 WAR, and Carmona’s prospects are far sketchier. Nevertheless, the full return for Haren: Chris Carter, Brett Anderson, Aaron Cunningham, Dana Eveland, Carlos Gonzalez, and Greg Smith. It’s safe to say Carmona is unlikely to command that size (in quantity at least) of a return.

Tim Hudson was another Athletic traded in the midst of a great extension. In August of 2000 the A’s inked him to a four year deal worth $9 million with a club option for the 2005 season valued at $6 million. In December 2004 Hudson was moved to Atlanta where he eventually signed a four year $47 million extension with another option tacked on raising the total worth to $59 million. Like Haren, Hudson had a stretch of consistent dominance that Carmona doesn’t come near. From 1999 through 2004 Hudson posted two sub-4 WAR seasons; those were his first two seasons and he combined for 7.5 WAR. The return on Hudson was a comparatively muted package of Juan Cruz, Dan Meyer, and Charles Thomas. That looks awful now, but Meyer as a top 50 prospect according to Baseball America before the 2005 season began and was ranked top 100 the year before.

It doesn’t appear we’ve had a deal with a knockout contract like Carmona’s moved during the season in recent times. Further, when we have had these type of deals, the player usually brings more consistency and less volatility than Carmona. That’s not to say he’s less valuable or anything, it’s just hard to get a feel on whether his troubles are really behind him, or if he can collapse again at any moment.

Back to the question at hand: what is Carmona’s trade value. This is all going to seem like much ado about nothing, but my answer would have to be that it depends entirely on what you represent as Carmona’s true talent level. If the answer is above average with the chance to get better, then hey, those aforementioned packages aren’t too far off with that contract in hand. If it’s an enigma who puts together one good season for every two mediocre seasons, then something of lesser quality is the answer.


George Steinbrenner Passes

George Steinbrenner, perhaps the most famous owner in sports, passed away today. Since I have no personal anecdotes to share, we’ll simply stick to the numbers.

He was in his 37th year of owning the Yankees, having bought the team in 1973. In that time, his team won the American League pennant 11 times and the World Series seven times. During his reign, the Yankees won it all an average of once per five years.

Their record since Steinbrenner purchased the team: 3,364 wins, 2,583 losses. They won 56.6 percent of the games they played during his ownership.

Seventeen different people have managed the Yankees since 1973. Under Steinbrenner’s watch, the team changed managers 22 times, an average of once every season and a half.

Forbes estimates the Yankees worth in 2010 at $1.6 billion. The next highest estimate was the Red Sox at $870 million.

That will be the legacy Steinbrenner leaves – a lot of winning, a lot of managerial changes, and by far the most valuable franchise in sports. Hard to call it anything other than a success…


Montero May Be the Better Value

Although it would be obviously too easy to turn the prospect packages offered to Seattle for Cliff Lee by the Yankees and Rangers into Jesus Montero versus Justin Smoak…we’re going to go for it anyway. When it comes down to it, the tipping point in Jack Z’s mind wasn’t Blake Beavan or David Adams, but rather the blue-chip cream fillings in the middle of the prospect pies. Although the Mariners ended up sending Lee to Arlington, they might have been better off seeing him in pinstripes.

To put things in perspective, I want to assess this breakdown as a competition for future value. Most importantly in baseball is offense. While Justin Smoak certainly has the build/repertoire of a Mark Teixeira, his minor league numbers do not completely back it up. A career .293/.411/.461 hitter in the minors, he certainly was getting on base at an outstanding rate due to a batting eye that is incredibly advanced for a young age. The pop, however,  mostly came in spurts:

2008 (21 years old, A): .304/.355/.518, 62 PA
2009 (22 years old, AA): .328/.449/.481, 227 PA
2009 (22 years old, AAA): .244/.363/.360, 237 PA
2010 (23 years old, AAA): .300/.470/.540, 66 PA

As mentioned, the walk rate is clearly there at a phenomenal level, but the power has not been consistent. In the major leagues this year, as a twenty-three year old turning twenty-four in December, Smoak is hitting .206/.311/.346 in 283 plate appearances, good for just a 77 wRC+ and -0.3 WAR. Considering he’s playing in Texas during the summer, you’d expect Smoak to be able to slug better than .346 for the ~43% of a full season he’s played. While his .237 BABIP is sure to find its way higher up, we don’t know what his true talent level BABIP is; Smoak may just be the kind of hitter who consistently has ~.280 BABIPs. If so, he may have solid peaks, but lower lows.

Smoak’s biggest issue is his inability to hit lefties. Scouts who have seen him have commented on his struggles, and the numbers back it up. In the minors, Smoak hit just .215/.304/.331 versus southpaws, good for an abysmal .635 OPS. It has been the same story in the major leagues. Justin has hit just .146/.211/.268 against lefties in 87 plate appearances, costing him -8.3 wRAA and coming out to a terrible .2011 wOBA. Switch-hitting doesn’t mean much if you stink from one side.

Hitting-wise, Jesus Montero is doing well for his age. Although he has not shown the plate discipline Smoak has (although not many minor leaguers have), he has certainly provided enough pop. His minor league line overall is .308/.368/.488, showing a solid eye and good power for such a young player. Here’s what Baseball America’s scouting report said about him:

Montero doesn’t have a classic swing or textbook rhythm, but he’s gifted with hand-eye coordination, keen pitch recognition, a knack for barreling balls and tremendous strength. He can be out front or off balance on a pitch and still crush it. He covers the plate well and makes excellent contact. Montero hasn’t delivered completely on his raw power, but he’s close to projecting as an 80 hitter with 80 power on the 20-80 scouting scale. One veteran scout called him the best young hitter he has seen in years.

Simply put, Montero has some amazing ability as a hitter. Last year, in Double-A at just ninteen years old, Montero hit .317/.370/.539. Montero out-slugged Smoak by .50 points in Double-A despite being three years younger (!), and he still isn’t even old enough to legally drink yet. His power potential surpasses that of Smoak. In Triple-A this season, Montero has struggled a bit, hitting just .252/.328/.415- still a better OPS than Smoak had at 22 in Triple-A, and mighty impressive for a twenty year old.

Defensively, Smoak is considered an above average first baseman who could win a Gold Glove before his career is over, and TotalZone has been kind to him in the minors, as has UZR in his limited MLB time. But he doesn’t have the Doug Mientkiewicz-type range/hands that would give him a ton of added value in the field when struggling at the dish.

Jesus Montero, on the other hand, has a ton of issues in the field. He is described almost universally as below average behind the plate, and many people see a future move to first base because of his large frame (he gets frequent comparisons to Mike Piazza in that regard). Montere, however, has been making improvements, is just twenty years old, and has thrown out baserunners at a 22% rate in the minors. From MLB.com’s Scouting Report on Montero:

The question with Montero has always been about his defense. He’s big for a catcher and isn’t all that agile. That being said, he’s worked very hard on his craft behind the plate and showed improvement, particularly in throwing out runners, over the course of last season…

…”I want to be a catcher. I love to catch. I like to be a catcher. I like to be in the middle of the game. I mean, it’s my position. I want to play my position.”

When it comes down to it, I think Montero is the better pick due to the possibility he stays at catcher and his massive offensive potential. A bat like that behind the plate is just too valuable a commodity to pass on. Sure, Smoak can hit 30+ homers with good defense in his prime and have peak years of 6+ WAR, but he also may become a slightly better Chris Davis or Casey Kotchman (Kotchman also had a big build with a solid eye but lack of power in the minors) . With Montero, you know the bat is going to play regardless, and if he does end up at catcher, he could be one of the best players in baseball.


Why Seattle Chose Smoak Over Montero

If we are to assume the Yankees reported offer – Jesus Montero, David Adams, Zach McAllister – was on the table, it would follow that the Mariners brass ultimately made a not-so-simple calculation, and ended up with this: Justin Smoak > Jesus Montero. The comparison is a significant stance because it runs counter to the majority of offseason opinions. Only ESPN’s Keith Law, among analysts I can find, ranked Smoak over Montero this winter.

And not much has changed since then; Montero has less-than expected numbers at 20 years old in Triple-A, Smoak had less-than expected numbers at 23 years old in Arlington. Ultimately, I can pinpoint three significant reasons that Jack Zduriencik used to reach their Rangers-favored conclusion. Two are reasons that have been (and will be) well-documented elsewhere:

1. The Mariners don’t believe Montero to be a viable option at catcher, even in a diminished capacity. As a corollary, they believe Justin Smoak’s long-lauded defense at first will outpace Montero’s eventual contributions there.
2. The understanding that Safeco Field would be a better fit for the switch-hitting Smoak than the right-handed Montero. This is no revelation: “Know Thy Park” is practically a commandment of front-office work.

Yes, these were surely factors that ultimately supported the M’s decision. But I think there is a third, significant reason that you won’t hear talked about much that led to choosing Smoak over Montero:

The Mariners evaluate potential commodities from the context of potential performance during team-controlled seasons only.

The two players in question have close-enough offensive profiles that I don’t think you could make the case for trading the 20-year-old Montero for the 23-year-old Smoak (in a vacuum). Montero has a decent chance to be in the Major Leagues next season, and thus, should have the longer Major League career. But if Montero does play in the Majors next season — and considering he’s hit .312/.377/.550 since June 7, I submit that it’s likely (especially if he had gone to Seattle) — his team-controlled seasons will come at ages 21-26. The remainder of Smoak’s will come at ages 24-28.

Seattle, I think, is betting that Montero will take a couple years to find his footing in the Major Leagues. I don’t think they would question his potential, just gambling that he’s most likely to reach it after he hits free agency. They look at a guy like Paul Konerko, who before the season, I listed as a nice median outcome for Montero’s career. Konerko, from ages 21-27, hit a combined .279/.342/.470, posting an OPS just 8% above league average. Since then, he’s hit .278/.363/.513, showing more patience and power, with an OPS+ of 125.

The opposite part of that argument is Miguel Cabrera, who is clearly the top-end of what Montero could become. Miggy hit 33 home runs at age 21, and was a cumulative .311/.383/.542 through age 26. At age 20, before being called up, Cabrera had a similar number of plate appearances in Double-A that Montero has had in Triple-A. In the Southern League, Cabrera hit .365/.429/.609, with 31 walks, 29 doubles and 10 home runs. In the International League, Montero is batting .252/.328/.415, with 33 walks, 19 doubles and 7 home runs.

The Mariners are essentially gambling on Montero to be more like Paul Konerko than Miguel Cabrera. And Smoak, meanwhile, will have the ages where most hitters hit their prime at the tail end of his arbitration-eligible seasons.

Montero is a great prospect, but almost every part of his game is still projection. The power is still of the gap variety. He’s yet to play his Major League position. Smoak has struggled in the big leagues, but the skills are there. Defense, patience, power. The Mariners don’t care whether Jesus Montero or Justin Smoak will have a better career, like Baseball America does. They care about which would provide the best value while still coming cheap.


Historical Four Factors: Joe Morgan’s Peak

It is incredibly unfortunate that my generation of baseball fans knows Joe Morgan primarily from his antics in the broadcast booth. Some know more about Fire Joe Morgan than they do about Hall of Fame second baseman Joe Morgan. Today, I’d like to use my four factors of hitting to shed some light on Morgan’s ridiculous peak, in particular his 1975 and 1976 seasons, in which he posted 21.5 total WAR and won the MVP both seasons.

For a reminder, the four factors are BB%, K%, POW (XB/H), and BABIP. The short reason for using POW instead of ISO is that Colin Wyers told me to. The actual reason is that BABIP actually can have a heavy influence on ISO. There doesn’t appear, to me, to be a reason to judge power based on what somebody does in ABs where they make outs (think “long outs”) or don’t even make contact (strikeouts). This doesn’t mean that ISO doesn’t have its merit, but in this case we are trying to separate what these four statistics are telling us as much as possible, which, to me, is the best solution.

Back to the task at hand, here are the four factors for Joe Morgan’s 1975 with The Big Red Machine.

The numbers are staggering across the board. It should come as no surprise that this season resulted in an MVP award and an 11.4 WAR season. Morgan had a walk rate 230% of the average player. When he wasn’t walking, he was making contact, and when he was making contact, it was either a resulting in a base hit or solid power. It’s disappointing that we don’t have plate discipline numbers from this period; I can’t imagine how ridiculous Morgan’s O-Swing% or contact rates were this season to allow him to walk over 2.5 times more than he struck out.

Amazingly enough, the 1975 season almost pales in comparison with what he accomplished in 1976:

The drop in Morgan’s walk rate was pretty much in line with a league-wide drop in walks. Then, in two categories where he already outclassed the entire league, Morgan made huge strides. The drop in strikeouts compensated for the natural drop in BABIP he saw – .298 was still significantly above the league BABIP of .281, making a .336 mark like he had in 1975 slightly ridiculous. If Morgan had merely equaled his power numbers of 1975, we would’ve been looking at another 190 wRC+ type season. Instead, Morgan slugged 27 home runs, a career high and ten more than he put out in 1975. Morgan walked at a rate 226% of the average player and hit for power at a rate 184% higher than that of the average player. Morgan’s numbers is the stuff of which any baseball analyst dreams, sabermetrically inclined or not.

It can be easy to simply dismiss Joe Morgan when we hear him talk in the broadcast booth. It’s important, for those of us who care about the history of the game, however, to remember that Morgan may have been the best second baseman of all time. These two seasons are only part of a five year peak which saw five 9.0+ WAR seasons and 3 10.0+ WAR seasons. Joe Morgan was a fantastic baseball player, and that is how I will remember him.


Ishikawa Power

Note: It’s the midseason, which means things are a little slow. As a result, I’ve taken this opportunity to try and give back to the readers by doing content requests on Twitter. This one comes from Zach Sanders, who actually writes for RotoGraphs and is quite smart and good on his own. He wants some Travis Ishikawa coverage and although he’s probably more qualified to do it than me, here goes nothing.

Buster Posey appeared to be the big winner when the San Francisco Giants traded Bengie Molina on July 1. Posey’s season debut came on May 29 and yet between those two dates he recorded exactly two starts behind the dish in something like 40 games. Posey is starting almost every day now, but so is his replacement at first base: Travis Ishikawa.

Okay, to be fair, it wasn’t just Molina’s departure that opened the spot for Ishikawa. Aaron Rowand’s ineffectiveness has allowed Bruce Bochy to play Andres Torres in centerfield occasionally alongside the Giants’ little blue pills (older players who are still usable, and not just for nostalgia purposes) in Pat Burrell and Aubrey Huff. The 26-year-old lefty who hit nine home runs for the Giants in 2009 has clenched the job with ever-yearning, inferno-drenched palms.

In 71 plate appearances Ishikawa has hit two homers, while drastically reducing his strikeout rate, and he’s flashing the isolated power that made him a reasonable first base option after the 2008 season. Perhaps the most impressive aspect of Ishikawa’s performance is that it comes without playing in the minor leagues this season. He missed time with two partially torn ligaments in his big toe and, while playing time has been mostly sparse, he’s made the most of it.

It’s hard to say what to expect moving forward. In Triple-A Ishikawa hit .310/.370/.737 in nearly 50 games, and in Double-A he hit .247/.333/.396 while being mostly young for the league. He’s been a mixed bag. One who shows pop and the potential to be a pretty nifty player, but also one who probably hits the ball on the ground too much for his skill set to ever truly flourish. He’s always been noted as a plus defender which helps his case, but he’s not much for hitting left-handers, which suggests his roof might be in a platoon capacity. Which I guess puts him in this family:


The Rays’ Pen

The Rays very well may be in possession of the best bullpen in the American League, as their collective 3.45 FIP ranks third overall and first in the AL, just ahead of the White Sox’ staff. Despite being in mid-July, the Rays have only made one roster move for their pitching staff all season, an early season demotion of Mike Ekstrom and promotion of Joaquin Benoit. Otherwise, the entire unit that opened the season is still intact. But maybe not for too much longer.

Joaquin Benoit has a 1.60 FIP and a strikeout-to-walk ratio of 10. A minor league signing in the winter, Benoit has exceeded any reasonable projections. Jonah Keri has called him the “embodiment of the Extra 2%,” which just so happens to be the name of his forthcoming book on the Rays. Benoit barely edges Grant Balfour (2.32) and Rafael Soriano (2.88)). LOOGY Randy Choate and ROOGY Dan Wheeler have been similarly good. In fact, only one pitcher in the Rays’ pen has an xFIP over 4.4, that being Lance Cormier, who has seemingly lost his once impeccable control.

So why might this group not be around for much longer? Because each and every one of them can reach the free agency market at season’s end with the exception of Andy Sonnanstine. Soriano and Benoit signed one year deals; Balfour and Choate will qualify for free agency of the non-released variety for the first time in their respective careers; Cormier very well could be a non-tender candidate at this rate; and the Rays hold a club option on Wheeler worth $4 million with a buyout worth $1 million.

With the Rays shedding something like $40 million in payroll, ostensibly a few will return. Benoit could return to the team willing to give him a chance and potentially close, setting himself up for a bigger payday in the near future. Choate has an ERA over 6 despite pitching well for the most part. Wheeler has become something of a mainstay in the Rays’ pen and is the son-in-law of Rays’ announcer Dewayne Staats. And so on. Soriano seems like the least likely to return, but who knows if the Rays can somehow win the World Series.

In their place the Rays could simply keep everything in-house during a down year. With rotation spots hard to come by the Rays have plenty of arms to throw into the relief corps. Something like this, perhaps:

LR: Sonnanstine
MR: Heath Rollins
MR: Aneury Rodriguez
MR: Dale Thayer
SU: Alex Torres
SU: Jake McGee
CP: J.P. Howell

There’s also Ricky Orta and Matt Bush lying around who could find their way onto the scene. That may not be a surefire recipe for success, but in a year in which there will be a ton of roster turnover, the bullpen seems to be no exception.


Four Factors: Brennan Boesch

It seems like there was a warm response to my four factors for evaluating hitting that I presented in this post on Martin Prado last Friday. As such, I’d like to use it to take a look at a few more players. One player about whom I think these stats tell a particularly interesting story is Tigers rookie Brennan Boesch.

As a reminder, the four factors of hitting are BB%, K%, POW (XB/H), and BABIP. That is, walk rate, strikeout rate, power (as measured by extra bases per hit), and success on balls in play. I feel that these four statistics sum up extremely well four facets of hitting under which the batter has control.

Let’s take a look at how Brennan Boesch fares under these four measures.

Boesch, to date, has excelled in both power and success on balls in play, performing at a level nearly 130% of the league average in both factors. He’s slightly above average in strikeout rate and a bit below average in terms of walk rate. There’s no doubt that he has been excellent so far this season; his .426 wOBA is right between Joey Votto and Kevin Youkilis on the leaderboard – certainly impressive company for a rookie.

Of course, when a young player with no MLB track record posts these kinds of numbers over any significant period of time, we have to wonder if it’s sustainable. Simply due to the nature of regression, even if a player has ridiculous minor league numbers (which Boesch doesn’t), we would never expect a .426 wOBA to stay that high. What can we reasonably expect out of this extremely hot hitter as the season winds down?

Unfortunately, ZiPS doesn’t have a projection for him in the system. CHONE, however, in its July update, projected Boesch for a .259/.300/.438 line, worth about -7 runs per 150 games. That’s a marginally over replacement level player with average defense in the corners.

To see why CHONE is so down on Boesch, we need to look no further than the four factors. Take a look at how quickly each of the statistics involved here stabilize:

K%: 150 PA
BB%: 200 PA
ISO (presumably, POW would stabilize at a similar time): 550 PA
AVG: >650 PA

Boesch is only 267 plate appearances into his MLB career. For that reason, we can be relatively confident on his below-average walking ability and his above-average ability to avoid the strikeout. However, the two aspects of his game that have him at the top of the MLB leaderboards – power and balls in play – just simply don’t show themselves this early in a player’s career. Boesch showed solid power in AA (0.84 POW) but hasn’t ever showed the kind of BIP skills that would necessarily lead to a .384 or even a .320 BABIP in the majors.

Right now, it’s simply too early for us to conclude that Boesch is so much better than his minor league performance would suggest to even say that he projects as an average hitter going forward. He has certainly impressed in his time on the field in 2010, but his power and success on balls in play are likely to drop. Given the rest of his skills, he simply can’t maintain the elite hitting if this drop occurs. It’s certainly not impossible that this is just a breakout year for Boesch, but the Tigers shouldn’t act as if Boesch is another Miguel Cabrera in their lineup as they plan for the second half.


Well Played, Mauer

A little over half way through the season, the Minnesota Twins, favored by many to win the American League Central relatively easily, are in third place. Their run differential indicates that they “should” be winning the division, something that will hopefully be noticed by Ron Gardenhire’s fan club (which includes some who should know better). Despite their inability to pull ahead in the division, the Twins have received great performances from Justin Morneau and Francisco Liriano, and perhaps most surprisingly, competence from Delmon Young. However, it is hard not to notice the relatively down offensive season from Joe Mauer, whose .345 wOBA at the break is equal to that of fellow All-Star John Buck.

A .345 wOBA from a catcher is very valuable, of course, and Mauer has already accumulated 2.1 Wins Above Replacement, meaning he’d be close to 4 WAR over the full season (if you buy into “on pace for” stats, which you shouldn’t). One shouldn’t pin the blame for the Twins failure to run away with the division on Mauer’s “bad” hitting. Still, one certainly expected more from Mauer at the plate after his .438 wOBA (.365/.444/.587) in 2009. While the best pre-season projections expected some regression, they were still extremely impressed: CHONE projected a .401 wOBA and ZiPS a .415.

The primary difference between 2009 and 2010 so far has been Mauer’s power, as has been discussed in detail by David Golebiewski. I substantially agree with that analysis, and have little to add to it. Mauer’s opposite field approach is a rarity among hitter, but usually works for him. With a 10% career HR/FB rate, one expected it to come back down from 20.4% in 2009. Little else stands out in Mauer’s peripheral numbers that would make one think something is “wrong.” His walk rate is slightly down, which is likely related to his higher percentage of pitches chased out of the zone, but the whole league is chasing more pitches this season. He’s actually making contact more frequently so far this season, and is hitting more line drives, but while Mauer has a tremendous gift for hitting singles and doubles, his 2009 BABIP was unsustainable.

Expectations for Mauer’s 2010 go beyond projected peformance, however, and were tied, fairly or not, to the eight-year, $184 million dollar “hometown premium” extension for 2011-2018 he signed during the off-season. That was properly analyzed to death at the time, so I won’t go over it myself in detail. Depending on how much you think the dollars per marginal win will be starting in 2010 and the average rate of inflation, I’d say the Twins paid for a 5.5-6 WAR player starting in 2011, assuming average decline in production and 7% salary inflation over the life of the contract.

With that in mind, it is understandable if Mauer’s 2 WAR through a little over a half a season might not be quite “good enough” in the eyes of some. While there are reasons to be concerned about Mauer’s production in relation to the big contract (and it is a 50/50 shot at best that it will “pay off,” given that it was pretty much a market deal), it is worth remembering that observed performance is not the same as true talent, that a player’s performance as he ages is rarely perfectly linear, and, perhaps most of all, that the best projection systems that have taken into account of Mauer’s offensive performance this season still see his true talent as far above his current performance: ZiPS Rest of Season projections spits out a .394 wOBA (.323/.404/.491), and CHONE’s July 1 update as a +36/150 hitter (.319/.397/.483). The BABIP and power are unlikely to return to 2009 levels, but he’s probably better than this. Expect better production from Mauer over the second half, given good health

For those still understandably concerned about Mauer’s current performance in relation to the future, consider one alternate possibility: Mauer’s Big New Contract doesn’t start until next season. He’s making “only” $12.5 million dollars this season, and even if he only has a .345 wOBA over the rest of 2010, he’ll easily be worth more than that if he stays healthy. Maybe, just maybe, he’s waiting to turn on the ~.400 wOBA production until he’s actually getting paid for it.

Well played, Mauer, indeed.


What the Tampa Bay Rays Should Do

Overview

The Rays got off to a torrid start this year, jumping out to a division lead on April 22 and eventually extending that to a six-game cushion on May 23. But nineteen games later they fell back into a tie, and since June 20 have been behind the New York Yankees. They recently rattled off six in a row to keep pace, though they didn’t gain a single game during that span. They’re still close, just two games back of the Yankees.

Buy or Sell?

The question isn’t of whether or not the Rays will add a player before the deadline, but of what player and when. They’re in an excellent position to make the playoffs right now, with Baseball Prospectus’s Postseason Odds report giving them a 64.89 percent chance, which trails only New York, Texas, and Atlanta. Yet they trail Boston by a game in third order wins, so they will probably want to add a player or two in order to solidify the lineup and pitching staff.

At third base, left field, and either right field or second base the Rays are set. They need not find upgrades over Evan Longoria, Carl Crawford, or Ben Zobrist. Catcher is probably set, too. While John Jaso has cooled down after his hot debut he’s still hitting well, and with Kelly Shoppach also in place the Rays don’t need to add at the position. At pretty much any other position, however, the Rays could certainly upgrade.

Shortstop presents an odd situation, in which two opposite-handed players, Jason Bartlett and Reid Brignac, have reverse splits in the first half. That will start to correct itself, and that could make the duo a decent platoon option. Again, chances are the Rays won’t look for an upgrade here, where they have players in place. Second base can be in issue, too, but it seems like they’ll be patient with Sean Rodriguez, especially with Zobrist able to take over the position if necessary.

Would the Rays consider a move at first base? Carlos Pena has been their man for the past few years, but he’s had a rough first half, a .326 wOBA. That puts him near the bottom of AL first basemen. Much of that comes from his performance against lefties, a .289 wOBA in about a third of his overall plate appearances. Acquiring a right-handed half of the platoon could work, especially because the Rays have a number of multi-position players.

The Rays could also use another bat in the DH spot. That’s where Corey Hart could fit in. Phil Rogers of the Chicago Tribune says that the Rays are “getting serious” about him, and that the Rays could use their pitching depth to lure the Brewers into a trade. Hart is experiencing a renaissance year, reminiscent of his breakout 2007 season. He’d fit in right field, where the Rays could use an upgrade, and also at DH — he doesn’t rate very well as a fielder but he’s not a butcher. Tommy Rancel of DRays Bay likes the idea, but worries that the Rays could overpay. Looking at their rotation now and in the future, Matt Garza, who will get more and more expensive in each of the next three seasons, could be the target, with Jeremy Hellickson taking his place.

If the Rays want to do someting about B.J. Upton and his poor production against righties, a .280 wOBA, they do have options. They would probably turn internally there, however, with Desmond Jennings getting the call. After a rocky start he’s hitting much better, a .412 OBP in June and a .368 mark so far this month. A righty-righty platoon doesn’t sound ideal, but Jennings handles righties well enough. The only question is of whether the Rays would call him up if he won’t play every day. They could give him the role by trading Upton, but given the patience the team has displayed with them I don’t think that’s particularly likely.

In the rotation there shouldn’t be much of a problem. The Rays have had the particular luxury of having only five pitchers start games in the first half, and for the most part they’ve been effective. They do have the flexibility to move one of them — again, probably Garza — if if would help them out. There is a possible replacement in the bullpen with Andy Sonnanstine, who is having a decent year, and on the farm. The bullpen probably doesn’t need any tweaking, which is an advantage. With nearly every team seeking bullpen help we could see a few overpayments this month. They could probably use a lefty upgrade over Randy Choate, but he’s pitched better lately and in any case it’s a luxury, not a need. Their bullpen, anchored by Joaquin Benoit and Rafael Soriano, and with valuable contributions from Grant Balfour and Dan Wheeler, can stand up against most, if not all, of their competitors.

On the Farm

The two players who could have an impact for the Rays in the second half are Jennings and Hellickson. If the Rays need to deal from the rotation, Hellickson is the obvious fill-in, as he’s crushing AAA as a 23-year-old. Jennings could see time later this year to help strengthen the outfield. Even if they bring in Corey Hart they could benefit from Jennings on defense. Then again, they do have plenty of options in the outfield and might want to give Jennings the rest of the year in AAA.

If they don’t get Hart, Dan Johnson could present another option for the corner spots. He has played at third base at AAA Durham this year, hitting .349/.405/.505 through 292 AB. He’s no great shakes, a .333 career wOBA, but he presents a chance for the Rays to catch lightning in a bottle. Chances are he can’t do much worse than the Rays’ DHs, who have hit a combined .240/.307/.373 this season.

With a slew of young pitchers among their top prospects, the Rays could use one or more of them as trade bait. They’ll want to keep some of them around for the future, of course, but with a rotation whose oldest member is 28 they can afford to trade from the lower levels.

Budget

The Rays are always working under tight financial framework, and this year they’ve extended themselves already. The $72.85 million they’re paying their players represents a franchise record. But that won’t stop owner Stu Sternberg from making a deal.

“Money won’t be an object,” Sternberg said. “Players are always an object for us and the money will be an impediment, but we’ll figure it out if it makes all the sense in the world for this team.”

There are practical limits to what the Rays can do, so Sternberg is certainly exaggerating when he says that money isn’t an object. But if it means adding a significant piece, they’ll find the room. That has to be reassuring for Rays fans.