The Cardinals Sign the Last Pitcher for Miles

Miles Mikolas
Jeff Curry-USA TODAY Sports

The Cardinals have put themselves in a bit of a bind. They take sustainability seriously, building to compete both now and tomorrow. They never rebuild, never go all in, and always balance the present and future responsibly. If your goal is to win forever, you have to think about more than just the next year when you make a decision. For all that focus on long-term planning, though, they have a lackluster rotation, and it’s slated to get a lot worse after this year.

Of St. Louis’ top five starting options, only one, Steven Matz, came into the spring under contract for 2024. That might not be a problem if there were a heaping helping of starting pitching prospects knocking on the door to the major league clubhouse, but there aren’t. Gordon Graceffo isn’t far off, and if you’re willing to do a lot of projecting, Tink Hence might be major league ready before too long, but the up-and-down fifth starters and swingmen with live arms that other teams use to bulk up their starting rotation in times of need don’t really exist here.

Now, the Cardinals have two starters under contract for 2024 after signing Miles Mikolas to a contract extension that will pay him $40 million for the 2024 and ’25 seasons, as Derrick Goold first reported. That doesn’t exactly create a complete 2024 starting rotation, but it’s twice as many pitchers as St. Louis had before last Friday. Bam, problem solved!

I mean, yeah, technically, problem solved. But there are a lot of different ways to solve this particular problem, so I thought it might be nice to use this article to contemplate both how St. Louis ended up in this particular spot and why the team chose to offer Mikolas an extension rather than make some other pitching move.

First things first: let’s look at the projected rotation. It’s not the projected Opening Day rotation, as Adam Wainwright won’t be ready in time, but if things go according to plan, these are the five starters the Cards will count on throughout the year:

Projected Starting Rotation, 2023
Pitcher Joined Team Age Under Contract Through
Adam Wainwright 2005 41 2023
Miles Mikolas 2018 34 2025
Jack Flaherty 2017 27 2023
Jordan Montgomery 2022 30 2023
Steven Matz 2022 32 2025

While the Cardinals have turned out useful hitters in bulk amounts in recent years, they haven’t produced a starter good enough to stick in the rotation since 2017. Even that hasn’t been a walk in the park; Flaherty is tremendous when he’s on, but he’s battled inconsistency and injuries for most of his career. He’s also headed to free agency this year and probably isn’t open to a contract extension.

Montgomery is the next logical choice for an extension. He’s on the team because of that aforementioned glut of young hitters; he came to the team in a trade that sent Harrison Bader to the Yankees. He was solid for the Cardinals down the stretch, though he faded at the end of September. I still think the team would happily ink an extension with him, but I can see why he might want to test free agency given how close he is to the promised land already.

Because of that 2017–22 gap, the Cardinals don’t have a normal complement of pre-arb and early-arb starters to fill in the back half of their rotation. It’s not even an issue of no arms they can trust; there just aren’t many options, period. Jake Woodford is filling in for Wainwright to start the season, but the Cardinals prefer to use him as a reliever. Our positional power rankings shouldn’t make Cardinals fans much more optimistic. Matthew Liberatore should figure into the picture a bit, and Dakota Hudson is still around, but the cupboard is exceedingly bare.

Most likely, the Cardinals planned on needing extra starters before the 2024 season. Wainwright looked cooked from 2017 to ’20, so projecting him to be around in ’23 was far out of the picture. Even after a resurgent 2021 season, ’22 made sense as a last ride; he and Yadier Molina could head off into the sunset together. But Wainwright was good enough to stick around for another year. That’s delightful for Cardinals fans, and probably a good thing for the 2023 season, but it left no room for signing a starter this offseason.

Would your starter bump Flaherty from the rotation? Matz? Those seem like the best options, but they don’t seem like great options, particularly given that the Cardinals just aren’t the kind of team that shops at the top of the market. Taijuan Walker is St. Louis’ kind of pitcher, but it seems like a weird fit for a team full of third and fourth starters to go out and grab one in free agency without an obvious place in the rotation.

That leads me to Mikolas, who has two things going for him: he’s reliable, and he already pitches for the Cardinals, which means they won’t need to add salary this year for a role where he’d be underutilized. It’s weird to think about, but the Cardinals like to do a lot of building for next year this year, and next year was looking shaky indeed.

Imagine a world where the Cardinals went into the offseason with no one other than Matz retained. Could they count on Graceffo and Liberatore to lock down two rotation spots? Not exactly; realistically, penciling them in for 30 combined starts is probably closer to the mark. That would leave the Cardinals hunting for three starters in free agency next winter, and it’s not a banner year. Maybe Max Scherzer wants to play one last year where he grew up. Maybe the Nootbaar bromance from the WBC brings Shohei Ohtani into play (not likely). Short of that, though, it’s Julio Urías, Luis Severino, or a variety of sketchy options.

It’s a tough year to need three starters. Any year is a tough year to need three starters, but this one seems particularly tricky. Three might even undersell it; there’s no guarantee that the youngsters will hold down their spot. This same rough predicament happened to the Mets this season, and it’s a good thing that Steve Cohen is as rich as Croesus, because their solution was to sign Justin Verlander, Kodai Senga, and José Quintana, a move the Cardinals certainly won’t be duplicating.

That brings us to Mikolas, and I should probably talk about him at least a little bit in this article about his new contract. He did exactly what the Cardinals hoped for in 2022, throwing 200 innings with a dead-average FIP and a ton of balls in play. That let the best defense in baseball feast, and feast they did: Mikolas’ 3.29 ERA was comfortably better than his true-outcome stats would suggest. If he delivers that performance in each of the years of his contract, the Cardinals will be quite pleased with the deal.

That level is no guarantee, though. Mikolas made only nine starts in 2021, and he missed the 2020 season entirely. When he’s healthy, 200 innings of average baseball is what he delivers — he had roughly the same season in 2019 — but health is clearly not a given, and some of his peripherals started to slip in 2022 even as his surface-level statistics still shone. ZiPS, which makes a habit of digging into peripheral and predictive statistics as a matter of course, thinks Mikolas will be worth only 1.6 WAR this year, followed by a *combined* 1.6 WAR in the 2024 and ’25 seasons. You hardly have to do the math; if he hits that projection, things won’t work out for the Redbirds. Some of that is injury risk — ZiPS calls for a combined 250 innings in 2024 and ’25, which is far less than a full complement — but some of it is just what happens when a starter who never possessed top-notch stuff starts aging.

So yeah, two years at $20 million a pop sounds high for that. If you were evaluating this on a dollars-per-WAR basis, I don’t think you could convince me this deal makes sense for the team. Busch Stadium is a perfect fit for Mikolas’ skill set, and he’s beaten the projections before, but $20 million will sign you an average starter for *sure* in free agency these days. Chris Bassitt, Jameson Taillon, and Walker all signed for roughly that amount just months ago.

To me, this deal is all about reducing uncertainty, even if it means making an offer too generous for Mikolas to refuse. Competing every year is hard; competing every year with a semi-consistent payroll is harder. Doing so when you need a huge talent infusion in the starting rotation is harder still. It’s entirely possible that the Cardinals could have filled their starting needs next season, but I’m fairly certain that they didn’t want to mess around and find out what might happen.

Probably, Mikolas will be good but not great for them this year. Probably, they’ll go into the offseason looking to add starting pitching. Probably, a few guys who pitched better than Mikolas in ‘23 will sign for less than him in the offseason, and Cardinals fans will grumble about it. Those aren’t bold predictions; they’re median expectations.

If you told John Mozeliak, the Cards’ president of baseball operations, that all of these things would happen, I doubt he’d be surprised. I think the median outcome of this deal is that the Cardinals spend slightly more money employing Mikolas than they’d have to if they acquired similar production in free agency after the season.

That’s just the cost of protecting against downside risk, though. It was easy to imagine some truly bad scenarios for the Cardinals after this year. Maybe Matz would get hurt again, Graceffo wouldn’t pan out as smoothly as expected, and they’d go into next year needing an entire new rotation. Maybe they’d miss out on their top five targets in free agency because they misjudged the speed of the market and end up offering big contracts to players they weren’t sure about. If you aren’t willing to take a year off of competing and don’t have an internal pipeline providing cheap innings, you have to worry about these eventualities.

Each of them is less likely after this extension. Even if Mikolas ends up being an overpay, it’s a risk-reducing overpay. I’m fairly certain that St. Louis will still try to engage Montgomery in contract extension talks and would do the same with Flaherty if it thought he might accept. Continuity is important, and having enough trustworthy pitching to fill an entire season is not a given. The Cardinals just showed how much they believe in those statements with this contract extension.





Ben is a writer at FanGraphs. He can be found on Bluesky @benclemens.

28 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
sadtromboneMember since 2020
3 years ago

The Taillon and Walker contracts told me that there has never, ever been a better time to be a starting pitcher who produces at the rate of being a 4th starter and threw for at least 150 innings the previous year. And Mikolas threw for a lot more than that.

So IDK if this is an “overpay” based on the current market. Mikolas isn’t that different than Taillon and Walker except he pitches more, and it’s for fewer years (although he is also older). But I have some doubts that the current market is going to hold, because it seems like there has to be a better way to spend your money than this.

Roger McDowell Hot Foot
3 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I really don’t know where the pitching market is going at this point. You could see it as an overdue pendulum swing back toward reliable bulk innings from back-of-the-rotation guys, but that story runs up against the reality that it’s happening at the same time that starting pitchers are throwing fewer innings than ever before. The free-agent dollars should probably be expected to go the same place that the innings are going. Maybe there’s a new market premium on (perceived) durability, but, as the article suggests, that doesn’t seem to apply very well to Mikolas.

bosoxforlifeMember since 2016
3 years ago

It will take a while, actually quite a while, for me to get a grasp on Miles Mikolas signing an extension for $40M for 2 years. I find the contradiction between starters getting huge deals while not even reaching the number of innings needed to qualify bizarre. Mikolas at least usually reaches 162 but I will take 5 Sandy Alcantatra’s if I may.

hazelrah
3 years ago
Reply to  bosoxforlife

There’s only 1 Sandy though

MorboTheAnnihilator
3 years ago
Reply to  bosoxforlife

Maybe we can trade Carlson for Alcantatra.

juliusMember since 2021
3 years ago

Not my first choice to go $20/yr on, but the ‘stache adds 25%

Last edited 3 years ago by julius
PemtlcMember since 2018
3 years ago

Their tendency to push prospect starters to the bullpen when they reach the majors has had some success, like Helsley, but it can also be frustrating to watch. Pitchers like Pallante, Woodford, and Thompson could all potentially fill out the back end of a rotation, but they get pigeonholed into a bullpen or swing role before they get a chance to make a string of consecutive starts.

I’m of the opinion that Alcantara and Gallen being traded away was the best thing that could happen to them. If they’d stayed with the Cardinals there’s a realistic possibility the team never would have given them the chance to pitch regularly in the rotation. Cy Young winner Sandy Alcantara would have been eighth inning set up guy Sandy Alcantara.

Last edited 3 years ago by Pemtlc
sadtromboneMember since 2020
3 years ago
Reply to  Pemtlc

I don’t really agree with this. Those guys you mention haven’t rally shown a lot that makes one thing they would be a decent 5th starter. And Liberatore keeps getting starts even though he’s a mess. Dakota Hudson too (although admittedly, with St. Louis’s infield defense it’s probably the one place he is reasonable as a 5th starter).

I would say that the bigger issue is that St. Louis has far, far more success with developing position players than pitchers. That’s true of most teams, because developing pitchers is hard, but it seems particularly extreme here. I guess we’ll see what happens with Graceffo, Hjerpe, and Hence (all of whom look interesting in one way or another).

PemtlcMember since 2018
3 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I don’t really agree with this. Those guys you mention haven’t rally shown a lot that makes one thing they would be a decent 5th starter. And Liberatore keeps getting starts even though he’s a mess.

Thompson has started one game in the majors out of 22 appearances; he started 29 games out of 41 appearances in AAA. I’m not saying the guy would be a three win pitcher in a rotation, but bringing him up and instantly making him a lefty reliever seems like incuriosity on the part of management, especially given the rotation needs the last two seasons.

Pallante has gotten more starts and was admittedly mediocre.

Woodford made a handful of starts the last 2 years and was average, although his stuff improved after some tinkering last year. He was all set for the swing role this year until Wainwright got hurt. Of the three pitchers I mentioned, I think he has the best shot at taking a spot going forward.

Liberatore has that pedigree shine and he’ll be 23 this year. He had a decent spring. Still time for him to figure it out.

I would say that the bigger issue is that St. Louis has far, far more success with developing position players than pitchers. That’s true of most teams, because developing pitchers is hard, but it seems particularly extreme here.

You’re right, but that perception would be considerably different if they’d held onto Alcantara and Gallen (assuming of course that the team would have let them start).

Last edited 3 years ago by Pemtlc
Lanidrac
3 years ago
Reply to  Pemtlc

I don’t think Thompson is in the bullpen for good. He’s just needed more in the bullpen for now. I fully expect him to compete for a rotation spot next year if not sooner.

Last edited 3 years ago by Lanidrac
Eucker's Tuba
3 years ago

A trade of Gorman (who’s playing out of position) for a SP would make a ton of sense, whether at the deadline or next winter.

Lanidrac
3 years ago
Reply to  Eucker's Tuba

It depends on how things go before then. If he really lights it up, they’ll want to keep him as their primary DH vs. RHP.

Ivan_GrushenkoMember since 2016
3 years ago
Reply to  Lanidrac

OK but that’s not as valuable as a starting pitcher. Juan Yepez can do that job

Broken BatMember since 2020
3 years ago

Ben, was waiting fir the chat yesterday. When were the subscribers advised you were cancelling it?

snakestl
3 years ago

Maybe pointed out somewhere in the comments, this is not a straight 2 year 40M extension. This deal tears up the final year of his 2020-2023 extension, which would have paid him 15.75M. Instead, he will receive 18.75M in 2023, and then 16M in each of 2024 and 2025.

https://legacy.baseballprospectus.com/compensation/cots/national-league-central/st-louis-cardinals/

Lanidrac
3 years ago
Reply to  snakestl

…plus a $5M signing bonus. They’re basically taking the $8M or so they initially wanted to spend on a lefty bat and tacking it on to Mikolas’s 2023 salary while still leaving enough in the budget to improve at the trade deadline.

Last edited 3 years ago by Lanidrac
fjtorres
3 years ago

If StL likes to take on back end starters there’s a lot of them in their mid-20’s.
They just need to identify a couple they can trade for, especially on teams with more limited budgets and no stomach for 8 digit salaries to back end starters.

tdouglas
3 years ago

The flip side of only producing solid position players is that you can trade them to bolster your pitching. STL has been super successful adding pitching mid-season and for a reasonable cost — I think they believe this method of pitching acquisition is the cheapest in baseball. Considering what it cost to acquire Montgomery and Quintana, it’s hard to disagree.

Gorman and Yepez aren’t going to get them a superstar, but they are more than enough to get a solid mid-rotation guy. If they build packages around each individually, it would be easy to get a mid-rotation and back-end rotation piece. Neither of these players will hurt to lose, though I wonder if the Cardinals want to give up a lefty slugger, considering the dearth of lefty talent in their organization.

I think this is just biding time to see how many empty slots Hence, Liberatore, Graceffo, and Woodford can fill in 2024. They’ve got a full season to make their claim. Once this year is over, they’ll know if they need one, two, or three pitchers.

fjtorres
3 years ago
Reply to  tdouglas

Yepez very likely.
Gorman? Maybe a four.

Lanidrac
3 years ago
Reply to  tdouglas

Also, don’t forget about Thompson likely moving to the rotation next year, plus Hudson can still work his back into being the mid-rotation type guy he used to be.

Ivan_GrushenkoMember since 2016
3 years ago
Reply to  tdouglas

I’m not sure about this. Reds got something comparable for Tyler Mahle. Joe Ryan, A’s traded Sean Manaea, Chris Bassitt and Frankie Montas for not that much.

Lanidrac
3 years ago

You seem to be forgetting quite a few of the Cardinals’ good depth options. Woodford is a pretty good swingman who is filling in for Wainwright right now. While he’s preferred in the bullpen, Pallante did a nice job as a rotation fill-in last year. Hudson has a decent track record and could make his way back to the Majors before too long. Thompson will probably be ready for a rotation spot next year, and maybe Liberatore as well, who is still a pretty good prospect.

Still, none of those guys are going to be able to immediately replace the outgoing talent next offseason., so this Mikolas extension was badly needed and at a pretty good price.

Lanidrac
3 years ago

I don’t know how long he can keep it up, but Mikolas *does* have top-notch stuff. He just gets it done through limiting walks and hard contact rather than a ton of Ks, which is a perfectly good alternative approach that has led him to become a legitimate 2-time All-Star. Having an excellent defense behind him does help, but it’s not a necessity, and he’d still do pretty well even on a team like the Phillies, just maybe not the Rockies.

fWAR for pitchers has always been an absolute joke by being based on FIP, despite the myth that pitchers have little control over balls in play being debunked many years ago, and it’s doubly so for a pitcher like Mikolas. There’s no reason not to suspect him to only decline gradually with age, which would still make him around a league average pitcher by the end of his new contract, and it’s more likely that it ends up being a small bargain over market prices.

Last edited 3 years ago by Lanidrac
hazelrah
3 years ago
Reply to  Lanidrac

Give us SIERA F-War!!

sadtromboneMember since 2020
3 years ago
Reply to  Lanidrac

Mikolas’s xERA last year was virtually identical to his FIP so, yeah, I’d say FIP-based WAR got his contributions pretty clearly.

Cool Lester SmoothMember since 2020
3 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Of course…he’s also consistently (and dramatically) beaten his xERA.

ZiPS actually projects him to have the same gap, this season…which translates to ~2.7 RA9-WAR in 156 innings (3.1 if you use the ZiPS DC IP count).

Mikolas is a high-end 3rd starter, and quite a bit better than the Walkers and Taillons of the world.

This is a very reasonable deal.

cardnationhoncho
3 years ago

The first thing the Cardinal scouts need to do is understand why their pitching results have not been what is needed. Look at Houston — what did they do right?? What is the Cards’ selection criteria/strategy?? We need adjustments!!

eely225Member since 2019
3 years ago

I appreciate a good Croesus ref when I can get one