Gerrit Cole Signs Nine-Year, $324 Million Deal With Yankees

As first reported by Jon Heyman of MLB Network, the New York Yankees have signed Gerrit Cole to a nine-year, $324 million contract. That’s $36 million per season, making it both the most money and the highest average annual value a pitcher has ever earned, eclipsing the $35 million AAV contract Stephen Strasburg inked yesterday.

Cole’s deal fits a pattern we’ve seen this offseason where free agents — particularly big ticket signees — have earned more money than we anticipated at the outset of the winter. As has been the case for most contracts signed by players on our Top 50 Free Agents list, Cole signed for both more years and more money than we projected. Kiley McDaniel forecast that he’d sign a seven-year deal for $242 million ($34.5 million AAV), while our crowdsourcing effort estimated seven years and $224 million ($32 million AAV).

If any pitcher could command that kind of deal, it’s Cole, who is the consensus best pitcher in baseball. Though he narrowly lost out on the Cy Young to former teammate Justin Verlander, the 29-year-old’s dominant performance down the stretch and in October established him as a unique force to be reckoned with throughout the playoffs, and ensured he’d be the top free agent on the market this winter.

Cole’s ascension from talented-but-inconsistent starter to bona fide ace is familiar by now to most readers: After leaning heavily on his sinker throughout his time in Pittsburgh, the Astros tweaked his repertoire after acquiring him in advance of the 2018 season. He started throwing his four-seam fastball more often, and also increasingly leaned on his slider and curve. His numbers ticked up immediately:

Houston Had a Solution
Year ERA FIP xFIP K/9
2016 3.88 3.33 4.02 7.60
2017 4.26 4.08 3.81 8.69
2018 2.88 2.70 3.04 12.40
2019 2.50 2.64 2.48 13.82

If anything, those statistics understate how dominant Cole became by the end of his tenure in Houston. Across 121 innings over his last 18 regular season starts, Cole struck out 186 hitters while posting a 1.63 ERA; batters hit just .174/.222/.313 over that stretch. One can only wonder how much lower those numbers would have been in a year without such a homer-happy ball, as for all his success, he did allow 29 dingers last season, some of which pretty clearly would not have left the yard in previous years. It’s scary to think that Cole may yet have another gear in him, but if he can miss bats like he has in recent seasons while also allowing fewer dingers, the Yankees are poised to reap the benefits from a historic campaign.

For the Yankees, the affect of the signing is profound. They’ve added an ace to go along with Luis Severino at the top of the rotation, an injection of impact talent at a position of (relative) weakness. With J.A. Happ out of favor and Domingo Germán in a different kind of limbo after being placed on administrative leave in the wake of a reported violation of the Joint MLB-MLBPA Domestic Violence Policy, the Yankees rotation appeared thin at the outset of the winter. It now looks a whole lot stronger, and the addition of Cole solidifies New York’s position as the overwhelming preseason favorite to win the AL East, and perhaps makes them the team to beat in the American League.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed.
We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member.
1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other.
2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off.
3. Dark mode and Classic mode!
4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them.
5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects.
6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.)
7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only.
8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO.
9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members.
10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features!
We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it.

It also ends an era in which the Yankees were unusually quiet on the free agent market: New York hadn’t signed a nine-figure free agent since inking Jacoby Ellsbury and Masahiro Tanaka back in 2014, though they did absorb more than $200 million on Giancarlo Stanton’s contract. While this doesn’t necessarily signal a return to the days in which the wage bill for the Bronx Bombers dwarfed that of their competitors, it’s a familiar financial flex for fans who grew up watching the dominant Yankee teams of the aughts and late-90s. Last season, the rotation was a weak point. With Cole in tow, in 2020 it won’t be.





Brendan covers prospects and the minor leagues for FanGraphs. Previously he worked as a Pro Scout for the Pittsburgh Pirates.

28 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
m_pemulis
6 years ago

Wow.

DmitryMember since 2016
6 years ago

If this signals the end to the Yankees austerity, and they start permanently acting like a big money team, I love this.. if this makes them gut the roster down the road in service of dropping below the luxury tax, it will make me sad. Let’s hope they keep reinforcing the team while the young core is still there

Cool Lester SmoothMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  Dmitry

Yep. This really shouldn’t have impacted their ability to retain Didi in any way.

That said…YES!!!!!

Pepper Martin
6 years ago

I don’t believe it did. They saw Gleyber as their SS of the future, and that’s that.

TheGarrettCooperFanClub
6 years ago

Reports have said the Yankees were not really interested in a Didi reunion, not really about the dollars (they could have offered him the qualifying offer, matched the Phillies deal), but instead they want Gleyber to be the SS next season.

Cool Lester SmoothMember since 2020
6 years ago

Here’s hoping we have some young exec screaming I’M SO FUCKING HAPPY WE GOT COLE into the Astros’ faces, next fall.

Bolton
6 years ago

I guess we won’t have months of collusion conjecture this offseason. That’s a plus.

stever20Member since 2017
6 years ago
Reply to  Bolton

yeah, Tony Clark has been MIA here the last 2-3 weeks.

Cool Lester SmoothMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  Bolton

Let’s wait a bit on that front.

stever20Member since 2017
6 years ago

a guy like Howie Kendrick getting 6.25 M as much of a reason as anything….

Already have 19 of the top 50 signed, with 6 of the top 10 signed now- and 2 of the top 3.

markymarc767Member since 2020
6 years ago

I’m Still wrapping my head around the idea of Paxton as a third starter and how a guy like Montgomery probably won’t even have a chance to make the rotation.

stever20Member since 2017
6 years ago
Reply to  markymarc767

if Paxton is 3rd starter that means Tanaka is 4th starter.

carterMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  stever20

Paxton wasn’t great last year but he’s def better than Tanaka

Cool Lester SmoothMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  carter

They were a rounding error apart by either form of WAR, last season…and by RA9-WAR over the last two.

TheGarrettCooperFanClub
6 years ago
Reply to  markymarc767

German is likely to be suspended for a long time, so pending another acquisition (I think Happ will be dumped at some point), Montgomery should the 5th starter to start nest season anyways.

Roger21
6 years ago

So did 2019 bring us a juiced offseason in addition to a juiced ball? What would Harper and Machado have gotten had they been free agents this year?

oozyalbies1
6 years ago
Reply to  Roger21

I don’t think they would have (or should have) gotten much more. While their free agency was hyped for the years leading up to it, they both proved to be relatively flawed players (especially Machado).

Now, Anthony Rendon on the other hand..

BrendanMember since 2018
6 years ago
Reply to  oozyalbies1

Agree. The quality level of the players this year is just much higher.

CJMember since 2020
6 years ago

Now I’d like to see Yankees get some LHBs, even average ones, if with other values (defence, speed..)

stonepie
6 years ago
Reply to  CJ

i thought villar was a decent fit, would love to see him run wild in the 9 spot in YS

feslenraster
6 years ago
Reply to  CJ

And a CF.

fuster
6 years ago
Reply to  CJ

Lindor would be a rather good fit

jskelly4
6 years ago

”it’s Cole, who is the consensus best pitcher in baseball. ”. He’s the CONSENSUS best pitcher in baseball? This seems like a pretty big exaggeration.

SubtleSlightMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  jskelly4

Yeah. Pretty sure I’d go with deGrom myself.

Fredchuckdave
6 years ago
Reply to  jskelly4

I guess that’s supposed to read best* (if you include age)

Dave from DCMember since 2018
6 years ago

“For the Yankees, the _effect_ of the signing is profound,” though in this case I suppose the “affect of the signing” is pretty pronounced, too, for elated fans.

Mike NMN
6 years ago

This is both “stupid money” and not. It’s of course too much and too long, but if you want what’s on sale, and there’s a scarcity of the product (not too many Coles our there) then you pay the price. Best case scenario–he’s an ace for a few years, ages gracefully like a Greinke (or a Mussina) and should that happen, the Yankees will be thrilled. Of course there’s risk.

feslenraster
6 years ago

Crazy.

But from Yankees point of view, necessary.