FanGraphs Power Rankings: Spring Training 2026 (No. 18–30)

Baseball is in the air. Grainy cellphone footage has started to leak out. The excitement for the World Baseball Classic is peaking. The last time we ran these power rankings, the offseason had just begun and teams were still making plans for how they were going to improve their rosters during the winter. This run of the rankings provides a good barometer for which teams took big steps forward with their splashy signings and big trades, and which ones have been left in the dust. Today I’ll cover the teams projected to finish under .500 in 2026, with those forecast for a .500 or better record to follow on Monday.

Our power rankings use a modified Elo rating system. If you’re familiar with chess rankings or FiveThirtyEight’s defunct sports section, you’ll know that Elo is an elegant ranking format that measures teams’ relative strength and is very reactive to recent performance. For these pre-spring training rankings, I’ve pulled the Depth Charts projections — now powered by both the 2026 Steamer and 2026 ZiPS projections — and calculated an implied Elo ranking for each team. First up are the rankings for teams 18-30, presented in a sortable table. Below that, I’ve grouped the teams into tiers, with comments on each club. The delta column in the table below shows the change in ranking from the last offseason run of the power rankings in November.

Spring Training Power Rankings (No. 18–30)
Rank Team Projected Record Implied ELO Playoff Odds Projected Batter WAR Projected Pitcher WAR Δ
18 Padres 80-82 1497 24.1% 26.0 14.7 3
19 Rangers 80-82 1497 31.6% 22.9 16.4 -6
20 Twins 80-82 1496 31.8% 21.7 16.4 -8
21 Reds 79-83 1493 19.5% 18.9 17.3 5
22 Athletics 78-84 1492 23.6% 25.7 11.4 1
23 Rays 78-84 1491 20.5% 21.3 16.7 -7
24 Guardians 75-87 1483 12.8% 22.5 12.9 1
25 Marlins 75-87 1482 7.8% 17.6 13.6 -1
26 Cardinals 75-87 1481 7.9% 22.0 10.2 -7
27 Angels 73-89 1475 5.9% 17.1 13.1 0
28 Nationals 69-93 1462 0.8% 17.1 8.7 0
29 White Sox 68-94 1460 1.2% 16.0 12.0 0
30 Rockies 65-97 1451 0.2% 15.0 7.8 0

…

Tier 6 – High-Variance Could-Be’s
Team Projected Record Implied ELO Playoff Odds Projected Batter WAR Projected Pitcher WAR
Padres 80-82 1497 24.1% 26.0 14.7
Rangers 80-82 1497 31.6% 22.9 16.4
Twins 80-82 1496 31.8% 21.7 16.4

It’s been a surprisingly quiet offseason for the Padres. They re-signed Michael King — a near necessity after seeing Dylan Cease depart in free agency and losing Yu Darvish for the season to elbow surgery — and Joe Musgrove should be healthy after missing all of 2025 with his own elbow surgery. But even with those two starters back in the fold, the rotation looks frighteningly shallow. You could probably say that about the entire roster, though. Years of win-now trades have depleted the farm system, and the upper minors look pretty devoid of meaningful depth. Maybe that won’t be a problem if everyone stays healthy, but the grind of the regular season means San Diego will inevitably have to dip into that depth at some point.

If the Rangers were going to squeeze every last ounce from this contention window that brought them a championship back in 2023, they needed to make some pretty dramatic moves this offseason. Trading Marcus Semien for Brandon Nimmo? Check. Sending a host of prospects to the Nationals for MacKenzie Gore? Check. Will it be enough to challenge the Mariners and Astros for the AL West crown? The projections aren’t convinced. Adding Gore to the starting rotation shifts the weight of expectations off of Jack Leiter and Kumar Rocker’s shoulders, but the pitching staff still looks weaker than the unit that led the majors in run prevention last year. On the offensive side of things, if you squint, you can see a healthy season from Corey Seager, a big step forward from Wyatt Langford and Evan Carter, and bounce-back campaigns from Joc Pederson and Jake Burger all powering an improved lineup. But that’s a lot of things that need to go right for Texas to hit its 90th-percentile win projection.

The Twins are in the midst of a significant transition at the organizational level. Last week, the team announced that it had “mutually agreed to part ways” with the president of baseball and business operations Derek Falvey. He had been at the helm since 2016, and combined with the huge teardown last summer, his departure represents a huge shift in direction for the franchise. Most of the moves the Twins have made this offseason have been on the fringes: They signed Josh Bell, Victor Caratini, and Taylor Rogers to short-term deals and have made a handful of small trades to clear space on their 40-man roster. And yet, they still have a strong core of players — including Joe Ryan, Pablo López, and Byron Buxton — and a trio of young position players — Luke Keaschall, Walker Jenkins, and Emmanuel Rodriguez — who could make an impact this year. The projections have them a hair below .500 right now, but it feels like that can swing dramatically depending on if they stick with the guys they have now or decide to continue selling off the talent they have left this summer.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed. We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member. 1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other. 2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off. 3. Dark mode and Classic mode! 4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them. 5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects. 6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.) 7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only. 8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO. 9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members. 10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features! We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it. In case you didn't read all that, here's the short version. Membership includes:
✓Ad-free browsing
✓Unlimited FanGraphs & RotoGraphs articles
✓Historical & platoon projections
✓Leaderboard & player-page stat heatmaps
✓One-click data exports
✓Customizable player-page dashboards
✓Dark & Classic site modes
✓Weekly Members-only mailbag
✓FanGraphs Walk-Off, your year in review
✓Optional homepage photo removal
✓Gift articles to non-Members
✓Full postseason coverage
Tier 7 – Laying the Foundation
Team Projected Record Implied ELO Playoff Odds Projected Batter WAR Projected Pitcher WAR
Reds 79-83 1493 19.5% 18.9 17.3
Athletics 78-84 1492 23.6% 25.7 11.4
Rays 78-84 1491 20.5% 21.3 16.7
Guardians 75-87 1483 12.8% 22.5 12.9
Marlins 75-87 1482 7.8% 17.6 13.6
Cardinals 75-87 1481 7.9% 22.0 10.2

The Reds blasted just 167 home runs last year, 10th fewest in the majors and a surprisingly low total for a team that calls Great American Ballpark home. Reuniting with Eugenio Suárez and his powerful bat should help in that regard. The rest of the lineup still has plenty of question marks. Will Elly De La Cruz bounce back after playing through a quad injury last summer? Can any of Spencer Steer, Matt McLain, or Noelvi Marte emerge as stars? Fortunately, the pitching staff looks like it will continue to be a strength. Led by Hunter Greene, the starting rotation should carry Cincinnati to the fringe of the NL Wild Card race. It worked out for the Reds last year, maybe lightning will strike twice.

The A’s continued to fortify the foundations of their roster by handing out a pair of seven-year contract extensions to Tyler Soderstrom and Jacob Wilson this offseason. Along with Brent Rooker, Lawrence Butler, and Rookie of the Year winner Nick Kurtz, those five players are signed or under team control through at least 2029. That means this core will still be with the team for its expected move to Las Vegas in a few years. Adding to the excitement is 19-year-old top prospect Leo De Vries, the prize from last summer’s Mason Miller trade who is developing quickly. Yet, for all that thump on offense, the less that’s said about the pitching staff, the better. That puts the A’s in an awkward position, where their lineup is plenty good enough to contend but their pitchers are lagging far behind. There are some promising young arms coming up through the organization, but they are still a few years away. In the meantime, the hurlers at the major league level will struggle to survive in the extremely hitter-friendly confines of West Sacramento’s Sutter Health Park.

The Rays snuck their way into three separate three-team deals this offseason, a near perfect encapsulation of their incremental approach to roster building. And with every other team in the AL East looking like a powerhouse, this year seems like a perfect moment for Tampa Bay to reset the roster and start building for its next contention window. Out are Brandon Lowe, Josh Lowe, and Shane Baz. In are Gavin Lux — probably a temporary stopgap at second base — and a collection of prospects to restock the farm system. Thankfully, Junior Caminero looks like a star to build around, and the pitching staff looks solid with the hopefully healthy return of Shane McClanahan.

Even if the rest of their offseason was quiet, it has to be seen as a success for the Guardians after they signed José Ramírez to a seven-year contract extension that should keep him in Cleveland through the end of his career. Locking up a future Hall of Famer to a team-friendly deal is something to be celebrated, especially since Ramírez has a pretty good shot at becoming the franchise’s best player of the last 100 years. But if you did want to quibble with the rest of the Guardians’ lack of activity this offseason, you could point to the small payroll savings they negotiated via Ramírez’s deal and the lack of reinvestment in the roster. Maybe those funds will trickle down to the roster in the near future, but the current group is pretty flawed. The Guardians were pretty lucky to win the AL Central last year, and the projections see them as the fourth-best team in that division heading into this season.

The Marlins did well to trade away from a position of strength — their starting rotation — to hopefully acquire an impact bat in Owen Caissie and restock their farm system with a gaggle of prospects. Eury Pérez took a big step forward last year after recovering from Tommy John surgery, and top pitching prospects Thomas White and Robby Snelling should get an opportunity to debut this year. These are small steps toward building a contender in Miami, but it feels like there’s some forward momentum here.

Chaim Bloom started tearing down the Cardinals as soon as he was installed as their president of baseball operations this offseason. He found trade partners for Nolan Arenado and Sonny Gray, removing the largest contracts on the team’s books, and also dealt Willson Contreras and Brendan Donovan for a bunch of prospects and draft picks. It’s a promising start to the Cardinals’ rebuild, and I’d expect more moves this summer. Meanwhile, top prospect JJ Wetherholt should have an opportunity to earn a spot on the Opening Day roster. That should give fans a glimpse of the future while the front office sorts out how to build a contender around him.

Tier 8 – Perpetually Rebuilding
Team Projected Record Implied ELO Playoff Odds Projected Batter WAR Projected Pitcher WAR
Angels 73-89 1475 5.9% 17.1 13.1
Nationals 69-93 1462 0.8% 17.1 8.7
White Sox 68-94 1460 1.2% 16.0 12.0

You can’t fault the Angels for attempting to raise their ceiling a little bit. They brought in five pitchers this offseason — Grayson Rodriguez, Alek Manoah, Jordan Romano, Kirby Yates, and Drew Pomeranz — who have each been fantastic at some point in the past, but have also dealt with significant injuries that have sapped their effectiveness. It’s a fine gamble to make, with the hope that at least one or two of them will actually make an impact this year. They also re-signed third baseman Yoán Moncada and acquired outfielder Josh Lowe, who will replace Taylor Ward in the outfield after they sent him to Baltimore in the Rodriguez deal. Will it be enough to lift the Halos out of their doldrums? No, probably not, but at least they’re trying something a little different.

New president of baseball operations Paul Toboni got right to work rebuilding the Nationals this winter. He dealt away MacKenzie Gore in the offseason’s biggest trade and made a savvy move to get catcher Harry Ford from the Mariners for lefty reliever Jose A. Ferrer. What these moves indicate is that Washington is about to embark on another rebuilding cycle after the last one petered out under former GM Mike Rizzo. James Wood is young enough, and under team control for long enough, that he should still be considered a big part of the team’s future. The same might not be true for CJ Abrams, though with three years left of control, the Nats shouldn’t be in a hurry to move on from their shortstop.

The White Sox had a pretty interesting offseason. Of course, the biggest headline was the signing of Munetaka Murakami to a two-year deal. It’s a huge risk, but it’s an exciting move that could pay off handsomely if Murakami adjusts to MLB pitching quickly. Chicago also moved on from Luis Robert Jr. and used some of the payroll savings to take Jordan Hicks’s contract off Boston’s hands in order to get an interesting pitching prospect in David Sandlin. With Colson Montgomery and Kyle Teel already making an impact in the majors, and Noah Schultz and Hagen Smith close to debuting, the shape of an interesting team is starting to emerge on the South Side.

Tier 9 – The Rock Bottom
Team Projected Record Implied ELO Playoff Odds Projected Batter WAR Projected Pitcher WAR
Rockies 65-97 1451 0.2% 15.0 7.8

Unlike some of the other front office hires this offseason, Paul DePodesta has taken a pretty quiet approach to reshaping the roster. The moves he’s made have all been focused on improving the margins of the roster. The Rockies have signed Willi Castro and Michael Lorenzen and traded for Jake McCarthy and Edouard Julien. The four newcomers provide some much-needed depth, but none of them really raises the ceiling of the ball club. I guess we’ll have to wait for this summer to see if there are any impactful trades in the offing.





Jake Mailhot is a contributor to FanGraphs. A long-suffering Mariners fan, he also writes about them for Lookout Landing. Follow him on BlueSky @jakemailhot.

85 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Yer Main GuyMember since 2024
8 months ago

Anybody really think Minnesota has a 31% of making the playoffs? I don’t see what they did in the off-season that improves things so dramatically from their 70 win season.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago
Reply to  Yer Main Guy

More like 20%, but it’s there. Keaschall and Buxton are great, Wallner and Royce Lewis are high-variance, and the rotation is still pretty good with Ryan and Lopez at the top and going six deep (seven if you believe in Mick Abel, which I do not).

But I’m not buying that Pablo Lopez is going to throw 169 innings, or that Buxton, Keaschall, and Lewis are going to have 560 PAs each. You take a third off of each of those guys and assign those innings / PAs to Connor Prielipp, James Outman, Orlando Arcia, and Austin Martin and I think you’ve got a different story.

drewsylvaniaMember since 2019🏆 MVP
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Roden is also there and MLB ready, but yeah.

cowdiscipleMember since 2016
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Keaschall is very exciting but I think it’s too soon to call him great.

I Like Big BuxtonMember since 2024
8 months ago
Reply to  Yer Main Guy

I’m inclined to say that seems about right. There is a lot of variance that can happen in a season and they play in a soft division.

Using Base Runs, they performed as a “true-talent” 75-win team in 2025. They ended up getting 15.7 WAR from their position players and 16.4 from their pitchers. FG Depth Charts has their pitching the same, but the position players up to 21.7, so having them around 80 wins checks out.

The vibes around this team are so bad that it’s hard to see the positive outcomes, but stripping out vibes is one of the reasons projection systems exist, right?

Jason BMember since 2017
8 months ago
Reply to  Yer Main Guy

I was blown away by the chart showing their rank was down eight slots – am I to believe they were ranked 12th in November? Was it ranking the 1991 Twins? Did Brad Radke and Doug Mientkiewicz unretire?

I Like Big BuxtonMember since 2024
8 months ago
Reply to  Jason B

They dropped eight spots, but their projected wins only went from 82 to 80. It’s because hardly any offseason moves had happened when the previous rankings were done.

Jason BMember since 2017
8 months ago

I just don’t know how anyone could look at that 70-win team at the end of the season and think, “yeah, that’s one of the best dozen teams in baseball.”

I Like Big BuxtonMember since 2024
8 months ago
Reply to  Jason B

Yeah, but it’s not a person generating the numbers, and projection systems don’t “think” like that. The November rankings were done with rosters as they were then – almost no free agents signed, few trades done, awful depth as a result – and used Steamer projections.

It was a snapshot in time, only a rough estimate of where teams were at the start of the offseason.

cowdiscipleMember since 2016
8 months ago
Reply to  Jason B

That was the reaction in the comments on those November rankings, too.

Last edited 8 months ago by cowdisciple
scottbotMember since 2024
8 months ago
Reply to  Yer Main Guy

They continued to reside in the AL Central

Adam SMember since 2016
8 months ago
Reply to  Yer Main Guy

Yeh, that’s the one that jumps out at me. I put a high level of trust in projection systems, especially when they’re averaged against two models.

But the Twins were awful in August and September last year and I don’t know how they’re suddenly respectable.

warpath
8 months ago
Reply to  Yer Main Guy

As a MN fan, that’s too high to me.

There’s a world where with some injury luck and young player improvement, they make the postseason. The pitching staff has some depth, if not a ton of proven talent beyond Lopez-Ryan-Ober, and guys like Brooks Lee or Alan Roden showing they can actually hit at the major league level isn’t unfathomable.

But unfortunately, I think it’s far more likely Lopez, Ryan, and Jeffers are gone at the deadline after the team has been hanging out a bit below .500 for a while, and the last couple months of the season is a rerun of 2025.

warpath
8 months ago
Reply to  Yer Main Guy

I actually quite like the Caratini and Taylor Roger’s signings, they definitively improve the team in my book.

Don’t like the Josh Bell signing one bit, would have much rather rolled with a Wagaman/Julien timeshare at 1B. As a fan I’d really prefer those Josh Bell PAs go to almost anybody else as Bell is well into his 30s and been a replacement-ish player the last few years. I don’t even know if the signing gets made if Caratini is signed first.

But yeah, not a ton to write home about. A couple decent signings, one baffling one, and then a lot of fiddling on the edges doesn’t really produce confidence.

raregokusMember since 2022
8 months ago
Reply to  Yer Main Guy

All fair points, but ask yourself this: would this be the worst Central division team to ever make the playoffs?

branflakesMember since 2024
8 months ago
Reply to  Yer Main Guy

Maybe Buxton is healthy all year, maybe Royce Lewis bounces back and stays healthy, maybe I win the lottery.

Shirtless George Brett
8 months ago
Reply to  Yer Main Guy

I said this last year but it probably still applies. The Twins are arguably the most talented team in the division. The problem is that talent is rarely on the field at the same time.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago

I’d put the Reds (and Padres) clearly ahead of the Rangers and Twins at this point. I’d say the Reds and Padres are the high-variance could be’s and the rest are just high-variance.

The Reds have a lousy outfield and bullpen but they go legitimately five deep in the rotation, with considerable upside between Greene, Burns, and (to a lesser extent) Lodolo, and I think the rest of the lineup could be good.

Otherwise I think this is about right. The teams from 19 through 25 (except the Reds) could contend for a wild card spot for much of the season but it’s hard to see them actually hanging in there for the whole year, and most of them are relying on a lot of young guys who might could easily underperform.

scottbotMember since 2024
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Somehow, someway, the Guards will be relevant

bosoxforlifeMember since 2016
8 months ago
Reply to  scottbot

Jose Ramirez and Stephen Vogt.

johansantana17Member since 2026
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Why are the Padres high variance? Even with great seasons from Tatis and Merrill, they’re still only a mid 80s wins team.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago
Reply to  johansantana17

They won 90 games last year while having less-than-ideal seasons from most of their stars so I think the upside should be obvious. But so much of their value is tied up in about five players and the rotation is a huge question mark so there are some pretty extreme downside scenarios too.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago

Also, penciling the Angels in for 72 or 73 wins seems pretty safe. Here are their wins by year recently:

2022: 73 wins
2023: 73 wins
2024: 63 wins
2025: 72 wins

Going into another year with Jo Adell in center field and Jorge Soler playing every day in a corner going to be…exciting. Reminds me a little bit of the time Preller decided Wil Myer should play center field with Matt Kemp and Justin Upton on either side of him.

Here are the Angels projected lineup and their FRV / number of innings from 2025:

C Logan O’Hoppe: -11 FRV, 869 innings
1B Nolan Schanuel: -1 FRV, 1131 innings
2B Christian Moore: -1 FRV, 411.2 innings
SS Zach Neto: -4 FRV, 1078.1 innings
3B Yoan Moncada: -9 FRV, 593.1 innings
LF Jorge Soler: -4 FRV, 315.2 innings
CF Jo Adell: -8 FRV, 724 innings (and another -5 in RF)
RF Josh Lowe: -5 FRV, 854.1 innings

Except for third base they could get by in the infield. But if Trout stays healthy all year and they aren’t tempted to put him in the field we could get the worst outfield defense of the Statcast era. It will be hard to beat the Tigers 2016 outfield with JD Martinez, Justin Upton, and Cameron Maybin but they’ve got a shot.

Jason BMember since 2017
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

But if Trout stays healthy all year 

No, to whatever else that sentence says. Just…no.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago
Reply to  Jason B

Don’t laugh! He had 556 PAs last year and not playing the field should help manage his chronic knee issue (left knee, I think).

He got hurt at the end of April in 2025 and returned at the end of May. He DH’d the whole time and had the most PAs of any Angels player between his return on May 30 and the end of the year.

In fact, he was 37th in PAs from that point on to the end of the year on out for all of MLB.

He could easily give you a full season’s worth of PAs, however you define it. I define it as 600 PAs but you could do 650.

TKDCMember since 2016🏆 MVP
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Trout not accepting himself as a DH 5 years ago was a huge mistake. He could be looking at a graceful second act, easily hitting 500-600 homers. And he wasn’t even that great in the field.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago
Reply to  TKDC

CF is a high-status position and players are used to playing through pain. And he was doing okay out there until 2024 too. You can see how that might lead him to oppose moving off of CF.

And this is why the Angels’ organizational philosophy of letting their stars dictate their own usage is going to end badly most of the time. These injuries are different than the ones he grew up with.

Last edited 8 months ago by sadtrombone
vbjd1111Member since 2019
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I was at last years game where he injured his knee. It was on a routine ground ball (he was hitting) and he wasn’t even running that hard. Makes me less sanguine that DH’ing will result in a full season of PAs.

mattMember since 2023
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

O’Hoppe has been rather disappointing

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago
Reply to  matt

Hard to be a positive contributor when you’re running a .260 OBP and you can’t frame the ball. Robo umps might help him with the framing. But when you’re striking out about six times as much as you’re walking your road to hitting adequately is narrow.

johansantana17Member since 2026
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

RIP Angels pitchers, especially those with low K rates. Looking at you, Jose Soriano.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago
Reply to  johansantana17

Could be worse. Hitters had a negative launch angle against him last year (I think the only starter who did). The infield is lousy but they are still better than the outfield.

(although pitchers who don’t get K’s or grounders don’t usually stick around for long)

Fun-Hating DorkMember since 2019
8 months ago

Is it unfair to me to say that the 0.2% playoff chance for the Rockies feels high?

boomstickMember since 2024
8 months ago

A colorado rocky mountain high?

johansantana17Member since 2026
8 months ago
Reply to  boomstick

He’d be a poorer man if he never saw an eagle flyyyy

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago

2 times out of 1000?

Yes, I think that’s a little high. They’re projected for 65 wins. That is probably an optimistic outcome for them.

The White Sox won 60 last year after being the worst non-expansion team since integration, and the Rockies had the worst run differential of all time last year.

60 games seems like a pretty good median guess for the Rockies, which would probably push their playoff chances below 0.1%.

But I think we’re already firmly in “so you’re telling me there’s a chance” territory either way.

Dodgers BlueMember since 2021
8 months ago

Doubt they would have the “best package” of prospects the Twins would want in a return for Pablo Lopez or Joe Ryan, but I think it’d be kinda cool if the A’s finished off an amazing off season of long-term commitment signings by acquiring a top flight guy like that to make the present legitimate.

johansantana17Member since 2026
8 months ago
Reply to  Dodgers Blue

I don’t think the Twins are sellers anymore, Tom Pohlad wants to compete now which was the rift with Falvey. A’s could look to acquire Sandy Alcantara

boomstickMember since 2024
8 months ago

Pretty wild the Rangers can cut league-worst offensive catcher Jonah Heim and sign the second-biggest catcher deal of the offseason, and it doesn’t rate a mention in the major team activities summary.

Do catchers not impact power rankings?

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago
Reply to  boomstick

Not this one. Danny Jansen projects for 1.4 wins by ZiPS over 321 PAs and Jonah Heim projects for 1.3 wins over 425 PAs. Steamer600 (which puts catchers at 450 PAs) has Danny Jansen at 1.6 wins and Jonah Heim at 1.2 wins.

Currently Depth Charts has Danny Jansen at 352 PAs for 1.3 WAR. Jonah Heim would be maybe at 1.1? Or 1? They’re probably getting as much out of that as the Jakob Junis signing.

boomstickMember since 2024
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Superb answer, thank you. ZiPS is way higher on Heim than the MLB front offices are.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago
Reply to  boomstick

If you look at the projection systems–Steamer600 is a reasonable choice because it’s all got the same number of PAs–there are something like seventy or eighty catchers that project between 1.0 and 1.7 WAR. Even if you think Heim is at the low end of that range and Jansen is at the high end, it’s still not a huge improvement. And the projection systems think that over 350 PAs the difference is probably only about 0.3 WAR. At most.

I think that Steamer, ZiPS, and the others are have a really hard time with the concept of replacement-level players at catcher. They just cannot believe that there are so many impossibly bad-hitting catchers out there and / or that the positional adjustment at catcher is so huge it will make up for it. This super-duper incorrect. There were 62 catchers with at least 100 PAs at catcher last year and thirteen of them were below replacement level for their work at catcher. If you thought the current catching crop was bad, wait until you see the guys that weren’t good enough to play over Martin Maldonado or Jose Herrera.

Heim wasn’t even one of the catchers below replacement for his work at catcher, he’s only below replacement because the Rangers amazingly had him DH for 27 games. I guess Joc Pederson and Ezequiel Duran were also super bad, but if you’re playing your 70-ish wRC+ catcher at DH you’ve made several mistakes to get to that point. Nimmo / Haggerty / Helman should be getting those PAs this year for sure.

Heim is definitely in minor league deal territory for me right now, and he might just be broken now. But he was a scratch defender at catcher as recently as 2024. I’d probably put him behind Christian Vazquez but I think he’s a better bet than Andrew Knizner, who somehow got a major league deal.

raregokusMember since 2022
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Totally forgot Knizner signed a major league deal. What does he have on Jerry?

aldenMember since 2019
8 months ago
Reply to  raregokus

A really nice smile and that’s about it

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago
Reply to  raregokus

Andrew Knizner, the catcher with -1.7 career fWAR?

I guess he’s only been -0.4 over his last 700 PAs or so. Mostly because he learned to frame since leaving St. Louis.

Okay I have no idea. I give up.

NATS FanMember since 2018
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

It’s all those Knizer intangibles

Jason BMember since 2017
8 months ago
Reply to  NATS Fan

A Knizer man I have never met.

David Klein
8 months ago

The Twins are in a real weird spot now with Tom Pohland running off Falvey(who may have wanted to sell more guys off), and wanting to be more hands on than the other Pohland’s were and thinking the team is better than it looks to be. Joel Sherman said the Twins were one of the teams in on trading for Peralta and Heyman said the Twins were in on Valdez.

cowdiscipleMember since 2016
8 months ago
Reply to  David Klein

It’s really unclear what they’re up to. Maybe they parted ways with Falvey because ownership didn’t actually want to sell as hard as they sold last summer? Hard to believe, but I am willing to keep an open mind and see what they do next.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago
Reply to  cowdisciple

It definitely seems that Tom Pohlad has a different idea than the previous control person about what should be done going forward.

There are some MLB owners who change their minds a lot and the front office has to scramble to appease what they want. But in this case it’s literally a different person, so who knows.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago
Reply to  David Klein

I can’t imagine that they’re going to find a top-tier external candidate to lead the front office going forward. Which is kind of too bad because they could use some fresh blood and ideas, and this is a good opportunity to do it.

Every top-tier candidate is going to look at the Twins and say: You want us to try and go for it with that roster as a base? And with that budget?

They’ve got Josh Bell at first base, Brooks Lee at shortstop, Royce Lewis at third base, and Trevor Larnach playing the field. Their closer had an xERA of 4.14 last year, and they only have four other relievers who project to be above replacement. And their best position players are constantly hurt, so you really need to be rock solid at every non-CF / 2B position and they just aren’t.

I could maybe see it if they decided to keep Duran and Jax, but they didn’t. Their chances in 2026 and 2027 are gone.

cowdiscipleMember since 2016
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Unfortunately I agree. They could “go for” the AL Central title but even if they make it they’ll be underdogs in just about every playoff matchup.

Last edited 8 months ago by cowdisciple
sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago
Reply to  David Klein

IMO, the only reason to not trade Joe Ryan is if you can extend him. The only reason not to trade Pablo Lopez, Bailey Ober, or Trevor Larnach is if they’re not playing well or hurt.

The Twins have a huge wave of prospects who are going to be ready in 2026 or 2027 at the latest. Walker Jenkins, Emmanuel Rodriguez, Connor Prielipp, Kaelen Culpepper and Kendry Rojas all look like they are ready to be MLB contributors soon, and neither Keaschall or Wallner have reached arbitration yet. Anyone can see that this is the group they need to build around.

David Klein
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Yeah, I think they are very likely to be good by 2028 if not earlier.

PC1970Member since 2024
8 months ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Of course, Jenkins & Rodriguez have the same problem as Buxton, Lewis, etc, they can’t stay healthy.

I also question if Rodriguez’ passive approach works vs MLB pitching.

drplantwrenchMember since 2024
8 months ago

something even halfway positive about the angels?? in this economy!??!!?

cowdiscipleMember since 2016
8 months ago
Reply to  drplantwrench

I really liked the Angels’ offseason.

airforce21oneMember since 2026
8 months ago

I have this weird belief in Edouard Julien and I have no idea why

Fun-Hating DorkMember since 2019
8 months ago
Reply to  airforce21one

I have a tendency to stay on OBP-heavier guys longer than circumstances merit.

warpath
8 months ago
Reply to  airforce21one

As a Twins fan, he’s had his ups and downs but I really believe the guy will be a useful major league hitter down the road.

He is not a good or versatile defender at all and was out of options, so he was squeezed off the Twins who already have too many DHish left-handed hitters. But I’ll be watching him pretty closely this year to see what he does given some run.

Jason BMember since 2017
8 months ago
Reply to  airforce21one

70-grade eyebrows

compucles
8 months ago

You actually have the Pirates projected as a .500+ team this year (and 3rd place in their division)? I know they’ve gotten significantly better this offseason, but that’s still a pretty big surprise.

eljefe17Member since 2025
8 months ago

is there an article analyzing how well these predictions work out because there are a couple teams that seem to be perpetual outliers

achidesterMember since 2020
8 months ago
Reply to  eljefe17

if the goal was to accurately predict the win totals for a single team (ex. Brewers), you’d make intentional adjustments to your projection system(s). But when you’re generating the median projection for all 30 teams, outliers are inevitable as you adjust to improve the accuracy of the projections.

Fun-Hating DorkMember since 2019
8 months ago
Reply to  achidester

if the goal was to accurately predict the win totals for a single team (ex. Brewers), you’d make intentional adjustments to your projection system(s).

Unless and until you have evidence of a systemic flaw, moving projections around — even if just trying to hone in on one team — is just going to reduce the reliability of your system overall.

If the argument is, well, some team (we’ll call them the Seattle Pilots) always over-/underachieves because of some specific team makeup or coaching, etc., those aren’t things that stay constant season-to-season. The Pilots will have some roster churn, have coaches leave, get bought by a used car salesman, etc. You want to create a projection system that tries to eliminate fudge factors, because those are the kind of things that break hard when conditions change.

Fun-Hating DorkMember since 2019
8 months ago
Reply to  eljefe17

I’d like to see that, too, just from an analytical perspective, but I also feel like “seem to be” is load-bearing in that sentence.

mattMember since 2023
8 months ago

I’ll take the significant over on the padres

Envy AngelMember since 2017
8 months ago

Same old, same old for the Angels: 1) make a few moves early, 2) sign or trade for some guys who were pretty good four or five years ago, 3) get a new manager, 4) let your farm system lie fallow, 5) wash, rinse, repeat for the next ten years, 6) watch your team string together the most sub-500 seasons in team history. Even Shohei couldn’t break this cycle.

Last edited 8 months ago by Envy Angel
johansantana17Member since 2026
8 months ago
Reply to  Envy Angel

Ouch. Painfully accurate.

scottbotMember since 2024
8 months ago

I’d love to see some impactful trades from COL but what even could they deal away that qualifies? Going all Mike Hampton contract 2.0 for Framber would have been fascinating just to see how he’d fare there but it’s tough to do much of impact when there’s just no impact talent (or really much second division regular) talent on the roster or near the majors to work with.

What do we think Hunter Goodman would fetch? ….Doyle?…..others?!?!?

johansantana17Member since 2026
8 months ago
Reply to  scottbot

I think those two, Dollander, and maybe Tovar are pretty much the only players of appreciable value on the MLB roster. I think the new regime is likely forming its own evaluation on their players before making significant moves though. The old regime didn’t even have a stuff+ model for their pitchers, so there’s some significant work to do.

Jason BMember since 2017
8 months ago
Reply to  scottbot

Doyle was dealing with a family tragedy last year, so impossible to know how much impact that had or how he rebounds, but he was awful last season. He’s had one passable season batting out of three and he’s running a 72 career wRC+

JimmieFoxxalorianMember since 2020
8 months ago

I’m gonna go out on a limb and declare that the White Sox will crack the 70-win plateau, and the Rockies will fail to get 60 wins

Scotty GMember since 2020
8 months ago

Unlike the past couple years, the White Sox at least have some interesting high-variance guys like who could feasibly greatly exceed projections with every day at-bats. And they’ve added a some actual MLB caliber late inning relievers. I could see a 10-win improvement just from not blowing a late inning lead 2-3 times a week.

Jason BMember since 2017
8 months ago

Saying the Rockies fail to reach 60 wins – brother you are on the sturdiest limb of that giant redwood you can drive a car through

KeithMember since 2024
8 months ago

A’s lineup/ Cincy rotation = 100 win team.
Alas….

Adam SMember since 2016
8 months ago
Reply to  Keith

I’m not sure Dodgers lineup/ Dodgers rotation = 100 win team, but I like the idea.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 months ago
Reply to  Keith

When Dan was constructing a team to beat the Dodgers I told him I wanted to see a team with the A’s lineup (#15 for position players per Depth Charts), Reds rotation (#8), and Guardians bullpen (#14).

That’s the #21, #22, and #24 teams here and I’m pretty sure that team would be a strong contender for the #2 team in MLB.

(If you could add Jose Ramirez and Steven Kwan from the Guardians I think you’d have a team that would rival the Dodgers)

docgooden85Member since 2018
8 months ago

Spring Training site power rankings:

1. Arizona
…
5. Florida

johansantana17Member since 2026
8 months ago
Reply to  docgooden85

For sure. Phoenix area is basically baseball HQ these days

bosoxforlifeMember since 2016
8 months ago

I thought the Rockies actually outperformed their talent level last season and it appears that they have done next to nothing to improve. Another run at 120 losses seems very likely, certainly more likely than anything close to 65 wins.

NATS FanMember since 2018
8 months ago

I’ll take 28th for the Nats. Witless ESPN had them 29th. I had them 25th using my system until they traded my favorite pitcher rather than extend him. I fully believe Gore will become an Ace this season! I really thought he was turning into our Logen Webb equivalent going forward. Pitching will be dark this season in the first few months. At least we have got two strong prospect pitchers coming next year. With a bunch of talent coming back from arm trouble as this season goes along, I think our starting pitching has a ok shot to be top 5 in 2028.

jrjbertsch
8 months ago

The Guardians went 20-7 in September of 2025 to win the Division for 3rd time in 4 years. In 2025, they came back to win the Division title from the largest deficit (15.5 games) in MLB history.

They have the entire team ( Noel was DFA’d) returning in 2026. How does the same team with new emerging talent drop 13 more games in 2026 than it did in 2025?

The “Soft” AL Central Division in the past 2 years has had 4 teams in the ALDS (more than any other MLB Division) and 1 in the ALCS.

Cleveland dominated Detroit in September, “… but they were lucky to win the Division … “. Since when does luck have anything to do with having the best record in the Division after 162 games?

Cleveland must have a steady supply of 4-leaf clovers dumped into the dugout. Over the past 10 years they been in 1 WS, 2 ALCS, 6 Division titles, and 7 post season appearances. Only the Yankees, Dodgers, and Astros have been better. 26 teams have been worse. Their luck is undeniable.

bosoxforlifeMember since 2016
8 months ago

Last season the AL East finished at +48. These projections have the division at +24. The teams have appeared to strengthen themselves more than most others and it would not be a surprise to see them beat the tar out of many of the weaker teams. The days of 19 games between division rivals is past and the 13 intra-division games with each rival will not seriously cut into the win totals. Last year the Yankees and Blue Jays won 94 and the Red Sox won 89. Three teams above 90 wins appears to be a reasonable prediction.

david k
8 months ago

“He found trade partners for Nolan Arenado and Sonny Gray, removing the largest contracts on the team’s books,”

When the Cardinals are paying $22M of Arenado’s $27M salary, I wouldn’t say they are really removing his contract from the books.

As for Sonny Gray, they are still paying $20M of his $31M, so between the two of them, they didn’t even really remove the salary of ONE player from their books.