FanGraphs Baseball

How Good Were The 2014 Giants?

The World Series is over, and though the San Francisco Giants have nailed down their third championship in the last five seasons, there is seemingly no time to savor the accomplishment. Qualifying offers are being extended, the first offseason transactions have begun to trickle across the wire, and hot stove season will soon begin in earnest. This week, however, let’s take one last look at the two World Series participants from a top-sided, macro perspective. How good were the Giants and the Royals, in various aspects of the game? Today, let’s take a look at the champion Giants. Read the rest of this entry »


Initiating the Cubs’ Next Level

The word we’re supposed to use is “introduced”. As in, the Cubs introduced Joe Maddon on Monday as the team’s new manager. Really, Maddon’s a guy who needs no introduction, and in addition to that, Maddon isn’t a guy you bring in, as an organization, unless you feel like you’re on the verge of something. Maddon isn’t a guy you give five years and $25 million, as an organization, unless you feel like you’re entering a new era. The Cubs didn’t want to get rid of Rick Renteria, but at the same time, this wasn’t an opportunity they could let pass by. As was noted in the days prior to Monday’s press conference:

On Friday, Epstein said Maddon “may be as well-suited as anyone in the industry to manage the challenges that lie ahead of us.”

About those challenges — there are always challenges, for everyone, and there are certainly always challenges in Chicago, but the challenges that lie ahead now are quite different from the challenges that were ahead a few years back when the Cubs overhauled the front office. The idea now is that Maddon can help the team transition from loser to winner, and though that’s what all losers want, the Cubs are in a particular position. Maddon spent a chunk of his press conference talking about the 2015 playoffs. Theo Epstein, at the end of the regular season, also talked about the 2015 playoffs. The Cubs see Joe Maddon as the first step in a new level. The Cubs now intend to be serious about the present. So how far away are the Cubs from looking like a competitive team?

Read the rest of this entry »


2014 Free Agent Leaderboards

The offseason is officially underway, as free agency begins today. The exclusive negotiating period ended yesterday, 12 qualifying offers were made, and now any player not under contract can negotiate freely with any team he desires, so long as they desire to negotiate with him, at least. You know the big names and the guys who are going to get all the money, but you probably don’t remember every player on the market, or all the various options at each position. That’s what we’re here for.

Thanks to the initial hard work of Steve Adams at MLBTradeRumors, and piggy-backing off the list created by Jeff Passan at Yahoo Sports, I’ve created a Free Agent Leaderboard that runs 176 players deep, including 79 hitters and 99 pitchers. I’ve done my best to remove any player who had an option that was picked up, though since this was a manual effort, I may have missed one or two; feel free and leave corrections in the comments below.

Because the leaderboards are generated based on sorting players who have already appeared in the big leagues, none of the international free agents are included, so this isn’t quite a complete list of every player available this winter, but it does reflect every player I could find that has played in MLB over the last few years.

You’ll note that the default setting from that link is to display all position players performance over the last three years. Too often, free agent lists and rankings are based off just the most recent year performance, when multiple years of data often provide a better perspective on a player’s true worth. Now, certainly, one should not assume that Chase Headley is really going to produce +5 WAR per season going forward — as he has averaged over the last three years — but the 2012-2014 leaderboards do serve as nice reality checks when we start putting too much emphasis on the last six months.

Read the rest of this entry »


Sunday Notes on Tuesday: Defense, Defense, Defense — Jackie Bradley Jr & more

Jackie Bradley, Jr. might win a Gold Glove tonight. He should. The Red Sox centerfielder is an American League finalist at his position along with Adam Eaton and Adam Jones. He easily outpaced both in Fielding Bible balloting, with only National Leaguer Juan Lagares ranking higher.

Then again, Bradley probably didn’t hit well enough to win a traditional Gold Glove. [Yes, the ghosts of Derek Jeter and Rafael Palmeiro continue to haunt.] The 24-year-old rookie put up a scary-bad .198/.265/.266 slash line in 423 plate appearances.

Read the rest of this entry »


My Five Favorite 2014 Aroldis Chapman Facts

I noted in my FanGraphs Player of the Year voting explanation that I very badly wanted to find a place for Aroldis Chapman. Ultimately I couldn’t do it, not with Chapman being a reliever and with other guys not being relievers, but I wanted to give Chapman some support for a season that was almost impossibly outstanding and extraordinary. Aroldis Chapman is coming off one of my favorite single seasons ever, and with everything in the books, none of the numbers are changing. Because I couldn’t give Chapman a vote, I decided I wanted to give him one last front-page post.

I know the headline sucks and I know lists seem lazy, but I don’t know a better way to capture what I want to be captured. I want to touch on my five favorite Chapman facts, and this is the simplest way to keep them organized. These are not the five best 2014 Aroldis Chapman facts, recovered after hours of mining — probably, there are things he did that have so far escaped my attention. These are just my five favorite facts, out of the facts I’m aware of. There are some good ones that didn’t qualify. Against left-handed batters, Chapman last season posted a negative FIP. He allowed a .121 batting average and a .172 slugging percentage, while National League pitchers batted .125 and slugged .156. Chapman was great! Here now are five better facts, that I haven’t bothered to order. It’s like trying to pick a favorite child, except none of these facts will spill grape juice on the carpet.

Read the rest of this entry »


Rockies Extend Qualifying Offer to Michael Cuddyer

Well, we’ve got our first surprise of the offseason, as right before the deadline to extend qualifying offers, the Rockies announced that they were going to extend that to free agent outfielder Michael Cuddyer. By making the QO, Cuddyer now has a week to determine if he wants to accept a one year, $15.3 million contract, or hit free agency with draft pick compensation attached.

Without the QO, I think Cuddyer likely could have landed a two three year deal, probably in the $10 million per year range. In the Contract Crowdsourcing project, the median forecast was for $18 million over two years, so even if the crowd was a bit low, expectations were somewhere in that range.

Now, though, that contract is basically out the window, as it wouldn’t benefit Cuddyer to accept a second year that only guarantees him $4.7 million more than accepting the qualifying offer. In order to get a deal that would be more valuable than taking the 1/$15M QO, he’s probably going to need to get three years. And ~3/$30M, plus the forfeiture of a draft pick, is a high price to pay for a guy who played in 49 games last year and turns 36 next March.

Now, the market has historically overpaid for power, and as a right-handed hitter with the ability to drive the ball, Cuddyer would likely have commanded a premium in free agency. Especially because he also comes with the reputation as a great clubhouse guy and off-the-field intangibles. But we’re still talking about a guy with a Steamer forecast of +1 WAR next year, and that’s assuming he stays healthy enough to play most of the season.

As a player, Cuddyer isn’t all that different from an older Kendrys Morales, though he does offer a bit more defensive value in that he can theoretically run around the outfield a bit. Last year, Morales bet on this skillset getting paid, turned down the qualifying offer, and found out that the market for good-not-great hitters with limited other skills wasn’t what he thought it would be.

Will Cuddyer turn down a guaranteed $15 million from Colorado in order to find out how much more valuable the league sees him than Morales? I’m guessing no. And if he does take the deal, becoming the first player to accept a qualifying offer, the big question then becomes what the Rockies do with their already crowded outfield.


A Season Recap of the Little League Home Run

The World Series can be a stressful time for a lot of folks. It can be stressful for friends, family and players of the two teams involved, because every pitch seems like the most important pitch of the year. It can be stressful for writers, because we’ve got to find something interesting from each game and come up with a unique take on it in a very short amount of time. And it can be stressful for fans of other teams, because they wish it was their team playing in the World Series.

But that’s over now, and we’re on to the offseason, which is about as sad as the World Series is stressful, because there won’t be any more major league baseball played for several months. 🙁

In these sad, stressful times for baseball fans, I’d like to start the offseason with something fun: the little league homer. Alex Gordon nearly did it to tie game seven of the World Series with two outs in the bottom of the ninth inning. Had he scored, it would have been one of the greatest moments in World Series history. However, he was wisely held up at third base. But there were 18 other players during the regular season who weren‘t held at third base, after the defense kicked the ball around for a little while, and came home to score.

Rather than show you all 18 little league homers, I watched film of them all and selected the six most representative of little league play, along with a choice quote from one of the broadcasters. The first clip is the only instance, to my knowledge, of a player being thrown out while trying to stretch a little league homer this season. The other five are ranked, in descending order, by the value of various postgame “team snacks” received as a child when playing little league. Do not debate with me on this. The snack list is final.
Read the rest of this entry »


Evaluating the AFL All Stars: An Audio/Visual Experiment

At the Winter Meetings a couple years ago in Nashville, I happened to be sitting next to Kiley McDaniel — now himself the lead prospect analyst for this site — while he was looking over some video he’d recently taken of then-amateur prospect Lance McCullers, a right-hander now in the Houston system.

As a person who is both an idiot and also curious, I began asking McDaniel a number of simple-minded questions about McCullers and for what, specifically, McDaniel was looking as he went frame-by-frame through McCullers’ windup. I learned a considerable amount during that five- or ten-minute exchange — and ultimately asked questions that would have never previously occurred to me.

This past Saturday, I sat next to McDaniel again — in this case, behind home plate at Salt River Fields in Scottsdale, AZ, for the Arizona Fall League All-Star Game. Once again, I asked a number of idiot’s questions and, once again, McDaniel answered them (mostly) patiently.

What follows is an attempt to reproduce certain moments of that exchange. For five different pitcher-batter encounters during the AFL All-Star Game I’ve reproduced animated GIFs of relevant pitches. I’ve also included several minutes of audio of McDaniel commenting on particular aspects of the footage in question. For each of the encounters, the reader can push play for the corresponding commentary.

*****

1. Nick Howard, CIN (Profile) vs. Eddie Rosario, MIN (Profile)

Rosario Howard 3

Rosario Howard 3 Slow

Read the rest of this entry »


FG on Fox: Smart Things Baseball Players Said This Year

Talk to the players as much as you can. Read about what they think. They are smart about baseball, and they can tell you things you never thought of before.

Nobody knows as much about the physical aspect of game play as the men who actually suit up to play it. Knowledge of the mechanics of the game of baseball should inform best practices, even if those insights come in a different form and language from the results we get from empirical research. So talk to the players. I have, and they’ve said some very smart things.

10) Sam Fuld, Athletics’ outfielder: “Ever notice that nobody talks about the length of the games when they talk about injuries being up around baseball?”

Read the rest on Just a Bit Outside.


Explaining Our 2014 Player of the Year Votes

Earlier this afternoon, we announced that Clayton Kershaw was the winner of the 2014 FanGraphs Player of the Year Award. In this post, we have asked each of the 10 FanGraphs authors who received a ballot to explain briefly explain the process they used to reach their conclusions. Their full ballots are included below, followed by that explanation.

Read the rest of this entry »