The Seventh Their Heaven, the Braves Beat the Marlins in NLDS Game 1
By and large, today’s NLDS Game 1 between the Braves and Marlins followed a predictable script. Atlanta came in having lost just once all year with Max Fried on the mound, and while the southpaw wasn’t sharp, he held the fort long enough for his homer-happy teammates to take control. Rallying behind long balls by Travis d’Arnaud and Dansby Swanson — and buoyed by the usual strong bullpen effort — the Braves prevailed by a score of 9-5.
The top of the first didn’t portend what was to follow. Fried’s first inning comprised just 11 pitches — it would have been eight had third baseman Austin Riley not committed a two-out throwing error — and all of them were strikes. A repeat of last week’s pitch-efficient, cruise-control effort versus the Cincinnati Reds looked to be in the works.
Looks can be deceiving, though Miami’s starter didn’t exactly string together goose eggs either. Two pitches into Sandy Alcantara’s outing, Atlanta led 1-0. Reminding everyone that he’s one of baseball’s best players, Ronald Acuña Jr. deposited an outside fastball into the right-field seats at Houston’s Minute Maid Park. (Hello bubble.) The tale of the tape was 428, the bat flip was just juicy enough, and Alcantara was anything but happy.
The top of the second began with Miguel Rojas catapulting a Fried offering 418 feet into the left-field seats. The Miami shortstop isn’t exactly what you’d call a bopper, but his regular season might be best described as boffo. Asked about his breakout with the bat — Rojas logged a career-high (by far) 142 wRC+ — he pointed to a confluence of opportunity and experience.
“Remember, this my third year playing every day,” Rojas told me in late September. “Early in my career it was kind of tough, because I wasn’t playing every day. Once you have that opportunity, you start to know what the pitchers want to do to you, and that creates confidence. I feel like that’s the key to my success as of late.”
The third inning offered ample evidence that Fried wouldn’t be going deep into the game. Hits by Magneuris Sierra and Jon Berti put runners on the corners, and Garrett Cooper sent both scampering home with a double into the left-field corner. Then Brian Anderson plated Cooper with a single to center. It was 4-1 Fish, and Fried was very much on the ropes. He otherwise survived the onslaught, only to be done for the day an inning later.
The top of the fourth nearly included pugilism. Alcantara plunked Acuña with a 98 mph heater to the hip, and the Braves outfielder was understandably miffed. Fortunately, cooler heads prevailed — this despite it being Acuña’s fifth plunking by a Marlins’ hurler — and nothing transpired beyond some icy glares and a handful of choice words. Braves manager Brian Snitker, despite some obvious irritation, told reporters after the game that he didn’t think it was intentional.
Alcantara paid the piper for his errant offering. Acuña scored on a Marcell Ozuna double, before d’Arnaud drove Ozuna in with another of the same. Suddenly it was 4-3 and Atlanta’s band of merry hit-makers was just warming up.
Fried had managed to avoid a KO when he took damage in the third. By the end of the seventh, Alcantara and the Marlins were, for all intents and purposes, flat on the mat.
“We’re a big-swinging team,” Snitker had said during the Cincinnati series. “We slug.”
And that’s what they did. Yimi García replaced Alcantara on the mound with two on and one out in the seventh, and promptly gave up a game-tying single to Ozuna. Then he surrendered a three-run gopher to d’Arnaud. Ozzie Albies then reached, after which Swanson swatted Atlanta’s second home run of the frame. A 4-3 deficit had turned into a commanding 9-4 lead, and it was all over but the shouting.
García had come into the inning not having allowed a home run all year.
Five Atlanta relievers proceeded to seal the deal. Matt Joyce knocked in a Miami run with a pinch-hit single in the eighth, but it was too little too late. In a game that included 21 strikeouts — seven by a predictably stingy Braves bullpen that allowed just three baserunners over five innings — it was ultimately the Atlanta offense that carried the day. As they’re wont to do, Snitker’s club slugged.
Game 2 is tomorrow afternoon.
David Laurila grew up in Michigan's Upper Peninsula and now writes about baseball from his home in Cambridge, Mass. He authored the Prospectus Q&A series at Baseball Prospectus from December 2006-May 2011 before being claimed off waivers by FanGraphs. He can be followed on Twitter @DavidLaurilaQA.
You throw behind a guy at 98, you have to be gone, sorry.
U throw 98 u less likely to control*. Fixed. Was 0-1 count
“despite it being Acuña’s fifth plunking by a Marlins’ hurler this year.” It was actually the 2nd of the year and the 5th of his career. This compares to Brian Anderson and Miguel Rojas, who have each been hit by the Braves 6 times in their careers, in comparable numbers of plate appearances.
Thanks. Sloppy mistake on my part. Correction made.
Really sloppy relative
Have those players been hit soon after hitting home runs on multiple occasions?
In fairness, Acuña hits homeruns at a much higher rate than they do.
It really doesn’t compare if you look at how Rojas and Anderson were hit by Atlanta pitchers.
Rojas was hit once by José Ramírez in 2017, twice in the same game by Julio Teherán in 2018, once by Sam Freeman in 2018, again by Julio Teherán in 2019, and once by Chris Martin in today’s game. Rojas was nailed by Ramírez and Freeman with fastballs. Teherán grazed Rojas with his two-seamer twice, and hit him in the thigh with an off-speed pitch once. Chris Martin hit Rojas with an 0-2 breaking ball that didn’t break.
https://www.mlb.com/marlins/video/miguel-rojas-hit-by-pitch-brian-anderson-to-2nd
https://www.mlb.com/marlins/video/miguel-rojas-hit-by-pitch-guR2Jf
https://www.mlb.com/marlins/video/miguel-rojas-hit-by-pitch-derek-dietrich-to-2nd
https://www.mlb.com/marlins/video/miguel-rojas-hit-by-pitch-JL8YVu
https://www.mlb.com/marlins/video/miguel-rojas-hit-by-pitch-7ekNxH
https://www.mlb.com/marlins/video/miguel-rojas-hit-by-pitch-pwreUC
Brian Anderson has been HBP 36 times from 2018-2020. 3 times by the Braves in 2018, twice in 2019, once in 2020. Once by Teherán, once by Sean Newcomb, and once by Touki Toussaint, all with fastballs. Anderson was hit three times with back foot breaking balls, once by Jesse Biddle, Jerry Blevins, and Tyler Matzek each.
https://www.mlb.com/marlins/video/brian-anderson-hit-by-pitch-0iVxsN
https://www.mlb.com/marlins/video/brian-anderson-hit-by-pitch-rafael-ortega-to-2nd
https://www.mlb.com/marlins/video/brian-anderson-hit-by-pitch-8SIHal
https://www.mlb.com/marlins/video/brian-anderson-hit-by-pitch-austin-dean-to-3rd-rosell-herrera-to-2nd
https://www.mlb.com/marlins/video/brian-anderson-hit-by-pitch-ILquWa
https://www.mlb.com/marlins/video/brian-anderson-hit-by-pitch-zBN3Lu
At this rate we’ll get the Braves and the Yankees in the world series where the winner of each game always gets double-digit runs.
Missed the game… Is there anything behind throwing at a dude up 0-1 though? Y waste a pitch if u hitting dude. All announcers said is history and all i found is homer in first. Highly doubtful on purpose. Unless u scum and don’t care about team.
Why waste a pitch if hitting someone? To make it not as obvious that you’re throwing at them.
That’s exactly what Greg Maddux did on July 18, 2000, in a game against Tampa Bay. In the 9th inning, after throwing a ball to Jose Canseco, he nailed him in the thigh with a changeup. At the time, Maddux said it “slipped.” Later, the real story came out.
https://www.ocregister.com/2008/12/08/maddux-was-a-sight-to-behold/
If you are up 8-2 in the 9th inning on a regular season game, sure.
In the 3rd inning of a playoff game with a 3 run lead, you’d have to be a complete idiot to intentionally throw at the hitter.
Listening to Alcantara after the game, pretty sure his idiocy is complete.
I need to use expressions like “as of late” more, like Rojas apparently does: “I feel like that’s the key to my success as of late.”
A short chronology of Ronald Acuña Jr. getting hit by Marlins pitchers.
1. August 15, 2018. Jose Ureña hits Ronald in the elbow with a 97 mph first-pitch fastball. The catcher is set up low and in.
2. August 23, 2018. 2nd at-bat: Against Elieser Hernandez, Ronald hits a two-run home run to deep left/center field.
4th at-bat: With two outs, no-one on, and two strikes, Javy Guerra hits Ronald in the arm with a 94 mph fastball up and in. The catcher is set up middle up.
3. August 20, 2019. First pitch, Elieser Hernandez hits Ronald in the ribs with an 87 mph fastball. The catcher is set up middle in.
4. September 7, 2020. Ahead 4-3, with two outs and no one on in the 4th inning, Jose Urena hits Ronald up and in with a 95 mph fastball. The catcher is set up low and in.
5. October 6, 2020. 1st at-bat, Ronald hits a leadoff home run off Alcantara. 2nd at-bat, ahead 4-1, with one out, Sandy Alcantara hits Ronald in the waist with a 98 mph fastball. The catcher is set up low at the knees and inside.
You can watch all of these here:
https://www.mlb.com/marlins/video/00u88m8foozYW24jF356/reels/a-short-history-of-ronald-acuna-jr-getting-hit-by-the-marlins
The Marlins aren’t grazing the uniform.
They aren’t hitting the shoetops with a yanked slider.
This isn’t Charlie Morton hitting Ronald in the hip with a 76 mph curveball by accident.
The Marlins have been nailing Ronald in the elbow, the ribs, and the hip with fastballs.
They aren’t throwing up and in to get him to back off the plate. They’re throwing *at* him.
In 44 games against the Marlins, all Ronald has done is hit 29 singles, 9 doubles, and 17 home runs.
He’s slashed .318/.414/.665 (1.079 OPS) against the Marlins.
With today, the Marlins are responsible for 25% of Ronald’s HBP total (5 out of 20). The next highest teams (Mets, Brewers, and Rays) have only 2 HBP.
This is just the latest episode of Marlins pitchers throwing a baseball at Ronald Acuña Jr. for hitting their mistakes out of the park.
The umps should have tossed Alcantara.
It’d be one thing if it were mere retaliation. This is a game tactic in line with body line bowling (worth a google). Basically a bet that the umps are so loathe to impact the game that the Marlins can get away with throwing at the other team’s best player and goad a response. If the Marlins were shameless, they’d do it every game after Acuna does some damage.
Alcantara certainly should have been ejected. MLB’s current enforcement isn’t adequate to what the Marlins are doing. They’ve made it clear they’ll throw at him intentionally, and if the only response is to warn both sides, then they’ve effectively gotten away with it. Throwing at someone intentionally is an automatic ejection, and intent should not be assessed as if there’s no history between this team and this player.
You can either enforce this effectively, which will probably cause the Marlins to cut it out (losing your starter in the second or third inning is a serious enough penalty that Mattingly might bestir himself to stop it), or you can wait until they break Acuña’s hand or wrist or jaw.
I think if they can show it’s an organizational thing you punish it at the org level. Which means no remedy now, but it gives the mlb more room to maneuver in terms of severity. Right now it’s either too little to deter anything ( a warning) or too much (throwing alcantera out basically ends the game for the Marlins and deeply hurts their chances to be
Competitive in the series- and hey maybe people feel that’s appropriate ). Take some prospects away (just an example) seems a strong enough disincentive that would solve a lot of problems.
I’m not sure if it’s an organizational thing at the level of management telling players to do it. I suspect it’s more a part of the culture of the Marlins locker room—throwing at Acuña is one of the ways a pitcher shows that he belongs.
The part that’s organizational is not stepping in to stop it. That’s within management’s power if they bothered to do it.
Good job by Jeff Wilpon and Brodie Van Wagenen by rage cutting d’Arnaud after all of 25 plate appearances last April. Happy for Travis for all of his successes since being cut here. Oh and Mets fans forget that he was a big part of the 2015 team even if he played under 100 games that year.
Let’s be fair, the Dodgers signed him to a nearly-zero deal after he cleared waivers (indicating zero interest) and then traded him to the Rays for cash considerations five days later, and in Tampa Bay he found a magical hot spring which cured him of all his ailments forever. But everyone had given up on him.