FanGraphs Baseball

Scouting Explained: The Mysterious Hit Tool, Pt. 6

Scouting Explained: Introduction, Hitting Pt 1 Pt 2 Pt 3 Pt 4 Pt 5 Pt 6

Over my first two months at FanGraphs, I was surprised that the thing I got the most questions about was bat speed. Part of that may be that I’ve spent a lot of words talking about how mysterious the hit tool is, while bat speed seems like an input of the hit tool that’s objective. The common question is basically that, if this one part of the mystery can be perfectly quantified, then why aren’t scouts trying to demystify the process by quantifying it?

The problem is that bat speed can’t be perfectly quantified and there are maybe a dozen inputs to the hit tool. I split power into raw (deepest shot in batting practice) and game (homers per full MLB season at maturity) because of the obvious split between tools and game performance. A player could be “measured” to have plus bat speed but have no ability to make contact with that swing, like a pitcher that can hit 95 mph but has to pitch 90-92 mph to command it enough to stay in the game.

Read the rest of this entry »


Transcriptions Are Unfair, In a Way

Bruce Bochy is a good manager. There’s no way around that one, he’s got the wins to back him up. And he gives plenty of press time, talks well enough, and knows the game backwards. When you have a conversation with him, it feels normal, like you were talking baseball with a knowledgeable guy. If there’s a weird phrasing in there, you work the sentence around the quotes and get the most important piece out of the conversation.

But in the postseason you get transcripts of these conversations. And, well, they’re unfair.

And funny.

Q. Belt caught stealing, was there a sign missed?
BRUCE BOCHY: I’d say it’s kind of, you know, but it’s — I’ll leave it at that.

Q. After the throw, your third baseman went down, the trainer went out; what was hurting?
BRUCE BOCHY: I don’t know, I haven’t — you talking about Pablo?

Q. Why is Vogelsong a good man to be pitching this fourth game?
BRUCE BOCHY: Well, he’s one of our starters.

That’s just three random questions in one ten-minute press conference after the game. With a slight bit of context taken out in each case. Seen this way, these real-life answers paint a silly picture.

But if you were having a conversation with him in the dugout before a game, you would have learned that he didn’t really want to leave his first baseman out to dry, that he doesn’t think of his players by their role, and that he has confidence in Ryan Vogelsong.

Try transcribing a random conversation you have with your friends and you’ll see. Transcriptions are unfair, in a way.


Stephen Strasburg: Game Four Relief Ace?

With a 4-1 victory over the Giants last night, the Nationals breathed a little life into their hopes of advancing past the NDLS. Tonight, they look to win another game in San Francisco, and the pitching match-up certainly looks to be in their favor, as Gio Gonzalez takes on Ryan Vogelsong. Gonzalez, however, is not exactly known for pitching deep into ballgames, which brings up an interesting question for Matt Williams tonight: would he be willing to use Stephen Strasburg as his first option out of the bullpen?

Due to the scheduled off-days both on Sunday and tomorrow, the Nationals have the option of starting either Strasburg or Jordan Zimmermann on full rest in a potential Game Five. Zimmermann shut down the Giants on Saturday, finishing one out shy of a complete game, and was actually the team’s best starter this season, even though he doesn’t have Strasburg’s raw stuff. The availability of Zimmmermann to start Game Five creates an interesting option for the Nationals to use Strasburg out of the bullpen in order to give the team their best chance of getting to that game, and Matt Williams said yesterday that Strasburg was available in relief in an “extreme emergency” situation.

Interestingly, Kilgore also wrote this in a separate piece: Read the rest of this entry »


Effectively Wild Episode 550: An NLDS Progress Report

Ben and Sam banter about Terrance Gore’s future, then discuss Clayton Kershaw and the Cardinals and the Giants-Nationals series.


2015 Steamer Projections!

The 2015 Steamer Projections are now live on the site! Much thanks goes out to Jared Cross, Dash Davidson, and Peter Rosenbloom for putting these together every year.

We have two different playing time allocations for Steamer projections this year:

Steamer – This uses the playing time projection from our depth charts. These are temporarily using playoff rosters, so there may be the occasional weird playing time allocation. Playing time may be updated on a nightly basis.

Steamer600 – This version uses a static 600 PA (450 PA for catchers), 200 IP for starting pitchers, and 65 IP for relievers.

The regular Steamer projections can be found on the player pages, and both Steamer and Steamer 600 can be found in our projection section.


Jeff Sullivan FanGraphs Chat — 10/7/14

9:03
Jeff Sullivan: Hello friends! Welcome to FanGraphs chat

9:04
Jeff Sullivan: Let’s talk about baseball, or what’s stressing you out

9:04
Comment From Carl Sbad
Is Stephen Drew a worthwhile player in 2015?

9:04
Jeff Sullivan: For real-life purposes, he’s probably a bottom-10 shortstop but a reasonable shortstop

9:05
Comment From Vslyke
Is trading Kimbrel the best way for the Braves to reload for next year? He’d bring in a nice haul and it would save a lot of money.

9:06
Jeff Sullivan: As great as he is, he’s not *that* cheap for a closer, and he’s got another three guaranteed years. The Braves could turn him into shiny bits, but not the most shiny bits

Read the rest of this entry »


Divvying Up Postseason Ticket Revenue

During the 2012 postseason, I wrote this post explaining how revenue generated by postseason tickets sales is shared among the league, postseason teams and players on postseason teams. The basic distribution formulas are established by MLB Rules and the collective bargaining agreement, and haven’t changed. But let’s review to make sure we’re all on the same page.
Read the rest of this entry »


Yasiel Puig’s Sudden Problems Making Contact

The story of last night’s NLDS Game 3 is almost certainly going to be about how the Dodger bullpen, which was known to be awful, was awful. After Pedro Baez in Game 1, and J.P. Howell in Game 2, it was Scott Elbert’s turn in Game 3. Other than Kenley Jansen, I’ve come to the conclusion that there is literally nothing Don Mattingly can do that isn’t going to blow up in his face. He could be the best manager in the world (well, probably not) or the worst, and we might never know, because the relievers he has at his disposal just keep on failing. (Yes, it was the right call to take out Hyun-jin Ryu, in his first start back from shoulder issues, when he did.)

Somewhat lost in that is the reality that if the Dodgers had merely managed to put up more than a single run against John Lackey and friends, they might not have needed to actually rely so heavily on the leaky pen. There’s a not-small part of that which is on umpire Dale Scott, but you can also only put so much on questionable umpiring. There’s a whole lot more you can put on things like… wow, did Yasiel Puig strike out seven times in a row? Read the rest of this entry »


The Bullpen Narrative

The first few days of playoff action have had a little bit of everything. At one point or another, we all likely saw something we had never seen before, and been reminded in some way why we had fallen in love with this game in the first place. Each postseason, a narrative or two seems to emerge – this time around, seemingly every media outlet opines that a team’s bullpen is the primary reason for each playoff team’s success, or lack thereof. This was particularly true during the Orioles-Tigers series, which in truth, did feature one of the most catastrophic pen implosions in recent memory. The narrative tells us that a club must do whatever possible, especially via the trade and free agent markets, to bolster one’s bullpen. In other words, do exactly what the Tigers did to build their still smoldering relief corps. Read the rest of this entry »


Doug Fister’s Mid-Game Adjustment

Three walks don’t seem like a big deal. Even if Doug Fister only gave up three walks once all year, you could look at the box score for Game Three of the National League Division Series and think, sure he had a Fisterian game. Nine ground balls to six fly balls, not many walks, a few strikeouts, and you look up and the Nationals have won behind him.

Except it didn’t really play out like that. Fister walked two of those three batters in the first inning. He went to eight pitches to get Joe Panik out. He went to five-plus pitches six more times before he got six outs. This was a man who averaged 3.7 pitches per batter faced during the regular season, averaging 4.8 pitches per batter in the first two innings. A man who once told us that he wants bad contact “in the first three pitches.”

After the game, Fister admitted that there was something going on early.

Read the rest of this entry »