If you pulled up the AL Central standings today, you’d find that the team currently sitting at the top isn’t the favored Chicago White Sox or the Minnesota Twins, but the Kansas City Royals. While 90% of the season remains, it’s hard to object to the notion that it’s better to be in the lead at this point rather than the basement. It’s still reasonable to believe that the two preseason favorites are better teams than the Royals overall, but that doesn’t mean the season can’t end with Kansas City in possession of a golden ticket to the AL Division Series.
Long-time readers will know that I’ve never thought the Royals were particularly well run, at least not since Ewing Kauffman, the team’s owner from the 1969 expansion, passed away in 1993. During Kauffman’s tenure, Kansas City was arguably the most successful team created in the expansion era, ranking eighth in winning percentage (.517). By 1993, only two other expansion-era teams were even at .500: the Blue Jays at .511 and Houston at .501. At the organization’s peak, from 1975 to 1989, only the Red Sox and Yankees won more games, and at one point, the Royals went to the playoffs in seven of 10 seasons.
Since 1993, the organization has generally been unsuccessful. In about a quarter-century, the Royals have only had four winning seasons. While they bagged a World Series title in 2015, they only made the playoffs twice, despite playing in what was arguably baseball’s weakest division. Under Kauffman’s successor, team CEO, and eventually full owner David Glass, the team fared much worse. In 1993, Kansas City had a $40 million payroll, the fourth-highest in baseball. By the post-strike 1995 season, they ranked 21st. There they stayed, usually in the bottom third of the league and frequently in the bottom five. Since Dayton Moore’s first full season as the general manager in 2007, Kansas City has ranked 28th in wins and 22nd in payroll:
Payroll vs. Wins, 2007-20
Team |
Payroll |
Rank |
Wins |
Rank |
New York Yankees |
$2,627,925,259 |
1 |
1246 |
1 |
Los Angeles Dodgers |
$2,236,600,402 |
3 |
1237 |
2 |
Boston Red Sox |
$2,302,517,441 |
2 |
1194 |
3 |
St. Louis Cardinals |
$1,617,713,889 |
10 |
1192 |
4 |
Tampa Bay Rays |
$818,419,932 |
30 |
1157 |
5 |
Los Angeles Angels |
$1,895,334,206 |
4 |
1148 |
6 |
Cleveland Indians |
$1,173,731,244 |
23 |
1140 |
7 |
Atlanta Braves |
$1,350,971,318 |
16 |
1128 |
8 |
Chicago Cubs |
$1,841,202,419 |
6 |
1124 |
9 |
Milwaukee Brewers |
$1,170,308,270 |
24 |
1117 |
10 |
Texas Rangers |
$1,556,372,185 |
12 |
1115 |
11 |
Oakland Athletics |
$949,971,231 |
27 |
1113 |
12 |
Washington Nationals |
$1,508,462,694 |
13 |
1103 |
13 |
Philadelphia Phillies |
$1,772,042,700 |
8 |
1098 |
14 |
San Francisco Giants |
$1,818,498,586 |
7 |
1092 |
15 |
Toronto Blue Jays |
$1,460,943,858 |
14 |
1078 |
16 |
New York Mets |
$1,728,971,294 |
9 |
1073 |
17 |
Arizona Diamondbacks |
$1,160,462,372 |
25 |
1068 |
18 |
Minnesota Twins |
$1,281,364,017 |
19 |
1061 |
19 |
Detroit Tigers |
$1,861,840,063 |
5 |
1060 |
20 |
Houston Astros |
$1,268,250,697 |
20 |
1058 |
21 |
Colorado Rockies |
$1,289,221,972 |
18 |
1040 |
22 |
Cincinnati Reds |
$1,246,221,968 |
21 |
1039 |
23 |
Seattle Mariners |
$1,589,181,892 |
11 |
1030 |
24 |
Chicago White Sox |
$1,425,636,018 |
15 |
1027 |
25 |
Pittsburgh Pirates |
$894,015,615 |
28 |
1016 |
26 |
San Diego Padres |
$1,006,395,416 |
26 |
1013 |
27 |
Kansas City Royals |
$1,185,768,401 |
22 |
1003 |
28 |
Baltimore Orioles |
$1,343,310,329 |
17 |
989 |
29 |
Miami Marlins |
$880,285,243 |
29 |
988 |
30 |
Read the rest of this entry »