The Blossoming of Marcus Semien
Marcus Semien is having a moment. Semien finished the 2018 season with 3.7 WAR, nearly doubling the next-best total of his career. There was a catch, however, in that Semien’s WAR was largely fueled by a sudden jump in his defensive numbers. While the numbers for Baseball Info Solutions and Ultimate Zone Rating never completely agreed on Semien, they both thought he was a below-average defender at short. Coming into 2018, per 1350 innings, BIS had Semien at -2.7 runs, while UZR had him at -7.6 runs. In 2018, those numbers were +8.5 runs and +7.9 runs respectively, numbers that, if believed, meant that Semien had added 10-to-15 runs of value from somewhere very unexpected.
While a White Sox prospect, it was thought that Semien would likely struggle playing shortstop in the majors. In the minors, he made 60 errors in 2203 innings (37 errors per 1350 innings), which led the White Sox to find as much time for him at second and third base as possible. And while error rates usually come down in the majors, Semien committed 35 errors in his first season as the A’s shortstop. You could argue that errors can be overused as a method of defensive evaluation — and you’d be correct — but there are limits. UZR actually had Semien as slightly above-average in range, with the -11.7 total run estimate coming from a brutal -12.6 runs from errors. That’s not a run-of-the-mill error-prone season, either:
Season | Name | Error Runs |
---|---|---|
2015 | Marcus Semien | -12.6 |
2017 | Tim Anderson | -10.7 |
2010 | Ian Desmond | -10.4 |
2010 | Starlin Castro | -9.7 |
2015 | Ian Desmond | -8.7 |
2004 | Angel Berroa | -7.6 |
2014 | Jonathan Villar | -7.3 |
2011 | Eduardo Nunez | -7.3 |
2006 | Hanley Ramirez | -6.9 |
2013 | Jonathan Villar | -6.9 |
2006 | Felipe Lopez | -6.9 |
2004 | Kaz Matsui | -6.8 |
2007 | David Eckstein | -6.7 |
2011 | Elvis Andrus | -6.6 |
2016 | Ketel Marte | -6.5 |
2016 | Brad Miller | -6.3 |
2009 | Everth Cabrera | -6.3 |
2003 | Erick Almonte | -6.3 |
2005 | Russ Adams | -6.3 |
2004 | Rafael Furcal | -6.2 |
2012 | Dee Gordon | -6.2 |
2005 | Clint Barmes | -6.1 |
2013 | Starlin Castro | -5.7 |
2015 | Danny Santana | -5.7 |
2003 | Rafael Furcal | -5.6 |