Archive for Chat

Members-Only Game Thread: World Series – Oct 28, 2026

Welcome to our Open Game Thread for the World Series game today. Only Members can participate, and unlike our usual staff Q&A chats, your messages will be posted immediately.

Our Member community is made up of thousands of incredibly knowledgable baseball fans, and we think this is a great way to follow a game with like-minded baseball enthusiasts. We might even have some FanGraphs Staff drop in and join the fun. Please be courteous to your fellow Members, or you may find your chat privileges revoked.

Go Rays!

go baseball

Good evening, everyone!

Let's go Brewers!

I am about as bored with the current narrative (pressure now on the Brewers) as I was with the previous one (Rays were done after game 3 and the sweep was inevitable). We assume the players are as emotionally unstable as the fans.

Fanthropomorphizing?

I like that word!

The reality is that there were 3 close games and one blowout. A few different 9th innings and it could be 3-1 Rays, and everyone is talking about how the Brewers keep blowing it even though they have performed better.

NLDS was the same way. Padres could have easily swept that. It’s crazy how close it’s been for the Brewers

Genuinely curious: What do the markets have on the velo of Miz’s first fastball?

not sure about the markets (screw those losers) but I think something like 104.5 is possible

I'm fascinated to see how Cash navigates this mess he's made of his available pitching

Welcome to steal it, cus it happens a lot.

Im getting drunk for the first time in months. If any Mets hate comes out of me, I apologize in advance.

what did we do to deserve that : (

For the sake of BrewersBiblio… Mets AKA Smoltz for the remainder of the chat

They’ve hurt hurt me with both of my teams.

Never apologize for Mets hate. Sincerely, a Phillies fan.

Let's go Rays

MIZ MIZ MIZ MIZ MIZ MIZ

That the game's brightest young star (personal opinion) is starting the potential last game of the season can only be a good thing.

Sorry MLB commercial, it's not darkest right before the dawn, it's typically darkest at solar midnight, usually in the wee hours of the AM long before sunrise

What do you expect from the same folks who think it's impossible to know how many days October has?

It’s saying something that FanGraphs is the only place sufficiently nerdy for me, and I play on the U Chicago math department softball team.

Good evening everyone! Gonna try hard to just enjoy baseball and not yell at my team!

I feel like BK is super throwing Chef whats her name under the bus.

If BK is admitting their chicken nuggets have sucked, shouldn't they be offering us some free new ones as compensation? WHY WERE YOU SELLING THEM TO US IF THEY WERE BAD

Lack of double-blind randomized experiments?

You'd think they'd check to see if they sucked

BK as a company only hires people that lack taste buds.

Oh man if they randomly released different Beta versions to different markets and didnt tell anyone, Props.

Read this as Brian Kenny at first

I'm on an actual TV Fox rather than stream tonight, so maybe the commercials I see will match more than a minority of you

"OK, we need to advertise MLB. How about Bill Hader losing his mind slowly?"

I still love Bill Hader

Jackson’s never seen a pitch he didn’t like

We all know that Drew Rasmussen isn't related to Dennis Rasmussen, but what my book suggest is that maybe he is?

Am I the only one who remembers this 1992 Dennis Rasmussen start? https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/CAL/CAL199209290.sh… I am? Okay cool.

We back! Hello everybody

I have a theory that all baseball players are related

I like Chourio first to put the pitcher in a false state of belief that the Brewers are going to swing at whatever he chucks out there

Genius

Im surprised more people aren’t wanting the Rays to win. If I were an outsider, I’d avsultely want them to win, just to keep the series going

We’re a passionate bunch

Bauers on a roll! Of not hitting I mean.

Puyallup, WA’s favorite son, Drew Rasmussen

I'm rooting for the Brewers to win in 7, so rooting for the Rays to win today and game 6

second

I want to root for Game 6, but I also don’t want to tempt fate.

I made it 3 minutes with Smoltz's commentary, but the part where he started saying Rasmussen was pitching better because he's more tired broke me

Rasmussen looking good

You just wonder how long he’s good for

I just want it to go back to Wil so the Brews can hit some homers

Jumanji Part 3: The Search for More Money

Jumanji: the FLAMETHROWER

The kids love this one

My rooting interests: Manfred Getting Eaten by a Hippo> Brewers in 7 > Rays in 7 > Brewers in 6> Brewers in 5 > Brewers in 5 and the broadcasters mostly talk about the Yankees and celebrities

What other Burger King products are we going to find out have been terrible all along??

I don't understand how you can have new Jumanji movies with the same cast. HOW ARE YOU PLAYING THIS GAME AGAIN

"OH, here are the lousier players in the lineup too"

If only there was some non-verbal way to communicate with someone. I dunno, like “hands” or something.

trash can, but a legal one that does morse code

I want to see someone get Jumanji'ed into a worker-placement Eurogame.

“You’ve been transformed into a bushel of wheat”

Have yall been following the AFL outfield adjustment results? Insane.

I heard offense was up, but I didn’t hear any specifics about it

33% increase in hits and runs. Over 200% increase in triples.

I could go for some more triples

Those flies piss me off in MLB the Show. You hit the Perfect/Perfect window and it's precisely hit to the CF who doesn't move a millimeters

Hello all! I am going to try to remember to stick around here for more than a few messages

It appears Misiorowski's IVB is back to (and actually better than) normal so far

Dome at sea level causes craziness

Is this true?

Hey Jon!

Mound problems again?!

Just make it out of concrete!

I think the conspiracy of road mound Miz has actually gotten to him.

Did not expect this much feet chat this early in the game

I've never seen so many mound problems in a dome.

I feel like that’s a bald joke.

What if you got extra fractions of a win for winning longer extra inning games? The series would be 3-1.33, and the Rays would only need to win 2 more as long as they play 6 more extra innings

Insert “that just might be crazy enough, TO GET US ALL KILLED” squidward meme

Are we allowed to talk about hard toes?

Should have stuck with the slippery mound.

I think the worst feeling for any pitcher would be something forearm related. Or family tragedy

Or maybe having a soft toe.

Line drive to the…?

Existential dread

I will allow a hit to Caminero only because I have his RC

That might've been the fastest first inning of the series by a good ten minutes

Don't jinx it! I'm hoping I WON'T be exhausted at work tomorrow.

Back to business: hitting it right to Turang.

As a truck driver, GTA is such a stress reliever. I get to live out all my road rage fantasies. Can’t wait for 6 to come out.

Have you ever played Just Cause?

I have not, nor have I heard of it. Should I?

I played Spy Hunter in 1982 on my Apple II+, does that count?

It's a more destructive open world GTA-like game. It's older at this point.

BeamNG

Why have more people claimed the Brewers are gonna win, than that the Brewers will win in five?

Hahaha, I noticed that too.

That was me. Silliness

I really appreciate them using the slow mo camera to show him walking with the trainer there. Helped me really make sense of the action.

Hello everyone. What is happening with Cooper Pratt?

MVP

Great read (or great guess) by Turang there

I think the first/third base coaches are on crack

Pooper Cratt.

Out of the basepath…. Drink!

We have basepaths again!

I think you should be able to run to home in that situation

Love that high home replay.

That was inside

Only one run there feels like a big, well not mistake, wasted opportunity.

I forgot the downside of watching the game at the bar is everyone here believes they are experts at coaching. It’s inexcusable Frelick didn’t run home on that rundown, according to the people here

Tell them the fangraphs chat guy says that you are correct and they are wrong and stupid. That will fix it!

Im wearing Chicago Cubs shorts, so I’m not trying to draw attention to myself…

Ur killing me BBphile. Tickets to G6 and Cubs shorts? Bile rising. 😉

What is inexcusable is Pratt not stopping at 1st. 1st and 3rd with 1 out is optimum in that in that situation.

I feel like the rookies show their rookiness in the post

Was that a combo Polymarket/election ad? Two of everyone's favorite things!

That one feels extra gross.

It’s quite impressive that gambling has found a way to make politics feel even more disgusting

That Polymarket ad shows the entire problem. She needs to bet everything he'll lose and THEN blow the whistle

Tampa can’t sell out a World Series game and they can’t have a decent mound that doesn’t require in game service. Embarrassing for a franchise.

That mound looks like they just dumped rubble on it

And now I'm looking at the pitchers' feet. Thanks, Miz.

So how many pitches before Miz throws something other than a fastball?

When it fails?

who is the largest shoe size (avg) : listed height

i have a suspicion that shoe size might be very slightly positively correlated with velocity

Whats the record for consecutive fly outs in a ws game? Either/both outs recorded by fly out and consecutive batters who flew out

but getting a height-independent measure for that sounds difficult (longer levers apart from foot)

Literally everything Smoltz says is in service of trying to deny the reality that baseball has been revealed as a game of strength and power rather than finesse and strategy. Everything.

True, and ironic considering he was successful mostly because he was one of the foremost power pitchers of his generation

The Pat Murphy angry smile

I wonder if Jackson would swing at a bowling pitch.

More research/public availability for whatever pain drugs they used to "fix" Jr's foot for this game. ?

At least they caught it this time, but is it that hard for them to communicate?

Yes. There are no ways to communicate.

Overcorrection from last night.

At this point I can only assume Caminero has a fetish for running into his teammates.

The replay showed Caminero screaming for it several times. It also showed neither looking at each other after the play…

I wonder if it’s because so many catchers wear the ear piece and an earplug in the other ear

Really interesting of Fox to go to commercial with "Rockin' in the Free World," which is very much in the news right now.

I think Fox is semi aware that they are just highly paid trolls at this point

Semi?

How much credit for self awareness do you want to give them?

It's also a song up there with "Born in the USA" that will be played completely ignorant of the context of the lyrics.

FOX usually plays a lot of jam bands going into commercial. Lots of Phish, lots of Grateful Dead. This series has seen First Tube and Tweezer.

it's been tweezer reprise this series, not tweezer

It's not like FOX is a big single entity deciding top down to troll, it's mostly Jacob Ullman likes jam bands and picks what to play.

Need a poll for most mistakes we’ll see tonight: running into each other, running too far, or misthrowing to first

New rule. Everybody dives twice on every play.

Jeez. Your feed is significantly ahead of mine.

I'm using an antenna. Much faster than cable and streaming.

You can set the chat to delay to match your feed in the settings

Gameday is almost a minute ahead of Direct TV. I wish I could find a way to use that advantage.

Bar bets?

Has there been any data about how much slower pitchers' average fastball velocity is in the postseason compared to the regular season? And is it different for starters and relievers?

I think I've written about this. Pitchers throw harder in the postseason. Adrenaline. And shorter outings.

Huh. Even by the end of October?

They also pitch better when tired according to the expert in the booth

Here's Eno from a couple weeks ago: "The average postseason adrenaline velocity bump is just over one mph. Gavin Williams was up 1.9 mph today and Freddy Peralta is up 2.5 ticks"

Oh, here's my article: https://blogs.fangraphs.com/reaching-back-for-a-little-somet…

Vilade diving into the lava pit

Wow

The Brewers pitching coach is named Hook? And he's not the one who pulls the pitcher?

And their manager is named Murphy and, so far as I know, he never gets folded up into an apartment wall.

Wait until you find out his rank in the military

He probably doesnt even listen to Blues Traveler either

No dives. B-

Why is it so hard to convince players that running through first is faster?

Instinct is awfully hard for logic to override in a split second.

Going to go against the grain here and say that I think there is a specific way to dive and get there faster, though most people don't dive into first that way.

I believe I read somewhere that if you dive in such a way that you launch yourself forward and touch the base before touching the ground you are indeed faster. But standard baseball slide is slower and (a) no more propulsion from legs and (b) friction with ground

i am also appealing to the logic of the "layout" or "bid"

If the sideline is yelling "bid for glory" I'll allow it

yes i will shoehorn in frisbee things. no i will not attend a tournament or even my local pickup group.

(i might attend a tournament. health and homework willing.)

the once and future frisbee player

I think that Cooper Pratt baserunning blunder is going to come back and hurt the Brewers

I wanna see Yandy hit the ball with his arm

Super Mario Sluggers Donkey Kong style

Is Murphy rubbing off on Miz? He looked pretty pissed off there.

If true that seems like an HR issue.

I’d love to see Murphy get called into an HR meeting

“So the reason we called you in…no, I don’t want a pants-pancake. What even is that.”

Never let them know your next move

Yandy has one cheek with triple-wide eyeblack and one with single-wide. What?

You wouldn't get it. Yandy is deep into postmodern eyeblack art.

His ever evolving war paint is one of the things I love the most about him.

It’s almost like it it isn’t really there for the stated purpose.

I coach little league. It’s never there for the stated purpose.

Diaz and Frelick competing for most injured?

Frelick hurt Diaz delay of game.

Oof

Tampa Bay delay of games.

That the broadcast did not use their AI tokens to show me a comparison between Yandy and Miz biceps should get them all fired.

I like how they squeeze ads into any possible break

I wonder if it's even possible for Yandy to fully button his jersey

This whole “let’s experiment with telepathy” thing isn’t working

Is it just insanely loud in the dome and nobody can hear each other?

That’s my assumption

Not the fans, the crumbling of the mound.

Everyone seems a bit on edge as well

OK, how many of you were betting three innings, Brewers winning, and count them zero strikeouts for Miz?

They need to summon Pat Morita to visit Yandy in the locker room.

Miyagi…. My KK lore needs updating

I don’t know how a hitter can even see these pitches

Was it Adames or Paredes who famously could not?

Adames couldn't see pitches in Tampa

See in Milwaukee I bet that’s an HR

HR in 19/30 parks

Hit the weight room JC

more bat speed training

Been really impressed with Simpson in this post

No no no announcer man… infield in=bad

Keep your eye on the ball. Baseball 101.

Someone I know said that Simpson fella can really fly

I had been thinking the devil rays jerseys were holding TB back. They should know better than anyone that they’ve really only ever had success with the true Rays jerseys

I didn't want to believe this, but I can't find any evidence to counter.

Miz is done

After another two innings.

That was close.

Trying to imagine blocking a 102-mph fastball from Miz with a runner on third

Again with the throws to first. I just can’t.

Please put someone else at third.

Palacios is available if you are willing to play him at 3rd

Make a good throw to third base challenge: impossible

Can’t blame them for getting their payday but I didn’t think Parquet Courts would be the type of band willing to sell out to Starbucks

Nm

Cash thinks he's got 5 bullpen innings tonight?

I think it’s more about Rasumssen than the bullpen.

I'm sure you're right, but 48 pitches seemed pretty light to me.

I’d like to think he could’ve gone more, but I won’t pretend to know that for sure. It’s making the Game 2 start look a lot worse though.

Cooooop!

Cooper. Man.

This could be the dagger inning

I keep on getting confused with the crowd cheering for what just happened was good for the Rays or the Brewers.

I saw a game in Denver like that when they played the Cubs. It was wild because no matter what happened half the crowd went crazy.

Don't the Rays know we need to squeeze every ounce of baseball out of this series because we don't know when we'll have it again?

Just enjoy it we are all going to die next week anyway.

Is that when Grand theft Auto comes out?

#6 is in the real world

Smoltz must be soooo disappointed that they scored with a hit rather than a bunt.

Ashby comes in when and for how long?

Was Williamson drawn really far in? Shouldn't they have been at double play depth?

Infield in=bad

I think the rule is you can’t be good at defense AND offense

Here we go again…

If Ashby comes in and gets some big outs is he the WS MVP? Leads the team in +WPA to this point.

Feels like Pratt maybe has the inside edge at this point? Think they'll always give it to an offensive player over a reliever.

If Ashby gets like 6 outs, I think it should be him

Of course, I thought Ashby should have been NLCS MVP, so YMMV

I'm still on Contreras

Pratts best game was in a loss. Unless he gets another 2 hits tonight.

If an offensive player gets it, it should be Chourio. Ashby should be the MVP though.

Rays need the Brewers to bring Shane Drohan in for some inexplicable reason

Chourio RISP master

What would it take for Kyle Harrison to finally get into a game?

Spring Training to start.

10 run lead 2 outs in the 9th

Probably a blowout or another long extra inning game. I think Woody would be trusted more.

Gangsters to pay Pat Murphy.

They should give out a postseason mvp award and Ashby would get that

Need to DH for Bauers

Not with the lead he’s the best defensive option at first

I've been watching the playoffs for a month now and still don't know what a self-driving network is

It’s a network that drives itself.

Not just self-driving, self OPTIMIZING

Self optimizing

That clears it up even more

willem_dafoe_forehead_slap.gif

I assumed it was a network that could identify all the stop signs, busses and motorcycles in the captchas.

The day I learned that users were unwittingly training self-driving cars by filling out those CAPTCHAs was the day I knew we were doomed.

Wait…what?

Is google trying to turn people off of sabermetrics? These full moon stats cant be real…

Contreras challenging pitches has been my favorite part of the World Series.

Gary Sanchez challenging every PA has been my favorite part of the season.

You had me at Contreras

And being mostly correct.

And threatening to do it before the ump even makes the call.

Hi guys, missed you all silly me socializing with real humans at a bar instead of on the internet

Im at a bar!

Are you at the same bar?

Are you at an Irish bar?

are you at True Laurel in the mission in SF? IF so…

I am not

Food just showed up for me, and I forgot I even ordered

That mound legit looks like you could BMX on it

I did drink a pickle beer in honor of Milwaukee

https://www.totalwine.com/beer/specialty-styles/specialty-be…

Told ya Miz is done

73 pitches and a slightly tired BP? No way. One more inning at least.

I refuse to let facts and data get in the way of my sincerely held deeply flawed belief

Nasty K

That felt like Miz taking credit for Yandy making a bad swing

What is best in life Miz? "Blowing fastballs by injured DH's and hearing the Lamentations of their fans "

You win the chat for using the word “lamentations”

apparently getting half swings at cutters in the waste zone?

Conan rules

Still feels crazy to me that he has no runs in, 15 outs, and only two by K.

The Miz, contact manager

Our Mailbag is a little light on submissions for this week. Anybody have any World Series related questions to submit?

What World Series had the most beer consumed per capita?

Are the brewers the greatest team in American history, or world history?

I need a full write up on the Strunk and White of when its Our Mailbag v Mailbag v The MAILBAG…

We don't know they play baseball in other solar systems.

What year will the Padres win a WS? The Rockies?

What player has had the most injuries in a world series? The most HBP?

Seems like consensus is that Ashby won't win MVP this year. When has a reliever deserved it most?

Run environment-adjusted best RP playoff performances

Is there an acronym for successful/unsuccessful/bullied ABS challenges by a catcher? Can we backronym something for Wild Bill?

Everyone in here send your questions to mailbag@fangraphs.com!

that seems like a lot of work

I think it’s Balls Eyed for Low Pitch or Hit

Im a paid subscriber, this should be good enough! /s

But Mailbag (re: Davy) is hungry!

What has a bigger impact on World Series ratings: the popularity/market size of the teams or the competitiveness/excitement of the games/series?

1982 suds series.

Mailbag, how does the mound at the Trop taste different from the mound in an open-air ballpark?

Back in the McCarver days, I used to successfully predict what he was going to say before he said it. That made announcers seem useless.

Yeah, I'm going with this ballgame is over. 3 runs feels like a mountain right now.

This feels insurmountable.

It is

Never say never. I mean until the game is over.

Found the guy who didn't have it tonight. How many more do Tampa have in their bullpen?

Chandler took a bad route. Probably wouldn’t have caught it but it was a bad route.

Already not a fan of Floridians and now the poor Rays getting no home game support. No redeeming qualities

They are like baselines… only real sometimes.

The Sanibel/Captiva area is nice. Mostly harmless retired Midwesterners. Still hasn’t fully recovered from Hurricane Ian, from what I hear.

I worked in Tampa for two years. I went to the mall one time and went to the sports store. 90% of what they sold was Yankees stuff. It was honestly embarrassing.

Are there a bunch of empty seats I'm missing or something? I feel like the whole "the Rays have zero fans" thing is a little overblown

I'm guessing it's more so that the stadium seems filled with Brewers fans who traveled over.

Huh. I really haven't gotten that vibe watching on TV

I have. They booed Diaz’ injury delays, the “Coop” for Pratt has been loud.

The Rays had the lowest playoff game attendance since 1919. Game 1 of the ALCS felt like a home game for Cleveland. Florida just doesn't care about baseball.

Oh wow

Interesting decision there

Had to let it drop. How could he give up another run???

Is letting it drop actually the right decision?

In this situation, it is the only decision.

I think let it drop is correct here.

When down already? I think so.

Cooper Pratt, stealth WS MVP candidate?

Up to .62 WPA for the series.

4-0 seems so much worse than 3-0

And 3-0 was already very bad

And the marginal difference from 4-0 to 5-0 or 6-0 (the risk of a big inning if you let it drop somewhat worse) doesn't seem as bad as the 3-0 to 4-0 jump.

Take the out. He has a chance to throw out Contreras. Drop it and Pratt might hit a double

What's the win probability difference if the RF lets that drop? I understand it's not really feasible to conevy that in the moment but would love to know, feel like the extra run's a killer.

It could have been 5-0 if Pratt gets a hit though

Difference between 3 and 4 is more important than the difference between 4 and 5 especially for a team that's struggled to score all postseason

That makes sense.

Should've let it drop. The Rays have only scored 5 or more three times this postseason

And they're running out of time to do it

Guy had 6 hits in last 6 ABs

WE bump there was only 1% so we may be wrong

dropping by to say go brew crew!!

I think WPA is underestimating the gap – who the hell knows, but 4 runs against this bullpen feels like it would be D-Backs vs Mariano level shock

Even before seeing that "teams are 27-4 when they score 4+ runs in this postseason" stat I was just thinking Game 2 was the death blow, brutal for the Rays to score 4 with their ace pitching on full rest and still lose

Here comes Vaughn

A slightly better throw and that sac is a double play and no runs score

Anyone have insight on the relevant arm?

The right one.

Just got home! How'd Miz look? The line's a bit confusing

….good? Mostly?

5 Ip and 0 ER IS pretty darn good

was talking to a non baseball fan coworker (whos also a data scientist) and we were brainstorming an idea to take the derivative of WPA to measure how fast the "vibes" can change

We might be 3 innings from no baseball for who knows how long. We desperately need a Rays comeback.

No we’re gonna do a Fangraphs winter league watch chat! Hopefully

If this goes the way it looks, the Pads and Rays should play for 2nd place.

Dodgers-Guardians for third place, like in the World Cup

I’ll be attending Puerto Rican winter league from November 7-15. Anyone who wants to find me on Bluesky is welcome to join the unofficial official chat!

They will play baseball in March.

Hope springs

Why is Matz coming in? Your season's already on life support and you absolutely cannot give up any more runs here. Is Matz really the most likely to get out of this with no more damage?

Unless Martinez is somehow available, I'm not sure who else they're supposed to use in the 6th. Sulser? Missing-fastball Baker?

I figured this would happen at some point. They don’t have enough pitching they trust and this is what happens when you wear out your whole bullpen.

Has Baker been that bad Matz is the best option here?

Chandler is the slowest fast-AF left fielder in history

Matz .574 vs lefties 873 vs righties no idea why they didn’t PH Vaughn there. That could have been the dagger.

Gotta keep Hamilton in for his defense

I am Mailbag and Matt Martell has advised me that I should solicit questions. I am hungry. For questions. Though I also enjoy Flamin' Hot Cheetos.

my Q: is baseball the "vibiest" of all sports? is there a way to measure that?

Which players have dyed their hair?

There’s a stat called BLEPH that measure that

Is this the lowest salaried World Series (relative to league average pay) in the modern era? If not, which series were lower? Were they more even in outcome?

1. Best RP post season performances. Adjust for run environment of that year's playoffs. 2. See how much better Mike Trout's career would be if he played in Babe Ruth's…environment (add in as many AAA and AA players as you'd need essentially)

If you had another player to place on the field where would you put him?

Best estimates of actual MLB revenue and the current distribution there of?

What is the absolute optimal pitch mix (assuming, say, you get 4 pitch types) within reason? Give a pitcher an ideal arm angle for theoretical stuff and play around with it/

If the Crew holds on, has their been a World Series champ that's been so close to losing most of their wins?

Is this the worst FA class ever?

I go the other way. Would baseball be more interesting with 8 on the field? And would you play 3 in the OF or 5 in the IF?

what WS is this one the most like in terms of similar teams?

I never think of good questions. But y'all do a fantastic job with the mailbag

I’m gonna miss baseball if this is it.

Is Smoltz cautioning Misiorowski on getting addicted to… pitching well?

Look, you're not going to be good forever kid, so start learning to be worse now.

Bwahaha

I'm watching in Canada where Sportsnet has its own announcing crew, so thanks for mentioning Smoltz by name. Occasionally people in this chat start complaining or riffing about totally random stuff, and I just have to assume that Smoltz must've said something crazy.

Smoltz is terrible, and I say that as someone who cheered for him so hard as a child.

Some of that is also just us.

Mailbag Q: can you build/develop more Ashbys (or further back, Andrew Millers)? If so, how?

How can you not mention Mariano?

I think you definitely can't create another Mariano.

Mariano was great, but he wasn't used the way Ashby has been this year (regular season and playoffs), or the way Miller was in his great playoff run. No shade on Mariano to ask about how to build/develop a guy who's used differently than Mariano was.

Yeah, yeah, yeah…strikeouts bad, radar guns bad…🙄

Only I am allowed to throw it fast and bendy too… how do you think I stood out enough to get to the hall of fame?

I got one for the mailbag: give us an analysis of Smotlz and quantify his claims to measure how wrong they are

A bottomless source of Mathemadage posts for Ben.

Miz is still not pitching “old school” enough for Smoltz, even though he has allowed zero runs with very few strikeouts. The guy still just seems to hate baseball.

He got really excited about football though on that Lions promo

Calf cramp. Calf cramp!

Oh cramp

FireJohnSmoltz dot com is available…just sayin’.

How many more "worst things for a pitcher" does Smoltz have?

Cramps are the worst thing in the world! But have you ever had space cramps?

I love me some pickle juice

That's a bummer of a way to finish this start for Miz

Oh man that's a bummer. For him and the team.

As someone who gets cramps all the time, it's so annoying. And yes, do the pickle juice.

Just the kind of advice I'd expect from a briny scientist

disc knower

At least it's not an elbow or shoulder injury

Pretty sure those are actually the worst things that can happen to a pitcher.

I mean he got them almost six innings. That’s awesome.

More than I expected

He said he wanted to throw 120 pitches. I expected 6 out of him.

If they hold on here, Miz WS MVP? 2 wins, 1 run in 10.2 innings

Aaron Ashby would like a word.

Gotta be Willy C right?

Would be especially fitting in first year of ABS!

If like to see a orthopedic surgeon who's never seen baseball watch that slo-mo of Miz' pitching motion and give their thoughts

“Give that guy my number”

Kyle Boddy kinda used to do this when Driveline was in its infancy… He nailed Strass sadly.

Does MLB oversee the home team groundskeepers in the playoffs? If this was the '50s the Rays would've def tried to make the bottom of the mound as soft and loose as possible to screw with Miz's stride.

I don't know for sure, but probably nothing special. The umps can make them do things, though.

Sad for him to come out like this – but I think if you had asked the Brewers if they could get 5 2/3rds from him with 0 runs, they would gladly have taken it

I have no idea who MVP will be. Chuorio 10 hits, Pratt 6 straight hits, Miz 2 W.

Ashby is my vote. Chourio is my likely to get it.

I'm confident it won't be Bauers at least

These things are all narrative, so Chourio seems most likely. Ashby has been pretty good too.

Pat Murphy would veto the Pratt MVP because of bad baserunning if he could

How heavily does abs fit in? 🤣 id vote contreras

At least he wasn’t loafing!

Miz has .50 win percent added over the series and chuorio is actually only + .02!

Pratt + .61 wpa

they just said on the radio feed that contreras will challenge if he doesn't win it

Speaking of, I recently read the Pat Murphy anger level article and thoroughly enjoyed it.

Worst feeling in the world? Mmm no. Giving up the series winning HR.

So the secret folks is get good players and have a good coach.

And a good clubhouse vibe

I recommend scoring more runs than the other team, preferably every game if you can manage it

Monkey never cramp. Just sayin

I started eating bananas before I went for walks, and I’m not saying it worked for my leg cramps, but in my mind they worked.

It’s crazy how every team that is about to win the World Series always seems to have a great clubhouse!

Contreras has contributed with the bat , the arm and his eyes. He leads IMHO

I second this. Contreras' double today pushed him ahead of Chourio

dj khaled voice

ANOTHER ONE

Bauers continuing to make his case for MVP

Bauers for the loss

Driving, game on radio. Need an update on how pissed off Pat Murphy looks.

He’s the kind of pissed off where the guy who ordered after he did got his food first.

No you don't, you knew before you asked the question! He's eternally curmudgeonly

"No you don't!” — Nathan Fielder

Maybe if Ashby shuts it down from here he wins MVP? Otherwise I don't see a way it could happen

would need TB to rally to at least one run game if not tied, then have Ashby slam the door for couple innings

Uribe, Megill.

Smoltz on that bauers DP ball with xBA of .420 “that’s about as easy as a play you’ll ever get as a first baseman”

To be fair xBA doesn't account for fielder location. That was smoked but right at the 1B who was playing on the line.

Had to make a nice throw too though!

F**king hiccups. I hate drinking

Nice back door there by JoJo

Smoltz talking about people who "have no business talking baseball…"

Yeah ironically this was his best take of the night too

Apparently I have no credibility. I talked about it in the, this would be fun and I want it to happen sense… but definitely am guilty.

Why did it take so long for Simpson to take off for 2nd?

Had to go back and touch 1st base

Holy crap he didn't touch first

Smoltz says *anyone* who thought Miz should come in last night has no business talking baseball… wait until he hears there is a guy out there who would rather give up a HR than walk the leadoff hitter!

He’s not wrong about that.

Ump cam during reg season great!
Playoffs no thanks

I'm good without it any time on anything but select replays

Ugh…cue up “putting pressure on the defense.”

Yep. Nailed it.

If Contreras wins, is MLB really gonna tout all his ABS challenges? Do they really want to highlight that there's so many wrong calls to correct?

Yes. The Umpires don’t really have a say here. They’ll claim they “fixed it”

He should get to pie the ump whose calls he got overturned most

That’d be a great way to send off CB Bucknor

It’s baffling to me that ABS challenges are apparently so popular that MLB (and T-Mobile, of course) are building entire ads around them.

This is their idea of marketing the game, smdh

Smoltz wondering if the gloves are too large and should be regulated is probably his best comment this postseason.

The Roki photoshop still makes me cackle every time I see it

Guys… didnt we talk about whether pine tar is legal on the mitts? and regulating them?… Smoltz reads our chats!!!

In the spirit of being contrarian – who actually likes Smoltz? Is this just the case the average baseball viewer is 55 and remember him at his peak, and thus think highly of him? I'm willing to accept the case for him, but a guy who s**ts on the game doesn't seem like it helps to sell it

I’m 49 and I remember collecting his rookie cards and his peak very well. Can’t stand him in the booth.

I’m having to mute after every pitch. This DJ should be imprisoned.

He's trying to drown out Smoltz! He's trying to help!

I dunno, Crapshoot, I remember Smoltz at his peak (though I'm 48, not 55) and he kinda annoys me. During Mis's cramp was like his required one time per postseason when he's useful

I just don't get as mad at broadcasters as I used to. There's simply not for me.

I actually watched many games broadcast by Joe Morgan. Smoltz is just garden variety compared to that.

One thing I forgot to mention last night is how much I realized I missed extra innings without a runner on second.

at least we dont have to listen to rex hudler anymore

Honestly, if you're a serious enough fan to subscribe to an indie baseball website and spend what could be the final game of 2026 watching here with us, the broadcasters aren't really there for you, either.

I am with you 100% Dan, I haven't listened to an inning or missed more than a few here at Fangraphs.

That will not stop us from complaining!

Yeah, I sometimes read the comments at The Athletic – there is very much a market for “I reject everything we’ve learned about baseball in the last 30 years.”

I'm just complaining for the love of the game — I've had him muted since the first inning

Not over till it's over and all that but can't see this Rays lineup scoring 5 runs in 2 innings against Uribe/MeGill

Brian Anderson is a great help to his color men. He knows how to lead a horse to water.

I admit I kind of liked Tim McCarver, despite stathead scorn. My grandfather was a Mets fan so I grew up listening to him, and he had folksy charm. Plus it was kind of fun when he was instantly proven wrong.

Not impressed by Joe Davis

He's a lot better with Hershiser. I think he just doesn't trust Smoltz and tries to fill in more color on these national casts.

Sarcasm aside Smoltz is a bad broadcaster because his play by play guy can never trust him: either Smoltz trips over his words so badly you have no idea what he's saying or he veers off on some tangentially related rant halfway through. Davis has to constantly be on guard to jump in and save him

John Smoltz to FanGraphs readers is like Yelp food reviews for Andrew Zimmern.

I hope we get to see Palacios make another little league lollipop throw to first

Murphy would be great cast in a post apocalyptic movie where surviving a zombie outbreak is how he finally connects to his rebellious son.

He wouldn't be a great national broadcast guy because he's a huge homer, but I often miss Hershiser as the color guy during the playoffs

Mailbag: Who among the FGers would make the best announcer?

Eric Longenhagen and I don’t think it would be close

I'm going to risk a ban from Dan and unironically suggest Carson.

I've switched to the Brewers radio broadcast. not so hard to get it synchronized.

I’m a baseball on the radio fan myself. There’s something about it that is magical.

Absolutely right! I miss Joe Castiglione so much that I am having a tough time accepting Will Flemming.

I grew up listening to Jon Miller, then got Gary Thorne as an adult, and have Kevin Brown now. As a result, national broadcasters always felt underwhelming and I generally tune them out.

O's fans really have been blessed with announcers. Baseball players, less so.

I’m not really that old (29) but I still miss bob costas

Costas totally lost me with the Pedro Strop thing

I've also never made an underwear spreadsheet, for the record

I think this denial isn’t helping you.

I think they should have like 8 different booths, and you can pick based on mood.

Would love a permanant crowd noise option

Provided the DJ is imprisoned.

Brian, I'm not a mod status for the unstructured chats, so I cannot ban you being nice to Carson sadly!

Feeling goofy? Here's Bennetti. Want good color? Here's Darling. etc.

David, you know they'd figure out how to do it with AI

In last night's chat, someone posited an extra inning rule in which eventually Smoltz and Davis take over as pitchers. My question is, which would you rather have? Smoltz is almost 60 and Davis is 38, so Davis might last longer before breaking down, even if Smoltz presumably remembers how to throw a curveball.

Oh give me the Hall of Famer

Smoltz easily, as long as he can still physically throw.

When do the guys in the pregame show get involved? Jeter vs. Smoltz is more of a competition, but still not much of one

Not ph for walls?

Right? I am an ardent Walls defender, but not pinch hitting here is indefensible.

I looked at their bench Mullins would seem to be their best option. Not that much of an improvement.

And Joe Buck always gave the vibe that he felt we were there to watch him instead of the game.

Buck always sounded like he couldn’t wait to call football again.

Smoltz has inspired me to keep my Duolingo streak going. This time next year, I hope to be fluent enough in Spanish to be able to watch the ESP broadcast.

Bruh…why is this inspiring me???

Yeah, take the Hall of Famer

That may help for Chourio's MVP case

Joe Davis is a broadcaster's broadcaster; sometimes he isn't necessarily a fan's broadcaster

Let us save a few reproachments for the Arod/Papi/Jeter trio who are incapable of expressing anything that wouldn't show up in a comments section. Is it that hard to find a thoughtful player? Can I not have a panel of Joey Votto, Sean Doolittle, and Brent Rooker?

The crew for Phillies-Braves wild card round was fantastic

The Wheeler Proclamation notwithstanding

And add Pedro and Rollins so we can get the hilariously awkward "who is Pedro's daddy tonight" segment.

Another idea was Manfred vs. Bruce Meyer–I think Manfred's probably likelier to be able to get one over the plate.

does this mean that Ashby is closing?

That feels a little too cute, Megill's fresh and can go two innings

But Ashby is WAY better. Megill has been sketchy in the postseason.

Yeah but he threw 31 pitches yesterday, he's been dominant but he's still human

Ashby human? Citation needed

Hit the gym Yandy. Too weak.

I've noticed that throughout this series. He keeps thinking he hit one out.

Im obviously biased as a giants fan but I think Jon Miller doing national stuff is utterly amazing. Him and Dave Flemming (another awesome person) are so so good

Jon Miller is a top 3 broadcaster left in today’s game.

Yeah up until now it didn't matter what booth you got for a Giants game, it was gonna be good

Megill is a notorious bunt hater so maybe it should be oops all bunts here on out for the flappy bois

Stop, you’re making Smoltz aroused.

I've got so many (bad) ideas for TV booth combos by mood now. Banned announcers, for the anti-woke, manned by Thom Brennamen and Curt Schilling.

John Rocker for on field reporting I assume?

Rocker and Jose Canseco locked in a cage for two minutes instead of the 7th inning stretch.

Paired with Lenny Dykstra.

One more inning until lockout abyss 🙁

I don't care. Being this happy for Milwaukee will sustain me for a while. It feels so good to see an organization do everything right and get rewarded. Plus, their fans are so likeable.

If this is it, a huge thank you to Sean and everybody who had a hand in putting these together! It has been great meeting so many of you, I hope we get the chance to do this again soon!

Thank you Sean & staff we love you and appreciate all you do! 🫶

I would definitely recommend these chats as one of the innumerable benefits that make membership worth it–worth mentioning in the whatever marketing you guys do.

@brewersbibliophile on Bluesky. Anyone wanna add me would be appreciated. I’ve enjoyed these chats.

Thanks everyone for being here with us.

I also have a suspicion that the labor stoppage won't be too long. The owners know that the MLBPA will never budge on a salary cap under any circumstances, so presumably they have something else they want to get out of negotiations.

Let's hope!

They will never budge on something every other major American professional league already has on? I am not so sure. Will be about making sure the players get their earned piece of the pie I think.

A union is going to generally be more unified than 30 different owners, many of whom don't have the stomach to lose that much money with a long strike.

They’ve seen how it works. You can’t unpop that cork. I’d bet those other unions are jealous of MLBPA. They know they’ve lost.

As a Brewer fan who's been frustrated by the economic disparity in baseball for years, I am quite fine with a WS win followed by a lockout.

Even if you’re not Christian I think the Jesus commercial is best. That or Sweeney. I mean basically the same ad.

Did I miss the ad where Jesus tries to get me to gamble on sports while wearing nothing but catcher gear?

Do his dads switch off weekends having a catch?

It's nice that the Brewers get to win the title in front of their fans.

Need a booth from All the Smoke (except N Swisher)

Cash's pitching decisions will be rightfully questioned (Seymour here???), but at some point your offense just has to score runs

Yeah this is mostly on TB’s bats. TB pitching held up pretty well outside of G3

Cash will be questioned, but the real story is, he ran into a buzz saw. It would take the ‘27 Yankees to stop a team like this.

Certainly the last two games have not been good.

I wouldn’t go that far but I don’t think there is any question which team has more talent here. The Rays are just outgunned.

And Peralta's blowup was extremely predictable, to the point that I said it would happen immediately after Game 2. It's too bad that I'm so philosophically committed to never betting on sports that even Sweeney couldn't convince me.

JD, now you're *really* jinxing it, unless my feed is 10 minutes behind

Though I do like the joke

Another good WS question would be who has won the MVP with the lowest cWPA for the series?Would presumably be like here, one without an easy winner.

Livan Hernandez sucked in the 1997 WS and I hate you for making me remember that.

One more half inning <3

Did the bottom of the 6th take longer than 7-8-9 combined if this ends quickly?

Feels like it!

Yes

My receipt says I have 10 beers in me. Do I have an 11th before the end of this inning??

Spotted Cow?

Guinness

this is very milwaukee

If you are capable of typing the question without grammatical mistakes or spelling errors then the answer is yes.

Get home safe

If my wife don’t answer, then I’ll be walking the half mile home 😅

I don't like commercials that feel like someone didn't want to just pay NBC for the rights to use Ron Swanson

Dammit! Beat me to the store-brand Nick Offerman joke!

If the Rays actually come back and win this they still have no rested pitchers for game 6. Cash really has not managed his staff well this series.

🍻

Two hits through eight innings after the extra innings last night is crazy. Can't say enough about Milwaukee's pitching staff.

Not a save situation, so I guess they don’t bring in Rollie Fingers. Maybe Dan Plesac.

John Axford!

I always like going against A's Rollie Fingers in MLB the Show because it looks like Luigi is on the mound against you

Harsh but fair.

Caminero has a plane to catch

Cancun is calling

The Mario Brother, not the murderer

The less cool Luigi

Sure, if we want to just erase Goomba lives like that

At what point do the Mets (or Phillies or Yankees) raid Milwaukee of it's front office?

Mets tried!

The Mets won't be able to figure that one out.

Mets bashing and it was not Biblio. Chat complete!

My last comment may not get approved, so *expletive* the Mets

I'm excited to see if Pat Murphy actually stops looking like he's annoyed during the celebration

I think he just has Resting Manager Face.

He's allowed to smile but ONLY if he looks like a proud father as he does so

Luckiest hit EVER

Wow.

This looks and sounds like a home crowd, my goodness

I’m not sure if I’ve ever met a Rays fan, and I went to watch a couple games at the Trop.

Jason Collette is a hardcore Rays fan.

The only Rays fan I know of is Dick Vitale.

Never met him

That reminds me to praise Hicks. I was skeptical about him being full-time catcher for a playoff team but his defense has been much better than I expected and his challenges have been nearly perfect as well.

Let’s just hypothesize that the Rays come back to win the Series after that. Best baseball story ever?

Don't think so–the story would be the collapse.

But that particular play would be more infamous than Buckner, right?

I want the Rays to threaten enough to get Ashby in the game

Shoulda bunted smh

Pitching out of the zone the right call here

It's not quite over yet…but it’s been a fun postseason. I’m really glad all of you chose to be here with us this October.

Hopefully this lockout is quick. We will have editorial coverage and some interesting payroll tools during the negotiations.

You all are why we are able to do what we do, and I know these chats have been something I’ve looked forward to. I’ve enjoyed getting to know a lot of you.

We are going to find more places to build community on FG.

Thank you, Sean!

FanGraphs makes baseball better

I’ll be signing up for one of the MVP things or whatever they’re called if games are missed. I love this site and don’t want to see it go anywhere.

So Simpson get's his first HR here?

Simpson HR, calling it.

Gotta hit it to bring Ashby in

There is hope!

I've got Simpson for MVP

Ok -if you're Murphy – do you bring in Ashby here? Megill's longest outing of the world series, and even a HR isn't enough yet.

Yes!!!

Serious question, what is going on with Megill's pants?

They’re losing the battle with the rest of Megill.

Megill is not the man

Megill has one more hitter either way, yes?

I think he’s in until it’s tied

I'd make a change

He's hoping for a pop up

Richie's gonna homer

Of course it ends with Turang fielding the ball

Condolences to the diehard Rays fans who genuinely do love their team, but this is the happiest I have been about a World Series win since 1983.

There we go.

WOO HOO MILWAUKEE

Congrats Milwaukee

Congrats Crew! Mostly happy for Vogey lol

Former cubs Minor league legend!

“You count on it, rely on it to buffer the passage of time, to keep the memory of sunshine and high skies alive, and then just when the days are all twilight, when you need it most, it stops.”

https://mason.gmu.edu/~rmatz/giamatti.html

BREW CREW *clap clap clap*

YAAAAAASSSSSSS

Thank you all and it better not be 18 months until the next game!

🍻Rounds of Spotted Cows all around!🍺

Ballgame

Man, I'm so sick of the Brewers.

Congrats Milwaukee

It's been over a decade since I lived in Madison, but I'll always have a soft spot for the Brew Crew. Enjoy it fans.

Finaafuckingly

Congrats to one of the sneakiest most dominant teams in MLB history.

Congratulations Brewers fans, you deserve this

That was a fun series, I wanted 2 more, but congrats MIL!

Man, i'm so not sick of the brewers

Good job August!

I enjoy Vogelbach following Murphy around in the hug line.

Congrats, Brewers!

Sorry to those who have tickets to Game 6 and 7!

Yo 🙁 I wasn’t gonna tempt fate by rooting for Game 6 though.

Every body drink you beers *drink drink drink drink drink drink drink drink drink drink drink drink drink*

I’m a 12 pack in

autocorrect must be doing good work for you

Somehow, Pat Murphy still manages to look serious. Not quite as angry as usual though.

They're reading a statement thanking Rays fans, but most of the people there are Brewers fans.

I have some sympathy. I spent too many games at Camden hearing Red Sox and Yankees fans.

NEW JERSEY MENTIONED!!

Camden Yards.

Darn. I had guessed as Camden NJ is way closer to New York than Camden Yards is, lol. I guess most people in that area are probably Phillies fans, though.

Thanks for everything, Fangraphs people. Not how I wanted it to end, but was a great season in these chats nonetheless.

FanGraphs is wonderful

I got the subscription recently and I'm so glad I did

Only good place on the internet! So much better than… We are all going dateless!

How does anyone NOT love baseball?

I’ve never felt more pedantic about baseball.

I love you FanGraphs. @brewersbibliophile on Bluesky. Find me. Ill

Miss yall

Thanks Fangraphs for making this happen. Best community in sports.

Thank you Fangraphs!

"Almost a home game for us"

we should do this more often

chat for every week of FA/lockout

Thank you, FanGraphs team! Keep it up and hopefully we get a 2027 season!

Thank you FanGraphs!!

Congratulations to the Brewers – a very well-deserved title. And thank you to FanGraphs! This Chicagoan and Cubs fan couldn’t be happier for Brewers fans. Cheers!

I said the same thing about Counsell as I’ll say about Murphy. They’ve gone as far as they’ll go under him. Time to fire the manager and find the next guy!

The power of friendship!!

It really is all about the friends we make along the way.

lol. I love the ******* bleeps. *** yeah. Let's ******* go!

Rosenthal doing his best Mean Gene to Megill's Andre here

Merry Christmas to all and to all a good night! I'm out.

The unsung heroes of this post-season has been the Brewers fans who came in droves to Florida to bring their team the World Series Championship. 3 cheers to all the fans!

I still can't believe the crowd.

I was texting friends and we were talking about what do you do if you are the Rays to make the atmosphere better for you.

Move to a state that's not full of transplant octagenarians

Adios, friends!! See ya on the other side. Thanks for a great month

Well that was something. Congrats to the Brewers and their front office. Amazing accomplishment

I had the volume down, can someone tell me whether the crowd booed Manfred?

Congrats Brewers,, well deserved

Goodnight yall! See ya next year.

They brought the Brewers fans on the field? That's cool!

I think that’s just the brewers employees. They flew 400 of them to the game. Took 3-4 planes.

Chatting with yall has been a highlight of my year!

“We’ll recognize the team in a minute, let’s talk to the head of HR! Get up here!”

A guy who should, but maybe doesn’t, realize nobody cares what he has to say.

And I work in HR so I can say that

you work in… home runs…?

Lolol I wish. Human Resources.

In how many parks would you work in HR though? For the rest of your career, how much xHR do you project?

Yay!!!!!!

Bill trying to give away the hardware to Ashby, gotta love it.

Class move by Contreras calling Ashby up to the podium.

It was, guy is so emotional right now. Wonderful to see

Imagine what it must feel like for a player like Contreras, to work your entire life at the sport and then not only to win your team’s first championship, but to be named MVP of the series.

How wild is it to even be where he is right now. He was a random throw in for a much larger trade.

Early reports says Zips has brewers at 79 wins next year, 4th place finish. /s

thats not bad for an 80 game season

Any podcasts or alternative post game shows out there?

I don’t get to see my nephew very often, but him texting me throughout these playoffs has been a highlight of my life.

Alright, I'm going to close this down. Once again, thanks everyone for a good season.


Members-Only Game Thread: World Series – Oct 27, 2026

Welcome to our Open Game Thread for the World Series game today. Only Members can participate, and unlike our usual staff Q&A chats, your messages will be posted immediately.

Our Member community is made up of thousands of incredibly knowledgable baseball fans, and we think this is a great way to follow a game with like-minded baseball enthusiasts. We might even have some FanGraphs Staff drop in and join the fun. Please be courteous to your fellow Members, or you may find your chat privileges revoked.

Baby’s posting from the mobile app! Go Sean+team

^^ Thank you for these all month, Sean.

Appreciate this.

Watching with my littles (4 & 7), and we'll see how long they make it tonight.

I am already falling asleep so good luck to them.

Poll is quite certain about a sweep, so far.

Yeah, I feel like we need to make that stock/investment advice…past performance doesn’t guarantee future results

Dustin May is gonna pitch 9 shutout innings

Dustin May is going for his fourth ring, which would tie him with Betts for most among active players. Dustin May!

He’ll _have_ those rings but did he really _earn_ those rings like Betts did…

Honestly kind of unfair to May, the man tore his larynx for god’s sake. (not sure how that applies vis-a-vis rings)

May's ring last year is particularly suspect since he wasn't on the Dodgers when they actually won it

Won't be able to watch this one, but I wanted to thank Sean and co for these chats – they've been an excellent companion for the post season.

Thanks for stopping by!

I second tdmoc’s message, thanks for all the hard work on the revised chat, it’s been great!

Sean, has Fangraphs ever considered having a masthead somewhere? It's only from these chats that I've realized just how much you do, which is truly incredible–I hope you have a properly august title. And there was a very funny moment on EW when Lindbergh didn't realize that Meg had been promoted. How was anyone to know?

We always talk about a masthead, then just don’t make one. Honestly, we’d forget to update it. lol, probably.

People should read the Wikipedia article about FG. It’s really stuck in the past.

Meg got promoted?

You knew this!

Wait when was Meg promoted?

Yeah to Editor in Chief back in Dec 2024. Or around then.

Oh I knew that. I thought maybe she was moved up to “Publisher” or “God-Queen of Greater Fangraphia”

Selfishly hoping it ends tonight because I won't be able to see the remaining games live

I feel like throwing May is a "Well if we win that would be great, But we will win at home anyways" move

I imagine he goes 2, maybe 3 innings tops. But that is needed, they can’t really run out 9 different guys to pitch one inning each.

Get the series wrap ups written, today’s game is just a formality.

I think the Rays definitely have an avenue to win tonight. In particular, they're much more likely to throw their A bullpen arms. And Jax > May. Tomorrow would be much harder but today is quite winnable in my eyes.

Another early challenge today!

Way to show Contreras he's not the only guy who can challenge on the corner.

This game is over! 😫

I only realized from your previous comment that it had started. Still haven't successfully logged on. . .

That throw was not close.

What is the consensus view on the longest possible odds for a legit WS team against another. Lets assume like best player gets hurt, worst starter available is starting, bullpen was used into oblivion last night, its a 4 PM game, facing a team that won 110+ with 1999-2000 Pedro starting… 75/25? 90/10? its not worse than 90-10… Right?

I guess what I'm trying to ask is, what the longest odds ever offered were for a single game?

Jax is nibbling too much. His stuff is good enough to just aim down the middle

At this point just watching to see if (a) the Rays can get one, and (b) Pat Murphy will get Drohan and Harrison in so the whole roster's played.

I don't understand why the broadcast always thinks Martinez is a big part of the pitching plan yesterday and today. Isn't he the expected starter tomorrow? You need to win all the games, you can't just go all out with all your starters tonight.

I think this is from Verducci's pregame interview with Cash? but it doesn't make much sense, and also just sounds too specific, so I suspect he's lying.

Other than the joy of not hearing Smoltz's voice for a long time, why are 60% in favor of the series ending early going into a lockout?

Brewers fans?

60% seems like a lot of Brewers fans, but I guess so.

smaller percentage than those in tampa bay

Brewer fans make up over 60% of fans in the Trop alone

After this we should rewatch the previous World Series together in reverse order 🙂

Robert “literally Sandy Koufax” Gasser

Kornheiser made that comparison on PTI today and I think Pablo's eyes rolled into his head in both shame and shock.

Robert “The Pinky Finger On the Hand of the Left Arm of God” Gasser

Wait until Chandler “literally Rickey Henderson” Simpson

dustin may looks like that kid who wipes ice cream on his forehead to cool down

lol Contreras

He's been doing that all postseason, I do wonder if it does lead to more strike calls

I strongly believe that this sort of psychology will work. People are influenced by perception way more than they want to believe.

The fact that framing has gotten less subtle but still works has an interesting relation to this phenomenon. Even if umpires see someone the catcher is trying to make a pitch look like a strike they are still willing to believe it is one.

Almost feels like James Harden doing crazy s**t and forcing the refs to call him out on it. Would drive me up a wall if I were competing against him but as a spectator I respect the hustle.

I love the Billy Bob Thornton commercial where he just randomly starts talking to the young woman

And no one else is allowed to say a thing.

And I love/hate liberty bibberty

With respect to the idea that people are allowed to enjoy whatever they like, what unholy reason can there be to love bibberty?

I hate/hate liberty bibberty

I didn’t say I was proud of it.

i watch the games on mute, partially because of the announcers, partially to avoid liberty bibberty

Wait I just figured it out. The announcers aren’t announcing for us, they’re announcing for people that have never watched baseball. Or any sport. Or TV.

Jeez, why are we all hating on the horrifying giant mangy tennis ball with human teeth?!?

Hey everybody!

The Rays should sell tickets to watch from the catwalks

How would fan interference work on the A/B/C ring?

thats exactly what the Phantom of Baseball wants them to do

You catch a ball, you get signed to a contract.

Only one way to find out!

If you catch it your team gets a run

If you drop it, you get ejector seated into a surprise bungee jump

If that's an intentional American Dad reference, chef's kiss

The way Simpson moves is strongly reminiscent of Hunter Pence to me.

Yes! 100% co-sign.

Sorta like an athletic alien inhabiting a human body for the first time?

Somebody oughta check on him and see if he has a fused vertebrae like Pence

Oh my God, the Rays are selling tomahawk steaks?

Rarely

Feels like it should have been an ATL thing….

This confused everyone I’m watching with.

Guess in ATL it would have to be a Tomahawk chop?

wheres the thumbs down emoji?? need it for the dad jokes

maybe a job for the thinking emoji

As a Cardinal fan who watched 90% of May’s starts in the first half – my man, what have you done to your beard lol? This guys confidence must be through the roof to rock that.

Yet another use for the thumbs down.

He's sporting the Randy Dobnak

I get the hint.

Can't believe Simpson didn't end up on third on that play.

I tbought he was!

this chandler simpson guy should be higher in the batting order

Looks like the Rays aren’t impressed

A Chandler Simpson extra base hit! Somebody bat this guy 3rd

What was Turang doing there?

Rays absolutely need 1 one run this inning

I have a good feeling

I have zero confidence this lead will last more than an inning

Ugly K.

Which pitcher over 6'5" throws from the lowest arm angle? Sale?

Tyler Rogers is 6'3", so yes

Today I learned the Rogers brothers are only 6'3".

I also immediately looked up Tyler Rogers height

Do we know what Randy J's was?

Randy was much more over-the-top than Sale

Man, do I hate this AI slop Fox seems to love.

Hi everyone, nice to see the Rays lead after two innings

Jiffin Grax sounds like the name of the protagonist of the worst Star Wars fanfic ever written

Get ready for Dax Kilby.

Terrin Vavra, anyone?

I am irrationally upset by the name Tai Peete

i hope fox used millions on tokens to make the stupidest thing i could imagine

Libberty Bibberty?

Bryan's still got it.

This is getting crazy

I feel like Bauers has had a couple of those? Need to work out more?

Just missing the barrel I’d guess

I'm pretty confused about Jax still being around after that Chourio hit.

I suspect Cash wants to get him through the 3rd inning before turning over to the bullpen with possibly another game tomorrow

The walks he's issued don't inspire confidence after a man is already on.

That changeup from Jax is filthy

Jax looks like the evil Nazi in the next Indiana Jones movie

So wait, then who will play the good Nazi or the morally ambiguous Nazi?

While the Jax family has been established in the United States for generations, their lineage blends ancestral roots from the German Rhineland and the British Isles

Stealing on 1-2? Is that normal?

Not convinced that was a swing

It clearly crossed the 45-degree angle if you regress ball spin on arm angle and adjust for humidity

Most people forget the humidity adjustment!

Oh MAN

Not going to show replay on that check swing ?

theyre too busy writing the prompt for AI to make a 2 second interstitial with pat murphy surrounded by vampires

Yeah, not been a huge fan of the swing judgements this series.

Wow, got to give Jax credit for getting through that after the walky inning.

Yandy mixing up the eye black tonight.

You know athletes are creatures of habit if they wear eye black in a dome at night

The also switched the uni's

They are back to wearing their Sam Fuld tribute jerseys

Yandy's eyeblack is growing

It's so funny and depressing to imagine some Fox intern pushing 5 data centers in Utah to the max so they can make a graphic about ABS challenges with William Contreras as Gandalf or whatever

honestly, thats more imaginative than you give them credit, hed just be a wizard in a stupid cartoon purple "moons and stars" gown like hes a cereal character

2 replays of a foul ball zero on the check swing

See, clearly it was no big deal then! Nothing to worry about!

I’m not SUPER impressed with either pitcher. He says while eating chocolate on the couch.

my arm hurts when i throw a baseball now: a story of the internet's harshest pitching critic

The way things are trending, I'm going to have to buy Halloween candy for a 3rd time.

They say chocolate cures cancer

My arm makes accordion noises when I throw.

Did Kalshi just tell me that I should rely on gambling to predict the weather? Is this a soft launch of the new NOAA?

liberty bibberty is now the secretary of education

Contreras under eye slowly moving to mouth

Rays watched some highlight reels!

DeLuca is having a really nice night out there

What a catch

man one of these hart hit balls is gonna find grass at some point, right

Nice to see the Rays remember they're good at defense

Brewers need to stop hitting rockets and start hitting more Texas leaguers

Rays secret weapon tonight – pitching to hard contact.

Huge, high risk catch. Jump looked a little confused on reply, but great catch. Eyes tracking it was good replay.

To think, there's an alternate universe out there with Paul DeLuca and Jonny Lo Duca instead of the other way around

And so it begins.

Fable reference?

Nope, just trying to sound portentous.

Brewers see two outs as an insult

And here. we. go.

Frelick was sick of watching Rays make nice catches against him.

Team of destiny

I like that the patch on the left arm of Jax looks like it just says Rays WET from the camera angle.

there we go. finally not catchable balls

GREAT slide view

im on a little bit of a delay, but why was the broadcast showing the back of a sign

It glitched

Tampa's falling apart again.

There's no destruction like self-destruction.

the rays have not hit a ball harder then 90mph. the brewers have hit 8

That's a great challenge buy Hicks, whose made plenty of questionable ones this series

I can't believe Jax is still in

I think he'll be out next inning

Gutsy, gutsy outing by Jax so far

OK so now Cash has told us to look out for Nick Martinez. Rasmussen on 3 days' rest tomorrow?

This completely blows my mind. Maybe tomorrow is Seymour?

Matz??

I think they'll be happy to figure that issue out if they can actually get to tomorrow

Or maybe Martinez is Yamamoto-ing from here on out

I told you all that Cash was jealous of Vogt's MOTY awards.

I know we talked about postseason game logs yesterday and how we didn't really have them on player pages. That's no longer the case: https://www.fangraphs.com/players/jackson-chourio/28806/game…

Incredible.

Thanks for that Sean! Glad I asked you about it.

Thank you!!

Wow

Was he out of the baseline

What on earth was that

oy yoy yoy

Had to be out of the baseline

What constitutes the baseline there? It's judgement right?

i think baselines are fake and runners should be able to go anywhere they want

I watched that Josh Harrison play in 2014. I stopped believing in baselines that day.

I think he stayed in the baseline, but that is not reviewablle

I'm not sure what you can review there.

Not a throw Hamilton probably should've made but I'd have liked to see Bauers come off 1B to keep that from getting away.

Baffling turn of events. I think he was out of the baseline, but challenging the tag is bizarre when the baseline element isn't challengeable

i knew chandler wasnt gonna be doubled off, but its hilarious for the camera to pan over and me to hold my breath seeing how close it is, only for chandler to be in RF already

simpson, chandler simpson
he's the greatest guy in history
from the
town of springfield
he's about to hit a chestnut tree

I need that Simpson Simpsons t-shirt in a medium post haste.

I heard something about 3 feet from where the tag is attempted but that seems super arbitrary… anyone know the actual rule?

So…it seems like I might have cursed Chandler Simpson.

Now there's a baseline.

baselines. are. fake.

That's just really, really bad with RH power at the plate vs. Romero.

Why is the baseline rule non-reviewable? My contention is that most non-reviewable plays should be reviewable.

Everything becomes more litigious. NFL tried that with pass interference and stopped that real quick.

I guess Cash/Jax are going for the complete game tonight.

Hamilton!

Before I could even type "Jax is still in there?"

These Brewers man.

Uh, well, that's making amends for the defensive misplay.

Sort of a reverse conservation of greatness for us ultimate nerds.

Greetings fellow scientific ultimate nerd. Stealing when winning by too much is a spirit foul

This is a good game.

can we put links in here? friend sent me the Chandler Simpson T-shirt link

Yeah, I just approve the links.

That is Not What You Want on an 0-2

I don't love second guessing people with inside info, but why Jax again?

Really not even a bad pitch. Just went up and got it

All because of the threat of the bunt.

David Hamilton, he of the .091 ISO…

Destiny is weird

Is Hamilton the new Enrique Hernandez? He's not just a different hitter in the postseason, he's a different category of hitter.

Maybe he's Daniel Murphy-ing

This IS a good game.

Two outs so this is where they make thirteen runs

Or not

Meg and Craig need to do something about the lack of Dog Park ads in the World Series

I’ve seen several new ads today. I’m unreasonably pleased.

I got a new one, but it is for a movie remaking a story from 200+ years ago that has been made 250000000 times

Same

Hollywood doesn’t read new books

Chandler Simpson shirt appears to be a Jomboy product. https://shop.jomboymedia.com/products/chandler-simpson

Martinez warming.

So if they win and keep winning, Rasmussen on short rest tomorrow, Martinez game 6, Peralta game 7?

Rasmussen and pray for…well rain wouldn't work

Is it bad form to point out that really really hard rain did work to stop baseball in the Trop?

They seem very reluctant to use Rasmussen on even regular rest so I'd be shocked to see them use him on short rest

Dodgers ran Ohtani on short rest last October in a do-or-die. It…didn't work for those few innings but they were willing to try

Well, yeah, but I'm confused by the plan all around.

Love Uribe when he’s on

F cancer

Antonym of Murderer's Row is 'Mesa Jr., Palacios, Walls'.

Jaywalker's Row

"There's no game 5 without winning game 4" is true sure but the goal is to win the World Series, not avoid a sweep. I disagree strongly with this move

Rays pulling out all the stops

Using Martinez before Baker here feels indefensible

Got to keep him for the save /sarc

I love when a team gets desperate with the pitching during the WS.

Only when its not the team I am supporting.

What a lot of people don’t know about Nick Martinez is he has the jimmy legs.

Restless leg syndrome

Now I want the Rays to win just to see what Cash will do tomorrow.

Maybe Murphy will get Misiorowski up now

This is my whole reason for supporting Tampa tonight… I want one more Miz start!

I’m getting word Cade Smith is warming in the bullpen

The Rays honestly could use a Grant Taylor to pitch the rest of the game

Its not 10-0… I am confused….

Louis Varland is up too

2 out base hit. Water is wet. Etc.

They can’t even keep Martinez in the frame for a close up shot.

Wow

How did Simpson field that

Who are the rookies in this game? Chourio, Pratt, …?

Chourio is a 3 year mlb veteran

Uhh I mean NOT Chourio

Who is excited for the Highlander remake?

Maybe?

Is a French guy playing a Scottish guy and a Scottish guy playing a Spanish guy?

Cavill is Macleod. Crowe is the spanish guy. So not quite.

Currently in the game, or on the roster? Lara is a rookie.

I think Mesa qualifies as a rookie too

Henderson

If the same team had Grant Taylor, Louis Varland and Cade Smith, would they be able to go with a 4 man rotation?

Jeeeeeeeeeeeeeez

Ooooof.

woah

This defense is so so good. I love great offense, but something about absurd defense wins out

Every margin play it feels like

That's some destiny right there

Oof, that's so deflating.

Oof.

The Rays have to stop hitting it so hard.

John “soft contact wins” Smoltz is completely vindicated!

OK, John Smoltz

Nothing he could do about that

That was beautiful

Wow!

Bruuuuuutal bad BABIP luck

Ouch. Don't even want to see the exit velo.

108.1 mph off the bat with a .890 xBA. So of course it's a double play.

i am remembering that gidp that stanton hit directly at bobby witt jr that he just had to laugh at

Dammit, did I miss the ultimate frisbee nerdery?

shoot did i miss it too!?

I am still here for it. I forget who I was responding to, but there are dozens of us! Dozens!

a salty scientist it was!

god i miss frisbee. i am so bad at it

I've never played anything more welcoming of new or bad players. Love the general attitude of it being for everyone. You somewhere with a pickup group?

@solitaire Denver. Yeah, the cult of frisbee has to be pretty welcoming 🙂

Maybe stop hitting it toward Turang. . .

Would TB have been more successful if they had an actual home field advantage vs such a high amount of away fans? Like give then a Philly environment

Most guys with crazy batspeed look like they swing really hard or are enormous… Jr is neither of these things

Ashby gets the 7th+, right?

After 2 days off Ashby will pitch innings 7-12

Effectively makes the game feel over

Is it too late for Ashby as Cy Young?

He had it wrapped up by the All Star Break

I mean yeah, he’s probably not going to get to 500 career wins.

My local bar prioritized local regular season nba and nhl over the WS on the TV’s tonight 🫠

What’s your market?

Boston

That's very Boston.

I guess I sorta get it. There’s probably more interest for those teams. In surprised they don’t have enough TVs for all three though.

I was going to guess Toronto. Passionate NHL and NBA market who can't possibly feel like watching the away team hoist the commissioner's trophy in a Domed ballpark.

In Boston, the baseball season ended September 30th. There's a rumor there are still some games someplace but Bostonians know better.

Yeah, cheaped out on just two boxes

That is also very Boston.

won't someone think of the David Hamilton superfans??

You’d better believe a few are still doing the Keno though (also very Boston / here’s your sign)

Why are Joe Davis and people here saying there's nothing Yandy Diaz could do on that line drive? Taught forever to just freeze on a line drive until you know it's through. He should not have take 2 steps on that liner. It was a good catch, not an unbelievable catch.

How long do they ride Martinez here? Until he gives up a baserunner?

Now that you've burned him you gotta get everything you can, right? You're gonna need a fresh bullpen if there's a tomorrow

He's got the changeup working and the Rays might take a while to score a run, I think as long as his stuff looks good Martinez is going to get to work for a while

Makes sense. Obviously you gotta win this game but even if you do there are three more to win.

I think I’d struggle to hit Martinez’s change- up.

i'd struggle to hit a padded wall

That could have been scary

My wife's analysis of Martinez is he has to pee and thats where his set up dance comes from

Whatever he’s taking for restless leg syndrome, it’s not working.

Raffel Betancourt used to do this too at a much much slower tempo… I have always wondered how he would have delt with the pitchclock … Now I know

similar to cl*vinger

Very sure he never existed.

you know what you're right.

Is Palacios getting the yips?

Palacios with the 30-grade throw

It's that time: what's everyone's favorite stretch?

I love a good calf stretch

Pigeon or happy baby

I particularly enjoy a good stretch after a fulfilling meal.

piriformis-involved stretches

Willie McCovey

corpse pose

Different kind of stretch, but partial to the Thera-cane over the traps and shoulders

Anything but sweet Caroline

standing up and stretching and going "uuuaaawwwwwhhhh"

waking up in the morning scrunched into a small pellet of human and having to extend every joint i have and scream along with the cacophony of creaking and crackling and the searing pain

i am a relatively long human who contracts very heavily in their sleep

I am imagining the inverse of those dinosaur-sponge-in-a-capsule toys

Why does Joe Davis think people want him to spoil the challenges?

AGAIN!

Nick Martinez vs Jacob Wilson is a matchup I'd watch

That would be a great super cut

Kevin Gausman has faced Jacob Wilson. I don't know how to get the video but I bet it's entertaining

Channeling that Shaq / cat meme

Watching a guy like Martinez battle is damn fun to watch.

Turang, human vacuum at the keystone.

very surprised Hall not Ashby

Ashby for the boppers

The last 3 batters have made 4 Turang-induced outs

Oh hey Baker is on the roster

I like using Baker for the heart of the order in the 8th, assuming he can't go more

Rays failing the Turang Test.

This wins on so many levels with the FG crowd

That's 5 Turang-induced outs in 4 batters

See what happens when you don't hit it to Turang?

The MLB record for the most consecutive outs credited to a single defensive position player in a game belongs to Jerry Grote, who recorded 10 consecutive putouts on April 22, 1970

This probably had to do with strikeouts, right? Grote being a catcher

That's all Tom Seaver

What about non-catchers?

Man… Mesa Jr could've used a big hit there in a bad way.

On June 25, 1937, right fielder Ben Chapman set the MLB outfielder record by recording 7 consecutive putouts in a row.

I see Google Gemini got it right the second time. 😉

correct. Just fun. Not claiming any credit or doing any looking beyond a casual search.

Ok, now what about non-racists?

As I pointed out yesterday, the "team of destiny" screenplay requires Yelich to hit a home run. This is the at bat. I acknowledge that he has not inspired confidence that he can hit the ball out of the infield this series, singles and walks not withstanding. Just putting this here so I get some credit if it happens.

Chapman was one of Jackie Robinson’s worst antagonists, no?

i do not know how much we have advanced in the past 50 years such that we can pick a fielder who has made many consecutive putouts (not interrupted by balls in play, no outs?) who is definitively Not Racist. but that could also be my biases

I guess someone needs to ask Turang some tough questions 😆.

Oh, well.

Kinda love the use of Baker here.

Yeah, and getting three outs on so few pitches is huge.

Huh, Baker pretty helpful after all

It makes sense to go down swinging with your best arms, and Tampa doesn't have the Brewers murderer row (ie, Ashby + Megill)

if a one-inning arm has a very short inning, at what point do you go to him for another inning? 8 pitches? 5? 3?

@milville, MIN and NYY flairs must've given you some strange emotions the last couple decades

i'm still looking for funny combos of letters moreso than teams, and have barely been alive for multiple decades. however this is very funny and true, and didi gregorius may be my eternal enemy?

What are you doing hanging out here at the old folks’ home??

Your description of waking up made me assume you were over 40

i have joint/soft tissue problems

millville's flairs aren't about teams

Who is next in for TB? Wells? Cleavinger? I assume not Booser

Is Brice Turang tall Kinsler? The offensively potent IKF? Vanilla Jazz?

say what you will about ikf's bat but he's a heckuva pitcher

Nah, Vanilla Jazz is like Pat Metheny.

+2, w metheny ref

I also stand corrected : Turang and Kinsler both listed at 6’0”

how can a guy named Didi be an eternal enemy?

Isnt it SIR Didi?

a Rays batter challenging? Now I've seen everything

Ump wanted to see what would happen

Turang is alt universe Brandon Crawford: better hitting, slightly weaker defense

This is giving Brandon Crawford too much credit (ignore my flair; I promise I'm not biased, totally not)

Why does the ad about new college students not knowing how to do laundry feature a guy who appears to be in his mid 30s?

I think he's in all the ads this year.

I cannot get on board with advertising cinematic universes

Bring back Lily

drafted out of southern california

well he's clearly not max muncy

Not *a* Max Muncy.

He's the thing, there are other forms of Max you can be

Maxmaxxing?

Hello Dan!

Kinsler may have been embellishing though, how many guys' listed heights changed with the beginning of ABS this year

Game 3 of the 2004 ALCS was a blowout and then game 4 was an extra innings game. Just saying, maybe?

neither of the maxes muncy are comparable to turang

Should be that you have no duplicate names. Already a Max Muncy in the majors? Fine, you can be Maxwell Muncy or Maximillian Muncy or Max Power Muncy.

sag/aftra rules?

This would be hard to enforce for the Luises Garcia

Or Max Munchy

How would we deal with the Luises Garcia? or is it Luis Garcias

Hahaha lzfreak, same thought

someone breaks the mold to be luiz garcia

This is particularly a problem for the Yuniors Marte, neither of whom has a middle initial!

I once had a fantasy transaction where I picked up Luis Garcia and dropped Luis Garcia

There was once a Luiz Gohara

i think the real answer is we'd see a lot more matronyms

I like how we just settled on one being “sea bass” and the other 2+ duking it out for relevancy with the Alex Gonzalez bunch

Hey I remember him

Need a poll! How many innings does this game go?

done

I decided I should be fashionably late so that the game doesn't go long enough for you all to tire of me.

This is a somewhat better game than last night.

Hi Dan!

like michael b. jordan

Minor quibble, but he should have gone with Michael Jordan (b).

Davy, I had a dream that you and Ben had a podcast called Bendavy and say "Ahh"

We'll get right on that.

Wait did Yandy fix the eye black?

Omg if I see one more HP commercial I’m going to…not buy one.

Dude you’re not getting a HP

Are ad breaks longer in the World Series? The mid inning reliever switches make it feel like watching a compilation of ads with a few moments of baseball in between

They're half a minute longer than the regular season!

That'll help interest!

2:15 for regular games, 3:10 for WS games. Nationally broadcast games during the season are 2:40.

The extra time really adds up.

Someone should do a tic-tac-toe eye black and if the pitcher gets you out, they get to put the O and if you reach base, you get to put an X.

Oh man, I hate ridiculous eye black, but I love this.

i do actually think keeping score on your face could be fun

Eyeblack hangman – they strike you out they get to guess K. You fly out, an F is guessed, etc. Object is to stay alive for the game. Good luck if you GIDP.

no Yandy still had his design

I love that the poll goes from 9 to 35

Oh, and hi Davy too!

If the game goes 35 innings I'll hate the Nick Martinez relief appearance for a completely different reason

booo hiss thumbsdown thumbsdown

Sean cracked a dad joke so bad even he couldn't handle it

Instead of longer ad breaks, have they considered selling in-game sponsorship? "This at bat is sponsored by L'Oreal, because you're worth it"

stay the HELL away from brandon marsh l'oreal. you dont want to know what's in there.

What if MLB and Project Runway switched corporate sponsors

Er, they’ve pretty much already done that. In addition to the longer ad breaks…as was inevitable.

The playoff bracket itself is sponsored: https://www.mlb.com/postseason

How long until Blue Chew gets involved? "Blue chew, get some wood on it"

Seemed like a good idea until Cialis decided to sponsor a Junk-Mastrobuoni at bat.

I’m working from home tomorrow with no scheduled meetings or calls. I’m in for whatever.

we're not talking enough about how the Brewers' custom protective cups have affected this series

This is an effectively wild topic if I've ever heard one

do you think jazz would have done better this season if he'd had one of those

OMG

"This Cal Raleigh appearance is brought to you by Cologuard."

Mitchell shoulda hit that one out of the park

No, he should have made soft contact!

The defense again – just wow. No words (obviously not as good as Simpson's catch yday)

I mean all he did was catch it

Hitting a homer is the optimal strategy

Homers kill rallies, Dan /sarcasm

Wow

Brewers just don’t have the strength

Dan, would you have the capability, if you wanted to, to build a live version of Zips? Basically, likelihood for each team to score in an inning assuming no pinch-hitters (which in extra innings would also give you the likelihood for the game to be extended)? I'm not suggesting you should do this, just wondering about the feasibility. . .

Gotta get Yelich back up tonight so he can hit the scripted homer, so whatever that takes.

David actually has the bits and pieces from the ZiPS matchup tool that he could put it together

Fascinating.

Could individual players get their bats sponsored? Like could Jake Burger have a McDonalds logo on his bat?

I'm not internetty smart enough to do it myself

My GOAT gonna give the brewers the win here

Man so many pitches taken right down the middle

it's good strategy to take down the middle, nod knowingly and purse your lips

I'm torn in that I'm kinda rooting for the Brewers, but only when we get to 7 games. I take more baseball over either team winning

Really hard to imagine a situation where I'd root for a sweep.

I'm for Brewers in either 4 or 5, because I have a conference starting Thursday.

out

Ugh another too close to call

You gotta challenge this, but I don't know if there's enough to overturn it

I thought that was out as it happened.

He's certainly out, but might not be enough on replay

Sure looks like he got the oven mitt

Palacios pulling his glove away from the hand to try and tag the body is crazy to watch in slomo

I'm not sure there's enough there

Um, why is it taking this long.

Trying to avoid a "stand"

Looks like stands to me

Reasons

It looks clearly out to me, but my eyesight isn’t great 😆.

I think he missed him by like 1/4 inch.

Davis and Smoltz disagree!

I don’t think there’s enough to overturn

unrelated but i bake so much bread and yet i own zero oven mitts. these baseball players and their handwear upset me greatly

See, my inclination is to root for John Smoltz being sad

We need them to zoom in.

even enhance a little bit

Wow!

Wrong call

Wait, why don't you use oven mitts? Oven mitts are great.

because i don't have them! the store is so far away, and i don't want to give jeff money over something so trivial. i just use a kitchen towel

Who chooses the bumper music?

I haven't seen anything convincing. But 🤷‍♂️

Was not expecting that.

NY paid off

Oh wow

Score one for my aging eyes! 🥂

Lmao Smoltz thought he had the definitive safe angle

I think he very well may have: all the wrong motivations to call him out / try to extend the series on mlb’s end?

Quite literally a perfect throw by Hicks.

We will at least get one more inning of baseball this year

He was clearly out of the basepath

I hate that this game has gotten to the point that we stop and take five minutes to see if a ball was .0007 inches away

Even more than ENHANCE scenes in TV murder shows where they create higher resolution out of nowhere, it always bugs me that they're not starting with a good shot in the first place. "OK, let's start with the suspect's license plate from 300 feet away shot."

We need Dana Scully to tell them that the resolution is too poor and it won't help much to enhance it.

i watched "the conversation" for class and got to see "zoom, enhance" but for audio. you're a literal sound designer. you work with tape. you should know better.

Catchers seem to be throwing way more toward the first base side these days for exactly this reason.

That's just about the first break that hasn't gone the Brewers' way

I feel like they weren’t lucky early in the game too

This would be a good moment for Max Scherzer to go to the mound and we can find out if anyone's brave enough to get him off of it

Even tho I’m for the Brews I hope the Rays walk it off

Chandler Simpson walk-off.

inside the park, please

Walk-off bunt.

With Simpson it should be called a "run-off"

Visions of Scott Podsednik

i'm rooting for him hitting it through the roof of the trop ohtani/tokyo dome style

"Now pitching for both teams…Max Scherzer, apparently."

FIFA this past summer really ruined my opinion of replay's use in sports. Like something like this overturn, he *probably* gazed the oven mitt, but I didn't see anything definitive. I'd rather go with the call in the moment than overturn and find things wrong that aren't called in the moment and aren't obviously wrong.

The dehumanization of baseball

The problem is that the rule's preference for keeping the call on the field – you need a high level of certainty to overturn – is not honored. But getting rid of it altogether will bring immediate and obvious regrets. You can't pretend video isn't there when it is.

Megill throwing only five pitches in a game that could go to extras. Hmmm

I think this is fine since his team is up 3-0

Abby has 13 innings in him

fair, Megill's well positioned for tomorrow. Maybe he can start for the Rays

There will come a time, I think in the fairly near future, when no one remembers either Harry Belafonte or the original Beetlejuice. Will Day-O finally be put to rest at that point?

Just think how long WWRY hung around and the staying power of 7NA… as im told "a good song never dies"

Seven Nation Army is an actual good song though.

Wow, gotta challenge that

I'll admit, I want a Caminero walkoff and a "we will see you tomorrow night" call

Dude, someone needs to tell Joe Davis that he is ruining the whole challenge system.

The whole point is that it's fun to see the little graphic.

He's also the ruining the whole "good play-by-play" thing

We got a mean of 13.6 innings for the game. Median 11 inning. A couple jokesters chose 35 innings.

i choose to believe that it lasts through any potential lockout until spring training

asf123, you'd take away the only calypso song that everyone knows?

If they played the whole song, that would be fine!

I like the song clip enforcement song. "You can do Walking in Sunshine, but you have to reserve a buttload of time and play the ENTIRE firetrucking song"

Yeah, I watched a little of the Rays’ clinching postgame, and I was thinking “Wait, are they *still* playing ‘Walking on Sunshine’ on a constant loop?”

I understand this is not timely and everyone is tired of talking about it, but I'm caring for a newborn and this is my free moment: what was the final split on the 'Did Yandy swing?' poll? Thanks for doing these game threads, it's been fun dropping in when I can!

I have that!

I feel like it was pretty even

I don't know the answer to your question but congrats!

55/45 yes

I feel like the yeses came in later, and the no was more instant.

I'm calling it first: day-o will outlast Oh Yeah

Tell you what, you can keep anything else if ”Everybody clap your hands” is forever eliminated. Deal?

👏👏👏👏👏

Why is it so hard to throw to first?

35 innings! 35 innings!

Caminero looks very not 100%.

18 innings and Yusmeiro Petit gets the W

Extras! I love postseason extra innings!

Here we go.

extree, extree!

cant wait for the HR derby to resolve this

I have plans tomorrow, friday, and saturday, so i hope this ends tonight!

76 in the chat. It was 40-something 30 minutes ago.

Welcome, everyone!

I wonder how many we'd get if this was Game 7 of LAD-TOR.

I think I was pacing my living room for that one and wouldn't be able to look at a computer

I am fully onboard with the abolition of the Manfred Man as a sticking point in negotiations… just call it a draw in the regular season.

Simpson getting his first ever barrel and walking it off would be the funniest thing ever.

I don't mind if there are more games, but I'm eventually going to have to go to the bathroom, and for a Kindle amount of time

There should be a break for this around the 14th inning

Simpson inside-the-park home run after he's tagged at third and he splits in half because he's two tiny Chandler Simpsonlettes inside a Chandler Simpson homonculus, and one of them scores

Brewers win 2.5 to 2?

this explains his gait (it does not at all)

no clue why Ortiz didn't challenge the 0-1 pitch (felt way outside)

i think after 18 innings they should allow reentry of substituted players. at 27, the roster expands to the 10 closest fans behind the dugout. at 45, the game ends. at 72, the game restarts from a save state. at 90, the cba is forcibly overwritten

This seems reasonable

So we'd see Front Row Amy and Marlins Man bat?

and after 91 you just flip a coin

roll in Bud Selig to do the shrug emoji like in that All-star game

I think after 13 innings everybody just gets to nap on the field for 25 minutes.

The home team is required to provide blankets.

Every time Aranda moves to make a play I mentally assume there will be no outs recorded

After 13 innings, a win should count as 2 games

millvillemeltdown, how about after 18 innings, plays who retired and last played with the teams may re-enter the game.

Or maybe after 18 innings BOTH teams lose. The series goes back to 2 to negative one

This

baumann from game 9 of the world series: please let me go home

I think after 12 innings they need to remove 1 defender each inning until it is just pitcher and catcher.

After ten innings each team gets to pick a player from the team they defeated during the post

Give Smoltz the 19th…for both teams

Two immaculate innings, naturally

The team with more small ball gets Smoltz. The other team gets Davis

Every time I see Chourio I am sad that I am not listening to Scott Franzke saying JACKson

In the 20th inning remove one defender hockey style

This is not the Brews best game, Rays can take them

Will Bauers finally hit one hard enough to get out to dead center?

Or see 30 pitches

After 20, bring in Schwarber for the swing-offs

Has Jonny DeLuca ever been introduced to Paul LoDuca?

After 12 innings, Rob Manfred and the head of the MLBPA have to pitch and the winner gets to pick one item in the next CBA.

This would actually be higher stakes than winning the WS

Flags fly forever…CBA's are temporary

How can this keep happening?

Oh… oh no.

dear lord

After 12 innings, the benches clear and they play beer pong.

That’s totally unfair with a team from Wisconsin. Come on.

How is that call not clear??

OoOoOoOoOoH

Oof

Big yikes

So many mental errors

After 15 innings they close one eye

Oh noooooooooo

No harm. Just foul.

Got it done

No worries Bauers has nothing

yelling "I got it" is for amateurs

It's too bad this is a 3-0 game 4 because it's been quite exciting

I only tuned in like 2 innings ago and just saw the one F&$%in racist Republican ad, have there been more?

You know the answer to this

I saw one where Republicans said "liberals are the new racists". So at least they admit they've been racist this whole time.

"nyerr, we're the og racists" is maybe not the own they thought it would be

After the 12th inning you move the fences in 5 feet and it's 5 more feet each additional inning

Love this!!

The first two were tense as well. And last night's had something we've never seen before. For a potentially short series, it's been pretty damn good.

After thirteen half the team is replaced by Savannah Bananas

Rather, each additional inning leads to an additional Banana Ball rule

OK Brewer fan, getting Ashby glasses, cool, but growing the same beard? Now you're weird

Simpson walk off little league home run starting from a bunt please

I think Simpson and Contreras should just arm wrestle

I would also accept Simpson triple followed by walk off steal of home

After 13, the defense has to wear the oven mitts.

on both hands!

Rasmussen unlikely for tomorrow

Just need a "Homer Simpson" headline

Aaron Ashby for Congress.

ugh, my parents are about to be repped by Mark Teixeira

how fast was that throw to first?

135 mph

i think playing pokemon vgc in my spare time has broken me because i hear a speed -> 135 -> "chien-pao flutter mane miraidon korai-"

Aaron Ashby for lenscrafters

That was a bullet.

that Ashby throw to first

No wait, call-in vote for best under eye wins!

Has anyone been to a baseball park and left thinking “You know what? What this experience was really missing was a DJ.”?

That needs to be added to his pitch count. 100 to Bauers

does bauers have a pitch count yet

outs top 6

Pat Murphy for apocalypse leader

Perhaps not the best swing decision there by Mesa.

Petriello just posted the Statcast data on the throw: 79.7 mph.

You mean 179.7, right?

Points in favor of my psychology theory on the ability of others to influence actions and decisions here. I saw the play before the chat about it and honestly thought it was not that high effort of a throw.

doesnt chris davis have a pitcher win under his belt

You bet he does!

he struck out David Ortiz!

2012!

This is the at bat.

Welp, can’t end the series now

That one doesn’t quiiiite have the distance.

called it that time

i forgot about the wells walls convergence and got very confused by who was pitching

Now that Tyler Wade has retired, someone has to take the baton. Or maybe Taylor Ward retired? No, I think it was Wade.

Speaking of Tyler Wade, I cannot see his name and not think about how Ohtani used to exclusively call him “ikemen,” which means “hot guy” in Japanese.

I give up.

but also i hope taylor walls appears as pitcher briefly

Where's Taylor Ward when ya need him

Has anyone seen Dan and his Kindle? It's been a minute.

Maybe it has to happen, after two losses, in Milwaukee …

i really, really want them to clinch at home

In case you're all wondering, the game will end as soon as my daughter wakes up with a dirty diaper and I have to stop watching. Should be in the next 45 minutes.

let's see how many outs occur in the intervening time

Lotta poop related end game conditions from the staff

Other kind of dirty diaper.

I have an 18 month old and a 4 month old, your Early Shift series ran at the perfect time to remind me the hardest part was over but also about to start again. I thoroughly enjoyed reading those, thank you. I'm so tired.

Peyton Manning has SO much money, why did he become spokesman for yet another company? Dude must just love doing commercials

line must go up

You think there’s such a thing as “enough money?” Welcome to America, komrade.

His agent needs to eat too

Who has more? Peyton or John Cena?

Barkley, Shaq… I feel like we're forgetting someone else

Also the bats in the header got me again. I thought there were bugs on my screen. Please can I turn them off lol

Yes, you can.

Click on your name. You can change it in your settings there

Click your name on the top right, click Seasonal Banner until it says Off.

But know that you will be hurting Sean's feelings.

I've liked the other ones!!! I'll turn them back on for Thanksgiving

“Ghost runner” shouldn’t be an option. Sorry not sorry 😆.

I might make a batless one next year. I don't have a good idea for Thanksgiving yet. We'll do snow/Christmas lights again.

It's the bats going left to right that are the issue for me

brave to bring Boozer in here I gotta say

I don't think Carlos Boozer is playing rn

Is Cam?

my partner on the need for a grounds crew here: "It's that fidgety dude. He did it."

hmmm i wonder to whom they may be referring to

Martínez is like a cat about to take a dump.

at least his k strut does not simulate cat post-dump

Wish commentary would have laid out for that. Grounds crew work is top notch ASMR

don't you mean Baseball Zen

As a former pitcher, blaming the mound is such a classic strategy. Rarely pays off

i really want to point a shotgun microphone at rich hill or payton tolle or just one of those notable grunters to get a really crispy high def sound

*grunts*

😖

The beginning of this sentence really had me worried.

wait til you hear what they call the windscreens

I sat front row at the visiting bullpen at an Indy Indians game to watch Rich Hill warm up last year. It was glorious. I said "can we get a selfie" and he said "not right now" and then never gave me another chance to ask, which was totally fair and I'll remember the experience forever

Ump is up past their bedtime

New way to win in extras first one to find the buried treasure in the mound!

digging towards ronald acuña jr's secret gambling den

If you find that you definitely are the loser

Booser doing everything he can other than throw pitches

Oh, your PitchCom “isn’t working?” Fine, you can do hand signals.

Turang should definitely run now

Everything is a swing this series.

Yes. The consistency is appreciated but I'd prefer more leniency across the board

I could go either way with what's a swing or not; just be consistent.

if the Rays win, Jax, Martinez, Baker, Wells threw 20+ tonight. could Peralta throw an inning tomorrow? Rasmussen in relief/bulk? otherwise they have Cleavinger, Matz, Seymour, Sulser; Kelly threw only 12 tonight; and Booser if they win now

cameron "bedro paez" booser

(i definitely meant to type pedro baez but, sure!)

Rays gotta win it here I think

at least MIL will have Megill behind Mis.

Had to do a bunch of stuff before bed. I gather this game is still going somehow? And Ashby is somehow still pitching? Is this like a time loop thing or something?

Curious at people's thoughts of Murphy only using Megill for one batter?

could be very handy in game 5

but weird to use Ashby for 7 batters then no?

He's got more quality options than Cash

Truly hilarious to bring in a new pitcher to face Walls.

Walls gotta feel good about chasing Ashby

Is Ashby having the best relief postseason in mlb history?

Ask the Mailbag!!!

Still A. Miller

Up there with Andrew Miller I’d guess

Depends on your definition of "relief," surely. See Yamamoto, Eovaldi, etc.

Correction: Ask Mailbag.

He's the first RP to open a postseason with 16.2 scoreless IP in MLB history according to TheScore app push notification I got.

has mailbag been eating enough?

2003 Rivera had 16 innings 0.56 ERA and a 0.44 WHIP.

Which Id adjust for run environment as being on par with this

Wow this is such an interesting hook

the legend of Taylor Wallops grows

Makes sense in that Walls isn’t going to get a hit regardless of who’s pitching. Beyond that..

Wallskoff now guaranteed

Walls last base hit was nine days ago.

so he's due

He’s due!!! /s

same hat david

Beat me to it

Senzatela as the potential winning pitcher in a deciding World Series game is such an odd outcome to contemplate.

/points at "2025 World Series Legend Will Klein" cross-stitch

Super relief ace or recent member of the Colorado Rockies. Murphy overthought this

Im going to laugh when Walls hits a walk-off HR here

I meant this in the 15th inning when he's up next

Yandy plz I need to go to bed

If we get to tomorrow I think Matz has to take some bulk innings, no?

Matz might be bulk pitching tonight still

Fair point.

Uh oh, Bill is fallible.

ABS system got it wrong that time.

That's the only explanation.

Contreras cannot fail, he can only be failed.

CONTRERAS MADE AN ABS ERROR I've seen everything now

Do you trust ABS, or do you trust Contreras?

If its within like 0.2 inches should we really overturn the call? Gotta be within margin of error right?

We don't need an 18-inning game EVERY world series…

Max Muncy has signed a one day contract with the Tampa Bay Rays

nonsense

Jorge Mateo always seemed very likeable when he was with the O's. I hope he gets to win a World Series game

1,2,3 of the Rays order has to produce something

Senzatella has a place in my heart by being one of the rare pitchers whose delivery looks like it belongs to a position player pitcher.

I remember when Yankee fans thought Jorge Mateo was the Second Coming of Derek Jeter

Hate this PR call here

Agree. Fewer than two outs, maaaaybe.

I wonder what the % likelihood of a run is here with a better runner compared to a worse one. I can't imagine the pinch runner adding that much expected value with 2 outs.

I feel like I'd rather keep Yandy available AND save the PR for a higher run probability situation

The double clutch…oof.

Too high

I should go to bed now. but also Steven Matz should go to bed now

Have to go to bed. Good night, all. Sean, thanks again for making all of this happen!

Thanks for stopping by and being a Member.

Well thats gonna be a no from me dawg

Good night to everyone on the east coast being responsible!

At what point during an extra inning game without the Manfred Man is it appropriate to just start swinging for the fences?

2nd inning

I have it on good authority from John Smoltz that you always want to make soft contact.

this is why we love steven kwan !!!

Not a fan of that PR. It's not Billy Hamilton for like 2017 Albert Pujols or something

Baseball fans: we want more baseball, please don't let the Brewers sweep.

Baseball Gods: Best we can do is a 20 inning game.

Anyone dressing up for Halloween? Does the FG staff do anything for it?

I like dressing up. I don't like spending time to procure a costume. I have a friend and he has always taken it seriously now his family of four has a theme every year. Usually it's something Marvel-esque.

if this game doesnt end on a yeli bomb, maybe he's the pitcher of record?

Derek Jr. is going as a pumpkin.

Remember: 27 more innings this game is the same as getting three more games!

This game feels like it should now end with Yandy's spot coming up in a key situation

lol of course

My God, STFU, DJ.

You can't be serious.

BOOM

I demand we see Miz for the bottom of the 12th now.

I would also accept Woodruff I suppose

or yelich. it could still be yelich

WOAHHHH

Wow. Not the best of times for Seymour.

I love the crowd.

put the kid to bed, dealt with a tantrum, and just sat down to see a home run

No doubter

Pratt, Hamilton, Frelick. just like they drew it up

none of them with 5+ homers in the reg season

None of them with a iso above .100

pooper cratt !?!? almost like my pooper cat ….

(he had worms)

Just a total hanger.

Those were some terrible seats behind Drohan

so who closes for MIL? Not gonna be Harrison or Woodruff I imagine (the latter's stuff didn't look great yday)

I imagine it'll be Senzatella for Caminero then Drohan after him

Has Drohan made an appearance at all? Genuinely curious

I was skeptical of Pratts bat, but he’s pleasantly surprised me this year.

Joey Ortiz has 5+ homers on the year so he's not eligible to hit one now

bauers needs to seymour pitches (i'm sorry)

As much as it is poor strategy, Miz to close is just too much fun… DO IT.

Two words: Rollie Fingers.

Huge pop for a visiting team's go ahead extra inning home run in the World Series.. poor Rays

Palacios’ arm stresses me out

Mark my words: Palacios is done as a 2B.

Palacios certainly seems to be having issues with his throwing

He should try the Seymour no look chuck it move

No ABS challenge for TB in the bottom of the inning now. The game will probably end on a borderline strike call. Or a check swing. Probably a check swing.

I just cannot believe Cash put Seymour in this game

the manager report cards for this are gonna be like 4,000 words. even if it ends here.

Everyone left threw yesterday.

He’s getting the yips in real time.

Who else does he have left? He used the Baker bullet already

focal dystonia is a real jerk

today was a great day to read Sam Miller's piece about how helmets are falling off at record levels

Chourio seems on him

He was mad at his bat half a dozen times in that at bat.

putting up stats that tie you with babe ruth, i would guess, is a good thing

Ashby or Chourio for MVP?

Pratt

Contreras

huh. how many ABS challenges did they win?

the friends we made along the way

im getting an mvp??

if you're gonna go friends we made along the way, ya gotta delete dodger flair

Screw it, give it to Murph.

Frelick, for intensity of eyes.

Caminero about to swing out of his shoes

he said “for more on Cooper Pratt…” but it sounded like “for moron…”

“For Mormon Copper Pratt”

We should do these chat rooms for Dominican league games

In.

let Brendan mod em

updating the stat i said earlier, brewers have 12 of the 13 hardest hit balls

I love baseball but if I never see this "Tom Brady 7 ring powers" ad again it will be too soon; makes me year for "Frank TV"

FOX has always had interesting choices.

but the single hardest hit ball is by the rays, into a DP

Bauers can’t buy a hit tonight

to be fair, most players dont use money for hits

whoa

oops

oh dear

Sean can we randomly pick 1 game a day during the regular season as the chat game?

Yeah, we are trying to figure out what exactly we want to do.

Again with the NOT THROWING TO FIRST

Oh no

That was a brutal throw – can't blame Bauers for that.

I can and will… he should’ve stretched and scooped the short hop

Great positioning, poor execution.

Ortiz had the rest of the year to throw that ball to first and get Jr.

Oh no Caminero

Yikes

I know that's gonna get scored as an E5 but a good 1B picks that all day.

Sure would be nice to still have Mateo available as a PR…

This is where I would like to have Mateo

Damn Bobo beat me to it

Oof. Diaz and Caminero both out. And also, STFU, DJ.

Bauers picks that on grass.

Can Williamson run well?

Simpson with a two run walkoff with two outs. Count it.

So who’s left on the Rays’ bench? Jorge Cantu?

Damian Rolls

even if bauers had just dropped it he would have time to pick it up before caminero got there. Instead he bounced it away

Wade Boggs

Kyle Harrison now officially the only rostered Brewer not to play in the WS

If this goes to another game I’m making the infield throw to first all night

Caminero is staying in to run?

whats jiman choi up to these days

Ah, Junior is staying in.

The only natural outcome now is a 122 mph ground ball double play followed by a controversial check swing final out.

I believe Hicks had a 34 wRC+ against lefties this year.

Sorry, 45.

So naturally.

Something something small sample something something…

Dammit, apparently your feed is like 25 seconds ahead of mine.

ssssss

If Caminero's spot in the lineup comes up again, the Rays have kept the game going, probably by scoring this runner

I would have put all my money on Caminero not going 1st to 3rd on a grounder

He still looks hurt

get brett phillips a bat

That was so dumb

wow. I feel for Drohan here – tough situation

Fascinating decisions being made

why is ceddy in now, of all times

I just hope the game keeps going and we see what he's like a third base.

caminero’s right hamstring appears to have 175 feet of running in it

Sorry I really do not think they're going to squeeze with a dinged-up Caminero on 3rd.

I'm shocked Chourio didn't even bother throwing to third

Same

Embarrassed from the transfer bobble.

Is Carl Crawford available?

Not until the 20th inning

Are we going 13?

Why wait for the pinch run?

I hope not

very satisfying that that foul grounder bonked a rosin bag off a BP mound

I have to be awake in 5 hours

Did he get (more) hurt?

Why not squeeze?!

This is a hot take but I think I put my middle infielders in double play depth instead of infield in here? I think?

Welp.

Like for that reason?

in my mind I cared a lot more about the runner on 1st than the runner on 3rd. Tie game isn't the end of the world here so long as you can turn two.

DP -> K -> 15 more innings

Baby's still asleep, by the way.

Throwing away Pratts heroics

TIE GAME

Would’ve been a DP if they were playing DP depth

Rays are being pesky

Drohan throwing it away

Infield in= bad confirmed

Drohan can't buy an out. MIL couldn't afford that error when they were down to the bottom of their bullpen.

Wow. The Rays have no real offensive threats left, but hey, it’s tied and they have a DJ!

the BABIP god giveth, and they taketh.

This is where you bunt it OVER the first baseman's head.

Ballgame over.

I don't hate putting the infield in. You're up 3-0, take risks, be aggressive

Please don’t post the results

Use chat delay

We ain't done yet

i once saw something about "joey gallo pops bunt out to yasmani grandal at 1st" and it destroyed my entire psyche

Simpson needs to be squaring earlier

Or not

How funny would it be if he homered

Lol. TB deserves a game at least, but if they lose this from here …

Man they gotta get Drohan out of there like yesterday

Kyle Harrison so far in the doghouse he might actually be dog food

And then consider phantom IL'ing him to get someone else on the roster for tomorrow lmao

Was that a barrel?

only 91.8 off the bat

Drohan = LVP

"We'll cya later tonight" is a cool call tbh

Amazing call

You kinda have to leave Drohan in given circumstances but man, sick to your stomach moment as a manger.

Error, single, single, single, single. That's the Rays way!

what a crazy game

LOL

NOT THE LAST CHAT

We have been given a ⚾️ reprieve!

I love everything about this, let’s go 7!!!

See ya tomorrow folks. Hopefully Brews will go the distance.

See you all tomorrow!

That was fun

gg. Good chat. We'll see you tomorrow night

Excited we get to do this at least one more time

Median 12 innings per the poll!

ITS STILL BASEBALL SEASON! YES!

Who is pitching for TB tomorrow?

I am

We all are!

brewers in front of their home crowd (not the one in tampa) will be nice

Couldn’t agree more

Game 5 is in Tampa though

David Price

Great game, thanks for chatting all

Baseball is fun

Didn't I read somewhere that Ben Williamson is only on the Rays because Dave Cameron texted Jeff Sullivan, "hey you guys want Ben Williamson?"

whats the probability that both junior and yandy are out

Alright everyone! We have at least one more of these tomorrow!


Brendan Gawlowski Prospects Chat 10/27/2026

Hello everybody. Good sports day today, Serie A is going already, some League Cup to follow. AFL, of course, and apparently another baseball game of modest import tonight. Should be fun. Let's get to it.

Thanks for the chat! Thoughts on Zion Rose? Eric mentioned wanting to see Zion Rose try some CF—any idea if the Royals plan to try that out?

I liked Rose and agree that it'd be interesting to see him in CF. Not sure yet if the Royals are going to explore that, it's on my list to ask when I get to their system.

What's your take on Buster Posey essentially hand-waving away any potential injury to a Giants pitcher in the name of improving their stuff? They definitely need to do that as an organization, but I'm not sure it's the best idea to say out loud to the media that they're going to push guys to a breaking point and oh well if they break.

Do you have a link?

What do you make of Tai Peete's AFL? Is he in the Cardinals T10 ? Is he a future T100 guy?

Obviously he's crushing it in Arizona. He's a guy I'm rooting for, but I don't think a whole lot has changed about him or the profile. He's a high risk player with a lot of swing and miss risk on spin and big upside if it all clicks. Top 10 in the system, everyday projection for me as a scout… Does that translate to the Top 100? Instinct is no, but we'll see how it shakes out.

Do you miss ash bats? The sound of contact just doesn't hit the same anymore

I miss the aesthetic, too. If the league ever decides to get serious about making it easier to hit the ball but harder to hit it over the fence, ash bats could have a role to play.

Enjoyed Eric's writeup of Dax Kilby. Who do you like more between Dax and Yostin Pena in the Yankees system and why?

Dax. In part because I think Dax is perfectly fine at short.

Pretty sure I haven’t asked it yet (and apologies if I have), but for Deyvison De Los Santos, is there much to be read into his contact rate improvement at AAA, or is this just improvements from repeating the level and that there’s not really a meaningful change in his profile at the plate?

It's up a little bit, but 73% for a bat-only guy in his sophomore year of AAA isn't great. Still projects as a bench bat/Asia masher.

I am so enthused to see the Brewer – Rays WS (although as a Reds fan watching the Brewers success is a bit painful). I admire both organizations for combining Analytics, Scouting, and Player Development attached to a clear organizational philosophy. I think the Cardinals are well on their way to similar success. My Reds – well….. How to you evaluate combining those three arms and organizational philosophy. Is one more important than another in your view or is organizational philosophy that is most important supported by the three arms of success?

I don't really think about it in terms of one being more important than the others, you have to do all of it to be competitive, particularly if you can't spend your way out of lousy PD/scouting. The consequences for being complete dogshit analytically are enormous in a way that they don't seem to be for having the worst scouting/dev staffs, so in that sense… It's important not to be awful there. But at this point, I don't think the gap between the sixth and twenty-fourth best group analytically is all that big.

Eh, his comments seem fine. Everybody understands that this is where the game is at right now.

I was surprised that Franklin Primera was not on the top 100 given his amazing performance so far on every level. What is there to be concerned about in Franklin's profile other than being in Single A

His approach and long swing are going to be stress tested by better pitching/more velocity and he's not super projectable. I suspect he'll be a pick to click.

How do you know when a ranked prospect just has an off year vs a complete change in valuation? Thinking how Francisca went from a 45 here after the '24 season to not even a 35+ last year to now right back to 45 again.

It can be tricky, and also hard to communicate what a down year means. Oftentimes when this happens, a player's ceiling doesn't change, but his odds of reaching it go down. That can shift a player down from an FV perspective.

I would also say… Without placing a value judgment on it, because I think you can argue for either approach… I think Eric is more inclined to move a player's FV, and I'm more inclined to let things play out over a long period. These are tendencies rather than absolutes, but something to keep in mind as you read our lists this cycle.

If Kristian Campbell was a prospect right now, what fv do you think he would have and what would change?

40+ and glad I don't have to commit to that.

What would be the minor league level equivalency of AFL pitching quality? I see B-ref shows 5.85 ERA, 10K/9 and 6.5BB/9 as league averages. Is that like Cal League caliber? Or worse, Complex-type competition? Or is there no direct comparison here? Thx Brendan.

It varies so much, the KBO isn't a bad comparison in that sense, from an overall talent perspective. The walk rates are very much of the complex, though.

Sell high on Gasser in dynasty after last night?

If someone's willing to buy him as more than a no. 4, sure

how controllable are diet/sleep/etc in the minor leagues? my understanding is the conditions are much worse which makes me suspect there are a lot of gains being left on the table

Conditions are way better than they were 10 years ago. Some teams do a better job than others of procuring good housing/providing healthy meals, but even the worst are here are doing a lot more than was common in the early-mid 2010s.

Of course, you're still dealing with teenagers and early 20 somethings and like everyone else at that age, a lot of them… will eat, drink, or sleep sub-optimally. That's just life.

Why were you so low on Cam Cannarella and Brandon Compton? They both had a wrc+ of 149 and 156, and Cannarella is a consensus top 100 prospect on every other list in baseball. Are you guys going to change there grades for upcoming season?

I think the reasons are clear from their writeups… It's fine to disagree. They both performed so well after publication that I definitely want to give them a fresh look, certainly possible that I was light, it happens. Cannarella's defense in particular is something that I agonized over at the time. The reputation didn't match the tape, but the tape is also not as good/reliable as the eye test in person. It's possible that if I saw him in the park, I would've felt differently.

What's the next experimental rule in the AFL? Having the outfielders wear a ball and chain?

I think the experimentation is broadly fine. I kind of liked watching outfielders need to go back on the ball. I'd tweak it so that they don't have to sit practically on the foul line, see what that looks like.

Have any of the A's arms at the fall league caught your eye? I know Richardson has struck everyone out but I'm wondering if that's a blip or more to look forward to of him

You named the one.

Hey Brendan! Eric said in his chat Briggs McKenzie looked like diet MadBum, what have your thoughts on him been?

Should we just sneak peak a full blurb here?

Why not

McKenzie received Atlanta’s biggest bonus in the 2025 draft, signing for a cool $3 million. A year of pro instruction and weight training have worked wonders, as McKenzie has filled out considerably and added a few ticks of velocity. After operating either side of 90 mph this time last year, he now sits 92-94 while touching a little higher, and he could have more growth ahead of him.

McKenzie is an athletic and projectable lefty with a clean, if long, arm swing and a deceptive delivery. That motion helps his stuff and pitchability play up, and they’re already quite good to begin with. He can move his fastball up and to both sides of the plate, and run his long and tight sweeping breaking ball on and off the dish as well. His fading CH is inconsistent but flashed above average a few times during my look at him in the AFL.

The southpaw was only in Arizona because injuries took a big bite out of his 2026 campaign. He threw just 26 innings during the regular season, and at one point was on the 60 day IL with nerve irritation in his pitching elbow. While that sounds a little scary, he is back on the mound and looked no worse for wear in the Fall League. Projecting outward, McKenzie has mid-rotation traits. He has sufficient velocity and seems likely to develop the command. And while his arsenal is still a little lean, there’s plenty of time for him to add a second breaking ball or a two seamer. While we want to see more length and durability, and perhaps another tick on the gun, before we consider bumping him onto our Top 100 list, I anticipate he has another gear and he’ll be a Pick to Click for me this winter.

There are orgs that are good at getting their young pitchers to add velocity, and orgs that are good at teaching their young pitchers new pitches. But are their orgs that are good at improving command?

Boston was the first org that came to mind. Seattle's had some success here, too.

How does the Royals' Brooks Bryan look for Surprise? Thanks!

Powerful. 35+/40 area as a thumper from the left side.

What have you seen from Padres prospects in the Arizona Fall League? Specifically, Alex McCoy, Ty Harvey and Winyer Chourio. Francis Pena, too.

McCoy and Harvey were the most interesting of the group. McCoy's power might just be an 80, that gives him a path to value even if he's pretty flawed everywhere else. Harvey's a good athlete behind the plate, like the bat speed. Suspect he'll stay in the Top 10 of that system even after a rough year in the Cal League. Says something about both him and SD's system.

do you ever think about how traits/tools fit into a team context while scouting? eg. the arraez fit with the phillies, or like how a prospect might add defensive value to a poor defensive major league team

All the time, usually more from a developmental context than immediate team need.

considering his hot run, whats preventing arjun nimmala from taking the next step up the T100 rankings and/or FV rating?

That he might not be a shortstop.

Assuming the Red Sox get Franklin Arias in the lineup relatively near the beginning of 2027 (if there's a 2027), what's a reasonable expectation for him next year? Does his peak look something like Michael Young's good years with the Rangers? His EV numbers seem more "average to plus" than "25+ homers on the reg"

Arias is a better defender. The dream here is Lindor Lite.

Re: changes to FV, how much of that difference with Eric (I understand it's a friendly disagreement) is scouting philosophy vs journalistic philosophy? Seems like player development is hard to report, because you can't just keep running articles that say, "still waiting to see how this plays out long-term." The internet wants content!

I don't even know if it's a disagreement, more of an initial instinct. I don't know if there's a "right" answer to how sensitive FV should be to performance, it's so context specific.

And you can find examples where both approaches were justified. Like, Hartman was sending signals right away this spring that he was a different guy than he was in '25. Moving quickly was the right answer there. Meanwhile, Ethan Salas had a rough couple years but the tools never really changed…

follow up q, is it arjun's defense then? is it range/technique/arm?

Range just okay, he's not that quick, footwork doesn't look great, can scatter his throws when he's not lined up well. Love the hands, growing chance it all plays better at third.

Brendan! Piggybacking on the Posey question (I’ve not seen those quotes either): at what point do you think it becomes a question of morality about pitcher injuries? I’m speaking as a father of a 12yo who A) plays baseball, B) has 99th percentile velo for his age, and C) can’t hit a lick. As a dad I’d really prefer he was a position player, but his path forward (at least to HS /JuCo, or university if he makes it that far) is almost certainly tied to his arm. I realize teams aren’t coercing players against their will to go to Driveline and gain velo only to blow out, but at some point does a front office become (if not legally at least morally) culpable when they tell a kid “you’d be a real prospect if you just threw a little harder”?

Complicated question, no easy answers, but very different context in the professional game versus teenage ball. At your son's age, the focus should be on having fun. Run screaming from anyone who wants to max out a 13 year old's stuff plus, or who wants to throw him all the time.

For the professionals, it's a different equation. There are a lot of risks inherent to being a professional athlete, and for a pitcher, subjecting your arm to a greater risk of injury in the search of better stuff is part of the equation. That said, I do think teams should feel some moral obligation to lower their injury rates, and I think players should be educated about which teams tend to get their guys hurt, and which do a better job keeping them healthy.

There's also a competitive angle here, too. At a certain point, you have enough injuries that you're doing something wrong. Like, Miami's injury rate is counter productive.

How has Charles Davalan looked at second in the AFL?

Misio improving his walk rate from 13.4% to 14.4% to 11.8% to 6.6% since 2023 is an XX% outcome ??

97.54th

I pulled him from travel ball and only have him in Little League (juniors) because I didn’t like the vibes I was getting. Maybe I’m costing him long term but like you said, I want him to have a great time and make a lot of happy memories.

Be wary of teams that play in a lot of tournaments. They're fun, but unless the team is bringing a ton of pitching and has a responsible coach, the good ones can get run into the ground.

One other question: quite a bit has been made about the Rays as of late and how they’ve utilized their sinkers, especially cases where pitchers are able to tunnel them effectively with their four-seamers. If this becomes part of the next big trend where teams try to develop this with their pitchers, which orgs particularly stand out as the best suited towards using this strategy?

The usual suspects.

I guess as optics go, I would have liked to see something like, "we're going to do everything we can to keep our guys healthy through this process," rather than, "no one is gonna get in trouble for pushing a guy so hard he breaks."

Personally, I thought Posey hit his marks there. I also don't care that much about optics. What people do is more important than what they say, which is in turn more important than how the media/social media perceives what they say.

How do ash bats make it easier to hit the ball?

They don't (at least as far as I'm aware, I suspect we'll learn more about bats and bat technology in the future) but my understanding is that they don't hit the ball as hard so, in a world where it's easier to hit but you don't want the homer rate to explode, their use could theoretically help maintain balance. Speculation on speculation here.

Dax Kilby follow up—what should the defense development Plan A be? Play him at SS as long as he can kinda handle it? Or switch to an easier position now to speed his path to the majors?

I would just play him at SS. I thought he looked like a 50/55 type there and spoke to two scouts who felt similarly. I've also heard that at least one team has him graded that way based strictly on their defensive metrics, for what that's worth.

Now, maybe he grows off of it, or maybe he'd be so good in center that you could justify moving him there based on that. But just from what I've seen, I wouldn't be in any hurry to move him.

You had Angel de los Santos as a long term pick to click. How we feeling about him now?

Similarly! Better than my other two year dart throw guess.

How repeatable is the Bauersaissance, really? Even if you accept that MIL is better at post-prospect development, that doesn't mean they can Bauersify any equivalent hitter who's bouncing around the league. How do they know who they cam help? Is it initially luck–they just have to get a guy and see? Can they predict it? Or is it totally luck and I'm giving them too much credit even for Bauers himself?

Can they reliably turn a 40 into a 60? Probably not. Do I think they can turn 35+/40 types into 45's more often than most other teams? Yes.

How did Salas look to your eyes in his callup time in September/playoffs? Any shading to his grades based on his MLB looks?

He looked great. He's (obviously) much closer to actualizing the future grades than he was a year ago and the 55 future power looks low since he's 20 years old and basically already there.

He's a great prospect.

I saw Eric said he'd put him in the top 5 in his last chat and, yeah, that seems about right.

So….can you confirm that you're working on the Atlanta list?!?!

I'm 98% done with it.

Favorite non top 100 LHP in the milb as of today and why?

Two for the price of one. Justin Lamkin's a fun watch as a pitchability guy who can kind of toy with hitters. I'm very interested in monitoring Kash Mayfield's development with Detroit.

Eric seems to slightly revised his confidence in Bonemer's bat upwards- do you agree with this? Is there a path to him being an all star level LF even if he's a LF?

He's scary, I think toward the bottom of the Top 100 is the right place to slot in the guy with a scary swing and limited defensive value… but also a lot of power and pretty good barrel feel.

Any prospects that you love but you have worries that they are majorly blocked by the current big league club around their debut?

No, talent pushes its way through eventually. The closest thing to this was River Ryan w/LAD.

You mentioned a few weeks ago that you were working on lists. Can you share what we should expect over the next month or two?

99.87% done with Toronto, close to that with Atlanta, ~90% done with Boston. After that I might start on Texas… From there, no plans. I'll try to keep folks informed on a rolling basis where possible. The two things that kind of push a system up or down are the number of potential T100 guys (higher priority to do quickly) and the teams who have a lot of talent coming up from the DSL (these get pushed back on the off chance we can get a meaningful look in the spring).

Eric has done that for a few years now and it makes a ton of sense.

Does Seth Hernandez have major reliever risk long term or are you a believer in his ability to be a starter 5+ years from now?

Every pitcher has some reliever risk, but Hernandez's is about as low as can be for a teenage flamethrower. He's really good.

non-prospect related, but what do you make of Victor Mesa's season? Just a late-bloomer or did he really benefit from change of scenery/team better at player development?

Little of column A, little of column B. He looks like a good player going forward. Curious to see if he gets much ROY consideration.

Do you think that Dzierwa has ace potential? If not, who in the MILB do you think currently has that no. 1 ceiling?

Good pitching prospect, but ace is a little hot there. Seth Hernandez and Ryan Sloan might be the only two I'd project as aces right now.

Can David Sandlin establish himself in the CWS rotation next year?

Yes.

I’ve seen some notes from Arizona recently about the outfield positioning rules they’re testing, which seem to effectively boost doubles and (especially) triples. Any thoughts on types of prospects who would look better/worse to you under those rules, if adopted at MLB? Just a boost to fast corner outfielders or would it impact hitting grades as well?

Speed in the outfield becomes imperative. Fourth outfielders with wheels and contact skill but not a ton of pop would get a lot more valuable.

As would groundball pitchers, I suspect.

Charlie Condon and Josue De Paula have to get an early look in 27 correct?

De Paula for all practical purposes has arrived. I don't know exactly how the Dodgers sort out the roster, and I can't guarantee that the answer is JDP is in the Opening Day lineup and stays there for 155 games, but he'll play a ton. Condon I would think is about ready to go but, as I said last week, Colorado's approach with him raises questions that require further investigation.

In retrospect, why didn't Ashby get developed as a starter? Was it health, command, a little of both?

He… did? He even made 19 big league starts in '22.

If you were the Brewers and decided not to bring Bauers back, what would your confidence level be of 1B shaking out to be some combination of Vaughn/Fischer/Burke?

Vaughn definitely part of the solution. Burke/Fischer have a shot to grow into a role there in 2027 but I are probably not part of the Opening Day plan. You're probably either committing to playing Vaughn there every day or looking for a Nate Lowe type to platoon.

Have you seen Ramcell Medina of the Royals at all recently. He seemed like a guy you were intrigued on a year or two ago, but his power hasn't really shown up at all in games like it was projected it might. Thanks a lot.

Stock down, didn't hit much on the complex. Raw power was 30 grade.

Curious about high rated prospects making it into Show in last 2-3 years but still young enough to bloom maybe this year; Based upon your evaluations, give us 2-3 position player guys you still think just need more time. Love the chats.

Cam Smith might have another gear. Amador showed signs of life at the end of the year. For a deep shot, I'd like to see Max Muncy get a healthy year…

when it comes to fast risers who end up getting shots in the MLB (Leo Bernal this year, Michael Harris in the past), can we chalk this up to the club identifies something they like more than the public?

Sometimes yeah. Sometimes its just org philosophy to push quickly. I wouldn't throw Bernal into that category though, he's moved at about a level per year.

Crazy to think the presumptive WS champions have the #1 prospect in the game knocking on the door. What is the plan with Made in 2027 if you're the Brewers? Start at AAA? What if he signs a contract extension? Does he supplant Pratt who has been leaky in the postseason at SS?

What's crazy is that this has happened a few times in recent memory. Langford was ranked second and was the Opening Day starter for the defending champs, and then Roki was the top guy on the 100 prior to the 2025 season.

As for the plan on Made, no need to rush, AAA would be just fine out of the gate.

Looking back at the Cubs farm post their 2020-2023 rebuild, they had a top 5 (maybe even #1 farm system) that produced basically PCA, Busch, and nobody else. How much of that was an entire industry miss, overvaluation of a big market team's prospects, or just regular prospect hit/miss cycle?

Was it a miss? Eric had nine 50 FV or better Cubs prospects on his 2024 list, and it was ranked as the second best system overall at the time: https://www.fangraphs.com/prospects/farm-system-rankings/202…

With a pretty big grade on PCA, too.

Think I'll shut it down here for today. Thanks as always for the questions, we'll do it again next week. Enjoy the rest of the WS and AFL.


Jay Jaffe FanGraphs Chat – 10/27/26

Good afternoon, folks! Welcome to what will be my final chat of the 2026 baseball season, as we're somewhere from one to four games away from the World Series wrapping up.

That escalated quickly last night, didn't it? The Brewers eight-run fifth inning turned the series from a still-competitive one to a steamrolling in the making. Given the uncertainty of the upcoming offseason, I wouldn't mind a longer series, but I don't blame Brewers fans for being over the moon right now.

Anyway, yesterday I wrote about Rays catcher Liam Hicks and two plays from Game 2 that loomed large — and then he didn't even get into Game 3 because the Brewers started lefty Robert Gasser.
https://blogs.fangraphs.com/liam-hicks-has-been-a-fine-catch…

Before I dig in, a reminder that to submit a question, you have to be logged into your FanGraphs user account (a paid membership isn't necessary but thank you if you're among our subscribers). And a quick announcement of some upcoming dates of interest:

The Contemporary Baseball Era Committee ballot for Managers, Executives and Umpires will be announced on Monday, November 2, with the results announced on Sunday, December 6. |

The dates for the BBWAA ballot are Monday, November 16 and Tuesday, January 1

Our site is dark for election day, November 3, so in all likelihood my first look will come the day after that. And now, on with the show.

Excellent article on Liam Hicks. Do you have a sense of why he didn't play yesterday?

Hicks really scuffled against left-handed pitching this season (.192/.274/.231, 45 wRC+) where the righty-swinging Nick Fortes was basically platoon-neutral, hitting 252/.315/.361(91 wRC+) against lefties.

If the Brewers break out the brooms once again tonight, where do you think their 2026 postseason run ranks among the all-time great playoff performances?

I'm working on a piece to answer that question 😉

The Rays baserunning has seemed as error-prone as the 2006 Tigers' pitcher fielding – it's not the only reason they've lost, as the offense has been disastrously thin too, but for a team that's scored 7 runs in three games, it's been pretty amazing to watch them get 3 CS AND get thrown out at home from short left field! Are there any similar baserunning collapses like this that you can remember?

I don't have a comprehensive answer for this but just last fall, Addison Barger was doubled off second base to end Game 6 and then Isiah Kiner-Falefa got a poor jump and failed to slide into home plate in the bottom of the ninth in Game 7. Those plays loom quite large given the outcome of the series.

I suppose it's unsporting to pile on the 1991 Braves for Ron Gant getting pulled off first base by the Twins' Kent Hrbek in Game 2 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MiraekmCNv4) but Lonnie Smith's subsequent failure to score from second on a Terry Pendleton double in the eighth inning of a scoreless Game 7 was a huge gaffe in what became a 1-0 Twins win in 10 innings (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MiraekmCNv4)

What will it take for Tampa Bay to win four straight and take the World Series?

A decision by the Brewers to move back to Seattle and return to being the Pilots. Given a likely territorial dispute with the Mariners, I don't see this getting wrapped up by first pitch tonight at 8ish pm ET.

Beyond that, I think it will take some Gashouse Gorilla-like rallies by the Rays, but I'm not holding my breath.

Since Murphy took over in 2024, Brewers hitters have scored the most runs in each of the RISP and Two Out splits. Over that same time frame Brewers pitchers have the lowest wOBA and fewest runs allowed in each of the RISP and Two Outs splits. Is this as close as we might get to seeing something like a manager's influence on his team's mindset / level of determination showing up in the stats?

I wouldn't lay it all on Murphy so much as crediting it as an organizational philosophy and manifestation involving both the pitching side and the hitting side. Coaches and front offices need to find the right players and supplement them with the right instruction and data to pull that off.

It's still damn impressive and, assuming the Brewers do take the series at some point, it will be quite the organizational accomplishment.

How is Brooklyn these days?

Autumn in Brooklyn is lovely. Recently I joined Citi Bike so I can now bike around Prospect Park as an exercise option, and seeing the leaves change color is a nice little treat that I associate with that.

both the devil rays and brewers have fantastic jerseys. when is the fangraphs article about wearing a great jersey influencing win probability coming out?

I thought Monday's Devil Rays throwback jersey was quite silly. As the D-Rays, they never won more than 70 games, and reached that mark just once. The franchise's exorcism of the Devil coincided with their sudden rise to relevance in 2008, when they won their first pennant. Why they would want to invoke the bad old days is absolutely beyond me.

On the other hand I generally love the Brewers' uniforms, with the powder blues being my favorites

What strategy do you see the mets adopting for 2027? Do they run this back? Thanks.

I absolutely can't see them running back this year's squad. We'll see what happens with Bo Bichette's player option — and the CBA's tax penalties, sigh — but I suspect they'll make an effort to lean into the youth movement even if it means eating some salary.

With the potential bookends of WBC title and WS have other players had the year(s) that Contreras and Chourio have had?

I believe that Alex Bregman and Luke Gregerson in 2017, via Team USA and the Astros, are the only ones to do it thus far.

I know in my heart that Yelich isn't going to make the HOF. Let's say he has 5 more mid seasons and somehow gets to 2500 hits and 300 HR – that still won't do it, will it? Especially if they're at DH?

I don't see that as likely to be enough. He had big ssons of 7+ bWAr in 2018 and '19 but otherwise hasn't had a single 5.0-WAR season (4.9 in 2016) and then nothing else above 3.8.

Who’re you most looking forward to appearing on the ballot? Who do you wish to get a look that you’re least certain will appear? I think for the latter, I would want Bill White to come back for a second look, but I’m not optimistic there’ll be room for him to get a fair shake in voting.

I suspect that White receiving the Buck O'Neil Award this past summer may mean he won't be on the ballot, and certainly won't be particularly well positioned if some combination of Bruce Bochy, Dusty Baker, Lou Piniella, Joe West, Dave Dombrowski, Billy Beane, and Theo Epstein are all on there (which isn't to say they will all be on there). I'll be most excited for Baker's appearance given the way the baseball world came around on him during his final years managing.

If the Brewers finish things off today with an 11 W – 1 L postseason and the first ever eight game LCS/WS sweep (on top of their 103 regular season wins) did we just witness a Top Ten single season ever? Looks like other WS winners with at least 114 combined wins have been 1998 NYY (125), 2018 BOS (119), 2022 HOU (117), 1986 NYM (116), 1970 BAL (115), 1975 CIN (115), 1909 PIT (114), 1927 NYY (114), 2009 NYY (114), and 2016 CHC (114).

Good question, one I'll try to address in the aforementioned piece.

If you're Kevin Cash, what's your pitching plan for game 4 and 5? Game 4 is a kitchen sink game, and then figure out Game 5 when it comes, but would you even consider Rasmussen for either game?

Well, as we heard early in last night's game, the original plan was to go with Nick Martinez for Game 5. I suspect they stick with that because bringing Rasmussen back on three days of rest, after throwing 89 pitches in Game 2, isn't likely to boost their odds, paritcularly when going up against Misiorowski.

In a hypothetical Game Six/Game Seven scenario, what former Brewers would most hype up the crowd for a first pitch? How loud a response would CC Sabathia generate, for example?

Well, they went with their Hall of Famers Robin Yount and Bud Selig before Game 1, and Paul Molitor before Game 2. If you're thinking in terms of franchise icons, the next in line is probably Ryan Braun. In terms of other recent icons, Prince Fielder certainly spent a lot longer in Milwaukee than Sabathia, who's really much more associated with the Yankees now that he's got the Hall of Fame plaque, the Yankee Stadium plaque, and the retired jersey number. Stars from the 1982 team would include Cecil Cooper and Gorman Thomas. I don't have a great feel for who would generate the loudest response but I think fans would be happy to see any or all of them, though I strongly suspect this series won't get back to Milwaukee.

brian cashman has to be in the HOF conversation no? I mean 29 consecutive winning seasons is ridiculous. also is there any chance milwaukee sells high on garrett mitchell

For sure, eventually. Cashman is too young to be placed on the ballot while still active. A manager has to be 65 or older and 6 months into retirement to be eligible, while an exec has to be 70 or older (can still be active).

Do you think the crowd being mostly/substantially brewers fans points to the unhealthy state of baseball fandom in tampa bay?

not particularly. The more lopsided a series, the less likely fans of that team are to shell out hundreds or thousands of dollars per ticket. I'd say this is more a commentary on the enthusiasm of Brewers fans willing to travel and to pay big bucks.

Ew Joe West

Indeed.

Someone in Ben's chat yesterday said they hope the "45 degree rule" on checked swings that's being tested in the minors doesn't get adopted in MLB because "it will advantage the hitters." But the hitters *need* advantages, they're totally outclassed right now. If this rule can shave off a few K's and also give them a split-second more time to commit, all to the good. If that results in too many dingers, maybe then you can soften the ball.

While I haven't done any research on the leagues that have experiemented with it, a 45-degree rule sounds quite reasonable AND I think could slightly nudge offense upward while lowering strikeout rates without forcing pitchers to do something like throwing from a longer distance (which I think will lead to them throwing harder to chase velocity nonetheless)

With Joey Ortiz basically becoming that "well-rounded offensive player with great defense" that the FG prospect write-up foretold and three years of team control, does he become a possible trade-candidate for the Brewers to replenish parts elsewhere (similar to the Durbin deal with Boston)? The Brewers have Pratt locked up thru 2033 and Jesus Made seemingly ready….

At some point, he's probably trade fodder, but I don't know that a move will be imminent. Made had an excellent season in Double-A at age 19 but I'm not sure that the Brewers need to bulldoze their roster to find a spot in the infield for him on Opening Day 2027. Having a veteran like Ortiz could be quite helpful when it's time to break him in.

Jay! I don’t really have a question, just a feeling of existential dread about my, like, third-most-hated team winning the WS heading into what will probably be a long, cold winter. Baseball has been a welcome crutch for me in what has been one of the more difficult years of my adult life, and I’m both sad to see it go and sad to see the season end this way. Any recommendations for staving off the darkness in the winter months?

I realize now that sounded a lot more ominous than I intended; I’m not in any peril, and fall/winter are usually the seasons I’m most comfortable in. Just feeling bereft is all.

There are a million books, TV shows, and movies out there that you probably haven't gotten to yet that can fill the void. Just to throw some TV series out there, lately my wife and i have been streaming Slow Horses, The Night Manager, The Gentlemen, The Lowdown, The Diplomat, Shoresy, Rivals, Shrinking, and Great British Bakeing Show. We loved Widow's Bay, and and I just found an SCTV archive on Netflix

The secondary market in Milwaukee during Games 1 and 2 was apparently so nutso that it was legit cheaper to fly to Tampa, get a hotel and go to Game 3.

That's wild!

Why wasn't Simpson subjected to the concussion protocol after ramming full speed into the wall?

That's a good question. I imagine since he didn't appear impeded after making the play, the Rays didn't send their training staff out to check on him. I don't know for sure but I suspect somebody at least checked on him in the dugout or clubhouse after he came in. He sounded fine during his brief in-game interview with Ken Rosenthal.

Given the possibility of lingering effects, I do imagine (and hope) that the Rays staff is keeping an eye on him.

"it's unsporting to pile on the 1991 Braves for Ron Gant getting pulled off first base by the Twins' Kent Hrbek in Game 2" – It is indeed, as that was unsportsmanlike conduct for which Hrbek should have been either warned or ejected! Alex Rodriguez was criticized far more for slapping Bronson Arroyo's glove. Hrbek pulling Gant off the bag was, *at best*, a bush league play; to my eyes, insofar as he was trying *successfully* to get one over on the umps, it was outright cheating, no more licit than the hidden ball trick and quite a bit less charming.

File this under World Series Plays That Would Have Been Affected by a Replay Challenge.

Kyle Harrison is quite close to spending the entire postseason on the active roster, yet never appearing in a game. Can you recall any other cases of that happening?

I can't think of any offhand. Crowd, got any nominees?

Who you got for WS MVP right now? Seems very close to me between Chourio and Contreras.

Yeah it's down to those two, I think. Chourio is 8-for-14 with a double, 2 RBI, 3 steals, and one big assist (the Hicks play), Contreras is 7-for-13 with 3 RBI, 3 caught stealing (in 7 attempts) and god knows how many successful challenges behind the plate. Either would be a reasonable choice but I can see Contreras getting it on the basis of handling the pitching staff.

OK, i just created a poll on that MVP question which published at the top of the chat, please vote if. you're still around.

Chris Turner (backup C) played zero innings for the 2000 Yankees. So it's probably backup catchers

Regarding the rostered players who didn't play in the postseason. Backup catcher makes sense.

Two O/U questions. (1) Skubal signing date: 11/15 (2) Total deal $400m. What say you?

I've got the Skubal capsule for our upcoming Top 50 Free Agents list, but I've only given these questions brief thought. My hunch is that his lack of a robust 32-start platform season and the impending lockout both keep him shy of $400 million, and if he signs before the lockout it will be in the final week. Like November 30ish

There had been whispers of Stephen Vogt interviewing in SEA (since then, they've been shot down). But it would seemingly require that he be traded to SEA. This got me thinking… what kind of return could a club expect for a manager? Cash? How do you unambiguously quantify a manager's contribution to a team?

Well, we've seen a few trades of managers in the 21st century. The Rays acquired Piniella and infielder Antonio Pérez rom the Mariners in exchange for outfielder Randy Winn — a 3-4 win player at his peak _ in October 2002. The White Sox acquired a couple of scrubs for Ozzie Guillen in September 2011, and the Blue Jays acquired Mike Aviles for David Carpenter and manager John Farrell in October 2012. The Winn return was widely viewed as an overpay, so I'd say that future returns aren't going to be guys who leave very big impacts even if it's a very good manager like Vogt.

Not exactly what the question is asking but Charlie Silvera won six World Series rings with the Yankees ('49-'53 and '56) and only appeared in a single game (1949 G2). Backup catchers again

notable, though those World Series didn't include additional rounds of playoffs.

The '82 Brewers were Harvey's Wallbangers. What should the nickname of this Brewers team be? Pat's Bats seems too, uh, pat.

Nothing alliterative or rhyming with Pat or Murph(y) comes to mind for me. Whatever it is, the bar is very high to beat Harvey's Wallbangers

Do you have any personal baseball "Mandela Effects"? For me, I could've sworn Harvey Kuenn was a hall-of-famer (not that I think he deserves it necessarily), to the point where I thought I remembered seeing a plaque for him in my book about the HOF I had as a kid.

Once in awhile I get confused about which popular 19th century players are in and which aren't, guys like Jack Glasscock, Bill Dahlen, and Tony Mullane, but I always figure it out before I have to go look it up. I know from recent experience that I tend to lump Roger Clemens and Pete Rose in with their Hall of Fame teammates whe I'm reeling off a list, then of course I have to go back and re-engineer those sentences.

Ok folks, that's it from me this week. No chat for me next week as we'll be dark for election day. Please go vote! And enjoy the rest of the World Series, if you can.

Looks like Contreras is winning World Series MVP poll by a 2-to-1 margin. Not sure if I have to close it separately or not. If not, I'll keep it open for those who come across the transcript
Thanks for stopping by!


Members-Only Game Thread: World Series – Oct 26, 2026

Welcome to our Open Game Thread for the World Series game today. Only Members can participate, and unlike our usual staff Q&A chats, your messages will be posted immediately.

Our Member community is made up of thousands of incredibly knowledgable baseball fans, and we think this is a great way to follow a game with like-minded baseball enthusiasts. We might even have some FanGraphs Staff drop in and join the fun. Please be courteous to your fellow Members, or you may find your chat privileges revoked.

It's 6:46?

7:47 here.

Was awaiting the fellow members with greater knowledge to arrive and impart Baseball Knowledge.

Busy weekend, mostly missed the first two games, but it is extremely good to be back!

Good news: The series doesn't start until the home team loses, so you didn't miss anything!

I think Rays fans get a really hard ride and I will straight up fight anyone who talks bad on the Trop but getting Jon Gruden to narrate the hype video is not awesome for the Rays

You think Dick Vitale wouldn't have done that if they'd called?

I don't know hockey but there had to be a Lightning available and willing

I think Nikita Kucherov is still drunk from the parade a couple years back

i have been kind of rooting for milwaukee but i am kind of hoping for them to win it at home

How is the Trop? That's one of the few parks that I haven't been to.

Simply awful , but I hate all indoor baseball, and I think Ty France agrees with me.

It's not just the indoor part, it's just so… empty and soulless in much of the facilities. The concourse has no personality or energy. Ray tank is kinda cool though

Glory Days came up on shuffle, good vibes

This was the only mildly obscene set of flair I could come up with

Who is the Baywatch reboot for?

horny people?

People of the land. The common clay of the new west. You know, morons.

The same people who got excited 40 years ago for it, and haven’t matured at all

Chourio will ….?

Sean can you ban anyone who badmouths the Trop? It's intimate and unique and has great food and really easy fan access, and for all its bland architecture and confused iconography it is instantly recognizable. When it's gone, baseball will be poor and less interesting for it, and I will not stand to have its virtues slandered by those who are either ignorant or have no taste

How is your press box seat?

Sure can! I also miss Three Rivers often.

Frankly we need more stadiums with unique and stupid ground rules, not fewer. Long live the Trop

I think PNC is wild overrated but I understand that this is a minority opinion and don't mind it remaining so. Hating the Trop is just too easy and evinces an outlook on life, liberty and baseball that I don't enjoy living alongside

I might not do your ban bidding after you said that about PNC Park.

Y'all know that the Oakland Coliseum, pre-Mt. Davis, was the best ever, right?

Been there.

Great summary!

I guess I can't stop anyone from begging for a restomod Camden Yards clone surrounded by luxury condos and a strip mall, anchored by a steakhouse with a player's name on it, it's a free country. But I won't let the tyranny of the boring go unchallenged

Since 2000, 11 teams have gone up 2-0 in the World Series. All 11 went on to win, only 2001 Yankees and 2019 Astros forced it to go beyond Game 5

Are you TRYING to jinx yourself?

I have tickets to game 6 and 7, so kinda?

The Tyranny of the Boring is my band name

Maybe I overestimate Chandler Simpson's speed, but I think he should've caught Yelich's bloop

that challenge was a Ben batsignal

Another bad challenge.

Another bad *early* challenge.

ohh, Taylor Walls' Devil Ray colored socks are so good

I know it's garish as hell but it's my favorite color scheme any major US sports team has had

Smoltz explaining the leniency of umpires east and west was fascinating. Does the data back it up? The way he was talking made me think he had the numbers but didn't want to lose the casuals.

I am sick and tired of John Smoltz

I hadn't seen Contreras in a while before the playoffs, when did he change where he holds his hands pre-swing? Used to be instantly recognizable but now he's doing something more conventional

OK I need to get out of here before I miss even more of the game berating our paying customers

Joe Davis try not to say “fastball freddy” challenge

if we're not paying to be berated at by baseball minds, then i dont know what my moneys going to

I figured getting yelled at by Baumann was an MVP level perk, he's out here just giving away the goods

looking at Vilade batting 2nd, Williamson batting 5th, etc. and frantically pulling up platoon splits to try to understand the Devil Ray Magic

St Petersburg consistently choosing the Devil Rays jerseys is Metal AF

Former Indianapolis Indian Ryan Vilade

Maybe the answer to competitive balance is for MLB to force the Dodgers to hire Smoltz as their POBO or manager

Can't believe I've never thought of trying to Harrison Bergeron the Dodgers, it's genius

Williamson is fifth so that Hicks can hit for him the moment the Brewers bring in a righty. It's bait.

Generally not a huge fan of batting order discourse but I’m trying hard to understand why third is the best spot for Simpson

Simpson 3rd vs a lefty is certainly a choice

I hope this means Caminero told them he hates hitting 3rd, but even if so, there have to be better options. Maybe they're leaning into how often the 3 hole comes up with 2 outs and nobody on in the 1st? And Caminero doesn't make enough contact to bat 2nd? I would just bat Caminero 3rd.

Smoltz is so annoying.

well that should quiet the simpson at 3rd haters

That was probably his average exit velocity

Steve Stone for world series broadcast when

Shoutout to Davy on that play.

Damn, Davy's article from today is instantly proven prescient

Holy crap Davy is prophetic

Big yikes, Chandler

Sucks that he got tagged out, but that play makes me want to see just how fast Simpson could go on a Slip N Slide

I don’t think I’ve ever seen such a cleanly stolen Bose turn into an out because the runner was simply going too fast still.

chandler simpson this inning was that Mike F tweet

"Check this s**t out motherf**ker [I slide one foot out from under me and fall on my ass, its not clear what kind of move I was trying to do]"

Maybe it's just me, but batting Ryan Vilade 2nd is way more egregious than batting Simpson 3rd

I get Simpson is absurdly fast but man I wonder if you just let Caminero hit there

Oh my god

Holy crap what a catch

WHAT A CATCH WOW

He just flew through the air.

Holly Chandler Simpson

Wow

Chandler Simpson can fly

Holy s**t! I hope he’s okay

That was awesome

Quite the wall face plant, amazing catch.

I would literally die if I hit the wall like that

Sensational. Seldom do you see a player hit the wall much harder than that.

I actually expected him to go through the wall Wile E. Coyote style.

This game absolutely rules

The Trop is rocking!

That was like Wile E. Coyote running into the tunnel painted on the wall. Wow. Ouch.

I have no idea how the hell he stood up after that – I'm pretty confident they would be picking up my carcass from the dent it left in the wall

I'm still down and I was watching on TV

rare i didn't see yours, i type slow

Hard not to think of Looney Tunes after that

That catcher throw would've been more impressive if Chandler hadn't just happened. Timing is everything.

Does anyone actually enjoy coaches/players being interviewed mid game? Who is this for?

His family to see he isn’t hurt.

(outdated answer) to see if La Russa is slurring his words yet in the 3rd inning

I was just typing almost exactly this. The only one that was ever worth watching was Freddie Freeman during spring training that one time. 99% of the time they're cringe inducing

Leave that kind of stuff for the all star game

I was saying this yesterday during the NFL games. They don't tell me anything and are really pointless.

Every time I see Chourio hit I can't believe he ever makes an out. Somehow it seems like every swing is a great swing.

Bauers looked like he wanted to go back and keep hitting. He's had so many long at-bats he's forgotten what short ones are like.

This would be a great time for the hidden ball trick

That wouldn't have happened if they'd done the hidden ball trick

guytappingforehead.gif

wow a lot happened there

PLAY GLORY DAYS

Lotta outs on the bases in this series/game

the secondhand embarrassment I felt knowing that the ball would also bounce between my feet for 10 seconds

If I had to reach between my legs and slightly behind myself like that, I would 1000% fall on my ass

time never moves slower than this moment

The Rays are very lucky the Brewers had a TOOTBLAN.

That needs to be an error. Bauers held up before the ball was muffed.

lol nope! In fact Mesa got an assist! Enjoy your earned run Freddy!

Smart by Mesa Jr to pretend to mess that up just to bait the runner /s

Tony La Russa comment made me think of 3 nights in August. Good book. I want to read it again now. Also just found out same author Bissinger wrote the mosquito bowl which is being turned into a movie rn

That Contreras bloop is an easy out in the OF alignment experiment in the AFL now, IMO, since corner OFs are positioned in and close to the lines.

I hate that. It's going to kill doubles down the line too. Not a fan.

I also saw Kilby drop an 8 iron deep fly on the warning that only a double due to the alignment. Saw three games of it live.

It also feels really weird to make the outfielders stand in designated spots but allow the infielders to shift (within limits). I worry that the AFL OF positioning rule would be a slippery slope to forcing all fielders to stand in designated spots.

I know the games have been kind of close but it just feels like the Brewers are always going to win/

I have that same annoying feeling, and I hate it.

That how destiny works

Having watched them this postseason I have to say this feels like a really, really good and complete team. One of the best of the decade. If they win this series they'll be more than deserving as a champion.

Yeah the universe is definitely pulling for the Brewers. Everything 50/50 is going their way

I don't care if they win, I just don't want 4 games.

I am fascinated by Contreras preemptively putting his hand towards his helmet to challenge before the call even happens. I'm sure it's just to be ready but I do wonder if it goads the umpire into a strike call, too

I can't remember if it was Ceddanne Rafaela or Wilyer Abreu this year who was so determined to challenge he challenged a call that went his way.

I noticed this too, if I was home plate ump or opposing coach/manager I would say something, can’t really be having him possibly influencing ump’s calls like that. not hating tho I love how aggressive Contreras is with his challenges

(also hi)

Contreras' slow nod when he won the challenge was so, so satisfying

absolutely a GIF

Smoltz is an idiot – I have no idea who his fanbase is anymore. It's just so regressive

I do think Smoltz was right about that challenge, tbh

in the sense that the upside wasn't worth it?

Yeah. It was really really close, not an egregious call by the umpire, and it's Taylor Walls up by two runs with nobody on

I actually don't mind it if the catcher is THAT good at it.

Even if he was right that is still a terrible challenge.

I would pay $100 to get Smoltz off the broadcast and replace him with almost anyone else

would you pay smoltz that $100?

Does he need it?!

Here in Canada we have different announcers. Sportsnet has their own broadcast team for the WS.

it's Votto'clock

How are they?

Please don't give him a chance to rub it in

At least for me in Canada, the play-by play is Dave Flemming who I love. Looks like his color man may be Ryan Spilborghs, who apparently does Rockies radio now?

Spilborghs is a regular on MLB radio.

So far this definitely feels like a series between a 100+ win team by Pythag or BaseRuns in the stronger league, and a 88-90 win team by Pythag or BaseRuns in the weaker league.

(unless the series is in OOTP)

Is it too much to ask for the OOTP version of that same matchup (when you're controlling the 100 Pythag win team) for the next few games?

what the hell I can't believe I got beaten to the punch on the OOTP reference

Hello yall! Finally joining, great game so far.

Called that a swing.

Deep breath, Coop

The tradition of, shall we say, old-school announcers is what it is, but what is shocking about Smoltz is how many of his sentences are literally tautological. I wish I could remember the example from game 2 that had me chuckling–something about value being valuable.

You just gotta say what you gotta say, you know? Those who played the game, played the game, and they understand that it is what it is and it's gonna be what it's gonna be.

Reminds me of the basketball scene from Bedazzled

At least twice a game he'll start a metaphor and completely lose the thread halfway through, then just babble until the PBP guy saves him

Agreed

Watching this series I return to the thought that the American League was really terrible this year. I think if the Brewers and the Rays were in the same division, the Brewers would be 15 games better than the Rays. The Rays might be the 6th or 7th best team in the NL.

It's weird to me to think of NL being so strong.

The Rays were probably something like the 4th – 6th best team in baseball this year but the AL was so bad they looked like juggernaut. Sometimes the underdog wins anyway but

Brewers not playing small ball today?

imo smoltz has drastically improved his attitude on the broadcast toward modern baseball over the last few years but it still feels like he’s doing it begrudgingly

I still think there should be a Fangraphs announcer at all games to insert hella random stat facts

Didn't Meg do some AFL games or something like that?

Like how players do on their bobblehead day?

Rays BLEPH- is 73.2

Contreras for WS MVP?!

Contreras NAILING every challenge is just watching someone who is a step function above at something just nailing it

It's the obvious disdain that really makes it.

Wow.

@Sean Dolinar: How do I get post-season games to show up in a player's game log?

We don't have that in the game logs on the player pages, but you can see something similar on the splits leaderboards: https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders/splits-leaderboards?positi…

I thought that was a bad decision to challenge. I was wrong.

Agree it was a bad one…for mortals

It was still a bad challenge. Too much risk in a low leverage situation.

Given the value of strikeouts it seems like a challenge that results in a k is almost always worth it.

Contreras has been like this all season, he challenges way more often than anyone else, he's right more often than not, and he's right at only a slightly below-average rate. Why would he change now? Why should he? It's been working.

Contreras clearly has the psychic old lady on his side

The super obvious fake Jamacian?

I haven't thought about Miss Cleo in a very long time

Peralta for Adam Lind trade keeps me up at night ngl

Man I wish there was an election coming up.

And now all Im thinking about is whether Miss Cleo actually did predict the grifting future and just try and start early with the… Whatever these idiots will literally believe anything bit.

Every team of destiny is a small market Central Division team with an iconic fan favorite catcher who will be elected to the Hall of Fame as a result of their World Series performance in spite of their otherwise iffy case.

No finger wag?

That boy nice

Chourio + Contreras = Critical Cs

Caibo Cids? Big stretch both VEN born

I think Chourio has the talent to win an mvp

(Frantically trying to figure out whether Endy Rodriguez, Henry Davis, or Rafael Flores Jr. is up to the task.)

Endy would be great if he could simply stop being injured all the time

We could turn this into Pirates chat real fast. But then everyone else will leave.

(Yes, I already know the answer.)

The way the Brewers bullpen has been pitching, this feels like it's 5-0.

I said it after Game 2, but I think this series will be a real test if seeing the same reliever a few times is an advantage (Im thinking Uribe vs Caminero as an example). I'm unaware of any great studies on the topic (seems like a cool fangraphs article topic) but my mental model is something like the 3rd time through the order penalty?

little surprised there isn't a canonical article about this given how often it's discussed in the manager report card series.

Why Nick Martinez for multiple innings tonight? Don't they have enough real relievers to cover effectively after Peralta leaves?

Maybe I am wrong but I thought the consensus on Chourio was that he is likely already at his peak? Not all young players improve toward their mid 20's

He improved a lot this year and is only 22. I have a hard time imagining this is his peak

Trout was never better than he was at 22? Acuna? Heyward?

Sure it's possible. But he was a top prospect, in the majors at 20, and 4.6 war isn't as hard to top as those other guy's age 22 seasons

I don't think he had an obvious peak this year. His high BABIP of .348 this year is suggestive he just had the kind of year that ends up being a peak year in retrospect, often. But I could never assume he isn't capable of more, even if the probability is 15%

Don't get me wrong… dude is phenomenal at baseball… just not sure where the upside is for more? Could very easily hit for more power as he ages but feel like the rest will decline.

I think there's plenty of room to improve his approach. Probably some meat on the bone defensively too. I think he's got a 7 win season in there he can unlock

There's some room to grow the walk rate if pitchers work around him due to more power.

Oh ill take the under there… odds?

I'd say Trout was at his best at 26. His two best WAR seasons were 20 and 21, but he was a better, more complete hitter in 2018-19, and I think that's the version I'd rather have on my team.

This is fair I was just picking off the top of my head… There is surely a better example out there.

I'd take 3:1 on him having a 7 win season at some point haha

Ok so we agree not likely

Yeah it's not a gimme but I think he has the talent to pull it off. Most guys don't, but he's in the class of guys who could make it happen is all I'm saying.

Julio Rodriquez is a better example of what you are trying to say IMHO.

Rodriguez could win an mvp too! These are young talented players who have some room for growth. I like Chourio's trajectory a little better but Rodriguez is great too

Good call

I don’t think there is any consensus at all about Chourio. There were only something like a dozen rookie position players younger than him this year. He’s 22 and could easily add another full grade of raw power and / or improve his swing decisions. Or he could not do those things, but I think chances are one of them happens.

Peralta's never been a surgeon, but I wonder if he's getting a little tired and losing command because he's been throwing max effort.

Looks safe to me.

Safe, but you gotta try something.

Second base didn’t give a great stretch on that.

Did not think we'd see Booser this early.

Cheers for the overturn–how many Brewers fans are in the stadium?

Still a nice try by Caminero who is showing a lot more glove than he was given credit for.

reminder that Ben Williamson is a Ray because of Dave Cameron and Jeff Sullivan

The crew can do no wrong

Chandler Simpson's noodle arm is why Contreras could score there.

Is this series over? Man.

Is now.

"They think it's all over…It is now!"

This used to be an interesting WS.

oof I feel for the Rays but the Brewers feel like the ultimate team of destiny right now

GLORY DAYS

I and all of the over 50 Brewers fans needed this.

I'm a 49-year old Brewers fan and also needed this

Brewers are team of destiny. I will be happy to see them win, but I was really hoping the Rays would bring one home after years of being so good with so little.

Ooh, we should get a Brandon Woodruff cameo later now.

I agree, this is the perfect time to let him have his moment.

Won't be for a while. Gasser's only thrown 44 pitches with 1 H and 0 BB, surely the Brewers will just ride him for a while.

TB kinda BABIP'd CLE so I dont feel so bad about this

Well that got out of hand quickly

Nothing against Cam Booser, but maybe he wasn't the right guy to bring in?

FWIW, having railed on Smoltz earlier, that line "it breaks you down" is where the announcers + context as a baseball player resonated

Groundball to 3B, groundball to SS, chopper in the hole, chopper down the line, 5 runs

There is one thing that's still missing from the forthcoming "team of destiny" movie. Ex-MVP/Captain near the end of his career needs to hit an iconic homerun. I mean, tonight the man's got two hits, a walk, and a great overturned call after which he scored. But the scriptwriters are begging for a homerun in Game 4.

Vogelbach sighting

Why are we hanging out Booser to dry here… I get the game is likely lost but, feels bad.

I thought the Brewers were better than the Rays. But I didn't think it would be like this. Amazing how the Rays' strengths–exploiting pitching matchups, defense, all the stuff around the edges–just seem to be kind of evaporating.

Almost like a few games is a bad way of deciding which team is actually better?

Bring back the best of 9!

Well, yes. But I am still surprised.

This is a thing that the Brewers do very well too, and has always evaporated for them in the playoffs as well. In the playoffs it’s hard to optimize because a lot of the scrubs you face in the regular season aren’t playing in a best of 7.

Only question now is whether the Brewers sweep again.

It’s crazy to me that the Brewers have only lost one game this postseason. And aside from this one and one game against the Dodgers it hasn’t felt like any of them were one-sided.

They have come from behind in nearly every game, it really is amazing.

Has Sulser been on this roster the whole time?

Wait. I thought *you* brought him….

Time to start googling "biggest blowouts in the WS"

1936 WS, Yankees 18-4 over the Giants.

Wait this genuinely has to be a record right for a WS Game? 7 straight 2 out hits?

GTP returned this…The absolute maximum number of consecutive hits by one team in any single World Series inning is 6 consecutive hits. In 1908!!

Ouch this is demoralizing for TB. Letting game 2 slip away is going to haunt them

Brewers could outscore the Packers from yesterday

good lord

At least I can go to bed at a reasonable time

I needed a good night's sleep.

Ok this is a parody at this point no?

oof

We going to see Woodruff tonight?

can't wait for the Rasmussen/Martinez switcheroo 3000 word deep dive

Has there ever been a position player pitcher in a World Series game? Surely not, right?

Just googled it. Never in the WS. Twice in the postseason. https://almostcooperstown.substack.com/p/a-position-player-h…

Just googled it. Never in the WS. Twice in the postseason. Cliff Pennington in 2015 and Austin Romine in 2018, both in the 9th inning.

we going see woodruff bat tonight?

It was a fun question… Chat GTP thinks…The absolute maximum number of consecutive hits by one team in any single World Series inning is 6 consecutive hits. In 1908!

For any lurking Rays fans, they have an opportunity to have the largest comeback in WS history (I assume)

Yup. Record comeback is from 8 runs down.

Game 4, 1929. The A's scored 10 in the 7th to overcome an 8-0 Cubs lead.

That's such a 1909-2015 Cubs thing to happen

Contreras lol – is that the equivalent of stealing a base up 10?

Every Brewer in the starting lineup has outscored the Rays so far

That's just mean.

Gahdamn bill that is an ice cold challenge right there

That inning reminded me of the 2003 NLCS but without the controversy

Through Ben Williamson all things are possible, so you can write that down

Brewers radio just confirmed that 7 straight 2-out hits is a WS record.

I have a old time book about the World Series (ends with Koufax in the 1960's) and the 1929 chapter is called The Big Inning

What's the book called?

Should Murphy let Gasser throw 100 pitches and give the bullpen a night off?

Until the score is within five or so, absolutely.

Unless he starts looking shaky or gets hurt I say let Gasser gas

That, or maybe today is finally the day for Kyle Harrison

Vogt would be bringing in Smith!

At this rate Gasser won't need to throw 100 pitches because he's going to throw a Maddux.

Greatest World Series Thrillers by Ray Robinson

Woah, the 10-run inning in 1929 was a comeback from down 8-0. That is a lot more of a thing!

It's so old I have the copy from my dad's elementary school library, and also the copy from my own middle school library

I'm curious how we get multiple Ashby innings tonight

Glad I was in the car with my daughter watching that together

Very happy to read that and check your flair and see MIL and not TB!

I hope you weren't on the road driving!

Presumably they were sold for being outdated and my dad and I are big enough baseball dorks that we brought them home

[guytappingheadinaRayscap.gif]: Don't have to face Ashby if you're down by 10.

Been hearing an upsetting number of songs I love in commercials lately

So at the end of the Chat GTP commercial, They all die on the boat right?

They boil away the seas with all the greenhouse gas emissions and walk to the smoldering remains of civilization.

Worst shutout loss in WS history is 12-0. Yankees over Pirates, game 6, 1960.

Proof that the Rays can still win, if you ask me.

Smoltz and Davis sound like they don’t want to be there anymore

"I don't even want to be around anymore" -Carl Havoc

"The hell with it, no one is listening anyway." Come on. We need a Uek ref

Another very curse- era cubs fact, from the book: The same pitcher was on the mound for the Cubs at the beginning of the Big Inning who gave up Babe Ruth's called shot in 1932: Charlie Root

1991: Carl Willis gave up a cycle in the 8th inning of a 14-5 loss.

I love that in that 8 run inning, the same guy (Bauers) somehow made the 2nd and 3rd outs of the inning. Baseball.

He's getting teased mercilessly for that.

Kangaroo Court is going to come for his whole playoff share.

And did it the same way. Fly ball to Simpson.

So, looking ahead, do 3-0 leads in the playoffs turn into sweeps any more or less often than you'd expect?

Very surprisingly a strong YES… ~75% sweeps

Brewers still running, wow.

In the regular season, losses this big seem easy to shake off. It's just one weird game where nothing went our way, it happens, we'll get 'em tomorrow. In the WS, seems like it'd be harder to shake off.

Kevin Millar voice: “don’t let Tampa win one!”

Time for picking Dave Roberts first in the vanquished opponents players/mangers draft?

Maybe Tampa should try a different jersey tomorrow

Man Kevin Brown got so robbed of the ‘98 CY

I pulled up the leaderboard and instantly went…"It must have been Maddux… nope Glavine???"

Literally 100 more Ks and 25 fewer BB than Glavine. But of course Glavine got 20 Ws so everything else goes out the window

haahahahaha

Contreras man

What can you even say anymore?

I get it. If William says it's a strike, it's a strike.

Grant Brisbee used to have a great bit that we should just let Brandon Belt call his own balls and strikes and I think it needs to be updated to Contreras

I’m gonna go on Kalshi and bet my life savings on the Rays.

Life savings = 50 cents? Because then it may be a good investment…

Gasser making a hipster WS mvp case

Getting handshakes now.

Gasser is done? Darn. I wanted him to go for the shutout.

just joined. Huge Crew fan who moved to Milwaukee from So

Let’s just all agree to award Vogey WS MVP regardless of the outcome of the series

Ueker… its a bit too late but would be fun.

Is there a write-in space on the ballot?

Gasser threw 90+ pitches eight times this season, including 100+ twice

Somebody get Smoltz some coffee!

Oh please NO!! Let him fade out!!

I know nobody likes Smoltz, but it seems like WS blowouts must be hard for any announcing crew to call. If you're a local crew calling a regular season blowout, you can talk about nonsense just to pass the time. Can't do that in the WS.

I wonder if John Kruk or Steve Stone are available to fill in for Smoltz the rest of the game?

Joe Davis also decides to leave and it's Kruk & Keith for the remainder

SoCal in 1999 and lived there till 2016. Became a huge Brewers fan. Bought 3 full season tickets for next season so I could get WS tickets. It'll be a long commute from SoCal but it looks like it was worth it! Being at Game 1 with my wife and adult son was one of the most memorable experiences of my life. And we were at Dodger Stadium for game 4 too. Sports fandom can be heartbreaking until it isn't.

Cool to be at those games!

I think you hang in there, keep repeating anything can happen, bring up the things ya’ll are

As a CLE fan from the 90's I hated ATL, but liked Smoltz the player… Always thought he was fun. So the dislike for his announcing is kinda honest.

I kinda liked him as a person his one year in Boston, which was terrible. He was very frank in interviews.

Seeing the NL representative perform like this against AL does feel very on brand for the 2026 season….

Oooof, this WE Graph: https://www.fangraphs.com/scores?date=2026-10-26. That Top 5th span is just so big!

The chat did correctly call that at 2-0 the game felt over

Already talking about tomorrow lol

Fearsome 3 hole hitter Chandler Simpson

Chandler Simpson is fun as they come but him only running a .331 BABIP and a .049 ISO gives the story away. He has no power at all.

Bauer needs a hit, cmon..

Can we get Contreras to pitch the 9th?

Is that allowed?

Strongly Strongly frowned upon but allowed!

Milwaukee is probably too good to let this happen but I felt a weird premonition when Bauers struck out in the first that in that moment he turned into a pumpkin again and spent all of his good baseball playing ability

The Rays trying to chase all sorts of tiny edges (and possibly overthinking it in the process) definitely hits different given how this series has played out so far. Saving your ace for game 2, sitting Aranda vs. a lefty, and batting Vilade second all come off as kind of sad when you're getting squashed.

Yung Gravy

Getting billing over TOM CRUISE!

Don’t even know who he is

I want to see Contreras pitch just to see if his ABS challenge magic works from 60 feet away.

Wait until he challenges his own pitch. Then the alternate reality opens.

The human. Oracle.

The Human Oracle? What are we doing here

They are hurting for something to talk about, I guess?

Are there non-human oracles?

This is what I thought. I thought oracles were almost exclusively clairvoyant women getting high on gnarly volcanic sulfur fumes

Are people riffing on US commercials that I can't see because I'm in Canada? Should I start riffing on Canadian commercials?

I think the chat has spiraled

Just commenting on what Smoltz, Davis and co. are yammering about.

If it's about All Dressed chips, Pizza Pizza's garlic cream sauce or milk in a bag, then yes!

Just because your election of stupidity is over does not mean you have to rub it in…

Murph managing like it’s Little League. Everyone gets to play

He better put Woody in.

I would love to know what Tom Cruise thinks about The Trop

Announcers have totally given up

Does Pat Murphy still look pissed off?

How do you tell?

fyi Gary Sanchez is the Brewers official position player closer.

Joe Davis goes home and takes the edge off with a long, tall glass of almond milk with dodger blue food coloring

Star Wars ref?

did you see the shot of Murph and Dickie V? I think they went to high school together.

Cruise played a Mummy hunter and Reacher. Playing an Oracle in a 300 Movie wouldnt be stretch

Grant Brizbee in his article on the commercials pointed out that he had no idea what the Sidney Sweeny commercial is advertising … He is right.. I still dont.

Tanning lotion I think

Modesty

I actually think Pat should manage like little league now…let Woodruff take the 9th, make sure Drohan and Harrison are in the G4 plan

I think the Rays didn’t use the right rum with Jobu

Jobu will not forget this typo! Is very bad to misspell Jaboo's name… IS VERY BAD!

What typo

Commercials I never need to see again: HP, Liberty, T-Mobile

My mom is legit offended by the one making fun of the people using the stairlift. Think its one of the insurance ones?

Was it discussed why Cash didn’t bring in Baker after Peralta? He’s not pitched this Series so has to be rested. He’s their best reliever. High leverage situation

I honestly think simpson may have thought… Screw that, im not diving again there

I am in Calgary. I will trade you HP, Liberty, and T-Mobile commercials for Firehouse subs and the Ontario government.

Deal

Woodruff is warming up! Love that

that'll leave Drohan and Harrison as the only two of 26 who haven't been used yet

I think batters should have the choice of not accepting first on a HBP

Strike zone bigger than the mascot

Do we think that challenge was a bit of having a laugh by the rays?

I know the Rays don't draw, but still shocked just how many Brewers fans there seem to be in the park tonight. It's the World Series!

I mean ya kinda saw that coming

shhhhhhh

thats just mean to woodruff

Should have floated one Rowengartner-style

We have at least one more of these tomorrow! Hopefully it's a more interesting game. Good night all!


Ben Clemens FanGraphs Chat – 10/26/26

Read the rest of this entry »


Members-Only Game Thread: World Series – Oct 24, 2026

Welcome to our Open Game Thread for the World Series game today. Only Members can participate, and unlike our usual staff Q&A chats, your messages will be posted immediately.

Our Member community is made up of thousands of incredibly knowledgable baseball fans, and we think this is a great way to follow a game with like-minded baseball enthusiasts. We might even have some FanGraphs Staff drop in and join the fun. Please be courteous to your fellow Members, or you may find your chat privileges revoked.

Hi everyone! We had an interesting ending last night. Hopefully tonight will be just as fun! We got our standard polls and a redux of our Rasmussen poll with a little dash hindsight.

Hello Sean!

I have just Seen Everything

I still need to watch The Rehearsal.

I've got a Brewers fan friend coming over for the game and he's bringing spotted cow. So I might be pulling for the Brewers tonight at least

I'm jealous. I wish I had friends this good.

I know there's alot of baseball left, but if last night was any indication, this is gonna be a great World Series. Go Orioles! Wait….never mind. Go Baseball!

The real winner this WS is Brat Rangoon

I have heard so much about spotted cow I had to do some research. Looks like it is tough to find here in CT.

It's light but quite tasty. Made by a small brewery in SW WI.

It used to be impossible or at least really hard to find outside of Wisconsin. I think it's still that way, but I haven't been there since 2023. When I did have to buy a Spotted Cow from the hotel, because State St. Brats closed early over Thanksgiving weekend.

Yeah my friend has family in Wisconsin and goes back periodically so presumably that's where he got it

Whoops!

What is a quintessential TB area thing?

This is going to be hard. The closest I've been recently is Orlando.

I saw everything the other night, and I cannot unsee anything

Saw it last week. My question is why we didn't get to see Nathan in the shower.

Pratt fall

More like Pooper Cratt, am I right?

You misspelled “Crapp”. 😉

Pratt's defense was said to be superb in the minors, but he has been a downgrade defensively compared to Ortiz.

Joe Davis calling the game from the future there saying "Tampa Bay unable to take advantage" with only 1 out

Must've been an alternate future, then!

Do I have to be watching the game to contribute to the thread?

I'm running back and forth while cooking dinner

Chandler Simpson in the 3-hole pays off early.

Chandler Simpson showing you can have success with oppo soft swings. Well, at least *he* can.

I wonder if a player with exactly 0 HR's during the regular season has ever batted 3rd in a WS.

I really hope Simpson keeps getting better because he's so much fun to watch

Simpson's stature reminds me of 80s/early 90s era baseball players.

He's like a taller version of Lance Johnson, former ChiSox CF.

Beautiful steal.

I do like replays from the Umpcam. That shot down the LF line looked pretty awesome from it.

Love the crowd reaction shots at the end of replays.

Oh boy

Hicks hits it to the sticks

Thank you John Sterling.

Oh man … that ball was destroyed

What is going on?

And here I was ready for a pitchers duel

This one looks to be over early.

Wow

OK, who had Henderson going one inning? ‘Cause you might win that poll question.

Hi Jack!

Hey Sean!

Also, is it fair to take this into account in judging the Rasmussen decision? Could have won both, maybe.

Exactly!

They got some solid innings last night from Martinez and Matz. But one of those runs made a difference.

Do they have a drone over the field??

love that this happened after I saw tons of comments complaining about Hicks after yesterday

How’s this for a facile hot take: Henderson pitching like a rookie, Pratt fielding like a rookie.

Hey everybody!

He better be right, and he is.

New Q. How many Kyle Harrison innings are we getting tonight?

Too many!!

3?

I do notice the mean for Henderson’s IP on the poll question has ticked down a touch.

Was just wondering who’s gonna get mop up innings

Woodruff?

I am more convinced than ever that this thing is going to 7 games.

I’m guessing they go drohan? they at least trusted him against the dodgers and they probably rightly believe they can still come back

Excellent, my secret plan is working

Cooper's "prattfall" set a bad tone for that inning. Ortiz makes that play with ease. They lose some offense with Ortiz, but he's a nice boost to run prevention.

Liam Hicks and the Hot Licks

Chourio not ambushing that one!

As a Tiger fan I get all 🤬thinking about how Liam Hicks was in our system and was allowed to walk just last year, and then I remember, oh yeah, Dillon Dingler

There's still a lot of baseball. A lot can happen.

Sure, it's an early lead, but it's an even-numbered lead.

That Hicks homer killed the rally!

Also, it’s not a prime number

Love descriptive statistics

Wow here we go

Chourio is quite good.

As Ernie Harwell would say, “The Brewers are kicking up their heels!”

When was the last WS game where both teams scored double digits?

I can't think of any game since 2017 game 5

Date Game Score
Oct 20, 1993 Game 4 Blue Jays 15, Phillies 14 (at Philadelphia)
Oct 21, 1997 Game 3 Marlins 14, Indians 11 (at Cleveland)
Oct 20, 2002 Game 2 Angels 11, Giants 10 (at Anaheim)
Oct 29, 2017 Game 5 Astros 13, Dodgers 12 (at Houston, 10 innings)

I thought we agreed to never speak of that again.

My wife was like what’s up with the Brewers and I was all, that’s the team that’s led the AL all year

Thought the Brewers and Rays were known for defense. . .

They were, but Pratt isn't living up to his MiLB hype in that regard.

Hicks is gonna want to use an ABS challenge here

He really wanted to challenge there.

Old school baseball!

Wow the hit and run

Man, Contreras is dialed in situationally.

That looked like am inning ending double play off the bat.

Brewers doing Brewers things.

Anyone else not able to find this chat in the app?

It's in the newest iOS version released yesterday via a banner on the home screen. Android is still being worked on.

That atmosphere looks amazing.

These pitchers aren’t fooling anyone

They are fooling me — I thought they were both pretty good.

Turang wasn’t fooled on that 109 mph second out.

How much I miss the hit and run. It was such a part of the game when hitters could be relied upon to make contact.

I bet it comes back to the game again, and probably sooner than we think. Game is always evolving.

When they finally go to 100% robot ump calls on pitches, will catchers still frame out of habit?

I hope so: "Nice try, meatsack. Beep-boop!"

These offenses are really, really fun

Different sort of game than yesterday.

Pratt can now atone for his error…

Is Rasmussen knuckling his changeup? Looks like that’s what his middle finger was doing on that run-scoring single just now.

No, pretty sure he's taking it off, which is what you do for a kick change.

Looked like it was tucked under the ball was why I asked

Pratt going for Most Suckee Player

Oof, the hubris of Contreras

The very word a had in mind.

For anyone unable to watch on TV: Brewers have JoJo Romero warming

The start to this game makes me wish I was in a bar in Milwaukee watching all the miserable Brewers fans.

Brewers fans maybe a lot of things but miserable in a bar they are not.

Henderson really doesn’t like an 0-2 count

A sacrifice bunt with no outs is taking this small ball a little bit too far.

in the second no less

Maybe that's what my wife meant when she called me a sadness vampire.

Game feels like a pre pitch clock slog I love it

I'm more ok with this in the postseason. 4-hour games during the 162-game marathon was too much.

Both of these teams take absolutely gnarly ABs

Anyone else think maybe baseball should actively try to reduce foul balls?

How would you do that?

What are ya thinking?

I suppose this is a good outcome, but how in the world would you achieve that besides increasing infield popups?

make fair territory bigger

Maybe, on the 2nd out, 2 fouls for free and the next one is a strikeout?

Change the in-play angle from 90 degrees to 360 degrees, like cricket 🙂

The only way I can think of to reduce foul balls would be to replace the wizards pitching today with normal mortals.

Then we wouldn't get to see Tristan Peters and Jake Bauers wow us with their long, and terrific, AB's.

Loves me some Tristan Peters

Maybe the foul lines don't have to precicely coincide with the basebaths? Have them angle out a bit?

We're a numbers site, so I should have something to back this up, but I feel like the vast majority of foul balls are tips/to the backstop or dramatically in foul territory.

You'd definitely would be moving things at the margins if that's what you are going for.

The margins *are* where interesting stuff happens…

Pitchers need to figure out how to pitch to squarer contact, but not toooo square. Sounds hard

TIL William Contreras is only 0.1 fWAR behind his brother in terms of cumulative performance this decade.

My fav Kalshi commercial and I hate Kalshi

Pat Murphy is a leader

Re: making pitchers mortal, maybe moving the mound back a few inches is a way to go?

Yah or down

I've thought so for a while. Less guess hitting should lead to more contact w/o necessarily spiking HR

I think they tried that in the Atlantic league and it had the opposite effect. Walks went up, but so did strikeouts.

Nuts! It's almost like better-motivated peple than I have worked on this issue.

That was a garbage experiment that gets cited as definitive way too much. Of course guys struggled after playing their whole careers at 60'6" — move it back a foot now and reap the benefits in years 10-50.

Yeah it was pretty short lived. The extra distance does give breaking pitches more time to move, though. It makes sense that it didn't just make hitting easier.

Yeah it's the kind of change that can't be evaluated in a single season or even a few seasons, and MLB seems so concerned about unintended consequences that they won't implement something they can't just throw minor league (or indy ball) games at

Makes sense. So many of these changes depend on how long it takes for players to adapt.

I also liked a commenter's recent idea to make the rubber narrower. Such an easy fix that doesn't change the fabric of the game yet mitigates the extreme arm angles

I like this a lot!

No one would even notice!

The best kind of change! Like the pitch clock.

Good idea, but now I wonder what we can do with the plate. We made the bases bigger, we're making the rubber smaller, maybe we start having opposite day games where the plate is pointed the wrong direction

Hi Sean! ABS spon con is weird

My last five messages are "awaiting review," which is a bit on the nose for messages about ABS

I was just looking up how T-mobile actually powers ABS.

Surely it's some garbage about how their network is used to transmit the results, right?

Google AI was really getting some stuff wrong.

I might be missing something, but I'm not sure why ABS needs a private 5G network to work.

It needs a 5G network to get sponsored!

They're allowing them to use the emergency network for ABS actually, 911 calls won't go through in Milwaukee if Contreras taps his helmet

T-Mobile owns basically all the 2.5 GHz 5G spectrum for North America and they set up a private network inside stadiums reserving a slice of the band. Wi-Fi would be a bad idea because it's public so theoretically it could get congested.

Oh boy aranda

"The ABS challenge workflow relies on players (batters, catchers, or pitchers) tapping their helmet or cap directly on the field to trigger a review. A physical wire tether to a player or an umpire would be dangerous, cumbersome, and impractical during active play."

Alright, thanks AI.

This is trying to answer the 5G question.

From my cursory research…it's better solution than WiFi or other wireless solutions. And it looks like it simplifies the infrastructure build out for the operation of it.

Oh no Aranda 🙁

Daaaaaang!

Wow

Just finished my shift, I miss anything?

That was not a strike.

Agree

Should have been a walk

#replaceUMPs

Was only listening to that Rhapsido commercial and could've sworn they were advertising Rapsodo

Do you think about Vaughn at all here?

Im always thinking about Vaughn

The Aranda play finally convinced me, the Brewers are inevitable

maxRISP

SP poll is closed! Rasmussen didn't go 4 IP, but we had him at 5.2 IP mean and 6 IP median.

Henderson when 3 IP and we had him around 4.1 IP mean and 4 IP median.

I would imagine SPs go fewer innings in the post?

Trying and failing to think of someone whose stock has fallen further the last couple years than David Stearns

Clase

Alek Manoah

Why?

I knew I'd be wrong when I posted, I just didn't know HOW wrong (re: Clase)

"Mets rich and bad Brewers poor and good" was the core of my thinking

Wander Franco?

Wow yeah I whiffed hard on this one lol

Okay Pratt making up for his mistakes

MLB can’t be surprised that players bet, when they’re forcing betting apps down our throats

It’d be like if every other commercial was for steroids

OK but tbh I'm very intrigued by the idea of steroid commercials

Every other commercial *is* for pharmaceuticals. Odds are many of them are steroids.

Surprisingly, that pharmaceutical that clears your skin but may increase your risk of infection that was just advertised is not a corticosteroid, even though it sounds like one.

Thoughts about using Ashby while losing, even by just a run, given his workload? Is he going to pitch multiple innings in literally every game?

Oh, I guess Ashby isn't actually warming.

Cannot hit batters. Ever. In the post. Unless it’s intentional.

Palacios specs are no longer neon green??

I was looking closely after someone mentioned it last night, I thought they looked different!

I just found Waldo

That seemed very close

Didn't matter in the end.

Fireable send

Speaking of gambling…

Oof

Reminds me of the days of Wavin Wendell

Has a 3rd base coach ever been fired in-game?

Fire that 3B coach, Tampa.

Dumbest send in WS history

oh that was a dumb send

What in the Hicks?

Fortune favors the bold, they say, but yeesh.

Fortune also favors the scouting report

What was the dumb send the other day?

Hamilton trying to extend a double to triple?

Mesa trying to steal third

I guess if you sac bunt earlier in the inning you’re pot committed to the send with 2 outs *shrug*

Bunting only works for teams that don’t strike out a lot and make a good deal of contact. TB is one of those teams. So is MKE.

lol I was thinking the same thing about the umps guns

Friend of mine says Eduardo Perez calling the game on the radio said it was a good send. Eduardo Perez is objectively a dumb s**t.

Maybe Perez is calling the game blindfolded, it's not like you could tell by his analysis

Woah!!!!

No way

that's baseball

Maybe they are a team of destiny

Woot!!!!!

Brand new ballgame!

Lexington!

Brewers have a long lineup

Mitchell against the dodgers, frelick here, hamilton (not) triple yesterday

This is good baseball.

my partner's review of the Frelick home run: "Ohhh, he's so cute!"

I'll show her the face he made during that nutty '25 NLCS double play

That's the insight we need on these chats.

Sal Frelick will hold the door for you at Friendly’s and share his clown cone. America’s or at least the metro Boston area’s sweetheart

my partner: he looks kind of like Jerry Seinfeld. Unclear if this agrees or contradicts your partner's assessment

Fangraphs article idea, all time playoff series ranked by average number of two strike fouls per game

there's a cutie keeping score behind the plate too

love to see it

alan thinks the hp umpire is cute !?!

Front Row Amy. Quite famous in that area.

alan and umpy sittin in a tree

umpires don't keep score

Aren’t umpires actually the official arbiters of the score?

Yeah but they aren't responsible for keeping a record of it, they let an entirely different guy screw that up

I just don't think I see it for the Rays right now.

we've got dave flemming calling the game in Canada, nyeah nyeah

What, you’re not listening to Alain Usereau?! Sacre bleu!

Ump needs to focus less on his guns, more on his eyes

OK, let's make it a series. my partner's review of Chourio: "how does a 22 year old get that big?? I thought maybe he was 37"

Brian's partner should submit a community post about reactions to these guys

lockout post!

Chourio needs to focus less on guns more on strike zone

I’ll just backseat drive all the players

If I remember anything from age 9, it's that you're gonna walk guys if you look at third base while throwing the pitch

For exactly one pitch in my last year of little league I thought "varying my looks" meant throwing a no-look fastball because a guy was on third

What the ****

wat.

Huh.

That went from, oh crap, to WOW, to damn.

lol FOX thought that ball was so caught in left they went right to “end of 5th” on the score box

I caught that too

I love catching broadcast goofs!

Thank god there’s a pitching change so FOX has time to reboot the thing

did they both get lost in the lights?

So Yelich's strategy this WS is to have outfielders drop his fly balls?

I feel like im missing something here. Ball went in the glove, glove smacked the ground, ball popped out. Why was there not so much as a review?

I don't think you are wrong, because they get a bunch of challenges in the postseason. But that was not a catch in MLB or the NFL.

I believe that would have been Tampas last challenge. They lost one on that terrible send where they thought Contreras was blocking the plate

If I remember anything from age 9 it’s that I thought Donruss and Fleer were cool

Punp your brakes kid, those cards were a national treasure.

I LOVED Upper Deck.

now FOX saying that Taylor Walls is the batter against DL Hall

"Father McGrath! I thought you were dead!" "I was!"

they took the scorebug down

It's back and still wrong

Third times a charm?

They broke it!

Someone’s getting fired

joe buck better watch his back

Is it me?

Hopefully it's Tampa's 3rd base coach

RISPmaxed

Taylor Walks strikes again (balls again?)

Yandy is a fun name

i can't even make a joke that it's short for yandrew because it's pronounced with the long a

bizarre parallel brain moment

Abner is such an underrated name

Wow I didn’t know that!

first Abner in the majors since 1891

oh man, i've been feeling so weirdly low today and not even the baseball is helping

Kinda same, just one of those blue days

I hope your tomorrow is better

That double might raise your spirits!

every day is a roll of the dice, sometimes you come up empty, but most of the time it's chill

glad to see ya here!

it is always good to be in community, in meatspace and computerspace

Ohhh that was close

Chandler Simpson is such a funny 3 hitter

I finally get here. hi all

Chandler Simpson is a genius 3 hitter. the top 2 slots go to big power nowadays. Simpson makes sure you do not get a double play.

genius and comedy are not mutually exclusive

Two dramatic hits!

Doooohhhhh

It's kinda felt like Milwaukee has been in the lead ever since the Rays were up 4-2

Every third at-bat of this game has had something dramatic

Simpson does not walk enough to bat first. You dont care as much about the three hitter walking.

Peak Brewers-Rays-ball would be a suicide squeeze here

is Liam Hicks as good a fielder as contreras?

millville are you maximizing orange flair or still trying to spell something?

nimble dethoosfg?

I'm hoping for a reveal that he is Dutch

nimble looked fun, then i gave up lmao

feel like i have to shake things up though

i have happened upon something quite rude, oops

apparently changes are applied retroactively. I'm pleased to have caught the one this was posted with

Still kinda shook from last night when Sean mentioned that viewership was 44.8 million in 1978 vs. 8 million this year. I knew it was bad but not THAT bad

It seems like the statistical methods are sound for that 44.8 M number. But I'm still curious how accurate those ratings were back then.

It is harder to watch a game nowadays cause you have to pay someone to watch. in 1978 it was free on one of the three channels.

As accurate as any statistically sound large-sized sample would be.

Right but I doubt the methodology has been consistent for the last 40 years. TVs were probably not as evenly distributed demographically in 1978 as they are now, even if we have no reason to question how the sample was selected. There are a ton of ways the numbers could be skewed in the analysis.

My flare is the minimum. If its not the minimum change the rule.

Oh good lord why did you swing at that

In 1978 no one was playing Mario or Call of Duty or binge watching anything

I was playing pong for hours!

bla beep kA blunk….. bla beep ka blunk

Pratt redeems himself!

Sweet redemption for Cooper Pratt

Team of destiny, logic be damned

I'm rooting for the series to go 7. Go Tampa!

huh, I guess my digital antenna set up is behind by almost a full minute??

You can delay the chat using the settings cog in the top right

Really? I thought terrestrial broadcast would be the fastest!

Brewers stringing together ABs

Thanks for answering my question, Liam!

I am LOVING all the SBs

lol omg almost

And just like that Cooper Pratt with the RTBLAN

partner's review of the Frelick flyout: "he's just a little guy!"

I thought that was going

Brewers radio has tricked me into thinking there was a home run twice this inning. In Boston we used to call this a "Trupiano," or, as a verb, "to Trup" (pronounced "troop").

I thought that was long gone

Did you have home pong or spend a ton of nickels in arcades?

I was the cool kid!

home

Someone please remind me how I add the team flair?

Click the little gear, top right of the chat.

the flairs dont show in the chat replay, right

I export a transcript for the blog post. But these persist on the chat url. We're still feeling out how to transition editorially.

i fear i happened upon a crude flair combo that i would not like to be perma attached to , um.

Thank you!

Diarrhea, nausea, and vomiting? Yeah, I am feeling all of those right now…

Symptoms suggest prolonged exposure to John Smoltz

Hmm. A second inning from Abner? He didn't do this too much during the regular season.

Caminero has a lifetime BELPH of .105 against RHP who pitch from the stretch on Saturdays.

is belph correlated with bleph at all, or are they separate metrics

BELPH is BLEPH standardized for park, weather, beer type, and amount of under eye

I heard someone is working on OwBLEPH+

This series is gonna be a great exercise in how much seeing a reliever multiple times in a series matters

if I learned anything from this strategy being deployed in 2019, it's that eventually we'll get Surprise Fernando Rodney

Yeah to be clear I have no idea but maybe it’s a versions of third time through the order?

After seeing these short sleeve hoodies, I'm wondering if we've reached peak hoodie.

fwiw i almost always roll the sleeves of my hoodies up, i don't fully understand why

Or if the hoody has hit rock bottom

Ryan Vilade went to the barber and asked for the Bo Bichette

Ryan Vilade taking an at bat in the World Series would've been a hilariously ridiculous thought like 3 years ago

that last play had an xBLEPH+ of 42!

But it had an xBLEPHCON+ of 156! Talk about unlucky!

my partner's review of Front Row Amy: "I mean, if you pay for it, you gotta show it off"

Good story about FRA in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. She seems like a nice person: Married to her high school sweetheart and they have a few kids together and live in Oshkosh. Not what I expected.

These close games are amazing and great entertainment, but I hope there's one where the score gets wide enough that Woodruff gets to pitch. Just check and he somehow hasn't pitched in the playoffs since 2021?

how about a 15th inning game?

I've long thought Yelich looked like an 80s teen movie villain. Curious about Brian's partner's take.

if its a ski movie, then I agree

There we go. Just hit it.

I have a man crush on Contreras and I’m not afraid to admit it.

What’s the record for 1 and 2 run wins over the course of a postseason?

The record is 8 postseason wins by one or two runs.

Team 1-run wins 2-run wins Total postseason wins
1996 Yankees 5 3 11
2001 Yankees 5 3 10
2020 Rays 3 5 11
2025 Dodgers 5 3 13

Eight more teams are one behind at 7: the 1992 Blue Jays, 1997 Indians, 2000 Yankees, 2003 Marlins, 2005 White Sox, 2010 Giants, 2014 Royals and 2022 Astros.

Notably, the Yankees were outscored in the 1996 World Series despite winning in six games.

Chandler Simpson throws like a guy in a 45+ men’s amateur league.

Almost slid past the base. That was closer that the real time looked.

Almost looked like he threw his shoulder out trying to stay on the bag

I and the fans of at least 27 other teams are so jealous of the fire in the Brewers team.

We need to discover more Contreras brothers, they're like magic for a team's vibes

NATS had that fire before the trade deadline. Then they didn't.

Who was he throwing to? The 2B ump?

Hicks getting some butterfingers for Halloween

partner's take on Contreras: "he looks like he feels the weight of the whole world on his shoulders."

I think his foot got in there

He looked safe live

I think that was a terrible tag by Fortes

Matz feels like an odd choice here right? lol not meant to be a reply

He scored! It’s gonna be 6-4

EDIT: ehhh, win some, lose some

Wow, assumed he was out by a mile when that throw came in but looking at the replay that looks almost too close to call

oh I don't think you can overturn that

It's the toe they have see? I haven't seen enough to overturn.

I don't know if there's enough there, but in real time, I thought he was safe

That's the right call.

So interesting how Fortes appeared to move his foot to avoid blocking the plate, which surely led to the awkward tag.

go Tampa!!!

you're choosing Elijah Dukes over Junior Spivey, huh?

point taken. I am retired, so i want it to go 7

Too close to overturn I guess but that's rough by Fortas to even make that play close

I thought the Brewers had a better shot overturning the call on whether the runner tagged the plate versus the obstruction challenge.

Raise your hand if you want the Rays to score one so we go into the bottom of the inning tied. 🖐️

I just want more baseball.

I'm rooting for the Brewers in this match but I'd love to see more baseball

Exactly!

You mean the 12th right?

@raregokus Sure, why not!

There will be more on Monday and Tuesday, so let's just wrap it here, OK?

Oh, yeah!

RISPmaxxing

Using the last challenge on the first pitch of the 9th inning in a one-run game feels suboptimal

both of his challenges feel like they had weird timing

The lost ones, anyway

When you’re feeling bulletproof like that guy is right now, you become more impervious to risk.

Huh, this is interesting.

Terrible pitch

Bunting here is asinine

This series is awesome

How did he not take third there?

victor victor mesa mesa jr is my favorit non Nationals or X Ntionals player!

maybe not

If I had played baseball in CUBA my hero would have been Victor Mesa.

I have no clue what a check swing is

Nobody does!

Just like knowing what a balk is.

Dr. Baseball101 asks: what the hell was Mesa doing pimping at the plate after that strike three swing? He should have busted it to first to draw a potentially wild throw.

Contreras has been a mad man with his blocks

Does Ashby have a shot at WS MVP?

Yes, but he keeps rightly crediting his primary competition, Wild Bill

There's nothing in any sport quite like a terrible bench bat coming to the plate in a critical playoff AB. I still remember the look on my roommate's face watching Michael Martinez come to the plate at the end of the 2016 WS.

How wild would it be for Yandy to take strike three called out of the zone to end the game, and it stands because he has never challenged a pitch yet?

Well, that was an equally entertaining strike three to end the game, wasn’t it?

Please stop throwing into the dirt

This sucks for the Rays. Down in the top of the 9th both nights. They make things happen, but then don't do much. I guess they still can tonight. But two meh outs here.

wow what a curve

He checked his swing. What an awful way to end the game

I say again, what is a check swing?

I thought he went, gutty by Ashby to pull that out

Replay of that swing?

They are bound to showing the celebration sequence without interruption, because, for some reason, the celebration has become the top clippable and shareable moment of any sports event.

Holy hell what an ending

That was ridiculous

Still waiting for the replay of that 'swing'

Rays felt lost at the plate after DeLuca got on.

NO HE DID NOT!

Junior went further around than that

oof not even close

Someone had to be somewhere tonight I guess.

yikes

Oh, yeah, he went

Overhead view makes it look like a swing to me

I think the overhead view is misleading.

I don’t. He went, by a lot.

I think that was a swing, but I've seen that called not a swing plenty of times.

I guess the owners want the larger market to win this one!

Tampa is the larger market by a good deal.

Milwaukee metro population: 1.5 million. Tampa 3.1.

higher salary

Landing planes is hard 😉

mil has way more wealth than Tampa per person I'll wager

My theory is it always depends how the 1B/3B ump is feeling.

or if he ate something dangerous for lunch

Need a poll on whether that was a swing, interested in how it breaks down.

If the ump has his hands in his pockets or more relaxed, he won't call a swing.

I don’t believe this at all. I think umpires are quite good at getting check swings right, at least as currently defined, which is bat crosses the line perpendicular with the front edge of the plate.

I'm being partly facetious. But you can tell the call by the umps body language before he signals. At least I think I can.

I have herd pitchers called dogs more this season than any other.

Maybe mlb should actually define a swing in the next cba.

New poll. I'll leave that open until next game.

good night

Tight 45/55 swing poll so far.

I don’t know if he did, but feel like the Brews deserved to win that game


Members-Only Game Thread: World Series – Oct 23, 2026

Welcome to our Open Game Thread for the World Series game today. Only Members can participate, and unlike our usual staff Q&A chats, your messages will be posted immediately.

Our Member community is made up of thousands of incredibly knowledgable baseball fans, and we think this is a great way to follow a game with like-minded baseball enthusiasts. We might even have some FanGraphs Staff drop in and join the fun. Please be courteous to your fellow Members, or you may find your chat privileges revoked.

i think the team that has the highest BLEPH is going to win tonight

Please go seven games, please go seven games.

We'll be chat while trick-or-treating!

Happy World Series!

If people want to get nostalgic here are links to Jeff and August's articles from their time here…
Jeff Sullivan: https://www.fangraphs.com/blog-roll?author=7030
August Fagerstrom: https://www.fangraphs.com/blog-roll?author=43631

Might also influence your vote.

Feels like August got an unlucky draw here, he's awesome but Jeff IS classic FanGraphs

August was one of the first _writers_ to leave for a team. And definitely the first of many here. Because after him was Cameron, Carson, then Sullivan.

lol shows what I know!

Pretty special series here.

Cmon clap for respect

Hello folks!

Need a poll on whether it's a good idea for the Rays to push Rasmussen back a day, or if they're overthinking it.

This is a situation where I defer to "the team has more information than we do." Ramsussen's feel, rest, etc.

I also wonder if there's wisdom in trying to maximize your chances of winning the non-Miz games. Probably getting a little too cute if that's the thought process, but it might play a role

I'd come down on the side of too cute. I'd want my ace to be available as much as possible during the WS.

No overweight players anymore 😂

Those Brewers entrance LEDs/Barrels/CO2 machines actually looked really good. Most of the time, whatever the teams do looks bad.

I can sing much better than this in opposite land.

She crushed the anthem. Damn

I wonder if the NPB is like, World? Really?

theyre prolly more like "World?, 本当に?"

Is the roof open? I'm streaming the radio broadcast and they haven't mentioned while I was paying attention.

I don't believe MLB allows it to be open. Or at least they are in charge of it. It should be closed to my knowledge.

Pity. If you have baseball in Wisconsin in late October, it should feel like it.

Yah it’s closed

If they have a problem with it they can come over here and take it from us

Too soon. lol

They sent Ohtani to take it.

what in the AI bulls**t is this malarkey

It sucks that the one time of year where there's amazing nationally televised baseball is also the one time of the year when commercial breaks are full of the most vile ads

I just realized that before tonight, I'd been to as many World Series, with as many wins to show for it, as both these teams put together

Do they have cheese curds and Spotted Cow in the pressbox?

There's a whole curd stand on this level. That's where I took the now-infamous Brat Rangoon photo. But no Spotted Cow. They didn't even have it at the bar I ate dinner at last night

Nearly all the other New Glarus beers are better than Cow … but you knew that

Any idea when this game will actually start?

I was thinking 8:08, but looks like that wasn't the case.

tomorrow afternoon

Hey friends!

two batters, two relatively well hit balls

Baumann, how's Wisconsin treating you?

He has had no spotted cow. I don't believe he's actually in Wisconsin.

One of my fellow writers just produced a two-pound bag of sausage from his backpack and offered to share, so things are going well here

its too bad this cant also be streamed via mlb tv. im on fubo instead and gonna be like 30 seconds delayed

Nothing but cheese from Miz so far

He's in the right state for cheese

Just like the Woodman's cheese aisle.

What a delightful swing from Simpson. I love it.

Raysball right there

What’s our take on the lineup choices? Milwaukee tinkering with order a bit and someone with a Time Machine from 2005 would have a heart attack about Simpson hitting 3…

It's hilarious how shallow the LF was and how quickly he got to Simpson's hit.

I do like that David Hamilton.

Miz looking good so far

Rays def not afraid of Miz

brewers def not afraid of nick martinez

That Simpson hit? 57.8 MPH.

Beautiful.

Brings a tear to my eye

Big spot already for Martinez. The Brewers feel like a bad matchup for him.

Wow, the green screen ad behind the batter is particularly egregious.

it looks like the typical angels broadcast (derogatory)

Yeah, I really miss charming local advertising in games. Happens on NHL dasherboards, too.

Next year you will be forced to bet on the game in order to watch it

Is Bauers okay? That was only six pitches

Yelich batting third? Why?

Welp

Baseball Posts that Age Poorly

I need a forehead slap emoji

Is it just me or does Smoltz trip over his words way more often than other color guys

Slightly to my surprise, here in Canada Sportsnet has their own announcing crew I guess? I don't have to listen to Smoltz!

Just like a Canadian to flaunt their superiority.

That's why.

He missed the catch! hello everyone

Man, I am so used to major leaguers making those catches that I am half-tempted to call for an error on that.

Can I change my vote on holding back Rasmussen?

I'll make a poll tomorrow that has a choice: I regret my vote from yesterday.

My goodness. Both of those balls hit leather.

Scorched off the bat

Looks like the Rays defense is not crisp today.

xBA of .630 and .620 according to statcast

Luck on Brewers side so far

hard to blame the rays defense with those EVs imo

Rays just getting all the bad luck out of the way inning 1 of game 1. It's strategic

I've determined that I want Milwaukee to win. The thought of Chandler Simpson batting #3 on a world series team is too much to handle.

The guy who almost won a batting title?

FanGraphs batting title should be wRC+

Personally, I find myself leaning Milwaukee just because they had the Violent Femmes playing a pregame concert. You deserve to win when you do that.

Simpson did beat Jose Ramirez by 1 wRC+ this year… But Cleveland is on another level strategically by batting him #2 instead

They made Chourio the Fonz. That works.

rays should just get the bad luck out of the way for the next 4 games

Simpson will get hits and never hit into DPs.

i love chandler simpson, but why not bat him first and push yandy/aranda down a slot

Not really a question quite yet but: if you're the Rays, how aggressive do you want to be using your best bullpen arms early if you're behind in this game?

On the road in Game 1, maybe not so much?

What I'm curious about is how often Cash will turn to his top end guys while losing, he did it a lot against Cleveland, if Milwaukee gets 4-5 looks I'd be worried

Yeah, same, but I've felt the same several other times in these playoffs only to find the managers disagreed with me.

Definitely feels like the Rays bullpen isn't set up as well as the Brewers' for this type of situation. Tons of single inning guys with a reasonably well defined hierarchy, bad combination if you're trying to avoid giving too many looks

or maybe 2nd if you still want yandy at leadoff

As a Crew fan, live the Rays bringing the infield in 1st inning. Dubious

Great challenge. Gotta be sure to challenge in a low-leverage spot.

Miz tightened up pretty good in the second

Against Cleveland that was definitely not a swing. 🤣#miz perks

Great piece of hitting by Frelick to go down and get that. Wow. His back knee was almost on the ground.

O/U 7.5 bunts tonight now that the first one is down?

I want to live in a world where that over hits

I only want to live in that world if they're attempts to bunt for hits

I personally don't think Hamilton will do anything other than attempt to bunt for hits

Ask Edwin Diaz about that.

Is it just my TV or is the video stretched vertically?

I don't have that here

No TV problem here.

Did it make Nick Martinez's muscles looked normal sized

Pretty odd Savant pitch value profile for Nick Martinez: 97th percentile for fastball, 91st percentile for offspeed, 17th percentile for breaking

The changeup he got Mitchell on to end the first was absolutely gross

From ~200 feet, Sal Frelick looks enough like Garrett Stubbs when he's running I've done a double take whenever he gets on base

I'm Abed from Community and there are several plausible timelines where DeLuca and Walls catch both of those balls.

are they the ones where everyone has goatees though

your Pudi. hey! Loved that show back in the day

A lockout is the darkest timeline

I'm not Danny Pudi but did not have faith people would get the reference without me setting it up.

Misiorowski in the mooooorning

Martinez actually looks super sharp

First guessing here – I always want the best pitcher in game 1 of WS to maximize the odds of using him thrice 1-4-7.

+1 for using thrice

fantastic band, and good baseball writers

Rays have taken several middle-middle four seamers already.

Can’t hit it if you can’t see it

Has Miz thrown a good breaking ball yet?

must've heard you and obliged

Enjoyed the horizontal statcast view of the slider vs 4S. I feel like statcast never gets utilized in unique ways on the national broadcasts, would like to see some more of that

Totally! No brainer.

Who in the minors is the next Miz? if anyone

Susana?

Was the Miz the next Miz in the minors? My recollection was that he was thought of as high ceiling, super high risk, potential future closer.

that sounds like what they say about Susana

His command jumped from below average to average just before he was called up. Tough for prospect raters to adjust

Yankees-Dodgers is clearly the darkest timeline from a World Series perspective

The Miz cutter is working. More please

I’ve been having a debate wit someone about what we think the TV ratings for this Series will be. He thinks it will be worst in history because of the small market teams. I think the various narratives around this Series will goose the ratings some and be reasonably decent considering this fragmented media era.

This is interesting. 2023 was the worst per Wikipedia. And those are bigger markets.

But also far less interesting teams. IMHO

Crazy to think in 1978, we'd be watching with 44.4 million other people.

In 2026, we might only have 8 million other people.

I’m sure that many people will see clips.

sounds like a waste of time unless one of you works for Fox. watch the games, who cares?

This is MIND BOGGLING!

Curious how people are watching. I’m on YouTubeTV.

I bought a one month fox subscription through Prime

Listening to Brewers radio via MLB app.

Fubo…

OTA local Fox station at the moment… might switch to stream (Sling) later

Yandy first time up: 99.9 mph exit velo, 347 feet the other way, F9
Second time up: 101.7 mph exit velo, .650 xBA, lineout.
Miz has handled everyone else fine but Yandy must want his money back

Yandy's LASER was a good example of why playing 3B is fun (if you have the balls for it, and protect them).

The brewers just put teams in the vortex

I'm rooting for the Brewers because I'm a Yankee fan, but also because I really want to see Yelich win one. Do the rays have anyone like that? Rasmussen with his injuries maybe?

But what was Yandy's BLEPH?

yandy paying to hit against Miz is real sicko stuff

the man wears medium T shirts – those poor shirts!

the MIA/Brewers trade for Yelich was armed robbery!

Best Kalshi add I’ve seen. Still will never use that trash.

Shane Gillis and Danny McBride doing a Kalshi ad together is excruciatingly on-brand.

This chat is cool on the app to use

How do I get to it on the app?

Has any other team ever worn their alternates this much in the playoffs

Laying off all that 100 plus, half an inch off the corner was really impressive by Aranda

I finally got here only to find out I missed a triple! That’s sad, I love triples.

With Yelich's original back it would have been a homer. It was a nice barrel (I assume).

Sorry to be that guy, but it was a fake triple! It hit leather!

On a diving attempt

I'm really liking new teams and players in the Series

Chandler SImpson batting 3rd feels a little "too cute" to me

Ugh, Mitchell botched that one.

That was a screamer

That's a lot of hits on balls that hit the glove today

Yah he wasn’t running

Balls off CF glove 1 to 1

I’ve played plenty of center and liners right at you are the worst

I think Miz is done

At low 50s pitches? You sure?

Nope

Mitchell was an E8 (in a world where I'm official scorer)

The threshold is "ordinary effort," and he broke in the right direction and was at a full stretch. That's a hit.

I usually keep score when I'm at the park, and I largely ignore what the official scorer says.

It's a hit but a lot of CF's would have had it in their hip pocket.

You're probably right based on how it's done. But in my timeline, you're supposed to catch that ball.

Some would, but I think a lot wouldn’t. That wasn’t a gimme.

There's a surprising amount of multiverse theory in this chat.

In the other multiverse, no one is talking about the multiverse and the Rockies are winning.

Are official scorers allowed to use Statcast catch probabilities?

The last thing I want to see on a World Series broadcast is the betting trend for who’s gonna win.

I'm going to be laughing about "Misiorowski in the Mooorning" for days to come. Thank you for that.

Holy crap Aranda was off the line. Rays positioning I tell you what

that should count toward 2B eligibility

There haven't been many instances where I have seen a 1st baseman that far into the hole.

There is a 98.9% chance that this chat is 50% more filled with stats than 90% of other chats.

Was that an odd place for the first baseman to play Pratt 3-and-2, two out, none on? He was practically lined up with where second baseman plays.

I love you Jonathan Aranda

I am not surprised to see Murphy get someone up. Misiorowski is not quite the same tonight.

He’s been off for a while now. The season has definitely worn him down a bit

Miz down to 97

In the Miz vs Skubal game I couldn't stop looking at their enormous feet. That game might have had the largest combined SP shoe size of all time. (Someone research this please)

John Rauch had the biggest feet I ever saw an a ball player.

also would accept ratio of combined shoe size to ERA

Rauch did not win that

The foul balls are noticable

He can't put the hitters away like he usually does.

Bauers!

That was a really impressive play on both sides

Have the playoffs demonstrated a playbook against Miz, that all opponents will take up next season?

Wait to hit him until the post

Seems more like fatigue than the scouting being especially better. The command on his breaking pitches has been abysmal so they can afford to sit fastball

Maybe, but it's always a game of adjustments, and if the strategy results in 5 innings of 1 run ball…

See? Told you he’s done.

Surprised Miz is still in there for Yandy.

What on earth???

!?!?

Bizarre play there with Yandy at the plate?

Yaaaaaas Contreras!!!!!

Why the hell are you stealing third there???

……….

Someone forward the Rays Ben Clemens resume

I would rather he stayed here.

Contreras continuing to have an incredible postseason

I'm just an unfrozen caveman lawyer – your modern ways confuse me – but even I know that when the dude throws 100 on some level the scouting report is just like it says on Leslie Nielsen's tombstone: "Let 'Er Rip!" (true story – he put a fart joke on his tombstone)

Is it just me or does Ariana Grandes eyes suggest demon possession

That was nearly Austin Wells trying for 3rd level of dumb

Quick poll. Does Miz come out for the 6th?

No

If the Brewers score a couple or more, for sure.

Probably not. Think he was emptying the tank in the 5th

yes

TOOTBLAN alert?

Throw so perfect too

Given the way Cash has managed the playoffs to this point, I'm surprised Matz is up.

I’ll take a veteran pitcher in the post

Wow REALLY stupid decision against Mesa

Victor Victor Mesa Mesa Jr

Catch-22 is my favorite book, and Major Major is one of the better characters (actually Major Major Major since that's also his rank)

Why not hold up after the stumble

I wonder if he thought it'd be harder to turn back once he started stumbling

OOF

At least it was the second out at third

another out at 3rd, wow

My favorite play in baseball, that was incredible

Holy redemption, Batman!

Stat from Canadian tv: in the expansion era, name the 5 starting pitcher seasons with the lowest BA against 3rd time through the order. List includes Miz this year, Pedro 1999, Ryan 1974, a Blake Snell season, and…another guy.

Arrieta 2015?

Clay Bucholz in 2013

dueling TOOTBLANs

good band name?

Drum and bass underground house duo

That's such an impressive relay by Williamson, who wasn't a second baseman until this season. That's not a natural throw for him.

Don’t run against Contreras. Don’t run against Mesa.

If it's from Sportsnet, I'm gonna say Kevin Gausman or Cy Young Robbie Ray

Buchholz in 2013!

That may go down as the worst decision of the game.

Or maybe Halladay?

wow Clay Bucholz is a Remember Some Guys pull

.8912 BLEPH! on that play

I love how single season baseball stats capture random dudes playing out of their mind for a season

where are you guys getting these team tags from?

good to settings then flairs

go**

This is the only game in 2026 that Miz didn't K at least 5 in a start of 5 innings or more.

Chat settings button in the upper-right

Thanks! Do they have Black Sabbath or is it just MLB teams?

Nick Martinez 5 Ks, Miz 3 Ks. Can't predict baseball.

Clay Buchholz is one of those guys for whom FIP-based WAR was created. In bWAR he looks like he's just great or terrible at random. In fWAR he's just a good-not-great pitcher with a fast decline.

they fired the BLEPH guy, let's get a better nonce acronym

top right of chat window, gear picture, chat settings

i bet nobody else has this combo

Sorry about the self-loathing; that must be unpleasant.

eugh

fwiw it's definitely in that order

Contreras is awesome at challenges.

Contreras is awesome at baseball

i'll tell you my flair story if you tell me yours

fangraphs member survey on the stories behind their flair

lockout article alert

Mine is boring, no teams close enough to home to count as hometeams while I was growing up, but my father was from Boston and we went up there a couple of times a year and occassionally caught a game at Fenway.

A lot of us single-team people will be boring. I grew up in New England, left for a job, miss it.

I was a multi-team fan until the Giants left NY. It has been more fun dedicated to one club.

who was more impressive to see live, mays or mantle or teddy ballgame?

Contreras MVP

Tough looking double play there for TB

This is the throw-'em-out game, I guess.

So many great arms tonight!

Contreras is awesome at baseball!

DO NOT RUN ON CONTRERAS

perhaps simpson is not the best 3rd hitter

They don't have him batting there because he's the 3rd best hitter

I lived in all 3 places (and never once considered liking the Yankees)

My parents were in NYC in 1962, my mother had the Mets as her favorite team till the day she died because she was still rooting for the underdog from that year. She also claimed Mets games were better entertainment than other teams, because you never knew what would happen on a "routine" popup.

Man, all kinds of runners getting cut down

I assume that one was a hit and run which isn't a bad call with Simpson's contact rate. Just looks horrible when it fails

BryanB is the Rays closer, he has changed sides and is now operating as a sleeper agent

It would be amazing if he was posting on his phone from the bullpen

It’s an XK Red 27 technique

Dumb question: does the catcher get the WPA for a caught stealing? Do they get the negative WPA for a successful steal?

There’s no defense in WPA just pitchers.

bosox for life with the age related flex

Really think Laurila should interview him in the offseason.

lockout article klaxon strikes again

Is it common for shortstops to wear the pitch com?

Apparently all infielders wear them? Or at least some. There was a whole kerfuffle earlier this year when players on first could hear the pitch call on Nate Lowe's pitchcom because the volume was up too loud

I think several infielders do- I saw Freddie freeman holding his hand over his hat/ear in an earlier series

I am fairly certain if you let pitch com reach the SS then the other team is listening.

Mays was the best because he was great at all phases of the game. Williams was in a class by himself as a hitter.

If Willie Mays had a Statcast card, it would be blood red from top to bottom.

It’s gonna end in a walk off?!?! Call Bowie!!!

I believe the broadcast missed an adorable side hug between Contreras and Aranda during that PitchCom malfunction. If I'd gotten a hug like that from a girl I liked I'd be walking on air for the rest of 9th grade

Just because we're throwing each other out doesn't mean we can't be friends

11th grade for me.

Willy C has the largest eye black tape I have seen

I love it

He and Yandy need to have an eyeblack-off

They should have a live face painting station before the game

cant wait for bauers to have a unicorn on the left side of his cheek

LOLLLLLL

I swear those pitch cons are made out of balsa wood and spit

Imagine Matz not throwing strikes, at his age

I think Harper also paints his whole face?

Harper is at some point going to force us to have a serious conversation about when "a ton of eye black" turns into "doing blackface on the field"

No, spit was banned back when bosoxforlife was a kid

Try telling that to Don Sutton and Jerry Reuss

Lew Burdette's nickname was "Lubricated Lew".

I think they should have a live face painting session before the game

Miz in full tiger face paint firing 103 would be peak

🦄

Baumann, during the lockout can we start a fantasy league of your 300 metros setup?

I don't know what this means

I think this is referring to your mega expansion idea

Pan-American Municipal Baseball League, 150 franchises? sorry i misremembered the number

Ohhhhh yeah definitely. I'm not sure I want to administrate such a thing, but if someone else wants to hack OOTP and make it work that could be fun

Meg and Appelman keep me locked in a windowless room unless I come up with three insane ideas a week, I have trouble remembering them all

RISP

Uribe – Hall – Ashby – Megill as needed to close it out

I think you can skip Hall.

I’m telling you, next season pitchers will pitch one pitch each

Caminero has great vibes in all circumstances from what I've seen

I will always root for a guy in sport specs

Richie Palacios vs. Ashby would be a real Sophie's choice for you

I'm sorry, but Palacios' glasses are too neon. Too neon by far.

Rec specs!

Where’s Karim Abdul Jabar when we need him

I love Ashby but there's no way the "two innings every game" bit works for him again this series, right?

I consistently underestimate him

The forehead sweat zoom in was pretty extra there by Fox

I'm growing to loath Polimarket advertising

I actually like the Craig Robinson one but I just find him funny

He sold out!

Beginning to be a fan of the stay-in-radius OF proposal

Is it harder for a lefty to bunt off a lefty or does it not matter?

MLB: if you want to turn away fans, keep advertising betting apps

Wonder where these gambling companies are getting all this money to buy adv—ohhhhhhh I get it

I guess T Mobile wants fans to be mad at them every time a fan disagrees with ABS.

I do so love it when a team is punished for a leadoff walk (unless it's my team of course)

Yet another run due to sketchy glove work.

One day they’ll stop throwing a first pitch strike to Chourio

Fox reduced all glove sizes by 20%

this seems plausible to me

Lachlan Murdoch: Baseball is boring. In cricket, men do not wear gloves. Can we get rid of the gloves?

I have no idea if that's fair

the wicketkeeper (catcher equivalent) in cricket does wear gloves!

Cricket does everything it can to make defense difficult. Of course, the fact that you can bounce the ball on the way to the wicket and that they don't replace a scruffed ball also make offense difficult, but a cricket bat is a much better shape to hit a round ball with.

They don't just not replace a scuffed ball, a single ball is used for hours at a time.

Yes, when you hit it over the fence they pause the game to get the ball back

also, south africa just beat australia in long form cricket and their captain batted for 9 hours of game time

(beating australia is generally difficult)

I don't know it like baseball, but I have enjoyed the Cricket I have watched.

and you have to bowl the ball in a way that looks deeply unnatural to me as a baseball player. I was once playing catch in the Caribbean and some kids wanted to play with us. I wondered why their form was so weird and then I realized that they were "bowling" my baseball

In Australia, some pals tried to teach me to bowl. Felt like I was going to separate my shoulder

There is a chance the rest of the country finds this a very boring game and I don’t care

I will take multiple guys getting thrown out on the bases any time

Great pitching there

A 93-mile changeup that does *that* is unfair.

The bowler cannot bend his arm at the elbow in the delivery.

with modern biomechanics they have realized that some bend in the elbow is inevitable, but it is indeed very limited

also, no foul territory!

ADS! ADS! ADS! More ads! Always ads!!

That pitch brought to you by Kalshi!

Emmanuel Clase, come get your 1 pitch payment

A single cricket match at the highest level lasts five days.

hence the 9 hours of batting by 1 guy!

Novig has better Ads than polymarket.

Rays Raysing Vilade to second base

Brewers mission comes down to “can we get the first four hitters out?” If so, it’s a wrap.

Last five in tonight’s lineup hitting .161 AVG, .429 OPS in playoffs. Really really rough.

Ahh Reacher. Such a good show.

Uecker was just given a shout out. It is a shame he couldn't have been around for this moment.

Just a bit outside

Uecker, Yogi and… who are the other two on the Mt. Rushmore of humorous ball players?

Bouton

Fidrych?

Wasn't around long enough for a Rushmore spot, but everything Munenori Kawasaki ever did or said was comedy gold

I watch the "monkey never cramp" clip about once a year

Kawasaki still playing in lower-level Japanese ball, true baseball man

What role do we think Woodruff has in this series? Is he gonna get a start? Low leverage guy? High leverage bulk?

bulk reliever

He hasn’t pitched since July. He ms max 40 pitches. Not a bulk reliever.

Contreras is allowed to go into the dugout during a commercial break? I don't think I ever realized players could do that

how do you think they pee?

I predict a bunt attempt.

Well, uh, that was bad

DOH

Bad bunt! bad!

Prediction was good. Attempt was bad.

This is such fun baseball – I'm sure there will be some ratings grumbling, but doing my part and I hope the baseball remains awesome

Pat Murphy tomorrow: we had him do a bunt pop-up so they would give him a pitch to hit out

That didn't look like the technique of somebody who had ever bunted in his life.

Cleavinger ain't got it tonight

RISPd AGAIN.

Lentz is going to have the plate tomorrow. i hope he gets his eyes checked before then.

I forgot about Gary Sanchez

Ask the padres about that.

And the Brewers are going to counter by calling the Dodgers and bringing in Freddy Freeman.

What a pick

Caminero flashing the leather!

This might be the first time all season Sanchez didn’t use at least one challenge

It’d be nice if they could have fewer commercial breaks.

I was unaware of Polymarket personally

Sometimes when the game goes into a ton of extra innings they run out of commercials and keep it at the field between innings

Furiously searching fangraphs to fact check the announcer's claim that Trevor Megill was a starter with the New York Mets

The answer is no. Tylor is not Trevor

ah, they're mixing up their T Megills…

Classic Megill mix-up

you have high expectations from X ballplayers

I miss Joey Ortiz. Such a good defender and I still believe in his bat

Oh man this would be an incredible moment for the first Simpson homer

The Homer Simpson if you will

anyone giving up a homer to him would definitely think "D'OH!"

What is the over under for Ray’s garbage time outs?

Uhoh

Well this got interesting

Shoulda caught that dude

Man, this game is living up to the hype.

Anybody know if there is a Junior Caminero Jr?

(haha imagine if Caminero pulls an Alonso here)

Moments like this are what separates baseball from the rest.

WHAT A BALLSY MOVE – double steal with your best hitter up there??

Oh man, I get not throwing Junior a pitch there, but on 3-2 to throw it in the dirt…..

Not impressed with this pitcher at all

This ain’t good

Oh my gosh, is Megill crumbling?

Giving away the game

I've been following silently as I wrote the mailbag, but hi everyone!

That's not the worst walk

And damn!

And also, he didn't check his swing

Totally agree

Please identify what a checked swing is.

This is great baseball!

And just like that a classic ending. And we get another one tomorrow!

THERE WE GO!!!

its the worst walk given that he already struck out

what a finish!

Well, this is a big challenge.

My god

HOLY GUACAMOLE

Not over!

Wow! What a brewers way to win

Liam Hicks has been disappointing this playoffs, I had him as an X Factor to lengthen that lineup

I'm not sure he's out at second

Oh no

I think he's off the bag

FWIW, this is where replay kills it – the game is over and if they bring it back now (even if it's close)

Imagine Megill having to get back to the mentality to get the last out

Yah that first throw sucks

Woahhh

Then review the check swing you fickers.

If this was an AFL game they could! (But with the AFL check swing rules it would still be a no-swing).

He is off the bag. This will eb overturned.

Business idea: telescoping cleats that maintain contact with the base

Yah all Turangs fault

Holy Toledo, is this not the most monumental replay challenge in replay challenge history?

Ask me after the next batter.

Remember when there wasn't replay?

Wowowowow

did we make a mistake by allowing reviews

Yes (unless they help my team)

Did they set off fireworks?

Is Andy Fletcher a guy who has ever been on tv before?

My exact comment to wife

Wow this game man

Steal home?

Contreras can't throw him out at least.

that's a perfect job for Joe West

The celebration smoke will blind DeLuca.

Well, that's not reviewable.

i have been looking for a very poopy cat to give him dewormer and i forgot that there was a baseball game. i am not a real sicko, forgive me

Do they have more fireworks available?

Baseball remains awesome.

And we get to do this again tomorrow!

Holy cow what a game

Good drama there

Delaying the inevitable.

Most entertaining 3-2 game I've seen in a while

Brewers playoff ball is entertainment at its finest

this is a good world series between good and entertaining teams, if it doesn't beat 2023 i'll be upset

thank god the angels arent in the world series cuz i would have to go to the ER if this happened to them

Incredible opening act to this series. I really hope it goes 7 (because I have tickets 😅)

Have a blast at the games you get to go to!

Thanks!

In 1967 I had tickets to game 6 and had to sweat out game 5 because the Red Sox were down 3-1.

This is looking like a good series.

Yeah that was pretty fun. I hope the rest of this series can be at least that good.

Sean, as always, thanks for having us over!

Hopefully we have 6 more!

Ken Rosenthal doesn't come up to Jacob Misiorowski's shoulder.

one bad thing when the WS being over is no more fun chats 🙁

I’ll miss these

"members-only Dominican League chats"

hot stove fg chats: nothing happens for a very long time until passan himself drops ordnance on all our houses

I’ll be at Puerto Rican league next month

lidom could feed families

we're essentially one step away from creating fangraphs discord

i am traveling to aus but with the melbourne team leaving the abl i likely won't be able to catch any games

what a crazy game though. pat murphy must be fuming (happy?)

Megill definitely did not slam any doors shut

I’m fine if it only goes 4

Great game tonight! See everyone tomorrow!


Eric Longenhagen Prospects Chat: 10/23/26

Howdy from the kitchen table in Tempe where I'm being serenaded by a symphony of leaf blowers just over the back wall.

Sorry that this is my first chat in a couple of weeks, I've been dealing with some still-undiagnosed health stuff that seems to be abating. Pretty sure I'm okay. Had some illuminating experiences with our health care system though, and I'm pretty sure that's not. Anyway, I've still been at a ton of Fall League games and have a midway point post and Board update brewing, which might run as soon as later today but more likely Monday. For now, we chat.

How much upside does Luis Lara have as a hitter? What would be a reasonable projection for him a few years down the road?

He has as much upside as he can add strength without compromising the things he currently does really well. I think he's always going to be a sub-.400 SLG guy who plays awesome defense and makes a ton of contact. I think he has better long term upside than what Sal Frelick has been, but that what Frelick has been able to do is a lot like what Lara's skillset looks like right now.

All of that is to say: I feel comfortable with the 45 we put on Lara, but less comfortable with it than the 45 we put on Pratt. Both feel like solid role players rather than stars.

Request to pass on: add a filter to the minor league leaderboards for prospect status. I'd love to be able to quickly filter to the guys of note and/or see what sort of stats are reasonable for prospects rather than 29 YO journeymen

We do have that, just click on the "Show All" tab and you can set filters for age: https://www.fangraphs.com/prospects/the-board-scouting-and-s…

Thank you for doing these chats. Do you think the Mariners place Ace Reece in AA to start the year next year or just put him in Everett and fast track him if he has success. Also is his stock a little higher than it was after the draft and is he a potential top 100 prospect?

I would ordinarily tell you that they'd give him a good amount of big league reps during spring training and then decide whether to start him at High-A or Double-A based on how he looks, but I think a lack of MLB spring training means we should take the "under", so to speak, on these guys' assignments. Reese probably isn't an offseason top 100 guy, I'm not one to be moved by an SEC hitter going to the Cal League after the draft and crushing it there. He should, it would have been alarming had he not. Send him to Everett and he'll probably do more of the same. He can't really play defense so I wanna see him crush in Arkansas before buying it, personally.

The fantasy community seems to have collectively gotten higher on Zion Rose in the months since the draft, and lower on Eric Booth Jr. Is this simple SSS overreaction, or are these informed by real scouting intel?

I can't speak for the fantasy "community" and I want readers to remember the way opinions spread online and how they can cloud what the array of opinions would be if everyone were sequestered before arriving at one. I can tell you that Zion looks damn good in the AFL, and that Brendan and I both agreed we should just 50 him this offseason. He's stock up. Booth is a hold. What your dynasty team needs (do you need a solid regular soon? Or do you need to take a shot on a potentially freaky stud who might also bust?) should dictate how you line them up on your FYPD board.

Congratulations on your promotion to Prospect Impresario!

This has been what Baumann has called me since the Crashburn Alley days, back in… 2012? Sheesh.

Hey Eric! This is John McNamara. We spoke last year when I interviewed with FanGraphs for the full-time prospect writer role. I was a scout with the San Diego Padres for eight years, and I really enjoyed our conversation about baseball and scouting. I recently wrapped up my time with the Padres and am looking for my next opportunity in baseball. I’d love to get your thoughts on where my scouting background might translate or if there’s anyone you think I should connect with. I’d really appreciate any advice or guidance. Thanks

Hey John, I remember. You were a good candidate and interview. I worry that scouting isn't exactly a growth industry, especially on the pro side. It's more stable on the amateur side because of how much more valuable and actionable "dope" is, and the fact that teams are guaranteed to acquire players via that market, whereas pro impact is more situational. So I'd try to stay on the amateur side. I also think it might be fruitful for more scouts to transition into college baseball as recruiters/GMs. Depending on how things turn out with the pending legislation around college sports, and where things settle post-lockout/CBA with regard to draft processes, it might suddenly make more sense for colleges to have more scouting and recruiting personnel than they already do. Find out what scouts have left pro ball for a job at a college and see if you can reach out to them for counsel. It might be cool to be the transfer portal scout for Miami, or something like that.

You see a batter change levels and suddenly his swing, contact, groundball, and pull percentages all take big jumps. But it's only 20 games. Guy got a new coach who taught/convinced him of a new swing/approach or just a flukey 20 games? 20 games is very small sample for results, but seems decent for approach. Eye-test needed to see if anything is actually different?

You can pretty easily marry the data change flag with a look at the wing on video to get a better feel for whether or not there has actually been a change. If you have a way of flagging changes in the data over a short (but statistically significant) window of time and then running down the flagged targets with your eye balls, that's ideal.

Does Kendry Rojas of MIN still project as a starting pitcher?

Yeah, I think as long as he has options he'll be rolled out as a starter enough to keep his innings count within a reasonable distance of full-time starting once his option years run out. The guys who tend to stick as starters are the ones whose bodies and deliveries look like Kendry's.

Eric! The Cubs are running back their MLB pitching infrastructure, which got me thinking about their inability to build any kind of a minor league pitching pipeline for what is now almost 20 years of the Theo/Jed regime. Is it just bad drafting, bad development, or some kind of institutional blind spot that’s led to this? I’d have a hard time coming up with more than five pitchers in the last 20 years that they drafted, developed, and got value out of. In fact, Cease would probably be on that list and they traded him from A ball.

I think they've had some success but it hasn't been sustained success. Steele popped and then got hurt and looked like a shell of himself during rehab in AZ. I can say that their style of development tends to include velo spikes and pitch additions. Everyone suddenly has a cutter and a sweeper when before they had just one breaker, and they might throw a few ticks harder. But they haven't tended to develop or improve command. The Naz Mule's of the world don't need two more pitches, they need control. So maybe there hasn't been cohesion with what the draft has fed the dev group. Some teams, like the Brewers' pitchers, show similar trends where they all of a sudden have five pitches. And others, like the Rays, basically have guys throw 2 pitches the whole time they're in the minors and don't really care to flesh out repertoires as much.

After AFL, how much confidence do you have that 2025 is behind him, and Welbyn Francisca is a legit prospect again?

He's back from the dead, imo.

How much are we knocking off your future value due to the health concerns?

You should ding my "party/hang" tool grade because I can't drink until I'm done with this run of medication. It was already a 40, unplayable now.

Hope you continue recovering from your case of the bleph

The Royals have to trade Blake Mitchell this winter, right?

I think catching depth is important enough that, unless they think he's totally bunk from all the K's, they should probably hold onto him. If you think it's enough K's to make him a binary "no" as a hitter, than sure you can sell high on him coming off a 30 homer season.

This chat interface is so rad.

How is Briggs McKenzie looking coming off injury? Young, but seemed like he had some good stuff early on and the Braves are one of the better orgs developing pitchers

I saw his first start and haven't run into him since (I went to see the Fielder/Holmes movie last night) but he looked like Diet Bumgarner to me in the first game. Graceful, repeatable, deceptive, feel, good breaker quality. Starter all the way, mid rotation upside. Think we'll leave the 45+ on him, though, and make him a Pick to Click rather than hondo him right now.

Looking at these two teams, there are a lot of really productive guys on both rosters who probably would not have been stars had they been developed in other organizations. Logan Henderson's a good example! Obviously, when you're doing a Board-type prospect ranking, it's hard to take org into account because guys can get traded and it's impossible to control for that, but – how much of the variance in a prospect's outcome can be traced directly to what organization they're in? And, as an analyst, what do you do with that?

This is the classic "predicting vs scouting" question. We have to assess the player in a vacuum, but you should feel free to put your thumb on the scale of predicting the outcome based on what orgs you think/know are better at developing players, or putting them in position to succeed. Like Andrew Vaughn changed orgs after he graduated, there's nothing we can do about retconning our grade, things just happen and it plays out and you hope you're directionally correct on the player.

When evaluating future outfield defense, how do you determine whether a player who is transitioning to the OF has the capacity to judge the flyballs/get efficient and quick jumps?

Just watch the initial transition and see how natural it is for the player to do the things he needs to do at the OF position. Then give it time to breathe and check in a few months later on whether there's been progress. Some guys take to it right away, others need time/reps, and some will never get comfortable doing it.

Thanks for chatting! Angeibel Gomez has been raking lately in AFL. Does that change your opinion of his upside?

I think the very aggressive 50 we have on him is still appropriate. Real power and feel to hit, probably a corner OF in the end. To go from "new signee" to "guy we feel pretty strongly is a future everyday player" is really impressive. I don't think he's Acuna or anything like that.

Eric, it looks like the banner link is missing part of the url for this chat–the one in the blogroll works. Thought you'd want to know!

Thanks, idk why, we've asked Sean and I'm sure I just goofed something when I built the post because it's my first time chatting solo with this interface.

Did Salas’ debut move the needle for you? I wonder if he has enough bat to be a superstar catcher like you’d expect from one getting started as a 20 year old.

Yeah, I think he's a top 5 prospect and will be a consistent 3 WAR catcher.

Not a prospect, but is Victor Mesa Jr. a possible major breakout next year in an everyday role? No real platoon split that would seem to indicate he needs to sit against lefties.

Seems possible, yes. Swing changed, more power without sacrificing a ton of contact. Contact was actually better in '26 than before, even with the more aggressive swing. Obviously has profile-altering arm strength and defensive profile. Could be 40 hit with 45 or 50 power and big time defense. That's at least a good platoon guy (45) if not an everyday player. We had him graded as an extra outfielder, basically a pure defensive replacement.

I know your opinion or way of thinking of these low contact sluggers (e.g. Murakami) has changed somewhat. I assume Griffin Conine is a guy who would fit into that bucket of bats. I've been waiting for the bottom to fall out give his awful contact rate, but is this a guy who could have a more sustainable role going forward given this shift in the game?

Yeah, the number of sub-70% contact guys keeps climbing and it's at the point where I need to reassess my baselines for viability, or at least try to separate the guys who aren't gonna hit enough to matter from the ones who will somehow. There are still guys with 65% contact who just aren't going to hit, it isn't like all of a sudden those guys are good to go.

But why Murakami (who sucked down the stretch btw, he might be due for a regression and all of this will be moot) and not Jack Cust, or whoever.

By your rankings Eyanson, Zazueta, Flora and Susana are are close to each other. Do you have a personal preference/order to these arms that differs from the rankings and if so, why?

Nah, they're *my* rankings. Susana it's 99-102 with bad shape, bad strikes, and an elite slider. He's probably a reliever but one of the ten best relievers in baseball. Zazueta it's velo, ride, command, changeup, but no good breaking ball. Mid-rotation guy with a flaw that prevents him from being a no. 2 or better. Flora could be the most complete guy of that group if he can stay healthy and throw strikes across 140+ innings, Eyanson is a little closer to having done that with 100 IP in pro ball this year.

Any chance Patrick Reilly can still start even with the lost time? Slider is playing much nicer than pre-TJS

Yes, I think the more vertical breaker will play against lefties and there are enough strikes. He's probably a five-and-dive type, though.

Following up on a few weeks ago – any insight into why Aiva Arquette went on the IL for the last two days of the season?

Arquette had three IL stints this year. In order: Sports hernia (which is what I thought I had two weeks ago), thumb sprain, then oblique.

What would you say is the % chance Brody Hopkins just sticks in the pen from here on out? I'm assuming he gets another shot in the rotation next year at least, but is that for sure?

I'd say like 90% bullpen now that he's on the 40. Conversion arms tend to be in the bullpen.

In my (very deep) dynasty league I have a chance to draft Jared Grindlinger if I drop Xavier Neyens. Advisable, or would this be negligible gain?

I want Grindlinger

(also fyi the banner link leads to a 404 page)

This has been fixed

Now with 3 injury marred or inconsistent seasons under his belt, do you have any confidence in Evan Carter or Wyatt Langford reaching their full potential? They have both showed flashes, but Wyatt's decisions at the plate, defensive miscues and health have been infuriating. Carter also can't seem to choose an approach that gives him sustained offensive success similar to the lightning in bottle run he had in 2023. Do you have any recommendations for either of them or the Rangers moving forward that you've observed? Thanks again!

I'm still on Longford, Carter I think is just okay.

more like Eric Lags-at-hangin' amirite

I'm only good at cooking and writing anymore.

athletics and sports all select for outlier/"freakish" traits; are there things that you have seen in baseball that you did not think were humanly possible? did any "freaks" end up really panning out from your perspective?

I've seen deGrom in person three times and was blown away all three times. Acuna's balls in play made retirees at AFL games moan in kind of a scared way. Teenage Tatis BPs were crazy. Watching Gerrit Cole's Fall League debut was crazy. Stephen Strasburg Harrisburg home debut with so many fans taht they ran out of food, had a brown out and a rain delay, and hearing his breaking ball spinning through the humidity throughout the whole ballpark was crazy.

Even Ray Kerr. Like, Kerr is "just" a middle reliever but he's here in part because he's pretty freaky.

Whenever anyone does high-end stuff of any kind, I wanna hopefully be sensitive to that and bet that will play in the big leagues. It doesn't have to be guys who run fast or jump high or who are built like underwear models. It can be Alejandro Kirk framing pitches like he does.

Anyone floating around the minors with speed who could try to completely sell out power for bat control and make it like Chandler Simpson? Or do you need truly 80-grade speed to make that profile work, no 60s or 70s need apply

I think you need at least a 70.

What's your fav defunct baseball site? BrooksBaseball or StatCorner.

Brooks was big for me in college.

I emailed FG support without a reply a few weeks ago but can you possibly let them know to add contact% as possible category to add on milb custom reports. They have swinging strike% but knowing whiff/contact% is different. Thank you

Contact rate doesn't come from the game logs liek the other data, that's Statcast/Hawkeye/Trackman stuff that I source from team people. I'll approach Sean and Co. about integrating it into the board somehow, but it'd be an end of year data point rather than something that could update in real time.

More importantly….how was the Nathan Fielder doc on a 20-80 scale?

Still digesting it, in the 65/70 area for me. OJ Made in America is the 80.

Two-parter: what's the best quote you've ever gotten from a prospect, and what's the dumbest thing you ever heard someone say? I feel like during the lockout we should get more human interest reporting about what it's like to be a pro/amateur ball player.

Not a ton of prospect quotes from me, I talk to some kids at the Combine every year and have some questions for kids on occasion, but those questions are almost always to glean information about how they're being developed rather than the player himself. Jake Burger is really funny, JJ Wetherholt impressed all of us at the combine a few years ago, JA Happ was nice to be around when I was a kid at Lehigh Valley back in '08.

curious if you have thoughts about the hypothetical landscape of college baseball, supposing HS players were excluded from draft eligibility in the next CBA… in particular, would it make home games in a Big10 city more relevant on the level of getting to see some capital-D Dudes before the draft?

Yeah, it's roughly 50 players who I ranked, and probably another 15 or so who I didn't, who get signed out of high school now but wouldn't if HS players are no longer draft eligible. In the bucket of the college player population it isn't a ton of bodies. But it is a lot of the most talented kids. All it takes is one Rocker/Leiter duo to make some noise and grab people's attention, and it would ensure those guys do some version of that, even if it's just for a year or two like in the NBA. But the things that make college baseball tough to watch (all the walks, lack of pitching depth, midweek games that go 4 hours because of all the runs, a bloated run environment because the bats are like golf clubs) would remain.

No question but a feature request: ability to sort Team Stats on the Minor League side like the MLB stats leaderboards. Thanks for the great work!

Oh yeah, that's interesting. I wonder if there might be barriers to coding that retrospectively because affiliates change?

Speed development. I remember Julio Rodriguez was projected early to fall to a corner. What stopped him from doing that? Did he gain speed? Not lose as much as predicted?

There's a Divish article about Julio completely changing his eating and workout habits you should dig up.

How has Aidan Miller looked?

Healthy, mobile, fast. Ends up playing next to Walcott a bunch, so also looks more human.

Among other reasons why purely scouting a stat line is sub-optimal, what percentage of MiLB hits would more usually be outs in the show? Like 10% between fielding, positioning, and "hits" that actually errors?

Man, that's a tough question. It's super relevant. Can we just assess BABIPs and have an okay enough notion?

asked brendan this and curious for your answer as well. Caceras, Gomez, Renteria, Frias. if you were starting a team which one are you taking?

Frias, Gomez, Caceres, Renteria.

When it comes to a player like Bryce Rainer (high strikeout, big power, lots of walks in minors with surprisingly good average for K%) what kind of attributes do you look at to shade up or down on developing better contact? Is it more of a physical thing? More of an approach thing? Odds Rainer can rein in his strikeouts to become an All-star or better MLBer? (pun very much intended)

Lever/swing length (which is kind of a double-edged sword because it's easy to say the longer guys will shorten up as they get stronger {Walcott has} but sometimes they just can't) and feel for altering their hands to help them make contact. Like the way Judge tucks his hands in to shorten up against stuff near his torso. That's how you avoid being too long to make contact in there. Rainer isn't doing that right now, it's realy really long.

Thoughts on Villanova breaking up the Big 5?

Selfish, cynical, douche behavior.

In connection with my earlier question (predicting vs scouting), what *do* the various teams do well? I think as fans we can sometimes overblow this stuff. Like Cleveland and Atlanta really do seem to be able to churn out pitching, and Tampa and Milwaukee always seem to be more than the sum of their parts offensively, and Toronto *typically* seems like they can get their guys to hit – until this year. Et cetera! Who are the orgs who you'd identify as having genuinely repeatable strengths?

Some of it is acquisition related, some of it is player dev, and some of it is deployment. Yes, Cleveland makes pitchers better. They draft strike-throwers and turn them into harder-throwing guys without killing their command. Milwaukee seems to know what kind of bat these guys should be using. Bauers, Turang… they've all changed their gear in meaningful ways. I think bat design/weight/shape cab be tailored for each individual's swing and Milwaukee has done that. Their international department also finds dudes via a "go-wide" strategy, which they also emply in the draft by taking all these HS guys spread across lower seven figure and mid sic figure bonuses. WHen you have great dev, it makes sense to want more bites at the apple and they have that locked in. Tampa deploys guys in the ways they're best suited to succeed. When you have Manny Margot and Corey Dickerson and their skillsets compliment one another, you can put both in the best position to succeed on a rate stat basis. You're turning 45s in a vacuum into 55s on a rate basis, and then creating trade value as if the players are 50s and 55s, dealing those guys when they become expensive and snowballing similar prospects to ensure you always have enough guys around to do this…

Kiley and I wrote a whole chapter in Future Value about this. Obviously that was seven years ago and things are different. We try to do a version of this every year in the System Overviews of the prospect lists to give you an idea of what we think teams are good at.

Okay friends, 90 minute chat today feels like a good re-entry after two weeks off. Thanks for coming, enjoy the world series.


Brendan Gawlowski Prospects Chat 10-20-26

Hello everybody, let's get to it.

As an evaluator, what have you been able to take from the sustained player acquisition and development successes of the Rays and Brewers?

Two of the prime examples of how holistic player evaluation is the right path forward. Both with great front offices, scouting staffs, and dev operations. Hand in glove operations.

I need a long-term young dynasty catcher. Who's most likely to have a solid MLB career out of Leo Bernal, Vahn Lackey, or Nathan Flewelling?

Lackey but I like all three.

How has Charles Davalan looked at 2B?

Promising but needs reps. Athleticism and range to do it…

Hi Brendan! Thanks for doing these. Every year, it's interesting to see evals and rankings update over the offseason even though there doesn't appear to be a lot of new information added. What's happening there? How do you approach an offseason where you have little new additional info.

I'm not sure I understand your question. We've got a year of new info to work with. Sometimes that changes the forecast, often it doesn't, but either way it's worth reviewing the year and checking in.

Has your opinion of Kade Anderson changed after seeing his four seam with the MLB ball?

I wish we'd been a little cooler on him on the midseason update. His FB grade will go down.

Re: evals over the offseason — apologies, mostly thinking about how you might approach looking at a player or an org given just new perspective but not necessarily any new looks.

Lot of video/data analysis. Even a guy who looks fairly similar might have added a pitch, and it's good to go in and take a glance at how that looks on video.

What do you think Jared Grimdlinger’s path looks like? Definitely not going to pitch? How quickly do you figure he’ll be expected to move?

LAA sources say they're going to try the two-way path. Harder to go quickly that way but fun/exciting nonetheless.

I went through old scouting reports on other sites and saw Profar had present 70 grade SS defense. Was that a misread or did Profar change over time?

There were some injuries in there but the 70 might've been a little hot. I was a neophyte back then though.

Who will be the next good homegrown starting pitcher for the Dodgers?

Zazueta is the leader in the clubhouse.

Years ago when Moniak was selected first overall, I read a report that when he showed up to camp in the spring he already looked less athletic. Do you recall your first look at him that Spring?

Didn't have one, but given that he's still playing a little center in big league games ten years after he was drafted, don't think athleticism was necessarily the prroblem there.

I attended the AFL triple header in Goodyear Saturday and then Glendale at Salt River yesterday. Dax Kilby looked awesome yesterday. His speed was impressive as was how hard he hit his triple and ground rule double. How do you measure speed for your evals? I notice that FGs has Kilby as a 55 spd while MLB and BA have him at a 60. Curious what you look at to grade it.

Home to first time is the anchor and I might throttle up or down a half grade depending on how playable it seems to be. Good example of a tool that's easier to see in all its glory when you're in the park. You get a better look at first step on defense or on the bases, and some video feeds make it tricky to get an accurate run time, too.

Amusingly, I know of a scout who once got into a ton of trouble for putting 60 run times on 30 runners because he was doing it on video and didn't know that all the camera angles weren't synced up.

How much has Nimmala risen in the last week and a bit?

Holding steady.

Maybe a tick down, I'm not ready to move him off of SS yet but I can see it going that way a little more every time I watch him.

Have you seen Nathan Flewelling? How would you rate his catcher D in particular his framing. How to do you grade framing when watching players?

Framing, for me, is easier on video; there's just so much else going on in the park, I have a hard time getting a good feel for it unless I'm really paying attention to just that at the expense of other stuff. But I'm looking for mobility, low stance, strong wrist, limited head movement. If most of the physical stuff looks good but the technique isn't there yet, that's fine, we can project there.

Flewelling himself does a lot of that well, he's low to the ground and can funnel balls toward the plate from all directions.

Hey Brendan! In your Pitcher AFL notes you wrote that Susana had split his breaking ball into two shapes in your October 10th look. The shapes were pretty blended in his AAA looks. Did you hear anything about how that transpired in the AFL and whether it was an explicitly intentional change?

There was enough velo separation between his slowest and fastest ones that I figured it was two pitches; he may have just been adding/subtracting. Regardless, I like that he's able to mix it up a little bit.

Brendan! Right now is generally when my friends and I start our generalized plans for our annual spring training trip. What’s your general feeling for if there will be any games in late-February next year? Minor leaguers will still be under contract, right? If that doesn’t happen we’re also considering Cape Cod, or putting it off until October for the AFL. What’s your general feel for which one would be more enjoyable for a bunch of depressed middle-aged nerds?

Really tough year to make plans, unfortunately. My crystal ball isn't any better than anybody else's. Maybe it's the hopeless optimist in me, but if I had to guess, I suspect we're looking at a similar deal to what we had in 2022, maybe with a few missed games, maybe not.

As for your situation specifically, if you have the flexibility to make plans just a few weeks in advance, you might actually get a pretty good deal on hotels and attendance at big league games will be pretty light, which is a positive in my book.

Alternatively, if you're cool with just going to the backfields, plan away.

Most of the Orioles players in the Fall League seem to be doing well. Anything caught your attention in particular?

Pleasantly surprised by Honeycutt, I guess. More in a 40-ish sort of way than huge impact, but he didn't look overmatched at the plate.

Did Cayden Wallace show enough this season to restore the 40 status he had when he was in the KC system?

That feels about right off the cuff, would need to dive into the defense to say for sure. He's reached the AA power grade he's had here for a while. Approach is not good though.

What position will Ace Reese eventually play?

1B/LF.

I saw the Mets just decided to hire more scouts. This is *maybe* more of a rant than a question, but why did so many teams decide to cut their scouting staffs in recent years, and is there any chance that this particular World Series matchup induces more teams to think about beefing back up in their scouting department?

A combination of things. Some people think that the data is robust enough that you don't need scouts. Some leaders don't like that scouts come from a different perspective and have a different view on players. Some scouts don't do themselves any favors.

If you're the White Sox, do you hold Colson Montgomery for another year? Can he improve?

Yes, numbers tanked right when he got hurt. I buy that he was playing through something in the second half .

I have never visited the backfields, can you give a brief or not suggestion of how to do that?

Each splits its minor leaguers into four or five teams. Those teams play games on the backfields which are usually but not always (Athletics, Giants, Reds/Guardos kind of) very close to the stadium. There are usually but not always two games going on simultaneously (A/A+ teams or AA/AAA teams). There are a few fans but not many, more scouts/family/autograph hounds than anything else. It's a good time.

End of season review on Josiah Ragsdale?

Pretty similar to the midseason eval: https://blogs.fangraphs.com/trade-deadline-prospects-guide-m…

What's David Hagaman's ceiling and ETA?

Ceiling of a no. 3, he'll likely be a 45 this winter, maybe 45+. Could reach the desert next year, take your pick on a 27 or 28 ETA.

I should admit, of all the things I grade/project here, the ETA is the thing I spend the least time on. It's hard enough to project on the tools, and the timeline is often not dictated by talent and performance alone anyway.

If you’re the Sox, do you feel like you have a Story/Arias situation? If so, what do you do about it this winter?

Good problem to have. Cynically, it gives you an excuse to delay the clock on Arias. In the unlikely event that Story is both good and healthy at short, great, if not you have the guy you really want there anyway just about ready to go.

has Walcott’s gotten enough work at SS in the AFL to quell any concerns about his defense there? will be interesting to see how Texas manages Jung and Seager going into next year

I'd shift the framing. It's less a concern to quell than a case where Walcott is going to have to continually prove that he can play short throughout his career.

Hi Brendan, do you have any intel on why Derek Curiel didnt see any MiLB time this year? Coming from LSU I would have thought straight to A or A+ was in the plan. I guess the approach worked well enough with Murf Gray, but seems odd to me.

Fairly typical for first round picks to not go out to A ball at the end of the year. Some do, some don't, wouldn't read too much into it.

With the benefit of hindsight, who were some guys you were way too high on this year, and why were you too high?

There are obviously a lot of guys who didn't reach their projection, but there were always reasons for putting them where I/we did. I think the ones that bug me the most are the ones where data led me astray. Putting too much weight on metal bat exit velos, over-grading a fastball due to shape generated with a minor league ball, things like that.

If the question is more like "why were you too high on Dylan Beavers?" I think you can generally follow the trail of thought from the writeup.

do you expect an over correction to the rabbit ball used in the minors from this year?

I don't really know what to expect. My guess is it will shift back toward where it was before but who knows. The league isn't great at making consistent baseballs.

Is there anything worth reading into from the 2026 draft class at all yet?

Bits and pieces. Couple scouts told me they think Ace Reece looked more hitterish than they expected, which is interesting. But more things like that than a "it really looks like Team X screwed that one up" so far.

Klaw said Aidan Miller looked good during the AFL, did you get a look at him too?

I didn't, sorry, kept missing him. Pretty sure Eric has got him a couple times though, better question for him.

If you had the 1.01 draft pick in a dynasty league this winter, who would you take with that pick?

Not a fantasy guy but PCA/Witt/Elly/Caminero seem most appealing depending on your risk tolerance and positional scarcity needs.

Who is the starting OF on Opening Day 2027, whenever that may be, for the Colorado Rockies?

Carrigg.

with how relievers are used in the postseason now (essentially every game for some), does that affect FV for pitchers projected to be late-inning relievers? Cade Smith ran out of gas but threw more innings than all the Cleveland staff except for Messick/Williams

It's an interesting question. All projections are tricky, relievers moreso than just about anyone else. The very best relief prospects don't reliably turn into dominant closers. And on the other side of the coin, how could you project Cade Smith to halve his walk rate the second he got to the big leagues?

Practically speaking, I'm finding that I'm projecting more and more guys who are starting in the minors into relief roles, and leaving their FV's higher than I perhaps would have a few years ago.

Are you glued to Peacock for this absurd day game tipoff for the NBA's opening day?

No. Bad opinion incoming but… I don't think basketball works.

Anyone from the back end of the top 100 list poised to take a leap on next year's list based on their 2nd half?

I imagine 5-10 will. Kilby for sure. Luis Hernandez wouldn't surprise me. Maybe a guy like Michael Arroyo, now that he's played a little bit in the big leagues, and played well. I'll be pushing to knock him ahead of Celesten at the very least.

Piggybacking on the reliever question, the recent Jaffe article highlights Ashby and points out that he could've won NLCS MVP. If you're starting a 7 game playoff series, would you rather have the lights-out fireman reliever or the 4.00 FIP #3 starter? I'd want the reliever, as I'm sure most would, but on opening day, would the answer be the same? Does (or should) that play a role in projecting players, or are we now introducing another tricky variable into an already tricky art?

To complicate things further: I'm not so sure that the no. 3 starter couldn't just be the fireman reliever.

Any thoughts on Jake Cook's first season in pro ball,?

It was okay. Speed played a little better on the bases than it did in college, which is a good sign. Arrow flat or slightly down.

RE: Rockies OF… that's a LOT of ground for Cole Carigg to cover by himself…

ah jeez, I read that as CF. I assume they'll run it back with McCarthy and Moniak in the corners… Boring answer, I know.

Who in your mind was a "can't miss" prospect when you wrote them up (for either us or PIT) who ended up missing? Why did they miss? If for injury, can you also think of an example that wasn't an injury miss?

I don't think anybody is "can't" miss but I had a big grade on Tovar, and if you'd have told me at the end of his 3.5 win 2024 season that, two years later, his walk/strikeout numbers will go in the right direction AND he'd have a 55 wRC+ I'd have been floored.

Answer there is that the approach got exploited in a big, big way.

What’s the updated super bull case for kilby? Well rounded regular kinda guy, or might there be another gear even on top of that?

The super bullish case is that he can hit .300 with a little power and play above average defense at short.

It's quite a ceiling.

Wait, why doesn't basketball work? I'm not a fan either but can you explain?

Block/charge/no call is just a vibe.

Since higher draft picks produce the most value on average, do amateur scouting departments focus most of their resources on the top two rounds (say, top 75) or so some teams try to focus on building greater org depth and look to hit on later rd picks as well?

Kind of both. The big picks get a lot of attention. Multiple decision makers will go personally see and talk to the seven-figure guys. But there are still plenty of people around pouring their heart and soul into looking for diamonds in the rough.

Does that make Veen or Condon attractive trade pieces? Challenge trade to a pitching rich team possibly (do pitching rich teams even exist given the number of pitchers used by teams per year these days…)

It's worth giving Veen another look but the swing and miss is really scary there. The way the Rockies have developed Condon is different enough from my eval of him that I feel the need to dig deeper to figure out what the heck is going on.

had zero idea that the NBA was trying out day games for opening "night" guess I'm not playing fantasy basketball this year

I didn't either From a distance, the league seems like it's in kind of a weird place. I think it's true in all sports but maybe in basketball especially, a lot of the energy seems to come from stuff not happening on the court.

Do you think draft pick trading will make it into this CBA?

I'd be pleasantly surprised.

Updated views on Tai Peete? Don't want to overreact to a small sample but between AA/AFL he's been great against better competition and has shown better swing decisions recently. Is a 45 FV fair now?

I would not go crazy on AFL production. I'm encouraged that he's continuing to make things work as he's facing better pitching but my feelings on him haven't changed much. He's the kind of player I'd project as a regular as a scout, but one that teams have to value lower than that because he's so risk/reward.

If pick trading made its way into the CBA, what teams do you think would be most poised to take advantage? Who would be most aggressive in acquiring picks, and who would be aggressive in trading them away?

The Rays would find a way to have 40 picks in the first ten rounds.

Ah, the vibe, just like a check swing (nothing defines "offering at the pitch" other than the umpires vibes)

There's some of this in all sports. Pass interference, penalties in soccer, the strike zone at times in baseball history, etc. "Can I legally go to the hoop?" seems more fundamentally problematic to me but… Like I said, it's a bad opinion. We all have 'em.

I saw Teruaki Sato was posted., but I didn’t see him on The Board. Any guess where he’ll slot in?

Sneak peak at Ben's list… He's in 50 FV territory there.

Rank the Ethans"

Salas, Holliday, Pecko, Conrad, Roberts… I'm running out of Ethans, please send help.

Maybe a better question for an article but what's something you think rookie scouts often overstate/understate relative to veteran scouts? What about something veterans more often miss than rookies?

You get better at projecting the longer you do it. You start to get a feel for how certain bodies and traits will age. For veterans, as the game changes, there's a risk that you either don't adapt or just get really frustrated with how modern baseball is played, and that can seep into the evaluations a little bit.

Caceras, A Gomez, Frias, Renteria…you get one to start a team with, who are you taking?

Leaning Gomez, caveat that I need to give Renteria a longer look. Caceres feels a little out of place here.

Sometimes we just have prospects, whom, no matter what we read about them, are skeptical they are ever going to be more than prospects. My recent one has been Tink Hence. Currently, it is Jamie Arnold. Do you have a prospect you are just skeptical of, regardless of hopeful promise.

It's interesting you mentioned Hence, I had a very similar feeling to what you were describing. As a general matter, I tend to be skeptical of the corner guys with light power but good minor league swing data.

Think I'll shut it down here today. Thanks as always for the questions, we'll do it again next week.