Last season, second basemen produced their best collective season ever in major-league history. There are a few different theories about what might have happened. With the increased use of the shift, it’s possible that teams were willing to deploy worse defenders at second in exchange for more offensive production. It’s also possible it was just a random blip of very good seasons by quite a few second basemen. Those are the most likely explanations, at least.
We’re now roughly halfway through the 2017 campaign, and the production from second basemen so far has been good — one of the better seasons of all time, if things hold up — but it also represents a big step back from what we saw last year.
How big a step back? Well, consider: last year, 11 second basemen recorded four-win seasons.
In contrast, here’s the list of players who are projected to hit 4.0 WAR by the end of the current season.
Second Basemen in 2017
Name |
AVG |
OBP |
SLG |
wRC+ |
WAR |
ROS Projection |
EOS Projection |
Jose Altuve |
.328 |
.402 |
.527 |
150 |
3.5 |
2.3 |
5.8 |
Daniel Murphy |
.339 |
.391 |
.578 |
146 |
2.4 |
1.6 |
4.0 |
Even if you include the players who are “on pace” to hit four wins — if not forecast by the projections to do so — then the only additions are Josh Harrison (2.3 WAR as of Sunday) and Jed Lowrie (2.1 WAR).
It’s not just overall value that’s taken a step back, either. If you look at the first table from this post, you’ll see that nine second baseman recorded at least a 120 wRC+ last season. Matt Carpenter — who split time evenly between second, third, and first — would make a 10th. Nor does that include the 122 wRC+ or 3.7 WAR produced by Neil Walker, as he fell roughly 50 plate appearances short of qualifying for the batting title.
Read the rest of this entry »