Archive for Chat

Eric Longenhagen Prospects Chat: 11/13/26

Hi from the kitchen island in cloudy Tempe, where the FanGraphs Meteorology Team is monitoring the storm cell that just passed over ASU Spring Break mainstay, Rocky Point.

I'm gonna hang out here for an hour and then re-evaluate the forecast. If things look dicey for our first AFL semifinal game of the day, I'll hang out a bit longer.

Good day game pitching matchup there, though. https://www.mlb.com/gameday/desert-dogs-vs-saguaros/2026/11/…

Congrats on starting the 2027 prospect cycle! Anything new that you're excited about for these updates?

Yeah, I think you might see aspects of the format evolve during this cycle. I just think things like the System Overview need a fresh coat of paint. I'm working on Yankees now. I'm excited to go do minor league ST in Florida next year. Usually, MLB Spring Training is prohibitive for FL travel because it's super expensive and crowded. WHy do that when I can stay home for the AZ version. But with Minor League ST essentially immune from the labor strife, getting over there earlier than April/May (which is usually when I go, for the time period when Extended and FSL stuff are going simultaneously) will give us a deeper look at the full season affiliates there.

Plus, February/March is better for HS scouting in FL than April/May.

Dynasty draft coming up soon and I need a big stick that will provide middle of the order impact down the road. Would either of Taitn Gray or Murf Gray be my man?

I feel better about Taitn's plate discipline and hit tool.

How are the minors going to work during the lockout? I think I read that anyone on a 40-man can't play? How is this going to affect team strategy and overall player dev next year?

It might depend on how teams are informed of Rule 5 Draft changes/cancellations, but if we assume no Rule 5 Draft (which is what happened in '21) then the number of players who'll be new 40-man additions will be low, and the impact will be minimal. The players who'll be impacted are the ones who were put on the 40-man late enough in 2026 that they remain prospect-eligible. Which you can basically see a list of in the right margin here: https://www.fangraphs.com/prospects

I think a shorter season might end up being good for pitchers' late-season stuff, everyone's work load will be a little bit lighter.

Teams might try to sneak remote dev programs in for some of the pitchers, or launder them through the third party facilities' people. I would.

I seem to recall you were pretty high on Serwinowski? Still see him as a starter? Thanks!

I did and do like him a lot. The chances of his starting are dwindling, but I think his floor is a really, really nasty lefty reliever, and I value him as if he were a BJ Ryan, Sean Doolittle type of guy who is a setup man/closer type.

Wandy Asigen didn't play a lot this season. Does he still project as a "for sure" shortstop? Is he likely to keep his 45+?

Not a "lock", still so young. On tape, lokay enough to keep developing there, but not great right now.

No longer a prospect, but have you got thoughts on Triston Casas moving forward?

I thought he was going to have such big lefty power that the swing and miss, on balance, would be palatable. I saw that Breslow said something like Casas "might" get winter league at-bats. How is that not something you know will happen or not at this stage of the schedule? Why isn't he here in AZ crushing guys and providing some notion of how he looks to inform whether he needs a winter league assignment or not? Is he not healthy yet? I'd assess how he looks when he actually plays before offering an updated opinion, he's in flux.

What is the latest update on Aidan Miller's health and ETA for 2027?

He's healthy and has been playing in Arizona, where he's walked a ton and has not hit for much power.

The state of the league at 3B has dipped substantially as Arenado, Machado, Chapman, etc. have aged, and as Devers has moved to 1B, and Ramirez had a down year. Here's the year-by-year, league-wide offensive performance at 3B the last while… https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders/major-league?stats=bat&lg=…

I think Miller will do enough to profile as an average everyday option, but I'd rather have Maikel Garcia, or Miguel Vargas, McGongile, Josh Jung, and I'd guess at least a couple of the old guys either bounce back or sustain (like Muncy has) enough to be a better producer there, too.

Curious how Made, Morales, Brito, Level and others ended up in winter ball rather than Arizona Fall League. Any insight on how teams decide?

I think the pitching in those leagues is more challenging than the AFL.

And the environment is more tense and lively.

He's post-prospect now, but do you think Zac Thornton will be in the rotation full time for the Mets this coming season?

In a universe where most of their guys are healthy, I bet he's up and down.

Hello. Thanks for chatting. Anyone who has knocked your socks off so far?

Lena, the 42-year-old reiki healer in Sarasota.

While command was always a weakness for Luis Morales, did you ever hear an explanation for why he completely lost the ability to throw strikes last season?

When it's that bad, I don't think there's an autopsy you can do perform to identify some lone, definable cause.

After his first season in the majors, has your opinion changed at all on Konnor Griffin? Or do you still see him as a future superstar?

The 20-year-old who just posted a league-average batting line? He's good, chatter. Give it a second.

"Would you give it a second? It's gotta go to space."

any player that has surprised you this AFL?

Antonio Anderson

I love Santiago Suarez. He is a pitcher that throws a ton of strikes but his arsenal is seemingly slow to develop. Do you feel that he'd stick on a big league roster if taken in the Rule 5 draft?

Tampa really only has guys in the minors throw two pitches. Like an overwhelming majority of their prospects are two pitch guys, there's barely a hint of a third let alone serious usage of it. I think it's more to do with org dev style than Suarez himself. I think he'd stick in a relief role, yeah. It's tough for a guy like him to stick in a *rotation* all year without being optioned, though, and so you're kinda goofing his development some to deploy him, say, like the Jays masterfulluy deployed Spencer Miles this year.

also do the saguaros have the best hats in the AFL?

AFL Hat Pref List and Grades:
Surprise (70) – Kelly green brim, the cactus is wearing a bandana, awesome
Glendale (60)- Orange brim, cool idea but coyote silhouette isn't drawn well
Scottsdale (50)- Red/black scorpion, average in every way
Salt River (45)- Love the brim color, miss the old logo. The new one looks like a toothpaste brand
Peoria (40)- Grey and lime green just doesn't play, best team name tho
Mesa (30)- I think the logo is way too big

Brendan mentioned the Braves list is due up next, who is "your guy" in that system?

Sears, Carey, Sinnard

Hey Eric – Great work at FPAZ last week. I got to see Tate Southisene a few times. I know you have been (correctly) critical of his defense in the past. I think you were easy on him. Will he be the major league's first mini-sized DH? Thanks!

TY, I'm comfortable speaking in front of however many people but less so individually afterward for whatever reason. 70 runner, try CF proactively, please.

Any new thoughts on Bazzell's defense after his AFL? Really started with a poor caught stealing performances. Is that just a quirk of the AFL (runners being very good, not being comfortable with pitchers, etc…)?

Throwing well for me, receiving and block not so much. Pitchers here are mostly 1.70 to the plate, the CS stuff isn't his fault.

Is it reasonable to conclude that A, the Red Sox will only trade Arias for a shortstop, and B, they don't have enough top guys left for a splashy deal that doesn't involve Arias? (Meaning C, unless they trade for a top shortstop, they're mostly looking at free agency and getting their current guys healthy to improve.)

That's probably too narrow. They have enough depth that they can make a big deal, still. It might limit their partners to teams who seem to prioritize depth in their returns, like Miami or Baltimore seem to. There are enough lemons with a good data point or two in that system who you can trick Miami's formula into thinking might be good.

Not great, folks https://www.accuweather.com/en/us/tempe/85281/weather-radar/…

Assuming Seaver King comes up in 2027, would you anticipate he would play at SS with Abrams at 2B (assuming Abrams consents)?

On my looks Seaver has had some pretty severe throwing accuracy issues, he's a guy who I'll wipe the chalkboard clean for this offseason. As I'm sitting here I'd expect him to be up mid-year only if a) the team is playing well enough to feel like they're in the playoff mix AND b) Seaver doesn't regress. Otherwise he's a Sept add.

Post prospect question – if you were evaluating Roman Anthony today, where would he land? How much if at all would the nagging hand/wrist issues be a factor in that?

Same grade: 60

So, since MLB players are apparently allowed to play in foreign and/or indie leagues during a lockout… who would you most want to see suit up for the Savanna Bananas?

Johan Mieses

Does Zion Rose have the speed and the power to comp to Carl Crawford in leftfield?

Nah

Crawford was a 1 of 1 type guy, skills-wise and swing-wise most alike to Kenny Lofton. Zion is a nice player but he's not *that* talented, K-Lo/Crawford had multiple 5-7 WAR seasons

How concerned are you about Edward Florentino's lower contact rates after promotion?

Not any more than we were before, the whiffing was always happening. Greensboro is a spot folks need to learn to take offense with a grain of salt. Big time lift/launch prospect who K's a ton is Florentino, there was an initial overreaction to his breakout I think.

Emmanuel Rodriguez. I have no idea what to make of this guy. Is the top-100 prospect still in there or are we looking at a 4th OF at this point?

He could have a season or two like James Outman's rookie year, and then several seasons like Outman's sophomore season and beyond

Does Braylon Doughty have the upside of the guys like Messick, Williams, etc. who have graduated from the Guardians pitching development machine?

Not Williams', maybe Messick's (to be clear, what I think Messick's overall output will be , which I don't think will be prorated '26).

Tony Blanco Jr upside Giancarlo Stanton or can he fake it in the field? Who's you best case comp?

When Stanton was Blanco's age, he had 85 career big league home runs and halfway through his second consecutive 35-homer season. Blanco has played 80 games above low-A. Blanco's future is probably more like Chris Carter's.

Is there a verdict yet for the Charles Davalan infield experiment?

Positive, wrote about here: https://blogs.fangraphs.com/arizona-fall-league-midseason-ch…

In a previous chat you said you liked the Tigers' draft, specifically mentioning a "kid from AZ who throws 100 and was kept pretty well hidden". Is that KJ Ward? And is he, like, a good arm strength RP flier, or is there more there?

Yes. Probably a RP but let's see. Gorgeous arm action, up to 100, sitting 98. Got in way better shape from '23 to '25 and '26

Speaking of knocking off socks, any prospects of note out there still rocking stirrups?

I haven't seen anyone wearing the Wimberlys

I read an excerpt re: Joniel Hernandez, essentially downplaying some of his DSL performance because he was signed out of Cuba, suggesting he was more advanced for an age because of the Cuban background. Do the int'l kids signed out to Cuba tend to have more experience seeing high level velo and spin? I would have assumed the kids in the DR and VZ are seeing every bit as good talent.

More than anything I think Joniel crushed the DSL because he has ridiculous bat speed.

If you had to continue your work during the lockout, which league would you want to do instead of MLB? NPB, KBO, LIDOM, MLB The Show, Little League?

I still have to continue working, for the record.

Send me to Japan. DR no. 2, little league last.

Did you read about the MLBPA's so-called nuclear option? What are your thoughts?

Decertification is not uncommon. Tough to file antitrust when the justice department is overtly sympathetic to the owners, might have to wait until that changes a bit early '27. I wouldn't decert unless that had already happened. I'd want it to feel actually threatening. Right now it doesn't.

assume everyone in your current top 10 has graduated by this time next year (won't be the case, i know, but rock with me here), who do you think are some of the most likely prospects to have vaulted into those slots?

Josuar

Say more about "lemons with a good data point"?

Is there a gap between you and Brendan about Dax Kilby sticking at short? If there is, do you know who is closer to consensus?

Gap closed when I did film study this week. Was better regular season than here, which I'm inclined to lean on.

What prospect's name sounds most like a piece of kitchen equipment?

Maykel Coret

Did you know Lawr Michaels?

Not well, intro'd through JGrey and the first pitch crew. Nice guy who people loved.

Cam Wagoner (35.1 K% and 58 FIP- coming off two missed seasons), Jose Meneses (31.4 K% and 63 FIP- plus an AFL nod as a 21yo), and Braylon Owens (29.9 K% and 73 FIP- as a 10K sign) going to be getting some digital ink on the Brewer list?

Yes, Laurila turned me on to Wagoner. He's good.

What orgs have proven the best abilities to help prospects like Rainer fight their contact issues? He’ll never win a batting title, but if he was with org X you’d arrow up on reaching a useable baseline.

LA. See: Harlan, Chase.

Bauers to Boston…maybe that's why Breslow gave a weird answer on Casas? But regardless, will be interesting to see how Bauers' games by position ends up next year. Think he or Contreras log more games at DH?

Oh shit, really? Hold please…

OKay yeah, gotta showcase Casas now.

Who are some prospects that could improve their stock the most by spending the offseason in the weight room?

Austin Charles

framed mogged by Walcott all fall. get stronger!

Are there any plans to pivot content during the lockout? Similar to how COVID content looked with the daily prospect notes video series?

I bet the other writers will have to drum up more than me. Like I'd expect Michael to do college coverage because he naturally follows it and has experience doing it.

I asked a Made vs Pratt question but what I really want to know is how does Made’s defense look after a season that began with a widely noted weight gain, particularly in the lower half.

Ok SS in a vacuum but worse than Pratt, so 3B for Milwaukee.

Follow up on Emmanuel Rodriguez. Fantasy question. Would you take him in a minor league draft (late first round, pick 10-15) over some of the FYPD guys either college or High school?

Depends on the guy. Gimme Grindlinger before ERod

Project Flewelling's FV if he is a catcher vs if he isn't

60 if he is, 50 if he isnt

Any reaction to the news that the Mariners have made Ryan Sloan "untouchable?" As an Ms fan, I'd personally do Sloan for Gunnar Henderson, but maybe I'm in the minority.

Six years of Sloan for three of Gunnar? Tough to do that when your payroll seems like it can only be so much. I'd rather move Gilbert/Kirby for a bat and have cheap homegrown arms.

Like if Sloan is Gerrit Cole, you wanna have that guy

can you bring up with the fact that is impossible to get a saguaros hat with the higher ups??

You've gotta get the good merch early on . I have a Sags hat that sits on a light up cactus which I've also adorned with its own bandana

What player archetype do you find yourself biased towards? Sort of how orgs tend to find players with similar traits throughout their systems

Switch hitting MIFs, big-framed catchers with power

Did you get any looks at Carter Graham in the AFL? Had a bit of a breakout in 2026 but seemed to swing and miss a lot in the fall.

Darin Ruf 러프 type role

will Oda have a FV after he signs or does he count as an international amateur who hasn't played stateside yet

the latter, Int'l amateur

if you were brian cashman, what would you do with anthony volpe? what would you make of his wildly shapeshifting skillset that nonetheless results in an ~85 wRC+ year in year out?

You keep him as a part time 2B and reserve infielder behind a nomadic Cabby and Lombard on the depth chart, and see if he plays himself into having trade value

Just play him as if he were any other guy at this point

Which is worse than lombard and cabby

Brewers have been playing match ups based on swing path versus the opposing SP's arsenal. With Bauers gone could Vaughn (flatter swing) and Luke Adams (more of an uppercut I believe) still make a decent platoon despite both being righties?

Just gimme Burke/Vaughn at that point

If (when?) Ketel Marte ends up traded, do you think Demetrio Crisantes is ready to slide in at 2B? Do you give Troy a shot there first? Move Lawlar back to the IF?

Pretty underwhelming, I'd rather try Troy/Lawlar

Okay sluggers, nice long chat today. Great questions as always. I'm gonna take one more hard look at the forecast and decide whether to run all the way out there. I was only going to stay for the entire first game because I have comedy show tix in town tonight (star-studded weekend here for that) Take care, see you next week


RosterResource Chat: November 12, 2026

There are reports that a lot of free agents are being offered 1 year deals because of the uncertainty, but there are also reports that teams aren’t interested in trading for guys with 1 year remaining because of the uncertainty. How does this make sense?

Big difference in risk here. If you're trading prospects with 6+ years of club control for a rental, there's a chance that there's no season (or a significantly shortened one) and you gave up prospects for a player who barely played for you, if at all. Signing a player only costs money, money that the player will never get (and that you won't have to pay) if there's no season, and players would only get the prorated portion of their agreed-to salary if the season has, say, 81 games.

Odds that each of Trevor Story and Masataka Yoshida are on Boston’s Opening Day roster? Is it possible to trade them to save a little bit of money by attaching a prospect, or are they just going to get cut if it comes down to that?

I don't think they'll cut either. Worst-case, they'll take on a big % of salary remaining. Both have enough value to trade. How much another team takes on would be the question. Would depend on return and, of course, any prospects attached.

Also, I think the Red Sox believe Franklin Arias will be ready in 2027. But can he be the starting SS on Opening Day? Not sure they want to do that with no backup plan, although their depth then becomes important. Do they trust Monasterio/Sogard to hold it down until Arias is ready to step in? Probably. But I think they value Story's veteran presence. They won't just give him away for nothing.

I think Duran is more likely to be traded since he's not far removed from being really good for 3 consecutive seasons. Even then, Yoshida might not have a big enough role to stick around. He can hit. But the Red Sox treat him as un-playable in the OF so not sure why another team would think otherwise.

Ketel Marte for Anthony Santander (plus other valauble assets from TOR, say a top pitching prospect) – is that a potential fit?

Both teams shed a problematic player. Both deals have complicated deferral structures, too, which may make it easier to accomodate a swap.

I don't really see the value in this from the Diamondbacks' end unless they're really getting a ton back from Toronto. I don't think you can count of Santander for much of anything health or production wise and while Marte does have a lot of contract left, his contract isn't actually a bad value even if 2026 Marte is just who he is now. Santander's contract is underwater. I'd think a Marte-to-Toronto trade is very possible but would be much more straightforward than foisting Santander on anyone.

What are your thoughts on Buster Posey’s comments hinting that they are only planning to sign 1 starting pitcher? Seems very light.

Didn't see the quote so I have no context, but I'd assume he's talking one impact addition to go along with Webb and Roupp. Adding a SP4 from the free agent group at a reasonable rate should also be on the priority list and I think they have a decent group of No. 5 candidates (Houser, Wilkinson, Molina, Marte, Whitman). Then you have Birdsong possible back in the 2nd half and Jackson Flora could force his way to the majors in 2027.

But, at least on paper at this moment, you'd probably have a good argument that they should be looking to add 2 impact starters.

Lots of Cashman's comments yesterday hinted at minor changes (outside of the pen maybe), suggesting they could roll with Volpe, McM, Stanton, and Ali Sanchez again. Is this just GM speak to not create a desperation tax (we can call it the Bubba Crosby rule that Cashman himself used)?

I only thought he was really definitive about Stanton, who Cashman said in no uncertain terms is going to be with the team in spring training (whenever it is) and that they expect production from him. The other comments I saw were more leaving the door open to possibilities that Volpe (starting 2B), McMahon (starting 3B) and Sánchez (backup C) would all have roles on the team. I think that's basically the most you can say as a POBO/GM, you're not going to get up there and say "yeah I don't think this guy has a future with us" when he's on the 40-man and projected active roster right now. Sánchez ending up with a spot would be especially surprising to me.

Baltimore has returning Westburg, disappointing Holliday, disappointing Mayo, surprisingly decent Alexander, and surprisingly decent CES for like 2.5 lineup spots (assuming Basallo gets a bunch of DH time). All too good to bury at the end of the bench, nothing left to do in AAA, and none with real trade value. All but Holliday are right-handed. How do you figure that shakes out?

At this point, they're relying on Gunnar Henderson bouncing back, Jordan Westburg returning to his pre-injury form, and a lot of young guys taking a big step forward. Even if Alonso continues to be productive, I think they probably need to add one more impact bat. They need someone who is reliable enough that they can be fine with just some combination of those things happening. Because not all the young guys will step up. The good version of CES might not show up. Tyler O'Neill might never be healthy/productive.

Coby Mayo absolutely crushes LHP so I think they're in a good spot there as long as they don't need him to be an everyday guy. Blaze Alexander has been really good offensively the past 2 seasons and can play just about every position. Maybe he can be even better if locked in at one spot. I think they can probably shake things up a bit — trading someone like Holliday or Cowser? — but having a solid rotation/bullpen is going to be the priority.

Is Chandler Simpson untradeable? It seems like he'd be a great fit for the Mariners who need more speed, more defense, a left fielder, and players who get on base.

I think the Rays have one untradeable player, and that's Junior Caminero. But I don't think the timing for a Simpson trade is quite right, without a clear heir apparent with Jacob Melton having an injury-ravaged 2026 and not likely to be stepping in early on in 2027. But I could definitely see it get more and more into consideration with Melton in Triple-A, Theo Gillen probably starting in Double-A, and Brendan Summerhill behind Gillen. That's a lot of LHH OF to think about and Simpson is a really fun player but if he loses a step a lot of that value goes away really quickly.

The over/under for games played in 2027? I will go with 100

I'll go with over/under 144 and go with the Over. I'm optimistic compared to most people but the lockout is just an obvious move for the owners. They have so much leverage in these negotiations and they're going to use it. Players only have a limited window to monetize their talent. Owners think they're gonna live until 100 years old or longer and never stop making money. No pressure for them. I do believe they'll take it further than 5 years ago, but baseball is in a great place and they won't want to lose more than a handful of games. My guess would be mid-to-late April start and 154 games after re-scheduling.

I'm going to set it at 120 but still take the over. A lot of the same reasoning Jason gives, and I'd also add that if owners are so concerned with franchise values growing at a slower rate than other sports… you probably don't want to tank an entire season or anywhere near it, because that'll certainly kill value growth.

What do you think the Cubs wind up doing to fill out their rotation? I feel like Peterson is a no-brainer since he’ll probably be cheap for a 1-year deal and he was mostly fine as a back-end guy. On paper Holmes seems like a fit, but he didn’t impress. Does Matt Shaw have any trade value left? It feels like there’s a fit with NYY to trade for one of their young starters, and then see if you can bring back Happ for cheap or splurge on Suzuki and hope for the best.

I don't think I've seen a single free agent prediction that thinks Peterson is going anywhere but back to the Cubs, he's a great fit there with all the ground balls and I think he has more upside (and should be cheaper) than Clay Holmes since he's much younger. I saw some pontificating that they could be a fit for Logan Gilbert as a trade-and-extend candidate (since there's so much risk in trading for a rental, as I talked about earlier), and Shaw would be as good a fit for the Mariners as Gilbert is for the Cubs, a righty super utility complement to Brendan Donovan. All the talk with the Cubs has (rightfully) been on pitching but losing Suzuki, Happ, Conforto, and Kelly to free agency leaves big shoes to fill, too, and it'll be interesting to see how they go about it.

Do you think the Blue Jays being interested in Adames has legs?

Sure, it's possible. Not straight up, though. Adames is due an est. 5-yr, $140MM and Gimenez is something like 3-yr, $70MM. Giants might have to eat some salary and additional players would likely be part of a deal, but I can see the reasoning for both sides. Giants upgrade defense and could save $. Jays add some power, vibes, and bounce-back potential.

Important part of this would be each team's SS prospects. JoJo Parker is likely the Jays' starting SS in 2028 so they'd likely move Adames to 2B/3B for the last 4 years of his contract. So his SS defense is not going to hold things up. If they think he'd be a productive bat with adequate defense at 2B or 3B, he's a fit.

Giants have 4 great/really good SS prospects (Jhony Level, Gavin Kilen, Josuar Gonzalez, Luis Hernandez), although Gimenez is only under contract for 3 more seasons and can also play 2B. So might not be as much of a factor, especially if the Giants can save money.

As to the leverage point, isnt there a cutoff date where the broadcasting deals get tolled for an additional year? Thats a huge leverage spot for the union.

Right. If at least 60 games are missed, all the deals get punted back a year, which delays Manfred's plan to revamp all the TV deals, line them all up, etc. The flip side is that if an entire season is missed the league still gets paid for 2027 but then they have to give away all of 2029 for free. Evan Drellich wrote about it in The Athletic a few months back: https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7627090/2026/09/25/mlb-lock…

West Sacramento Tommy White over under Plate Appearances?

Even before they make any offseason additions, I have him with 120 PA … https://www.fangraphs.com/projections/playing-time/teams/ath…

So maybe 100 PA would be my over/under. He wasn't very productive in 2026. As long as Nick Kurtz is healthy, there won't be many opportunities at 1B. Same with Brent Rooker at DH. I think he was fine at 3B, but not sure he's going to get an extended look there.

If you were the yankees or mets, would you be interested in alec bohm

Yes, but only for a pretty limited, Paul Goldschmidt-like role where he's only facing lefties and certain righties, platooning with Garcia or McMahon in the Bronx or Jared Young in Queens. But if I'm Bohm, I don't see a reason to sign such a deal. It's a weak free agent market and he should have no problem getting a decent-size deal (one year or two years with an opt out, perhaps, for $10M-$12M a year) to start. We've only seen those two teams connected to him so far but plenty of others make a lot more sense. The Pirates and Cardinals both come to mind there.

Where's your wRC+ cutoff where a hitter goes from "you can contend with this guy batting 8th or 9th" to "he is a black hole who seriously limits your offense"? I say it's 83.

Really depends on position and how good they are defensively. Most extreme example is Patrick Bailey. He had a 70 wRC+ in 2025 and that was probably just good enough for the Giants to pencil him as their everyday guy in 2026. He was at 13 wRC+ when they traded him but I'm guessing that anything under 60 and he would've lost playing time.

Ke'Bryan Hayes is another extreme example. With his elite defense, I think the Pirates or Reds could've lived with an 85-90 wRC+. But he's not even close to that, which is why he's probably not a starting 3B anymore.

For someone who is just an average defender (or worse), I think anything 100 wRC+ and their job is on the line.

Skubal landing spot: you picking the Dodgers or the field?

Definitely the field, and specifically the Mets. I'm seeing too much cold water poured on the idea that the Dodgers are going to be super in on him (they don't want to go long-term, for example) and too much Mets chatter and articles more or less saying that everyone is focused on the Mets there to see him end up anywhere else at this point. But, of course, the meetings he's taking with teams next week could change things, and there are always mystery teams!

How is it possible to project IP for guys like Glasnow and Snell?

Projecting is easy. Predicting is impossible because you have no idea when either is finally going to stay healthy. Thus, a lot of people will disagree with a “projection” because they’re thinking of it as a “prediction”.

With those two specifically, they’re getting a lower % just based on injury history. And then you consider that the Dodgers will be super cautious with them in order to have them ready for the playoffs. That’s specific to the Dodgers because of their division. So maybe a bit lower again because of that factor.

Even after considering that, they’re both healthy, not old, and likely coming into camp with no limitations. So my current projections of 150 IP (Snell) and 140 IP (Glasnow) are already assuming that they’re going to get hurt and miss close to 2 months with a yet-to-happen injury. I do think of these as reasonable over/under totals, based on several factors that could change before Opening Day.

The chatter on the Red Sox blogs is that they are all-in on Suzuki which would only add to the mess that is the team's outfield. I assume Rafaela is locked in and Anthony, despite not showing much yet, is penciled in for LF. Abreu has taken home 3 Gold Gloves while playing the toughest RF in baseball, and has 25 HR power, but looks like the odd man out. I am thinking that he might be able to pry Hancock, Woo or Kirby from the Mariners.

I haven't seen it specifically framed as all-in and more just interest, but anyway I don't think it'd be very hard to squeeze him in. Duran is as good as gone and Suzuki and Anthony could just rotate DH and LF without much friction, players will get hurt, etc. The Red Sox ultimately really need another power threat and Suzuki (or Arozarena for that matter) would be the best way to add one in free agency.

Anthony Volpe has had individual seasons in which he ran a >10% barrel rate, played a 13 OAA shortstop, stole 20+ bases, ran a double-digit BB%, increased his avg. bat speed 3 ticks, and gotten his ZCon% up around the 85% mark while lowering his Chase%. Needless to say he has not put these all together. What are the odds that he eventually does?

I have no idea. But one of the really cool things about this sport is that "I have no idea" has nothing to do with all of the analytics we have to tell a story and everything to do with these are human beings and it's just going to click for some guys and it can be much later in their career. It can click for one season and they can suck the next season. It's a mental grind and I don't think any of these players (current, past) are great at explaining it. It makes the game more unpredictable. It makes for a lot of great stories.

That will do it for today. Thanks for joining us! We'll be back next Thursday at the same time.


Dan Szymborski FanGraphs Chat – 11/12/26

And we are alive! I actually have this open as an open chat, I think, rather than a stricter Q&A. Think of it as an experiment

What is zips seeing with Theo Gillen, Kaelan Culpepper, and Josue de Paula for the 2026 season? Such interesting minor league seasons…how rewarded were they?

ZiPS has a league-average SS; remember, it always liked Culpepper. Gillen would be there too, but ZiPS doesn't really like his CF defense. ZiPS is right around where Steamer is for JDP

You mentioned in the 2027 Brewers write-up that Jesus Made is currently projected to have 40-something career WAR, which would be a fantastic career. Made me think — what’s the single best pre debut projection the model has ever produced? Anyone have their median forecast be HOF worthy?

Trout is the highest I believe, and it's not particularly close. Now, I don't have him right before his debut, but after his cup of coffee, and ZiPS was pegging him at *70* WAR which is unreal for a projection

As a counting stat that depends on available opportunities, RBIs are discounted as a measure of a player’s performance. Have you seen a measure along the lines of “percent of RBI opportunities converted”? For example, the percent of time a hitter drives in a runner on second base, and so on? Is or would such a stat be meaningful in measuring and comparing a player’s hitting results?

It's interesting and STATS did it in a couple of their books. I think the thing you run into is that RBI/opportunity kinda falls in the middle where it has limited use. If you just want to talk about RBIs, then talk about RBIs. if you want to talk about underlying RBI ability, you talk SLG and ISO. So something like this only really comes up when you're discussion something very specific. It's not useless, of course, but the applications are just limited

I feel like I'm in a minority of Tigers fans who don't view moving off Spencer Torkelson as an absolute need in the offseason. I understand the underperformance compared to expectations, but he's been fine offensively for two seasons now. If Detroit were to move on from Tork, what's the upgrade that Scott Harris would be willing to make? Is it simply moving Colt Keith over to first (who I do NOT necessarily view as an upgrade) and make Valencia full-time DH? Would they realistically spend to get France?

Imagine projecting this and being the UNDER

BA OBP SLG G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO HP SB CS SH SF + DR WAR
.268 .340 .468 152 568 103 152 26 11 22 67 53 142 10 34 10 3 2 110 2 4.1
.274 .352 .523 151 558 110 153 28 12 29 77 58 148 10 31 9 3 2 127 2 5.4
.278 .360 .542 154 568 116 158 29 11 33 83 63 147 11 32 8 3 2 134 2 6.1
.285 .370 .568 156 572 122 163 30 12 36 89 67 142 11 30 8 3 2 142 1 6.9
.284 .371 .565 156 570 122 162 30 11 36 88 69 143 11 29 8 3 2 142 1 6.8
.282 .370 .558 156 568 122 160 30 11 35 86 70 142 11 28 8 3 2 140 1 6.5
.281 .372 .558 155 565 122 159 29 11 35 86 72 143 11 26 7 3 2 141 1 6.5
.278 .369 .552 155 562 121 156 29 10 35 85 72 144 11 25 7 3 2 138 0 6.2
.274 .364 .535 152 555 116 152 28 9 33 80 70 139 10 23 6 3 2 133 0 5.6
.272 .360 .520 149 544 112 148 27 9 30 76 66 128 10 20 6 3 2 128 0 5.0
.269 .355 .505 145 531 105 143 25 8 28 72 62 117 10 18 5 3 2 123 0 4.5
.267 .350 .489 138 509 98 136 24 7 25 66 57 107 9 13 4 3 2 118 0 3.8
.262 .343 .449 131 485 90 127 23 1 22 58 52 96 9 11 3 3 2 107 -1 2.8
.258 .33

I'd be inclined to, the problem being that options aren't great. France is 32 and coming off his best season and had been really meh for years. Keith is in one of those awkward spots where if you don't have enough defense to play third but not enough offense to play first, you end up as a platoon role player

Briceño is in AAA

Briceño probably needs at least another half-season in AAA though, no?

I'd rather run out Keith, Valencia, Tork and Briceño for a year before blocking the position with a guy like France.

And it missed low! lol

What do you make of Alec Bohm? Is the 3B defense as terrible as his reputation or can it be coached up to where it was in 2024-25, which was just kind of subpar? I think he’s an interesting buy-low candidate to deliver like a 3.5 WAR season for you for $9M

Note that unless I screwed something up, this is an *open* discussion, so all of you can add your opinions to these things!

My opinion is that this is a terrible idea! Have you seen my opinions?!

speaking of trout, whats the variance around his ZIPS projection for 2027? hes getting older but hes only a few years removed from 5-6 fWAR paced seasons

Tinkering with this as an offseason format. While I'm still answering as much as I can, I like the idea of a more open format thing rather than me pronouncing from the Mount.

My only hope for the franchise formerly known as the Cincinnati Reds is a salary floor. Any ideas Dan?

Trout Percentile 2B HR BA OBP SLG OPS+ WAR
95% 28 34 .295 .432 .551 169 5.5
90% 25 30 .280 .416 .529 161 4.8
80% 23 27 .268 .402 .498 149 4.2
70% 22 25 .257 .393 .476 143 3.8
60% 21 24 .251 .383 .460 136 3.3
50% 20 22 .244 .375 .444 130 3.0
40% 19 21 .237 .368 .430 124 2.5
30% 18 19 .230 .360 .413 117 2.2
20% 16 17 .218 .350 .391 111 1.7
10% 14 14 .204 .334 .362 97 1.0
5% 12 12 .188 .323 .329 89 0.4

if he can get 22 homers over the next 4 seasons on average, that gets him to 500, the only thing i ask of the baseball gods

Eventually we'll be able to post images

but this looks less horrible than in jotcast

Reds fans would benefit from a salary floor, but getting a salary cap is going to be required to get a salary floor and you have to defeat the MLBPA to get that

Have you seen MY opinions?

BRef has (or at least used to have) an RBI/Opp report. I do agree with you that it isn't all that useful. Players don't tend to have a preternaturally good/bad ability to convert RBIs that doesn't also correlate with their other hitting stats

Has there been any reporting as to what the vibes are in the MLBPA right now? I'm hoping the players are united AF right now, and I'm wondering if there's any evidence of that

I've said it before and I've said it again: if MLB were really considered about revenue disparities between teams, then they'd actually solve…revenue disparities between teams. And I've written about it!

But increasing revenue sharing pools and giving it on the basis of market size AND wins in order to make marginal wins value across markets doesn't naturally suppress salaries.

I'm not sure on the vibes. The thing is that at some point I somehow became one of the olds and I talk to teams/agents more than individual players

Age probably has something to do with it. I realized halfway through fall ball that my kid’s little league coach was born sometime after I started college. Time is undefeated.

I'd imagine Wander Franco's career projections were pretty stellar?

Oh, they were

They'd still be if not for…you know

Dan! What’s the ZiPS machine expect Seiya to get in free agency? I realize the Cubs probably can’t fit him AND an entire rotation into their miserly budget, but I’ll miss him terribly. For big stretches of the season he carried the offense (well, he carried the half that PCA wasn’t carrying).

I have the general impression that both sides are fired up now, but we don't have the pressure points yet

ZiPS suggests 4/102 for Suzuki

Excuse me, 4/105

$ CUM
$38.7 $38.7
$30.5 $69.2
$22.5 $91.7
$13.2 $104.9

See that’s just frustrating. The idea that the third- or fourth-most-valuable franchise in baseball can’t fit that into their budget is insane.

Time is the ultimate badass. Except I guess the Big Bang which kinda created time

When I was making ZiPS, it was still kinda weird to be older than some MLB players

Now I'm 48, so I'm old enough to be the dad of a huge percentage of them

Wait’ll you get to 51 and parts of you stop working for no apparent reason.

$ CUM 😹

OnlyZIPS

It looks worse if I don't do all caps. But I don't like letting an unfortunate word tell ME what to do

What does ZiPS see for Tyler Mahle's performance over the next couple years? He somehow held onto his second-half performance gains in the playoffs. Could he be a 3-4 win pitcher again?

Who does ZiPS like better next season, Tolle or L.Henderson? Need to pick one in a keeper league

Good to see you Alex!

BAM Player Yr Tm T Age W L S ERA G GS IP H R ER HR BB SO HP WP G/GF HBP GDP IBB BK ERA+ FIP WAR 5WAR WPr 3YERA+
701656 Logan Henderson 2027 MIL R 25 9 7 0 3.79 25 25 116.3 98 53 49 17 32 124 3 3 41% 3 5 0 0 109 3.82 1.8 9.0 15 108
801139 Payton Tolle 2027 BOS L 24 10 6 0 3.41 29 28 153.0 134 63 58 18 40 165 6 4 44% 6 7 1 1 123 3.42 3.2 16.2 15 124

You too, Dan! Also, Dan didn't answer about Alec Bohm, so I will: he's a super BA-dependent righty corner infielder who offers neither power nor defense. I'd be terrified that he turns into Chris Johnson at any moment. I could certainly see him getting a one-year shrug emoji contract – I'm sure he can outhit Ke'Bryan Hayes!

If you were running a team that was in the market for a corner OF would you prefer Seiya, or Arozarena as a value play? I’ve seen a lot of people projecting Randy to get a lot less (Ben had him at 3/$70m), but I’m not sure he’s ~30% worse of a player.

Oops, forgot about Bohm. I'm with Alex. He's kinda stopgappy

I'd prefer Seiya. I honestly think people are underrating what Arozarena will get

What 2027 ZiPS projections surprised you the most? I'm very surprised that the Phillies and Mets both project as pretty good at the moment.

which FA do you think most likely to turn into a pumpkin compared to expectations? i do feel like randy is a top choice

Tolle has the funner comps too

Comp1 Comp2 Comp3 Comp4 Comp5 Comp6
Billy Loes Scott Bankhead Brett Tomko Scott Sanderson Larry Dierker Art Mahaffey
Mike McCormick Jim Merritt Frank Tanana Greg Swindell Chris Sale Billy Hoeft

Man I loved me some late-career Tanana back in the day. Those early-90s Tigers teams were a fun bunch. Massive TTO guys hitting bombs, your ace is a 43yo guy throwing 82mph, your closer occasionally throws a knuckleball, and one of your best players has 20 starts at 6 different positions. Didn’t result in a lot of wins, but they were entertaining.

I like Trevor Rogers, but he's really risky – he's one of the best non-Skubal pitchers in FA and he might get a crazy contract relative to projections

But of course, the lockout throws a monkey wrench into the works

Man, those are some wild comps for Tolle. Dierker is much underrated. A true ace, but injuries took a toll on his arm from early on.

Jeremy, remember, the projected standings are Steamer only right now! I've only JUST got ZiPS running official projections, so I'm not yet at the point where I have enough breathing space to think about that stuff

I lost a day projecting players in the year 20227 and my damn IP address changed last weekend and I lost some time until I was updated for FTP access (I needed some of the data we have on our FTP)

In 20227 baseball will be played on the moon and Coors Field will be considered a pitcher's park

Underrated as a manager too

Tanana has such an interesting career since he spent a large part of it as a flamethrower and a large part as a low MPH slop tosser

He probably lost 8-10 mph on his fastball which is REALLY hard to overcome

I remember reading an interview where they asked him what he threw, and he said “a curve, a slider, a split, a change, and whatever that thing is that used to be my fastball.”

Ok, in that case what Steamer 2027 projections surprised you the most? For me, it was projecting the Mets and Phillies to be pretty good.

According to Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, the last World Series will be played in 16 years

What do you make of Crochet in 2027?

Bigger fan of traditional knitting. You can’t kill a man with a crochet hook.

The Bell Riots already shoudl have happened two years ago!

you can TRY

101 IP of 3.10 ERA | 3.30 FIP | 3.61 xFIP at AAA from 2025 to 2026 and 123 IP of 2.33 ERA | 2.92 xERA | 3.26 FIP | 3.31 xFIP | 3.14 SIERA in MLB from 2025 to 2026 shakes out to a 3.79 ERA projection for Logan Henderson? Why such heavy regression for a 25yo pitcher who has done nothing but perform at the highest levels over the last two years?

regression for all pitchers is pretty significant!

I'm surprised Steamer liked the Brewers so much

ZiPS has kinda been the most optimistic

Thoughts on valuing RBIs and Wins for season end awards? I've circled back to finding them valuable if the awards are meant to reward what happened vs. skill

(though still missing horribly low)

I haven't circled around. I still think of those as things that happened *for the teams*

Antietam was a big deal and it DID happen, but I'm not giving George McClellan any MVG trophies

Imagine Wander and Caminero playing next to each other for a decade

On Henderson, remember that there's still a lot of 2025 AAA performance in there – AAA performance doesn't become less predictive when we have MLB performance near it

Matt Shaw: Yankees opening day 3B?

Don’t threaten me with a good time.

Which of the glut of FA 2B does ZiPS like the most? Relatedly, which does ZiPS think is the most cost-effective?

Note on new chat format: the format doesn't appear right when you post a column of stats. Also, where can I find replies to my comments? Just scrolling back?

Hi Dan! I doubt we'll miss an entire 2027 season, but how would that theoretically affect ZiPS in 2028? Would you just assume an ageing curve for each player and weigh the past 3 seasons a bit more evenly?

Unique stadiums give a big advantage to the home team. Why are new stadiums looking traditional? How about a giant stadium?

ZiPS has Lowe with the best 2027 projection, but Arraez with the best five-year projection

2026 Misio was projected at 1.7 WAR with 2.8 WAR as the 80th percentile. He ended up with 6.6 fWAR | 7.4 rWAR. Did he exceed his 99th percentile projection?

Unique stadiums also make things awkward for road games though

How much are we trusting the defensive turnaround from Lowe and Arraez btw? I know OAA isn't super sticky but both went from horrible to stellar….

If we don't have 2027, probably filling in 2026 projection with the missed time non-injury modifier

I really hope I don't have to do that though for obvious reasons!

93. Not in fWAR, but the percentiles were based on like 110 innings

I'll note that ZiPS chops a LOT off of Arraez and Lowe defense

For those of you here, I'd like to see what you think of something

For some of our offseason/lockout options, I'm hoping to propose some kind of FanGraphs Audio type of revival where me and someone else (maybe Ben?) actually have it set up for callins, so that FG subscribers can bring up what's on their minds and argue with us a bit

Hi Dan & Ben, long time listener first time caller. What's for lunch? I'll hang up and listen.

Defensive metrics remain a black box to me. I don't get how you can go from abysmal to elite, and I super don't get how per OAA Walls is below average but per DRS he's Andrelton Simmons.

Is that the kind of thing anyone would be interested in?

I hate it! What is it?

Without baseball, I want to push more community things for our members

If zips sees De Paula like STEAMER, seems like it likes his bat a little less than McGonigle's…what are some of the differences? surprising since similar lines in AA and de paula had a good mlb stint (sss)

Oh that’d be fun. I’d absolutely subscribe. I’m not sure you’d want me calling in, but I’d listen for sure.

I feel that one of the reasons we survived COVID isn't just that we started directly asking for money, but that our readers felt they were part of something

or I might be wrong and romanticizing?

I take feedback from you guys very seriously!

I had a cheeseburger for lunch!

DoorDash sent me a notification about a Hardee's deal and I though "Whoa, I forgot they still exist" and had a burger. It was decent but needed salt

Any teasers for which teams you will project next?

Is it just me that forgets that Hardee's exists?

I grew up around Hardee’s but never went to one, then moved to CA for college and they became Carl’s Jr. Which Id eat at for a while when I was in college, but they’re just not that good.

Pirates!

then Rangers probably monday

ZiPS going to be a little more flexible than usual. Pre-lockout transactions may swamp things and I want to be able to grab some of those myself

Makes sense. I’m curious if there will or won’t be the flood of transactions predicted because of the impending lockout.

A couple weeks ago, I realized that ROY ROGERS still exist. And their roast beef is better than Arby's

Apparently, western MD still loves Roy Rogers

I forget Hardee’s exists, but in live in California where it’s called Carl’s Jr.

I dont' think Hardee's has ever been as popular as Carl's Jr. is in CA. No?

I’d take an In-n-out burger over Carl’s any day of the week…

I don't spend much time in CA

I was shocked to see Roy Rogers in Cumberland. The moderately nice woman my age who doesn't like when I tell stories about her wanted to stop at the dispensary and I saw Roy Rogers so HAD to get it

I assumed they had all gone out of business in 1998 or something

But I mean Carl's Jr is still more popular in CA than hardee's elsewhere, I think. Not making a burger value judgment

Any other baseball stuff before we go? I gotta get Pirates ready for Meg and Matt so it can go in the morning

I mostly listen to audio things in my car, would you guys be likely to set up FG audio on pop streaming platforms like YT music or spotify or keep it in-house? I'd make a point to listen regardless but I'd probably frequently forget otherwise

FA has been on spotify!

Yeah, Carl’s is reasonably popular out here. I’ll happily make the burger value judgement for you on this one.

It's been on hiatus since Dylan Higgins left

We haven't really had a podcast person since

I do miss doing FanGraphs Audio and would like to see it back in some form

Or if not, just do a really weird Szymborski podcast

OK, on that note, I'll close this off for the week

But again, this is an OPEN chat, so you guys can freely talk things


Brendan Gawlowski Prospects Chat 11/10/2026

Hello everybody. Little bit of housekeeping: I think the Blue Jays list is going to run tomorrow. It might be Thursday but either way, we're on deck for a list. Braves will be close behind, either Friday or early next week I suspect. Rangers and Red Sox pretty close to done as well.

With that out there, let's get cooking

Post prospect question but do you think that Colt Emersons issues this year were due mostly to his undisclosed injury or adjusting to MLB. Or is it just impossible to tell with out being closer to the situation.

Both. Injury clearly hampered him. Think he was rushed, AAA performance didn't scream "promote me now!" Still like him as a high floor type.

Hi Brendan! Do you have any way-too-early 2027 MLB draft takes? Overall draft quality/depth, potential 1.1 picks, etc?

Lot of college pitching depth, which I think is the most fun kind of draft to follow, certainly the easiest to wrap your arms around as a fan/analyst. High school pitching looked pretty good at Area Codes, some of the consensus top up-the-middle bats didn't look quite as intriguing as they normally do. I don't have a hot take on 1:1 yet.

What have you seen from Alex McCoy and Ty Harvey of the Padres in the Arizona Fall League? What are the holes in their games?

McCoy might just have 80 power. Flawed player but so much juice that he'll likely do something. Harvey, I need to put on the tape defensively, bat is a work in progress, slow lane.

What position does Kilby wind up playing if he has to move off of shortstop?

Depends why he has to move. If he's still really fast but is just moving out of deference to Lombard or what have you, CF?

Hey Brendan – about Jake Cook – Do you feel like he's made strength gains enough to maybe get to a Kevin Kiermaier style of player? Crazy good speed, top flight defence, and enough hit tool to be a little bit dangerous? What's your take?

100 mph EV90, 105 max for a 23 year old is not great, especially with his contact issues (tons of popups in addition to all the swing and miss). Eric talked me into keeping him on the main section, I agree that he's one to stay patient with given the background, but I'm not overly enamored with him.

BA just said Mitch Jebb has the best hit tool in the Pirates system . Am I crazy if I disagree. I'd pick 8-10 folks before I'd come to to Jebb

Reminder that I generally try not to comment on the rankings/judgments of other outlets… I will say that this is a tough exercise with PIT. Look at our list from last year, and look at all those positional guys with future 3 or future 4 hit tool grades. Not a system overflowing with slam dunks in that regard.

Which is a strange fit for the park, incidentally.

How far has Juan Sanchez fallen after a rough season?

He's in the 40 section.

Care to humor me and possibly let me down quickly before Braves list…How far has Diego Tornes' stock fallen since last spring?

He tumbled, low 40 currently. May kick him down another rung as I do my last gut feel toggles.

Please speculate based on your pro experience: why would the Guardians use a 40 man spot on Jose Tena?

I/we liked him as a prospect a couple years ago, maybe see a late bloomer chance?

Could Mackenzie Gore represent a reasonable projection for Liam Doyle at this point?

It could go that way… I think high-octane reliever is more likely.

Who is the latest Toronto riser not named Bloss?

Some of their depth infielders stepped forward last year, Goodwin and Harry both surprised me. Perry obviously surged out of nowhere. If there's a regular hiding in the low levels it might be Caricote.

Re: the Blue Jays list, what are the 2027 expectations for Jake Bloss after coming back from injury and pitching in the AFL?

We somehow have two Jake Bloss questions… Weird season for him. Came back throwing gas, got tattooed anyway, velo down a little in the AFL. Strange sequence. I think the mid-rotation projection we had last year is still in there but we need to see how the velo/command looks in a full season. Stock is down a little with that uncertainty.

Toolshed shortstops with questionable hit tools comparison: who do you think is more likely to hit enough to be an everyday player between Jacob Lombard and Justin LeBron?

LeBron, just betting on the athlete closer to maturity.

What do you make of the concerns over Anthony Eyanson’s pitch shapes? His fastball sits 93-94 with, apparently, dead-zone movement, and he doesn’t seem to have an effective horizontally-moving pitch. Is his command enough to make up for this?

The velo depends on when you caught him. On the year it averaged 94, pretty big fluctuations in where he sat. 18 IVB, 1 horizontal, high release. He could really use the arm strength, let's just say.

The cutter gives him a (very slightly) E-W pitch and it played well last year, fwiw.

I'm fine still projecting a no. 3 but he's one where a lot of analysis will be required in his T100 blurb to fully contextualize what we're dealing with.

Why is Jonny Farmelo #54 on the 100 but Tai Peete not somebody you're considering in the Top 100 per your last chat? Peete better exit velos, faster, higher defensive upside in CF, and K rates are now pretty much the same

Partly the hit tool risk, mostly though it's because I just don't like the Cardinals and if I can find a way to subtly ding their players I'm going to take it.

For the record, in last week's chat, I wrote: "He's the kind of player I'd project as a regular as a scout…" And that has been the case for years.

I like Tai Peete. He's a risk/reward player with a lot of upside. He will be ranked ahead of some risk/reward players with upside and behind others.

If all of the position groups formed gangs and had a giant brawl, who would win? Catchers, right?

Pitchers have a huge numerical advantage. I'd take them.

What is the most likely thing to hold Henry Godbout from being a regular? Defense? Swing mechanics?

Both are factors.

Is John Gil a starting major league shorstop? How likely is it that he becomes 1) a cromulent first-division starter 2) an All-Star at some point in his career?

Probably not; 30% or so; unlikely but not impossible.

How likely is it that we see Jesus Made be the starting 3B/SS on opening day next year?

Between the good-not-great season at AA, how young he is, and the big-league options available, I think it's more likely than not that he starts in the minors. But that's just speculation.

Can you expand more on Doyle's reliever risk? It looked like he turned a corner in the second half … is the toolkit just not enough to start in the majors?

Body doesn't look great, lot of walks overall. I should be clear, I think he can start, and could be quite good in that role. But I see more relief risk with him than some of the arms in his orbit on the top 50.

Is it time to call Dasan hill a reliever or hope he can work out the walks?

I would stay patient. May well be a reliever in the end but let's see this play out for a while first.

Let's say Alfredo Sena signed tomorrow with ATL: Where would he slot in in terms of the top-100 list and the Braves system overall?

He'd be a 45+, the rare guy I'd be going out of my way to see right from the jump in the DSL, and a potential T100 candidate on the same kind of timeline as Angeibel Gomez. I can't get behind 50'ing a teenager who hasn't played pro ball.

Hi, compared to teams like Rays and Brewers, what are the areas in which Mariners are weak, in terms of player acquisition and development? Thanks.

Depth. They turn their big-bonus guys into dudes at a high rate and they've had a lot of success developing starting pitching. But the system is thin.

Do you think there’s a chance Nolan Perry could make it to the majors this year? What’s his long-term outlook?

He'll have a 2027 ETA. In my mind that's more July/August than next spring, but who knows. Projects as a no. 4/5 type, could exceed if the fastball or his command are better than I'm projecting.

Any big reactions from the ROY voting?

Patrick Dubuque has written persuasively about the ROY should go to the best guy, and that WAR shouldn't really be a factor in the same way it is with the Cy/MVP. I agree with that, and if, in that sense, you think Sal Stewart is THE GUY in this class, I think it's a defensible selection. Personally, I don't feel that way: I think he's a good player, he ranked highly for us and was graded appropriately in view, but I have the Mets guys and Weatherholt ahead of him. Maybe one or two others, it was a very strong class.

If you were going to trade one of Franklin Arias or Jesus Made, which would you be willing to part with and what is the distinction that led to that decision?

Wouldn't be in any rush to deal either of them. If someone offered the moon, sure, but that applies to both.

When do you think players should be Rule V eligible, since it's coming up as a potential change?

I have conflicting thoughts here. In general, I'm in favor of more player movement and anything that gets guys to FA earlier. On the other, I think the earlier you let guys get to R5, the more you're pushing pitchers into the pen. Practically speaking, teams are pretty reluctant to take players who aren't ready to help in some kind of way, so I don't think that eligibility changes would be all that impactful.

Another post prospect question – what do you think bubba chandler’s outlook is after his rookie year? What changes does he need to make to improve it?

Mid-rotation, no. 2 upside in play but fading a little bit. Build on the control gains he made in the second half. More experience going second- and third-time through will be helpful.

What are the chances Davalan actually sticks on the dirt?

Pretty good, chance he's their next super utility guy.

Doubling up on Kilby questions: rough ETA if he stays healthy unlike this year? 2028 or later?

2028 is very reasonable.

Do you think Reimer still has a shot to start at 3b for a good team?

A shot, yes. I'd personally take the under.

What would prevent Cam Smith from becoming the next Jordan Walker?

I'm not sure if you mean this as a good thing or a bad thing…

Do you think David Davalillo can get his control to the point he can start, or destined to the bullpen?

Still projects as a starter. Control was much better in second AAA spin. Seems like he's one of those guys who needed a beat to adjust.

Crystal Ball gets fired up and we see Kendry Chourio in 5 years. What current or former MLB starter does he most resemble?

If it all breaks right, he's on the Sonny Gray path

I spent much of last year following Devin Taylor wondering if he was a guy that could hit his way to a higher projection, and then the last couple of weeks started to worry about a strikeout rate. Should I just go back to worrying about if he has a position?

Too much worrying. Broad contours of this profile are pretty well set. Three true outcome hitter, fits at DH. We'll see if he gets to the power often enough to play everyday.

Feels like once the CBA is hashed out and the Vegas/TB stadiums are sorted, the league will be hurtling toward expansion. I've seen it floated that the expansion teams should be given a 2-3 year run up to build their farms before fielding a major league team. Practically speaking, how would that happen? Minor league expansion draft of some kind?

This would/will all be very fun. I'd support some kind of window but the details — how many players/teams do they get? — are tricky. I'd think a minor league draft would be part of it.

Ha! Funny re: Smith. I meant more in the spirit of — can Cam convert his underlying batted ball data and obvious athleticism into a potential offensive breakout? If not, what would appear to be in his way?

It's in there, his approach is an impediment. And Walker having a stone-cold elite tool gave him a leg up on Smith, who has a lot of power, but not like JW.

Any chance Wilder Dalis starts the year in aa next season?

Any chance? Sure. Rockies don't tend to push all that quickly though, I'd be surprised. I'd bet he gets to Hartford at some point, though.

What can we expect from cam cannarella next year? Enough juice for 10 15 with 15 swipes?

I'm not sure he's going to hit for that much power. Lower launch guy — reasonably so, given his speed and approach — with maaaybe 40 raw? Tough HR park, too.

neslon rada and raudi rodriguez have to be put on the 40 man for the angels, right? whats the over/under in games played for 2027?

If it was a normal year, yes, locks to be added. If there's no R5 draft though…

Do you expect Murf Gray to be on a similar trajectory as Esmerlyn Valdez? Such as starting the year in Triple-A after spending just a part of last season in Double-A. Valdez only 51 games to conclude 2025, Gray 45 games to conclude 2026. I feel like there could be some urgency with Pittsburgh's third base opening, but wanted to hear your thoughts on this front

Sounds reasonable to me.

assuming 500+ PA, what do you see JDP's season looks like next year?

.274/.377/.449. Better but flawed defense, fair bit of DH'ing.

Been getting into LIDOM, who are the main prosects to watch in winter ball this year?

Made's there… Roldy Brito, Leo Bernal, John Gil, Jefferson Rojas… Emil Morales is on Gigantes but doesn't seem to be playing much… Justin Gonzales same thing. For obvious reasons, it's a lot lighter on the pitching side.

Circling back around from a "because you asked" last month, who do you think has the highest upside between Cards middle infielders Yairo Padilla, Miguel Hernández, and Sebastian Dos Santos?

Miguel scares me a little but he could also be pretty freaky. That bat could get very, very fast.

I think the minor league ball used last year is too new for scouts to correct it like they have the PCL over the years. will we be surprised when a pitcher was overlooked in 2026.

I'd push back a little, we were all over the different ball in the first week of the season. How to handle it is more art than science, and one assumption I've made is that the command/control guys who really got whacked were exposed as not having enough stuff to thrive against good competition… but it's possible that that reasoning is flawed.

If you were Chaim Bloom, how would you deploy the Cardinals' oddly deep catching pool? Is Bernal the C and RR heading to a corner?

Treat it as a great problem to have, find the right balance between keeping guys fresh and running with the hot hand until you've got clarity.

Would you change anything about the R5 draft? Seems like it hits about the right line overall but some teams really get pinched certain years.

It's weird. The purposes of the R5 are to give blocked players a second path to the big leagues and to prevent orgs from hoarding talent. It doesn't do either of those things very well, imo. Instead of a draft, I think I'd rather have a shorter path to minor league free agency.

How many Blue Jays catchers are you rating? Like the Cards they have a lot of guys who could be something.

Four on the main section, counting Sprock. A bunch on the HM section, including Parker who was a late cut (and who might also not be a catcher).

Hi Brendan, are you and Eric keeping the same list split this year? Any chance you'll get to the Red Sox sooner?

Won't be exactly the same, and we have to account for Mr. Fegan's lists, too. Sox will go fairly early.

Billy Carlson had an injury-shortened season in A-ball. Any change to his stock overall? Or is this a "run it back and reevaluate after more performance" situations?

I'm a little concerned about the lack of game power…

Besides De Paula, who do you see as next Dodger prospect to force his way into conversation?

Sirota, but it might be a trade conversation. His tracking skills scare me a little bit and there's no room to DH.

Honest feedback: I love the deep cut of the lists but I'd rather have my team's top 25 in April than go 60-deep in June.

I suspect you're not alone. Trying to do both this year.

Okay folks, thanks as always for the questions. I've gotta run and shore up the Jays and hopefully track down a couple sources on other lists. We'll do it again next week.


Jay Jaffe FanGraphs Chat – 11/10/26

Good afternoon, folks! Welcome to my first chat of the offseason. Last week I had my parents in town and the site was mostly dark for election day, so we hit the Jackson Pollock/Lee Krasner exhibit at the Metropolitan Museum of Art — I can't recommend it enough!

Last week also marked the announcement of the 2027 Contemporary Baseball Managers/Umpires/Executives Era Committee ballot, for which I gave the overview here:

https://blogs.fangraphs.com/dusty-baker-and-bruce-bochy-head…

It's the most stacked ballot, I think, since the change to the 8-candidate, 3-vote format in 2023, and at some point it might rival the 2022 ones in terms of future Hall of Famers.

Since then, I've run profiles of Lou Piniella, Bill White, and yesterday Joe Maddon (https://blogs.fangraphs.com/2027-contemporary-baseball-era-c…). I'm deep into researching and writing up Dusty Baker for the next one. What a fascianting career and life!

Did you get an awards vote this year?

It's awards season, but no, I don't have a vote. As I'm in the New York chapter, it's not hard to find enough voters for the various awards, but in smaller markets, my FanGraphs colleagues do get to vote. I know Meg Rowley was among those who voted for the NL Rookie of the Year last night; she had Carson Benge and JJ Wetherholt and Nolan MacLean ahead of Sal Stewart, who won. I would have done the same — I think I had them here in that order awhile back, and some took umbrage at my not elevating Stewart with his big RBI total over them. Jeff Zimmerman voted for Kevin McGonigle in the AL ROY vote, which is whom I'd have chosen. https://bbwaa.com/26-nl-roy/

I expect Dan Szymborski has a vote somewhere in here, and there may be others.

Wouldn't they be better off releasing all award winners within a couple days of the World Series being over? Probably get more eyes and ears that way…

Are you kidding? It's a very dead spot on the baseball calendar, and MLB, MLB Network, and the BBWAA are happy to provide four evenings of programming.

PCA was best player in NL by 4 FWAR and led Cubs to playoffs – should anyone who uses a first place MVP for someone else have their voting privileges revoked?

Eh, I know that sentiments like that are often played for laughs or outrage, and I'm not above that flavor of hyperbole once in awhile, but the point of a vote, rather than a statistical system or an award for leading the league in WAR is to let human judgment into the equation. You can't give people an opening for subjective decisions — especially when it comes to the very vaguely defined "value" — and then demand they all see things the same way OR ELSE.

That said, I do expect PCA to be a unanimous choice given his late-season surge and Ohtani's collapse.

any memories or stories about the recently deceased Bob Boone?

I'm pretty sure Boone was among the players in the first two packs of baseball cards my mom bought me, the Topps 1978 set. My younger brother and I pored over those cards and tried to pay the game on the back (each card had a batter outcome — single, double, triple, home run, strikeout, etc). I still remember most of those cards because visual memory is a superpower i inherited from my paternal grandmother. Kent Tekulve, Manny Sanguillen, Billy Martin, and Rob Picciolo were some of the ones in that subset; later I went back and completed the set.

Boone, of course, was a staple of the Phillies, who made the playoffs five times from 1976-81, and so I saw a lot of him on TV during those postseasons against the Dodgers and when the Phillies won it all in 1980. He was a good glove man and handler of pitchers, and at his peak he could hit reasonably well. He lasted forever at catcher, so long that when he retired he held the record for games caught before Carlton Fisk and Ivan Rodriguez (Pudge and Pudge) surpassed him. And of course he was the middle man in a 3-generation dynasty, the son of Ray and father of Aaron and Bret. A pretty full baseball life. RIP

some articles' videos are auto-playing with sound (I'm a logged in member)– the cooper pratt article was one. Can you run it up the flagpole to see if that can be addressed? It's a real problem when I'm trying to read fangraphs while coasting through zoom calls!

Hmm. I'll pass that along. I've never seen a setting to autoplay when I embed videos, so I'd check your browser preferences

Do you think any Negro League players are high-probability inductees the next time they're eligible?

I wouldn't hold my breath. Both Vic Harris and John Donaldson made pretty solid showings on the 10-man ballot that elected Buck O'Neil and Bud Fowler on the 2022 Early Baseball ballot, for which the candidates' main contributions happened prior to 1950, but both received five or fewer votes on the 2025 Classic ballot for those whose main contributions happened before 1980. Unless and until the Hall makes it easier to consider those players in a context more reflective of their era, it's going to be hard to get any of them elected even with the explosion of research (and MLB's belated recognition of their leagues as major) in that area.

Bobby Grich and Lou Whitaker are, I believe, generally considered the two best second basemen not in the HOF. When (if ever) do you think they will be considered again and what are their chances of ever being elected?

I'm hopeful Whitaker will be on the 2028 Classic ballot a year from now. Ideally Grich as well, but so many candidates from that era have been endlessly recycled that they've crowded him out, and the new rule about eligibility on the next ballot, double-edge sword though it is, doesn't officially apply to the 2025 vote.

How do you feel about Sal Stewart winning will lesser advanced stats. There is a part of me that thinks that awards like ROY aren't strictly about "value" and that having fan palatable statistics and the excitement of legit slug from a rookie should count a little extra. Do you agree?

Particularly for ROY, I don't think one has to go strictly by the numbers because some key rookies often aren't in the majors at the start of the season, though the PPI system has changed that equation somewhat. I get why Stewart is popular but man, I'm never gonna wave the pompoms for the RBI guy winning out when we have better measures. Benge going 20-20 with excellent defense should be every bit as exciting to a ball-knowing fan as Stewart driving in runs.

what do you think luis robert jr will be like next year?

I hope he's healthy and productive but the dude has averaged 90 games, an 87 wRC+, and 0.8 WAR in the past three seasons so I'm not exactly optimistic.

Jay! Great wrote up about Joe Maddon, even though as a Cubs fan I personally don’t see Maddon’s case for the Hall. My unpopular opinion (at least among Cubs fans) is that if Theo had hired Francona instead of Maddon and signed Scherzer instead of Lester they’d have won more than one ring. My personal feeling is that he ranks somewhere behind both Gaston and Johnson, and they both have better resumés. No real question, just appreciated your writeup!

Thanks for the kind words. I see Francona as a stronger case for the Hall than Maddon but not necessarily the more interesting and innovative manager. Maybe you're right about how things would have played out on the alternate scenario you've suggested but what strikes me is how abruptly Maddon's tenure ended in Chicago. I think it was Ricketts (and Theo) being wary of long-term investments in players and I'm not sure Francona wold have fared better.

I would put Johnson ahead of Maddon in the short career/innovative and influential/1 World Series win batch even before considering Johnson's solid major league playing career.

Hi Jay, I have long agreed with you that pre-testing = Wild West, but a positive test is a DQ. But I've recently changed on Manny and A-Rod, and I'm wondering if I can pull you over too. My re-frame was due to a hypothetical: what if Mike Trout tested positive today? His career until now has been transcendent, and, critically, verifiably clean. As such, he'd still get my vote. I respect that you may disagree… but if you could see yourself bending here, then I think A-Rod and Manny deserve the same. They had late positives but in their cases, I think people see those positives and extrapolate to assume they were using pre-testing as well. And though probably true, I think we should push back. It's to their detriment, not their benefit, that they played in an era when MLB catastrophically failed to both police and protect their players. And as such they deserve to be treated as innocent up to those tests. If a Trout candidacy could (maybe) survive a late positive, so too should theirs.

The problem with what you're suggesting is that even before Manny and A-Rod were suspended for violating a policy of which they had to be aware, both were reported as having failed the 2003 survey test. Yes, that was supposed to be anonymous, and in my ballot deliberations I haven't used that as disqualifying (e.g., I voted for Ortiz and Sosa), but that was because neither of those two guys were shown to have violated the post-testing rules.

The fact that Manny and A-Rod illustrated their lack of common sense in other ways in public doesnn't help their cause either. I don't see myself flipping for either of them.

I'm curious – would you say your personal list of "why aren't these guys in the Hall??" players matches what JaWS has to say?

My "want" list isn't in order of JAWS — we know why Bonds and Clemens aren't in the Hall even apart from what the numbers say. The numbers are great, and I'd prefer they were in the Hall, but if I had to choose Bonds or a criminally overlooked guy like Whitaker for wom my metric brings things into focus I'd choose the latter.

What's more a lot of the guys on my want list are eithe Negro Leagues/pre-Negro Leagues Black baseball candidates or nonplayers , so we can't go by JAWS there either.

Hi Jay! Any insight into why the BBHOF is really the MLB (with a smattering of Negro Leagues) HOF? As an ice hockey fan, “it’s the HOCKEY hall of fame, not the NHL hall of fame” is often used as justification for electing a player who excelled in the KHL as well as the NHL, for instance. Why is this not the case in baseball? Is it just the bare fact that it was originally such a one country sport, or has the hall explicitly addressed this question?

it's the *National* Baseball Hall of Fame, which meant USA when it was established in 1936 and has been expanded to include Canada because it's part of MLB; put an MLB team in Mexico City and those players would be eligible too. Membership is voted upon by American and Canadian writers who had the most exposure to those players, whereas they didn't get to see or cover players in Japan, Cuba, etc.

Are we going to be waiting a while on Pete Rose and Shoeless Joe despite their reinstatement? I just don't see how a process that has been so unfriendly to Bonds and Clemens comes close to electing those two.

I don't like the newish "two strikes" rule but I'm hopeful that if either Rose or Jackson is on the next Classic ballot that they'll be rejected so resoundingly (5 votes or fewer) that they'd be ineligible for a 2031 ballot, and then if that were to happen a second time, they'd be "permanently" ineligible.

I'd be surprised if the two-strikes system gets that far. Some great manager or Negro Leagues legend is going to slip through the cracks and the blowback of ruling them out permanently won't be great for the Hall.

Do you agree with the HOF’s decision to put Joe Maddon on a ballot before Mike Scioscia? Scioscia had 268 more wins, a higher winning percentage and more division titles. He also managed the same team for 19 years and was never fired. The Angels have been around for 66 seasons and Scioscia is their lone WS manager. And FWIW, his 2002 Angels were just the second team ever to win a WS without any players to ever make the HOF, win a league MVP or Cy Young award.

The decision on who gos on the ballot is made by the 11-member Historical Overview Committee, not the Hall itself., and it's possible Scioscia narrowly missed inclusion. That he won just one pennant while Maddon won two might have been the separator. Of course, down the road this could work out to Scioscia's advantage given the possibility that Baker and Bochy get in, but then again, Francona is going to be a strong candidate at some point down the road.

I realize I’m way too into the weeds on why the 2016 Cubs became the MLB equivalent of the 1985 Bears, but it seemed at the time that as early as 2018 Maddon had completely lost the clubhouse, and they needed to be quicker to change gears. I agree that the Ricketts’s inability or disinterest in investing in the team played a larger role, but at the time there were a lot of complaints coming out from “unnamed players” in local media about a lack of professionalism and commitment to winning. I realize he runs some people the wrong way but Willson Contreras was the only one willing to go on record saying as much at the time.

There's probably some truth to what you're saying. I did note in the Maddon piece that the sentiment that he had become less hands-on with and accessible to players was conveyed to him by Theo in the 2018–19 offseason. Maybe it was too late by then

I just pulled up our new-ish Projected Standings archive, which shows that the Cubs were 7 wins below their Pythag and 5 below their BaseRuns projected records. We tend to credit managers for teams that outperform those things — sequencing is kind of random, but bullpen usage can reflect the manager's touch — so it makes sense that we at least note when they underpeform.

I guess where I disagree with considering the survey test (even if only done in situations where it's part of a larger body of evidence in combination with a later positive test) is that what I'm saying is that I don't even *care* if they were using pre-testing. Yes, given their lack of common sense and all the circumstantial evidence they were almost certainly using all along. But to me, that makes them victims, not perpetrators. I'm not saying that their careers to that point *were* clean, just that any guilt during that time should be placed so squarely on MLB that we might as well think of them that way.

Perhaps chat isn't the right forum for this though, there's so much to say. So let me also say that I 100% appreciate and believe your approach is the right one, and wish other voters were able to take such a logical, measured stance. You are fighting the right fight! I just wonder (and don't necessarily have an answer for) whether there's room for those two in that fight as well.

Thanks. I can't say I don't *care* about guys using in the pre-testing era, just that I've tried to separate rumor (the bogus "positives list" that circulated back in those days) from reported information, and the leaks do place those guys in a separate category.

Mostly, though, it all sucks and I'm goad I don't have to expend as much energy thinking about this as I did 5-10 years ago.

are jim edmonds or kenny lofton more likely to get in given beltran/jones

Yeah I think their elections help both players' causes. I suspect we'll see Lofton on the next ballot, maybe Edmonds at some point too as the two-strike rule at least stimulates some churn among the candidates.

In Michael Baumann's article today on Morejon, he advocates for bringing back the 1970's style relief ace. As for me, I'll take any opportunity to work 1974 Mike Marshall into a conversation. For you though, do you think that multiple/consecutive 100+ IP innings from a reliever will ever be sustainable?

Given how hard most elite relievers are throwing these days I suspect 100+ innings isn't a sustainable model. Pull up a list of 90+ inning relievers in the Statcat era and the top two entries are for Ryan Yarbrough (2018 and '24), he of the opener/bulk framework and the sub-88 fastball.

In fact, a look at the top 10 shows there's only 2 guys whose four-seamers averaged 95 or higher, AJ Blubaugh in 2026 (96 IP, 95.8 mph) — we don't know if he can follow that up — and Derek Law in 2024 (90 IP, 95.1 mph), 9 innings in 2 seasons since due to arm problems.

custom table there.

How much did 2026 ding Skene's potential HOF narrative?

I wouldn't suggest that any active starting pitcher 3 years into his career be subjected to a Hall of Fame narrative. Let's see if he's still pitching at a high level when he's 30.

Soto or Lindor higher HOF odds?

Lindor because he's already close to the JAWS standard and playing a skill position that helps him accrue value even when his bat isn't great.

Skubal prediction (team and basic structure)?

Mets. With an opt-out somewhere early.

what are your thoughts on team expansion? i feel like diluting the talent pool should be treated very very carefully

We've gone longer since the last round of expansion than we did at any time between 1961 and '98. The player pool has enlarged greatly in that time through US population growth and the influx of elite Asian players. Remember, prior to Ichiro's 2001 arrival, no Japanese position player had even come over.

Coming back to NL ROY – why did TJ Rumfield get screwed so hard? Objectively he was the best hitting NL rookie with 500+ PA, and you can't hand waive it as Coors effect because he actually had a higher wRC+ on the road (132) than at Coors (116). Simple as HR go brrrr or….?

I wouldn't go so far as to call it a perfect storm but: 1B with non-traditional offensive profile, added value from defense that could be ignored if only focusing on triple crown stats, anti-Coors Field bias, and the ease of ignoring the Rockies due to their perennial loserdom. Tough break.

Skubal: 8/$320m with opt-outs after years 3 and 6? Trades overall length for opt outs.

I'd guess he either tops Yamamoto's $325 million or Scherzer/Verlander's $43.3 million AAV for the purposes of bragging rights. not sure about where the opt-outs would be but one after year two or three makes sense.

OK folks, I gotta see a man about a toothpick so it's time to wrap this up. Thanks so much for stopping by, and have a great week!


Ben Clemens FanGraphs Chat – 11/9/26

Read the rest of this entry »


Eric Longenhagen Prospects Chat: 11/6/2026

Hello hello. I just walked in the door from my First Pitch Arizona panel, sitting down to chat momentarily. Thank you for your patience.

For those unaware, here is the website for first pitch arizona. https://www.baseballhq.com/articles/Events/first-pitch-arizo…

My update to Asian Pro players is now live on the board. The accompanying piece is with editing and I will link to it when it's published.

Okay, let's get to your questions.

What's the furthest you've ever bumped up a prospect after reevaluating? And what's the furthest someone has dropped?

The college arms who pop in a big way, like Will Warren and Cam Schlittler, essentially go from nothing to top 100 guys pretty fast.

Then you have the big money teenagers who you learn pretty quickly are bad, like Roderick Arias.

Now that a full season and fall/winter leagues have occurred, have you noticed anything different with the Rockies at all? Could be anything- hitting/pitching approaches, technology, just more scouts/staff?

I thought my answer was going to be "everyone is swinging less" but when I checked the team leaderboards…. https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders/major-league?pos=all&stats…

I think the braintrust has been around more. Depo, Byrnes, Tanous… you see them around. Idk if there's anything else tangible that I've noticed but I'm sure there are things I'm just spacing on.

Did you see any of Tekoah Roby in the AFL? What's his outlook in '27?

Roby is one of the guys who I have yet to see. Will get him this weekend, though.

The chatter has been positive. Would anticipate he's a '27 graduate.

Do you think Sammy Stafura is a major league SS?

I do, but I'm not convinced he's an average everyday player, though I know scouts who are, including the one who drove the bus on acquiring him in that deal. He can play defense, he's strong. I think he's gonna K a lot.

Noticed you and BG seem to view Dax Kilby's ability to stay at SS differently. When that happens for scouts is it typically different evaluation on their skills or a different emphasis on which skills are most important for given position (say arm for a SS).

I think it's "bias on look", if I see Kilby airmail a couple of throws in the 6 games I see, I'm gonna worry he can't play there. If Brendan doesn't see that, he probably won't. Teruaki Sato, video when watched in reverse chronological order, shows him airmailing several throws within the first 20 attempts, so we're on the same page there. Some of it is I am meaner/more miserly than Brendan, who wants to give the players the benefit of the doubt and time to develop.

I think defense is more of an inherent thing.

Eric, thanks for both your #1. Passion #2. Dedication, to providing honest feedback in regards to these many prospects. It’s understandable there will be both hit and misses, but you sure seem to get a lot more accurate than some of the other forecasters. Nice job.

Hey thanks, it feels good to have done this long enough to be comfortable being wrong, and to not get defensive when I am. The couple of studies that have been done (Lindbergh sends me one every now and then) tend to agree with you.

At least, I think I use the entire scouting scale in a way that is most useful.

General thoughts on the 2027 draft class? Last I read, the Guardians have 6 picks in the first ~100. Please remember that I will cling to your response as a beacon of hope as the lockout kicks in and the temperatures drop.

I like the top 10 and think that group is deeper than usual. Didn't love the HS guys during the summer and think the overall depth is below average. Heavy on college arms, that group tends to have some injury attrition during the spring.

Do you have a general outline & timeline of what we can look forward to this offseason with BG on board for a full offseason? Status quo/same stuff be done sooner/new content

We have some technical tweaks to go over with Meg and Sean regarding possible data viz and changes to the system overview section, Once that stuff is cleared will be rolling at a little better pace than before. Brendan already has a couple of his lists mostly done.

I have all this data and wanna have an accordion feature like we do on the top 100, but instead of the distribution graphs, I want it to be data viz spider graphs or even just a year-to-year breakdown of a few key metrics for these guys.

Some of that might be easy for Sean to do, and some might be harder.

Is every prospect who vaguely resembles Miz (*cough* Susana *cough*) now overrated, at least by fans?

Mmmm kinda? Guys who throw hard and that's it do not equal Miz. Susana doesn't have nearly the same kind of fluidity, he's more like Duran to me.

It's tough because, who resembles Miz?

On some level, being a unicorn has its own value, but sometimes that's Miz, and sometimes that's Altuve.

Once the prospects get called up and get an opportunity, but don’t run with it right away, and struggle, what do you view as a potential alarm? Chase, swing and miss. Hard hit, ground balls- launch angle, low walk rate, etc. What skill say in following year after Cup of Coffee can get better just with getting older and adding experience for position players.

I try not to get too over my skis in either direction. Trout, Judge, Utley… there are several HoF caliber players who initial taste was sour. I do know there are people in the game who think if you don't perform or show improvement during your first six or eight weeks, that they think you're cooked. I think there are too many examples of players improving (period, sometimes that means going from good to great, sometimes from fringe-y to decent) to say that's true.

what's preventing franklin primera from being turbo elite? obviously the models must love a 19 yo catcher with a .367/.499/.581 and 48:36 bb:k, who kept it up in A ball. Is this a deeper question about stats v scouting? Like why is this not surefire t50 with a great chance to be t10 by midseason?

physically mature kid with basically no projection.

How does one value a prospect who will definitely make the big leagues and also definitely have a ceiling as a UT/RP? Big leaguers have value, but…?

Are you talking about in fantasy? You probably shouldn't value that guy. Here we use grades, where a 45 is like a premium utility man, lefty platoon bat, or set-up man, 40 is more like a true reserve who's on the roster because you need a second shortstop or a guy who takes at-bats against righties, a more limited role, middle reliever. We value them but more for the role rather than war production, since war production is a counting stat that true everyday players are compared to one another via

Is the International Players tab of The Board getting an update soon?

I updated it at 5am

The Cardinals need to fill holes at CF and 3B by the start of 2028. Will players already in their system be the answers at one or both spots, or do you think they will need to go outside the organization to meaningfully improve at either spot?

I would guess they keep things in-house at 3B and see what a combo of Gorman/Fermin/Saggese, etc can do. They have depth there. In CF they don't. Vic Scott is playing in winter ball, haven't seen enough of him to know if he' looks better. CF FA market is tough, they could always trade a catcher for a 3B/CF but idk which org has a CF surplus off the top of my head. Buxton for a catcher with Jeffers out the door in MIN?

Do you ever talk to cistuli

Yes, but his cell phone plan is weird now that he lives in Canada.

He's good, he says. "Uh… sure, you can say hello for me."

How's Ike Irish looked this fall? In my brief looks it was a lot of groundballs but also fly balls smoked to left center

Ditto. Good corner platoon bat, nice piece. Needs a Manny Margot type caddy as a RH/defense first pairing.

How do you view 1B shaking out for the Brewers assuming Bauers is gone? Could one or both of Luke Adams and Blake Burke be a ready made solution?

I think those are both interesting in-house options along with Vaughn . Some 1B reps for Contreras also makes sense.

The Brewers seem to be very good at helping their prospects become the best versions of themselves, rather than drafting and developing for lift-and-pull hitters or max velo pitchers. How much do orgs vary in terms of how much they seek to draft and develop the most valuable traits (pull-side power; velo) vs. how much they just try to draft players who are good at some things and can get better at other things?

Huge differences. There are teams who draft pitchability guys and then develop velo (Cleveland, New York) and there are orgs who draft good hitters and try to make them strong (Milwaukee, Tampa) and there are teams who are willing to consider moving guys up the defensive spectrum (Sacramento, Detroit) because they had good prior reports on players at those positions.

out of the braves system, who's got a better chance of hitting their way up in the next 2 seasons: Hartman or Southisene? Hartman seems like the higher ceiling because of the power-speed combo, but Southisene is probably a major league hitter and up-the-middle defender, even if it's 2B and a 90 wRC+

I like Southisense's feel to hit more. DOn't think he's an INF tho

Can you give us a preview of what you're thinking of writing about during the apparently-inevitable lockout? Any ideas for new projects you're thinking of pursuing?

Well the minor league stuff will be happening more or less like normal, so there's that. I wanna write about autograph culture and meiji university and do more self-evaluation type stuff that is slightly different than the How's My Driving pieces.

Jake Bloss' velo had been down in the AFL but has started to tick back up. How dependant will his success be on getting back to the late summer velo he teased before the teres major injury?

I'm less concerned about his velo and more about his command. His fastball rides enough that if it's "only" sitting 94-96 but located well, it'll play.

Any fresh dope on Samil Serrano or Angel De Los Santos? I'm trying to temper expectations but both look very projectable to me.

Lotta Samil Serrano questions in chat today. De Los Santos is really athletic and projectable, also very chase prone and is gonna K a lot. Really exciting player with some bust risk because of the Ks. Serrano had a great DSL season, data looks awesome. Definitely has some misreads in here, he has a 123 max exit that simply isn't real. COvers the inner half really well, think he's a nice hit-tool oriented prospect whose swing has lovely natural loft. Not overly physical, could break out if he can add muscle without getting stiff. Already squaring it up consistently. Probably the equivalent of a first round HS prospect.

Does Bodine block Flewelling as catcher of the future for the Rays? Or is Flewelling too raw to even be in that conversation?

The latter, for now. There's a chance Bodine entrenches himself so much that the Rays just decide to make Flewelling into Soderstrom.

Have you ever been tempted to buy baseball cards of prospects you think that market is undervaluing? Or does it seem like a money pit even for knowledgeable insiders?

Nah. I have been tempted to try to move the market on a lie for Machiavellian funsies. The only cards i collect are to fill out my MLB Showdown collection and dual sport athletes. I have some cool Brian Jordan/Deion Sanders stuff and whatnot.

Higher ceiling: Yostin Pena or Alexander Frias?

Frias but they're both freaky

Of arms yet to debut, does S Hernandez, R Sloan, J Susana, L Doyle and Zazueta seem like an agreeable top 5? Maybe J Flora is next in line to join that group?

Healthy Thomas White at least belongs next to Doyle. I'd take Gage Wood, Anthony Eyanson, and Flora over Zazueta, who doesn't have a good breaking ball.

The new International board is awesome, and it reminds me of Roki Sasaki and what an interesting odyssey his career has been so far. What FV would you give Sasaki right now?

45+

Are you seeing Kyle DeBarge making adjustments that might help him make enough contact to have a chance at an everyday role, or does this feel more like taking advantage of less refined pitching?

The latter, but he's a big leaguer. Good utility guy, A bit less physical than Ezequiel Duran but could play that kind of role.

Any chance Roldy Brito pulls an AJ Ewing in '27?

You mean striking out 25% of the time and slugging under .400 while everyone glazes him?

Give it another year, I can see why you're making the comp. I think Brito does a little more at 2B and a little less in CF (Ewing is good btw, I'm just joshing)

Re: the college arms and others who pop, what about them makes them pop to evaluators? Is there something subsurface that doesn't appear until they hit the minors? Or is it minor league dev changing something to unlock a hidden talent? Seems like some orgs routinely add a few mph to guys' fastballs pretty quickly.

Yes. This is where some of the strength and flexibility testing comes into play. There are physical traits that you can measure when you get your hands on the player at your facility that help you understand the players capacity for strength, or learn what their deficiencies are so you know what to work on after you draft them. Like Schlittler the Yankees might have known he's so underdeveloped, but has huge capacity, so let's take this human construction crane and see what happens….

Sometimes it has nothing to do with sports science and is just intel from your people who know the college pitching coach sucks, or whatever. But the space in which people are evaluating has less to do with the tool grades (which are more measurable now than ever) and more with the aptitude/athleticism/secondary traits that might indicate the baseball skills can improve.

Admittedly more of a post-prospects question, but curious about your thoughts on Jack Perkins and if you think about him sticking as a starter (or at least away from the bandbox he’s called home). Been looking into him for a good bit (particularly as a four-seam/sinker tunneling candidate like the Rays implemented a lot this past season), but curious if your thoughts have changed any on him.

I can see why they want him to start because of his build and delivery, but to me his command has always been so bad that I thought it was a long shot.

Any update on Jan 15th International Signing Day? I think Braves fans will fall apart if Alfredo Sena isn't part of the organization on 1/15/2027.

From what I've heard it will still happen but it might not happen in Januar. I think MLB would love to push it another six months. It will mean that since the pandemic they've pushed it a year.

Based on whats going on in the AFL, how does Patrick Reilly compare to the other intriguing Os upper minors arms (Dzierwa, Hunter, Gongora, Forrett, etc)

Nastier breaking stuff, worse command. Five-and-dive starter.

Susana-starter or reliever? If reliever, closer?

RP, closer.

If defense is more of an inherent thing, who would the Dodgers prefer play an inning in LF in a game today, Josue De Paula or Eric Longenhagen?

Today? JDP. In 2010? Bro, I'm playing CF.

Is Hyun Min Ahn 안현민 on your radar at all? Was a name I was expecting to see on the Board based on stats alone, but I don't have much more context there.

He's in the piece that should be published today. Actually looking at Slack, Martell has notes for me I need to fix some stuff.

Gimme like 1 minute

Back

Did you get an opportunity to watch either of the Red Sox' top two draft picks play this season (Schaffner and Hull) and do you have any general thoughts on either of them?

Yes, I like Schaffner (Small school cold weather background, natural feel to hit, non-zero shot to stay at shortstop) and I'm not so hot for Hull whose swing I think is too long for him to hit. I'll be looking for an overhaul this spring.

Looking at Asian player updates, I don't see Shoki Oda. Do you think there is realistically no chance he comes straight to the US?

It's just an asian pro player update. Oda is an amateur. He's likely coming, I would expect he signs in 2027, whenever the signing period actually begins. I wrote more about him in the piece that has yet to publish. He'd be a first round pick if he were a HS pitcher here.

Spangler or Miller, who's a better MLB hitter?

Miller

Roby left the AFL didn't he? At least The Cardinal Nation reported that maybe a week plus ago. They just wanted him to get some game innings in and a limited amount with a plan of him heading home early

I thought he was on the fall stars roster and assumed i had just been missing him over and over

Another Miz-inspired question: what's the advantage of a short stride, if any? Not that Miz-level extension would work for every pitcher, obviously. But watching Miz got me wondering if the short striders of the world are just leaving a lot of meat on the bone in terms of velo, and/or putting extra stress on their arms to achieve high velo. Or am I wrong and short striders as a group tend to gain compensating benefits (maybe command?)

A shorter stride might change the angle of the pitch or allow it more distance to break in a way that's beneficial.

Boston shortened Crochet's stride.

Ok ya'll. Lemme make sure I'm interfacing with Matt as soon as he needs me to. I'm gonna split. Please consume my international pro update this weekend, it's a doozy. Talk to you next week


Brendan Gawlowski Prospects Chat 11/3/2026

Hello everybody. Lighter queue today so far, guess that means it's the offseason. We'll see if it picks or if we have a shorter one today.

How much has Zion Rose juiced his stock in Arizona?

For us? Enough to go from where we had him in the draft to somewhere on our T100.

which prospects have elicited the loudest uncontrolled reaction from you? shock, awe, dismay, hilarity?

I'm relatively even keeled but I did just start laughing when Yanquiel Fernandez hit a fly ball 47 feet over the foul pole, an ump called it foul, and then he hit one even further out to right center on the next pitch.

And also when Modesto broke an eighth inning, 0-0 deadlock when a wild pitch bounced off a catcher's shin guard and into the dugout and allowed the only run of the game to score.

And when Juan Guerrero started playing hackey sack with his glove in left field as his pitcher came set.

I'm an 880ish rating. Is that Rookie Ball?

That's probably 60th percentile or so on Chess.com? Sounds pretty good to me.

You mentioned somewhere (I think) that the Red Sox list was to be released earlier this offseason. Usually it’s a little later. Is this change due to feedback or something else? Either way, I’m looking forward to it

Nope, just picked it out of a hat. Metaphorically, at least.

Would you rather have a lineup of 9 Chandler Simpsons or 9 Yandys?

Would be fascinating to see the 9 Simpsons play the 9 Yandys. Think I'm team Yandy but what a mess of a game that would be.

Is Angel Genao just blocked all across the infield to the point the Guards try him in LF, or is the bat just not playable there?

I would view his situation as more of a temporary obstacle than something where you need to consider switching his position. Could be a trade chip, could be a Rocchio replacement, could be a second baseman and you move Bazzana.

Brewers LHP Wande Torres threw the 3rd most MiLB innings in their org this season. Do you think he profiles as a starter long term?

Not out of the question but he's not very loose/fluid and he's already walking a fair few hitters. 80/20, 90/10 relief outcome.

What's one scout friendly change to the CBA that you'd like to see happen? (I know they're not at the table, but a change where one of the consequences is more human intelligence.)

Pushing the draft back to June.

To the user who keeps asking whether Players from Country Y are motivated and those from Country Z lazy: I'm not publishing that for what I assume are obvious reasons.

Awesome stuff, struggled with command seems to be Jarlin Susana's AFL report on repeat… how does an organization forecast development with a prospect like that?

They'll be kicking around various paths forward. Coaches and dev staff will have ideas on what they want him to do physically and how likely it is that change X can facilitate outcome Y (better command in this case).

In Susana's particular case, that will likely involve a tailored plan for the winter (workout regimen, throwing program, etc.)

And then an assessment of where he's at come spring training

Would Bazzana’s bat play anywhere but 2B? Seems like a “good, not great” player if he makes it long term at 2B, but does he hit enough (or field enough) for anywhere else on the dirt?

If he's a ~110 wRC+ bat over the long haul, that could play in a corner. I'm not saying "move Bazzana," more "I don't think you'll see Genao move to LF, here are a few ways he could get in the lineup without doing that."

Not a prospect but from an evaluation standpoint which role do you think Grant Taylor is best suited for: starter, closer or Andy Ashby?

I think he can start, and given Chicago's rotation situation, it makes sense to give him a shot. The other two are nice fallback options.

If anything, what under the radar things are taking place in player development systems?

I think if you're here and subscribed to FG, you're probably pretty plugged in and aware of a lot of the things going on. Holistic athletic assessments, tailored and increasingly sophisticated strength and conditioning training, bat handle/barrel shape experimentation, pitch design labs…

You, understandably, wrote up Po-Chun Lin as a total wild card on the Mariners list last offseason. Any updated info on him now that he's pitched on the CPX?

Please check back next week, I don't have a great answer for you this very second and complex stuff requires a little more legwork than I can do with a chat going on.

What strengths can a farm director bring to a major league clubhouse?

People management. Farm directors have to get so many different types of people and personalities (coaches, players, trainers; new school and old school; native English speakers and people still learning; front office folks; etc.) motivated and swimming in the same direction. It's a different challenge than managing a team of major leaguers and handling the media and whatnot, but if you're good at people management, I can buy that that skill could translate to a managerial setting.

When do you expect list season to kick off? I check twelve times a day for the updated Braves list : )

Hopefully next week. But sounds like you could use a second sneak peak.

Luis Guanipa: Guanipa was a $2.5 million international signee out of Venezuela in the 2023 class. Despite the bonus, the 20-year-old is neither especially toolsy nor projectable, and the contours to his profile are similar to what they were a year ago. He makes a lot of contact (77% overall, 84% in zone last year) but it’s not especially authoritative. He tends to swing inside the ball and generates a lot of opposite field contact. Guanipa has average bat speed and is only able to consistently pull offspeed pitches that hang over the middle or inner part of the plate. His approach and swing decisions are generally solid but he started chasing more spin off the plate this past year and hardly walked at all after a late-season promotion to High-A.

Defensively, Guanipa’s tape is a mixed bag, with a blend of good reads off the bat and drifty routes that sometimes get him in trouble. He has the look of a guy who can play but not excel in center, and if anything he looks a half step slower than he did at last check in. There’s still enough hit skill and defensive versatility for him to grow into a fourth outfielder role, but some of the strongest parts of his game look a little dicier than they did in the low minors, and he’s correspondingly fallen a bit in this year’s update.

What are your “if the lockout lasts too long here’s what I can write about” article ideas?

Eric and I are not going to struggle for content.

In an ideal world where all lists are published and there's no MLB, we've still got the minors, foreign leagues, colleges, etc. to follow. And I'd love to do more PD/scouting articles like the one I had last month about pro scouting.

Not a prospect question, but I keep reading about how the Brewers are good at bat design. Can you explain that to us, and particularly, why other teams can't copy it? I always think objective analysis is a lot easier to agree on than the more subjective analysis that so much of scouting is built on.

I have no idea how good they are at it relative to anybody else but they're not alone in experimenting here. I can't find it but I thought I read something a couple years back about Julio trying various bat handles and actually not choosing the one that led to the very highest max EV because he didn't like the way it felt? Is that out there somewhere?

What do you think is the biggest jump or fall a player has ever taken in an evaluation cycle? Have you ever bumped a 35+ to a 55+ in one season? Or the reverse?

Better question for Eric, since he's been doing this forever… Plenty of really young guys will go from off the radar to the 40+ category in any given year. Breyner Figuereo with Texas just might end up in that territory.

Conversely, there are a few guys who got money in the DSL who start as 40/40+ types that just aren't good. Kendry Martinez, Cristopher Polanco, etc.

When it comes to the draft, are there prospects that you like who are likely to fail because of the team that drafted them? Can you name any situations in the past when you were upset for the player because of the team that drafted them?

Of course. We try to comment when we think a player goes to a particularly good spot for their talents or vice versa.

Too pithy to say "every time Colorado drafts a pitcher" but not by much.

I mean, the Brewers were very involved in the most famous "bat design" incident (?) in recent baseball history: last year's "torpedo bat" opening weekend controversy.

Came from the Yankees, but yes good example

Since you mentioned at the outset that the queue was a little lighter, can you take us behind the scenes of one of your chats? Are you cross referencing notes with stat pages with video, etc., or is it as simple as the questions come in, you pick one and type an answer and move on?

Sure. First though, you guys have picked up the pace in a big way, tons of stuff in there now. But it's pretty simple, I see all the questions that have been asked, I try to select mostly ones I can answer relatively quickly but I also have my spreadsheets open and will watch a little video if there's a guy I'm familiar with but need a refresh or a new look. The Wande Torres question, for example, I pulled some video of him and had that in the b/g for a few minute while I took other q's. If there's something interesting that I'm unprepared for, I'll ask folks to come back the next week and try to do a little research for them between now and then.

I've also heard some feedback that my answers can be terse; I don't mean them to be, I just wanna answer more rather than less.

Are there any pitchers you or Eric have discussed hundo'ing based alone off pitch shapes or traits without the requisite sample size or game performance

Discuss, maybe, but we generally want to see guys throw a little bit before we go nuts. Briggs McKenzie is a good example. We like him, I'd put a mid-rotation grade on him if I were scouting for a team… for the 100, let's see him hold his stuff over longer stretches first.

Are there any prospect types that are benefiting from the consolidation of the minor leagues?

The handful of guys that are boat racing through are perhaps getting to the big leagues faster than they would have in the old days of ten years ago.

Caminiti has seemed poised for a breakout for a couple years now, is he someone who gets a long runway to develop a viable offspeed? If the change doesn't come around, is there still enough stuff to 50 him?

CH looks better year over year. He's one we have to talk through but I think he makes it.

Any surprise 50s for the Red Sox list? How close are Godbout, Primera, Delzine?

Delzine may just sneak on there. Primera PTC I think, Godbout I'm a little down on relative to last May.

>Bud Smith 11:40 AM What do you think is the biggest jump or fall a player has ever taken in an evaluation cycle? Have you ever bumped a 35+ to a 55+ in one season? Or the reverse?

iirc Vance Honeycutt went from 2025 45 FV to 2026 HM

(checks board) and now he's back to 40 FV!

There are probably even more dramatic movers out there, too.

How do you see the white sox handling Smith/Schultz/McDougal next year? Rotation? Bullpen? AAA?

Just speculation, but Schultz gets every chance to start, Smith is the relief ace, McDougal less of a factor.

Sebastian Walcott offense showing up in AFL stat line. If he makes it to the majors in 2027, what defensive position(s) would you expect to see? And what is a reasonable guess for how much shortstop he plays in his career ahead: more or less than 450 innings of major league shortstop?

That's a fun over/under. I'll take the over, because that's not really all that many games. That said, if/when he makes it in 2027, I would guess it's in the outfield just b/c Seager is still around and productive.

Do you think there is any chance a version of the Rule 5 draft takes place at some point this offseason? If the likelihood is low will it materially impact team's 40-man roster decisions over the next two weeks?

Chance, sure, doesn't seem likely. Team behavior would change if they knew one way or the other.

How does the MiLB ball vs the MLB ball impact your evaluation of pitchers? Do all pitchers lose x% of their stuff, or does it only affect certain types of pitchers? On a related note, is Jacob Odle a Dude?

Good question. Does not seem to effect all pitchers evenly, seems to effect the overhand/carrying fastball guys more than others but need to do more work to tell if that's anecdotal or a trend.

Is Arias Gleyber Torres with better defense or is that just me?

That comp doesn't light me up.

But, if he posts a 113 wRC+ over his first nine years like Torres did, he's a star.

Any chance Bodine or Gillen debut in 2027?

Good chance, particularly for Bodine, who's already in Triple-A.

Will there be any fringy free agents that jump the gun and sign overseas just to avoid hits to development time?

Speculation, obviously, but I'd buy that the uncertainty could push guys on the fence to take the leap. Maybe a few more Dan Straily types available for KBO clubs this year.

What do you make of Bishop Letson after the way he finished his season?

Let's pull up the game logs here…. oh damn, that was pretty good: https://www.baseball-reference.com/register/player.fcgi?id=l…

I don't have any strong opinions off the cuff, it's the kind of thing that will have me looking for changes between September and July.

But also, guys do this. I bought BIG on Case Williams throwing harder and missing a ton of bats down the stretch in 2022. Next spring, the velo uptick was gone and he was Case Williams again.

Listening to you on There R Giants right now. How many other orgs are lucky enough to have someone covering their farm system so comprehensively?

Roger does a really good job, he's plugged in and is on top of all sorts of stuff. You and I hear a rustle in the wind, he hears that Samir Chires is throwing harder in a bullpen session.

I don't want to miss anyone, so forgive errors of omission, but obviously Sox Prospects do a great job with Boston. Scott Lucas covers Texas and is a friend I've run into countless times on the backfields. Matt Winkelman on the Phillies. There are others, again, forgive my scrambled brain right now.

MadFriars

How do you think about choice between having the multi-inning super reliever vs keep trying them at a starting (Aaron Ashby)? To phrase it differently, when do you just accept that you have a stud reliever who can cover multiple innings?

If every start seems to start well and then turn into a quagmire around the third or fourth, you've got a good candidate.

What franchises would you anticipate most aggressively gambling that the Rule V draft doesn't take place?

Franchises should not be gambling, it's against the rules.

(More rooting than gambling, I'd imagine. Teams with deep systems, a crowded 40, and a ton of guys eligible for the R5. TB/MIL/SF come to mind)

Looking at stuff, build, projection, delivery, athleticism, command, compete, holding velo, age x level, everything, am I crazy for thinking Zazueta is the best RHP prospect the Dodgers have had in like 20 years?

He's up there. The tricky part is that we have the benefit of hindsight on a few good ones that haven't worked out. Like, Bobby Miller was a very good prospect, River Ryan we're obviously high on still, etc.

re: Case Williams and velo jumps, Landon Knack hitting a hundo in spring training feels like a lifetime ago now

Maybe the prospect with the widest range of radar readings I've encountered from the first to second time I saw him

A good reminder that, while you can't/shouldn't ignore the gun, you shouldn't chase it either.

Re: Grant Taylor- James has written a few times that Brian Bannister has, when talking about Taylor, brought up how his extreme extension is similar to Glasnow, and seemed to imply that it may lead to similar injury concerns with a starter's workload (especially on shoulder/lat which he's already had trouble with). Is this a concern you share, both for Taylor specifically and more generally as a potential issue for high-extension pitchers?

Bannister on Taylor: Guys that pitch at max extension are kind of in that danger zone…

"There's just an added level of stress involved versus somebody who pitches more in the range of their physical height. If they have six-five extension and they're six-five, I think everything is operating in more of a middle, neutral range of the bell curve. It's just an observation and I do a ton of studies on my own, because a lot of this you have to operate in theory because there's not huge sample sizes. Like [Tyler] Glasnow [who has similarly high extension], when you look at the track record of innings pitched — and I have a lot of respect for him and his talent — there's a lot of seasons where he threw like, 60 innings. There's just not an extended track record of throwing 100-200 innings."

Great question, I have no answer, but something interesting to think about. Might ask around this winter and see if there's an article there somewhere…

Think I'm going to shut it down here. Thanks for coming as always and we'll do it again next week. In the meantime, be well.


Ben Clemens Top 50 Free Agents Chat – 11/2/26

Read the rest of this entry »


Eric Longenhagen Prospects Chat: 10/30/26

Happy Friday, party people. We're slated to get something like 2-to-3 inches of rain this weekend in Phoenix and it's pouring at the FanGraphs Desert Vista Compound right already. Looking forward to a weekend of Emo/Shoegaze writing like when I was in PA. For now, we chat.

Jefferson Rojas outlook changed much in the last 3 months?

I don't believe so. Still projects as a good everyday infielder, either SS or 3B, who's top 20 at his position. Good get for them. Folks can watch him most days playing in LIDOM for Gigantes. He and Roldy Brito are often in the starting lineup.

Candy corn?

I'll eat it. It's not high on my pref list but I'm always curious enough to try it again. Especially the pumpkins.

Given the Yankees aging core and the likelihood that Kilby isn’t a SS long term, do you see him being a guy they push pretty aggressively provided he continues to hit as he moves up?

I think so, it's reasonable to expect him to be promoted at roughly the same pace Lombard was if he keeps hitting. I think them sending him here after he barely played this year was fairly aggressive and he's thrived. Wouldn't chock me if he starts at Hudson Valley.

As a Mets fan, what happened to Jacob Reimer this year? Between he and Clifford it feels like the corner bats we thought were close maybe aren't coming at all. Or is that too harsh?

Clifford was always going to be flawed in a way that left you disappointed, assuming you bought into peak expectations 2-ish years ago. His reasonable outcome was always more of a platoon bat. Reimer I was in on and remain on to a degree. He's better than his injury-altered 2026 statline, not just betting that he'll be better when healthy but looking at his underlying data, which is more favorable than his surface output…

The problem with Reimer is he's maxed out, tightly wound corner guy. If he's gonna K a quarter of the time and have roughly average power, does that really play in a meaningful way? I think it plays some, but not as a top 20 player at 1B if he ends up there alone.

Position changes- rainel to third is that a real thing- Jesus made where does he play? Seems odd that he only played ss this year- seems like they’re committed to Pratt at short

I guess I'd wanna see Rainiel play third base before declaring yes or no. He's a heavier kid but built a lot like Max Muncy, who has been able to do it well enough to stay at 3B and moonlight at 2B for a while. I think a position change is what gets his bat in the lineup soonest because he otherwise still has so much work to do as a catcher.

Made I agree they should have (or at least should in LIDOM) see what happens with him at 3B. Pratt is the better defender. Joey Ortiz and David Hamilton should not be blocking a potential 30-homer 3B.

Prediction for where Skubal lands?

I'll go off the board a bit and say Braves

They have a lot of money coming off the books in the next few years, Acuna and Sale and Profar, Albies, Suarez… it adds up. Kinda wonder if there's a Ketel/Acuna change of scenery trade in here somewhere? One more year of Albies makes that less a fit.

Any names popping up from either instructs or the bridge league?

Instructs ended a couple weeks ago. Most of the good players are guys you already know. I thought Angeibel Gomez looked good, the Giants infielders, Grindlinger, Comeau… You should take a peek at my pieces from that window of time I wrote a ton as it was going on.

Prediction for the largest change to MiLB/draft/amateur to come out of the lockout?

I think we will get an agreement before that stuff is ironed out. They'll say "here's the deal, let's play baseball." and then will hammer out draft/int'l stuff as an afterthought in the weeks following.

Does John Peck have starting shortstop upside? He kind of came out of nowhere but he has some nice underlying numbers, including his player comps on Savant.

I like him but consider him more of a good utility type rather than a first division regular.

does Vance Honeycutt make the main list next year? OPS and EVs look pretty, but he's still K-ing ~30% with "empty" (non-competitive) walks

Back on there. The defense will allow him to play a role. Crushed for me yesterday, hit a ball 108 to dead CF. I agree the K's are too scary to project him as a consistent 2+ WAR guy but he'll play a role.

" Bonemer entered the AFL season as the one of this group I was worried I’d come away feeling more skeptical about because of how much whiffing he did during the regular season. Instead, I think his power is weaponized by sufficient barrel feel. He is likely to be a left field-only defender in the big leagues, but he could have output similar to Teoscar Hernández." His arm not strong enough for RF? Is he just in center to have easier reads?

Not a natural thrower from the OF whatsoever.

Does Seaver King start next season in the MLB? What are your thoughts on his ceiling?

I think Washington will look to maximize years of control there. I was super high on King coming out of college, became pretty skeptical at the end of 2025 because he had zero ability to pull the ball (I'm not a "pull everything!" guy but I do think it's scary when you can't do it at all) and was really shaky on defense. He had an awesome season, and needs a re-eval from scratch this list cycle. Washington's new regime absolutely made their hitters better right away and I'm willing to bet he's a true arrow up guy rather than a product of this year's wacky minor league offensive environment.

Wildly close lightning strikes here, like cartoon sound effect lightning.

I swapped my Dax Kilby for Grady Emerson in my long term keeper league. Did I screw up?

You should consider it a lateral move I guess, id have to know way more about your league and roster to give you a cogent answer.

I'm curious how to best deal with a bad year of production for younger prospect bats – guys like Jansel Luis or Gabriel Rodriguez? How do you weight production on toolsy guys in full season ball?

It's tough. You look for reasons to give them the benefit of the doubt. Were they young for the level, were they injured, does the surface production deviate from the underlying data in any way?

ATL farmhands Owen Carey and/or Isaiah Drake make any notable impressions during in-person looks in the AFL?

Drake can really really run, he has a RB's physicality. Can he hit enough to be anything more than a specialist? He has an interesting data profile (huge launch, roughly average contact) but visually his feel to his is crude. Carey is on time to pull, probably LF only defender (30 arm), like him as an eventual corner platoon bat, though it'll depend on how strong he gets. They're both prospects, but not likely impact guys.

i know this is likely the million dollar question, but is Bryce Rainer swing something that can be fixable in offseason to return to hos rookie season contact rates?

I don't think it's something you actively tinker with yet, I think he might shorten up naturally as he deals with failure and is forced to adjust.

How do you balance (your time, focus, etc.) making sure you nail your evals on top 100 dudes with having 1200+ reports on prospects?

It's the toughest thing, honestly. Like yesterday I went to Peoria with Laurila. We went earlier than I would have on my own because Laurila interviews players, and that happens well before the game. Then it's nearly impossible to focused on writing in the press box because people in there wanna socialize (which I get), then Patrick Reilly was useful to see for four innings in perfect weather, then nobody else threw strikes and we had like 24 combined walks. I'd have rather been doing anything but watching three pitchers be required to finish an inning. But once your'e in the bowl with the scouts it's kind of a faux pas to leave early, they don't know you're going back to the box to do more work. Anyway, yes this part of it has been the toughest thing for me to wrangle in ten years of doing this. Marrying the depth I'm capable of and the depth that is a differentiator for us as a site (along with the writing quality imo) with the broad, Taylor Swift type tastes of the reading and listening audience that wants everything done right now and could care less about the 40s and 35+ guys.

For a dollar: Which outfielder in the Cardinals system will have the highest peak season WAR? Walker, Baez, Peete, Frias, Condon?

I think Frias.

Chase Harlan is down as a guy you want to see more of this fall – do you have any specifics you want to assess with him or more just a general get eyes on?

I just want more looks at him playing defense to feel better about where we project him. The league average wRC+ at 3B this year was 98. At 1B it was 111. Where he plays defense really matters to how he stacks among his peers.

Congrats to the Brewers! Do you think they'll realize more out of their side of the Peralta trade (Sproat, Jett Williams) in 2027, or is that shaping up as a lose-lose trade?

I still think Sproat will be good. Jett will be a role-player.

Any chance we get another visual scouting explanation series? Or perhaps a few ABs/plays from one player where you break down scouting them from the basics (what do you see mechanically) to the more advanced?

Yeah I want to do a video podcast series that takes you through the list-making processes.

Any flawed prospect that should consider switching to football to replace Tanner McKee? Or play O-line? Or call plays?

How has Elijah Green not started playing football at Georgia yet?

What's the next "thing" you see teams like the Dodgers, Brewers and Rays doing from either a development or player acquisition standpoint, that will cause the rest of the league to play copy cat?

Brewers tailoring bat design to the player's swing.

Is Axel Plaz's bat good enough for him to be a regular? Is Rafael Flores' bat good enough that he plays daily for the Pirates?

Plaz is Botero Jorge Alfaro. Flores will play a big role, yeah. How many catchers really play every day anymore? It's only the top couple guys. They almost always share time and I think Flores will, too, but thrive as a hitter in that role catching 80 games rather than 120.

How has Brooks Auger looked in the AFL? Still a viable path to being a starter?

Built like a starter, moves like a starter, commands it like a reliever. Think in that org he's a swingman.

The question about Reimer and Clifford makes me wonder: aren’t Baty and Vientos still ahead of those guys in the (young and at least somewhat unproven) Mets corner infield queue? Or is the cement dry there?

Definitely stacked ahead of Reimer/Clifford. Ronny Mo, too. It's a deep group, they 've given themselves lots of bites at the apple. Some of these guys regress, some progress, and when you have enough of them around you can capture the peak years of the best couple guys and do okay.

How do you evaluate a young, high upside, projectable prospect who misses 1-2 years due to injury? Yairo Padilla, for example. Should we assume his development "paused" or is it more likely that he's been progressing off the field?

It's tough, but Ethan Salas is proof of concept that these guys shouldn't simply be dismissed because of lost time.

Can Chandler Simpson improve his arm? Very unnatural throwing motion

Nah, feels like he's just in 20/30 area and you live with it.

Jake Cook didn't have much hitting experience before the draft. Is he developing as you would expect? How did he look in Arizona?

I love this guy. Has run sub-3.9 for me multiple times, which is like Billy Hamilton fast. Except this guy has more size than Hamilton and is relatively green as a hitter. Think he has a chance to be pretty good. At the very least he's going to be super fun to watch develop, or try to.

Has Zion Rose passed Burress with his AFL performance?

Burress looked good during instructs and I wish they had AFL'd him rather than Guedez. I think I'd still take Burress, just a more explosive athlete in the box.

How do you see the looming lockout affecting the pro hiring cycle and any player development efforts around spring training/opening month of MiLB season?

I think some of the more budget-conscious teams will have fewer additions to ops this offseason. Same as COVID and the last lockout.

What’s more likely for Derek Curiel? He’s able to stick in center or develop enough power to be a regular? As a Bucs fan, I’d love both, but both feels like a tall ask.

Let's see what his body looks like in February. These guys can get in the weight room in their early 20s and get pretty strong pretty fast.

Who are you most interested in seeing how they develop further – if you think they can – now that they’ve reached the majors?: Spencer Jones, Victor Mesa, Cole Carrigg

Carrigg is the toolsiest of that group.

Not a question-video podcast series for the lists would be must watch!

I've had this idea for a long time but clearing music and video rights could be a nightmare. I obviously shoot a ton of my own video but sometimes broadcast footage is just better for showing what it is I want to show… we'll see.

Where would Miguel Hernandez have gone in the 26 draft of he were eligible? When looking at his metrics, he seems impressive and I prefer him over the Cards actual draftee Condon.

Good question, Bubs. I think he'd be a 700k type in the draft. Sub-70% contact rate guy is scary for Low-A, good plate discipline and power for his age. There's something there but not a first round something

Can you try to develop a pitcher for an Aaron Ashby-type role?

I think you develop them as starters and then it becomes clear their best role is this Ashby type thing. Grant Taylor, etc.

Dynasty question: I can only keep two of Johnny King, Kash Mayfield, and Bishop Letson. Who should I cut loose?

Kash

Can you give us an idea of how to think about AFL as a level of competition? Both in terms of "who they're up against" and also "who should be sent and who isn't ready"?

High-A pitchers in a Cal League hitting environment. The bullpens here are always bad. I don't know how to solve for this because the pitchers sent here are almost always sent here because they were hurt during the regular season.

Okay friends, great chat today. I am speaking at First Pitch Arizona next week during our scheduled chat time, so I will need to either change day/time next week. Be sure to check the chat schedule on the site for updates, I'll try to come up with a solution that is creative and fun (like maybe chatting live during Fall Stars?)

TTFN