We’re two weeks into the long-delayed 2020 season, and one thing that sticks out thus far, beyond the schedule mayhem caused by COVID-19 outbreaks and the rule changes regarding extra innings and doubleheaders, is the plight of starting pitchers. Between the lengthy shutdown due to the coronavirus pandemic, during which players had no direct supervision, the abbreviated summer camp buildup, a flood of injuries, and expanded rosters, starting pitchers are pitching less than ever. Whether this is simply a continuation of a more long-term trend, an aberration founded in the unique circumstances of this season, or the start of a bigger paradigm shift, the numbers are worth tracking.
During the 2019 postseason, I noted that the period from 1998 to 2015 was fairly stable when it came to starting pitcher usage, even given a wide range in scoring environments and a whole lot of change within the game — expansion, the height of the PED scandal, the advent of PED testing, and the adoption of loose pitch count standards and innings limits on young pitchers. Since that time, we’ve seen starting pitchers throw fewer innings with each passing season, while at the same time generally improving their performance relative to the league.
Starting Pitcher Performance 2015-20
Season |
IP/GS |
Change |
K% |
BB% |
HR/9 |
ERA |
ERA- |
FIP |
FIP- |
2015 |
5.81 |
-2.61% |
19.5% |
7.1% |
1.06 |
4.10 |
103 |
4.03 |
102 |
2016 |
5.65 |
-2.8% |
20.2% |
7.7% |
1.24 |
4.34 |
104 |
4.30 |
103 |
2017 |
5.51 |
-2.4% |
20.6% |
8.1% |
1.34 |
4.49 |
103 |
4.48 |
103 |
2018 |
5.36 |
-2.8% |
21.6% |
8.0% |
1.21 |
4.19 |
101 |
4.21 |
101 |
2019 |
5.18 |
-3.4% |
22.3% |
7.7% |
1.44 |
4.54 |
101 |
4.51 |
100 |
2020 |
4.73 |
-8.7% |
23.2% |
8.6% |
1.28 |
4.13 |
101 |
4.13 |
101 |
2020 data through August 5.
Bang! Already what sticks out is that this year, for the first time, starters are averaging fewer than five innings per turn, and their per-start average is down more than one full inning since 2015. What’s more, if this trend continues, it would be the biggest year-to-year drop in innings per start in the span, more than double the drop from 2018-19, and more than triple the other year-to-year drops within that span.
Over the years, a number of factors have driven that decrease, starting with deeper pitch counts, which are a byproduct of higher strikeout rates, as you can see in the table. There’s also the increased understanding of a few sabermetric concepts: starters are generally less effective facing batters for the third time in the game than prior; relievers are generally more effective facing batters for the first time than starters are in any of those appearances; and batters are less effective when they lack the platoon advantage. As starters’ workloads have decreased to account for those factors, their run prevention relative to the league has improved ever so slightly.
The drop-off from 2019 to ’20 is even steeper by a couple other measures:
Starting Pitcher Workloads 2015-20
Season |
IP/GS |
Change |
TBF/GS |
Change |
Pitches/GS |
Change |
2015 |
5.81 |
-2.6% |
24.5 |
-2.3% |
93.1 |
-2.6% |
2016 |
5.65 |
-2.8% |
24.1 |
-2.0% |
92.6 |
-0.6% |
2017 |
5.51 |
-2.4% |
23.6 |
-1.8% |
91.5 |
-1.1% |
2018 |
5.36 |
-2.8% |
22.7 |
-3.9% |
88.1 |
-3.8% |
2019 |
5.18 |
-3.4% |
22.1 |
-2.6% |
86.4 |
-1.9% |
2020 |
4.73 |
-8.7% |
19.8 |
-10.6% |
77.8 |
-9.9% |
2020 data through August 5.
Read the rest of this entry »