Archive for Chat

Members-Only Game Thread: ALCS – Oct 19, 2026

Welcome to our Open Game Thread for the ALCS game today. Only Members can participate, and unlike our usual staff Q&A chats, your messages will be posted immediately.

Our Member community is made up of thousands of incredibly knowledgable baseball fans, and we think this is a great way to follow a game with like-minded baseball enthusiasts. We might even have some FanGraphs Staff drop in and join the fun. Please be courteous to your fellow Members, or you may find your chat privileges revoked.

Over/under for how many innings from bibee? He hasn't pitched in a week, vogt must be mad

I’m hearing under 1 and 2 from my FanGraphs coworkers.

I'm pulling for Cleveland tonight only because I love game 7s and them winning gives us a better chance at that

Games 7 *are* fun!

Good evening everyone!

Hello everyone. Steven Kwan is letting the beard grow and I am proud of him.

Armstong pitching. Is Nominative Determinism the new Moneyball?

Kwan. On. Fire.

So somebody on this broadcast seems to have read my article.

That article was excellent

Thank you!

If I'd had a little more time, I was going to do some fun graphics. You'd see a picture of José Ramírez or whoever with a big thumbs up, and then in huge letters at the bottom of the picture, it'd say "87.2 mph."

They really ought to give credit

I think the mindset is that if it's on the internet, it's there to use.

Is it just me or are there a lot of Guard fans there?

👍⚾️👍

Noted FanGraphs reader Ron Darling

Hello from Raleigh, everyone!

North Carolina, not Cal

I like how the motion sickness medicine ad makes me slightly sick

Hey guys! What's in Raleigh, Jon?

Open source coding conference

Greetings everyone… lets give this maybe one last go… I promise to be nice to Vogt for at least… awe who am I kidding. Glad to be here, GO GUARDS!

At this rate Armstrong going 9

At this rate, he'll have a Maddux.

It is very Maddux that he caught that himself!

The universe is telling us something.

New Balance nerfing Ohtani

Who makes those pitch coms? Yugo?

Old joke… You go…because it doesn't.

“Huh??” said everyone under 40 😆.

coding chat returns!

Can Joey tillo, or can he not illo…or maybe both??

Hey I hope everyone is having a great night 🙂 excited to watch some ALCS baseball

Can anybody help me? I am trying to come up with anyone who went from the outhouse to the penthouse as dramatically as Fastball Freddie did after his trade from the Mets.

I can do the opposite with Casey Blake in CLE… (Bauer both ways?)

Who at MLB thought "Baseball is Something Else" would be a compelling slogan?

Well the other option was “Baseball: we like strikes”

Alright everybody, best joke of the night has been achieved before we're out of the second inning.

Seriously, baseball is kinda cool would have been better

Baseball is baseball would have been better

Maybe they had “Just…baseball” and then Sydney ruined it?

I would like Szym to calculate how much money Kyle Snyder has increased the estimate for Freddy’s next contract.

Bailey having a rough series with challenges

After Hedgie was the single best in the preseason… the entire CLE team has been awful at it.

He's had trouble with ABS all season, which is a little surprising considering his framing skills

I would like to institute a three challenge rule with my wife.

I wonder if Simpson practices making the ball bounce up high like that

Most players train to lift the ball… what if he intentionally tries to top it as much as possible

Post-ground launch angle

lol he's going for yards after contact

I would love a player who made his living off the Baltimore chop.

Let the Simpson worship begin!

Could he BE any more safe?!?

Check that glove for pine tar… I legit dont know if this is legal…

Glad I logged on in time for the Friends reference

Thank you Mesa.

Words never spoken in CLE after 97…

I wish there was a food called a Baltimore chip

Now there is!

chop

Not sure I agree with Matt Festa as potentially the third reliever used in an elimination game

Yes it is very odd considering his reluctance to use him in close games in July

… and then the walk. Yi

Not fit to protect a six-run lead for an inning, but here…sure, why not?

A Festavus for the rest of us

Does the Trop have the most foul territory now that the Coliseum isn't a thing?

Also by “not sure” I mean “I do not agree.” Your report card will suffer, Vogt

I'm doing my best here!

I like the pronounced turf splash when the ball plunks down in the outfield

Yes bartender, I’ll have a Turf Splash with my Baltimore Chips

It the combo is called The Something Else

Well done, Sir

This may not be ideal for Cleveland

I think we're gonna need a bigger boat

Does this count as small ball? Multiple steals

Or a bigger bullpen.

I know Bibee was not great down the stretch but it is honestly hard to understand why he didnt start this game.

As a long (lifelong) suffering Cleveland fan, I'm ok with either of the other remaining teams winning this WS this year. The affinity I feel for lower budget teams is sorta like Larry David shouting "Prius!" at the other priuses on the road

I need the Rays to win this game before Cascade Platinum Plus infests my brain permanently in another game

That commercial drives me crazy.

Imagine being a dishwasher repair guy and just going from house to house saying, "Yeah, nothing for me to repair. You owe me $300 for the visit, though."

I keep hearing "double dong power" and giggle because I"m a child

Channel your disappointment at Vogt, Herrin. Yes, yes, let the evil flow through you.

Also, we tried those pods. The plastic didn't dissolve all the way and they made my dishwasher leak all over the floor.

That’s a feature. It’s called Expanded Water Radius.

They work great in mine.

So yesterday Vogt empties the tank completely when losing 3-0 but today he goes to Festa.

I am so perplexed.

I am both bemused *AND* amused

lol check the ball it him in the arm

BryanB, you're on fire tonight. Can you help me punch up articles?

Happy to. I have advanced dad joke skills.

After Pat Murphy facial expression analysis and the thumbs up and down article I have no notes

I'm vexed. I'm terribly vexed. Nothing against Festa. Seems like a cool guy and all. Something about espresso during the wbc?

YOu can always come back and win three straight in this best-of-9 series

Found Dusty Baker's burner account.

Strategy: HBP takes fewer pitches than BB.

Boy I sure am GLAD the CLE season comes down to a guy not good enough to protect a 6 RUN LEAD!!

He wouldn't even use Festa to protect a 6 run lead against the Reds in the dog days of summer.

Man, the sooner this bullpen game crap goes away the better. I don’t know what possesses a manager to think nine innings of tired pitchers who the other team is seen three or four times apiece makes any sense. Use your starters. If they don’t have it, pivot to a bullpen game,

Can we add that to the negotiations? Verlanders rules.

Just fire Vogt!

Has anyone done an article about bullpen games in the playoffs and if it ever works?

It definitely can work but it depends on your personnel. You eventually need pitchers you can trust in innings that matter so you need to consider that if you're managing

…especially in higher leverage games?

The individual games where teams bullpen have been split 14-14… the team that bullpens more has won 12-11 in series.

Since 2024 it is 10-4 for the most bullpeny team

or so my very quick AI search tells me

You probably need to look at counter factual pitchers instead of just looking at outcomes. Though, that doesn’t seem to be bad for the bullpen team. If I understand it right.

Is a counter factual pitcher… Fallacious?

That one skipped 3x off the lake

Sometimes it sounds like Franceour is talking to himself

Wow huge

Finally a good challenge at the right time.

What a great challenge

Hicks has been pretty good with challenges in the playoffs.

This is remarkable considering he was quite bad during the regular season, successful on just 49 of 87 challenges initiated as a catcher

guardians ran out of steam and now are getting BABIP'd, its really over

There were some babip goings-on yesterday too.

i missed yesterday (daughters birthday)

My intuition is that the luck cannot be as bad as it seems when watching. But then something like that keeps happening and it really may be.

Hoist'd on their own petard.

Excused absences are permitted

Guess what, Steven…Cantillo could have just started this game and giving you multiple innings. And then you wouldn’t have had a bunch of other pitchers pitching in unusual spots.

Magic 8 ball said NO.

chandler simpson might be my favorite non star in the playoffs

Oh WOW

Nice!

CHANDLER

The essential Chandler move

He was 3 the first season of ZiPS 🙁

Time is a predator.

What were his projections that year?

Ground ball, CMON

Ya I think we can just flat say that CLE got out coached in this entire series.

I generally like Vogt but I think he gets too cute at times. On the other hand I give him credit for getting this far with so little

I think its a despite him thing.

Vogt is a very good manager. 25 teams would hire him in a New York minute if he became available.

Good they can have him

I tend to agree with you. I just think there is only so much blood you can squeeze from a stone

FESTA as the BULLPEN ACE!!!!

Ha — it's so weird that he wouldn't have trusted Festa in a meaningless game in midsummer but here he was today.

potty training?

Already maxed on power.

I like Cantillo but Bibee would have been my choice to start today. Has decent history in playoffs if memory serves — at least before his relief appearance this year

The return of the bunt as an offensive weapon has added so much to the game this season

I'm as much an analytics guy as anyone, but bunt hits are so much fun!

That inning could have had a very crooked number.

Lineup churn he's though. #9 and then top of the order up next inning

If a manager can get a team this far with Jo Adell as your cleanup hitter you have to be good.

HE IS THE ONE HITTING ADELL CLEANUP!!!!!!!!!!!

I mean it speaks volumes that the lineup improved so much when the likes of Adell and Lowe joined.

Adell is all he has! Who's better? Manzardo?

almost literally yes

I hope they don't go with "small market disrupters" as the narrative if it's Rays Brewers. These teams had the best record in their leagues this year! They're just good teams!

"Baseball is something else"

No one else to use!

Oh man I wanted to see them challenge Mesa again

More horribly coached actions… DONT RUN INTO THE OUT!!!

Slick as hell double play!

Its not a double play if the runner stops

It might still be. Go to first for the force then get Lowe into a rundown. Lowe isn't fast enough to start, stop, start again and be obviously safe at second

So what… make them work for the out instead of gifting it

I am afraid that wasting that 1st & 2nd with no outs was the Guardians last chance.

If this score holds, every playoff series will have been won by the team with the better record.

Which might be a good omen for the Brewers

They gotta stop walking Walls

Tired: walking Walls

Wired: walling Walks

Man, walking Taylor Walls twice is really inexcusable.

What he said.

Taylor Walls legacy game at this rate

Some are calling him "The Petey Halpin of Game 6"

This is the problem with Cantillo

WHY IN THE WORLD IS CANTILLO PITCHING TO DIAZ HERE!!!

oh good get Espino up now…why be prepared or anything?

You want to keep your best relievers saved just in case you need to hold a deficit at six!

I wish the lady in that commercial just did better brushing her teeth so that she didn't have to be ambushed

The correct pitcher IS in there now at least

The magic 8 ball is right once out of 10 times

I have a bad feeling about this

Caminero sure does hit it to the deepest part of the park a lot

I think he heard me

I could take the Cascade commercial if after the guy says "Well now we know" if the dishwasher guy said "Knowing is half the battle!"

I have switched to Rays radio–was listening to Cleveland so far (my TV seems to have died). I love Tom Hamilton and his vowel(s), but it was getting depressing.

Hot take… Hamilton is mostly just an old curmudgeon anymore… He was legit great once… that time ended about 5 years ago.

same applies to Wilbon on PTI

I love Hamilton but he can get a little bit get off my lawn at times

Summer would not be summer without Ron Darling and Keith Hernandez opining on subjects like the true purpose of Area 51

Honestly, I'd be very wary of a product that shows teeth whiteness change in one day

Ron Darling's always fun because I imagine it's James Woods

Ooh good one

I appreciate someone who can be invested in his team without being a jerk about it. As a Sox fan, I am very done with Will Flemming, who is invested but struggles with the not being a jerk part.

I used to work in the garden and listen to Joe Castiglione. I just can't get into Will Flemming and seldom listen on the radio any more.

I had only Castiglione for 7 years–couldn't afford cable in grad school. His is the voice of baseball in my head.

Its weird like that, I only had a few years of Herb Score… Im not THAT old… and he is the voice in my head.

Given how this is going its time for Vogt to pull Espino for Bibee

I used to get really mad about broadcasters when I was younger, but I kinda got over it. Because like Nickleback, they're not really FOR me.

Also like Nickelback, we're not sure who they are for

I was raised on Hawk Harrelson so all the other broadcasters just seem weird to me

And if you're hanging out here, and paying to read our site, you're not really the target audience for them either

Broadcasters are there for some dude who watches 8 games a year and flips on it becuase it's the ALCS and he needs someone to explain why theres' a guy named Petey

I admittedly was also confused about Petey into this series

As I've aged, I've realized I'm not the target audience for much of anything besides Fangraphs

I was the target audience for the skateboarding Ray

Well, I’d like to see ol Freddy Peralta wriggle his way out of THIS jam!

*Peralta wriggles his way out of the jam easily *

Ah! Well. Nevertheless,

Is BA saying DeLauter's name correct? I was under the assumption that it was De-La-uter

in the end, are we not all of the uter

Chicago accent … DA law tr… is how I say it.

Dan, I cut a joke about those Knowing is half the battle PSAs from my article today.

I'm both proud and ashamed to admit my first concert was Nickelback when I was in 7th grade. I don't really listen to Nickelback anymore, but I had fun and perhaps against my better judgment, l like that one album, "All The Right Reasons."

But also if I never heard a Nickelback song again, I would be content

Matt, buddy, they publish these transcripts.

Davey, the Fensler Films GI Joe videos was the hit of 2004 nerdy online people

Oh my God, I'd completely forgotten about those.

were

Peralta departs, having pitched more innings than any Cleveland pitcher has gotten outs.

Should you find yourself rowing home from Troy, take Nereus

So, Nereus is apparently for counteracting the wrath of Posidon. Who knew?

I feel like Tanner Bibee is on the roster as some sort of punishment, like he has there and sit watching and SEE how little they trust him to pitch

I had exactly the same thought

He knows what he did

Just have to wait for the robot clone to be done like Festa…

Why not pinch hit Genoa here?

"SEE TANNER, LOOK WE'RE EVEN LETTING J-RAM PITCH BEFORE YOU"

Have we addressed that Tampa Bay has played multiple ALCS games wearing "Devil Rays" uniforms? What happened to dropping devil from the name? It's one thing for throwback jerseys but this seems like a concerted effort to reestablish devil in the name.

It's a luck thing – apparently liked their record in them

It's in the fine print of their Fasutian bargain

They're pulling out all the theological stops for the ALCS

They went down to the crossroads, and he said “You can have viable starting pitchers…but I’m taking the naming rights back.”

Society realized that gradients are cool

I wrote a song in 2020 about how you can't just sell your soul to the devil and then get it back by buying new uniforms. Looks like I was right.

I started some weird pandemic hobbies too. I get it.

White Sox had the Pope, the Rays? Well…

Beat me to this. Quick on the draw

They saw how far the White Sox got and decided they wanted more

I like that they're just the Rays because I can imagine it's just a bunch of guys named Ray

Like the Cleveland Naps

The original Ray is in New York

or the Charlotte Bobcats

The Jays?

RAY… when someone asks you if you are a DEVIL, you say YES!

🎶These are the Rays I know I know 🎶

If the Rays get the WS and get Brewers to an elimination game, they should choose then to whip out the never-before-seen red-and-black Tampa Bay Devils unis full of death imagery

"Nate Lowe, standing and smiling"

Not watching TV all year and then watching commercials during the playoffs is an Interdimensional Cable fever dream and also makes me feel bad about humanity

Ads represent us at our worst

The founding fathers really screwed up putting election season during the mlb postseason. I hate that I watch way more network tv when political ads are most frequent.

Believe me its worse in Ohio

I live in Utah and I even get the Ohio and Texas ads! Like why guys

but you'll have clean dishes and teeth

and you'll know just what to ask your doctor about if you have motion sickness and want to go on a boat chase

I'm watching via HBO because I don't really have TV, and there are no ads! It's been lovely, and made me glad the Brewers swept because Fox definitely does have ads.

This should be HBO's entire pitch to get more subs

Forgot about HBO! I've been watching via Sling like a chump!

What is a self driving network

I dont know but can it bring me my bag of Chipotle that is twice my volume?

The graphic in the Crest commercials suggests that sparkly toothpaste goes right into your bloodstream

Is that not how it works? I might be doing it wrong.

Only if you have gingivitis

Good use of the RH PH there Vogt… you genius!

There's a buffet right behind the Rays bullpen. Do you think the relievers ever ask for a snack?

They're not saying boo, they're saying BOOOOOOOOOOOS

Cam Booser, reliever who throws it exactly where he wants it. What universe is this?

(I think they're just cheering)

Booser has been so impressive. The Rays' Ashby.

New plan guys… lets get Baker's fingers greasy on fried food. We are going to need about 8 walks to win this as one will surely get caught stealing.

Who are the red-bearded Rays pitchers. They all look the same. Rasmussen, Baker, Booser, and I think at least one more. ?Kelly? It's kind of crazy

It's the new moneyball

Buck Showalter does *not* approve.

Cade Smith has spent a lot of time pitching from behind lately

Extremely nitpicking complaint: Darling has been saying "bulks pitcher" instead of "bulk pitcher" all postseason and it's driving me up a wall

Yale does *not* approve.

they're the ones who give up RsBI

That looked like a screwball

bang!

Wow, what a way to cap this series

Is exhausted Cade Smith > Tanner Bibee?

Nope

Hmmm, has Cade Smith pitched enough now?

That feels like the one that does it

Junior has just been camping on the high inside stuff all series

HE POINTED AT RANDY AND DID THE RANDY POSE!!!

I love that he pointed to Randy and hit the Randy pose. What a move.

loved that sound off the foul pole

I feel bad for Cade. He did every they asked this year and he just ran outta gas

Junior with a little LiDom flavor on his way to 1B lol

Big Papi meandered so Caminero could amble

Pallacio with the thermawrap on in the dugout. Stars, they’re just like us

Looking like the Guardians might need to Chase DeLaudanum

Could they bring Randy back? Would he come back for the $2.25 an hour plus tips that they'll offer him?

Look I am happy for Jr. but I just wish he still played for CLE… im not sure about this Myers guy

No income tax on the tips

330’ off the label is big time bat speed

The robot version of Megan Fox is not an improvement.

Like tears in rain

There's a non robot version of Megan Fox?

I like how Scotch-Brite makes sure you know that they're America's number one scour pad since that's really important to viewers

I DUNNO IF I CAN TRUST THE NUMBER TWO SCOURING PAD

You and I are not seeing the same ads

Are the tru tv/tbs stream commercials very different than broadcast?

apparently as we are both in Ohio? and I also did not get the scotchbrite add

Has the tree fallen in the forest?

I'm in California watching on tbs streaming

thought Dan was

Am I referencing things nobody knows WTF I'm talking about?

I'm on the stream

The internet has ruined a shared culture! /s

how long have been referencing commercials that only I am seeing?

Guardsball!

If it’s any consolation, I share your skepticism of second-place scouring pads as a principle, even absent any context.

October 19, 2026: Dan discovers that people are just listening to him and politely smiling and moving on

I mean, I genuinely have enjoyed it, and I'm not seeing ANY ads!

I haven't seen the scouring pad ads.

Neither have I. But I HAVE seen the bizarre Jay Leno car contest ads with the cello player. I doubt that plays outside of California but it is WEIRD

Listening to the game on MLB AtBat app, and what I’m getting is that the ads that no one likes are more entertaining than the game.

You getting the Byrna ads?

Like it probably just feels this way but it really really feels like every margin play has gone for the rays

I'm not convinced of the necessity of scouring pads. I just buy sponges with the coarse part on the back, and I have survived so far.

My wife bought the non stick pots. I was skeptical but I will never go back

I got a big set of Le Creuset as a graduation present 22 years ago. Enamel still intact.

Fielder positioning just slightly wrong, HR hits foul poll, Popup just stays in

I'm getting ads for America's vices and AT&T

HBO Max coverage is presented without ads by PayDay, the candy bar, so I'm going with that was a reasonably cheap ad buy…

Peanuts, one might say

My goodness.

What about the lying Sherrod Brown ads?

I've been getting those all month

The Pepsi ad with the 90s song about a crys*l bender gets me every time.

My current ad is telling me that my financial planner will definitely cheat at basketball

Thrivent reminds me of Vivint, who bamboozled me into an expensive home security system that I had to promptly remove and refund once I came to my senses

is walking the bases loaded bad

I did it lots in high school, and I'm still alive

7 more to go

my specialty was HBPing them loaded. More efficient

Patrick Bailey. Do it

Patrick Bailey could become the Aaron Boone of Marco Scutaros right here

Homer Bailey, World Series Hero?!

Do it for Buster!!

Ohhhh goodness Patty that’s two of em

Bailey will replay that 3-1 cookie in his mind for a long time

This could be the beginning of an epic collapse

suddenly looking great for my offhand prediction yesterday of 6-5

6

Ian Seymour… please

Very interesting

This is what happens when you don't look where you're throwing

This is the scenario I was dreading when they put in the 3-batter rule.

They need to stop doing that.

5

Should've seen less, not Seymour

Nothing to see here. It's just the northern lights.

That's textbook intentionally getting hit by Martínez. He turned away from the pitch while leaning into it. Well done

A Sam Antonacci special

Indeed, a beautiful example of taking one for the team.

you guys bought fries for Kelly too, Right?

Who is this pinch runner? I swear I've never heard his name before.

One offseason, I'd for MLB to tell umpires "Hey, you know that HBP rule that you've been ignoring 100% of the time about making an effort to avoid getting hit? Can we try enforcing that?"

Back in the day I feel like there were a couple of umpires who had the guts to call it. I haven't seen it in a long time.

Rocchio one of the preeminent wielders of dark magic in my experience

Spoken like a true White Sox fan

Dark as in he swings as if he’s in the dark? Crazy strike three swing

welp

Counterpoint: why should a batter have to make an effort to avoid getting hit?

They should not have to avoid getting hit, just avoid intentionally sticking something in the way to get hit, IMO.

Just 5 walks short

Rocchio didn't have his magic wand with him this time.

Jeez. Maybe shorten up the swing just a *smidge* there, Rocchio?

That was really damn scary for the Rays

That was probably the final scare

They will get top of the lineup leading off the 9th, too

Against Baker though. And he hasn't been Cade Smith'd (ie hasn't pitched in 9 consecutive games)

Kelly could have thrown a beach ball and Rocchio would miss it there

almost like you should save the PH for when it matters

He was swinging for the Keys

In fairness, it’s his job to do big damage as the no. 9 hitter.

I think the turn away from the pitcher but not actually get further from the ball move is a-okay (morally and aesthetically, not with respect to the rules that I won't claim expertise on). Actually leaning into it is a no-no in my book

I was taught that move too, and I appreciate it. But if I were king, I'd still say it should count as leaning into it. Because it is.

Rocchio has looked, uh, not great at the plate.

I have been wondering, if a batter is HBP by a ball in the zone but the ump allows the HBP, if the pitching team can ABS challenge

That's a great question!

A dog vet named Dr. Lobos? That sound suspicious

Tell me this was an ad

They should be able to challenge anything. Ask ABS if ketchup should ever be on a hot dog

Call confirmed. Yes

I'm against ABS now

was JRam subtly grooving to that music or was it just camera shake

Was just typing, “do you stick with Kelly to start the ninth given Baker’s velo loss?” Apparently the answer is no.

Oh they walked Walls again

clearly afraid of the mighty bat of Walls in this series

Yandy!

Welp.

The final nail!!

That was mostly Walls.

To be fair, if you walk Walls three times you deserve that.

Gotta get to Diaz, right?

That one feels like the dagger

Well, that's a quick way to get the runs back

TOD 10:55 PM

if you talk big stuff you better do big stuff!

OK, NOW bring out the chase de laudanum

"he's not only a good hitter, he's also comically muscular"

I like to imagine that Yandy is pronounced "y and y"

Or “Why, Andy?”

Depeche Mode misheard lyrics

I say it exactly how John Travolta says "Sandy?!" in Grease the first time he sees Olivia Newton-John after their time apart

Guys im not the oldest one in the chat anymore!!

I need more walks 🙁

Yandy! sounds like a birth control that has obnoxious commercials

Which only you can see.

Too bad for CLE there wasn’t a 5 batter rule

I love when they find a different camera angle that provides no useful information or visual

I’ll watch any angle of 112 to the back of the bleachers

Also… Im happy for Yandy I just wish he still played for CLE.. I am not sure about this BAUERS! guy…seriously this is a postseason of ex CLE players making CLE feel bad.

Lotta layers to this one

How do they get topical bumper music ready so quickly?

the AL Central sends its failed 1B to Milwaukee and weird things happen

Not at all sure Yandy should be jumping on guys for bear hugs. Seems like a great way to lose Martinez (?) for the WS with ruptured discs or something.

*stares in kendrys morales*

In 2013 David Ortiz had this thing where he would pick up Koji Uehara and carry him around after every playoff save. I was terrified one or both of them was going to get hurt.

I loved that team!

Man what a game

Since I'm 84, I doubt if you ever were.

whew I'm a mere 48

The AL central has once again been mercifully dispatched

We're getting a new champion

Now what do I do for the next 3 days?

Right?

OOTP?

Did he just make a Hurricane Milton joke?

I get some extra time to write my NLCS Dave Roberts report card

That's the one I've been looking forward to.

Glad you're the one writing it!

I expect carnage in the Vogt one!

Welp. The one WS matchup possible where I dislike both teams. Baseball ends a little early for me this year.

Will the FG team flet us know if there’s a Jeff Sullivan sighting in the celebration?

how can one dislike the brewers AND rays. That's pop on toast!

I mean, look at my flair. It’s more about loyalties (though I have always unreasonably hated TB’s uniform situation).

We’re in for quite a World Series I think

Looking forward to more exhilarating chat on Saturday night but lasting through this upcoming 4 day fast will be tough.

I think we should spend the next four days inventing a new stat that perfectly predicts the score in each game. Aaaaand go!

World Series is chalk. Payroll be damned both #1 seeds won the pennant

Enjoy the rest of the postseason folks. It's been fun.

Amazing that the rays have won two pennants this decade while spending no money at all.

I like the Rays green jerseys

How does the Rays farm compare to the Brews?

Beer>Skate

I think the Rays have oranges and the Brewers have barley and hops.

FG has the Rays #1 overall.

WS should be fun. See you folks there!

Good night all!


Ben Clemens FanGraphs Chat – 10/19/26

Read the rest of this entry »


Members-Only Game Thread: ALCS – Oct 18, 2026

Welcome to our Open Game Thread for the ALCS game today. Only Members can participate, and unlike our usual staff Q&A chats, your messages will be posted immediately.

Our Member community is made up of thousands of incredibly knowledgable baseball fans, and we think this is a great way to follow a game with like-minded baseball enthusiasts. We might even have some FanGraphs Staff drop in and join the fun. Please be courteous to your fellow Members, or you may find your chat privileges revoked.

Hey! Everyone, we got a dinner-time game today, so we won't be up late, but we do have NFL football to compete with. Though the Tampa Bay game just ended. And the Browns already won.

man, "And the Browns already won." feels like a sentence from an alternate timeline…

Tampa. Need them to win pennant to cash this ticket. They’ve done me well. Al east cashed. I need two more wins. I love fan graphs, love the site. I really appreciate the service.

Sigh…

Think the ball is carrying better today

for sure

o/u number of times Messick growing up a Rays fan is mentioned?

It's still weird to me that we're at the point where guys in the big leagues "grew up as" as a Rays fan. They're not that old and they didn't really have fans their first decade

Depends how long he lasts, not off to the greatest start here…

What are you guys talking about?

Baseballs?

He had to challenge that!

Terrible challenge

But not this one.

It’s still way too early for this.

According to last night its time to bring the infield in

The challenges have been just bizarre all postseason.

That bobble by Rocchio could turn out to be the play of the year.

Still a lot of baseball left here

Guards have not been playing clean D the last couple, and they really have to for Guardsball to work

I feel like in the regular season, you load the bases like that and 3 plus runs score. Postseason you get dinged one run, and no one scores again until the 7th inning.

This postseason in particular seems to be selecting for better pitchers moreso than better hitters

How much does this start lead to questioning starting Bailey over Hedges with Messick?

I am trying to understand why DeLuca didn't challenge the 2-0 pitch. The leverage index couldn't have been much higher and his body language said he knew it was a ball.

wanted more than one run!

Use challenges when the leverage calls for it. i

We also don’t get an outfielder running over the parabolic mic guy in the regular season either.

I know hitting is tough but a major leaguer should not swing through those two fastballs in the heart of the zone.

hate both of these teams

Upholding the Yankee fan stereo types… "if we cant win I hate everything and everyone" lol

I can't judge. I hate them back.

people have ask for a "Neither" option in the polls, but that was more for the Yankees games.

no like i particularly hate the guardians' fake offense for how much it gets praised as the only "real baseball" and the rays now adopting it over the past few seasons. swing for the fences like a real team or at least put up a Brewers-level team OBP

cry more… im thirsty

oh yeah? i will

The babip gods are making their presence felt here

How much longer can you ride Messick here?

mostly tough babip luck

The infield shifts have ummm not worked… those were both easy outs/potential double plays

check swings feel like the hardest thing for me to see in real time from CF cams. I’m wrong all the time.

Hi everyone!

What a gift for Messick.

no team deserves to have given up 2 runs on 5 hits in 2 innings of allowing a .188 xBA as much as cleveland

You watch a LOT of CLE games for a Yankee sellout shill.

you think i'm watching this

not sure you know where you are let alone what you are watching

I get it Sean… Ill back off. Just dont like the trolls and wanted to push back a bit. Most Yankee fans are not like this.

Pretty sure Junior would swing at a ball into the stands

Is that Ronald Acuña ad for Kalshi any less weird with the volume on?

I’d say it’s more weird

It's much weirder with the volume on

He lives in a tunnel under home plate, is that the premise??

Yes and you should bet on it or something?

I bet he actually lives in a house.

THAT should be a Kalshi bet

Keebler Elf tree.

Probably a large one.

Wow what a catch

A good poll would be which commercial do you hate the most?

Liberty Biberty is in the mix

There is an obvious answer to this question but it is not a fit topic for a baseball chat.

How will Cleveland cover 27 outs here?

Dunno but I'm excited to find out

Okay, this is random, but what about letting the winning team in the postseason pick a player from the opposite team for the rest of the post? I know, I’m crazy.

Wow, those 2014 Royals…

This would be a fantastic offseason/lockout article, actually. Say, postseason series of the 2020s where the victor takes a player from their opponent…perhaps Dan can ZiPS up the biggest additions

Simpson is in their heads

Broadcast booth has a collective Speed Boner.

they're just like me!

I mean yes, but can’t blame them

Is it a prerequisite for being a playoff broadcaster that you have to wish the game were still played like it was in the ‘80s?

That's how they train them in broadcasting school.

Rays are going to score 1 run every inning to win 9-0.

My hot take on bunting is that showing bunt should be treated as a swing and therefore often a strike

That has to be caught!!!

Rays relaxed on challenges

I think Simpson tried to high five the ump

The ump was holding the bat out but Simpson was too far away to grab it

RISP kings

With the lack of travel day after this it makes this feel more critical than the average 2-2 game 5. Loser is gonna have to really ride their A bullpen

Can we get a return interview with Jeff after the Rays win the WS to breakdown the minutia of the playoff decisions, positioning, pitching strategy… or is that too proprietary to ever become public?

Brew Crew might have something to say about that!

Brewers certainly look like the team to beat to my eyes

Who is the target audience for Limu Emu and Doug?

Stoners?

Haters of all that is good and right?

We should have Jeff and August face off against each in podcast before the WS starts.

* said with the caveat, I have no power to make this happen.

Are there Fangraphs alumni reunions at the Winter Meeting ever?

All the time, and Saberseminar. Though team employees have more restrictive schedules during Winter Meetings.

Wow

That was a fun bunt

This is a real fun team

Ill admit that was super smart and well executed.

Just a great opportunity to catch them off guard: relatively fast runner who can't really hit anyway, lefty reliever on the mound

If the WS is Milwaukee against Tampa, it should be a very entertaining defense and baserunning show. When was the last time there was more team speed than that in the World Series?

Probably one of those Royals teams with Dyson, Cain, Gore, etc

So quickly you forget Eckstein… FJM remembers…

But KC played the Giants, who I don't remember as overly fast.

I did not think Kwan had a chance in the world there

This inning has had some serious excitement

Kwan has the best weak arm in baseball

The one-run-per-inning thing looks to be in jeopardy.

oh well.

love me an exciting scoreless inning (when it's not my team failing)

The circumstances are setting up for Rasmussen to potentially go deep in this game

Cleveland really needs a baserunner. It's been a too long.

there ya go

the challenge furthered the stated goal.

I've been getting some other work done, and I swear every time I looked up the Rays were on base.

That's a good challenge.

What does it say about the state of these commercials all month that I'm grateful for a Wendy's ad?

it says you are sane

I like that they are bringing back the yellow packaging.

Now we need more solariums.

Magic 8 ball says Sabrowski

Holy cow

I mean, Walls certainly isn't in there for his bat

The margin feels much bigger than 3 runs

I've used the word feckless a lot in the last 30 minutes talking about Cleveland's offense.

Not one feck

In all seriousness the biggest difference in this game has been defensive positioning… Rays =Great, CLE=Bad

On the broadcast the other day, they compared Rasmussen to Doc Halladay… feels apt after this postseason

Is it just me or could Sabrowski be Messicks brother?

Another TB baserunner…I looked up at the TV.

Not for long!

That was the first time all series Bazzana did that right

Was he even running?

Do teams give players scouting reports for the likely defensive alignment they will face on a given night vs a given team vs a given pitcher… Do we know the level of detail in that sort of prep?

That was middle-middle to both Kwan and Ramirez

Alright Cleveland is awake

🥱

Here we go

now its up to everyones favorite former angels player

sike never mind

lol shortest half inning ever

I’ve been shouting at the team to take Rasmussen out but did he listen to me? Nooooo.

Welcome to my world with Vogt.

The reverse communication function on TVs never works as well as it should.

Stunning to see Cash, notorious for yanking pitchers, leave Rasmussen in.

Surprised Rasmussen doesn't use that changeup more

Brilliant to not challenge in order to forgo the strikeout in favor of the double play

That’s advanced fortune telling

ah, not challenging because you had the double-play pitch charged up, Rays are streets ahead

80-grade reference

Well of course you’re gonna lose weight if you have diarrhea, nausea, and vomiting

Ah man I was hoping all three would

Oh man I was hoping all three would hit each other

I don't love taking out your best hitter in the 8th

Has DeLuca hit a ball?

It's always an adventure with DeLauter

That is a very kind way of saying it

Not a huge fan of chasing this game with Cade Smith with no more off days.

Vogt strikes again!

Cleveland bullpen would look way deeper with Clase

Cade here is…questionable

two more ABs for cleveland though… Vogt betting on his bats

Is Stephen Vogt trying to mismanage the bullpen so badly that he gets fired and can take the open Seattle job so that his wife gets to be by her family again?

4D Chess

I think I want JoRam up to lead off the 9th if I'm Vogt

Unless I want the seattle job I guess

Kwan on fire today

Really bad swing decision, but it worked out for him.

nice wedge play there

The visiting bullpen labyrinth shot

Ahh man I like Booser

Feels like you have to go to Baker here, even if it burns him for the 9th

That was huge

If I’ve learned anything from these commercials it’s that Americans are very sick and very in need of insurance

Jake Bauers should get an insurance commercial gig

This is correct.

Yep

I take that back. We are in need of health care.

Oh wow was that pitch outside

There’s a lot of depressed vampires here tonight. I mean broken bats.

Yandy is…inevitable.

Wondering what happens if the Guards come back and we go to extras without Yandy and Junior.

Dogs and cats living together, it’ll be anarchy!

This is a lot of pitches for Smith given that he's basically guaranteed to pitch in every remaining game in this series

Martinez in there for defense?

Not the ball-catching kind. A different kind.

He is Vogt's talisman this year… Why there is one obviously terrible player who he decides to ride into defeat each year is another question all together.

White Flag warming up in the bullpen.

Poor guy.

Did you see the moon behind him?

Kwans game

That catch sounded weird, right? Like the double tap of a foul tip.

Ohhhh. It bounced off the wall — but THROUGH his glove.

Imagine if that matters… says the CLE fan hopefully.

Kwan trying to win this game himself

Kwan is the defensive replacement

Mesa (and Junior) need to stop being selfish

WOW

what a giant glove

Who is this guy in the AT&T commercials? His voice is odd.

He's the new Lily. Prepare to see him even more during the NCAA tournament.

He’s no Lily.

You people leave the sound on for commercials?

Yah…

I mean the remote is at least two feet away…

Given the nature of the adds in Ohio… off is the only option. Like leave the game muted to avoid the breaks only option.

Good AB dude

lol wth dude

oof

How many times do you practice that?

Knoblauch

i thought lowe tattooed that

in an elevator shaft

Adell … the first pitch and it was right in the heart again…

I mean I’m for the Rays but credit to the Guards, they never give up

may cost them tomorrow if the Rays get to Sabrowski, Gaddis or Cade…

But it may not!

Definitely one of those options

can't wait for the 6-5 game tomorrow

What am I going to do when the WS is over 😭😭😭

stare out the window and wait for spring… or read Fangraphs

Alright everyone. We got at least one more LCS game tomorrow. See you then!


Members-Only Game Thread: ALCS – Oct 17, 2026

Welcome to our Open Game Thread for the ALCS game today. Only Members can participate, and unlike our usual staff Q&A chats, your messages will be posted immediately.

Our Member community is made up of thousands of incredibly knowledgable baseball fans, and we think this is a great way to follow a game with like-minded baseball enthusiasts. We might even have some FanGraphs Staff drop in and join the fun. Please be courteous to your fellow Members, or you may find your chat privileges revoked.

Hi everyone! The weather looks clear though cold in Cleveland tonight. https://www.wunderground.com/hourly/us/oh/cleveland

Poll is the same as yesterday, since we didn't play that game.

elsewhere in the midwest, a millvillemeltdown realizes they forgot all their hoodies, sweatshirts, and light jackets when packing

I broke mine out again this morning.

Hello, Sean.

Hi!

i love hoodie weather. slightly less pleasant without the hoodie though

i borrowed a cardigan that is just a bit too threadbare to protect against the wind

Sweatshirt weather is the best weather.

14 hours at an analytics conference and I am ready for a break *immediately logs into FanGraphs*

Hopefully this is more fun. Though, any analytics conference sounds fun to me right now, too.

For those who have never been, CLE is not like SF in fall. That 43 feels like 35 at most.

i spent a bit of time in the bay area one december and was thoroughly unimpressed

my staunch opinion, and maybe this is informed by abnormal physiology, is that hoodie/sweatshirt weather extends past 0°C

to my chagrin, i was raised in the South

Any reason why neither team went with their game 1 starter tonight? Wouldn't they be on regular rest now?

hubris

a less flippant answer might depend on, like, the pregame work they did yesterday?

It looks like Griffin will be the bulk guy actually. Not sure why you keep Rasmussen out for a day though

granted he didn't look too sharp his last start

Would starting tomorrow line up his throw day with Game 7 potentially?

Maybe? But you'd think pitching today would only make him more rested for a possible game 7

May have something to do with now having to play 4 days in a row with no travel day.

Yeah I guess this makes it more likely you can use both Martinez and Rasmussen in a potential game 7, but that seems pretty specific

Over under on combined K's tonight? I am setting the line at 19.

on one hand, kwan and simpson. but on the other, Jordon Scott Adell

Ya Cle is not that K prone and neither is tampa (lowest in MLB)… but both pitching staffs are.

Love the full name lol… for reasons inexplicable to even myself, I still say Clifton Pfifer Lee whenever his name is mentioned

his name isn't joseph! which the mariners did not know when they let him rob 3 hrs

Tom Emanski is upset.

Zombie Tom Emanski is an available username

It would be a great idea to do an article about a sloppy defensive game from the point of view of Tom Emanski. I'm writing that down.

second

davy singlehandedly keeping notgraphs running like weekend at bernie's

Please make sure to include a supporting comment from Baseball Superstar Fred McGriff.

ohhh that's why butler is lawdog

Have people picked up on the change in the lyrics that the fans sing for Chase's walkup?

The “hit a homer”? Yeah, that’s pretty awesome.

Did not expect a Kyle Lohse name drop! Loved that guy

now why are you running on Victor Mesa Jr

Hello all!

Pretty fantastic stuff from Griffin that inning

Is nine pitches and two strikeouts good?

I didnt like the move at the deadline… I thought that they traded Will Dion (6+years) for Will Dion (.5 years)…. I was very likely wrong….

wills dion are fleeting, ephemeral… flags fly forever…

fleeting and ephemeral is exactly how I would have described Griffins first half at the time… lol… Like I said it was a bad take.

we'll see how dion develops, he looks to be solid at least

when did they add the "ball in dirt" animation to gameday

If Aranda runs through there, wonder if everyone is safe

i think it'd only work if they were trying to stay out of the dp

because if the pivot holds onto the ball, they can try and catch him between 2b-3b

That's probably true. Just looked weird to stop right in front of a force out

Yeah Aranda looks like he slipped a bit. It was a closer play than they made it out to be.

Petey Halpin always finds the action

With all the love in my heart, he caught that like a Petey

A remarkable athletic play that was like 20% derpy

What was the exit velo and angle on that?… I have a feeling on a warmer night that was out

110.7, 29 degrees, per Gameday

110.7, 29

110.7 at 29 degrees

"xba 1.000"

out in 17/30

So Petey covers 13 stadiums. News you can use

cheers guys!!

interestingly, both cle and tb in the parks it's not a hr in

If I back calculate an Xdistance from the numbers I get 433 which is definitely out in both…

depends heavily on atmospheric factors + spin

for sure. That was for neutral wind and normal cle temp/humidity… should have used game conditions

also was in that odd pocket where the tall wall starts

TNT doing an embedded Waste Management ad instead of letting the audience hear the crowd sing was a choice

thankfully hammy and rosey calling attention to it

Brutal for Walls

do they gotta put genao on for tbazz?

Boy with possibly 4 straight days of games I'd be trying to get more innings from Griffin who looked mostly really good tonight

If anyone here has any logic to how Vogt uses the bullpen ever let me know because I have given up… I think its literally a magic 8 ball.

if he goes to gaddis or smith today i'm going to be really disappointed

Pick the worst possible reliever and the worst possible time and prepare for disappointment. Just not Festa… he is a MYTH

If it's close he will absolutely use them

matt festa, zero innings pitched

espino this early bodes poorly for me

Espino being nasty makes me happy. Hopefully he gets a solid career

Yeah, even if he’s just a filthy reliever that would be great given we all assumed his career was shot

Legit think they should make him a short stint starter next year and just go for something like 120 innings… If the BB rate is under 4.5 he is going to be very very good.

he sure feels like a leverage guy rn

Googling MLBPA service time pension milestones…let’s get him to 4 years before they try to stretch him out again

i think bazz should not steal here. he probably will try to, though

Two big double plays in the fifth

1.000 ops Bailey was amazing while it lasted

That feels like something you can’t do and win

ya walking 2 guys for JCam is a bad plan

Guessing 116 on that one

Another 110 but absolutely smoked

Hit his spot at 98 and Junior did that. He’s so good.

gave up the run but one of the best things in baseball is a good outfield relay. Kwan played it well off the wall and made a quick throw, keeping one of the fastest players in baseball at 3rd

Tootblan?

Tootblan

contact play= not TOOTBLAN…???

So am I wrong that infield in is dumb here?

Seems like runs are nearly impossible to come by this postseason, so I get it

I mean, that was a heck of a pick by Lowe

The slide was 2 feet from home plate

My most dad quality is reflexively saying "Nice block" whenever I'm watching baseball, even if I'm alone in my apartment.

Also, hi

Guards have been doing this all post-season—stopping the big inning. They gotta feel pretty good with only one there.

ESPN win probability estimate says the Rays went from 79% WP after the Caminero double to 60% now. Huge escape there

Is the plan to pitch Peralta in this inning and start him in G6?

Center field is not where the hits are tonight

Middle infield is, though

I thought DeLauter probably should've caught that

That looked so catchable…

He was too busy pretending to attempt to catch it

Is that a swing by automated checks?

Ball dont lie I guess

Yandy if there were ever a time to challenge, that was it

Yandy is so committed to the never challenging bit

I do hope they go through with the new check swing rule they're testing in the minors

oof

This is a rough inning for DeLauter

OH NO

HE GRISHAM'D IT

Wow, DeLauter looking like a good DH today

Petey Halpin needs to play every position

infield in = dumb… I am vindicated?

If Cleveland scores 3, definitely.

Chandler Simpson hitting a ball >300 feet, what a time to be alive.

WHY NO THROW??? I know it was near pointless but so is not throwing

Guess no one is challenging anything tonight?!

too cold

So I missed this earlier, I assume Peralta is scheduled to be the game 6 starter and today is just a throw day, so no adverse consequence?

I dont know what that is in the bullpen but I am positive that it is not the REAL Festa….

Patty barrels makes way for Pummelin' Petey

Playoff Patty poking Posey in the eye

Jk Pummelin' Petey is getting pinch-hit for

Bailey for Tugboat I adored at the time… looks better every day.

Honestly if Buster Posey calls with a trade idea, just say yes

My Guardians fan friend has taken to calling Angel Martinez "Devil" because of his recent struggles

Back to back hits by Bazzana and Bailey:
107.8 EV, 21º, 374 ft.
107.9 EV, 20º, 375 ft.

As a Yankee fan, who is this person and what did he do to Ian Seymour

ah, good, more intense baseball for me

INFIELD IN=DUMB!

Guardsball! I yell over and over. My dogs are hiding under the bed but I can’t stop yelling Guardsball!

After the NL series, I’m not used to the bullpens allowing so many runs.

Resource scarcity. Used to be you had several Ashbys available. These days there’s just the one

If this is Festa now… I am going to start cheering for the Rays.

time to change that team flair then

This is the first time I’ve seen him throw and I’m enjoying his whole deal so far

Festa is by no means terrible… which is why it was soo soo odd that he was never used to this point and still kept on the roster… it was/is maddening.

I just got home from seeing the Nathan Fielder movie about the fraud lady, which is completely insane. I gather there has been a lot of Ray and then more recently some modest Guard.

A comedy? Love me some NATHAN FOR YOU

It's supposedly a documentary, but with Fielderish layers.

You did this Vogt… You broke me!

Seymour almost just ruined the entire game for the Rays

There’s still time

I will say this, the Guards are showing why they deserved to win over CWS

Vogt’s going to start pitching everyone on 3 weeks rest now

Booth gassing up Seymour to get 9 outs fell apart fast.

Yah they clearly saw Seymour

The slo mo replays of Guards hitting him really highlighted his head whack. It was probably 50% camera angle and 50% knowing the result of the AB but it looked wild.

Maybe Aranda is deaf like Nate Lowe

Ah we're into the alliterative part of the Tampa Bay bullpen

Pitchers are supposed to pitch STRIKES, right?

Nope, supposed to get OUTS.

Thats the game with the bigger ball and the smooth pieces of wood on the floor.

Soooo close

Pitcher #653

Smith is up… WTF VOGT!@@!@!@@!!!

It's his bullpen day

He's committed to driving you away

All catchers hate pitchers.

I think that ball is still going

It’s in the lake, but not the one you’re thinking of

ooh

I wonder if Cam Booser ever faced Seth Beer in the minors.

Guys its been good… Vogt is about to bring in Smith because the 8 ball (PG version) said so…. Im gonna need a new hobby… suggestions?

Saved by the actually good decision to leave in Festa's robot clone… lets bring back a bit of the flair…

Well, that might just about do it.

He doesn't hit that off Smith! /s

Oof this game was interesting for a bit.

[SpongeBob 'aight imma head out' meme]

And now a new pitcher burned… WHY? JUST WHY???

I’m surprised that went out

I thought it was going foul off the bat. I am … not a smart man.

Ange- err, flappy bois in the outfield carried it a bit farther

Same

I was really enjoying Festa’s whole deal

i completely fell asleep and woke up to the chekov's festa

I am not joking when I say that Vogt is so bad at bullpen strategy that he should be removed from all decisions.

TNT needs to check back in on that sad lady with the row of empty Miller Lites

Not impressed with the home ump

Really bringing in Baker?!?

it sounds like he's been warm, you don't want to (ahem) "dry hump" him too much

Cash is jealous of Vogt's MOTY trophies.

lol even the score bug knew that was a ball

Junior having a hard time finding the ball

Whoa, Cantillo bullying Junior with three straight changeups.

Anyone else think Tampa should have tried to finish this out without using Baker? You potentially play 4 days in row here and at minimum need to play three days in a row. I feel like I’d try to preserve him in a non-save situation

Ya this is a horrible horrible use of Baker.

Cash is honoring Joe Maddon by bringing his closer into a non save situation in Cleveland. Surely these extra reps won’t come back to bite Tampa

So which of these teams would be more of a challenge for MIL? I feel like either staff would be vulnerable to the relentlessness, but TBR could at least hit some homers to compensate, particularly if Junior ever wakes up.

rays absolutely a better team. cleveland is more pesky than good

I think of Tampa as like 85% of what Milwaukee put together. They do all the same things just not as good.

Cleveland would be a tougher series for Milwaukee. Cold weather, playoff tested, better rotation and bullpen

its 7 games I would ballpark the actual odds difference at around 1.5% in favor of the Rays vs MIL vs CLE

good call by hammy, baker's velo is down

Series is tied! We might get 7 games here.

the proximate brewers fan: yes… ha ha ha… YES!!!

he's sitting 92 after averaging 96ish?

Alright everyone! Let's do this again tomorrow around 5PM ET.


Members-Only Game Thread: ALCS – Oct 16, 2026

Welcome to our Open Game Thread for the ALCS game today. Only Members can participate, and unlike our usual staff Q&A chats, your messages will be posted immediately.

Our Member community is made up of thousands of incredibly knowledgable baseball fans, and we think this is a great way to follow a game with like-minded baseball enthusiasts. We might even have some FanGraphs Staff drop in and join the fun. Please be courteous to your fellow Members, or you may find your chat privileges revoked.

the brewers fan in my vicinity has stated "i don't care who wins this series, only that it goes 7" which. i think is fair at this point

but wouldn't MIL lose some of its momentum?

how massive is milwaukee. i figure their collective inertia should carry them a while

7 games with two extra inning games in TBR.

Though there's two off days between a game 7 and game 1 of the WS. Which is plenty of time of a bullpen to recover. SP might not be lined up.

I wouldn't mind more baseball games.

without giving away too much, i got an interview in baseball thanks to seeing a posting on fangraphs! thanks fangraphs!

eyo, grats!

that's awesome! good luck!

congrats!

did you have to fight through AI resumes and AI HR screening?

… don't remind me of the hell that awaits me after my thermo midterm…

honestly no, it was a pretty lightweight application and process thus far

I'm scared if I had to apply for jobs again.

i'm hearing all my classmates complain about r. i have never used r. i keep reading that i should learn r, upskilling and whatnot, and i just don't want to.

i wrestle with computers enough… i don't want to do more wrestling… i don't want to wrestle a computer to make the computer wrestle more computer…

When I was in college more than 15 years ago I also had classmates learning R. If it's still in use now, that's an eternity in computer time so maybe learning it is a better investment than learning some other things?

i will be honest, i just don't enjoy stats! i think it'd probably be good for me, but i took quantum with that intention last year and it was not very pleasant.

I bet the Rays at 25/1 to win the AL East (thanks to FG projections), so I've been a fan all year. I kinda like them at +155 to win the Series, but the Sim says I need 2/1, so I'm reluctantly gonna pass.

You would have lost money if you bet against the Brewers because of our projections.

I've lost money betting against the Brewers the last THREE years!!

Sorry about that!

But had the 2 long shot AL East winners (TOR/TB) because of FG. That makes up for a lot of OV/UND misses.

It looks quite wet in Cleveland. Tarp just got put back on…so that's not good.

Tarps on is just not compatible with baseball in 2026.

I didn't realize the game was going to be delayed when I posted up on the couch, and now I've got a sleeping cat on my lap and my book is in the other room.

I've never looked up Cleveland's weather so much as I have in the last week.

mike trout would be so disappointed in you

I look up weather a lot. Just not Cleveland.

And sunrise and sunset.

I learned R in grad school and it (in addition to my non-coding skills) has kept me in steady work since 2021 ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

im in a similar spot, but i did Python instead of R

I live on the other side of Lake Erie and all of our storms come from the general direction of Cleveland

I've been slowly building up the Python skill, mostly for ArcGIS

Oooo…are we turning this into a coding chat? I'm in!

Until we get baseball?

what do you use to code the chats? i assume its mostly javascript?

if it turns into a coding chat, do I need to leave or will I learn something?

neither, we'll probably be incompressible and boring with a dumb joke every now and then

Sean actually has his own bespoke programming language just for fangraphs? /snark

Most disappointing thing is sitting down on the couch with delivered pizza in hand and seeing a tarp on the field.

Hey, at least you have pizza. I have cat.

But think of the people who are seeing a tarp and *don't* have pizza!

Cat? Side note, our 15 year old cat just caught a fly. That was exciting.

the cat i live with is trying to convince us that he has never been fed

what toppings?

The kids are cheese and so am I.

My favorite pizza in town is a Beef Tostada though.

I'm couchlocked by a sleeping tabby (see above)

Our orange tabby just got off the couch to wait for his food in 90 minutes.

Our front end is NextJS. We still have a handful of pages that still use .NET webforms which is old.

So the front end of chat is in Next/React/JS.

I see the chat polls are a lot more realistic now for who's going to win. Game 1 was 91% for the Rays.

Chat backend is .NET, so C#.

R gang member, reporting for duty

Which this is a lot like some corporate stacks and in turn a lot of teams have tech stacks similar to this. Or at least had a few years ago.

Python >>>>> R

brought to you by the Python Gang

i am decent enough at python that i think i can read docs and be vaguely competent

my partner knows ???frontend??? as well as everything else from cs undergrad. but i know not

Been a while since I logged on to a Fangraphs chat and understood nothing of what was being said. But I know what wrc+ stands for! Is that worth nothing???

what's a run? are they like points?

Yes, but also literally a guy running, which is a necessity; see Merkle, Fred.

Part of me wishes we used more python, but in the end it doesn't matter too much. I also don't do as much with our ETL process.

and sean joins the python gang…

We really ought to bring boner back as a term for messing up

but why doesn't the ball go in the goal?

See, now I'm thinking of Andres Cantor calling a home run

Also, don't know what's happening in Cleveland, but I'm a couple hours west and it's barely drizzling if anything.

if i had my hands on the fan graphs code, id definitely convert more to python and add more plotly style interactive visuals

What would the visuals be?

id focus on the interactive parts more – like adding visuals for all the leaders tables and hovertext, filtering, employing splits filtering into visuals too

We need to add custom photoemojis. I surprisingly use an Austin Hedges one a lot in my baseball group chat. And since Hedges was a league average hitter this year (wRC+ 😉), it was used a lot.

It's wired up to use a .png. We have to hard code it in there, but it's ready for it.

I would add a notification system to the comments so that I would know if somebody replied to me. Would be much easier to waste my days yapping about baseball!

We might be able to do that now. Part of me wants to rip out WP's comment system for a modified version of chat.

Email is the easy notification for this. Probably could do app notifications too.

i also wanna know if my jokes in the comments get likes or not

HOOOOOOOONNNNNRROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOON

also i have several baseball themed emojis that i abuse in my baseball discords, would love them here

The storm is reaching across the lake now, don't know if that means it's moving away from Cleveland or just quite large

It's moving south and east. So I think it's clearing up now.

Does the tabby get food before baseball starts?

Mine was fed before scheduled first pitch.

Ours is 7 AM, noon, 6 PM, and 9 PM

I'm understanding about half the coding words being discussed here? maybe less?

I'm a field biologist by training so if we get beyond the analysis stuff I actually do I'm pretty much with you. The main thing is to get good enough at the basics so you can work through solutions to the thornier problems by leaning on StackOverflow, etc.

another fun thing we can do while we wait is a friend of mine sent this questionnaire supposedly a baseball team used for job screenings

if my link is allowed?

gotcha

Coding, 1908 references, cats trapping people on couches, Cleveland weather. This chat is LIT!!!

Bad weather along the Great Lakes… kinda wish I had an Edmund Fitzgerald Porter now

I remember drinking a lot of Railbender when I was up in Erie.

Hard to come by in Denver

Usually when I am at a chat on Fangraphs about baseball I feel like I have a strong understanding of the subject but my slash line about what is being talked about here is .000/.000/.000.

This is why they don't let me on these often.

two more chat coding feature requests – uploading images and ability to delete your own comment

Don't make the same mistake I did and start giving a cat three meals a day. I could believe that in theory you could break the cat of the habit, but it would inflict so much pain and suffering that it's not worth it. I can barely hold him to just the three

Welp.

We're going to have to do this tomorrow/Sunday.

This was the best non-game game thread we've ever had!

Same time tomorrow for game 4. Then game 5 will be Sunday at 5PM ET.

whens the last time a playoff game got rained out


Members-Only Game Thread: LCS – Oct 15, 2026

Welcome to our Open Game Thread for the LCS games today. Chat with fellow readers as we watch the Rays play the Guardians then later tonight the Brewers play the Dodgers! Only Members can participate, and unlike our usual staff Q&A chats, your messages will be posted immediately.

Our Member community is made up of thousands of incredibly knowledgable baseball fans, and we think this is a great way to follow a game with like-minded baseball enthusiasts. We might even have some FanGraphs Staff drop in and join the fun. Please be courteous to your fellow Members, or you may find your chat privileges revoked.

Rob Manfred just announced that if the Guardians win today, tomorrow's game will be played at 9 a.m. as punishment.

When it rains, it gains.

I'm ok with that. Get it done and out of the way first thing in the morning. Like going to the gym.

Why does MLB hate baseball? Forcing most of the nation to have a tab open at work to track playoff baseball

Why does MLB hate baseball? Forcing most of the nation to stay up way too late to track playoff baseball

it moved due to impending weather

How does hockey and basketball do it? Longer time frames to complete the series?

shorter game times hlep

Was the weather supposed to be bad? My app shows only light rain starting around 10 PM…

they can finish well before 11 EST even with a 830 start

mine too L. Ron, but that is what was stated

Maybe the teams have better weather models than what is available to the public

Re: other game (Brewers) – it's that lovely time of year when the team with the best record in baseball, in the highest-stakes games of their season, can only trust 3 of their starting pitchers

Drohan+May is not embarrassing for your fourth starter. Unfortunately for the Brewers, the Dodgers' fourth starter is Tyler Glasnow

Looks like there are more people at the just-moved up early Cleveland game than the Dodgers game last night.

As far as I can tell, the Brewers have not even announced a starter for tonight, no?

Not as far as I can tell. Here's the exchange from last night's postgame press conference:

Q. Pitching tomorrow?

PAT MURPHY: Yeah, there will be pitching.

Wait this isn't a joke?

Day baseball is the best!

Also, hi

begging baseball broadcasts to show defensive stats when they show the defensive alignments instead of gold gloves

I appreciate Murphy being very literal as a source of snark, which is something I like to do

I still think my Nereus commercial would have been more effectively targeted during the playoffs.

I thought Kwan challenged that pitch

Nope on replay

But he probably should've

He's reacting to all the other early 1st inning challenges.

Perfect throw, great tag

something in me is convinced that if a starter comes out firing, they're bound to give up a homer or a big inning later in the game. so idk how to feel about either of these guys right now

but especially gavin williams, some fallacious, treacherous part of my gut is about 85% sure that yandy is going to go yabo off him in the 4th or something

or he makes me look totally stupid. that works too

I've been on Gavin train for a while now!

A gambling commercial centered around a guy with a $100M+ contract becoming homeless is a choice

The fans and players need to really push back on the gambling ads. I know Alex Call did but for the Sweeney of it

I'm putting some Cy Young money on him next year (since I'm not an AL voter)

I did really well on $200 on Scherzer Cy Young in 2013! Feels like this is gonna be the same type of value bet

I think it is funny. No NY and soon No LA.

don't jinx it, terry lol

I'm down for an all Midwest WS. We'll go all out here for that.

Don't know how many people will care.

i will be razzing the person who once used the handle "hoby milner defender" on the website formerly known as twitter the whole time

Turned on that one nicely

That was a crazy ricochet off the wall

This postseason has featured way more Petey Halpin than I expected

there's always one cleveland outfielder who goes nuclear for a postseason

some of them are out of the league by the next… rip spongebob and big christmas, we will tell our children your stories

I'm sorry, there's no way you can make a scour sponge exciting

chainsaw attachment might help

2 cylinder scrub sponge would revolutionize the kitchen (by giving everyone co poisoning)

I guess there's no rules about awards voters betting on awards?

There are!

If we're going to vote on them

Okay so only the awards you vote on are off limits?

I don't bet on any NL awards to avoid the chances I have to recuse

We also have rules about working for gambling

You're not worried about Williams's postseason dominance inflating his odds for 2027? I'm guessing he's much more on people's radars now than he was a month ago

It's kind of funny that Nereus discloses that it may inhibit your ability to use a vehicle or machinery at the same time their little animated video has a person driving a car in a high speed chase.

Oh, I'll definitely check the odds first, but he's definitely a player I'm watching from a +EV standpoint!

I don't gamble much, just opportunistically

I get no endorphin-related thrill

Gambling is too expensive nowadays. Money is better used elsewhere

That did not look like Gold Glove defense.

Walls *is* a good name for a defensive player

JRam is so fun to watch

he's like a little wrecking ball of baseball prowess

Whenever I hear the name Griffin Jax, I think of Jax from Mortal Kombat and his robot arms and I imagine him with robot arms. Mostly because part of my brain is broken

hah, he would become a must-watch just for the chance someone charges the mound

I'd watch that game/movie.

Mortal Kombat, but baseball.

Kinda like a modern Tungsten Arm O'Doyle

Just once I want them to say marooned a runner or abandoned a runner

Marooned seems good for a Seattle Mariners game

or maybe Taylor Walls immured a runner he tags out stealing

apparently shane drohan is starting game 4

I think starting a lefty is smart for Milwaukee. Roberts seems to bench Muncy vs lefties which I believe is detrimental to their offense

The Dodgers just went 0-27 against lefties. Drohan is the correct choice.

ZiPS has been meh on starter Drohan, so the probs are basically unchanged

They're probably not quite THAT bad

Though I do personally like the idea

with the way the Dodgers are hitting right now, Smoltz and Wainwright could come out of the booth and shut them out

as long as Wainwright doesn't catch the last batter looking with that curve…. =\

I am completely bent out of shape at the changing of the starting time. My day was carefully planned and 2:00 was mowing the lawn which I cannot fail to do since it is going to rain tomorrow then drop into the 40's which is too cold for these old bones. CYA tonight.

We'll be here!

i feel like there was an article recently about how win streaks increase the chance of winning the next game, and same with losing streaks increasing the chance of losing the next game. feels like the dodgers are in the midst of that, but with hitting lefties

Ohtani turning into a slap hitting DH hasn't helped

The Rays didn't even strike out seven times in a full game 73 times this year

How are we rating Mesa in drafts going into next year?

Extra bases for Simpson!

props to millvillemeltdown for calling this 45 minutes ago

you know what's funny, i was going to call simpson going yard but i thought it was too unrealistic. triples is fun though

Nice bit of hitting there

The 6th sweeper of the at-bat caught too much of the plate there

I think it'd be fun if we had a lottery before each season to let exactly one guy use steroids. Imagine Chandler Simpson on the early 2000's Bonds stack, he's giving you 5-7 homers no problem

Tyler Rogers would be a fun one too

jo is the king of hitting it hard into outs

Hi everyone, the Rays and Guardians are playing a game like the Rays and Guardians

Dear MLB advertising sales team – I live in Chicago. Why are you so determined to try to make me hate Sherrod Brown?

I thought I was just seeing so many being in Ohio…

No, I'm seeing them too in Massachusetts, but obviously because an Ohio team is playing

The worst part of the playoffs has been the national political ad buys

Anybody happen to know the record for most times struck out by a winning team?

JRam probably has the highest approval rating of any player in the league but his official MLB pic this year is surely unsettling

I knew Gavin Williams was good this year. I didn’t realize just how good he was by xFIP, SIERA, or K to BB though.

In the postseason, the most strikeouts for a winning team was 23 by the Orioles iN ALDS Game 4 in 1996. But that was a 12 inning game

In a regulation game, the record for a winning team in the postseason was Rangers (ALDS Game 1, 2023) and Yankees (ALDS Game 5, 2017), with both team striking out 16 times

16 is a lot. I guess I don't see the Rays striking out 17 times this game if it's only 9 innings.

they're only 1 K off the pace…

In the regular season, there are five teams that struck out 19 times and won

Including the Steve Carlton complete game loss in 1969 when he struck out 19 Mets but lost 4-3

I'm sorry Crest, there's only one Dr. Teeth and he woudln't have been the same without the Electric Mayhem

Should Jax have let Walls get that? Would Walls have had a chance?

I'd be in favor of a line on the pitching side of which only the pitcher can enter on defense

Or maybe, I'd have to give it more consideration than 15 seconds

BANGGG

Petey Halpin really

Petey

Petey Halpin

Just as everyone expected: Petey Halpin post season heroics

PETEY POWER

I was surprised Jax was still in

How does this guy keep coming through?

really wish I wasn't at work rn, this box score alone is exciting

and this is why i love working remotely (baseball playoffs)

He should just announce "for now on, I'm Pete."

Sure Peteyed that one.

Petey Halpin has to have the highest ratio of go-ahead HR per HR in baseball

2 guys in there for defense making a rally

Who TF is Petey Halpin

Took the words right out of my mouth

Just remembered this chat was going on, hi all!

Now that's a bat flip

So yeah, Griffin's allows some jax

kevin cash watching too much dave roberts

I know his given first name is Peter but Petey Lyndon Halpin is one of the finest full names in the league

A name that would fit seamlessly on the 1902 Brooklyn Superbas roster.

He needs an adjective prefix. Like "Slidin' Petey Halpin"

some mf named petey

The full name has a better ring to it. Petey Lyndon Halpin rolls off the etongue really nicely IMO

That is a dead-ball era ass name

Exactly what I said in the Game 1 chat lol. It's just perfect.

Petey Halpin fits neatly into my mind's imagination of Brett Phillips

I would love it if announcers did middle names on emphatic home run calls

Are they telling them to go their room?

damn what a throw

By What Means Peter Halpin Acquired the Style and Title of Petey Lyndon

When was the last time a guy got caught stealing without doing the “Challenge it! Challenge it!” bit to his dugout?

I like the name Superbas

before challenges became a thing?

Pummelin' Petey Halpin?

Why were they singing Country Roads

It's DeLauter's walk-up song with lyrics tailored to him

DeLauter is from West Virginia.

I cannot learn which toolsy and generally injured outfielder is named Jonny DeLuca and which is named Chase DeLauter. I know the Cleveland one is the better one, but man their names are interchangeable to me

because chase delauter matches the meter of west virginia

Lifting Gavin here?

Lifting Gavin…jam band or Christian rock?

sappy rock like the Fray

It's always disappointing when a random bench postseason hero is from California. I usually hope they're from Bumblesville, Nebraska

We put it on driving through WV once which a mistake, cause my daughter made us listen to it 1000 times. It's good, but nothing is good 1000 times in a row

Apparently that song isn't actually about West Virginia, but actually the western part of Virginia

When I lived in Maryland I met a few people who insisted it was about Maryland. "The country roads in West Virginia are taking him home to Maryland!!"

madison bumgarner is from bumtown, north carolina

Between Packy Naughton, Petey Halpin, Liam Doyle, Mike McGreevy, Jack Flaherty, Kevin McGonigle, Jimmy Crooks, you got a pretty good Boardwalk Empire baseball crew

Crooks might be a bit on the nose

Yeah I'm surprised Williams is out of the game

Though NOTHING beats early baseball where everyone sounded like an Irish gangster

The best way to drive to Maryland from the midwest DOES go through west virginia extensively

Noted Irishman Honus Wagner ran the numbers racket on the side.

I-79 to I-68 > I-70

If Jimmy Crooks too on the nose you can put in Buddy Kennedy

or Mick Abel

Espino really went from chronically injured post-prospect to part of the leverage bullpen quickly

I love Junior but the zero homers in the playoffs has been a bummer so far

Sure sure, fantastic Irish mobster names abound in early baseball, but let's not forget about the man who remains the greatest German pitcher ever, Pretzels Getzien, who started 6 games of the best-of-15 1887 World Series for the Detroit Wolverines

That was some fairly impressive Espinoing

When you tell stories about Brickyard Kennedy or Silver King or The Only Nolan, people think you're making crap up

Does Old Hoss Radbourn imply the existence of New Hoss Radbourn?

Probably just Hoss Radbourn

The 'Kid' nicknames really fit for that era. Like Kid Gleason or Kid Carsey. Carsey also threw 415 innings in his age 18 rookie season for the Washington Statesmen which is very of its time.

Or that you could go by the name Rube and be taken seriously

It was a place holder just in case there was a new Hoss someday

Glenn Hubbard is the player from Germany with the most games played BTW

Max Kepler could theoretically pass him soon

and had the most baseball cards featuring a giant snake

Williams fastball velocity dropped to "only" 95mph in the 5th inning. Not surprised they pulled him based on that, plus it was the third time through the order.

The most recent game that had an Irish-born player was 1945 (Joe Cleary). And before him, it had been since 1918 (Jimmy Archer)

I imagine he probably will

"High Pockets" Kelly

He was pretty bad this year, but he's probably still going to get MLB time for a bit longer

Bazzana definitely sounds like something an Australian would say with several exclamation points

I could imagine Steve Irwin wrestling him to the ground and talking about how he could bite through an entire pack of big league chew with ease

Rough day for the ump.

bazzzzzaaaaannnnna

how many big league pitchers are now shorter than high pockets kelly? (6'4") is it 25%? more? less?

You know, Reggie's destroying his chances at getting easy service calls. Now he's not going to get a quick hour for a clogged dishwasher filter

I used to call Tim Collins Low Pockets

IM HERE IN JUNGAMUNGAWOOTSY AND CRIKEY, I SEE THE RECLUSIVE BAZZANA

The classic photo of Tim Collins and Everett Teaford inside Jonathan Broxton's pants. https://sports.cbsimg.net/images/mlb/photogallery/031512-tea…

the bazzana is faster than a speeding wombat, more powerful than a salty

popup petey

Rays went down QUICKLY last two innings

"The Bazzana" definitely sounds like how a bunch of Aussie dudes would describe attempting to drink 3 pints in 2 minutes or something

I've actually bugged MLB people to track bat flips

Apparently the ump can't handle the shadows. Just some terrible calls today. Can't imagine not having ABS already.

Did they run out of paid commercials? Just getting Commercial Break in Progress quiet

Apparently they think it only takes 7 innings for everyone watching to have already voted, taken their motion sickness pills, and traded (not gambled) on their favorite prediction market.

haha, I just saw the "Bio" at the bottom of the chat page "I build things here"

Sean has a very Spartan bio

If we ever get FanGraphs Lego, then we can all build things here

Shouldn't they pinch hit for Walls?

Honestly, if her oil pressure was low, she could either top off the oil if there was an action scene or something else was going on

I'll pitch the idea of FG Legos.

https://buildamoc.com/pages/business-project/microsoft-power…

This but with FG DataGrids and an FG Mug.

We should get products to partner with us before preseasons

FANGRAPH NEREUS DRUGS

I can confirm many of us on the engineering have many Lego sets.

And I've used Legos as a metaphor of cloud infrastructure.

This at bat is Bauers-esque

Despite a terrible strike call on pitch #1 too.

We need a good name for that kind of AB, like a Maddux or equivalent.

If only Yandy would challenge

There are too many teeth related commercials. While I brush my teeth they make me want to not brush my teeth out of spite

Love the little head shake by Hicks after that ABS overturn

He keeps having to challenge "balls" where the entire baseball is inside the strikezone.

I like ABS challenges better than abs challenges because I always lose the latter

When you're not there in person, it sounds like they're singing "Take me home, Jerry Lawler"

No, he plays for the Diamondbacks.

I really like that walk up song getting the crowd involved.

Please change fWAR to use DRS for defensive WAR instead of OAA. Taylor Walls just showed us yet again why OAA is completely worthless.

If tomorrow gets rained out, what's the plan? Doubleheader Saturday? Move everything back a day? Use the travel day for game 5?

Is Steven Matz proof you can just stay around as a lefty with a good changeup?

I'm pretty sure they'll just shift everything around. I can't see anyone wanting a double header unless they have to. Or deal with a suspended game.

Not necessarily proof, but gotta have a righty plan with LOOGYs dead

And now we wait……

I'm going to make dinner in between. And ship some free agent crowd source code. We'll be back before 8PM. But I'll leave this open.

w

not a fan; except maybe one using pre-agreed fans/actors as a bit

What'd everyone have for lunch? Mine was a meal-replacement shake, coffee, and a dried fruit bar.

Roasted butternut squash, spinach, tomato, apple vinaigrette, parmesan, pecans. Also doing a variation of that plus chicken / nutmeg caramelized onions for dinner.

very seasonal, nice

What's your replacement-level meal that your Quad-A shake is substituting for?

Is it just me or does A Rod look particularly orange this postseason?

Let's score some (a lot of) runs!

Glasnow warming up to Dazed and Confused rocks

Does he actually? Just tuned in and didn’t catch that. That rocks so hard. The “Song Remains the Same” live version of Dazed is still my favorite live performance of all time

It was definitely playing right before the start of the game. Not your typical game start music so it really stuck out

Just YouTubed it and it is indeed his song. That rips so hard

Man you really don't want to miss the first pitch to Chourio this series

That was crazy

How was your autumnal dinner, Sean?

Fantastic! Fall in a bowl!

I've been playing around with savory fall dishes this October.

Dodgers aren't losing!

I hope to some day love something as much as William Contreras loves early challenges

great ABS challenge. I've noticed that neither team has finished a game burning all their challenges. Are they too cautious?

ugly strikeout redeemed by a flurry of amazing hair

Ohtani is lost.

I understand he is Shohei Ohtani but at some point you gotta admit he just doesn't have it right now. Or you can put him leadoff for some reason. Idk I don't get paid millions of dollars to run a baseball team.

they're batting him first?

except that no one else is clearly meant to be on top of the order right now.

Not like anyone else is proving their worth in the box

The EV on the single yesterday from Ohtani was pretty impressive. Roberts might think it's the start of a turnaround. When you have to win 4 straight, I don't hate batting the generational superstar leadoff

^!!! If your superstar says "I got this," at some point you have to trust hiim

am i reading correctly that Ohtani has the 2nd highest wRC+ on LAD in the NLCS?

I am also surprised he has a .417 OBP. Just goes to show how good bad Ohtani is

That is correct. He's got some BBs and a HBP that help.

His wRC+ is 63 if you look at the whole postseason.

…*puts head in hands*

No Will Smith magic this time.

yeah, the cut off is hard. because the NLDS and NLCS performances are almost inverted across the entire lineup. Hard to tell what to look at (from my browser window)

I'm guessing the bats will come alive tonight.

See, back-to-back hits.

is max muncy pitch hitting? can there be a hitter/fielder version of an "opener"

Clint Hurdle did this with Pedro Alvarez in 2015. He didn't start, but pinch hit when his lineup spot came up.

How aggressively do you expect Murphy to manage his bullpen? Go all out to try to end it here or figure you've got three more shots at this thing so don't overdo it?

I expect him to go for the jugular

May will go 3+. If the game is still close, will play for the win

There he is

THERE IT IS

Ohtani's back!

Sean, you get the Ted (Double Duty) Radcliffe Award for the day.

was about to emoji reply to sean but my hands left my keys

I was really hoping Ohtani would be very bad so I could redraft him for cheap next year in fantasy…

May trade was so anti-Brewer and he has been a net negative add

Any Red Sox fan could have told them that he wasn't a positive addition to the Brewers.

If they had given up some mid-level prospects for him, whatever.

And there it is…

There's something about Brewers Dodgers NLCS game 4 that brings out Ohtani's best I guess

they're gonna announce that Ohtani is pitching tomorrow

That HR bat flip was pure catharsis.

Hello everyone

Did you make anything good since the last time we saw you?

For dinner?

Sadly no, I am having leftover pizza from my freezer that FanGraphs paid for (and by extension, our lovely Members paid for) during SaberSeminar though!

Popping in to say I found the brief split screen of Ohtani going through the dugout to be a little much

Well now seems like a good time to hop in here

Oh, now yinz show up!

113.1 mph, 428 feet

Emotionally, that felt like 700 feet lol

From Baumann: "I missed the bulk of the celebration because I was watching the ball" — That's how far it went

Dustin got angry there wasn't any gatorade left in that cooler

angry pat murphy time

Evergreen

Dodgers better hope that that wasn't a one off. Jays fans spent the summer thinking Vladdy was back every time he had a good AB or two, but he never got it together.

Wow Ohtani is back just like I knew he would be. Batting him leadoff was a genius move that I also would have done.

love that strike out. interrupted smoltz from talking for one thankfully quiet moment

Do people still get mad about bunting during a no hitter or have we moved past that?

do any paying members of FG care about bunting during a no-hitter? how weird are we?

I'm sure most players and people over 40 do.

I am well over 40 and don't care.

The Dustin May esophagus injury story never ceases to unsettle me

Like when it comes up, not all the time thankfully

indeed. life is freaky

Moral of the story: Never eat salad.

Oof, I just ate a salad and then read about that.

"I like when a tall pitcher pitches tall." The Smoltz Word Salad

The perceived velocity point was valid but yeah that's bad phrasing

I like when a Smoltzy announcer announces Smoltzy.

Back to back ground rule doubles

Unreal

Rake Bauers

You hang 'em, we bang 'em.

is he only good at full counts?

a billion dollars of pitchers can't get out noted health insurance needer jake bauers

cannot emphasize enough how much awful these in game interviews are

The Pat Murphy one where he finished by swearing at Jackson Merrill was incredible

the toy story shoes. wow. is he on the disney dole?

I really like David Hamilton. Fast guys with smarts are one of my favorite ballplayer types.

Hamilton was born 20 years too late

Vogelbach sighting. Loved that dude on the Buccos

what is this ???

Bauers coming up with the bases loaded…

he can't possibly get a clutch hit every night

Not if you walk him

Guy_tapping_his_head.gif

Pitching around Bauers with the bases loaded is an unusual strategy.

Man. The Dodgers are. . . not having a great week.

The half-intentional walk of Turang not looking great

I'll be really bummed if these LCSes are short series.

A full week between games would be sad

yeah i hope the NLCS goes 7🤣

Rust vs rust in the WS. 🤮

at least we won't be seeing the top of the Brewers line up for at least the first 10 minutes of their next half inning at the plate

If the Dodgers lose tonight, they won't have to face them again for months!

I hope this game goes to extras. I cherish every playoff extra inning ever since they ruined extras in the regular season. We haven't had many extra inning games this year yet

Games 4 &5 of the 2004 ALCS will forever be the most exciting and , life threatening to me, I ever watched.

I'm still very ok with the ghost runner. Those 18-inning regular season games were killers.

Game 3 of the 2018 WS is another unforgettable experience. They are rare so they are great in the post-season.

Game 3 last year was also incredibly fun

Game 3 in 2018 ended at 3:36 here in New England.

WOW

Is Garrett Mitchell even a homerun guy?

When he gets a hold of one they go far.

He hit 11 in 531 PA this year, so not really

Was he 18th in exit velocity this season ? The power is there

Good call – just hasn't consistently happened yet

These Brewers may be inevitable

Full Count Killers

Rang him up on strike 2.

Veteran pitcher.

I wonder if everybody is getting the TV feed at the same moment in time.

Got back from walking the dog! What'd I mi–wtf

bad bad not good

I believe Sæder is referring to the game. Your dog is presumed to be a very good boy or girl.

Rich Hill walking his dog; the rest of the Dodgers walking the Brewers

low key take away from this NLCS is that Kyle Tucker has been one of the only bright spots on this squad on offense.

I'm happy for him. This can't have been a fun year for him. Not that I'm getting out the smallest of violins for the very rich man who was sad sometimes, but still

Amazing to see Jo Jo still out there. In 55 appearances this year he went 2 exactly once.

He was well rested didn’t pitch since Monday and prior to that Oct 6th.

I would consider paying for a feed without the in-game interviews.

boog has been fantastic on the national radio call

Charlie Manuel, who refused to do them when they were first becoming a thing, had the right idea.

Bring back the Petriellocast!

Diaz wearing 3 for the Dodgers feels odd

Last I checked, 3 isn't even, so you're right

This is a big moment

And are any of us surprised?

I understood the Dodgers might lose but I never thought they could look so juiceless

kudos to MIL

truly, how hard have they been squoze, to have no juice

If the Dodgers do lose this, it'll be interesting to see the narrative around them heading into the offseason. It feels a little 2010 Phillies, but there's still a ton of talent and resources here.

might depend on how many players end up getting major surgery that they've not yet announced to the public

Also on some interesting decisions they need to make. I'll be fascinated to see what they do and say about JDP and other young players–are they prepared to get younger, even if it means moving on from some veterans or rethinking some positioning? Obviously that starts with Ohtani, which is tough.

would a busted ohtani be a better outfielder than jdp

im still slightly riding the high of calling "two good pitchers, cruising early, give up a crooked number in the middle innings" but had a truly awful nap and am debating calling it a day without having done anything productive today. anyway, how's the baseball been

18 inning game, here we come!

Whoa – potentially huge error there.

Why do they keep telling us the results of the ABS challenge before showing the graphic. So annoying.

Must be a mandate from FOX, as Davis didn't do this on SNLA broadcasts

Kyle Tucker, the rich man's Jake Bauer

Wow. Maybe the Brewers are truly blessed by the beer gods

dionysus more powerful than the abrahamic G-d?

Nice job by Mitchell there to call everyone else off. No chance to tag up

I was dreading a collision there.

Should they have run for Smith?

Arguably yes, though wouldn't have mattered on a ball that shallow

never thought i would be talking about running with known speed demon rich hill and his blazing mid-80s fastball

Excuse you, it was high 80s!

my deepest apologies for shorting you of a few crucial mph

The Dodgers' performance with RISP is just not survivable.

100 mph sinkers with that curve… I know it's been said, but how does anyone ever get a hit anymore? Like genuinely, do the biophysics add up?

the human nervous system is pretty nuts

Well, if there’s anyone on Earth who knows about being down a run in the ninth, down 3-0 in a 7 game series, staring elimination in the face, he’s managing the team that is…

See, you'd think Roberts would be very eager to deploy pinch-runners!

You definitely see things that you never see during the regular season, such as Edwin Diaz going 3.

Huge kudos to Edwin here, wow

Why did I talk

Hamilton! Wow.

david !???!?

Now the Brewers are ruining baseball

David Hamilton of all people

That is amazingly the first time this postseason I've said "I cannot believe that just happened"

I have a feeling this is it for the series

I was misled about the Brewers HR prowess

There's a soul jar somewhere in Wisconsin fueling all this

Brewers just making up new guys to hit homers now

Blew their last ABS challenge on a 0-0 count? Ok

Can't take 'em home with you.

You can take them to the bottom of the 9th in an elimination game when you need 2 runs, though

Did this graphic forget about Cleveland?

They appeared in the 2016 World Series

Oh, appearance, missed that thanks!

Rajai Davis had the biggest, most inconsequential World Series GM7 home run that year until… Bichette last year.

if this is it, talk about poetic justice

swept one way, swept the other

Hamilton had an ISO of .091 this year.

i'm waiting on the statcast bat speed on savant

He is tied with Ohtani for homers this post season

76.8 on the swing, exited at 105. solid

whoa chourio and bauers kind of mogging ohtani in swing speed

I see, the Dodgers are just setting it up to do something legendary

Is Muncy really this bad against lefties that he needs to be pulled here? I'd think he's one of the Dodgers better hitters

at least a pesky at bat…

muncy had looked completely lost today

edman's also good from the right side

Edman's one of those guys that make me annoyed that he's on the Dodgers, since he'd be a very helpful full-time player on lots of other teams.

Sean weren't you going to do a series on the best "picks" so far? That was incredible by Pratt!

Pat Murphy is an actual madman

As the great sage, Lawrence Peter Berra was credited with saying, "It is getting late early" for the Dodgers.

Ballgame. And season.

ICk

Been a pleasure, everyone

well. Milwaukee has been good for years and years.

Wow. That was just an unbelievable four-game performance, particularly the bullpen.

I have a hard time imagining the AL teams beating the Brewers

I did not think he was catching that ball

Ashby my god

i like MIL. But I actually quite like the rays and guards too. I'd think I'd root for the AL in this case

Going to be a great WS

Rob Manfred is in shambles

Good.

But doesn’t he want parity?????????

So are we!

Those small market teams just can’t compete without a salary cap.

MLBPA should demand an end to CBT. It’s only fair!

Blue Blood and rain,

I can hear the bugle playin

Go Guards! All Midwest series, let's go! It's going to be so frickin' cold.

Perfect for the offseason negotiations

If the Rays win we'll have a guaranteed new champion

even a guards ws is not a bad outcome given the drought, imo

And yet the Guardians have waited the longest!

yes i am biased because jose ramirez deserves a ring, but no matter the outcome i'm chillin

It is if you're a Tigers fan who hates the Guards

… ah, my condolences comrade

Here's hoping

in the midst of this Man City scandal, how can anyone take owners' claims seriously

pls give us more money plsplsplsplsplsplspls we're soooo hungry – owners

reminds me of my stupid hyperthyroid cat

Brewers going to the Series, and I'm going to bed. Merry Baseball, everyone!

gutenacht nick!

Rays have never won it. And yet have been an exceptional franchise for so many years. So many good story lines all around.

Alright everyone. One half of the WS is set. We'll be back for the next ALCS game.


Members-Only Game Thread: NLCS – Oct 14, 2026

Welcome to our Open Game Thread for the NLCS games today. Chat with fellow readers as we watch the Brewers play the Dodgers! Only Members can participate, and unlike our usual staff Q&A chats, your messages will be posted immediately.

Our Member community is made up of thousands of incredibly knowledgable baseball fans, and we think this is a great way to follow a game with like-minded baseball enthusiasts. We might even have some FanGraphs Staff drop in and join the fun. Please be courteous to your fellow Members, or you may find your chat privileges revoked.

Hey everyone! It's almost 5PM in Los Angeles. We have some polls for you. Including the stadium chants poll that came up during the ALCS yesterday.

We got a lot of Brewers fans here already.

i like freddie mercury probably more than freddie freeman

Does anyone else feel like a batter in the booth might have been a good idea?

I dislike all those chants lol

Planned chants are terrible

Any predictions for celeb cameos at this game?

hank aaron apparently

LET'S GOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Hahahahahahahahahahaha

Baseball rules

BOOM!

Also hi

I am not listening to the sound, have they made a comment about the venerable Dodger Stadium being the second oldest park in the NL yet?

I thought the “Chourio is a capital S Superstar” piece was a bit premature but that was pretty neat

Love the spin about how giving up a first pitch homer can actually make you MORE locked in as a pitcher so actually it's probably good for Snell that it happened

Yeah you always want to trick your opponents into an odd-numbered lead

It lulls them into a false sense of security

“Got them right where we want them”

All this and every adage about wanting to score first (in every sport).

The one-run lead is the worst thing in baseball, the two-goal lead is the worst thing in hockey

The 28-3 lead is the worst lead in football

Pat Tabler as a broadcaster once justified a pitcher giving up a grand slam as a good thing because it clears the bases and clears his mind. I'm not making this up.

Very selfish to hit a grand slam because it kills the rally. Pretty sure Joe Morgan believed that.

Sounds like something A-Rod would say

Watch it Chrissy

He had a quote about Bobby Fischer that didn't quite land.

So it seems I missed something.

Only if you blinked when the game started.

I do tend to blink several times a minute.

Doing that over a long period of time has historically killed people

How are we rating Murphy's anger level so far?

Isn’t it the inverse of his pocket snacks?

He can't watch the game from an underground bunker, so he must be furious.

They need to send a trolley line through the outfield

What do we think Ohtani is going to do here?

Grand Slam

If Ohtani hits a grand slam this inning I like the Dodgers' chances

Tucker on! Setting up that two-base runner grand slam.

it's part of the new CBA

Does Ohtani not pull anymore? Seems like everything is relatively weak the other way

Yeah. Sometimes it's like he's behind on everything, but most of the time he just looks like he knows he can't go out and get it, so his plan is to stay back and hit it the other way.

last year that was oppo HR

Gasser looks sharp. Sinkers diving just below the zone.

Sorry, sweepers

all the Dodgers look like they suddenly woke up on the wrong side of the aging curve

I maintain that they should be trying to find a way to get De Paula's bat in the lineup. Not saying you should bench Ohtani, but is JDP really so unplayable in the outfield that it's ridiculous to put him out there?

my impression is yes.

Dodgers stadium has a bunch of empty seats….apathy abounds.

that, or people don't want to sit with the sun directly in their eyes right now

Apathy, work is just ending. Plus an 0-2 series coming home for game 3 is never good.

Plus, Dodger Stadium has a lot more concourse space (including beyond the outfield) that fans like to hang in

That I-5 traffic

The parking is also a nightmare

After just consuming Davy's brilliant piece on Pat Murphy's anger levels, I was really looking forward to the in-game interview. He looked downright happy-go-lucky!

Being apathetic in the NLCS is absurd to me. As a fan of a team who hasn't been to the CS in 24 years, you really can't take it for granted

i wouldn't assume apathy. 5pm game time is hard to make in LA

Ticket prices did drop a lot.

also. fiendishly scheduled at dinner time. maybe everyone stuck in line for food lol (I hate it when movies or things are scheduled for 11am or 5pm!)

"Sacrifice situation coming up for Tommy Edman" or, hear me out, let him hit?

Why did they refer to this as a "sacrifice situation" for Edman?

Snell's high heat is about as good as I've seen it in a while. He's getting guys to chase 97 well above the zone and they look like they should be so obvious to lay off. He's making it look easy

Does Davis think Edman is a pitcher?

Gary Sanchez career line vs Snell: 7 for 23 with 5 HR and 8 BB.

Gary's post-Yankees career has been fascinating. He was a reliable backup catcher/platoon DH this year

I've been so curious! his Yankees career felt so bizarre at the time… but now in hindsight seems remarkably normal for the yankees

They scapegoated him, IMO. Whenever he was healthy, he was a productive hitter. I know they were ahead of the curve on framing and they wanted to go in that direction, but he could always hit and I wonder if they didn't have Stanton clogging the DH spot if they would've kept him around in that role

the fans are doing the same with Volpe

Volpe is nowhere near as good as Gary was

*not starting over Bauers, tho

I'm not sure I remembered that Sanchez is on this team

Did it hit the roof?

Hi everyone!

There is a praying mantis on Jackson Chourio!!!!!

my north carolinian neighbors have been telling me that the praying mantis is a local good luck superstition

It is indeed and I was very careful not to harm one the other day.

Does…does Jackson Chourio know the difference between "I got it" and "I can't find it"?

No La Tengo

Maybe giving up that leadoff homer really WAS a good thing for Snell…

At least Snellzilla's locked in

until his 'world class manager' got too cocky/comfy

what is that pinned question at the top of this box about Dodger Stadium in a hillside?

You enter the stadium at the top level and walk down to the field which is dug out of a ravine below.

for sure. I've been many times. I'm just wondering why it's pinned

I do love that it's in Elysian Park and somewhat on a hill above downtown

edit: nevermind. I didn't realize it was an "announcement" i could dismiss. this chat box has so many features!

If Snell could have stayed on the mound we would be talking about him like we talk about Randy Johnson and getting his Hall of Fame plaque ready.

2 Cy Youngs, but lots of injuries. Similar WAR totals to Lincecum

I wouldn’t quite say Randy because he was 1 of 1 and has no comparison. I’m struggling to come up with another one though.

every time i think about tim lincecum i have the thought that I hope he's doing alright

he's still as cool as ever

Every pitcher looks better some days than others. But does Blake Snell have the biggest gap between how good he looks when he's on, and how excruciating he is to watch when he's not on?

It's like entire seasons with Snell is the thing

What do you think when you hear the name "Gasser"? 1. Someone who fuels cars; 2. someone who is "gassed" as in tired; 3. someone experiencing flatulence?

I wish the R was French/silent. Gassay

I picture some sort of deep sea vent.

He is Jumping Jack Flash in a Rolling Stones sense and not a Whoopi Goldberg movie sense

Truist Stadium in Winston-Salem is somewhat similar but it is the out field that was excavated and abuts a hill.

Ooh, I should go! W-S isn't too far away from the Triangle

It is a great little ballpark and right by the interstate.

Anyone else annoyed that Joe Davis is spoiling the ABS graphic for us by telling us whether the call is going to be overturned as soon as he announces the challenge?

I haven't loved that either.

honestly i hate to use the word but if any announcer is "overrated" i think it's davis. he's good, he's solid, he's not one of the best in the game today

Given that Davis replaced Joe Buck, I believe he still counts as an improvement although I would definitely rather have dave flemming or dan shulman. Dave got the wild card series in san diego and that was fun

I like Buck on baseball

omg I just tweeted that

I don't like the strike zone lighting up strikes either

TBS' doesn't

Smoltz seems confused about home runs

Who else would have preferred Wainwright over having to hear anything else from Smoltz?

Hot take: Smoltz has gotten better over the years. He's not the best, but I no longer mind listening to him.

Stockholm Syndrome?

Stocksmoltz Syndrome

Have we ever had a playoff game where the only run was scored on the very first pitch?

This is a fun question!

Sounds like a Mailbag question for Davy to answer this week!!!!

mailbag please come back. you were one of my favorite bits.

i loved how you munched on the questions and spit out the answers

I did not like how Mailbag stalked me and stole my passwords while I slept

i am reminded that volleyball has a counting stat called "kills" and i think this is something missing in our great pastime

Carl Mays would be the leader (too soon?)

granted, the big unit (and maybe will brennan??) both have a bird on their ledger

Kills are a lot like RBI in that your team mostly has to set you up for them

Kills are like RBIs in the same way that receptions in football are.

How grouchy does Pat Murphy look right now on a scale from 1 to Pat Murphy?

He is the very caricature of an Irishman.

i'm reading murph.5 but my murphometer's been sketchy since the braves backstop came off the il

He kinda looks like DeNiro with the weird de-aging technology in The Irishman (2019)

The Brewers' baseball glove logo made out of an m and a b is the best logo in baseball.

It’s also the most appropriate name

Freeman’s gotta be Gasser’s last hitter if Senzatela’s ready in time, that was smoked

All Gasser needs to do is get 1 more out.

sentences uttered before disaster strikes

Thank God I didn’t curse it

This Dodgers offense is kinda reminding me of that mid-2010s Cubs pitching core — it looked unbeatable, until it suddenly looked really old

I wonder if the Dodgers are almost in a unique situation where they AREN’T “Built For October” because their aging roster is just gassed by then.

Gassed and facing Gasser's gas

Wonder if anyone's ever looked at whether older players underperform in October because they're too banged up, we know it happens to catchers as the season goes on

Man, that Hader trade.

The Dodgers having just one (1) extra base hit through 23 NLCS innings is wild.

Gasser wasn't bad this year but man if this Dodgers lineup can only muster 3 singles against him they really just don't have the firepower to win it all.

Love Chourio's hustle on that groundout.

Fwiw, this isn't surprising to those of us who have watched the lineup all year. These slumps happened a few times

Yeah for like an entire month.

At this point, The Dodgers need to hand Snell a bat because he is single handedly trying to will out a win.

Talking about the Dodgers offense falling off. Their xwOBA is 3rd this postseason and wOBA is 9th. A .057 difference.

https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders/major-league?pos=all&stats…

Is that bad luck? or great defense against?

The Brewers haven't played good defense this series so I don't think it is defensive quality

hence the rage of pat murphy

Also crazy to see those numbers for the WCS teams that lost.

looks like everyone is having a bad time except MIL

Milvillemeltdown, I would love to get the story behind that combination of flairs

oh man i started trying to make words, and then just went "eh, sod it i'm gay now"

Clepitathtorcol is definitely a prescription drug with harrowing side effects

i'm taking it right now

i will cop to an affinity for cleveland (kwan, jram, bazz are up there for me) but not strong enough to call myself a fan

Did anyone else just see that Polymarket commercial about predicting whether an incumbent would win re-election and then his staffer walking in on him having an affair? Or did I hallucinate?

I saw a commercial that sounds like that, but I wasn’t paying much attention

i think i realized today for the first time in a long time. staying in shape is so hard. i can run 6-8 miles at a respectable pace, and am well on pace to beat my half marathon pr. i cannot sprint 50 yards.

what's your half pr?

somewhere in the 2:10 neighborhood! i'm not competitive, but i'm happy enough with it

Nice! The half is a really good distance. And you are definitely right maintaining that is quite the chore. Good luck on your next race!

thanks <3

Roberts is no Cash, but Murphy is. Roberts let Snell go 6 while he is cruising but I see no reason for taking Gasser out. Let's see of Uribe turns into Nick Anderson.

Brewers pen allowed 1 run in 23 innings. Hard to argue going to them.

*Crossing fingers* Uribe really doesn't have it

Tie happening soon

Go ahead happening soon

Defensively: Muncy to 3rd, Rojas to 2nd, Edman to center

Murphy found the guy who doesn't have it. Let's see how bad it hurts him. Assuming he's angry now.

maybe ohtani has it

Ohtani bloop over short…bold prediction

Shocked that Uribe's still in there vs. Ohtani

So am I!

PAT MURPHY

Throw the man a strike!

BING BANG BOOM

BILLY!

Classic Pat Looking Pissed moment after the non competitive AB to Ohtani

I love awful overmanaging.

Well he finally found the plate.

That is a very perplexing sequence from Murphy

How do these guys hit doubles off the walls on the handles? Test them all!

Maybe Smoltz was right. Home runs don't win

I believe that’s called “not a save”

What the hell was that decision making? He walks 3 guys and you leave him in there??

Yah he never had it and it was obvious right away

Am I watching a video of Game 6 of the 2020 WS? The only difference is that it was Snell who was yanked while he was cruising.

They showed Gasser with a blister thing potentially

Simply a cover story.

So JDP is just burned? How is that scored?

Yeah he was announced and then removed so he's gone. Feels like a waste of a really good bat

I'm always curious why managers play the platoon game so much with pinch hitters when pinch hitters have been shown to have a fairly noticeable penalty right? I would rather have had De Paulu hitting

I agree with your premise although in this case JDP was also going to be a pinch hitter

What a PA by Bauers. He has had some very fun to watch PAs this series

Seems like Hall should have just been in for Ohtani

At 2-1 it’s an officially high scoring game this postseason (seriously what’s going on with the league wide offense)

granted there were some fireworks against both sox

Are we sure this isn't just baseball without the Washington Nationals? They might have singlehandedly been elevating offense levels

That was until they traded away half their offense in Mead and Garcia.

They were still allowing a lot of runs!

I heart this

does barometric pressure affect flight? or el nino?

edit: nvm, seems el nino means low pressures typically in So Cal

off the top of my head, hi pressure -> more spin-induced movement but also more drag, is my guess

not a meteorologist so no clue about atmospheric effects of el niño

Offense this postseason looks like people trying to box under water. Unable to pack a proper punch

edman really having a putrid time out there

Dave Roberts has the chance to do the funniest thing ever by leaving Blake Snell in too long

And so he did….

Beautifully called Matt

Wish I could take credit, but it was all Baumann to me over slack

really, what's the worst that can go wrong putting jdp in for defense. kyle schwarber was an outfielder once

Especially with Pages out of the game!

exactly. slap him in center

Although "what's the worst that can go wrong" is actually pretty bad

Putting JDP in a corner moves Teoscar or Tucker to center, which is even worse

(can you tell my rooting interests are primarily "team entropy")

Tucker could in theory do it

oh man, i wouldn't trust tucker's range. he's not been a great rf in quite some time

Is Yelich faster than Vaughn nowadays? Enough to be worth pinchrunning?

Yelich is a good baserunner but they also have David Hamilton on the bench who is much better

yeah that matches what i thought. yeli has a good nose, but has lost a couple steps

I am very interested in how Snell is handled here by Roberts.

Kyle Schwarber was a catcher once!?

there are so many surprising former catchers, i feel. daulton varsho might be the least surprising one

some pitchers, like Jansen, right?

harper was a catching prospect at first iirc

Jansen, yeah. I love that he *caught* Kershaw when they were minor leaguers.

Kyle Schwarber stole a base in the world series once!

Anybody know why the batters box lines are so thin?

GLP-1s are everywhere now

it's tough keeping weight over a full season… i don't think anyone in sport necessarily wants to be taking glp-1 (yes i am fun at parties [lying])

This is a Dodgers Stadium thing and it drives me crazy. I'm sure they have a reason for it, but I don't know what it is.

dodger pitchers vs Bauers 2: electric boogaloo

Bauers is one tough hitter. Another very long AB which will drive Snell out of the game.

Oh my GOD I thought he had that

heart attack emoji

Well that gave me a heart attack

Oh man he almost snuck one through

So close

omg

Didn't miss that time

Every major league position player was a shortstop, catcher or CF at some point as a child

Ah he straightened it out

Bauers is a modern Wade Boggs

RAKE BAUERS

i remember a bit in some other bb community was the bauers pauer hauer

bauers pauer hauer is a great bit

i don't think he stepped on 2nd base

Much closer

A truly great AB!!

Wow. Roberts should've pulled a Cash

Did Jake Bauers just earn himself several million future dollars over the past 2 games?

Good lord what an AB

Snell meltdown. A… Snelltdown?

NO WAYYYY!!!!!

MITCHELL

I can't believe Snell is facing another batter and Roberts is embarrassingly wrong.

Headlines in TB tomorrow: Cash vindicated

Bauers should end up being NLCS MVP if they win. He’s had two of the most pivotal PAs so far

barring truly unforseen circumstances i think he might have it in the bag. but then again, that's baseball, suzyn

there's also a guy named William

WOW

Kevin Cash has to be laughing his butt off

Blake Snell and a playoff game featuring LA going too long. Name a more iconic duo

This will be a fun manager report card.

Hard not to think the 100-pitch at bat played a huge role in that

This is the team that’s going to win it all. Something feels different

Did Dave Roberts fall asleep? I assumed Snell was gone after the Bauers HR

Had a righty warming

doc "tony la russa" roberts

He owed Pat Murphy one for keeping Uribe in too long

i did last night get movie tickets for what would be Game 6 and Game 7

I’m so conflicted. I kinda really wanted to use my Game 6 ticket…

Don't worry! Several catastrophes which you'll hate could still make this possible and unpleasant

Do you have WS tickets?

Yea, I’m not at the point of hoping for losses just yet, because of that possibility. It’s gonna be even worse if they make the Series as I’ve got Game 6 and 7 tickets for that 😬

I think we need to collectively remember that the Brewers are a really good team. They won 103 games, which is more than many teams ever have in a season. They might just be better than this Dodgers group.

People not appreciating the cliff at 35y and this LA team embodies ‘35y man’ to a T. Not since the mid aught Yanks have we seen a club so committed to the unc lifestyle

surely this is collusion by the players to reduce owner leverage in the ongoing labor talks

That's 3D chess.

Manfred crying into his wads of money

Wads of money he claims to be losing

I just realized Jake Bauers is the same guy who put up negative WAR for the Yankees a few years ago. Quite a breakout.

This season I’ve found myself falling out of love with baseball (life is hard) but this postseason has given me hope, even though my team has been eliminated. Pulling hard for the Crew

I slowly abandoned my old team over the last ten years. The Brewers over the last two years have brought me back to single team fandom. It’s been so much fun.

There’s something about baseball that’s able to center me like nothing else can. Such a beautiful thing

time for the bottom of the brewers lineup to go full pest mode

Bauers taking a job he didn’t want because he needed health coverage is incredibly relatable

i had a pal who was corporate / office staff for the dodgers back when. said that there was only one health plan for the whole org, so even the desk jockeys in marketing got the same healthcare as the pro baseball players, which was over the top

I'm over 35, tell me more about this "unc lifestyle"

I stepped away for one half inning and missed nothing okay cool cool.

Snell frustrated shaking his head at the iPad like “shouldn’t have thrown those down the pipe” got me giggling.

I literally rage closed my laptop after Murphy left Uribe in and came back to this (I'm a Giants fan, aka the biggest Brewer fan you'll meet this postseason )

Insane play that Ortiz made look routine

It just made me think I should do a roundup of the most satisfying short hops of the postseason.

Unbelievably confident approach on that ball.

They announced the gold glove finalists today and somehow he was left off the utility finalist list. I don’t know how that is possible unless you have to play both IF and OF to qualify. His glove is unbelievable.

Jake Bauers was once traded straight up for Damon Casetta-Stubbs, who has been out of baseball since 2023.

Only because Casetta-Stubbs is Canadian and didn’t have to worry about healthcare. Move him 100 miles south and he’s a leverage guy in Cleveland’s bullpen right now

It may go under the radar but DL Hall really saved this game and got five outs at its emotional peak

The CLE/TBR game got moved up tomorrow? Guess we are going to be back here earlier than I thought.

I never know when the games are. The banner for this chat has been how I found out there was an afternoon game more than once.

Smoltz remarkably silent when Davis brings up that home runs win games

I find it strange that Sasaki's jersey says "R. Sasaki" … do they have multiple Sasakis?

His NPB team did, and he just kept it

Multiple Asian players do that – Ha-Seong Kim and Jung Hoo Lee, off the top of my head.

About half of all Koreans are named Kim or Lee it seems- their World Cup soccer roster had like 4 Kims

So does the LPGA. It is loaded with Kim's and Lee's.

Lee is a remarkable name because it's not uncommon in the English language either

There's also Carlos Lee! It transcends ethnicity

These are the Lee's I know I know

I'm a simple guy, Sasaki's gigantic mitt still makes me giggle

He’s still showing his grip. I thought the whole point of pitchers moving to the giant gloves was to hide the ball better

is the Milwaukee bullpen sequence going to be Hall Ashby? Hidden cameo there

The stranger name thing to me is that you never see teammates with the same last name have their first initials on their jerseys anymore. Any idea why?

Indeed my thought. Did Andruw and Chipper have initials?

Isn't it usually up to them?

In baseball, would you ever really be confused?

An image search for Andruw Jones shows some with A. Jones on his uniform

Between Andruw Jones and Chipper Jones? Probably not. Between two middle relievers named Martinez or Brown or something? Sure.

So I'm listening to the Brewers radio broadcast. Pitching changes are sponsored by a company selling adult diapers. Someone in the division series had it sponsored by an exterminator, which at least made a little bit of sense. Anybody got anything stranger?

That's a good part of the audience today and I can definitely relate to it.

Not pitching changes, but for Cubs radio games this year, just about every inning break featured an ad for “less lethal” weapons that told the “true” story of some guy who was hiking with his family and encountered a mountain lion. The weapon purportedly allowed him to stun the mountain lion and get help. Remarkably specific target demographic there.

These were on Twins radio too

Um, 2 runs for the Dodgers used to be not impossible

these scores are logarithmic this year

3 might be

It's too bad that both Max Muncys aren't on the same roster.

If Muncy the younger has a breakout the Dodgers will snap him up.

Oh wow, look how mad Roberts got!

A team-wide meltdown for the fans

Hall and Outs

Should we make a mad manager meter for the WS? Or even later this series?

Mad Murphy Meter

Ohtani lives

Ohtani doing his best Luis Arraez.

5.1 mph faster than any ball Arraez has ever hit in his career

Well yeah, he’s Ohtani. Of course his best Arraez is going to be better than Arraez’s best Arraez.

Calling for mad manager stats in the rest of the Managerial Report Cards

Ohtani’s single registered 113.5 mph — that's the hardest hit ball of the night for either team.

I love it when the hardest-hit ball of a whole game is just some random routine grounder that Yandy or someone pounded straight into the ground at 250 mph.

I am perplexed by how focus some are focused on the managers' mood.

Davy had an article about it today.

Ok, fair enough 😃

All common name tournament: Lee vs Kim vs Johnson vs Martinez

Lockout article idea.

Mining chats for gold already

FAWNGRAPHS: Which player named Lamb was the GOAT

yes please. I also have done all time teams for "guys in red" and "NYC vs the world"

Yeah, this is great.

Saeder. That's amazing.

Kim Jong Il pitched 20 perfect games in a row.

which team does Lee Smith play for in the all-name series?

Walter Johnson and Randy Johnson vs Pedro and Dennis vs probably some great KBO pitchers

Was Contreras stretching something out or was he thinking about backpacking Ohtani off first?

Looked like he was signaling something

guys in red gets ted williams and pujols and mike trout and joe morgan, etc

Might it even get Babe Ruth?

managed by Kevin Cashmere

Babe Ruth is on NYC vs the world, obv

he was a red sock

And a Boston Brave! They wore red, right?

Harvard-Westlake could field a team of its own.

and Rob Deer bats behind MIke Lamb

Nm

Pesky brewers gonna pester (laudatory)

Does Pesky apply when they hit 3 HR two of which traveled 400+ feet?

BS challenge.

desperation move

or backdoor mound visit breather for Wrobleski?

top 9, smoke 'em if ya got'em

yeah but when he was a red sock he wasn't BABE RUTH he was just a very good lefthanded pitcher

I think he was talking about Pesky.

Joey Ortiz looks as permagrumpy as Murph

Watch the Guardians win the WS this year

(I have lost all reason)

dodger fans start out with reason?

I imagine Dodgers fans are pretty disappointed, it’s been almost 50 weeks since their last championship

Nah, it applies when they steal bases

Seems suboptimal to let Hernandez and Edman bat here.

Their bench is just Feduccia

For all you Dodger fans, I have good news for you. There is life after Game 3, as my handle indicates.

Did they use De Paula earlier? I was out for dinner. Nevermind then.

DePaula made a cameo appearance.

They did but immediately took him out when the Brewers brought in a lefty. De Paula didn't see a pitch

most of us missed it. apparently he was subbed in and out while standing in the on deck circle

Managering.

And that's your ballgame

I see Mary Hart and her husband gave up their seats, this one is truly over.

amazing

that's a fierce Brewers team

I thought the Brewers were in better position than the projections indicated but wasn't expecting this.

Brewers have a chance to be very rested for the World Series if they win tomorrow

I hope LA can at least win a game or two. I cannot deal with another "rest vs rust" conversation from the talking heads.

They never discuss rast, rist or rost.

In Milwaukee those are all pronounced the same anyway.

Revenge sweep?

If Milwaukee sweeps they have to do it again next year for the rubber match

Huh. ARod got a hair transplant. Mane transplant?

Are you suggesting Alex took medical steps to alter his natural abilities and appearance?

Believe me, I understand how farfetched it sounds.

Alright! We'll see everyone tomorrow for that 1PM ET game!


Members-Only Game Thread: ALCS – Oct 13, 2026

Welcome to our Open Game Thread for the ALCS games today. Chat with fellow readers as we watch the Guardians play the Rays! Only Members can participate, and unlike our usual staff Q&A chats, your messages will be posted immediately.

Our Member community is made up of thousands of incredibly knowledgable baseball fans, and we think this is a great way to follow a game with like-minded baseball enthusiasts. We might even have some FanGraphs Staff drop in and join the fun. Please be courteous to your fellow Members, or you may find your chat privileges revoked.

The response (as of this writing) to the 2nd poll is peak Cleveland.
6/6 respondents want Cleveland to win but only 1/6 believe it will happen.

Hello everyone! We got a few polls for you. The likability ranking from last night, we'll let that ride for at least another day. Then we have the standard who ya got for the game and the SP poll.

I've been thinking about possible ranked polls. If there's an all-midwest WS you'll definitely need some food polls and they will have to feature cheese curds (does Tampa have a cuisine?). I'm also mulling over one on the poignancy of loser heroics–Randy Arozarena, Rajai Davis, Carlton Fisk. I know there are other good ones I'm forgetting.

Bob Gibson in the 1968 World Series is the all-timer

Yes, absolutely.

Also Chase Utley in 2009

Any word on if Caminero and DeLuca are banged up at all after the collision yesterday? Looks like both are good to play at least which is a good sign

Caminero just got the wind knocked out of him, DeLuca was fine

Hi everyone!

Who else is doing Star Wars Legos during the game?!? I assume the answer is just me.

What are you making?

My son kind of wrecked the AT-AT Walker so I'm rebuilding it. I just got the Tantive IV in the mail yesterday

Every time I see the Billy Bob Thornton commercial I think the cops are coming for the crazy guy who keeps bothering people trying to relax in the massage chairs by presuming they want to hear about T-Mobile

Jon, what do you think about this camera angle? For the pitcher-batter matchup?

Didn't Tropicana have an almost perfect straight on angle before the hurricane? I could be wrong. Maybe I need to replay MLB the Show for the answer.

Pretty good but it's perfect in the regular season, yeah

I have a strange question for the group after watching Diaz lope down the line. Should a player go hard on such an easy play and risk a hammy or give himself up?

Depends on the state of his hammies going in. I was OK with Willson Contreras taking it easy when it came up with him–he was clearly hurt, and he's not in the lineup to get infield hits.

I remember Tony La Russa taking a lot of heat in Chicago when he told his players not to hustle on routine plays. Then they fired him and the next season the 3 best White Sox players all got hurt running the bases in April. Sometimes you just can't win

I lean to the don't risk injury side.

What was that commercial!

i feel like dodgers sorta have to play shohei at this point, whats there to lose

Well this is a bad challenge.

Good thing they get two

The replay coach needs a pair of glasses.

G'evening

Messick only retired one batter that inning but still faced the minimum

Dan, obviously there's a long way to go in the NLCS. But from what we've seen so far, do you think projection systems need better ways of accounting for players not on the IL but playing hurt? I feel like all of them, not ZiPS particularly, have been projecting LA at their best and not as they are.

A rare Walls hit!

Phil, it would definitely hurt, but the problem is the actual data itself.

I've always wondered if there's something that can be done here, such as sudden change in playing time over a seven-day-period, but I haven't really dug into it

errr, it woudl definitely HELP

how would you even predict injury?

Yeah, I recognize that reliable data is a huge problem. You don't want ZiPS scouring the papers.

Maybe some day AI can figure that out, but that day is not now!

The problem is that both players and teams lie. I don't know that AI will ever get to the point where it can see through an obvious lie. Our greatest advantage over the machines!

I just checked Eric's 2023 Guardians prospect list and a remarkable 14 players on that list are on the roster today. The Rays have only 4 from that year.

RosterResource has CLE second to STIL in number of homegrown players.

Rays dead last.

Oooh, I should check my 2023 Guardians prospects

From ZiPS Top 200

Bo Naylor
Brayan Rocchio
Logan Allen
Tanner Bibee
Gavin Williams
Daniel Espino
Angel Martinez
George Valera
Juan Brito
Gabriel Arias
Tyler Freeman

That’s an impressive list.

Lotta double plays already

This won’t be one though

Messick doesn't look as sharp as he usually does. The double plays are bailing him out.

First to third on an infield hit!

That seemed fast even for Simpson

Yeah as soon as that bounce went way up he hit another gear

It looked like he ran through first by liek 50 feet too

Ramirez not having a good inning

Bucknered

Bucknered

Oh my – rough two plays for J-Ram

It's the green glove

Buckner's wasn't hit as hard!

I'm seeing double, 4 Seans!

4? Did the message send 4 times?

Simpsons reference.

lol, scared me that something was more wrong than just client sending twice.

Yikes

I wonder if Tyler Wells ever takes an at bat for Taylor Walls just to see if anyone is paying attention

The ball Ramirez failed to come up with hit the edge of the infield grass and stayed down. It is impossible to foresee that and it is more like bad luck, but still an error, than anything else.

The Megan Fox commercial leaves it kind of ambiguous if she's trying to sell us the drug or she's actually the drug

J-Ram kinda has to wonder how come that's an error and the other 750 bloopers not by the Yankees are hits

Oh hell yeah Junior

☝️😏☝️

I liked the competent inelegance of the Caminero catch as he kinda just threw his body in the general direction as a reaction and then caught it

"That first pitch to Jo Adell was the fastest pitch of Freddy Peralta's career, including playoffs, at 99.4 mph" via the great Sarah Langs

I don't know how Sarah does it, she's way faster and more productive than 99% of us that don't need health aids.

Fastball Freddy's heater is the definition of carry.

Hot take: HBPs shouldn't count if it hits your armor.

I had the same thought, but I don’t think we want to incentivize “Wear it!” culture more.

Don Baylor used to make no effort to avoid being hit by the pitch. Of course he was made of concrete.

It’s at the point now where Little League kids are being pressured not to get out of the way.

That's fair.

Jeez. Yet another inane challenge.

I was always told to not get out of the way in Little League tand that was 35-40 years ago

Your coach was a sociopath ahead of his time!

I looked away for a second and not sure why you'd waste a challenge on that. At least it's not the first 3 innings.

And I didn't. I was an overcompetitive kid. I would lose my s%#@ about the mercy rule even if we were on the bad side of it

Fastball Freddie really needed to get away from the Mets. Put a bow on that performance.

Where on earth did Petey Halpin come from? I've now watched a game and a half with him in the starting lineup, and I still have no idea who he is.

San Mateo, CA, sez here.

Man, they’ve really doubled down on that Sydney Sweeney ad.

I almost feel bad for her. It's like she blew her Euphoria money on ice sculpting lessons or something.

That sounds like investing in herself.

Oof that's the shortstop's ball

We had Messick and Peralta going 5 IP for the median, and almost 5 IP for the mean. We were spot on for Messick. And short for Peralta.

Wow, a pinch hitter without a mound visit? How often does that happen? It’s almost like they knew Palacios was on the roster before the game!

Guardians bats gotta do better than pop on toast

This is a good series for undersized sluggers. Palacios , Mesa Jr., Hicks, and of course the great J-Ram

not so great for J-Ram's D!

Arby's commercials always make me a little sad because I'm reminded of my cat Galileo

I saw your story about Galileo and Arby’s in a chat recently. It made me smile, surprised to know that Arby’s has done some small bit of good in this world. I’m glad you have those memories.

I was saying how there’s no way Hicks should be starting against a lefty, but SSS >>> my brain.

The Guardians started Hedges at catcher so they could use Bailey as a PH. I hope that sounds as ridiculous to others as it does to me as I write it.

Gotta keep the other team thinking. Zag when they expect you to zig, etc.

It's amazing how often in recent postseasons Vogt has had Hedges at bat in extremely high leverage situations. Now he has competition for that spot!

"I put my hand on the stove because it feels so amazing when I take it off!"

Was that punitive for heading to first early?

He LOOOOVED Arby's. I couldn't eat Arby's for a year after he died. I mean, he was 20, so he was a really old cat, but still miss the guy because he was the cat who was invariably around me when I was working, including all ZiPS work from origin to 2019.

Vogt has been having Hedges and Bailey pinch hit for each other all year. Drives me up a wall

Gotta think of it as more of a catcher funging than pinch hitting, I guess.

Yeah, that's how he uses it. I just wish he'd pinch hit someone else then make a defensive sub. Although it's not like there's a slugger on the bench.

I was gonna dispute the factoid, but I didn't realize that Kwan was THAT good total in the second half. 155 wRC+

You are allowed to pinch hit with a non catcher though

I mean, he turned it on, but I didn't see the number

I like when they mention Booser, because it's always in a situation where saying boozer sounds funny

THERE'S A BOOSER GETTING WARMED UP

He’s actually a recovering alcoholic.

OH geez, I didn't know that

True story.

Not a convenient name to have

I know, right?

My dad drank himself to death, but he didn't have an ironic name.

How would you explain changing it, though?

"Call a lawyer?"

I just read an article about him the other day. He was out of baseball when he was 27 due to injuries, which led to depression and addiction. But he made it back. So, major hat tip.

Seems like it's a story i should have remembered. Good story

I mean, these days there’s always a chance that the article was a total AI fake, but it seems unlikely that a fake article about a Rays reliever would be real high on anyone’s AI priority list.

Not the matchup Cash would want here.

Man, Adell looked horrible on that changeup

I want to see another Jo Adell triple

That was not a good at bat for Adell

Yes, I'm still here – just went down a deep rabbit hole looking for the best World Series performances from players on losing teams

Lenny Dykstra was tearing it up in 1993

Yes, Dykstra is on the list

A 6-inning rabbit hole

Sorry if I sent you down it! But I'd be curious to see the answer. Wondering about CWPA, too.

Send it as a mailbag question!

Yikes! Terrible bunt.

I mentioned that I watched him several times in Worcester and thought nothing of it. He was just an old never-will-be. Perusing his history shows he did not appear in organized ball between his 26-28 year old years.

Armstrong is a good name for a pitcher

Certainly better than Flimsyelbow

The Twins used to have a starter named Kevin Slowey

And the guy actually named Tommy John ended up having to have Tommy John surgery. How ironic is that?

Don't get me started on Lou Gehrig!

Cy Young never won a Cy Young award

I hate to break it to you about Bill Goodenough.

In retrospect, it seems inevitable.

Why wasn’t Kwan sent home on the double? I thought he was fast.

I couldn't believe he wasn't sent. I guess the 3rd base coach was afraid of him being thrown out in the 1 in 10 chance that might have happened. I hate 3rd base scared 3rd base coaches as you might have ascertained.

Will there ever come a point at which people decide they’ve had their fill of Day-O, “boom boom boom and let me hear you say hey-o” and “Everybody clap your hands!”? Can we poll that?

I much prefer "everybody clap your hands" to the relatively recent alternative "I can make your hands clap"

Yeah I don't love a disembodied voice bragging about how he has control over my body

Rotten potato, rotten potahto.

Jeff Sullivan once live-blogged a Mariners game which included a post "everybody clap your hands clap clap clap clap clap clap clap clap clap clap clap clap clap clap clap clap clap clap clap clap" and I will never not laugh about that now

We’ll do a stadium chant poll tomor

The “free mound visit for a pinch hitter” rule is such a farce.

“Gotta give the pitcher the scouting report,” my ass.

I'm grumpy and never ever participate in fan things, even as a kid

One of my earliest memoried is my older brothrr explaining why the wave is stupid.

I just genuinely don’t get why people apparently like the same five sound bites over and over and over and over again for years on end.

Another of life's imponderables. How did Bryan Baker morph into Mariano Rivera?

That's just Ray Magic.

You should see what they did with the Butcher and the candlestick maker

Patrick Bailey, pinch hitter, folks.

Mesa is entertaining even on the routine plays

Ballgame

See ya' all tomorrow.

Excited to suffer through a Snell start?

Good night, all.

I would go see a band called Bryan Baker's Primal Scream, though the actual band might be unhappy

NIght!


Brendan Gawlowski Prospects Chat 10-13-26

Hello everybody.

Have you seen Jhonny Level at all this year? I think he's become underrated among the glut of young SFG MiF. Was skeptical on him at SS but looked great this year and just hits everything

Several times. He doesn't have the same defensive ability or upside as the younger guys, and at some point he needs to get a little more selective. But it'd be wild if there was prospect fatigue settling in here already, he's a good hitter with sneaky pop. Easy T100 guy.

With the move into Cardinals org Tai Peetehas seemed to take a big step forward. What did he do differently this year and is he a top 100 candidate

Repeating High-A was a good idea. There's still a lot of swing and miss, probably too much for realistic T100 consideration, but it's really encouraging that it didn't skyrocket after he was promoted to AA. And of course, there are more than 100 or 110 interesting prospects with everyday upside!

How would you rank Flora, Bresnahan, Keyner, Marquez and Cayama within the Giants system?

Flora, Marquez, Keyner, Bresnahan, Cayama.

Last week you wrote that Dax kilby looks like one of the best guys in the league – with guys like Walcott here, that was a bit of a wow moment for me. Reading too much into it, or has the last week been that for you too with kilby?

He doesn't have the same kind of freaky, elite upside that Walcott does but he looks like a high-probability regular. Solid defender at short, really good feel to hit.

Which would be a greater concern for a hitter-chase rate,in zone contact or contact vs 95mph+?

Depends; who do you have in mind?

If you're in AZ or have heard from others, how's Bonemer looking in the OF?

Raw. Not unexpected, most guys struggle in their initial exposure, particularly in center. It's not true in every case, but I think as a general matter you need to live with growing pains out there for at least a few dozen games before you have any idea if the guy has the instincts to play the outfield.

With Josue De Paula set to potentially play a larger role for the Dodgers as they fight for their lives, is there anything that a prospect like him could show you in a short series like this that could meaningfully affect your view of his outlook?

He could pull an Arozerena I guess. That's probably the best example of a guy playing himself into a significantly higher grade just based on postseason performance alone.

When you watch a player on defense, what are you looking for to say that this player can stick at the position?

Depends where they are on the journey. If it's a teenager on the complex, speed/athleticism are big. You'd also like to see good hands/feel for the hop if it's an infield position, but reliability is a little less important at that stage. For a guy in Triple-A or the majors, the bar is higher, and you want to see him make plays that an average player at that position can handle.

of the angels many holes on the major league roster, which one(s) do you think can be reasonably filled by their non existent farm? or will stan kroenke need to spend his way through everything

I wouldn't say the farm is non existent, there are some dudes down there. They're kind of far away though, Rada could help in '27 but that's probably going to be a rough big league season regardless of what they do.

Back in the day, John Sickels had a theory that prospects with boring names tend to get underrated a bit (Brad Miller was the example that I recall). Have you encountered anything like that?

I appreciate the unique angle here but… no?

Who's a more promising version of the Joey Gallo archetype: Spencer Jones or Lazaro Montes?

They take different routes to a similar place. I'd maybe lean Jones but they're fairly close together on my personal pref.

Sss in full effect, but davalan hasn’t been hitting much in the afl – any sense of what the balance is of that being due to focusing more on fielding/it’s the hardest competition he’s faced/just random?

It's a handful of games.

on the subject of defense: how much are the "instincts" actually coachable? i'm spoiled as a frisbee player because i have a large, slow object that has fairly observable and predictable flight patterns, but i learned to make reads pretty fast. i don't know how that translates to baseball, esp supremely gifted athletes who seem to struggle to track fly balls

I think good instincts give you a higher baseline from which to start. Guys can/do get better at things like tracking a ball in the air or reading a hop on the ground, but some people have a lower ceiling than others.

Would it be fair to say that no farm system has jumped further up the power rankings than the Giants in the last calendar year?

They're up there. St. Louis has an argument too. Atlanta is coming from a lower spot on the rankings but that system's up a decent bit, too.

Would you want to be a scout back in the pre-draft, no tech, no advance knowledge era? When a scout might show up at a game not knowing who anyone was looking for diamonds in the rough? Or is knowing who and what to look for, getting to review video and radar and such make it more enjoyable?

Positives and negatives to both environments. The old days probably a tiny bit more fun but travel logistics were brutal back then.

Alexander frias’s numbers dropped post trade.any concerns?

No.

Who are some of the biggest risers since mid season reports?

Kilby and Flewelling for me personally. Bernal has probably played his way onto the T100.

How deep into off-the-field stuff do teams investigate potential draft picks to make sure they guy isn't a knucklehead? Do they ever hire like PIs or psychologists to screen kids?

I don't know about a PI but teams do their homework.

Have you gotten any looks at Angeibel Gomez in the AFL, and if so, what were your impressions?

I know we are looking at the "whole" player, but can't we take a minute to appreciate how good Josue De Paula must be to go from Double A to be in consideration to start on the Dodgers in the playoffs?

He's very good.

Have you done much youth scouting overseas? I'd imagine a lot of that is still low-tech wild west style. Or am I naive and do these teams know every 14 year old worth looking at?

Zero personally. Some teams are more organized than others in Latin America but there's a limit to how deep into the future you can peer when you're evaluating a 14 year old. There are tons of guys, pitchers especially, who don't pop until late into their teen years.

If you were in charge of the Mariners, would you be comfortable with Young and Emerson at 2B and SS next year?

Young yes, Emerson I'd sure want to have a capable Plan B on hand.

Hello BG!

Hello Big Fan

For the past several years one of the big talking points during the postseason has been how important it is for teams to have the ability to hit home runs. Yet Milwaukee, Cleveland and Tampa were 29th, 27th and 22nd respectively in that category. Not to mention they were right next to each other on the team ISO leaderboard (25th thru 27th). Why does this work for them? More specifically, how has Milwaukee been able to maintain the best OBP and nearly the best walk rate over the last couple seasons with so little power?

Two slightly different things here. The home run factor in the postseason is magnified because there are fewer runs/baserunners in general, which means that homers have a disproportionate impact on run scoring relative to the regular season.

To the question of how have teams who don't really hit homers are succeeding this postseason: There are still multiple ways to be successful and there's a lot of variance in a short series.

As for Milwaukee: They have a lot of guys with really good approaches and hit tools. And, as Sam Miller said more eloquently than I'll paraphrase in one of his newsletters, there are some real benefits to being the team that hustles in an otherwise non-hustle league

It's not that they get a ton of value in the aggregate out of infield groundballs but they squeeze more out of them than anybody else.

Is S. Walcott on the major league roster and starting next spring? Timeline for J. Farmelo who has tools but has lost so much time to injuries?

Walcott I'd be very surprised, for a couple reasons. He's blocked, for one, but also not ready. I spoke with a scout who made a persuasive case that he's the kind of player who could use a full year in Triple-A.

Farmelo is another one who I don't think is on the fast track. Wouldn't be surprised if he needs most/all of '27 at Double-A. I think even an 85th-90th percentile season has him getting to Triple-A late in the summer.

After attending a lot of MiLB games at different levels I’m in awe of anyone who can ID an A ball player beyond ‘that guy is better than everyone here’ with any certainty that it means ‘he’ll play in the league’ or ‘he’s a star.’ What are markers at that level (hitter side) you found useful

Nobody's good enough to tell you with certainty how many WAR a 20 year old in A ball is going to accrue in his career, but some blend of size/athleticism/tools/physical projection can usually tell you who's got a shot to be impactful.

Did you have a chance to see Sam Horn, GDD? Does he have a future in MLB?

How concerned are you about Emerson going forward?

I still think he's going to be a good player. But if I'm trying to contend next year, I don't think I'd plan on him as a "set it and forget it" SS from day one.

Do you enjoy seeing a prospect attempt to make the knuckleballer conversion?

Sure. Tend to think more guys should play around with it.

Is there a guy in the Jays org that no-one is talking about? I was wondering if Ryan Sprock might be that guy.

I've just about wrapped up Toronto's list. He'll be on there, likely as a 40 unless sources are all over the guy in a way I'm not anticipating.

When you look at a guy like Justin Gonzales, what are the things that you'd see to say "Wow, he's going elite" as opposed to "Let's see how this goes…"

I'm more in the 'let's see how this goes' camp with him. He's got a lot going for him, and the power is clearly nuts. Odd swing, stiffer mover than most big prospects. It's not a slam dunk case where everything lines up.

What’s the deal with George Lombard Jr.? Does he have to move off the position

I don't have anticipate that. I think he can be above average at short, and I'm the low man here on his glove.

In your eyes, what happened with someone like Jasson Dominguez? Did pressure of being 'The Martian' get to him? Constant analysis of defensive miscues got to his head? Is there a post-prospect hype arc he could conceivably stumble upon? League average hitter in '25 with semi-regular at-bats…

From what I can gather, there seems to have been a sizable gap between how baseball people evaluated him as a player — both publically and with teams — and how the public perceived his talent. Eric has a theory that the baseball card community is a factor here, particularly with players from the Yankees.

And I can buy that.

As a player, he projected as a regular but not a star. Guys like that fall short all the time.

As for Dominguez himself, a second act as a 110-115 wRC+ player with shoddy defense in some kind of role — maybe more against righties than lefties? — wouldn't shock me.

Emma Rodriguez and Mike Sirota have kinda similar offensive profiles and are the same age – does erod’s injury history explain the 2 grade gap between them? Something else I’m missing?

It's a factor. The bigger thing is that it looks like Rodriguez will be vulnerable in a huge swath of the strike zone in a way that Sirota won't.

Reverse of the Dominguez question – who is the player in recent memory that baseball folks were way, way higher on than the general fan public?

This is one where different pockets will have different answers. The A's, for instance, were way higher on Esteury Ruiz… For scouts it'll often be toolsy guys with scary data… I really liked Spencer Jones the two times I saw him as a scout and was kind of oblivious to how he was a punchline online for all the strikeouts.

Hao-Yu Lee had a decent but not overwhelming rookie season. Is there another gear?

I hope so, he's so fun to watch. He's limited enough defensively that I think "good reserve where you pick your spots/stretches to play him" is the reasonable projection.

Muni’s in zone fastball issues sure came out against Cleveland. Is this a case where over 162 enough pitchers will miss the hole and he punishes but in October better and more focused arms hammer that spot until he adjusts?

Everybody suffers a little in the postseason as the competition gets tougher.

But also, stuff happens in five games

In five games from August 1 through August 6, he hit .136 /.208 /.182 with 12 K's and one double in 24 PA's.

In five games from May 6 to May 12 he hit .111 /.238 /.278 with 12 strikeouts in 21 PA's against the mighty Angels/Mariners/Royals.

Kellon Lindsay and Joendry Vargas are their stats inflated by the minor league hitting environment?

Them and everybody else this year.

Much hope left for Carson Williams? Or is he an odd man out in Tampa?

I don't think he's going to hit.

Any updated Braves news you haven't shared with us before? The trade deadline refresh was much appreciated, and there were slew of promotions after that.

Nothing beyond what I published in the AZ notes. I suspect they'll go fairly early in the list cycle.

What did Salas’ performance with the Padres do to his prospect ranking?

Very little, more because he's already 10th on our board. Not much room for us to move him!

Unless he morphs into a LF this offseason, Sean Keys seems awfully blocked in Toronto. But he's also look a lot like the kind of bat they could use, particularly with the power and patience profile. Could he be a serviceable outfielder with reps, pushing others to DH at bats? Or do the Jays look for a trade partner? They often deal with the Guardians, who sure don't seem inclined to use Bibee for much this postseason…

I don't think you're going to flip him for Tanner Bibee, if that's the question behind the question. You can find ways to get him in the game as a PH or at DH with occasional starts elsewhere. I think trying him in left and seeing how it looks is a reasonable idea. If he hits, they'll find a way to get the bat in there.

Are you taking an Amador victory lap?

No, but glad he's a relevant player for COL again and cautiously optimistic that there's still a regular in there.

You can never take a victory lap in this business.

If he’s not going to hit is Carson Williams the in-house all glove SS when Walls gets expensive?

Could be, yeah.

You mentioned J. Gonz. was stiff. I've seen that critique for lots of guys. Have you ever seen someone get considerably less stiff? Like they went all yoga and loosened up their core?

Usually goes the other way. There was a really good article 10 years ago or so about how Justin Verlander revived his career by limbering up, but that was more of a case where he'd let his flexibility atrophy a little bit rather than finding something brand new.

How much of a leap do you expect Konkor Griffin to make next year?

A pretty big one. I expect him to be very good next year.

Were you able to look into some of the low lower Mariners starters like Jack Bowery?

Thank you for your patience. Bowery/Easterly look like HM/35+ types. I like the strikes but they're succeeding by leaning on good execution of shapely but not particularly nasty secondaries. Never say never in this era but they don't strike me as especially projectable, either.

What do you make of what Vance Honeycutt did late in the season in AA and so far in the Arizona Fall League?

I liked him more than I thought I was going to. Flawed hitter, still see a path to value as a good glove/danger bat off the bench even if he's pretty limited at the plate.

Can Lazaro Montes become Murakami-lite (poor BA, acceptable OBP(.320's-.330's?), 35+ HRs?

That's the projection right there.

Does Anthony Eyanson have a chance to break camp in the rotation, or are we likely looking at May/Jun debut?

~90/10 the latter.

Any thoughts on Nehomar Ochoa at the AFL? Classic big tool, big swing & miss profile the Dana Brown-led Astros fell for.

Bench bat.

Who will emerge from the scrum to become the Cardinals' near- and long-term catcher?

Reminds me of the situation the Jays were in about five years ago, lot of potential options, tough to go wrong. I've been a Bernal fan for a while, why stop now.

Best baseball comp for Arch Manning?

Jackson Holliday?

How badly has Winston Santos fallen in rankings this year :'(

Sigh. From a valuation perspective, clearly a lot. We'll see how stubborn I'm feeling come the Rangers list.

What's Kendry Chourio's upside?

Sonny Gray.

What happened with Elmer Rodriguez this season? So you still see him being successful in the majors as he was in AAA?

Very effective in AAA, major league cameos shone a bright light on his crudeness as a strike thrower. Still like him as a GB-generating SP prospect.

Thanks for all the answers!

And thank you for all the questions, always fun to hang out. Disappointed about the lack of enclave chat but like that we got to hit on a bunch of different teams/some players we don't often get to here. Let's do it again next eek.


Jay Jaffe FanGraphs Chat – 10/13/26

Good afternoon, folks! Welcome to another edition of my weekly chat. THis is my second time on our new internal platform and I'm still feeling my way around this thing.

As a reminder, you need to be logged into your user account (not necessarily a paid member, but thank you if you are) to submit questions.

I've got a piece on Victor Mesa Jr. in the pipeline for today

Yesterday I previewed the ALCS https://blogs.fangraphs.com/2026-alcs-preview-rays-face-guar…

Anyway, let's goooo…

How much does Jose Ramirez finally having a postseason to remember impact his HOF odds?

It doesn't hurt him, obviously, but I think the heavy lifting has already been done. He's not yet at the JAWS standard for third baseman, but he's above the peak standard (44.7 vs. 43.4). He'll get some additional limelight when he passes 300 homers (he's at 297) and 2,000 hits (1,779). Another trip to the World Series would be a feather in his cap, too.

I've got a piece on Ramírez's rebound from his slump on track for later this week, incidentally.

Why did the Fangraphs Playoff odds change in the past hour? I noticed the Dodgers were below 25% and they seemed to have inched back up above 25% since then?

Without looking, I'm not sure, but it could be because starting pitchers were named or lineups were adjusted. The odds aren't set in stone, they're adjusted as we get new inputs.

Are you familiar with King of the Mound?

It’s on my kid’s school reading list and is apparently about Satchel Paige and his time with the integrated Bismarcks. I’d never heard of that part of Paige’s barnstorming.

I'm not familiar with that book, either. I don't have a strong recollection of the Bismarcks, but they're covered in Larry Tye's Satchel: The Life and Times of an American Legend, which was pubbed in 2009 and which I really liked.

We don't have many questions in the queue at the moment, so don't be shy about submitting yours

Going into collective bargaining, a Brewers vs. Guardians or Rays WS is just about the best outcome for the MLBPA and the worst for the owners, right?

Yes, and it's probably even better now that the Dodgers are down 2-0 and looking like they're on the ropes.

What's your personal ranked choice vote for the remaining 4 teams in order of how much you are rooting for them to win the WS?

Beyond the obvious links to my growing up a Dodgers and and generally defaulting to them as a rooting preference, I really don't have strong preferences here — the Brewers and Padres are kind of neck-and-neck in terms of the NL teams besides the Dodgers and Mets (for geographic reasons) that I watch most, so maybe Milwaukee if I had to pick?

The fact that the Brewers, Rays, and Guardians are all among the more analytically inclined teams obviously has some appeal here too. USA Today's Gabe Lacques had a good piece on these teams' interconnections yesterday https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/mlb/columnist/gabe-lac…

The "sit Ohtani?" discussion is ridiculous, right? Like, yeah he's been bad but can the solution to your problems possibly be "bench the greatest player alive?" Feels like there should be 10 more things to adjust before that.

I feel like we're back to the 2024 World Series after he injured his shoulder, where the information regarding his true condition was a closely-kept secret and his value in the lineup rest partially on being a decoy. His at-bats haven't been great, and he hasn't pulled a ball in the air since August. I'm not 100% sure I don't pull the DePaula lever myself with the team down 2-0, but I don't know exactly what he's dealing with.

Thoughts on MLB's proposed changes regarding season and playoff length?

Didn't love it but it didn't stink on ice like every other MLB trial balloon they've launched during this propaganda cycle. If you're going to shorten the schedule, 154 games is the obvious number to start with, but what will happen is the owners will say, ok, your salaries will be cut 5% to account for this shorter schedule and then the proposal will be deader than Babe Ruth.

Have you ever thought about a JAWS equivalent for managers/coaches?

I've thought about lots of applications for JAWS — and a medical journal even cited it for a "peak plus average" study that they did that was unrelated to sports — but I haven't come up with anything useful enough to unveil.

If there's a lockout I'll go back to the lab.

The most fun I've had thinking about a JAWS application is Astronaut JAWS because I'm a bit of a spaceflight nerd. I watch Apollo documentaries and just about any sci-fi movie where They Puttin On Helmets.

regarding the Brewers making the world series being bad for owners' bargaining position, do you think players on eliminated teams see it that way and are actively rooting for the brewers? Or is it such a small factor and MLB players are recuperating from the season to a degree they don't get that invested in the playoffs after they're out

Mostly the latter, I don't think the players get particularly invested unless they have ties to certain players, coaches, or execs with those teams.

How far back would the mound have to be moved for there to be a notable change in the way pitchers have to pitch?

I think even a foot changes things. I know this is a common suggestion for how to fix baseball but every time it comes up I look at the injury data and think "You wanna place more stress on pitchers' arms?" because it's human nature that they're going to work harder to approximate their current velocity rather than deciding to live with lower velo.

If Posey is the most likely inductee, and Utley and Felix are running 2nd and 3rd, who do you see making a big jump this year? Pettitte? Pedroia/Wright? Rollins riding Utley's coattails?

I think Pedroia riding the coattails of Utley (and to some extent Andruw Jones) is the mosst likely of t hose outcomes, maybe a bit more momentum for Pettitte as voters realize that he'll be a dead letter in front of the Era Committee given the Hall's engineered panels.

With Chris Sale seemingly cementing his place in Cooperstown after his stint in Atlanta, which other active starting pitchers, who are maybe at a career inflection point, could put themselves in that discussion with a strong run in their mid to late-30s?

Gerrit Cole, Zack Wheeler, and Jacob deGrom all need to make some additional waves if they're t o replicate Sale's late-30s recovery. Wrote about them in August https://blogs.fangraphs.com/cooperstown-notebook-chris-sale-…

Beyond that, maybe the next hope would be Max Fried, who has lacked volume but has performed well, but he's had just one season above 5.0 WAR and that's not gonna turn any voter's head.

If ohtani were to be healthy enough to pitch, in what role would the dodgers be most inclined to use him. It feels as though they wouldn't necessarily need him in the starting staff but could they use him as a reliever?

The problem with using him as a reliever is that once he comes out he'd have to take a position in order to remain in the game. The rule built specifically to showcase him doesn't apply in those cases.

Joe Espada is being interviewed by the Mariners for their Manager position. Is this the right fit for both sides?

I don't know that he's a perfect fit but I haven't seen anything to suggest he'd be a bad one. it's been awhile since I thought the Mariners had a good manager, and if they hired him, I'd probably think it was a solid move unless there was a candidate I thought more highly of.

Posey shouldn't be eligible until he is completely out of baseball IMO. There is conflict of interest and puts especially local writers in an impossible situation.

Did you see the knives come out for Posey during all his screw-ups this year? I trust the professionalism of the Giants' beat reporters who have votes and their ability to separate the player from the executive.

Are the Phillies now in the same spot as the 2010-11 team where the title contention window is almost closed and they have to play out Ryan Howard’s contract (Now Trea/Harper’s contract). Unless a magically pop up prospect happens, I cant see any path to a winning team until a tear down happens.

I don't know about the EXACT spot, and I don't think Harper at this stage is nearly the mllstone that Turner looks like he is, but they do need an overhaul. This team has both Luzardo and Sánchez tied up long term whereas that one had only Lee beyond the 2014 option for Halladay that they declined.

my idea to fix the mound is to shorten the pitching rubber by a few inches on each side. Not a drastic fix, but eliminates *some* pitcher advantage, because they're all over that thing trying to have more deceptive deliveries / angles.

Hmm, I'd at least entertain the notion of seeing this implemented in the AFL or Atlantic League for a closer look.

Thoughts on the AFL experiment restricting outfielder positioning? Also, if that becomes the MLB rule, surely we need to call it the "Strawberry Patch" rule after Daryl Strawberry, right?

and speaking of which, I don't like this one at all, given the amount of tech involved. So far, I think the answer is move the fences back and make them higher, and revisit the strike one boundaries (or maybe check swings) in order to help increase offense

By my count there has only been 1 world series in the last 100 years where neither team had won a title before. If Milwaukee and Tampa advance, it would happen, likely for the last time. How exciting would you find that matchup on those grounds alone?

Are you telling me we won't see a Padres-Mariners World Series?

(Ever, I mean. Obviously not this year)

I do think it would be cool to see a World Series that guarantees a first-time title, but I don't want to knock the other possibilities. The Guardians are long overdue for a title, especially given the high quality of that organization over the past 30+ years . If the Dodgers come back, they'll be in a rematch of one that happened in 1920 or 2020 and in pursuit of just the fifth threpeat ever and first of any NL team. Those are all interesting outcomes.

I don't quite understand the "if you move the mound back, pitchers will just maximise velo and break even more". Aren't they already pushing as hard as they can?

Yes, but that obviously hasn't stopped anyone from pushing the envelope. It's always going to be "how can I keep my velo in the upper tier" before it's "gosh, i better learn to throw a new pitch"

Just read Mike Vaccaro’s (sp?) new book on George Steinbrenner – good read! In your opinion, Do books like that coming out have any sway with the Hall as it sets up the latest Eras committee? Something that makes them more inclined to add a Steinbrenner/stack the committee accordingly?

Eh, minimal I think. And I don't think there's going to be a crushing rush to make Steinbrenner a candidate when there are so many managers on the doorstep. the Boss got less than five votes in 2017 and '19, which would be a strike against his future candidacy if he gets another one under the newish rule.

Also, I don't think the Hall wants a twice-suspended owner in, to be honest.

If you were making the dodgers lineup, would you make radical changes in hopes of a spark or trust the veterans who got you there? Examples being struggles of Smith, Betts, Ohtani with De Paula on the bench and Tucker/Muncy further down in the order.

I think this is an overraction to two games. Tucker's hitting .300/.391/.500 in the postseason, Muncy is slugging .684. If there's particular matchup stuff regarding the starting pitcher for Game 3, I might give it more sway but I'm not sure Robert Gasser represents such an imposing opponent that they're going to upend everything.

Where do the Phillies turn for a manager now that Cora has (reportedly) rebuffed their approach? Remove Mattingly's interim tag? It's a veteran team that's clearly on the downswing. Feels like a bunch of potential candidates either wouldn't want the gig, or wouldn't be the right fit for it because the vets wouldn't respect them.

I think bringing back Mattingly would be on par with returning Turner to shortstop and assuming Nola is a top-of-the-rotation guy. Just a foolish waste when the clock is ticking. Current coaches like Kai Correa, Ruben Niebla and George Lombard Sr. might be fits as might experienced guys like David Ross, Rocco Baldelli, and Espada, but so much will come down to who Dombrowski connects with.

Will we ever see a healthy Ohtani for a full season as both hitter and pitcher again?

We're never going to see a 200-inning Ohtani and I'd be surprised if we see a 162-inning Ohtani. I think 100-120 innings is going to become the target if he's healthy.

Here's the Mesa piece https://blogs.fangraphs.com/victor-mesa-jr-has-hardly-platea…

If you were asked, would you accept a position at the Hall to help formulate committees and make decisions on voting?

I'd be happy to consult with them so long as it didn't mean giving up my day job here as well as my voting privileges.

But I don't see myself as winding up on a Hall payroll, if that's what you're asking.

I’m interested in the idea that a Tamp/Cleveland v Brewers WS undercuts the cap logic (it probably does) but might miss the forest for the trees in that it tells the massive middle tier of franchises they don’t have to spend in FA to win. Noses, faces, spite, etc

Eh, if the runs by the current teams haven't already underscored it, the reason they're playing in an LCS is because they are well-run, forward-thinking teams that search for any edge they can get, not simply because they don't spend money in free agency. Theirs isn't the only way to succeed, but it's not a recipe that's replicable just because you *don't* spend in FA.

Pat Murphy about to win MOY for the 3rd consecutive season in the NL. His regular season W% currently is top 25 in history surrounded by HOFers. There is basically no precedent for someone who started this late, but is there a pathway to the HOF for him especially if he leads the Brewers to their first WS?

I think that's a tough lift for a guy who's already 67. If we presume that the Brewers' current success will be harder to maintain as their current core gets more expensive – and as their pitchers deal with injuries, ahem — they'll be subject to the usual gravity any competitive team faces. Will he ride that out? Will his career look as impressive after three years below .500 somewhere in there? I'm just spitballing here but I think he's a longshot simply because of the late start.

The Dodgers aren't successful because they spend money, it's how they spend it that counts. And the Brewers aren't successful just because they don't sign FAs, they invest heavily in other areas (that many teams neglect) to help offset the approach. Easy to attempt, far harder to replicate from both sides, as evidenced by ample teams failures.

yup yup yup

I am left wanting by the metrics I've seen on who is good/bad on pitch challenges. We need metrics that consider the number of opportunities to challenge, how egregious the original call was, even maybe some leverage stuff and accounting for how many challenges a team has left. Current "How many times did a guy challenge correctly?" or "What % of time are challenges correct?" need to be improved.

Players and managers aren't the only ones feeling their way around the new system. Give it time and I imagine you'll see more advanced applications — and for all we know some teams are working on this

How seriously should we take the talk of a possibly "juiced" ball in minor league play in 2026? (Whether intentional, or just a variance in the seams.)

I'd like to see some actual data before I take it seriously. PCL scoring went down, IL scoring went up but was still below 2023-2024 levels. Lower than that isn't really something I'm attuned to but if there's something there, let's see the numbers.

Do you think the HoF arguments now need to be “TikTok”ized? Meaning the 500 HR, 300 Wins benchmarks need to be severely cut down? The debate of DeGrom is what drives me on this. Any Fangraphs reader who watched him pitch knows that he’s on a very short list of all time great pitchers.

voters already largely recognize the increasing rarity of those once-automatic benchmarks but I think it's going to take a more radical shakeup to get deGrom into the Hall. I'm not incredibly sold on him right now, as I wrote in the piece linked above

FWIW, Savant's ABS data does have leverage aspects and they did just add some accounting for losing a challenge. I don't necessarily agree with the exact implementation/numbers chosen, but it's at least a start.

Thanks

regarding the minor league ball, it's a different ball for AA and below so the PCL/IL scoring is not relevant. BG/Eric have been all over the juiced ball in the lower levels

Noted, and yes, that rings a bell.

What do you see for Bauers on the free agent trail? He's earned a contract but the short history and current age suggest something pretty nominal, 2/$30? or does that fall short?

I think some kind of 2-3 year deal is a likely outcome. It's not the nicest thing to do to his market but I wouldn't be surprised if the Brewers QO him but also make clear that there's some kind of longer-term option available as an alternative.

The Brewers bullpen is amazing, but can they keep riding it this hard all the way to a title? I kind of feel like playoff managers collectively have tend to lean a bit too hard into "win today and worry about tomorrow tomorrow."

The nature of the Division Series with its extra off days makes it a different creature than the LCS when it comes to bullpen management. I expect we'll see teams balancing the usage more, and familiarity effects setting in.

Ok folks, that's it from me for today. Thanks so much for stopping by, please tip your servers, and enjoy the baseball!