Eric Longenhagen Prospects Chat: 11/20/26
Eugenio Velez
Jace Avina Hit Tool >= Grade 40?
Eric Longenhagen
The big league average K% is 22%, batting average .244. Avina has a career 24% K and .246 batting average. His strikeouts have tended to be worse when he is age appropriate for the level, and better when he's repeating the level. I think he'll strike out enough to have a below average hit tool. He should still get to enough power to be an okay role player, but I don't think he's a 20/20 guy in the big leagues.
jazzpaw
Hey, Eric! How do you see the potential logjam at catcher in Tampa shaking out over the next few years?
Eric Longenhagen
Are you including Flewelling as part of the jam? I don't think he's good enough on defense yet to even consider as being part of it. If anything I think they could use as many as two more guys right now, I don't think having Piper be the backup is ideal. Bodine they might accelerate into the mix even though he's a '28 40-man add, that's still just two guys with him and Hicks. You need three.
Eric Longenhagen
Flewelling is either a) years away as they wait for him to improve on defense or b) he's not a catcher, he's Tyler Soderstrom and they move him proactively.
wheelhouse
i don't want to ask you to answer questions about a different publication's list, but i'll ask about a specific point. BP is really down on elmer rodriguez because his fastball package got absolutely lit up to the tune of like a .400 xwOBA in his major league time in 2026. obviously you see it differently, so what do you see in his 3-fastball approach that gives you faith in it?
Eric Longenhagen
This is a good way to ask it. Brendan and I talked about nerfing Elmer's grade for basically these reasons and because his command isn't great. Ultimately, we like the raw material enough (above avg velo, sink, plus breaking stuff, Elmer's long term body projection and if I'm being honest probably some bias because of New York's ability to max guys out) to think they'll figure things out and that he'll be good. But the issues BP identified as concerns are absolutely valid.
InsertWittyNameHere
Read the Gomez piece and when he said he was trying to hit 100, the old school in me came up. I agree that high velo is statistically better, but what’s the delta? If prospect A sits 99 with a 45 command, and prospect B sits 96 with a 60 command, which would you take? For SP and RP since it could be different depending on role.
Eric Longenhagen
I think it depends on a myriad of other factors and command is one of them. Joe Ryan has a monster fastballs because of his command AND because of the amount it moves, and because of the direction of the movement, and because of the angle at which it approaches the plate. Gomez can only control so many of those variables, he can't just decide to have the exact same body, mechanics, release, hand position, etc. as Joe Ryan. Nor do I think he can just decide to throttle down to 96 and magically have plus command. It's like asking Shaq to just get better at free throws. Just get better! SOme guys have that touch and feel off their finger tips, some do not.
Anonymous Member #46
Do the Yankees have a disproportionate amount of "amazing fastball, no clue where it's going" pitchers?
Eric Longenhagen
Yes, but that's in part because they're good at developing velocity.
hansford
Are Anthony Potestio's chase rate and whiff rate what kept him off the honorable mention portion of the yankees list? What does he need to do to improve to maybe make the honorable mention portion of the list next year?
Eric Longenhagen
Wasn't really on that guy before the draft, either. A college guy cleaning up against Low-A pitching late in the year, after the better guys have been promoted, really doesn't move the needle for me. You can have flagged him for how he did to see if it continues at Hudson Valley in 2027, but I think the guys who get the standard day three bonus $150,000 need to prove it more than that, otherwise I'd be writing up hundreds more guys.
war2d2
Eric! I had posted this question to BG, and would like your take as well: BP put a shockingly high FV on Hartshorn, have your thoughts on him changed any since you put a 50 on him a couple months ago?
Eric Longenhagen
BP doesn't use FV
Eric Longenhagen
FV is a value grade. Basically ceiling minus time and risk. BP is more just telling you what they think the ceiling on the player is.
rcoon1429
Are Grindlinger and Hayden Alvarez both top 100 guys for you going into 2027?
Eric Longenhagen
Yep. Brendan will have to sign off on Grindlinger a bit, but for me he's a 50 already.
DBRuns
Can I get your thoughts on Guardians prospects Ralphy Velasquez, Kody Huff, and Cooper Ingle? Can these be 2027 impact bats (assuming there is a 2027 season) for a team that needs offense? Can Huff be a guy behind the plate for a team that has historically deployed defense-first backstops?
Eric Longenhagen
Bailey is the clear starting C, Huff is the second best defender of the catchers on their 40-man, Fry and Ingle are more corner defenders who could catch in an emergency or maybe late in games because they pinch hit for Huff or something. Ingle will make lots of contact and keep the line moving, not a lot of power. Ralphy is a slugger who'll add a dangerous element to the middle third of their order, but he'll K a lot.
Cool Lester Smooth
Are Roderick Arias’ under the hood numbers still terribad?
Eric Longenhagen
The contact rates have been, yeah. 30% K guy all the way up. Roughly average raw power with a 20-grade hit tool.
Eric Longenhagen
62.7% contact in '26. 110 max, 105 EV90, 45% hard hit. Def good power for a 22 year old shortstop, but not good enough to have a 63% contact rate and be valued as a prospect.
Cool Lester Smooth
(Surface level stuff at AA looks like a bounce back!)
Eric Longenhagen
Yep, I get why you asked. It was the same reason I re-checked him and decided it's okay to move on.
tjb2010
Most likely outcome for Yostin Peña is what, something like Ruben Rivera or Dominic Brown?
Eric Longenhagen
The most likely outcome is something like Aristedes Aquino, Adolis Garcia, Domingo Santana type guy. He chases a lot, he's volatile. The way that manifests for this huge-tools guy is something like that trio. But remember this guy sat for a whole extra summer. He found ways to avoid strikeouts even though his approach is bad. He has right tail outcomes where the chase is dialed down via exposure and… he's more like Jorge Soler, where the production is spread out across a greater span of time.
tjb2010
Didn’t realize your boy Luichi Casilla had a 15 k/9 and 3 bb/9 in 6 low-A starts. Could he actually be a dude?
Eric Longenhagen
Didn't see him myself during instructs but a scout told me he looked kinda back, yeah. 92-95 (so not peak Luichi velo anymore) flashing 70 slider
Fangraphs Man
No question I’m just sad about Luis Castillo, he had one start with the Sox where he looked vintage but otherwise just seems cooked
Eric Longenhagen
Yeah, just seemed like a salary dump in which Colorado thinks they can make Davis Martin consistent and values controlling him for several years while they net some wisdom from Castillo as he's on the 18th green.
Eric Longenhagen
Sean Sullivan is an okay low leverage bulk guy. Nice to have him during his option years, funky low slot dude with huge extension. Lower impact guy, but super fun and a fine return in this situation because he's going to contribute immediately.
rcoon1429
Gunnar Henderson comp on Dax Kilby really stuck out today… Is it safe to say you think Kilby has top 5 prospect potential?
Eric Longenhagen
If he shows up significantly stronger to start '27 the way Gunnar did, the way George Lombard did.. then yeah. Can the ceiling on his power get bigger because he takes good care of his body? He has the contact and body projection foundation for that to happen. Now, he might get huge and have to move off shortstop or something like that. Right now we're talking about a top 30 prospect. It's like projecting a hurricane. He could be a category four or five if things break right, right now he's a cat 3.
Eric Longenhagen
Gunnar is a better defender too, btw
Neil Baumgarten
Hey Eric – Business of baseball question – I love the AFL, but am afraid that ultimately the owners will shut it down as they continue to cut minor league costs where possible. What liklihood do you place on this? Thanks!
Eric Longenhagen
Yeah, I'm starting to wonder if it needs drastic change to survive, or even to remain useful. The quality of the pitching has made it less and less useful.
Ice Cream Helmet
Thoughts on NTangible and their Clutch Factor test?
I remember Dave Cameron used to argue something to the effect of "the path to MLB weeds out anybody who wilts under pressure already, so pro players aren't more clutch than one another." What's your opinion – Clutch/choking isn't a thing at all, or it's probably a thing that we just can't measure/predict yet?
Eric Longenhagen
I'm aware of NTangible, but I don't know the specifics of Clutch Factor. I think what you're attributing to Dave might actually be Keith's opinion? Regardless, I think it's true for a subset of the players, but not true of the entire population of players. People are weird and unpredictable. For instance, I am comfortable speaking in front of an entire stadium full of people, but I feel weird and nervous looking at my webcam and doing it. That's not rational, and not everyone in media is that way…
Eric Longenhagen
What I'm saying is, what you feel like is a moment to be nervous enough that you get worse is going to vary person to person. I think "clutch" or being "cold blooded" or whatever actually exists, but that person to person, moment to moment, it changes and my instincts are that it's not a thing you can measure worth a damn.
apeloton
Am I crazy for thinking the kilby write up is way less glowing than the AFL notes were? If so, what changed? If not, am I focusing too much on the nitpicks and not enough on the “potential plus hit and power” piece?
Eric Longenhagen
He sucked the last couple of weeks here and the tape study did not have a ton of flush contact. I muted my hit tool enthusiasm some. Still really good for a shortstop. Reminder, here is the league average line for shortstops: https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders/major-league?stats=bat&lg=…
InsertWittyNameHere
Odd follow up, how can one improve their touch and feel of their finger tips? Or is it just innate?
Eric Longenhagen
I think it's innate, maybe you can get there through reps. I can feel a baseball coming off my fingertips with great specificity. Shooting a basketball? Nope. Something about how "hard" i need to chuck a basketball from deep makes my feel go away, something about using my lower body for basketball makes me lose coordination in my hands/fingers.
rcoon1429
With a lockout approaching, what if any changes do you anticipate for the mlb draft and international signing period? Will both take place as scheduled? Do you anticipate major changes in the next CBA?
Eric Longenhagen
I think we'll have an agreement on the bigger dealings before any of this stuff actually gets decided. They'll have a big league agreement in principal and get going on the season before they actually hammer out the details for this. I have no inside info. Speculation: MLB will use the lockout as an excuse to push the international signing date. They'll have effectively delayed Int'l amateur signings one year since covid, and they'll consider that a win they can just bank so why not do it?
Eric Longenhagen
On domestic draft: I think the optics of eliminating HS draftees would be so bad that they won't do it, and it would open up MLB to class action if it comes to that. They won't do it.
GB
Have the Yankees traded away more prospect talent in the last 3-5 years than any other team? Off the top of my head: jazz, garcia, soto, bednar, even rizzo
Eric Longenhagen
No, San Diego. By a lot.
Eric Longenhagen
next cluster: NYY, NYM, BOS, TEX
Eric Longenhagen
SDP I have at 23 guys, and it's actually more than that because a bunch of the guys they've moved, I didn't like enough to rank.
aiyer917
You think Owen Ayers could be a 450 PA per season upon landing?
Eric Longenhagen
Certainly as their roster is constructed right now. He's better than Amaya already.
ahughes584
"Botero Jorge Alfaro" heh!
Eric Longenhagen
(deep bow)
Charles Bengal Tiger
How far away is Hyun-Seok Kang from ranking in the Dodgers' top 10?
Eric Longenhagen
You mean Jang, right? Right up there in that area. He threw strikes this year while some of the guys ranked ahead of him during last list cycle (Nieves, Carias, Gonzalez) were either hurt or did not.
SEAfahrer
Hey Eric, you guys have Sato listed as a 45 for speed on the Board. There are some stats from NPB that have his sprint speed at 29.5 ft/sec which would be 95tg percentile and I imagine more a 60/65.
Does his speed really play down in games? It doesn’t look like he had many SB attempts in Japan.
Eric Longenhagen
Sprint speed is measuring peak speed, it's feet per second in the fastest one second window for the player. Our speed grades are determined by run times from home to first, which we use because I can measure with a stopwatch on any field or via video at any time, rather than rely on tech being at a field and getting access to the data. Whether you're safe or out at first base is also what I consider to be the most common way speed impacts baseball, so that's another reason. I had Sato running about 4.4 home to first.
grandbranyan
Quero and Dinges haven't caught much the last two years on account of various injuries. Has recent 40 Man add Matthew Wood (& his 1.08 BB/K ratio over the last four years) passed them on the org depth chart?
Eric Longenhagen
I don't think he's passed them but I think he's put himself in the mix for a 40-man spot on an earlier timeline than Dinges.
Cosmo
How would you rank Made, DeVries, Walcott, Josuar?
Eric Longenhagen
DeVries 4th of that group, Made/Walcott first in some order, then Josuar. For now.
baseballfan115
I noticed PGC has a 40 run and 40 throw, but a 55 fv for outfield defense. Does he take exceptional routes/jumps? Is he excellent at pre pitch positioning? What does he do that projects as an above average fielder with below average tools?
Eric Longenhagen
Super comfortable at the catch point and around the wall/net in foul territory. Made a bunch of awkward plays look totally easy and routine. Slow to approach the baseball on the ground in the gaps and corners, can't throw.
war2d2
Could you go into a little more detail on the comparison between FV and OFP? Looking at the description of OFP in the BP glossary it looks like a distinction without a difference. If a player is listed as “OFP: 70 / All-Star” and “Variance: Medium” how would you equate that to FG’s scale? I’m just tying to get my head around it, I’ve been reading both sites’ prospect coverage for a dozen years and assumed they were the same thing.
Eric Longenhagen
My 70 is 5+ annual WAR on average during the years of team control. There are so many articles about how I apply the scale. I think if you looked at a histogram of the grades we/pipeline/bp/ba put on players and compared the distributions you'd see a clear difference. Lemme dig up a recent article on or scouting scale.
Eric Longenhagen
Bunch of stuff here: https://blogs.fangraphs.com/the-new-fangraphs-scouting-prime…
Eric Longenhagen
And here: https://blogs.fangraphs.com/how-to-use-the-board-a-tutorial-…
jwise224
What's Angel Genao's playing time situation look like for 2027? He profiles a better bat than Rocchio, but less of a fielder. We know how Cleveland likes their strong defenders at key positions. Seems like too much talent to just ride the pine as a bench bat.
Eric Longenhagen
Cleveland tends to behave in such a way that maximizes the amount of time they control the player. And so I expect Genao will open the season in Columbus, unless one of Bazzana/Rocchio/Ramirez gets hurt during spring training.
deadpullpitcher
Any thoughts on newly signed Raider Sanchez?
Eric Longenhagen
St. Louis signed this guy, $650k, Romero reported it. Big power, physically mature kid. Track record on guys like that isn't great, definitely has real power. 35+ FV type. Bonuses for late-market guys tend to be inflated by market forces, 650K guys barely make the board a lot of the time.
Eric Longenhagen
Lots of attention because he's signing now, alone, with no other news, as opposed to in January when lots and lots of kids sign for 650k
grandbranyan
Brewers just won the WS with the youngest pitching staff since the 2003 Marlins. They got the most WAR from position players Age 28 and under last year and overall since 2023 (with ten of them currently set to return for 2027). With their recent emphasis on HS arms they had 12 of the 88 pitchers to throw at least 60 IP in their Age 20 or younger season last year in the minors, most any other org had was six. They typically have the youngest position player groups in their respective A/A+/AA leagues. Is their front office just blaring All The Young Dudes on a loop over the house system or what?
Eric Longenhagen
Their multi-year draft approach is working, they take HS players and JUCO arms who are 20 or under and control the development during the years it's most important, especially for position players. It's a really well run operation that is going to allow them to be competitive basically every year.
Cromulent
Follow up on the AFL question would be why teams with presumably some interest in the financial success of the Fall League allow prospects to play in other unaffiliated winter leagues like LIDOM, etc.? Would have been nice to see Made, Duno, Level, Brito, Emil Morales, Jefferson Rojas to name a few in Arizona.
Eric Longenhagen
I spoke with a media member who was doing work for the league who told me the finances of the AFL really aren't important. It's not a money making endeavor in any way. It might be an interest-catalyzing endeavor for folks like 19-year-old Eric Longenhagen, and other nerds.
Eric Longenhagen
And I want it to be a healthy, vibrant thing.
Eric Longenhagen
But you can't make the teams send good players here. Some of them don't care and will send guys who walk two batter per inning. I can also understand sending Jefferson Rojas, a young adult, home to play winter ball in an environment that is more enriching and competitive, rather than send him to AZ for six weeks.
Ogbert
Eric – a question I've failed to ask in previous prospect chats: can you explain what a cold-weather background means for an amateur's pro potential? I hear that used in terms of hitters who come from New England or such — is it that cold weather depresses some amateur stats/metrics so there's more to dream on than initially meets the eye during scouting?
Eric Longenhagen
A bit of both. I can feel better about varsity play data samples in Florida and Texas than I can in Wisconsin.
Eric Longenhagen
And you might need a prolonged initial adjustment period if you've been facing kids throwing 78 for three years in PA, especially if you play football or something else (or just have a normal childhood) such that you're not on the showcase circuit year round
robert kelly
Is Driveline as successful in assisting players' development as it appears from the bits and pieces described in various baseball articles? If so, what's their secret sauce?
Eric Longenhagen
I don't think one can properly answer this question in chat. If this is Bobby Kelly the comedian, next time you're in Phoenix I'll just get someone from driveline to take you to the facility. I think what has become of driveline is incredible, and has only become moreso now that they have set up shop in Japan and the DR. Standing ovation, that's amazing. I think they help develop pitchers, either directly or through the osmosis that has occurred as their style and aporoach has been copied and popularized. I also think they have had knock-on effects to the baseball ecosystem that are negative, some of which I wish they'd foreseen, and some of which are not their fault.
Baseball Learner
When doing the Yankees system, who was one (non Kilby division) prospect that made you go wow he's better than I thought
Eric Longenhagen
Kean and Boudreau, probably Beck too because of the new offspeed pitch.
Baseball Learner
Does Kilby have the bat to be a 1st division 3rd baseman if he needs to move there
Eric Longenhagen
Yes, I think if he moves there it's in part because he's become too big and strong to play SS< which will have yielded more power. 3B production is way down since the peak of Chappy/Machado/Arenado and that group.
crossedup
Probably an article and not a chat response but I'd be curious about the concern over class action lawsuits when we've seen in the past couple decades the NBA have the college rule. I think the NFL has the rule as well though you wouldn't line up an 18 year old player in the NFL anyway.
Eric Longenhagen
A great point. That might hold less water if NIL money goes away. The NIL alternative, imo, means you're less likely to be able to claim you're being harmed by not being allowed in the NBA. I agree there's a separate safety issue in the NFL that changes how I think about anyone but 18-year-old Adrian Peterson going straight to the NFL from HS.
wschuyle
One more on Kilby. There were articles about his big swing change at start of AFL. How did that look – did not see much written about it from the evaluators. Overall like your approach to him – hot takes are bad and need to see how he shows in a full-season – this year too small sample.
Eric Longenhagen
I didn't notice anything different, but the prior video we have on Kilby since turning pro is so limited because of his injuries.
Eric Longenhagen
Ok friends, that's gonna do it for this week. Thanks again for coming. I'll see you in TWO WEEKS. I leave for Pennsylvania this weekend, so if you're bar hopping in Catasauqua Wednesday, you might see me. Happy Thanksgiving, go roughies.







