The Twins are Also Winning at the Box Office

The Twins have done a lot of winning lately.

Entering games on Monday, Minnesota was 36-16. No team in baseball had more wins, and no team in baseball had a better record. They’ve been buoyed by a potent offensive attack, becoming just the second team in baseball history to hit 100 home runs over their first 50 games in a season. Their pitching, too, has been quite good, as one might expect for a team that is already 20 games over .500 this early into the season.

Clearly, the 2019 season is going just about as well as the Twins could have expected. They’ve already built a double-digit lead in the AL Central, and their playoff odds reflect this newfound dominance:

The only place where the Twins were struggling was in attendance. As Craig Edwards chronicled at the end of April, baseball attendance to begin this season was a mixed bag. But the Twins in particular seemed to face difficulties putting people in the seats at Target Field. At the end of April, their average home attendance of 17,007 fans was the ninth-lowest in baseball, and their year-over-year change of -4,065 fans per game represented the third-most per game of any team.

Those weren’t promising numbers, especially for a team that had jumped out to a 17-10 record after the first month, holding an early AL Central lead.

In the weeks since, though, the Twins’ attendance has seen a major turnaround. On Sunday, Target Field hosted its largest crowd since 2016, with an official attendance of 39,913. That represented the third time in four games that the park hosted a crowd of at least 30,000. With that in mind, take a look at the Twins’ 5-game rolling average attendance since the beginning of 2017. (Single admission doubleheaders were counted as one game for this graph.)

Overall, the Twins’ remarkable month of May has brought their season-average attendance per game up to 19th in baseball, a three-spot jump, and their year-over-year change in fans per game has increased to just -659 fans. If this trend continues, I wouldn’t be surprised if the Twins find themselves with more fans at the ballpark in 2019 than they did in 2018.

Of course, none of this should be shocking to you. The Twins are in first place, and this would probably be more of a story if the team still wasn’t drawing well even after all of these wins and this large division lead. But what’s so interesting to me is just how quickly the Twins were able to see their attendance complete a full 180-degree turn.

I see this great run boiling down to a few factors.

First, warmer weather. Over Memorial Day weekend, Minneapolis enjoyed a great three days of baseball weather: a 72-degree and partly cloudy first pitch on Friday, a 66-degree and partly cloudy first pitch on Saturday, and a 68-degree and sunny first pitch on Sunday. Those sound like gorgeous days to spend outside watching first-place baseball to me.

But despite the lovely long weekend, weather can’t be the only variable in the Twins’ attendance rebound. Last April saw average temperatures in Minneapolis 13.4 degrees lower than the average, the coldest among teams with outdoor stadiums, according to research from Accuweather.

Here’s a graph showing Minneapolis temperatures in April 2018:

And now here’s a graph showing Minneapolis temperatures in April 2019:

As you can see, there appear to have been more typical temperatures in 2019, and yet the Twins still drew 4,000 fewer fans per game this April compared to last. So, while it’s easy to point to weather being a main factor in this recent run of success at the box office, it’s likely not the only reason why more Twins fans are at the ballpark.

The second theory that could apply here is affordability. You may recall that, on May 8, the Twins announced they would be selling $5 tickets for the remainder of their home games this month. They sold 20,000 tickets within a day of the announcement and, due to the large volume of interest, released over 10,000 more.

Affordability has often been cited as a main reason why baseball fans would rather watch the game at home. Teams have attempted to tackle the issue of affordability in different ways; one of the more popular options that we’ve seen in recent years has been the ballpark pass, something the Twins offered even before this $5 ticket promotion was announced.

But through this new strategy, the Twins have continued to make affordability a priority, even if it was for just a few thousand seats per home game. They were rewarded with significant interest in the team, which in turn probably sold plenty of seats on its own. With those two factors—affordability and interest—combined, the Twins were able to draw an enormous crowd like they did this past Sunday.

Still, it’s likely none of this would have happened without all of the victories that the Twins have piled up. Good weather is important to convincing fans to grab a ticket and hot dog, and so is affordability, but team success probably also has a significant impact. In this specific case, it’s hard to distinguish what exactly has led to these increases; it is likely a combination of all three of these things, potentially more. Still, it’s great to see fans in the seats at Target Field, supporting this surprisingly successful Twins season.





Devan Fink is a Contributor at FanGraphs. You can follow him on Twitter @DevanFink.

33 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
DustyColorado
7 years ago

Just imagine the attendance figures if they stopped playing service time manipulation games and called up Wander Javier.

dewelar
7 years ago
Reply to  DustyColorado

In case this isn’t a joke, which I’m about 95% sure it is, but anyway…

A 20-year-old who missed all of last year, has played one game in A-ball this year, and plays the same position as the best-hitting everyday player on the team? Really?

DustyColorado
7 years ago
Reply to  dewelar

Yes really Mr./Ms. Dewelar. Wander Javier’s will is stronger than your doubt.

Billsaints
7 years ago
Reply to  DustyColorado

Are you his Dad?

DustyColorado
7 years ago
Reply to  Billsaints

No? That’s a weird question to ask Bill. Are you?

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  dewelar

Check out Dusty’s twitter account sometime if you want the full-on crazy.

dewelar
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

No thanks. Twitter’s interface is lousy when you don’t see well like myself. I consider it half-a-step up from Reddit, which is the bottom of the barrel. I’ll just remember not to take the user seriously going forward 🙂 .

DustyColorado
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Thanks for sending new followers my way, sadtrombone. Wander Javier’s will is stronger than your doubt.

rhswanzey
7 years ago

Compare to Cleveland, which saw stagnant attendance entering this season in spite of their three year run of dominating the AL Central. If attendance had followed success, perhaps they wouldn’t have faced a mandate to cut payroll from a playoff caliber core. Alas, they gave a great opening to the Twins by gutting the offense for cost savings. That’s a shame for Cleveland. Lindor and their rotation *is* the window you build for.

v2miccaMember since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  rhswanzey

I would say that attendance has a strong correlations with winning and success, it also has a strong correlation with novelty and change. The Twins have been bad for a while. Now they are really good. Not only do they get the bump from being competitive, but also from being a welcome change from the past. In a Hypothetical scenario in which the Twins take over as the presumptive power in the AL central for the next 3 years, but fail to ever win a World Series, I suspect their attendance numbers will peak at some point in year 2 of the run, and decline there after.

rhswanzey
7 years ago
Reply to  v2micca

Yeah, pulling up the BBref page, this model is more accurate re: Cleveland’s recent run. Cleveland got a boost in interest following their WS loss to the Cubs, although they’ve peaked at just 9th in the AL during the Lindor run. The year before Lindor arrived, they actually finished last in the AL for per game attendance, despite winning 85 games and coming off of a wild card berth. I didn’t realize it was possible to actually be outdrawn by Tampa Bay.

Their 17,031 per game so far this season is less than half of average attendance for the late ’90s/early ’00s core, and their lowest since 1992.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago

I’m really happy that a team decided to prioritize getting fans out to the ballpark. Not only does it direct some extra money to the team and lead to some more concession sales, it makes for a better game experience for everyone when it’s full. And it gets people in the habit of going to the ballpark with their family or friends, which pays greater dividends to the team and baseball as a whole. While I suspect those seats that were $5 were the cheapest ones in the stadium, it’s still a lot easier to get in the habit of going to the game at $5 than at $20, much less the $50-$70 ones.

cowdiscipleMember since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Target Field is a nice little ballpark. There really isn’t a bad seat, especially for $5.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  cowdisciple

Unless it’s seriously obstructed-view, I can’t imagine anyone complaining over $5 tickets. That’s like minor league pricing.

BryzMember since 2019
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

There’s only a couple problematic obstructed-view seats in the entire ballpark. (One off the top of my head, the last row of the lower deck has a couple seats that are obstructed by the handicapped row the next section over, which blocks the view of home plate.) They did a fantastic job building the ballpark.

timprov
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

This will probably be more common now that the entertainment tax deduction is gone. Teams are no loner quite so incentivized to keep average prices high even if it means empty seats.

tunglashrMember since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I know I am in the minority, but I have a very different view on this. I used to go occasionally and would get the $20-25 seats. They were fine, but the crowd sucked. it was a hassle to get food or go to the bathroom, and the parking was a nightmare.

Now I exclusively get more expensive tickets, and I will never go back to cheaper seats. At least in Seattle, the better seats are very much worth it. I get All Star Club, and they come with VIP parking across the street, unlimited (very good) food and soft drinks, and a cash bar. There is also a semi-private bathroom that is never busy. These seats are like $125-150 each (from season ticket holders), and when you calculate the cost of food and parking, its not much more than the cheap seats. For someone like me, just the fact that I never have to deal with a crowd almost makes it worth it even without the free food.

Obviously I am very fortunate to be able to spend that much money on seats for a game, but in a case like this the value really makes it worthwhile. Its like going to a really nice restaurant that also happens to have a live sporting event in the background. I went to 17 games last year, which is more than I had gone to in my whole live before that.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  tunglashr

I get this. Once upon a time, I scored free tickets right behind home plate in DC for a Nationals game, four or five rows back. I just googled it and I think it is called “Diamond Club” now, although I think it may have been called something else then. In any case, it was utterly extravagant, with free (glorious) food and parking, and the best view of a baseball game I’ve ever had in my life.

It was way out of my price range then, and now too, but sometimes I go back and think about what it was like to be able to call balls and strikes myself. Everything was nice, but the view is what I miss more than the food and parking.

TheGarrettCooperFanClub
7 years ago

It definitely doesn’t have anything to do with Astudillo coming off the IL, but I still am convinced it’s 100% because Astudillo came off the IL

barrybondsjuicedforoursins
7 years ago

Minnesota fans are frontrunners. It’s pretty simple.

timprov
7 years ago

Yeah, we run from cold fronts.

timprov
7 years ago

The temperatures overall may have been more normal, but the actual April home games were the 12th through the 18th, which sucked, and the 26th through the 30th which weren’t much better. In the early-month spike they were in New York and in the mid-month spike they were in Baltimore and Houston.

Also we had a seriously difficult winter this year and there’s a hangover effect, especially with a high-variance spring. Even now we’re a little reluctant to believe in a nice day more than an hour or so in advance, which makes planning to go to a baseball game difficult. When you look at a graph like 2018 that gives you confidence that going to a baseball game next week will be better and you can go ahead and buy your tickets in advance. 2019 has not been like that.

BryzMember since 2019
7 years ago
Reply to  timprov

It also gets really cold once it gets dark. It can be 70 and sunny early in the game, then seemingly 55 and windy in the 7th.

DBPanterA
7 years ago
Reply to  timprov

Well said. The local tv meteorologists have had a fun time with their own graphs which have shown the average temperature for the month has been below average for every month in 2019. The precipitation in various forms is above average, which is why the farmers are anywhere from 10-12 days behind schedule in planting their crops.

I was at a weekend game a few weeks ago and had to buy a Twins winter stocking hat, in mid-May, to get through it. It’s been very trying, but I do believe that once the temperature increases and hopefully we get several days in a row without rain, the crowd size will not be an issue.

The front office threw out a statistic that somewhere around 70% of the $5 tickets (standing room only) were purchased by people that had not been to Target Field in the last several years. The promotion was a success as it got new customers inside the ballpark.

dbminnMember since 2016
7 years ago

The Twins played at home March 28-30, April 12-18 and April 26-30. There was only one home-game day where the temperature was above average. It was miserable. Game time temperatures between 30 and the low 40s.

The ticket offer was a great way to get fans back to the park. With a winning team, they’ll keep coming.

gja6722
7 years ago

What’s interesting is that the Twins have one of the most limited promotional schedules in the MLB. Their recent stretch of good attendance featured only one promo item, being one of 4 Joe Mauer bobblehead days.

That said, 5-game rolling average may not be the best way to represent the success, as there are differing numbers of weekend games. In May 2018, the Twins had 9 weekday and 3 weekend games. This season, 6 weekday/6 weekend. What is encouraging though is that the Saturday and Sunday games vs. White Sox > 39,000 fans are easily the best non-Opening Day attendance games in the last two seasons.

June should be interesting to look at. They have 9 weekday and 3 weekend games again, including 3 weekdays vs. Red Sox, as well as Joe Mauer day. If they can average 27,000 fans again in June, then they have a really good shot of beating last year’s attendance.

ThrasiusMember since 2016
7 years ago

I don’t think I’ve ever criticized a FanGraphs article. However, this article clearly didn’t match up the weather to the actual home games. It’s pretty apparent weather was a major factor. Despite that, the article dismisses it.

Still, I would enjoy more articles that analyze the relationship between the baseball and business sides of the league and its teams.

Gus
7 years ago

Remember when MLB, in their infinite wisdom, voted to contract the Twins and Expos by a margin of 28-2 in 2001? With the Twins franchise flying high and the return of the Expos on the horizon, this seems like a million years ago.

ScottyB
7 years ago

Am I missing something?
This article reports that the team with the best record in baseball has the 19th best fan attendance, and is on pace for fewer fans than last year, all despite having ridiculously low priced tickets. Right?

timprov
7 years ago
Reply to  ScottyB

The “ridiculously low-priced tickets” is a bit of an overstatement. They released a limited number of their worst seats for $5, and those tickets sold out in the first few hours. Then they “increased” them by selling a bunch of standing-room tickets also for $5. I guess there are people who are happy to have a ticket to a baseball game that doesn’t include a seat, but I don’t understand them.

The vast majority of the seats in the stadium are priced on a par with the rest of the market.

ScottyB
7 years ago
Reply to  timprov

I’m from New York, and when we went to visit family in Minneapolis we went to the beautiful target field. We got amazing seats for $25 there. The kind of seats that would run in the 300+ range at Yankee Stadium.

timprov
7 years ago
Reply to  ScottyB

Yeah, wait until you see the kind of house you can buy here for $500k.

bjoakMember since 2020
7 years ago

Would love to see more articles like this. I’m really curious how the A’s All Access is working out.