The Team That Went Up a Hill but Fell Down a Mountain

On Monday, the Rockies announced that executive vice-president/general manager Jeff Bridich would be leaving his role with the team. Whether or not this amounts to a resignation or a “resignation” allowing a long-time employee to save face, the result is the same: there will be a new face responsible for personnel decisions in Colorado. (For now, that’s team COO Greg Feasel, who will serve as the interim GM, but the team expects to hire a full-time replacement after the end of the season.) This organization generally has had a great deal of loyalty to its general managers over the years: After nearly 30 years of existence, the team has only had three GMs in Bridich, Dan O’Dowd, and Bob Gebhard. But will this be enough to right what’s gone horribly wrong in Denver?

The Nolan Arenado trade this winter may have been the straw that broke the camel’s back for the team’s chances of a longshot wild card run in 2021 and the fanbase’s feelings about the Rockies. Bridich’s relationship with Arenado soured the team’s relationship with its franchise player, but ownership was a key player in making the trade happen.

In February, the Rockies bowed to the pressure, trading Arenado and $51 million to the Cardinals for a package that included pitcher Austin Gomber and four mid- to low-level prospects. Monfort was largely the architect of the trade, sources told The Athletic, but blame fell to Bridich. There is enough to go around. Bridich was the one who alienated Arenado; Monfort is the one who allowed it.

“We lack process in so many ways,” one now-former member of Colorado’s front office said. “We lack leadership in most ways. And there’s very, very little accountability.”

So, how did the Rockies get here? Where they sit now, firmly at the bottom of the NL West, is a product of long-term decision-making failures, not just the recent drive to save money or a few poor moves in recent years.

Let’s set the time machine back a decade. In 2009, the Rockies made their second appearance in the playoffs in three years under O’Dowd. These weren’t perfect teams, but they had a solid core, with a young Troy Tulowitzki, Ubaldo Jiménez, Carlos González, and Dexter Fowler. That’s a quartet worthy of building around, and Todd Helton had not yet fallen off the cliff. To keep the run going that winter, the Rockies did, well, nothing. Or at least, almost nothing, re-signing Rafael Betancourt to a relatively inexpensive two-year deal and inking veterans like Jason Giambi, Melvin Mora, and Miguel Olivo to one-year contracts.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed. We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member. 1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other. 2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off. 3. Dark mode and Classic mode! 4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them. 5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects. 6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.) 7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only. 8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO. 9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members. 10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features! We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it. In case you didn't read all that, here's the short version. Membership includes:
✓Ad-free browsing
✓Unlimited FanGraphs & RotoGraphs articles
✓Historical & platoon projections
✓Leaderboard & player-page stat heatmaps
✓One-click data exports
✓Customizable player-page dashboards
✓Dark & Classic site modes
✓Weekly Members-only mailbag
✓FanGraphs Walk-Off, your year in review
✓Optional homepage photo removal
✓Gift articles to non-Members
✓Full postseason coverage

The team slumped to 83–79 in 2010 and, in a double-whammy, neither traded off veterans at the deadline nor signed them over the winter. The Rockies shed another 10 wins in 2011, dropping to 73–89. Jiménez was traded to Cleveland for four players, most notably Drew Pomeranz, but a larger sell-off wasn’t happening. Colorado did, however, make its first signing of a free agent to a significant contract in years, and it was a curious one: Michael Cuddyer, on a three-year, $31.5 million contract; over the previous four seasons, he averaged just 1.2 WAR for the Twins. (The compensation draft pick, meanwhile, turned into José Berríos.)

Three more years below .500 ended O’Dowd’s tenure with the team: He resigned at the end of the season, as ownership had not acted on his previous request to have himself fired a couple of years earlier. In came Bridich, the team’s senior director of player development since 2011. He had a solid record of player development, with Arenado, Charlie Blackmon, and DJ LeMahieu coming up under his watch, and drafts that included, among others, Trevor Story and Jon Gray.

The long-term problem since has been the decisions made at the major league level. Whether the fault lies with Bridich or the Monforts in ownership, the team repeatedly failed to get value from their veterans in the midst of losing seasons. Colorado never got anything in return for Gonzalez, LeMahieu, Jorge De La Rosa, or Justin Morneau, and the Tulowitzki trade was more of a salary dump than a restock of the farm system. The Rockies did land Germán Márquez and Jake McGee for Corey Dickerson, but that’s better than they did for all the other departing players combined.

In free agency, the decisions made were even more disastrous. I’ve been following baseball professionally for 20 years now, and I can’t remember any team having such an epic run of failure when signing major league free agents. Let’s chart out this Kafka-esque tale of woe.

Rockies Free Agent Signings
Player Contract WAR
Ian Desmond $70,000,000 -1.7
Wade Davis $52,000,000 0.3
Gerardo Parra $27,500,000 -1.0
Jake McGee $27,000,000 0.6
Bryan Shaw $27,000,000 -0.5
Daniel Murphy $24,000,000 -1.0
Mike Dunn $19,000,000 -0.1
Jason Motte $10,000,000 -0.3
Chris Iannetta $8,500,000 0.1
Carlos Gonzalez $8,000,000 1.8
Nick Hundley $6,250,000 0.9
Chad Qualls $6,000,000 -0.1
Greg Holland $6,000,000 1.1
Kyle Kendrick $5,500,000 -0.9
Daniel Descalso $3,600,000 -0.4
Mark Reynolds $2,600,000 0.3
Alexi Amarista $1,100,000 -1.1
Total $304,050,000 -2.0

Paying $150 million per win would be bad enough, but this organization somehow topped that, paying $150 million per negative win. There’s no doubt that there are elements of bad luck here, such as Murphy being dragged down by injury problems. But few of these deals had any argument for them, at least if you’re a believer in modern analytics. The Desmond signing was particularly noteworthy in that the Rockies both made a gross misevaluation of his skills and used him in a manner in which success was nearly impossible. If you thought at the time that he could still play shortstop, you could squint and justify the deal; he was coming off a 3.5 win season for the Rangers despite playing a mediocre center field. But from day one, Colorado intended to use him as a first baseman — a problem given that ZiPS projected Desmond for a 101 OPS+ in 2017 and going downhill from there.

The Rockies didn’t just fail in the broad strokes. Mike Tauchman was no star, but the team had zero interest in getting a look at him, preferring instead to give playing time to up-and-coming youngsters like 38-year-old Matt Holliday. Traded to the Yankees, Tauchman’s 2.6 WAR in 2019 was a better performance than anyone the Rockies signed in free agency. Roberto Ramos didn’t get a single appearance in the majors in a lost 2019 season and left for the Korean Baseball Organization, where he hit .278/.362/.592 in 2020 for the LG Twins. Little-used Tom Murphy got a total of 210 plate appearances in four years in Colorado, was waived right before the 2019 season, and posted a 126 wRC+ in Seattle that year while Rockies catchers hit .245/.317/.360.

The point isn’t that any of these players would turn around the organization, but that the Rockies displayed absolutely no desire to see what they had to offer. The result of all this is that while they did make the playoffs for consecutive seasons in 2017 and ’18, the foundation was paper-thin. Success was based on the team’s few stars, with almost nothing to support it. With no reinforcements at the trade deadline or free agency, Colorado’s brief foray into contention was doomed to be short-lived, only lasting as long as it could ride a handful of big names.

The farm system won’t spearhead a quick turnaround. In terms of rest-of-career WAR via the current ZiPS projections, the Rockies rank 30th in baseball, just behind the Reds and Rangers. In my colleague Eric Longehagen’s top 133 prospects for 2021, only a single player, outfielder Zac Veen, makes an appearance, down at No. 70.

The long-term question the Rockies face is whether ownership has learned anything from the Bridich era. Bridich no doubt made many of the decisions on his own, but it’s nearly undeniable at this point that the Monforts, who have been the primary owners since 2005, play a key role in the choices Colorado has made. Will they allow Story and Gray to be traded rather than letting them walk at the end of the season? Would they be willing to trade Márquez, the 22nd-ranked player on our 2020 trade value list? Will they actually spend money?

That last one is a challenging obstacle. Teams can win without spending money — hi, Rays! — but it’s tough to do without a modern front office, and Colorado may have trouble attracting top talent. In the midst of a global pandemic and a shedding of jobs around baseball, two-thirds of the franchise’s minuscule analytics department quit rather than return to the team for 2021.

In a perfect world, the next GM of the Rockies could have a dream job. Denver’s a beautiful city with a fanbase that has supported winners in the past, and Coors Field is one of the best places for baseball to watch a game with unique characteristics that make it one of the most fascinating puzzles to try to solve. A new GM could put their imprint on the Rockies with a true blank slate and build the team from the ground up, from scouting to major league talent acquisition. But it would involve the organization choosing to wake up from its self-created nightmare.





Dan Szymborski is a senior writer for FanGraphs and the developer of the ZiPS projection system. He was a writer for ESPN.com from 2010-2018, a regular guest on a number of radio shows and podcasts, and a voting BBWAA member. He also maintains a terrible Twitter account at @DSzymborski.

43 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Myf Norris
5 years ago

What is the over-under on the team not hiring a new GM and instead Dick Monfort putting on a uniform and making himself the first owner-GM-manager in modern history? I would take those odds over him actually stepping back and investing in a competitive front office.

bglick4
5 years ago
Reply to  Myf Norris

As a fan of trainwrecks, this would be great. As a fan of baseball, this would be less great. I hate seeing teams destroyed by incompetent front offices. This team has seemingly drafted and developed talent very well. I mean, if they would have hit 2019 with Story, Arenado, Blackmon, and LaMahieu, and Gray, they would have been a decent team. Throw in a decent free agent pitcher and they could have challenged for a wild card at least. That core of hitters could have kept them competitive for years.

CC AFCMember since 2016
5 years ago
Reply to  bglick4

Counterpoint: it’s more fun when there’s at least one team to make fun of. Used to be Dave Stewart’s D-Backs, now it’s the Rockies. Being that is fun for 98% of baseball fans who are not Rockies fans, I’d call it good for baseball. Sorry, Rockies fans.

Dmjn53
5 years ago
Reply to  CC AFC

I miss the La Russa/Dave Stewart DBacks. They were far more entertaining than a well-run team could ever be

SæderMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Dmjn53

It’ll be a new way to fund the franchise: copyright the life-rights of the story, sell it to Disney, and collect $$$$ off a reboot of a Major League reboot

kidzeroMember since 2019
5 years ago

I was a season ticket owner since inception (1993) but quit this year as the Rockies outlook is bleak for many many years to come. The one issue is Dick Monfort. Period. Doesn’t know sh*t except the meat packing business. As long as this clown owns the club, the Rockies will be terrible.

Ruben Amaro Jr.
5 years ago

Dumbasses.

Dave Stewart
5 years ago

Dumb asse’s. Its two word’s, dumb ass.

tgiff33Member since 2020
5 years ago

Dick has been an infamously accessible owner. He regularly replies to fan emails including a few I’ve sent him over the years. While I applaud his accessibility, he’s been one of the worst owners in sports and doesn’t seem to have anything resembling a coherent plan for the team. So, all of that being said, is it possible he was cyber pressured into asking Jeff to fire himself? He seems like the type of rich guy who would be surprised that people really liked Arenado and wanted more in return than Gomber and a bucket of baseballs.

tgiff33Member since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  tgiff33

I just find the timing of this to be incredibly odd. Why not fire him after last season? Or hold onto him for the rest of this year?

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  tgiff33

That was my first thought, and then I remembered they traded Arenado at the nadir of his value but kept Story and figured that “timing” might be a chronic problem with this organization.

johnMember since 2017
5 years ago
Reply to  tgiff33

Possibly to prevent more damage in poor trades if Story, Marquez, J.Gray, etc. are divested. When someone is steering you over a cliff you may need to pry their hands off the wheel.

fredsbankMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  tgiff33

This not making sense actually makes perfect sense, when we consider how little sense the Rockies tend to make. If Bridich was fired in the offseason, that would have been “normal,” and therefore weird and suspicious. This being bizarre means it’s rote and boring for the Rockies.

fredsbankMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  tgiff33

The broadcast last night mentioned “social media” and “media pressure” multiple times as important factors. The targeted negative press following The Trade were way different and more intense than they’ve been used to, and the fan backlash has been tremendous. I think it almost certainly was a factor in the decision here.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago

Jeff Brdich is probably a good example of the Peter Principle. If you look at the players that came up during his run in player development you’d think he knows what he’s doing, but not in his new role.

But he’s also a good example of how very good GMs in earlier eras look average now (Theo Epstein), and how average GMs look bad (Brdich). Brdich is probably no worse than Dan O’Dowd, and probably a lot better. But it’s way easier to win when you’re competing against teams assembled by Ned Colletti and Kevin Towers than versus Andrew Friedman and Mike Hazen.

This is why a huge number of teams have top decision-makers who have trained in Cleveland, Tampa Bay, Houston, and Boston. By my count, about 13 teams have top decision-makers who are part of those four “analytics families”. Some teams have done well by just promoting the next guy up, like the Nationals and Mike Rizzo, because they can adapt and/or hire the right people to stay with everyone else. But the Rockies promoted him at what was likely the precise moment that teams around the league started getting way better, and he couldn’t keep up / hire the right people.

PC1970Member since 2024
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Good post.

Al Avila says Hi! I view him similarly to Brdich. Just overmatched compared to the other guys

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  PC1970

If Al Avila was general manager in 2009 he’s probably a mid-range GM, maybe even better than that. You saw how great Walt Jocketty was back in the day with the Cards and how he was relatively overmatched in Cincinnati. Same with Kenny Williams when he (finally) turned over full decision-making to Rick Hahn. Jim Hendry was a GM then. Jack Zduriencik and Ruben Amaro were hotshot new hires. In that era, Avila looks a lot better.

Every so often you get guys who realize they have more to learn (Dayton Moore, Anthopolous, sort of kind of Dombrowski) and can hang around for a while and even thrive but I don’t think Avila is necessarily one of those guys. He’s just a man out of time.

NickMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Avila is now the 6th most tenured GM in ball, per my cursory research. Absolutely amazing to me. The Tigers have the fewest wins (291) and the least WAR per this site since his first full season in ’16. He doesn’t have the meme-ability of a Bridich or GMDM and has probably had some bad luck with prospects not panning out, but you wonder how long a guy has to show fruits of a rebuild before you see if someone else can do better.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Nick

I said this the other day, but I think the nail in his coffin is going to be Casey Mize. Mize might turn into a competent mid-rotation starter, but if he doesn’t do it soon there will be something really obvious to pin on Avila.

Ironically, picking Mize was actually sort of defensible. That whole first round was a disaster, and aside from Kelennic it’s hard to say there’s a single guy in there that you know is going to be better than Mize.

PC1970Member since 2024
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Could be..esp if Brady Singer continues to outpitch Mize AND KC’s hot start keeps them in the playoff race. They started rebuilding after Detroit & if they make the playoffs or are close, the heat will turn up.

As for Mize/Kelenic- I have a friend who’s son worked for Tigers FO at that time & he said they were looking for an excuse to take Kelenic, but, Wisconsin (where Kelenic is from) had an awful spring, so he barely played & there was little updated data on him..so, they felt Mize was the best choice..& he probably was the logical choice.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  PC1970

Yeah, there were five teams that passed on Kelenic before the Mets grabbed him.

I don’t think I realized what a great season Brady Singer was having. That’s amazing. Grayson Rodriguez is another name but I don’t think you can really beat yourself up when you’re saying you should have taken the guys who went #11 and #18. The times you should really beat yourself up is when you miss and the next few picks turn out well. And the next four picks after Mize look like a role players except maybe Bohm, who is an R/R 1B pretending to play third and who is hitting terribly right now.

It was just not a good draft year. 2019 was much better.

PC1970Member since 2024
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Or is the issue player development, not who they drafted?

That draft was weird, a lot of names (Bart, Bohm, Swaggerty, Kelenic, etc), but, by the time the draft came around they’d all dropped a scouting level or 2 except for Mize..who did have a helluva year at Auburn.

Lanidrac
5 years ago
Reply to  Nick

That’s misleading though when you consider a few guys with longer tenures who were technically replaced as GM when they were promoted to some Baseball Operations title like Billy Beane and John Mozeliak.

Lanidrac
5 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Although, Houston headhunted a bunch of their analytics guys from St. Louis in the first place.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Lanidrac

The four analytics families that seem to populate the league are the “Friedman Tree” (Neander, Click, Bloom, the man himself), the “Epstein Tree” (Cherington, Hoyer, Hazen, Dipoto), the Shapiro tree (Chernoff / Antonetti, Falvey, Atkins) and the “Luhnow Tree” (Stearns, Elias). There are other analytically savvy front office leaders (Beane, Alderson, Mozeliak, and somehow, Dayton Moore). But if you look at the names you expect to see as the next GMs, they’re largely guys from those four trees like Amiel Sawdaye, Matt Arnold, Josh Byrnes, and Bobby Heck.

CoryMC
5 years ago

Super minor but the Tulowitzki trade wasn’t considered salary dump at the time. Hoffman and Castro were highly ranked in the Blue Jays farm system and that was considered a very fair trade. https://blogs.fangraphs.com/troy-tulowitzki-the-blue-jays-and-upgrading-strengths/
https://blogs.fangraphs.com/scouting-the-prospects-in-the-tulowitzki-trade/
https://blogs.fangraphs.com/projecting-the-prospects-in-the-troy-tulowitzki-trade/

tung_twista
5 years ago
Reply to  CoryMC

Whether a trade was largely a salary dump and whether it was a fair deal are orthogonal issues.

Josh
5 years ago

“We have no process,” said one now-former member of the Rockies’ front office…

I disagree. The sustained run of horrific signings, coupled with playing *any* bad veteran over *any* young talent show the Rockies very, very much do have a “process.” It is dogsh*t, but it is a real process.

AnonMember since 2020
5 years ago

So the Rox are leaving the non-baseball COO to handle the absolutely inevitable Trevor Story trade. Yeah, that should go well.

Seeing that free agent chart is just stunning in its glorious ineptitude. I mean, Descalso and Reynolds aren’t so bad as cheap veteran fill-ins and you could maybe justify one of the reliever deals, but man, the rest are just “What were you thinking?” levels of bad. Not just “worked out” bad, they were “bad idea from the start” bad.

The Rockies will forever be looking for a way to solve he altitude problem, specifically developing pitchers but also battling the notion that their hitters are good when they often really aren’t. Both Arenado and Blackmon got paid way beyond what was reasonable for their skills.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Anon

I think that the COO is naming an interim GM. They still have Assistant GMs, one of them will probably be in charge until the Rockies realize they can’t get Thad Levine or Theo Epstein.

Lanidrac
5 years ago
Reply to  Anon

Arenado’s contract was at least reasonably fair when you also factor in his defense.

dukewinslowMember since 2020
5 years ago
Reply to  Anon

It’s weird because, to me anyway, signing productive free agents seems easier than 1. producing middle infield talent and 2. producing pitchers who can keep it in the Park at Coors. Brdich oversaw an organization that basically nailed 1 and was ok at 2, which seems like the hard part of the job, to fall down at acquiring productive free agents, which seems like an easier thing to do, just given the amount of data you have on veteran players. What’s really depressing is that if you trim the outliers from the above table, CarGo and Desmond, things get WORSE (but not by much)

lavarnway
5 years ago

MLB should reinstate John Coppolella and he should become the GM. He gets the punishment of having to work for Monfort but Rockies fans get someone that is actually competent.

szielinski
5 years ago

Nearly as bad as the McClatchyfield debacle in Pittsburgh. It can be said that the Pirates did not spend hundreds of millions on players who were worse than replacement level. But that damns the McClatchyfield regime with very faint praise. The Rockies had a few winning seasons and playoff series along the way. Pirates’ fans had decades of soul crushing hopelessness to endure before they bested the McClatchy Line.

Good luck Rockies fans.

will1331Member since 2019
5 years ago

Saw on somewhere on twitter from a former Rockies FO member “Dick Monfort thinks he’s Billy-f*cking-Beane” and if that doesn’t sum this all up I don’t know what does.

The Duke
5 years ago
Reply to  will1331

That Arenado deal might make him look like Billy Beane in a couple years. It’s quite possible he realized that Arenado wouldn’t opt out with his crappy trend line and did the best he could do to get out from under that commit. Remember it was the Rockies that added the opt out. They wanted him to go and end up with a Pujols situation where they got all the good years and someone else paid for the decline.

If you looked at what they spent on Arenado and how he performed they made out like bandits. The cardinals are the one with the 200 million problem now.

Hunter Bingham
5 years ago

Cardinals will hire him with some of the Arenado cash. Only explanation for that deal.

vslykeMember since 2020
5 years ago

Probably not entirely fair to cite the total amount of the Desmond contract since they got out of his 2020 and 2021 salaries when he opted out

tdouglas
5 years ago
Reply to  vslyke

That just makes them look worse. He would have racked up even more negative WAR.

Richard Bergstrom
5 years ago

Couldn’t have said it better myself. Yes you have some severe mistakes with free agency, but the Rockies bled away a lot of their young pieces. Meanwhile they gave those opportunities to vets and failed to recoup any kind of value for them.

natekeiser
5 years ago

Hope they can turn it around this season. Have some good players on the roster.