Archive for Chat

Eno Sarris: yo

Eno Sarris:

Comment From Houzer
Thoughts on Severino for the playoff run?

Eno Sarris: lovely

Comment From Tough critic
Is a check swing reviewable on replay? Also, are there any good reasons why the 1B or 3B umpire should NOT call every checked swing? If replay was added to get calls right then MLB should adjust this rule as well. The whole concept of allowing the HP umpire to call them contradicts the “getting the call right” theme.

Eno Sarris: I don’t think it is, but it should be. But what if there was a chip in the bat and on the plate? What if robo umps? Is Tennis so bad?

Paul Swydan: Hi everybody! Jeff is travelling home from Saber Seminar tonight (did you go to Saber Seminar? If not, go next year!!!) so you’re stuck with just me. Come back at 9 pm ET, and we’ll talk some baseball, or anything else you’d like to talk about! See you soon!

Paul Swydan: Hi everybody! OK, let’s do this.

Comment From Jasper
How much of Joc’s struggles should be attributed to a .218 2nd half BABIP?

Paul Swydan: Obviously a good bit of it. His BB and K %s have remained basically static. But the drop in his BABIP doesn’t explain the drop in his HR rate, and it’s also a little weird how he’s going oppo more often (11% more often). He’s not as good as he was in the first half nor is he as bad as he has been in the second half, but there is a good chance he is going to be streaky like this.

Paul Swydan: Also notable is that his soft % was 14.9% in the first half and it’s 31% in the second half.

Comment From Ol Sea Capn
I have a tough keeper question – Do I keep the hot-lately Reisel Iglesias or trade him high? He’s really cheap ($3) and I can trade bigger names like TWalker, McHugh (both at 10x cost) and the bat Maybin. 14 teams obp league.

Kiley McDaniel: I’ll be back and start answering questions in a couple minutes.

Kiley McDaniel: Kiley is here and ready to chat with YOU

Comment From Bret
Not a pure prospect question, but definitely one about an exciting young player. Should the Jays have any apprehension about having Marcus Stroman return to the rotation in a few weeks if his rehab goes well?

Kiley McDaniel: The answer to any question about returning from an injury is1) they should be careful to not risk his future in coming back to soon
2) they know way more about his body than I do, so I can’t tell you much more than you already know

Comment From Xolo
Were he eligible, where would Javier Baez fall in your rankings?

Kiley McDaniel: I was always low on him–I think I put him in the teens a few years ago and people were telling me I was crazy to not put him in the top 5. He’d be a 50 or 55 at this point but I haven’t really thought about him much since he lost prospect eligibility and everyone I’ve talked to about him said he hasn’t made any adjustments…and makeup/coachability/attitude concerns are the reason I’ve always been the low one on him

Paul Sporer: We’ll get started soon! https://www.youtube.com/wat…

Comment From Kevin
How late in the week did Dave wait to ask you to do the chat today?

Paul Sporer: LOL we knew Jeff would be out for a while.

Comment From Pale Hose
Sporer! Sporer! Sporer!

Comment From Pale Hose
I can eat.

Paul Sporer: I just ate breakfast

Eno Sarris: Top ten Marley songs day, deal with it.

Eno Sarris:

Comment From Neil Murman
Nice Crawford piece this morning. Do you think he can be a valid top 5 SS for next couple years? or is he sell-high worthy in dynasty leagues?

Eno Sarris: His personal batting coach left town and he took off. He’s now adjusted and adjusted back in the same season, and he was in the bigs a little early because of his glove. I’d be comfortable with projecting him for 15-18 homers next year.

Comment From Xolo
What can the Padres (and Padres fans) expect from Travis Jankowski?

Eno Sarris: I think the projections are pessimistic on his batting average. He should make contact and run, but where? Fourth outfielder?

Kiley McDaniel: Kiley is ready to chat now

Comment From Hobbes2d
Hey Kiley,

Kiley McDaniel: Hey!

Comment From Nelson
Which list did Pompey not make it onto? Is he less than a 50FV?

Kiley McDaniel: Noticed that a few guys for that rookie list slipped through my filters, like Pompey (50) and Alex Gonzalez (50). I’ll go back in and add them after the chat.

Comment From Colby
Would Kopech have made your updated list of the non 200 if he wasnt suspended?

Dave Cameron: Yeah, it’s a Tuesday, but Kiley and I have flipped places this week. He has a pretty big prospect update coming out tomorrow, and we figured you guys would rather ask him questions after that was published, so he’s taking my Wednesday spot at noon tomorrow, so I’m doing the Tuesday chat this week.

Dave Cameron: So, the queue is open, and we’ll get started in 20 minutes or so.

Dave Cameron: Alright, let’s get this thing going.

Comment From WillE
What player were you most wrong on (wrongest?) this season?

Dave Cameron: Has to be Nelson Cruz, right? Though I’m pretty sure that no one saw this coming. 34 year olds don’t generally put up a 180 wRC+ for the first time in their careers.

Comment From Zonk
Who is your NL rookie of the year pick at this point?

Jeff Sullivan: Well, it’s this again

Jeff Sullivan: It’s me moderating a live baseball chat, with you

Jeff Sullivan: You better make this week count, because next week I’m gone!

Jeff Sullivan: (And then I’m back. I’m not quitting FanGraphs.)

Comment From adam
good riddance

Jeff Sullivan: kisses!