How the West Got Fun: Giants Add Kris Bryant for Stretch Run

The NL West has been a slugging match all year. The Giants have the best record in baseball. The Dodgers are hot on their heels and just added two All-Stars to go for the division title, with the Padres in hot pursuit. San Francisco wasn’t going to take that lying down, though. As Jeff Passan first reported, the team has acquired Kris Bryant from the Cubs in exchange for two prospects, Alexander Canario and Caleb Kilian.

Bryant has been a hotly rumored deadline chip for seemingly forever; as soon as the Cubs hit a rough patch in the standings, they announced their intentions to sell off pieces that weren’t controllable past 2021, with him, Anthony Rizzo, and Javier Báez the obvious candidates for a move. All three have now been dealt to contenders, and for my money, Bryant is the best player of the three. He’ll slot into San Francisco’s roster all over the place, one of the perks of trading for him; he plays all four corner spots capably and has even started 10 games in center as the Cubs dealt with injury and ineptitude in the outfield. He’s not going to win a Gold Glove out there anytime soon — and the less said about his two innings at shortstop, the better — but if you’re looking to squeeze Bryant’s bat into the lineup, there are any number of possibilities.

That bat is the reason San Francisco made this trade. Rumors of Bryant’s demise were greatly exaggerated; he had an absolutely abysmal 2020, playing in only 34 games and compiling easily the worst line of his career, but he’s been back to his old tricks in 2021. That game is power and walks, and it’s worked to the tune of a .267/.358/.503 slash line, an on-base-light approximation of his career line.

I’m not going to waste a ton of space discussing the reason for Bryant’s resurgence this year; Dan Szymborski and I have plenty for you to read if you want to go down that particular rabbit hole. The gist of it is that he’s gotten better at hitting high fastballs, a pitch that caused him no end of trouble last year. That, and a season without nagging injuries, have helped him turn back the clock, and it couldn’t have come at a better time with free agency looming after the season.

In San Francisco, Bryant would be an upgrade in any of several positions. Wilmer Flores has done yeoman’s work playing across the infield, but he’d make more sense as a sometimes first baseman than playing the hot corner, Bryant’s natural position. That would move LaMonte Wade Jr. to an outfield corner or Donovan Solano to the bench if the team thinks Flores can handle second base. It also gives San Francisco far more flexibility against lefties; Wade, Alex Dickerson, and Steven Duggar are all platoon bats, and some of their replacements are sketchy at best. In all, that upgrade will likely be worth at least a win over the remainder of the season, and every win counts in the cutthroat West.

If and when Evan Longoria returns, things will get more complicated, but not in a bad way. Having to work out where to plug in an impact hitter who can play multiple positions is a great problem to have. Before this trade, we projected the Giants for the eighth-worst runs per game; even accounting for their park, that leaves plenty of room for improvement. That hasn’t matched reality so far — they’ve scored the eighth-most runs per game — and adding talent is an excellent way to fight the regression monster. A core hitting group of Bryant, Buster Posey, Mike Yastrzemski, Longoria, and a rejuvenated Brandon Crawford is a fair sight better than what the Giants have been running out there most of the year.

As an added bonus, the Giants made this trade without dealing from the very top of their system. Canario, the higher-ranked of the two prospects, is a boom-bust type, both in-game and in terms of his risk profile for the Cubs. He has all the tools you love to see in a young, bat-first outfielder: tremendous bat speed, which he gets from his natural strength, and a hellacious swing that translate into thumping raw power. That violent swing leads to plenty of swing-and-miss, though, and he’s made hard contact less consistently than you’d like to see, even though his approach at the plate has improved. His line in A ball has been disappointing, and the strikeouts will definitely be a limiting factor. Defensively, he looks like a fit for right field; he’s an average runner with a plus arm.

Kilian wasn’t ranked on our Giants list, but he’s the kind of pitcher the Cubs have increasingly targeted in trade. He’s a righty with a low-90s fastball and three average secondaries: a cutter, a curve, and a changeup. Scouts aren’t blown away by his stuff, but he throws a lot of strikes and mixes pitches well. He’s looked awesome in Double-A this year; a 26.2% strikeout rate and 3.3% walk rate will play anywhere, and he’s given up only two homers in 60-plus innings. Chicago loves command-first pitchers, and Kilian fits that bill exactly. Will he have the stuff to survive in the majors? Who knows! The Cubs will likely find out, though, either this September or next year.

Viewed in relation to the other trades for impact talent from this week, I think the Giants did well here. The Mets gave up a similar amount to get Baez and Trevor Williams, and I’d rather have Bryant. I’d also rather have Pete Crow-Armstrong than Canario, particularly if I were selling everything that wasn’t nailed down the way Chicago has done. The Giants are also in the perfect position to add hitters; they have several lineup spots that could use reinforcement and are starting from ahead in the playoff race, so they aren’t sending prospects for a one-in-ten shot at a Wild Card spot or anything silly like that.

Given all the trade pyrotechnics from earlier, the Giants were looking at Bryant or nothing, and with the Dodgers powering up so much and Báez, Rizzo, and Joey Gallo already moved, he was the last impact bat remaining. Doing nothing as your closest competitor loads the boat wasn’t really an option, and given that, the fact that San Francisco added a premium hitter without giving up a king’s ransom (some outlets had Canario at the back end of the team’s top 10) is quite the coup.

I’m not sure the Giants are likely suitors for Bryant in free agency, but that wasn’t the point of this deal. Two months of slugging in a tight division race was the point, and I don’t think they could have done any better for the price. The Cubs, meanwhile, had to move Bryant somewhere, and San Francisco clearly had prospects they were interested in. Maybe they didn’t get quite the dynamic haul that fans hoped for, but it’s a solid return for an expiring contract — just another way that keeping Bryant down an extra few weeks in 2015 to squeeze an extra year of team control out has paid off.





Ben is a writer at FanGraphs. He can be found on Bluesky @benclemens.

28 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
natedub
5 years ago

When I saw what Rizzo, Baez, Kimbrel, and even Marisnick got, I was pretty nervous, but it’s pretty impressive that considering all of this, the Giants got Bryant for just Canario & Kilian.

I’d imagine Zaidi waited for some leverage to come down. The Cubs had no reason, at 4PM (EST) to hold onto Bryant, and they’d get nothing more than a pick in the third round if they QO’d him. The Giants did well here.

Zaidi continues to show he doesn’t panic when his rivals make big moves. What a trade for him.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  natedub

I think the Giants got Bryant for quite a bit less than the Mets gave up for Baez. This was a really good deal for the Giants. Canario is an interesting prospect but he’s very risky. I think Pete Crow-Armstrong is a much better prospect.

I agree, this was a really solid move for them.

j27roenick
5 years ago

I agree that Zaidi did well here. When KB still didn’t have a new team with only a few minutes left before the deadline, you knew it was going to have to be Jed who was the one who blinked. That being said, Kilian has the best numbers I’ve ever seen for an unranked guy in a trade. I was not expecting that when I went to his player page. I mean, wow. In 100+ professional innings, he has 113 K’s and 11 BBs. He has allowed 2 HRs. I’m guessing he won’t be unranked for long.

edges64Member since 2021
5 years ago
Reply to  j27roenick

yeah I get that Kilian is 24 years old but I don’t see why Longenhagen refuses to give him even a 35+ grade at this point.

anarchosnailMember since 2024
5 years ago

Great analysis. Small correction: Canario has been in low-A, not AA, all season

Tyson WirthMember since 2019
5 years ago

Did the Cubs not kick in salary on this deal like they did for Rizzo and Chafin? Wonder if they wanted to but SF preferred not to pay the extra prospect price?

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Tyson Wirth

If someone has figured this out, I would love to know. I can’t find any information about how much they’re paying on the Baez deal but Pete Crow-Armstrong seems like a stronger prospect than Canario. Your theory is also my theory on why it turned out this way.

GrandpaboyMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Tyson Wirth

No $$$ from CHC to SF; as a Cubs fan this is *easily* the worst deal of the last few days.

miltonfriedman
5 years ago

I’m kinda happy my Tigers didn’t buy or sell. Still think they could win the division.

carterMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  miltonfriedman

Huh? Like they could win the division if winning was getting second place. But they are 11 games back. If they go 40-17 from here on out they still will not win the division. And guess what? They are not gonna go 40-17.

Jason BMember since 2017
5 years ago
Reply to  miltonfriedman

“Still think they could win the division.”

That is totally insane, but if you earnestly believe it, most sportsbooks are offering +30000 odds on the Tigers to take the Central this year. If you follow up your belief with a little cash, you could make the prognosticators look foolish AND win enough to never have to work again!

Mike NMN
5 years ago

when i look at trade after trade it looks like the Yankees consistently overpaid in comparison.

JohnnyRingoFWC
5 years ago

Perhaps an uneducated take on my part, but this is the best you get for KB?

Seemed like Hoyer might have missed a move or two along the way by holding on.

sogoodlooking
5 years ago
Reply to  JohnnyRingoFWC

It feels like most writers believe Kris Bryant is still the Bryant of his first three seasons in the bigs and that this isn’t 2021, where everyone throws gas and even a slight slowing of reflexes ends a career. The return for a couple of months of an above average regular no longer approaching AS-caliber looks entirely appropriate.

gtagomoriMember since 2017
5 years ago

Does anyone else suspect that the Giants have targeted older (28-32) aged players as being undervalued in the marketplace?

They just seem like the calmest (and oldest) good team I’ve seen in a while.

EasyenoughMember since 2016
5 years ago
Reply to  gtagomori

Like the 2019 Nationals? I think they are a couple late to be first to this insight…

gtagomoriMember since 2017
5 years ago
Reply to  Easyenough

Exactly. But the nationals only did it because it lined up for them. They were built around a traditional core of upcoming young players (Soto by himself indicated they could contend for the next 10 years)

The Giants seem to have built around and adding to an OLD core.

How do you think K Ruiz is going to pan out for the Nats? His scouting reports suggest anything is still possible.

johnforthegiants
5 years ago
Reply to  gtagomori

Their thinking seems to be that the main problem with older players is they get injured a lot, but if you have enough pretty good older players and you have a number of players who can play various positions, this isn’t such a problem. They just assume a lot of injuries are going to happen and you have to be prepared to deal with them. They have 15 different players with at least 150 PAs this year (compare with 12 on the Dodgers and 10 on the Astros). Getting Bryant when they have Longoria is a perfect example of this–they aren’t counting on Longoria to stay healthy when he comes back, but on the other hand if he does, Bryant can always play somewhere else. It’s a great move.

LHPSU
5 years ago
Reply to  gtagomori

Older players are generally what you get on the marketplace.

sogoodlooking
5 years ago
Reply to  gtagomori

I suspect we’ll eventuallly learn that Zaidi and the Giants FO have figured out something that rejuvenates old players. They’re not foolish enough to think that because their old players luckily (if it was luck) all got better at the same time, it therefore means that old players are now suddenly a bargain and will perform the way the Giants’ old players have.

carterMember since 2020
5 years ago

Since I haven’t seen an article regarding the Rockies not trading Story, I will post it here, since it is the same division. Coors is a glorified beer garden. I mean that in the nicest way, it is one of the most enjoyable places to take in a game. I feel like when the management moved Arenado and instantly got blasted for it they decided they do not care. They are making money hand over first from beer sales. People still go there. I’d be curious to see profit from concessions because I assume they would be near the top. So what I think is they just held on to Story to piss people off. Because they do not care about the on field product. They aren’t the only team, but they seem to be the only one who doesn’t currently care about optics.

natedub
5 years ago
Reply to  carter

That’s a ridiculously cynical take. It’s also most likely incorrect.

I loathe to defend the Rockies here, but I think the fact that people still show up to the ballpark created a value conversation for them. I have family in Denver and they go to almost every Rockies game. They cared tremendously when the Rockies traded Arenado. They didn’t want them trading Story. Or Blackmon. Or Marquez. And most of the fans largely don’t care that the Rockies didn’t trade any of those guys for a handful of players who’ll spend the next 1-4 years in Albuquerque, Hartford, or Asheville.

We learned, quickly, from 2020 that ticket sale revenue matters. And I’m not sure that Coors Field becomes much of a draw if they don’t have Arenado or Story or others. I’m just not. And so I could see that being a factor in not trading Trevor Story. They actually do care about their fans and they likely know that their fans are more interested in Trevor Story than they are Alan Trejo.

waters96
5 years ago

They got a guy who won’t add much. He is a shadow of his former self. Longoria 2.0.

channelclemente
5 years ago

Fans are ecstatic with Bryant trade. They might dance in the streets sans Covid.

johnforthegiants
5 years ago

I don’t think it’s accurate to simple say they signed bryant for his bat. They also signed him because he can play multiple positions, at two of which (3b and 1b) they have old but still relatively high quality players (longoria and belt) who are out with injuries which they may or may not successfully come back from this season. If either of they can’t come back, bryant can fill in for him. If both of them successfully come back, bryant can play the outfield. That’s a really good fit for this team now.

sogoodlooking
5 years ago

“That, and a season without nagging injuries, have helped him turn back the clock…”

—This is silly, unless you mean to 2018, the worst of Bryant’s first 5 seasons in the majors. If he cranks it up he might get back to 2019, but let’s face it: 2015-2017 are irrevocably gone.

One of the interesting things about the upcoming offseason is, who is going to overpay for this 3 win player going into his age 30 season? Even 5/$100m seems unwarranted—and to think he once rejected $200m.

VinnieDaGooch
5 years ago

Where is SeñorGato at? He kept saying the Cubs wouldn’t do a firesale