Time to See if the Royals Will Trade From a Strength
There was precedent for Wade Davis‘ amazing Royals transformation. You could, for example, point to Wade Davis, in 2012. Or you could point to any number of other guys who’ve found comfortable homes in the bullpen after struggling as starters. But a year before Davis turned into an unhittable Royals reliever — that is, the same year that Davis was a very much hittable Royals starter — there was, in the same uniform, Luke Hochevar. Hochevar, for years, was a very mediocre starter. In 2013, he took off in relief, and he projected to be of great help again in 2014, until he blew out his elbow at the start of spring training.
So, Hochevar had Tommy John surgery. And the Royals, famously, didn’t miss him. They rode defense and their bullpen almost all the way to a championship, and then they arrived at more or less the present day. And after paying Hochevar millions of dollars to not pitch in 2014, the Royals are going to pay Hochevar millions of dollars to hopefully pitch in 2015 and beyond. Word’s out that Hochevar has re-signed as a free agent, for two years and $10 million, and now one’s left to wonder what the Royals might do about their roster construction.
Hochevar, today, isn’t even a year removed from his operation. The idea is that, following an ordinary timetable, he could be ready for the start of the next spring training, but we’ve seen enough guys struggle to come back from elbow surgery lately that nothing here is guaranteed. It’s very possible that Hochevar will experience setbacks; it’s very possible he might not even be ready to contribute until the break, or even until the year after. There’s uncertainty here, but the Royals clearly feel good about Hochevar’s rehab process, and as a reminder, here’s what Hochevar was able to do as a reliever in 2013. I’ll show you some stat categories, and then Hochevar’s percentile rank among big-league relievers who threw at least 40 innings.
| Stat | Percentile |
|---|---|
| K% | 91% |
| BB% | 76% |
| K-BB% | 93% |
| ERA- | 92% |
| FIP- | 79% |
| xFIP- | 90% |
| 1st-Strike% | 96% |
| Contact% | 82% |
At the meaningful stuff, Hochevar was very good. He missed bats, he threw early strikes, and he threw later strikes. He only got better as the season went on, and in case you feel like you miss action baseball .gifs, here are some clips of Hochevar from a dominant five-strikeout outing:
Hochevar worked with a fastball around 96, a cutter around 91, and a breaking ball around 80. That sounds a lot like Wade Davis, although Davis’ curveball is sharper, and I think you see where this is going. The Royals right now have last year’s bullpen, plus Luke Hochevar. So, how willing might they be to trade a piece away?
Some facts. For one thing, the Royals would like to contend again in 2015. That’s what you expect of a team that just finished a win shy of taking the World Series. And, of course, the Royals project to have baseball’s best bullpen. Steamer projects them at +5 WAR, and the runner-up’s at 2.9. It seems like the market is very excited about the prospect of available shutdown relief, since both Andrew Miller and David Robertson might end up with four-year contracts. Zach Duke got three guaranteed years after just one year of being productive. And there’s also the matter of the Royals’ needs. They’re short one starting pitcher, and they’re short one DH/RF candidate. A rumor I just saw linked them to Melky Cabrera.
If this were, say, the Red Sox, maybe it wouldn’t be a thing. The Royals aren’t the Red Sox. Last year’s opening-day payroll was just north of $92 million. Right now, the Royals have a 25-man roster that projects to earn just north of $88 million. There’s obviously some room to work with. The Royals made a very deep, very surprising playoff run, and that has significant revenue benefits. Historically, teams that’ve done something like what the Royals did have raised payroll. Next year’s Royals ought to get into nine-figure territory.
But they’re still the Royals, and they’re still presumably going to spend less money than most. If they put about $10 million toward the rotation hole, and another $10 million toward the DH/RF hole, you’d have a payroll close to $110 million. Maybe they’re willing to go that high, but if they wanted more flexibility, Davis and Holland will combine to make something like $16 – 17 million. How important are those pitchers to the Royals, given that Herrera and Hochevar will also be around?
The Royals know how they got where they got. They understand better than anyone how much they leaned on Davis and Holland in the later innings. So there’s going to be loyalty there, and a memory of how critical those pitchers were in the Royals’ best season in decades. On the other hand, other teams also saw how the Royals got so far. The Orioles, too. There’s currently a healthy market for relief pitching, and there hasn’t yet been talk of an available Aroldis Chapman or, say, Craig Kimbrel. How badly do the Royals need to pay Holland $9.3 million? Alternatively, how badly do they need to pay Davis $7 million?
It stands to reason that the Royals would be able to pull good talent back. Miller seems to be holding fast to his four-year contract demand. Robertson has been said to be seeking Jonathan Papelbon money. Holland’s got two years of control, and Davis has three years of club options. Given how dominant they were, the Royals could sell one of them for an immediately helpful piece or two, and because of how bullpen-chaining works, it might not even feel like so big of a loss. Granted, you can’t count on the other relievers to remain healthy and effective, but, the same goes for whichever reliever the Royals would elect to trade away.
Every team understands that relievers can be unreliable. Given the Miller and Robertson markets, teams are either willing to look past that, or they’re willing to make exceptions for the elite. Holland and Davis are elite. They’re of great value to the Royals, but the Royals don’t seem like a team that should have tens of millions of dollars occupying the bullpen. That’s a heavy investment in a volatile area, and such depth is a luxury, not a necessity. I’m not saying a great trade would be out there, but it seems like one could be, and Dayton Moore would be doing his team a disservice if he didn’t at least have some conversations.
Perhaps the Royals keep things as they are. Hochevar’s an unknown. As is, even if one of the big four were to get hurt, the Royals would have three good relievers remaining. Maybe the Royals want to wait to see how Hochevar pitches before they deal an arm elsewhere. But then, it would be tougher to stomach losing Holland or Davis once the season’s underway. There could be an opportunity right now. The Royals have by far the best bullpen in the league. How much of the best bullpen do they need?
Jeff made Lookout Landing a thing, but he does not still write there about the Mariners. He does write here, sometimes about the Mariners, but usually not.





The Royals got burned by standing pat with Joakim Soria, so trading Holland is probably a logical move. I tried asking Dave Cameron on today’s chat what either he or Davis could fetch on the trade market, but didn’t make the cut. Given the Royals’ status as contenders now, they would probably require major league ready offense, but off the top of my head I can’t think of any plausible trade partners.
The sox have too many OF and every team can use releif arms (Tazawa and Uhera are the only names really cemented in that pen)
Anytime Holland is mentioned, “Soria” is a response. Hollie may blow up, Ventura may blow up, they’re pitchers.
As for now having a Quadrinity, Dayton Moore may be thing that a lot of high leverage innings are worth similar money to a dominant starter. He may also remember that the Royals’ BP problems last year were in the 5th and 6th innings and adding Hoch to the mix allows the fireman Herrera to be used earlier yet, maybe even in the 2nd or 3rd to get out of an inning before the game is out of hand, then hand a clean start to middle-relief through the 6th.
Dayton Moore may trade, he may not. The team needs 60 games of a good defensive RF who can hit lefties and it needs an LH DH with some pop. After that, or maybe before, is another SP if the deal is right.
KC Dave poses the useful question, what would the trade of an increasingly pricey closer bring back when “Soria” comes to mind? Hollie likely is worth much more to the R’s than a trading partner and Royals don’t need a salary dump, so I’ld keep him and figure our which lefties will join the ‘pen, a couple are needed. This could be the start of the best bullpen ever.
Two “smart” teams, the A’s and the Rays, put big bucks into relievers last year – with disappointing results. KC’s season, of course, points in the other direction. The KC example seems to be carrying the day.
Billy Beane also traded prospects for starting pitching and he thinks Billy Butler might make a productive DH.
Beane has made some very questionable moves. Maybe he’s showing the As fans and the media “see, your stupid shit doesn’t work. Trading prospects for one shot at the playoffs with an ‘Ace’ is dumb”
The Butler I can’t defend at all. Don’t get it.
I agree they should look into dealing one of them but it really all depends on what they could get back. Thats the boring answer but its also the right one.
If they cant get much back then its not a huge deal. If having 4 stud relievers is a problem, its at least good problem to have.
“I’m not saying a great trade would be out there, but it seems like one could be, and Dayton Moore would be doing his team a disservice if he didn’t at least have some conversations.”
And with that, a new narrative was born! It has been decided that if Moore does not trade one of his better relievers, it will be for a lack of effort, not because he couldn’t find an appropriate deal. Because it is Dayton Moore.
The only narrative I see here is the “Fangraphs writers hang and burn Dayton Moore in effigy on the 2nd Tuesday of every month” narrative. Stating that a GM would do his team a disservice for not considering trading away a player is something a Fangraphs writer would potentially say in any piece, about any team. Nice try though.
You quote a sentence from the article and then disingenuously misrepresent what it says. He doesn’t say anything approaching what you claim. He clearly says, “Moore would be doing his team a disservice if he didn’t at least have some conversations.” You think that means that not trading one of them means Moore didn’t try. Clearly, that’s not what Jeff said.
Jeff very clearly states that a great trade might not be out there so, if no trade is made, maybe it’s because there wasn’t a great trade out there, NOT due to a lack of effort. You didn’t read it that way because you didn’t want to read it that way. If you had, you couldn’t then also be indignant about some phony bias against your favorite team.
You were looking for something to be outraged about and couldn’t find it so instead you concocted something to be outraged about.
Hey. Hey. I don’t come to Fangraphs for analysis and insight, I come to complain that Jeff and Dave HATE the (Royals/Phillies/Orioles/Albuquerque Isotopes). Take your “reading” and “understanding what words mean” somewhere else, bud.
I see this for sure being a great way to keep the window open.
As a Braves fan, I’d like them to consider trading Dyson and Colon for Gattis. Gattis is a better DH (probably) than Butler, can catch to give Perez days as a DH to rest his knees.
To make up for the loss of a 4th OF and MIF bench piece, could probably trade one of the four here for solid OF and MIFs. Everyone wins.
fangraphs arent the only one saying it. Others have said so because the demand is so high. But remember theyve found a rare animal. Holland is proven and very reliable. Giving away 1 could open up holes later. Hochevar is not ready. Their bullpen is still very top heavy and finnegan may still need time. I dont see them trading him until mid season if it comes to that.
Even if it opens up a hole, that’s only a 60-70 inning hole vs the value of possibly 150-200 innings for a starter or 600 AB for a player.
I’m not sure who would trade with them or for what though. My previous post I was thinking they still had Aoki for some reason. They should probably keep Dyson unless they trade one of their elite relievers for a better OF, which would be hard to find.
Its not the inninhs its the war. Herrera isnt close to as valuable as davis or holland is right now. Holland is to 2 to 3 war reliever who is reliable. We are talking chapmanish territory. Their bullpen is wonderful because of davis and holland combine for 5 plus war more than some bullpens. Trade holland away and davis geta hurt and all that value evaporates. Herrera is very good but davis and holland are on another level. Royals would need someone to at least replace hollands war level. But even then holland value comes in high leverage situations which is one reason they overachieved. It looks solid now but there is a reason bullpens this dominant are rare. Its so top heavy that its kind of a house of cards. Finnegan and hochevar alone cant match that value.
I like the idea of moving a reliever for an area of need. I can think of a few teams that consider themselves contenders that would love to have Davis in the fold. How bout Nats for Souza? Mets for Flores? Pit for Lambo? take on one of these post hype guys that are waiting to break out. heck, flip Davis to Tor for newly acquired Saunders. The pen is a strong point, which is where you should deal from. If it doesnt work out its only a 60 inning hole like antonio said.
Mike Ilitch would probably give KC the Red Wings in exchange for Wade Davis at this point.
The Royals will continue to play crazy close games next year with their decent but not great starting staff and slap hitting offense. They showed this is generally enough when they can shorten every game to 7 innings. Using this model they can probably win enough games in the regular season to make the playoffs; however they will burn out there relievers if they did this all season. If they want to win the way the won in the playoffs, they will need more than 3 shutdown relievers. They could trade Holland or Davis and try and win a different way, but why? The only thing that stopped them was Mad Bum’s unprecedented super human pitching.
Or their lack of plate discipline against MadBum…
Cespedes for Wade Davis and a prospect!
Don’t want a year of Cespedes in exchange for two of Davis plus a prospect. Cespedes was little more productive than Dyson, the OF he would replace, in half again more PAS than Dyson, so trading Davis and prospect to get 0.3 more fW sounds like a hang up on the call to me.
I don’t think the Red Sox would make a great trade partner for KC; Cespedes is intriguing to fulfill that DH role, but not really enough so that KC should want to “break up the band”, so to speak, just for one year prior free agency. There is no need for Victorino when you have plenty of non-tender candidates that would provide the same production (Andy Dirks comes to mind). KC already has better version of Jackie Bradley (Dyson), and presumably Mookie Betts and Rusney Casillo are untouchable. I’m actually starting to come around on Dave Cameron’s idea of signing Michael Morse to DH, and then leaving well enough alone with the bullpen.
Morse is possible, but the cost would be what Masterson will get or most of what Santana will bring in, and that for a player who looks like The Beast but has the durability of a butterfly.
R’s just need a LH DH and use RH for half rest days for Perez, Cain, Infante, and Escobar and to give some more PAs to Colon. And Royals do have Carlos Peguero at AAA who OPS’ed over 1.000 against righties last year and is doing well in the Dom, so solution may be in house to fill DH plastoon.
Sign Aoki for the RF platoon, then spend the remaining $16m+ for another starter to fill the #4 or higher spot. That $16m is close enough to what Shields will get to convince David Glass to authorize.
I could see Davis and Colon to Dodgers for Kemp. Maybe add one more prospect to entice LA to eat more of Kemp’s salary.
If Kemp is ok with DH’ing then maybe because in that giant OF he would be an absolute disaster.
But the Dodgers would have to eat A TON of his contract to even get to a starting point in this deal. Kemp would make about 1/4 of the Royals whole payroll and would for the next 5 years.