Rays Bounce Into Game 5 After 12-Inning Thriller

Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. — It didn’t always feel like a Rays home game. Multitudes of Brewers fans, unable to procure or afford tickets to Wisconsin’s first World Series games in 44 years, had flown to Florida to see their team clinch. But home field advantage played a part in the Rays’ improbable, dramatic 12-inning 4-3 win in Game 4 to extend the World Series at least one more night.

The Tropicana Field turf is one of the fastest playing surfaces in the league, and the Rays are able to derive an advantage from it that no other team can extract from its own home field. So while the Brewers took the lead in the top of the 12th by hitting the ball in the usual direction — up, in the form of Cooper Pratt’s solo home run — the Rays struck back with four grounders and a liner in the bottom of the inning.

The decisive hit, by Ben Williamson, went straight into the turf, bounced over Milwaukee’s drawn-in five-man infield, and landed… who cares where. The Rays are still alive.

FanGraphs Playoff Coverage Is for Members
You must be a Member in order to read our postseason coverage. You can read our announcement here, but it's not the only reason you should consider becoming a Member. Membership includes:
✓Ad-free browsing
✓Unlimited FanGraphs & RotoGraphs articles
✓Historical & platoon projections
✓Leaderboard & player-page stat heatmaps
✓One-click data exports
✓Customizable player-page dashboards
✓Dark & Classic site modes
✓Weekly Members-only mailbag
✓FanGraphs Walk-Off, your year in review
✓Optional homepage photo removal
✓Gift articles to non-Members
✓Full postseason coverage




Michael is a writer at FanGraphs. Previously, he was a staff writer at The Ringer and D1Baseball, and his work has appeared at Grantland, Baseball Prospectus, The Atlantic, ESPN.com, and various ill-remembered Phillies blogs. Follow him on Twitter, if you must, @MichaelBaumann.

25 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
EltnegMember since 2020
14 hours ago

Gutsy win by the Rays, I’ll admit I thought it was over after Pratt’s homer. I have no idea what the Rays do for Game 5 pitching now, though. Rasmussen on short rest and then just cobble something together after that?

Only consolation is the Brewers’ best bullpen arms all got worked hard tonight (except Megill) so if Miz gets knocked out early it could be chaos for both teams. Should be fun!

Brian ReinhartMember since 2016
10 hours ago
Reply to  Eltneg

The Rasmussen/Martinez switcheroo is now the central decision of the whole series.

I’m guessing the Brewers bring Megill on right after Miz and hope the two of them can get through 7 with a comfortable lead before rolling the dice on anyone else.

Rays have to go Rasmussen? And then quick hook for…Matz to take a turn through the order? Kelly should be OK if things are close.

Ivan_GrushenkoMember since 2016
7 hours ago
Reply to  Eltneg

I can’t see anyone else decent even being available. The pen pitched 8 innings.

I can’t see getting eliminated with Matz and Seymour.

The only other remote option is Peralta.

Sonny LMember since 2017
6 hours ago
Reply to  Ivan_Grushenko

I think it was the 10th inning but the camera cut to the Rays dugout and Peralta was going to town on his arm with the theragun. He’s available today

Ivan_GrushenkoMember since 2016
5 hours ago
Reply to  Sonny L

Then I’d start him, and use everyone except Rasmussen and maybe even him.

At least give the home fans a win.

branflakesMember since 2024
14 hours ago

That was some incredibly bad babip luck for the Brewers, everything found a glove, hope the worm turns tomorrow.

raregokusMember since 2022
12 hours ago
Reply to  branflakes

I think you might have this backwards. The Brewers had insanely good BABIP luck the first 3 games, the worm turned in game 4.

MichaelMember since 2017
10 hours ago
Reply to  raregokus

12 of the 13 hardest hit balls were by the Brewer’s. 9 of the12 resulted in outs.

Thornton MelonMember since 2020
10 hours ago
Reply to  raregokus

For game 3, absolutely the case. But game 1 brewers were -.011 ba vs. xba (vs. +.028 for rays), and game 2 brewers were +.019 vs. -.016 for rays…so basically they both got about what you’d expect

raregokusMember since 2022
12 hours ago

Really feels like they’re just staving off the inevitable, but I’ll never complain about getting more baseball

JoeyVottoIsGoneMember since 2016
8 hours ago

“Rays, Rays, against the dying of the light!!”

drewcorbMember since 2020
7 hours ago

Ask five fans what the roughest ways to lose a game is, and you’ll get five different answers. Through the first three games of the World Series, the Rays had offered a variety of crushing losses fit to suit any taste.

Oof tough but accurate

OnWI1933Member since 2016
7 hours ago

Joey could have run halfway to first and still gotten Junior.

Convinced if they get the first out inning plays out differently.

Sigh

cashgod27Member since 2024
7 hours ago

I don’t know why, but I’m actually getting this feeling the Rays could, at the very least, make this a series. They’ll be huge underdogs tonight, but that means if they win, the Brewers will be SWEATING on that flight back to Milwaukee.

Nevertheless, Murphy made the right call trying to close it out with the dregs of his bullpen instead of Misiorowski. When you’re up 3-0, you really just need to avoid a catastrophic scenario, and burning Miz and losing would be pretty catastrophic.

Gho5tRun3rMember since 2016
7 hours ago
Reply to  cashgod27

If there was any team that could make history by winning 4 in a row after losing 3 in the world series, it’s the Rays… Unfortunately, the other team that could do that is the Brewers which they’re currently up against.

tdmocMember since 2023
6 hours ago
Reply to  Gho5tRun3r

Yes, the Rays make their own luck. It’s just that the Brewers also make their own luck.

John WickMember since 2018
6 hours ago
Reply to  cashgod27

Miz is out of gas and (arguably) has been their third-best starter in the playoffs — their Game 6 and 7 starters have pitched well. Even with a loss tonight, I don’t think they’ll be sweating going back to Milwaukee needing to take one of two at home — they’re a composed team that has handled adversity just fine.

David Klein
6 hours ago
Reply to  cashgod27

I thought he he should have used Megill for more than one batter, and I would have kept Sentzela in after the error.

Bud SmithMember since 2020
6 hours ago
Reply to  cashgod27

If that’s the dregs of the bullpen, then what do you call Kyle Harrison?

OnWI1933Member since 2016
5 hours ago

So a few plays of interest. Caminero not being called out when he was well into the grass avoiding the tag from Hamilton. Aranda basically tripping Chourio. Which was due to the second baseman channeling Sax or Todd Walker with his throws. And of course Yelich being rung up on a checked swing that wasn’t close to the Diaz swing that had so many online in a tizzy

Not looking to start anything. Just looking for others thoughts.

maximus74Member since 2025
4 hours ago
Reply to  OnWI1933

Caminero was barely on the grass, definitely not anywhere near the 3 feet that is necessary to rule a runner out

aldenMember since 2019
3 hours ago
Reply to  OnWI1933

Tag/baseline rule has nothing to do w where the runner is relative to the dirt and grass (or turf in this case) iirc. If I understand the gist of the rule the baseline only exists when a fielder makes an attempt to tag a runner, then the baseline is created in a line straight from where the runner is at the point a tag effort is made to the base and the runner is allowed 3 feet on either side of the line to avoid the tag attempt.

OnWI1933Member since 2016
2 hours ago
Reply to  alden

FWIW I have seen runners called out exactly to what transpired in the game. Hence the question

Baffled why being curious on what others think gets downvoted.

O'KieboomerMember since 2021
3 minutes ago
Reply to  OnWI1933

A good clue that you’re not at all correctly understanding the basepath rule is that neither Hamilton nor his team protested whatsoever nor asked to review it.

drewcorbMember since 2020
4 hours ago

“No one expected us to get here. We had a 1% chance, according to a lot of writers, to make it to the World Series, and we had a 5% chance going into tonight to win the World Series. So, by those odds, we had a five times better chance to win the World Series. So, I like our chances.”

This line from Jax is a pretty good one that made me laugh to myself