ZiPS 2023 Top 100 Prospects
For the eighth time, we’ve reached the point in the offseason where I run down the ZiPS Top 100 prospects. For those wandering in who may hear “ZiPS” and think of the University of Akron or possibly the popular Cincinnati burger spot, ZiPS is a computer projection system that crunches a lot of data about players and attempts to peer through the fog that obscures the future. More can be read about the system here or in MLB.com’s executive summary.
ZiPS is a useful tool, but the projections, whether for prospects or for baseball as a whole, are not intended to replace scouting. The purpose of ZiPS is to get the best answers possible from the data available, not necessarily to be the one-ring-to-prove-them-all-unified-field-theory-giant-Katamari-Damacy-ball of prognostication. ZiPS doesn’t see some things that scouts do. But by being able to process large amounts of data and instantly put those numbers into context and make adjustments, ZiPS also sees some things that scouts can’t. Computers and humans have different strengths, after all.
How well does it work? ZiPS, like human scouts, has its own share of gigantic misses (hello, Arismendy Alcántara), but it also has a number of notches in its virtual belt. ZiPS regularly ranked lots of future stars, such as Mookie Betts, Austin Riley, and Pete Alonso, significantly higher than consensus. Last week, a reader looked at Top 100 lists from 2018 onward and ZiPS did just as well as others, including naming the most players with 5 WAR so far (29).
Naturally, there is a lot of agreement between ZiPS and other lists when it comes to top prospects. Elite prospects tend to please both the scouts and the silicon, and 68 of this year’s ZiPS Top 100 overlap with the official FanGraphs Top 100. The ZiPS list should be used in addition to other lists, not in a mutually exclusive fashion.
I’ve adjusted the methodology of the rankings slightly, going with the interquartile mean for career WAR rather than the 50th percentile projection. That’s because, with the benefit of hindsight, it consistently slightly outperforms the 50th percentile rankings (though none of the actual rankings will be retconned for the ZiPS Cinematic Universe). ZiPS will still have a tendency to like high-floor, low-ceiling players more than scouts do. This is understandable given the nature of projections; scouts are optimistic by nature, traveling to Hagerstown or Kannapolis to see something special, not just to find a useful fourth outfielder or innings-eating fourth starter.
So, let’s get to the Top 100. The position listed reflects where the player has played the most recently; ZiPS is making no attempt to gauge where a team will choose to deploy a player, so take that into consideration:
ZiPS Rank | Player | Pos. | Organization | FanGraphs Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Corbin Carroll | CF | Arizona Diamondbacks | 2 |
2 | Gunnar Henderson | SS | Baltimore Orioles | 1 |
3 | Francisco Álvarez | C | New York Mets | 13 |
4 | Anthony Volpe | SS | New York Yankees | 11 |
5 | Orelvis Martinez | SS | Toronto Blue Jays | Unranked |
6 | Eury Pérez | P | Miami Marlins | 4 |
7 | Jordan Walker | 3B | St. Louis Cardinals | 12 |
8 | Grayson Rodriguez | P | Baltimore Orioles | 17 |
9 | Endy Rodriguez | C | Pittsburgh Pirates | 22 |
10 | Kyle Harrison | P | San Francisco Giants | 26 |
11 | Andrew Painter | P | Philadelphia Phillies | 5 |
12 | Masataka Yoshida | OF | Boston Red Sox | Unranked |
13 | Brett Baty | 3B | New York Mets | 23 |
14 | Ricky Tiedemann | P | Toronto Blue Jays | 24 |
15 | Elly De La Cruz | SS | Cincinnati Reds | 6 |
16 | Noelvi Marte | SS | Cincinnati Reds | 94 |
17 | Brandon Pfaadt | P | Arizona Diamondbacks | 16 |
18 | Jackson Chourio | CF | Milwaukee Brewers | 7 |
19 | Ezequiel Tovar | SS | Colorado Rockies | 41 |
20 | Taj Bradley | P | Tampa Bay Rays | 37 |
21 | Jasson Domínguez | CF | New York Yankees | 50 |
22 | Daniel Espino | P | Cleveland Guardians | 93 |
23 | Kyle Manzardo | 1B | Tampa Bay Rays | 42 |
24 | Curtis Mead | 3B | Tampa Bay Rays | 27 |
25 | Bo Naylor | C | Cleveland Guardians | 45 |
26 | Oswald Peraza | SS | New York Yankees | 40 |
27 | Addison Barger | SS | Toronto Blue Jays | 53 |
28 | Coby Mayo | 3B | Baltimore Orioles | 36 |
29 | Brayan Rocchio | SS | Cleveland Guardians | 54 |
30 | Bryan Ramos | 3B | Chicago White Sox | 60 |
31 | Matt McLain | SS | Cincinnati Reds | Unranked |
32 | Miguel Vargas | 3B | Los Angeles Dodgers | 48 |
33 | Alexander Canario | CF | Chicago Cubs | Unranked |
34 | Jose Salas | SS | Minnesota Twins | Unranked |
35 | Triston Casas | 1B | Boston Red Sox | 29 |
36 | Royce Lewis | SS | Minnesota Twins | 55 |
37 | Mick Abel | P | Philadelphia Phillies | 25 |
38 | Blake Walston | P | Arizona Diamondbacks | Unranked |
39 | Matthew Liberatore | P | St. Louis Cardinals | 107 |
40 | Andy Pages | RF | Los Angeles Dodgers | 58 |
41 | Marcelo Mayer | SS | Boston Red Sox | 18 |
42 | Robert Hassell III | CF | Washington Nationals | 112 |
43 | Ronny Mauricio | SS | New York Mets | 90 |
44 | Diego Cartaya | C | Los Angeles Dodgers | 28 |
45 | Ceddanne Rafaela | CF | Boston Red Sox | 49 |
46 | Pete Crow-Armstrong | CF | Chicago Cubs | 14 |
47 | DL Hall | P | Baltimore Orioles | 64 |
48 | Quinn Priester | P | Pittsburgh Pirates | 108 |
49 | Marco Luciano | SS | San Francisco Giants | 97 |
50 | Logan O’Hoppe | C | Los Angeles Angels | 51 |
51 | Brice Turang | SS | Milwaukee Brewers | 65 |
52 | Spencer Steer | 3B | Cincinnati Reds | 47 |
53 | Jordan Lawlar | SS | Arizona Diamondbacks | 15 |
54 | Tink Hence | P | St. Louis Cardinals | 74 |
55 | James Wood | CF | Washington Nationals | 3 |
56 | Josh Jung | 3B | Texas Rangers | 31 |
57 | Angel Martinez | SS | Cleveland Guardians | Unranked |
58 | Kodai Senga | P | New York Mets | 39 |
59 | Edwin Arroyo | SS | Cincinnati Reds | 52 |
60 | Maikel Garcia | SS | Kansas City Royals | Unranked |
61 | Mark Vientos | 3B | New York Mets | Unranked |
62 | Cade Cavalli | P | Washington Nationals | 63 |
63 | Ky Bush | P | Los Angeles Angels | Unranked |
64 | Owen White | P | Texas Rangers | 32 |
65 | Hunter Brown | P | Houston Astros | 34 |
66 | Jake Eder | P | Miami Marlins | 62 |
67 | Kevin Alcantara | CF | Chicago Cubs | 73 |
68 | Kyren Paris | SS | Los Angeles Angels | Unranked |
69 | Gordon Graceffo | P | St. Louis Cardinals | 69 |
70 | Mason Montgomery | P | Tampa Bay Rays | Unranked |
71 | Gavin Stone | P | Los Angeles Dodgers | 59 |
72 | George Valera | RF | Cleveland Guardians | Unranked |
73 | Adael Amador | SS | Colorado Rockies | 43 |
74 | Allan Cerda | CF | Cincinnati Reds | Unranked |
75 | Yunior Severino | 3B | Minnesota Twins | Unranked |
76 | Logan Allen | P | Cleveland Guardians | 57 |
77 | Edgar Quero | C | Los Angeles Angels | 80 |
78 | Drey Jameson | P | Arizona Diamondbacks | 78 |
79 | Jorbit Vivas | 2B | Los Angeles Dodgers | Unranked |
80 | Bobby Miller | P | Los Angeles Dodgers | 33 |
81 | Ken Waldichuk | P | Oakland Athletics | 86 |
82 | Jordan Westburg | SS | Baltimore Orioles | Unranked |
83 | Jack Leiter | P | Texas Rangers | 111 |
84 | Ryne Nelson | P | Arizona Diamondbacks | 89 |
85 | Drew Rom | P | Baltimore Orioles | Unranked |
86 | Connor Norby | 2B | Baltimore Orioles | Unranked |
87 | Harry Ford | C | Seattle Mariners | Unranked |
88 | Joey Ortiz | SS | Baltimore Orioles | 66 |
89 | Michael McGreevy | P | St. Louis Cardinals | Unranked |
90 | Alec Burleson | LF | St. Louis Cardinals | Unranked |
91 | Tanner Bibee | P | Cleveland Guardians | 70 |
92 | Juan Brito | 2B | Cleveland Guardians | Unranked |
93 | Yoendrys Gómez | P | New York Yankees | Unranked |
94 | Cristian Mena | P | Chicago White Sox | Unranked |
95 | Gabriel Arias | SS | Cleveland Guardians | Unranked |
96 | Sal Frelick | CF | Milwaukee Brewers | 68 |
97 | Christian Encarnacion-Strand | 3B | Cincinnati Reds | Unranked |
98 | Justin Foscue | 2B | Texas Rangers | Unranked |
99 | Carson Williams | SS | Tampa Bay Rays | 56 |
100 | Edouard Julien | 2B | Minnesota Twins | 75 |
To make it easier for fans to know whether they should be delighted or furious with me and Mr. Szymborski’s monster, I’ve also prepared a useful summary chart for each team:
Organization | Top 50 | Top 100 | Top 200 |
---|---|---|---|
Cleveland Guardians | 3 | 9 | 11 |
Baltimore Orioles | 4 | 8 | 12 |
Cincinnati Reds | 3 | 7 | 11 |
Arizona Diamondbacks | 3 | 6 | 10 |
Los Angeles Dodgers | 3 | 6 | 16 |
St. Louis Cardinals | 2 | 6 | 8 |
New York Mets | 3 | 5 | 5 |
Tampa Bay Rays | 3 | 5 | 7 |
Los Angeles Angels | 1 | 4 | 9 |
Minnesota Twins | 2 | 4 | 7 |
New York Yankees | 3 | 4 | 5 |
Texas Rangers | 0 | 4 | 6 |
Boston Red Sox | 4 | 4 | 7 |
Chicago Cubs | 2 | 3 | 7 |
Milwaukee Brewers | 1 | 3 | 6 |
Toronto Blue Jays | 3 | 3 | 6 |
Washington Nationals | 1 | 3 | 6 |
Miami Marlins | 1 | 2 | 7 |
Chicago White Sox | 1 | 2 | 2 |
Colorado Rockies | 1 | 2 | 5 |
Philadelphia Phillies | 2 | 2 | 4 |
Pittsburgh Pirates | 2 | 2 | 5 |
San Francisco Giants | 2 | 2 | 4 |
Houston Astros | 0 | 1 | 4 |
Kansas City Royals | 0 | 1 | 5 |
Oakland Athletics | 0 | 1 | 7 |
Seattle Mariners | 0 | 1 | 3 |
Atlanta Braves | 0 | 0 | 1 |
Detroit Tigers | 0 | 0 | 11 |
San Diego Padres | 0 | 0 | 3 |
For the second straight year, the Cleveland Guardians do extremely well here. The Baltimore Orioles ranking highly should be no surprise, even with Adley Rutschman graduating. The Cincinnati Reds better rank highly after dumping most of their team, and I’ve already talked about ZiPS secretly being paid off by the Diamondbacks. It’s jarring to see the Braves and Padres so low after how dominant they’ve been in the rankings previously, but a lot of that is the price of success; Austin Riley, Michael Harris II, Spencer Strider, and Vaughn Grissom would all be ultra-elite this year, but they’re all in the majors, a result the Braves no doubt prefer. As for the Padres, they’ve made a lot of trades in recent years, which will naturally reduce the level of talent in a farm system. The only other team shut out of the Top 100, the Detroit Tigers, can take some solace in the fact that they’re tied for third overall when you extend to 200 prospects.
Since a chart of 100 players is unwieldy, let’s break it down by position, and talk about a few of the highlights. Me saying “ZiPS says X” for 100 individual prospects would be rather boring, so please, put your questions in the comments if there are things you’re curious about! And for detailed breakdowns of the players as a whole, be sure to check out The Board. We’ll start with first base:
Pos. Rank | Player | Pos. | Organization | FanGraphs Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Kyle Manzardo | 1B | Tampa Bay Rays | 42 |
2 | Triston Casas | 1B | Boston Red Sox | 29 |
3 | Tyler Soderstrom | 1B | Oakland Athletics | 30 |
4 | Matt Mervis | 1B | Chicago Cubs | Unranked |
5 | Niko Kavadas | 1B | Boston Red Sox | Unranked |
6 | Alex Isola | 1B | Minnesota Twins | Unranked |
7 | Grant Lavigne | 1B | Colorado Rockies | Unranked |
8 | Michael Toglia | 1B | Colorado Rockies | Unranked |
9 | Hunter Goodman | 1B | Colorado Rockies | Unranked |
10 | Wilfred Veras | 1B | Chicago White Sox | Unranked |
First base prospect lists just aren’t what they used to be. Teams are generally (rightfully) resistant to moving their prospects to first unless they have to. Generally speaking, there are two tiers of first base prospects here. The top four all rank in the ZiPS Top 200, then there’s a big drop-off from Matt Mervis at 189 to Niko Kavadas at 282. Triston Casas tends to be the consensus top first base prospect, but ZiPS likes Kyle Manzardo even more; he has one fewer year of pro experience, but the minor league translations are more impressive and because he’s younger, ZiPS sees more chance of a tantalizing breakout. ZiPS wasn’t overly enthused by Tyler Soderstrom’s performance, but is much happier when you take his age into consideration. ZiPS prefers Mervis to fellow Cub Trey Mancini, but Mervis finishes fourth here by virtue of being older than Manzardo, Casas, and Soderstrom, and the computer just not seeing as much upside as it does with those three.
Pos. Rank | Player | Pos. | Organization | FanGraphs Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Jorbit Vivas | 2B | Los Angeles Dodgers | Unranked |
2 | Connor Norby | 2B | Baltimore Orioles | Unranked |
3 | Juan Brito | 2B | Cleveland Guardians | Unranked |
4 | Justin Foscue | 2B | Texas Rangers | Unranked |
5 | Edouard Julien | 2B | Minnesota Twins | 75 |
6 | Michael Busch | 2B | Los Angeles Dodgers | 46 |
7 | Jeremiah Jackson | 2B | Los Angeles Angels | Unranked |
8 | Eguy Rosario | 2B | San Diego Padres | Unranked |
9 | Nick Yorke | 2B | Boston Red Sox | 102 |
10 | Brett Wisely | 2B | San Francisco Giants | Unranked |
No, ZiPS did not give additional points to Jorbit Vivas for having such a fun name. The second base list has some of the same characteristics as first base, simply because a lot of the “true” best second base prospects are currently playing shortstop. Vivas ranks 78th in the Top 100, while Adael Amador, a shortstop who ranks six places ahead of him, doesn’t even crack the top 15 at his position! Connor Norby, along with Jordan Westburg and Joey Ortiz, is why I’m sort of annoyed with the Orioles for making one of their few free agent signings second baseman Adam Frazier. Even by 2022 minor league offensive standards, a second baseman with a .960 OPS is someone you shouldn’t sleep on, and as a former second-rounder, it’s not like Norby doesn’t have a pedigree. Justin Foscue has been a ZiPS favorite for a while, with the computer seeing him a bit like Nick Solak if Solak had met expectations. There’s still a question about Edouard Julien’s ultimate position, but he has a fascinating offensive profile. The projections know to not go too nuts over walk-heavy minor leaguers, but Julien isn’t a passive, power-less bat; he hit .300 with 17 homers at Double-A in 2023. There’s a pretty wide range of possible outcomes when it comes to Julien, but with a little luck, his long-term projections would involve a higher batting average than the rather unimpressive mean projections he currently has.
Pos. Rank | Player | Pos. | Organization | FanGraphs Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Gunnar Henderson | SS | Baltimore Orioles | 1 |
2 | Anthony Volpe | SS | New York Yankees | 11 |
3 | Orelvis Martinez | SS | Toronto Blue Jays | Unranked |
4 | Elly De La Cruz | SS | Cincinnati Reds | 6 |
5 | Noelvi Marte | SS | Cincinnati Reds | 94 |
6 | Ezequiel Tovar | SS | Colorado Rockies | 41 |
7 | Oswald Peraza | SS | New York Yankees | 40 |
8 | Addison Barger | SS | Toronto Blue Jays | 53 |
9 | Brayan Rocchio | SS | Cleveland Guardians | 54 |
10 | Matt McLain | SS | Cincinnati Reds | Unranked |
11 | Jose Salas | SS | Minnesota Twins | Unranked |
12 | Royce Lewis | SS | Minnesota Twins | 55 |
13 | Marcelo Mayer | SS | Boston Red Sox | 18 |
14 | Ronny Mauricio | SS | New York Mets | 90 |
15 | Marco Luciano | SS | San Francisco Giants | 97 |
Here’s where you can see some serious prospectage from top to bottom. I hope Orioles fans can forgive me for Gunnar Henderson ranking behind Corbin Carroll, but he’s still the best shortstop prospect among a very impressive group. And if he moves to second or third base, he’s the best prospect at those positions as well! Henderson had one of the biggest breakout seasons for a shortstop in prospect history in 2022, and it’s with good reason that he’s quickly moved into ultra-elite territory.
The most controversial projection here may be that of Orelvis Martinez, who ranks above some seriously high-quality shortstop prospects. Most of that is a dispute over position; there’s a real question whether he can stick at short or will move to third base. ZiPS uses a Total Zone-esque method for looking at minor league defense, for which I have the location/angle hit of every defensive play in the minors. This method nailed players like Luis Robert Jr. as minor leaguers, and right now, it thinks Martinez is below average but not alarmingly so. If he turns out to be Hanley Ramirez-esque at shortstop, he drops very quickly in the rankings given the competition here.
The Cincinnati Reds have accumulated a comical number of shortstop prospects. Elly De La Cruz, Noelvi Marte, and (surprisingly) Matt McLain all make the top 15. Edwin Arroyo missed, but he ranks 58th overall, and yet another shortstop, 2021 third-rounder Jose Torres, finishes in the Top 200. Spencer Steer and Christian Encarnacion-Strand, both higher-floor/lower-ceiling guys in ZiPS’ view, ought to feel a bit of urgency because someone here is inevitably going to join the fight for third base!
Pos. Rank | Player | Pos. | Organization | FanGraphs Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Jordan Walker | 3B | St. Louis Cardinals | 12 |
2 | Brett Baty | 3B | New York Mets | 23 |
3 | Curtis Mead | 3B | Tampa Bay Rays | 27 |
4 | Coby Mayo | 3B | Baltimore Orioles | 36 |
5 | Bryan Ramos | 3B | Chicago White Sox | 60 |
6 | Miguel Vargas | 3B | Los Angeles Dodgers | 48 |
7 | Spencer Steer | 3B | Cincinnati Reds | 47 |
8 | Josh Jung | 3B | Texas Rangers | 31 |
9 | Mark Vientos | 3B | New York Mets | Unranked |
10 | Yunior Severino | 3B | Minnesota Twins | Unranked |
Jordan Walker doesn’t get the shiniest mean projection — ZiPS projects 1.8 WAR from him in 2025 — but his upside is quite explosive. If we look at the 75th-percentile projections for 2025 instead of the 50th, that 1.8 WAR jumps to 3.7 WAR. Simply put, ZiPS think there’s a decent chance that Walker puts up some obscene home run totals, even if that’s not necessarily the over/under line. ZiPS is a fan of Curtis Mead causing a position battle at third for the Rays, which I imagine will result in someone ending up in an outfield corner. I hope the presence of Coby Mayo discourages the O’s from prematurely moving Henderson to third like they did with Manny Machado when they gave priority to J.J. Hardy. Last year’s surprise third base inclusion, Bryan Ramos, maintains his rank, and ZiPS doesn’t know that the Dodgers will probably have Miguel Vargas play other positions more often than third in 2023.
Pos. Rank | Player | Pos. | Organization | FanGraphs Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Francisco Álvarez | C | New York Mets | 13 |
2 | Endy Rodriguez | C | Pittsburgh Pirates | 22 |
3 | Bo Naylor | C | Cleveland Guardians | 45 |
4 | Diego Cartaya | C | Los Angeles Dodgers | 28 |
5 | Logan O’Hoppe | C | Los Angeles Angels | 51 |
6 | Edgar Quero | C | Los Angeles Angels | 80 |
7 | Harry Ford | C | Seattle Mariners | Unranked |
8 | Yainer Diaz | C | Houston Astros | 79 |
9 | Austin Wells | C | New York Yankees | Unranked |
10 | Israel Pineda | C | Washington Nationals | Unranked |
ZiPS is going to be Super Annoyed if Francisco Álvarez spends a good deal of the season at Triple-A Syracuse, to a degree that humanity is fortunate I’m nowhere near smart enough to program Skynet. I like Omar Narváez, but Álvarez has a good chance to be something truly special, and there comes a point where the Mets are just wasting his time in the minors. Endy Rodriguez has leapfrogged way ahead of Henry Davis among Pirates catching prospects thanks to his 2022, and while it doesn’t have an effect here, I like that the Bucs are still occasionally using him at second base and in the outfield, which could make him some kind of Beast Mode Austin Barnes.
Bo Naylor’s power blew up in 2022, so it ought to be no surprise to see him rank so highly, and the Angels now have two catchers here, with Logan O’Hoppe likely being a semi-starter as a minimum in 2023. Harry Ford is one of the names on the list that really interests me. As an aside, I’m going to keep saying Harry Ford whenever possible because my dumb brain still calls him Henry Ford about half the time. ZiPS is a bit concerned about his defense; 14 passed balls and eight errors for Harry Ford is a lot in 54 games, and while Harry Ford’s not hopeless at controlling baserunners, it’s also not really a plus. But Harry Ford’s bat, which went from high school to full-season ball very quickly with few consequences, may end up playing anywhere. Harry Ford.
ZiPS Rank | Player | Pos. | Organization | FanGraphs Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Corbin Carroll | OF | Arizona Diamondbacks | 2 |
2 | Masataka Yoshida | OF | Boston Red Sox | Unranked |
3 | Jackson Chourio | OF | Milwaukee Brewers | 7 |
4 | Jasson Domínguez | OF | New York Yankees | 50 |
5 | Alexander Canario | OF | Chicago Cubs | Unranked |
6 | Andy Pages | OF | Los Angeles Dodgers | 58 |
7 | Robert Hassell III | OF | Washington Nationals | 112 |
8 | Ceddanne Rafaela | OF | Boston Red Sox | 49 |
9 | Pete Crow-Armstrong | OF | Chicago Cubs | 14 |
10 | James Wood | OF | Washington Nationals | 3 |
11 | Kevin Alcantara | OF | Chicago Cubs | 73 |
12 | George Valera | OF | Cleveland Guardians | Unranked |
13 | Allan Cerda | OF | Cincinnati Reds | Unranked |
14 | Alec Burleson | OF | St. Louis Cardinals | Unranked |
15 | Sal Frelick | OF | Milwaukee Brewers | 68 |
ZiPS sees Corbin Carroll as the class of the 2023 prospect contingent, a franchise player who the Diamondbacks should try to sign to a long-term deal as quickly as possible. (They appear to be doing this.) Jackson Chourio ranking second in the outfield group isn’t a shocker, and ZiPS loves his combination of power and speed. The first big surprise is Alexander Canario. ZiPS thinks his defense is better than the consensus in center field, and based on some of the advanced hit data from the minors, the system thinks he got totally hosed in the BABIP department. Add in impressive power upside and you have a pick that might look genius or absolutely crazy in three years. Remember, all of the projection misses remain Carson Cistulli’s fault.
The most notable projection here may be how low Nats outfielder James Wood ranks. In this case, ZiPS is designed to be skeptical about players with little minor league time — and completely agnostic about high schoolers yet to debut — and it’s actually fairly impressive that he ranks this highly. If all goes well, Wood has an easy path to the ZiPS overall top 10 in 2024. That is, if he doesn’t blow through the minors quickly; the Nats were certainly willing to give Juan Soto a chance very, very quickly, and if he continues to hit like this, it’ll be hard to not use Wood similarly. Colton Cowser slipped a lot after a rather weak Triple-A debut; without it, he’d rank 87th overall rather than tumbling to 105. One other big slipper is George Valera, who ZiPS still sees as a prospect despite dipping to no. 71 after placing fifth overall last year. The scouts seem to have gauged him better than the computer, at least in 2022.
Pos. Rank | Player | Pos. | Organization | FanGraphs Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Eury Pérez | SP | Miami Marlins | 4 |
2 | Grayson Rodriguez | SP | Baltimore Orioles | 17 |
3 | Kyle Harrison | SP | San Francisco Giants | 26 |
4 | Andrew Painter | SP | Philadelphia Phillies | 5 |
5 | Ricky Tiedemann | SP | Toronto Blue Jays | 24 |
6 | Brandon Pfaadt | SP | Arizona Diamondbacks | 16 |
7 | Taj Bradley | SP | Tampa Bay Rays | 37 |
8 | Daniel Espino | SP | Cleveland Guardians | 93 |
9 | Mick Abel | SP | Philadelphia Phillies | 25 |
10 | Blake Walston | SP | Arizona Diamondbacks | Unranked |
11 | Matthew Liberatore | SP | St. Louis Cardinals | 107 |
12 | DL Hall | SP | Baltimore Orioles | 64 |
13 | Quinn Priester | SP | Pittsburgh Pirates | 108 |
14 | Tink Hence | SP | St. Louis Cardinals | 74 |
15 | Kodai Senga | SP | New York Mets | 39 |
16 | Cade Cavalli | SP | Washington Nationals | 63 |
17 | Ky Bush | SP | Los Angeles Angels | Unranked |
18 | Owen White | SP | Texas Rangers | 32 |
19 | Hunter Brown | SP | Houston Astros | 34 |
20 | Jake Eder | SP | Miami Marlins | 62 |
21 | Gordon Graceffo | SP | St. Louis Cardinals | 69 |
22 | Mason Montgomery | SP | Tampa Bay Rays | Unranked |
23 | Gavin Stone | SP | Los Angeles Dodgers | 59 |
24 | Logan Allen | SP | Cleveland Guardians | 57 |
25 | Drey Jameson | SP | Arizona Diamondbacks | 78 |
26 | Bobby Miller | SP | Los Angeles Dodgers | 33 |
27 | Ken Waldichuk | SP | Oakland Athletics | 86 |
28 | Jack Leiter | SP | Texas Rangers | 111 |
29 | Ryne Nelson | SP | Arizona Diamondbacks | 89 |
30 | Drew Rom | SP | Baltimore Orioles | Unranked |
Surprisingly, there’s quite a lot of agreement between the ZiPS list and the FanGraphs list at the top of the pitching ranks. Eight of the top nine prospects in ZiPS are basically the top pitching prospects on Eric and Tess’ list. I’d have liked to see Grayson Rodriguez stay at the top, but you can’t deny that 2022 added some additional uncertainty to the mix. A lot of the disagreement on the remaining pitcher, Daniel Espino, may simply come down to the fact that ZiPS isn’t aware that his shoulder problems have continued, which is something that should always frighten you about pitching prospects! Ricky Tiedemann may be the most impressive big jumper here, as it’s hard for a pitcher to rank this highly based on so few professional innings; that simply reflects his dominance in those innings.
Blake Walston is the first big surprise here, a low ceiling prospect who didn’t have an impressive season on the surface in 2022. But on a play-by-play level, ZiPS thinks his high BABIP and too-high HR/9 (.341, 1.35) weren’t actually earned from his pitching, and given how offense exploded in the minors, ZiPS is much sunnier about his recent campaign. ZiPS continues to like Matthew Liberatore, and he’s joined by two teammates, Gordon Graceffo and Tink Hence. Hence’s rank is more impressive than it looks for a reason similar to Tiedemann’s: he only has 16 starts above rookie ball! But what a 16 starts they were. Fourteen strikeouts per game with a low walk rate and just a single homer? Sign me up. More of this, and Hence will rank like Rodriguez or Eury Pérez in ZiPS (I checked). Drey Jameson and Ryne Nelson join ZiPS’ Arizona Bias Factory to give the team four of the league’s top 30 pitching prospects by ZiPS. Mason Montgomery is one of the ZiPS low-ceiling/high-floor specials; pitching in the Trop against the backdrop of a pitcher-friendly big league offensive environment, ZiPS sees Montgomery’s control as just good enough to give him a shot at crafty lefty territory.
Kodai Senga’s relatively low rank reflects the fact that he’s already 30 and has fewer years remaining than other pitchers who work out rather than indicating any skepticism about his abilities.
Comments? Questions? Complaints? The comment section is open!
[Note: Masataka Yoshida was originally not flagged as a rookie and left off the list due to the slight incompetence of the author -DS]
Dan Szymborski is a senior writer for FanGraphs and the developer of the ZiPS projection system. He was a writer for ESPN.com from 2010-2018, a regular guest on a number of radio shows and podcasts, and a voting BBWAA member. He also maintains a terrible Twitter account at @DSzymborski.
Been looking forward to this all week, thanks Dan! Minor error fyi, you misspelled interquartile.